18 SEP 2014 1 - Male Violence Texas court throws out ‘paternalistic’ ban on ‘upskirt’ photos...

7
9/19/2014 Texas court throws out ‘paternalistic’ ban on ‘upskirt’ photos http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/09/texas-court-throws-out-paternalistic-ban-on-upskirt-photos/ 1/7 A U.S. NEWS DON'T MISS STORIES. FOLLOW RAW STORY! Follow @rawstory Texas court throws out ‘paternalistic’ ban on ‘upskirt’ photos TRAVIS GETTYS 18 SEP 2014 1.4K Facebook Twitter More Photographer paparazzi (Shutterstock) Texas court threw out a law banning “upskirt” photos, finding the statute a “paternalistic” violation of free speech guarantees. SHARES Rhiannon Poole, Mike Hersh and 289,395 others like this. Like Se NEWS OPINION MORE

Transcript of 18 SEP 2014 1 - Male Violence Texas court throws out ‘paternalistic’ ban on ‘upskirt’ photos...

9/19/2014 Texas court throws out ‘paternalistic’ ban on ‘upskirt’ photos

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/09/texas-court-throws-out-paternalistic-ban-on-upskirt-photos/ 1/7

A

U.S. NEWS

DON'T MISS STORIES. FOLLOW RAW STORY! Follow @rawstory

Texas court throws out ‘paternalistic’ ban on ‘upskirt’photosTRAVIS GETTYS18 SEP 2014

1.4K Facebook Twitter More

Photographer paparazzi (Shutterstock)

Texas court threw out a law banning “upskirt” photos, finding the statute a“paternalistic” violation of free speech guarantees.

SHARES

Rhiannon Poole, Mike Hersh and289,395 others like this.

Like

Search ...NEWS OPINION MORE

9/19/2014 Texas court throws out ‘paternalistic’ ban on ‘upskirt’ photos

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/09/texas-court-throws-out-paternalistic-ban-on-upskirt-photos/ 2/7

The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals ruled 8-1 that photos are “inherentlyexpressive” – just like paintings, films, and books – and are protected by the FirstAmendment, reported the Houston Chronicle.

“The camera is essentially the photographer’s pen and paintbrush,” Presiding JudgeSharon Keller wrote in the majority opinion.

The ruling by the state’s highest criminal courtupheld a previous decision by the San Antonio-based 4th Court of Appeals.

Ronald Thompson appealed the constitutionality ofthe law after he was charged in 2011 with 26counts of improper photography after takingunderwater pictures of children swimming at awater park.

He challenged the law before his trial began, arguing that the statute could beused to jail street photographers, entertainment journalists, pep rally attendees,and “even the harmless eccentric.”

The Bexar County District Attorney’s Office argued that surreptitiously taken photoswere beyond First Amendment protections because the law required illegal intentto be proven, but the court disagreed.

“Protecting someone who appears in public from being the object of sexualthoughts seems to be the sort of ‘paternalistic interest in regulating the defendant’smind’ that the First Amendment was designed to guard against,” Keller wrote.

A First Amendment law expert said the court ruled correctly, saying “it’s hard to seehow you could make taking a picture a crime.”

“To think that it’s unlawful to look at a little girl in a swimsuit, when you havelascivious thoughts, in public, and you did not do anything to that child?” said PeterLinzer, a University of Houston Law Center constitutional law professor. “Thatcannot be made a crime in the United States. The fact that some people might findthat very offensive doesn’t change anything.”

“You can’t prevent someone in public from looking at you and having darkthoughts,” Linzer said.

1.4K Facebook Twitter More

SHARES

From The Web by TaboolaSponsored Links

15 Jokes We TOTALLY Missed In Beloved Films From Our YouthRefinery29

Please Don't Retire At 62. Here's Why.The Motley Fool

13 Stars You Won't RecognizeAnswers

9/19/2014 Texas court throws out ‘paternalistic’ ban on ‘upskirt’ photos

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/09/texas-court-throws-out-paternalistic-ban-on-upskirt-photos/ 3/7

By commenting, you agree to our terms of service and to abide by our commenting policy.

READ COMMENTS - JOIN THE DISCUSSION

NEXT ON RAW STORY >

WATCH: Teen comes out to hismother and she surprises him withher own confession

See The Before and After Photos of 18 Celebs Who Clearly Have Fake TeethPOPnHOP

Most Outrageous Gowns at the Met GalaThe Cut

20 Extremely Dumb CelebritiesRant Lifestyle

The First Wine Club to Get it RightThe Huffington Post

This Way to Pay Off Mortgage May Surprise YouBills.com

Recommended

15 Jokes We TOTALLY Missed In BelovedFilms From Our Youth (Refinery29)

Please Don't Retire At 62. Here's Why. (The Motley Fool)

13 Stars You Won't Recognize (Answers)

See The Before and After Photos of 18 CelebsWho Clearly Have Fake Teeth (POPnHOP)

20 Extremely Dumb Celebrities (Rant Lifestyle)

Most Outrageous Gowns at the Met Gala (The Cut)

The First Wine Club to Get it Right (The Huffington Post)

This Way to Pay Off Mortgage May SurpriseYou (Bills.com)

5 Tips for a Healthy Lunch Kids Will Love (Stonyfield)

7 Restaurant Deals You Shouldn't Swallow (Bankrate)

by TaboolaSponsored Links

9/19/2014 Texas court throws out ‘paternalistic’ ban on ‘upskirt’ photos

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/09/texas-court-throws-out-paternalistic-ban-on-upskirt-photos/ 4/7

TRENDINGSTORIES

Photos show ‘Django Unchained’ actressstraddling boyfriend in car: ‘They weref*cking’

0

‘No, daddy, no!’: Philly dad catchesdaughter’s boyfriend in bedroom, shootshim in head

9/19/2014 Texas court throws out ‘paternalistic’ ban on ‘upskirt’ photos

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/09/texas-court-throws-out-paternalistic-ban-on-upskirt-photos/ 5/7

0

Doctor admits he intentionallymisdiagnosed cancer, ordered unneededchemo

0

Another week, another atheist demandswe call his sexism not-sexism. (Thistime, Sam Harris.)

0

Sponsored Links

Newsmax Headlines

DeLay, Tarkenton, Dershowitz on DIRECTV349, DISH 223

Secret Emails: Liberals Slam Hillary, BackWarren

NYC: Illegals Get Free Trips to the Zoo

Reid’s Senate Built on 4-Day Workweek

Palin, Romney or Huckabee For GOP 2016,Vote Now

An Easy Solution to Owning Gold OffshoreIn Your IRA

The One Thing Your Prostate Needs EveryMorning

Are You an American Born Before 1965?Please Read

What's This?

9/19/2014 Texas court throws out ‘paternalistic’ ban on ‘upskirt’ photos

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/09/texas-court-throws-out-paternalistic-ban-on-upskirt-photos/ 6/7

NEW STORIES

Researchers can trick the body intofighting HIV, flu, other infections

0

Angelina Jolie mastectomy sparks surgein female cancer tests: study

0

Angry with Washington, 1 in 4 Americansopen to secession

0

9/19/2014 Texas court throws out ‘paternalistic’ ban on ‘upskirt’ photos

http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2014/09/texas-court-throws-out-paternalistic-ban-on-upskirt-photos/ 7/7

SIGN UP FOR OUR NEWSLETTERGet the best of Raw Story, delivered daily

Email Address SIGN UP

SEE ALL RAW STORIES

CDC: 90 percent of children who diedfrom flu last year had not been

vaccinated0

WATCH: JetBlue passengers brace forlanding after engine explodes and cabinfills with smoke

0