1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in...

64
1 Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven- Binaries

Transcript of 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in...

Page 1: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 1

Page 2: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2

Page 3: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 3

Double stars

Rev. John Mitchell - 1767

“it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty

in general, that such double stars as appear to consist

of two or more stars placed very near together, do really

consist of stars placed near together, and under the

influence of some general law.”

The definitive existence of binary stars was demonstrated by William Herschel in 1802.

Page 4: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 4

A multitude of types

Binary stars

astrometric eclipsing

spectroscopicVisual

Resolved bytelescope into

two starsOscillatorymotion on

the sky

Stars periodicallypass in front ofeach other in

our LOS

Unresolvedby telescope,but two setsof spectrallines seen

Page 5: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 5

Example of Visual Binaries

Krueger 60 : d = 4 pcM3.5V + M 4V, Period = 44.5 years

Page 6: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 6

Example of Visual Binaries

Page 7: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 7

a

d

( )a

radd

d

a

265,206

''

265,206)(

)(

265,206

''

pcd

a AU)(

)(''

pcd

a AU

Page 8: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 8

23

GM

a

Sun

AU

YR

MMM

aP

21

3

21

1

Kepler’s 3rd law:

Page 9: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 9

Ursa Major, The Big Bear (Big Dipper)

Mizar was the first known binary, noticed in 1650 by Riccioli.

Page 10: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 10

Mizar: A binary within a binary

Page 11: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 11

Resolution of a telescope

D

sec

1

5.01.0

arc

mD

Page 12: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 12

Binary system Mizar A Observed by NPOI

Navy Prototype Optical Interferometer (NPOI) Array south of Flagstaff AZ, The Mizar images were obtained with the inner three 0.5m telescopes. A total of 10 telescopes will be operational starting in 2003.

Mizar A binary (period 20 days).

0.01 arcsec

Page 13: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 13

Page 14: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 14

Example:

Wavelength λ=500nm, baseline B=100m

Θ ~ 0.001“ = 1 mas

D

• CHARA – Center for High Angular Resolution Astronomy at Georgia State University

• SUSI – Sydney University Stellar Interferometer• NPOI - Navy Prototype Optical Interferometer • Mark III Interferometer• PTI - Palomar Testbed Interferometer

Page 15: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 15

Page 16: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 16

Page 17: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 17

Page 18: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 18

Keck Interferometer (2x10m) Mauna Kea, Hawaii

VLT Interferometer (4x8m)

Chile (ESA)

Examples of Optical Interferometers

Page 19: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 19

a1 a2

M1

M2

CM

2211 aMaM

The binary motion

Page 20: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 20

21 MM

2M 1M

Page 21: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 21

12 5.0 MM

2M1M

Page 22: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2212 1.0 MM

2M 1M

Page 23: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 231001.0 MM Planet

1MPlanet

Page 24: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 24

Kepler first law:

Page 25: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 25

Kepler second law:

Page 26: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 26

Origin of orbits of both stars

Periastron point

Empty

Page 27: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 27

The Masses of Sirius A & B

– 5th closest star to us: d = 2.63pc– Sirius A is the brightest star in the sky

Page 28: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 28

Wobble of Sirius

Page 29: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 29

Sirius AB Binary System

HST image

Page 30: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 30

Orbits of Sirius A and B

Page 31: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 31

Sirius AB Binary System

24.7 Vm

0013.01010 9.25.2/24.7

,

,

VA

VB

L

L

Page 32: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 32

• Ratio of motion:

3.23.2

1

1

1

2

2

1 a

a

a

a

M

M

Distance estimate:

a = 7.62” 20.04 AU at a distance of 2.63 pc

M1 + M2 = (20.04)3/(49.9)2 = 3.23

Kepler’s 3rd law:

Sirius AB Binary System

Page 33: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 33

• HenceM1 / M2 = 2.3 and M1 + M2 = 3.23

– so, unraveling the masses gives

M1 = mass of Sirius A = 2.25 M

M2 = mass of Sirius B = 0.98 M

Sirius AB Binary System

Page 34: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 34

1915-Adams obtained a spectrum of Sirius B T~25,000 K

1862- Clark resolved the two stars

Sirius AB Binary System

%)3(0084.0 SunB RR

Page 35: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 35

The H-R Diagram

L = 4 R2 T4

425 ///107.5 Kscmerg

%)3(0084.0 SunB RR

Page 36: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 36

The Sizes of Stars

Page 37: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 37

Gliese 229B8’’ separation

10 mag difference in J,H,K

(Nakajima 1995)

Page 38: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 38

A multitude of types

Binary stars

astrometric eclipsing

spectroscopicVisual

Resolved bytelescope into

two starsOscillatorymotion on

the sky

Stars periodicallypass in front ofeach other in

our LOS

Unresolvedby telescope,but two setsof spectrallines seen

Page 39: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

39Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 40: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

40

One star with a spectrum composed of two spectra

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 41: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

41

The Doppler Effect

Spectrum of Hydrogen in Lab

Spectrum of a

Star

radv

c

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 42: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

42

Spectroscopic binary

Spectrum of Hydrogen in Lab

Spectrum a Star…..Day 1

Spectrum a Star…..Day 2

Spectrum a Star…..Day 3

Spectrum a Star…..Day 4

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 43: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

43

21 MM

2M 1M

To earthTsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 44: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

44

Spectroscopic Binaries

If the Doppler shift of a star’s absorption lines changes with time (redshift, then blueshift, then redshift, etc.), it’s a spectroscopic binary.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 45: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

45

Spectroscopic Binaries

Double-lined spectroscopic binary.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 46: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

46

Spectroscopic Binaries

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 47: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 47

Single-lined spectroscopic binary (SB1)

Page 48: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 48

Single-lined spectroscopic binary (SB1)

Page 49: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

49Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 50: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

50

Eclipsing Binaries

Animation Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 51: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

51

• Time T1 = first contact

• Time T2 = beginning of total eclipse

• Time T3 = end of total eclipse phase

• Time T4 = last contact

Time

Bri

ghtn

ess

T1 T2 T3 T4

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 52: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

52

Star ofradius R1

Star of radius R2

a

Orbit ofstar 2relativeto star 1

Eclipsezone

T1

T2 T3 T4

LOS

1 24 1 2

rel

R RT T

V

1 23 2 2

rel

R RT T

V

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 53: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

53

)()( 1421 TTP

aRR

)()( 2321 TTP

aRR

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 54: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

54

The geometry of the eclipse

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 55: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 55

Relative dimension: )()( 2321 TTP

aRR

Relative surface flux

Inclination

Page 56: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

56

CoRoT-Exo-2

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 57: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

57Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 58: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

58

Absolute Properties of the Main-Sequence Eclipsing Binary Star BP Vulpeculae

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Lacy et al. 2003

Page 59: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

59

BP VULPECULAE

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries

Page 60: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 60

BP VULPECULAE

Page 61: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 61

BP VULPECULAE

Page 62: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 62

BP VULPECULAE

Page 63: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 63

Page 64: 1Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 2 3 Double stars Rev. John Mitchell - 1767 it is highly probable in particular, and next to a certainty in general, that.

Tsevi Mazeh: Leuven-Binaries 64