1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

67
5 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Pharmaceutical Industry in Bangladesh Following the Drug (Control) Ordinance of 1982, some of the local pharmaceutical companies improved range and quality of their products considerably. The national companies account for more than 65% of the pharmaceutical business in Bangladesh. However, among the top 20 companies of Bangladesh 6 are multinationals. Almost all the life saving imported products and new innovative molecules are channeled into and marketed in Bangladesh through these companies. Multinational and large national companies generally follow current good manufacturing practices (cGMP) including rigorous quality control of their products. The Drug Act of 1940 and its rules formed the basis of the country's drug legislation. Unani, ayurvedic, homeopathic and biochemic medicines were exempted from control under the legislation. The pharmaceutical industry was dominated by the foreign companies at that time. Even in the allopathic market there were extemporaneous preparations dispensed from retail pharmacies. The pharmaceutical industry, however, like all other sectors in Bangladesh, was much neglected during Pakistan regime. Most multinational companies had their production facilities in West Pakistan. With the emergence of Bangladesh in 1971, the country inherited a poor base of pharmaceutical industry. For several years after liberation, the government could not increase budgetary allocations for the health sector. Millions of people had little access to essential life saving medicines. With the promulgation of the Drug (Control) Ordinance of 1982 many medicinal products considered harmful,

Transcript of 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

Page 1: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

1. INTRODUCTION

1.1 Pharmaceutical Industry in Bangladesh

Following the Drug (Control) Ordinance of 1982, some of the local pharmaceutical companies

improved range and quality of their products considerably. The national companies account for

more than 65% of the pharmaceutical business in Bangladesh. However, among the top 20

companies of Bangladesh 6 are multinationals. Almost all the life saving imported products and new

innovative molecules are channeled into and marketed in Bangladesh through these companies.

Multinational and large national companies generally follow current good manufacturing practices

(cGMP) including rigorous quality control of their products. The Drug Act of 1940 and its rules

formed the basis of the country's drug legislation. Unani, ayurvedic, homeopathic and biochemic

medicines were exempted from control under the legislation. The pharmaceutical industry was

dominated by the foreign companies at that time. Even in the allopathic market there were

extemporaneous preparations dispensed from retail pharmacies.

The pharmaceutical industry, however, like all other sectors in Bangladesh, was much

neglected during Pakistan regime. Most multinational companies had their production

facilities in West Pakistan. With the emergence of Bangladesh in 1971, the country inherited

a poor base of pharmaceutical industry. For several years after liberation, the government

could not increase budgetary allocations for the health sector. Millions of people had little

access to essential life saving medicines. With the promulgation of the Drug (Control)

Ordinance of 1982 many medicinal products considered harmful, useless or unnecessary got

removed from the market allowing availability of essential drugs to increase at all levels of

the healthcare system. Increased competition helped maintain prices of selected essential

drugs at the minimum and affordable level.

In 1981, there were 166 licensed pharmaceutical manufacturers in the country, but local

production was dominated by eight multinational companies (MNCs) which manufactured

about 75% of the products. There were 25 medium sized local companies which

manufactured 15% of the products and the remaining 10% were produced by other 133

small local companies. All these companies were mainly engaged in formulation out of

imported raw materials involving an expenditure of Tk 600 million in foreign exchange. In

Page 2: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

spite of having 166 local pharmaceutical production units, the country had to spend nearly

Tk 300 million on importing finished medicinal products. A positive impact of the Drug

(Control) Ordinance of 1982 was that the limited available foreign currency was exclusively

utilised for import of pharmaceutical raw materials and finished drugs, which are not

produced in the country. The value of locally produced medicines rose from Tk 1.1 billion in

1981 to Tk 16.9 billion in 1999. At present, 95% of the total demand of medicinal products is

met by local production. Local companies (LCs) increased their share from 25% to 70% on

total annual production between 1981 and 2000.

In 2000, there were 210 licensed allopathic drug-manufacturing units in the country, out of

which only 173 were on active production; others were either closed down on their own or

suspended by the licensing authority for drugs due to non compliance to GMP or drug laws.

They manufactured about 5,600 brands of medicines in different dosage forms. There were,

however, 1,495 wholesale drug license holders and about 37,700 retail drug license holders

in Bangladesh. Anti-infective is the largest therapeutic class of locally produced medicinal

products, distantly followed by antacids and anti-ulcerants.

Other significant therapeutic classes include non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drug (NSAID),

vitamins, central nervous system (CNS) and respiratory products. A most remarkable

progress the local industry has made in recent time is the phenomenal increase in the local

production of basic chemicals. There are now 13 drug manufacturing units, which also

manufacture certain basic materials. These include Paracetamol, Ampicillin Trihydrate,

Amoxycillin Trihydrate, Diclofenac Sodium, Aluminium Hydroxide Dried Gel, Dextrose

Monohydrate, Hard Gelatin capsule shell, Chloroquine Phosphate, Propranolol

Hydrochloride, Benzoyl Metronidazole, Sodium Stibogluconate (Stibatin) and Pyrantel

Pamoate. However, most of these are confined to the last stage of synthesis. There are

three public sector drug manufacturing units. Two of them are the Dhaka and Bogra units of

Essential Drug Company Ltd. (EDCL), which is functioning as a public limited company under

the Ministry of Health and Family Welfare. EDCL produced medicines worth Tk 964 million in

2000. There are separate vaccines and large volume IV fluids production units under the

Institute of Public Health (IPH). The productions of both EDCL and IPH are mostly used in

government hospitals and institutions. In 2000, there were 261 unani, 161 ayurvedic, 76

Page 3: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

homeopathic and biochemic licensed manufacturing units. They produced medicines worth

Tk 1.2 billion in 2000.

One of the major positive impacts of Drug (Control) Ordinance is the rapid development of

local manufacturing capability. Almost all types of possible dosage forms include tablets,

capsules, oral and external liquids (solutions, suspensions, emulsions), ointments, creams,

injections (small volume ampoules/dryfill vials/suspensions and large volume IV fluids), and

aerosol inhalers are now produced in the country. In recent years, the country has achieved

self-sufficiency in large volume parenterals, some quantities of which are also exported to

other countries. The development of local manufacturing capability helped contain

dependence on the import of pharmaceutical products (raw material and finished product)

around pre-1982 level. Under the Drug (Control) Ordinance government fixes the maximum

retail prices (MRP) of 117 essential drug chemical substances. Drugs other than these

essential ones are priced through a system of indicative prices. This rule applies on the

locally manufactured products only. For imported finished products, a fixed percentage of

markup is applied on the C&F price to arrive at the MRP, regardless of whether they are

within the list of essential 117 molecules or not. It is interesting to note that, even with

withdrawal of price control from many products, prices have not shot up; healthy

competition has been keeping the prices within affordable levels.

Physical distribution of pharmaceuticals in Bangladesh has evolved in a unique way. Unlike

other countries Bangladesh pharmaceutical industry is more retail oriented and bulk of

distribution is done by the companies themselves. Pharmaceutical companies distribute

their products from their own warehouses located in different parts of the country, as no

professional distribution house is available. Wholesalers play a limited role in this regard

since companies supply goods to both retailers and wholesalers. Export of pharmaceutical

products is still in an infant stage, although a number of private pharmaceutical companies

have already entered the export market with their basic materials and finished products.

They export their products to Vietnam, Singapore, Myanmar, Bhutan, Nepal, Sri Lanka,

Pakistan, Yemen, Oman, Thailand, and some countries of Central Asia and Africa.

The primary responsibility for drug quality control lies with the manufacturers. However, the

Page 4: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

government's drug testing laboratories (DTL) and the Directorate of Drug Administration

(DDA) have the monitoring and supervising role. There are two government drug testing

laboratories. DTL at Dhaka is in the Institute of Public Health and the regional DTL at

Chittagong is under DDA. Drug administration is responsible for registration of drugs for

marketing in Bangladeshand for inspection of premises and licensing. With its present set up

and inadequate strength, DDA often finds it difficult to carry out its very large volume of

assigned work. The national drug policy and the regulatory control policies are yet to

achieve best results for a healthy growth of the pharmaceutical industry. Because of the

limited capacity of the government's drug testing laboratories, the quality of products

manufactured locally cannot be uniformly ensured. Restrictions on patent rights discourage

foreign investors to come up actively in the pharmaceutical market in Bangladesh.

Introduction of new research molecules is difficult due to slow registration process and

restrictions on patent protection. Although the fixed mark-up system of pricing helped keep

the prices of pharmaceutical products low, this made it difficult to cover costs of marketing

and distribution. The fixed mark-up system also discourages some companies to invest for

cGMP and assurance of high quality production. Some important therapeutic classes of the

pharmaceutical market (antacids and oral vitamins) are only open to the local companies

even after 20 years of the drug ordinance. This policy is discriminatory and also contrary to

the announced investment policy of the government.

The annual per capita drug consumption in Bangladesh is one of the lowest in the world.

However, the industry has been a key contributor to the Bangladesh economy since

independence. With the development of healthcare infrastructure and increase of health

awareness and the purchasing capacity of people, this industry is expected to grow at a

higher rate in future. Healthy growth is likely to encourage the pharmaceutical companies to

introduce newer drugs and newer research products, while at the same time maintaining a

healthy competitiveness in respect of the most essential drugs.

In Bangladesh Pharmaceutical sector is one of the most developed hi tech sector which is

contributing in the country's economy. After the promulgation of Drug Control Ordinance -

1982, the development of this sector was accelerated. The professional knowledge,

thoughts and innovative ideas of the pharmacists working in this sector are the key factors

Page 5: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

for these developments. Due to recent development of this sector we are exporting

medicines to global market including European market. This sector is also providing 95% of

the total medicine requirement of the local market. Leading Pharmaceutical Companies are

expanding their business with the aim to expand export market. Recently few new

industries have been established with hi tech equipments and professionals which will

enhance the strength of this sector.

1.2 Objectives of the Study

The specific objectives of this study are as follows:

To examine the existing financial system of pharmaceutical companies in Bangladesh.

To understand the solvency of Square and Beximco Pharmaceuticals Ltd.

To evaluate the Asset Utilization conditions of Square and Beximco Pharmaceuticals Ltd.

To know the profitability of Square and Beximco Pharmaceuticals Ltd.

1.3 Methodology

This is exclusively an observatory research. Thus observation and study of historical records,

financial statement and company /industry brochure have been taken as major bases for

research.

1.4 Sources of data

This report has been prepared on the basis of secondary information. The Books,

Periodicals, Journals, Annual Report of Square and Beximco Pharmaceuticals Ltd, Economic

Trends, Published articles and manual sore other printed materials as well as records related

with the topic are the source for the conceptual Part of the report. For this Purpose, the The

Annual Reports of Square and Beximco (2009-2010) have proved to be great help.

Page 6: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

1.5 Scope of Study

This report was conducted in Bangladesh area. Because it is assumed that perspective of

customer satisfaction of Dhaka city will represent the other people of the country and thus

will cover the targeted population. It is also guide to establish a link between the theoretical

and practical situation of the total economy.

1.6 Limitations of Study

During this report certain problems were faced as pointed below. These problems may

impact the quality of the work.

Difficulty to collect data because of the excessive nature of confidentiality

maintained by the officials of those pharmaceuticals companies.

There were too much precious works available.

Pharmaceuticals don’t organize public relation program frequently.

Unavailability of relevant data and information.

Lack of adequate time to complete the report successfully.

1.7 Conclusion

1.7.1 Benchmark Analysis

Analysis of firms in a same industry is called as Benchmark analysis. Even for industry

analysis the benchmark may have limited usefulness if the whole industries major firms in

that industry are performing poorly.

1.7.2 Relative Measurement

A primary advantage of ratio is that they can be used to compare the risk sand return

relationships of firms of different sizes. It also provides a profit of a firm, its economic

characteristics and competitive strategies.

Activity analysis evaluates revenue and output generated by the firm’s assets.

Liquidity analysis measures the adequacy of a firms cash

Long-term debt examines the firm’s capital structure.

Page 7: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

2. THEORITICAL FRAMEWORK

2.1 Industry Analysis

Industry analysis is an important part of business planning. This analysis often looks at the

external factors that will affect the company’s operations.

Investment practitioners perform industry analysis because they believe it helps them

isolate investment opportunities that have favorable return-risk characteristics. We likewise

have recommended it as part of our Three-step, top-down plan for valuing individual

companies and selecting stocks for inclusion in our portfolio. What exactly do we learn from

an industry analysis? Can we spot trends in industries that make them good investments?

Are there unique patterns in the rates of return and risk measures over time in different

industries? In this section, we survey the results of studies that addressed these questions.

In the research we describe, investigators asked the following set of questions designed to

pinpoint the benefits and limitation of industry analysis:

Is there a difference between the returns for alternative industries during specific

time periods?

Will an industry that performs well in one period continue to perform well in the

future?

That is, can we use past relationships between the market and an individual industry

to predict future trends for the industry?

Is the performance of firms within an industry consistent over time?

Several studies also considered questions related to risk:

Is there a difference in the risk for alternative industries?

Does the risk for individual industries vary or does it remain relatively constant over

time?

Page 8: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

2.1.1 Industry Performance Over Time:

In another group of investigations, researchers questioned whether individual industries

that perform well in one time period would continue to perform well in subsequent time

periods or at least outperform the aggregate market in the latter time period. In this case,

investigators found almost no association in individual industry performance year to year or

over sequential rising or falling markets.

These time series studies imply that past performance alone does not help project future

industry performance. The results do not however, negate the usefulness of industry

analysis. They simply confirm that variables that affect industry performance change over

time and each year it is necessary to project the future performance for individual industries

on the basis of future estimates of these relevant variables.

2.1.2 Function

Industry analysis involves reviewing information on current economic market conditions.

Industries studied can include retail, fast food, manufacturing, various repair services and

construction. The type and number of business industries analyzed depends on the local

economic market. Markets with large groups of consumers or several demographic groups

often have more business industries than smaller economic markets. Free market

economies are built on the concept of supply and demand. Markets with high consumer

demand often have more companies in particular industries.

2.1.3 Types

Business owners can conduct an industry analysis in one of two ways: quantitative or

qualitative. Quantitative analysis uses mathematical forecasting techniques to analyze

specific pieces of an industry’s information. Decision trees, game theory or other forecasting

methods are commonly used in the industry analysis. Qualitative analysis involves business

owners reviewing industry information and making personal judgments or inferences from

Page 9: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

the information. Business owners with particular experience or expertise in an industry

often use qualitative analysis as they are already familiar with that particular industry.

2.1.4 Purpose

Industry analysis is important because it allows business owners to estimate how much

profit they can generate from business operations. Business owners rarely enter industries

at the plateau stage or those which have begun an economic decline. Industries under these

conditions do not usually generate enough profits for new business ventures. Business

owners also assess the number of competitors currently selling consumer goods or services

in their industry. High levels of competition often create lower than desired profits.

2.1.5 Benefits

Conducting a very detailed and intense industry analysis can provide business owners with

specific knowledge regarding the economic marketplace. Business owners may discover a

market niche not currently being met by other companies. Business owners can also

conduct consumer surveys to learn about new goods or services that could have high

demand in the marketplace. This information can provide new business owners with a

significant benefit over existing companies in a business.

2.1.6 Warning

Industry analysis does not guarantee success in the business environment. Business owners

can misinterpret information or make incorrect judgments on the best way to pursue profits

with a new business venture. Spending too much time on industry analysis can also subject

the business owner to paralysis of analysis. This theory states that individuals who collect

too much information may be unable to make a business decision. Additionally, more time is

spent doing the analysis phase than making a decision.

Page 10: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

2.1.7 Performance of the Companies within an Industry:

Other studies were designed to determine whether there is consistency in the performance

of companies within an industry if all the firms within an industry performed consistently

during a specified time period, investors would not need company analysis. In such a case,

industry analysis alone would be enough because once you selected a profitable industry

you would know that all the stocks in that industry would do well.

These studies typically have found wide dispersion in the performance among companies in

most industries. Studies have also shown evidence of an industry effect in specific

industries, such as oil or autos, but most stocks showed a small industry effect that has been

declining over time.

Implication of Dispersion within Industries Some observers have contended that industry

analysis is useless because all films in an industry do not move together. Obviously,

consistent firm performance in an industry would be ideal because you would not need to

do company analysis. For industries that have a strong, consistent industry influence, such

as oil, gold, steel, autos, and railroads, you can reduce the extent of your company analysis

after your industry analysis.

Most analysts do not expect such a strong industry influence, which means that a thorough

company analysis is still necessary. Even for industries that do not have a strong industry

influence, industry analysis is valuable because it is much easier to select a superior

company from a good industry than to find a good company in a poor industry. By selecting

the best stocks within a strong industry, you avoid the risk that your analysis and selection

of a good company will be offset by poor industry performance.

2.1.8 Differences in Industry Risk:

Although a number of studies have focused on industry rates of return, few studies have

examined industry risk measures. The studies on industry risk investigated two questions:

(1) Does risk differ among industries during a given time period? (2) Are industry risk

Page 11: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

measures stable over time? The study results regarding the dispersion of risk found a wide

range of risk among different industries at a point in time, and the differences in industry

risk typically widened during rising and falling markets. The results on the analysis of risk

stability were positive—an analysis of the risk measures for individual industries over time

indicated that they were reasonably stable over time.

These findings indicate that although risk measures for different industries showed substan-

tial dispersion during a period of time, individual industries risk measures are stable over

time.

This means that the analysis of industry risk is necessary, but this analysis of risk is useful

when you attempt to estimate the future risk for an industry.

2.1.9 Summary on Industry Analysis

The conclusions of the studies dealing with industry analysis are:

During any time period, the return for different industries very within a wide range,

which means that industry analysis, is an important part of the investment process.

The rates of return for individual industries vary over time, so we cannot simply

extrapolate past industry performance into the future.

The rates of return of firms within industries also vary, so analysis of individual

companies in an industry is necessary follow-up to industry analysis.

During any time period, different industries risk levels vary within wide ranges, so we

must examine and estimate the risk factors for alternative industries.

Risk measures for different industries remain fairly constant over time, so the

historical risk analysis is useful when estimating future risk.

Page 12: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

2.2 Company Analysis

This section groups various analysis components for discussion. “Firm Competitive

Strategies” continues the Porter discussion of an industry’s competitive environment. The

basic SWOT analysis is intended to articulate a firm’s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities,

and threats.

These two analyses should provide a complete understanding of a firm’s overall strategic

approach. Given this background, we review the fundamental valuation models. In the rest

of this chapter, we discuss estimating intrinsic value using the two valuation approaches: (I)

the present value of cash flows, and (2) relative valuation ratio techniques. Fol lowing this,

we discuss the significance of site visits to companies, how to prepare for an interview with

management, and suggestions on when an investor should consider selling an asset. This is

followed by a discussion of unique considerations regarding evaluation of international

companies and their stock. The final section of the chapter discusses the unique features of

true growth companies and presents and demonstrates several models that can be used to

value growth companies.

2.2.1 Firm’s Competitive Strategies

In describing competition within industries, we identified five competitive forces that could

affect the competitive structure and profit potential of an industry. They are: (1) current

rivalry, (2) threat of new entrants, (3) potential substitutes, (4) bargaining power of

suppliers, and (5) bargaining power of buyers. After you have determined the competitive

Structure of an industry, you should attempt to identify the specific competitive strategy

employed by each firm and evaluate these strategies in terms of the overall competitive

structure of the industry.

A company’s competitive strategy can either be defensive or offensive. A defensive

competitive strategy involves positioning the firm so that its capabilities provide the best

means to deflect the effect of the competitive forces in the industry. Examples may include

investing in fixed assets and technology to lower production costs or creating a strong brand

image, with instated advertising expenditures.

Page 13: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

An offensive competitive strategy is one in which the firm attempts to use its strengths to

affect the competitive forces in the industry. As an investor, one must understand the

alternative competitive strategies available, determine each firm’s strategy, judge whether

the firm’s strategy is reasonable for its industry, and, finally, evaluate bow successful the

firm is in implementing its strategy.

In the following sections, we discuss analyzing firm’s completive position and strategy. The

analyst must decide whether the firm’s management is correctly positioning the firm to take

advantage of industry and economic conditions. The analyst’s opinion about management’s

decisions should ultimately be reflected in and be the basis for the analyst’s estimates of the

firm’s growth of cash flow and earnings.

Porter suggests two major competitive strategies: low-cost leadership and differentiation.

These two competitive strategies dictate bow a firm has decided to cope with the five

competitive conditions that define an industry’s environment. The strategies available and

the ways of implementing them differ within each industry.

Low-Cost Strategy The firm that pursues the low-cost strategy is determined to become the

low-cost producer and, hence, the cost leader in its industry. Cost advantages vary by

industry and might include economies of scale, proprietary technology, or preferential

access to raw materials. In order to benefit from cost leadership, the firm must command

prices near the industry average, which means that it must differentiate itself about as well

as other firms. If the firm discounts price too much, it could erode the superior rates of

return available because of its low cost.

Differentiation Strategy With the differentiation strategy, a firm seeks to identify itself as

unique in its industry in an area that is important to buyers. Again, the possibilities for

differentiation vary widely by industry. A company can attempt to differentiate itself based

on its distribution system (selling in stores, by mail order, or door-to-door) or some unique

marketing approach. A firm employing the differentiation strategy will enjoy above-average

rates of return only if the price premium attributable to its differentiation exceeds the extra

cost of being unique.

Page 14: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

2.2.2. Focusing a Strategy

Whichever strategy it selects, a firm must determine where it will focus this strategy.

Specifically, a firm must select segments in the industry and tailor its strategy to serve these

specific groups. For example, a low-cost strategy would typically exploit cost advantages for

certain segments of the industry, such as being the low-cost producer for the expensive

segment of the market. Similarly, a differentiation focus would target the special needs of

buyers in specific segments.

Next, you must determine which strategy the firm is pursuing and its success. Also, can the

strategy be sustained? Further, you should evaluate a firm’s competitive strategy over time,

because strategies need to changes an industry evolves; different strategies work during

different phases of an industry’s life cycle. For example, differentiation strategies may work

for firms in an industry daring the growth stages. When the industry is in the mature stage,

firms may try to lower their costs.

Through the analysis process, the analyst identifies what the company does well, what it

doesn’t do well, and where the firm is unable to the five competitive forces. Some call this

process developing a company’s “story?’ This evaluation enables the analyst to determine

the outlook and risks facing the firm.

In summary understanding the industry’s competitive forces and the firm’s strategy for

dealing with them is the key to deriving an accurate estimate of the firm’s long-run cash

flows and risks of doing business.

2.2.3 SWOT Analysis:

SWOT analysis involves an examination of a firm’s strengths, weaknesses, opportunities, and

threats. It should help you evaluate a firm’s strategies to exploit its competitive advantages

or defend against its weaknesses. Strengths and weaknesses involve identifying the firm’s

internal abilities or lack thereof. Opportunities and threats include external situations, such

Page 15: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

as competitive forces, discovery and development of new technologies, government

regulations, and domestic and international economic trends.

The strengths of a company give the firm a comparative advantage in the marketplace. Per-

ceived strengths can include good customer service, high-quality products, strong brand

image, customer loyalty, innovative R&D, market leadership, or strong financial resources.

To remain strengths; they must continue to be developed, maintained & and defended

through prudent capital investment policies.

Weaknesses result when competitors have potentially exploitable advantages over the firm.

Once weaknesses are identified, the firm can select strategic to mitigate or correct the

weaknesses. For example, a firm that is only a domestic producer in a globa1 market can

make investments that will allow it to export or produce its product overseas Another

example would be a firm with poor financial resources that would form joint ventures with

financially stronger firms.

Opportunities, or environmental factors that favor the firm can include a growing market for

the firm’s products (domestic and international), shrinking competition, favorable exchange

rate shifts, a financial community that has confidence in the outlook for the industry or firm,

or identification of a new market or product segment.

Threats are, environmental factors that can hinder the arm in achieving its goals. Examples

would include a slowing domestic economy (or sluggish overseas economies for exporters),

additional government regulation, an increase in industry competition, threats of entry,

buyers or suppliers. seeking to increase their bargaining power, or new technology that can

obsolete the industries product By recognizing and understanding opportunities and

threats, an investor can make informed decisions about how the firm can exploit

opportunities and mitigate threats.

Page 16: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

3.0 RATIOS AND FORMULAS IN FINANCIAL ANALYIS

Financial statement analysis is a judgmental process. One of the primary objectives is

identification of major changes in trends, and relationships and the investigation of the

reasons underlying those changes. The judgment process can be improved by experience

and the use of analytical tools. Probably the most widely used financial analysis technique is

ratio analysis, the analysis of relationships between two or more line items on the financial

statement. Financial ratios are usually expressed in percentage or times. Generally, financial

ratios are calculated for the purpose of evaluating aspects of a company's operations and

fall into the following categories:

liquidity ratios measure a firm's ability to meet its current obligations.

profitability ratios measure management's ability to control expenses and to earn a

return on the resources committed to the business.

leverage ratios measure the degree of protection of suppliers of long-term funds and

can also aid in judging a firm's ability to raise additional debt and its capacity to pay

its liabilities on time.

efficiency, activity or turnover ratios provide information about management's

ability to control expenses and to earn a return on the resources committed to the

business.

A ratio can be computed from any pair of numbers. Given the large quantity of variables

included in financial statements, a very long list of meaningful ratios can be derived. A

standard list of ratios or standard computation of them does not exist. The following ratio

presentation includes ratios that are most often used when evaluating the credit worthiness

of a customer. Ratio analysis becomes a very personal or company driven procedure.

Analysts are drawn to and use the ones they are comfortable with and understand.

3.1 Liquidity Ratios

Page 17: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

3.1.1 Working Capital

Working capital compares current assets to current liabilities, and serves as the liquid

reserve available to satisfy contingencies and uncertainties. A high working capital balance is

mandated if the entity is unable to borrow on short notice. The ratio indicates the short-

term solvency of a business and in determining if a firm can pay its current liabilities when

due.

FormulaCurrent Assets

- Current Liabilities

3.1.2 Acid Test or Quick Ratio

A measurement of the liquidity position of the business. The quick ratio compares the cash

plus cash equivalents and accounts receivable to the current liabilities. The primary

difference between the current ratio and the quick ratio is the quick ratio does not include

inventory and prepaid expenses in the calculation. Consequently, a business's quick ratio

will be lower than its current ratio. It is a stringent test of liquidity.

FormulaCash + Marketable Securities + Accounts Receivable

Current Liabilities

3.1.3 Current Ratio

Provides an indication of the liquidity of the business by comparing the amount of current

assets to current liabilities. A business's current assets generally consist of cash, marketable

securities, accounts receivable, and inventories. Current liabilities include accounts payable,

current maturities of long-term debt, accrued income taxes, and other accrued expenses

that are due within one year. In general, businesses prefer to have at least one dollar of

current assets for every dollar of current liabilities. However, the normal current ratio

fluctuates from industry to industry. A current ratio significantly higher than the industry

average could indicate the existence of redundant assets. Conversely, a current ratio

significantly lower than the industry average could indicate a lack of liquidity.

FormulaCurrent Assets

Current Liabilities

Page 18: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

3.1.4 Cash Ratio

Indicates a conservative view of liquidity such as when a company has pledged its

receivables and its inventory, or the analyst suspects severe liquidity problems with

inventory and receivables.

FormulaCash Equivalents + Marketable Securities

Current Liabilities

Page 19: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

3.2 Profitability Ratios

3.2.1 Net Profit Margin (Return on Sales)A measure of net income dollars generated by each dollar of sales.

FormulaNet Income *

Net Sales

* Refinements to the net income figure can make it more accurate than this ratio computation. They

could include removal of equity earnings from investments, "other income" and "other expense" items

as well as minority share of earnings and nonrecuring items.

3.2.2 Return on Assets

Measures the company's ability to utilize its assets to create profits.

FormulaNet Income *

(Beginning + Ending Total Assets) / 2

3.2.3 Operating Income Margin

A measure of the operating income generated by each dollar of sales.

FormulaOperating Income

Net Sales

3.2.4 Return on Investment

Measures the income earned on the invested capital.

FormulaNet Income *

Long-term Liabilities + Equity

3.2.5 Return on Equity

Measures the income earned on the shareholder's investment in the business.

FormulaNet Income *

Equity

3.2.6 Du Pont Return on Assets

A combination of financial ratios in a series to evaluate investment return. The benefit of

the method is that it provides an understanding of how the company generates its return.

Page 20: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

FormulaNet Income *

Salesx

SalesAssets

xAssetsEquity

3.2.7 Gross Profit Margin

Indicates the relationship between net sales revenue and the cost of goods sold. This ratio

should be compared with industry data as it may indicate insufficient volume and excessive

purchasing or labor costs.

FormulaGross Profit

Net Sales

Page 21: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

3.3 Financial Leverage Ratios

3.3.1 Total Debts to Assets

Provides information about the company's ability to absorb asset reductions arising from

losses without jeopardizing the interest of creditors.

FormulaTotal Liabilities

Total Assets

3.3.2 Capitalization Ratio

Indicates long-term debt usage.

FormulaLong-Term Debt

Long-Term Debt + Owners' Equity

3.3.3 Debt to Equity

Indicates how well creditors are protected in case of the company's insolvency.

FormulaTotal Debt

Total Equity

3.3.4 Interest Coverage Ratio (Times Interest Earned)

Indicates a company's capacity to meet interest payments. Uses EBIT (Earnings Before

Interest and Taxes)

FormulaEBIT

Interest Expense

3.3.5 Long-term Debt to Net Working Capital

Provides insight into the ability to pay long term debt from current assets after paying

current liabilities.

FormulaLong-term Debt

Current Assets - Current Liabilities

Page 22: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

3.4 Efficiency Ratios

3.4.1 Cash Turnover

Measures how effective a company is utilizing its cash.

FormulaNet Sales

Cash

3.4.2 Sales to Working Capital (Net Working Capital Turnover)

Indicates the turnover in working capital per year. A low ratio indicates inefficiency, while a

high level implies that the company's working capital is working too hard.

FormulaNet Sales

Average Working Capital

3.4.3 Total Asset Turnover

Measures the activity of the assets and the ability of the business to generate sales through

the use of the assets.

FormulaNet Sales

Average Total Assets

3.4.4 Fixed Asset Turnover

Measures the capacity utilization and the quality of fixed assets.

FormulaNet Sales

Net Fixed Assets

3.4.5 Days' Sales in Receivables

Indicates the average time in days, that receivables are outstanding (DSO). It helps

determine if a change in receivables is due to a change in sales, or to another factor such as

a change in selling terms. An analyst might compare the days' sales in receivables with the

Page 23: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

company's credit terms as an indication of how efficiently the company manages its

receivables.

FormulaGross Receivables

Annual Net Sales / 365

3.4.6 Accounts Receivable Turnover

Indicates the liquidity of the company's receivables.

FormulaNet Sales

Average Gross Receivables

3.4.7 Accounts Receivable Turnover in Days

Indicates the liquidity of the company's receivables in days.

FormulaAverage Gross Receivables

Annual Net Sales / 365

3.4.8 Days' Sales in Inventory

Indicates the length of time that it will take to use up the inventory through sales.

FormulaEnding Inventory

Cost of Goods Sold / 365

3.4.9 Inventory Turnover

Indicates the liquidity of the inventory.

FormulaCost of Goods SoldAverage Inventory

Page 24: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

3.4.10 Inventory Turnover in Days

Indicates the liquidity of the inventory in days.

FormulaAverage Inventory

Cost of Goods Sold / 365

3.4.11 Operating Cycle

Indicates the time between the acquisition of inventory and the realization of cash from

sales of inventory. For most companies the operating cycle is less than one year, but in

some industries it is longer.

FormulaAccounts Receivable Turnover in Days

+ Inventory Turnover in Day

3.4.12 Days' Payables Outstanding

Indicates how the firm handles obligations of its suppliers.

FormulaEnding Accounts Payable

Purchases / 365

3.4.13 Payables Turnover

Indicates the liquidity of the firm's payables.

FormulaPurchases

Average Accounts Payable

3.4.14 Payables Turnover in Days

Indicates the liquidity of the firm's payables in days.

FormulaAverage Accounts Payable

Purchases / 365

Page 25: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

3.5 Additional Ratios

3.5.1 Altman Z-Score

The Z-score model is a quantitative model developed in 1968 by Edward Altman to predict

bankruptcy (financial distress) of a business, using a blend of the traditional financial ratios

and a statistical method known as multiple discriminated analysis.

The Z-score is known to be about 90% accurate in forecasting business failure one year into

the future and about 80% accurate in forecasting it two years into the future.

FormulaZ = 1.2

+1.4+0.6+0.999+3.3

xxxxx

(Working Capital / Total Assets)(Retained Earnings / Total Assets)(Market Value of Equity / Book Value of Debt)(Sales / Total Assets)(EBIT / Total Assets)

Z-score Probability of Failureless than 1.8greater than 1.81 but less than 2.99greater than 3.0

Very HighNot SureUnlikely

3.5.2 Bad-Debt to Accounts Receivable Ratio

Bad-debt to Accounts Receivable ratio measures expected uncollectibility on credit sales. An

increase in bad debts is a negative sign, since it indicates greater realization risk in accounts

receivable and possible future write-offs.

FormulaBad Debts

Accounts Receivable

3.5.3 Bad-Debt to Sales Ratio

Bad-debt ratios measure expected uncollectibility on credit sales. An increase in bad debts is

a negative sign, since it indicates greater realization risk in accounts receivable and possible

future write-offs.

FormulaBad Debts

Sales

Page 26: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

3.5.4 Book Value per Common Share

Book value per common share is the net assets available to common stockholders divided

by the shares outstanding, where net assets represent stockholders' equity less preferred

stock. Book value per share tells what each share is worth per the books based on historical

cost.

Formula

(Total Stockholders' Equity - Liquidation Value of Preferred Stocks - Preferred Dividends in Arrears)

Common Shares Outstanding

3.5.5 Common Size Analysis

In vertical analysis of financial statements, an item is used as a base value and all other

accounts in the financial statement are compared to this base value.

On the balance sheet, total assets equal 100% and each asset is stated as a percentage of

total assets. Similarly, total liabilities and stockholder's equity are assigned 100%, with a

given liability or equity account stated as a percentage of total liabilities and stockholder's

equity. On the income statement, 100% is assigned to net sales, with all revenue and

expense accounts then related to it.

3.5.6 Cost of Credit

The cost of credit is the cost of not taking credit terms extended for a business transaction.

Credit terms usually express the amount of the cash discount, the date of its expiration, and

the due date. A typical credit term is 2 / 10, net / 30. If payment is made within 10 days, a 2

percent cash discount is allowed: otherwise, the entire amount is due in 30 days. The cost of

not taking the cash discount can be substantial.

Formula% Discount

100 - % Discountx

360Credit Period - Discount Period

3.5.7 Current-Liability Ratios

Current-liability ratios indicate the degree to which current debt payments will be required

within the year. Understanding a company's liability is critical, since if it is unable to meet

current debt, a liquidity crisis looms. The following ratios are compared to industry norms.

Page 27: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

FormulasCurrent to Non-current = Current Liabilities

Non-current LiabilitiesCurrent to Total = Current Liabilities

Total Liabilities

3.5.8 Rule of 72

A rule of thumb method used to calculate the number of years it takes to double an

investment.

Formula72

Rate of Return

Page 28: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

4. CASE ANALYSIS

SQUARE AND BEXIMCO - Comparative Financial Perspective

4.1 Fixed Assets:

At Square Pharmaceuticals, all property, plant and equipment is initially accounted for at

cost and depreciated over their expected useful life in accordance with property, plant and

equipment. The cost of acquisition of an asset comprises its purchase price and any directly

attribute cost of bringing the asset to its working condition for its intended use inclusive of

inward freight, duties and non-refundable taxes. In respect of major projects involving

construction, related pre-operational expenses form part of the value of asset capitalized.

Expenses capitalized also include applicable borrowing cost. The assets and liability of the

subsidiary-Beg Rubber industries Ltd, has been measured at the fair value as at the date of

acquisition.

On retirement of otherwise disposal of fixed asserts, the cost and accumulated depreciation

are eliminated and any gain of loss on such disposal is reflected in the income statement,

which is determined with reference to the net book value the assets and the net sales

proceeds.

At Beximco Pharma, all property, plant and equipment is initially recorded at cost and

depreciated over their expected useful life. The cost of acquisition of an asset comprises its

purchase price and any directly attribute cost of bringing the asset to its working condition

for its intended use inclusive of inward freight, duties and non-refundable taxes. In respect

of major projects involving construction, related pre-operational expenses form part of the

value of asset capitalized. Expenses capitalized also include applicable borrowing cost.

Expenditure incurred after the assets have been put in to operation, such as repairs &

maintenance, is normally charged off as revenue expenditure in the period in which is it

Page 29: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

incurred. In situation, where it can be clearly demonstrated that the expenditure has

resulted in an increase in the future economic benefits expected to be obtained from the

use of the fixed assets, the expenditure is capitalized as an additional cost of the assets.

Software are generally charged off as revenue expenditure. Fixed assets include cost of

assets (including exchange loss) acquire under financial lease.

On retirement of otherwise disposal of fixed asserts, the cost and accumulated depreciation

are eliminated and any gain of loss on such disposal is reflected in the income statement,

which is determined with reference to the net book value the assets and the net sales

proceeds.

4.2 Depreciation

No depreciation is charged on freehold land or on capital work-in-progress. Depreciation is

charged on all fixed assets on a reducing balance method for square pharmaceuticals ltd.

Depreciation for full years has been charged on additions irrespective of date when the

related assets are put into use and no depreciation has been charged on assets disposed off

during the year.

The rates at which asserts are depreciated per annum, depending on the nature and

estimated useful life of assets are given below:

Factory Building and other Construction 10%

Plant & Machinery 15%

Laboratory & office Equipment 10%

Furniture & Fixture 10%

Motor Vehicle 20%

Electrical Installation 15%

Books and Periodicals 30%

Page 30: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

No depreciation is charged on land. In respect of all other fixed assets, depreciation is

provided to amortize the cost of the assets after commissioning, over their expected useful

economic lives. Depreciation is computed using the reducing balance method. Full year’s

depreciation is charged on additions and no depreciation is provided on retirement,

irrespective of data of addition of retirement respectively.

The annual depreciation rates applicable to the principal categories of assets are:

Building and Other Construction 5% to 10%

Plant and Machinery 7.5% to 15%

Furniture & Fixtures 10%

Transport & Vehicle 20%

Office Equipment 10% to 50%

4.3 Cash in Hand

This comprises cash in hand and cash at bank which are available for use by the company.

This comprises cash in hand and at banks.

Page 31: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

4.4 Inventories

Inventories are stated at the lower of cost or net realizable value in compliance to the

requirements. Stock of raw materials, packing materials and finished goods are valued at

the lower of cost and estimated net realizable value. Work-in-proceed are valued at

material cost while other stocks are valued at cost. The cost is determined on weighted

average cost basis. Net realizable value is based on estimated selling price less any further

costs anticipated to be incurred to make the sale. Any obsolete stock or abnormal losses are

recognizing as expenses.

Inventories are carried at the lower of cost and net realizable value. Cost is determined on

weighted average cost basis. The cost of inventories comprises of expenditure incurred in

the normal course of bringing the inventories to their present location and condition. Net

resizable value is based on estimated selling price less any further costs expected to be

incurred to make the sale.

4.5 Income Tax

The holding company is enjoying tax holiday for seven years in respect of its AgroVet unit

with effect from December 1998. The company is also enjoying tax holiday for five years of

its Dhaka unit with effect from April, 2002.

Provision for income tax has been made @ 30% on net profit of taxable unit for the year

after adjustment of 10% rebate for declaration of Dividend above 20%

Provision is made for taxable temporary differences for the prior years and will be adjusted

in due course of time as and when required.

Page 32: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

Current has been provided on the estimated taxable profit for the year under review @

30%, being the tax rate applicable for publicly traded company. It also includes adjustments

for earlier year’s short/excess provision.

The company has adopted deferred tax in compliance with the provisions of Bangladesh

Accounting Standard (BAS) – 12 “Income Taxes”. The company policy of recognition of

deferred tax assets/liabilities is based on temporary differences (Taxable of deductible)

between the carrying amount (Book value) of assets and liabilities for financial reporting

purpose and its tax base, and accordingly, deferred tax income/expenses has been

considered to determine net profit after tax and earnings per share (EPS).

4.6 Revenue Recognition

Local sales of both locally manufactured and imported Pharmaceuticals Drugs and

Medicines, Agro Vet products and pesticide products are recognized at the time of delivery

from depot. Exports of Pharmaceuticals Drugs and medicines are recognized at the time of

delivery from factory go down. Local sales of basic chemical products are recognized at the

time of delivery from factory go down. Dividend income has been accounted for on receipt

basis.

4.7 Foreign Currency Transactions

Page 33: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

Foreign currencies are translated into taka at the exchange rates ruling on the date of

transactions in accordance with the effects of changes in foreign exchange rates. Bank

deposit in foreign currency for retention quota account has been translated in to taka at the

year end at the rate of exchange ruling on that date and gain (loss) have been accounted for

as other income in the income statement.

The financial records of the company are maintained and the financial statements are stated

in Bangladesh Taka. Foreign currency transactions are recorded at the applicable rates of

exchange ruling at the transaction date.

Other monetary assets and liabilities, if any, denominated in foreign currencies at the

balance sheet date are translated at the applicable rates of exchange ruling at the data.

Exchange differences are charged off as revenue expect exchange loss relating to obligation

under lease which has been capitalized to relevant fixed assets being procured under the

said obligation, as a requirement of the Companies Act 1994.

4.8 Share Premium

The balance in share premium account shall be utilized in accordance with provisions of the

companied Act 1994 and as directed by the Securities and Exchange Commission in this

respect.

Page 34: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

The section 57 of the Companies Act 1994 provides that the share premium account may be

applied by the company:

a) In paying up unissued of the company to be issued to members of the company as

fully paid bonus shares;

b) In writing off the preliminary expenses of the company;

c) In writing off the expenses of or the commission paid or discount allowed on any

issue of shares or debenture if the company; and

d) In providing for the premium payable on the redemption of any redeemable

preference shares or of any debenture of the company.

4.9 Earnings Per Share

Earning per share is calculated in accordance with the Bangladesh Accounting Standard

(BAS) 33 “Earnings per share”.

This has been calculated by dividing the basic earnings by the weighted average number of

ordinary shares outstanding during the year.

4.10 Borrowing Cost

The company capitalizes borrowing cost for new projects such at interest on term loan and

other related fees/charge for the period till to commencement of commercial operation and

charges the cost to revenue account as financial expression after commencement of the

commercial operation.

Page 35: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

Borrowing costs relating to projects already in commercial operating are charged as

expenses for the year under review. In respect of projects that have not yet commenced

commercial production, borrowing costs are debited to capital work in progress.

Page 36: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

5. FINDINGS

SQUARE AND BEXIMCO - Relative Measurement

5.1 Liquidity Ratios

Liquidity of Square and Beximco in terms of net working Capital to Total assets Current Ratio

and Quick Ratio for the financial years 2009 and 2010 has been developing as under.

5.1.1 Current Ratio:

Current ratio has been computed by dividing current liabilities into current assets. This gives

one an idea about the ability of meet current debts. The current ratio of Square 1.50 to 1.53

and for Beximco 1.45 to 1.40 times during the study period 2009 to 2010.

The average being 1.52 times. As compared to the standard norm of 2 (two) times current

ratio of Square and Beximco found to be more or less satisfactory during the period.

5.1.2 Quick Ratio

Page 37: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

Quick ratio has been computed by dividing current liabilities into quick assists i.e. current

assists minus inventory and prepaid expenses. This is a more severe test of the liquidity since

it concentrates strictly on the liquid assets.

The graph shows that quick ratio of Square within 1.19 to 0.41 times the average being 0.8

the study period. Quick ratio of Beximco varied from 0.63 to 0.72. As compared the standard

norm of one time wick ratio Square and Beximco have been or less satisfactory during the

period.

5.2 Asset Utilization Ratios

Page 38: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

Asset Utilization ratio are known as activity ratio includes inventory turn over, Days

Receivable Ratio Fixed Asset Turnover, days receivable Ratio Fixed Assets Turnover and

working Capital Turnover. These ratios measure the efficiency of the use of assets. These

ratios in the context Square and Beximco for the period 2005 to 2009 are analyzed as

follows.

5.2.1 Receivable turnover:

Receivable turnover has been computed by dividing sales into receivables. This gives one an

idea about the ability of a firm to meet its current debts. The graph shows that receivable

turnover of Square 23.17 to 24.54 times the average being 23.85.

Other hand the receivable turnover of Beximco 4.00 to 4.26 times the average being 4.13.

As compared the receivables turnover the Square is good and Beximco is poor.

5.2.2 Average collection period:

Page 39: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

Average collection period turnover has been computed by dividing Account receivable into

Average daily credit sales.

The chart shows that Square 15 days to 14 days and Beximco 89 days to 84 days. As

compared the Collection Square is good and Beximco is poor.

5.2.3 Inventory turnover ratio:

Page 40: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

Inventory turnover has been calculated by dividing sales by inventory. This measure the

extent of generating Takes cost of goods hold per- Taka of inventory some authors for the

profitable industries and this may also be considered so for the selected industries. The

graph shows inventory turnover of Square varied from 5.41 to 5.27 times the average being

5.37 times during study period.

Inventory turnover of Beximco varied from 1.71 to 1.97 times the average being 1.84 times

during study period.

As compared to the Square and Beximco, inventory turnover of Square is poor and Beximco

is good.

5.2.4 Fixed asset turnover ratio:

Page 41: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

This turnover has been calculated by dividing net fixed assets into sales. This is a measure of

indicating the extent of generation sales volume in terms of net fixed assets. One author

considered 5 times fixed assets turnover as the reasonable more for the profitable firms for

judging the of Capital assets and this may also be considered so for the Square indicated

that fixed assets turnover 1.32 to 1.34 times the average being 1.33 times during the study

period. Fixed assets turnover of Beximco 0.39 to 0.45 times the average being 0.42 times

during the study period.

As compared with standard norm, fixed assets turnover of Square and Beximco has been

satisfactory during study period.

5.2.5 Total asset turnover ratio:

Page 42: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

Net working to total assets has been computed by during net working capital by total

tangible assets and the quotient has been expressed in percentage.

The graph shows that Net working Capital to total assets of Square had been 0.78 to- 0.76

the average being 0.77 during the period.

For the Beximco, it was 0.20 to 0.30. The average was 0.29 during the period.

Page 43: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

5.3 Profitability Ratios

Profitability refer to the earning capacity of an enterprise where net profits, either before of

after taxes are expressed in relation to sales, equity capital, net worth, total assets etc. in

this sense, profitability ratios include return or sales, return on equity, return on invested

and returns on capitalization. These ratios in the context of Square and Beximco during the

period under review are analyzed as follows.

5.3.1 Return on Assets Ratio:

Return on asset ratio has been computed by dividing net income into total assets. This graph

shows that the Square of return on assets ratio is 12.67% to 12.53% the average is 12.6%.

On the other hand, return on assets of Beximco is 3.80% to 4.47% the average is 4.13%.

As compared the two companies the return on asset ratio shows the Square is good and

Beximco is poor.

Page 44: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

5.3.2 Return on equity ratio:

This return has been found out by dividing net profit after tax by equity and then multiplying

the quotient hundred. In the graph the return on equity of Square is pointed out and varied

within 22.55 % to 18.21% the average being 20.38% during the study period. And Beximco

varied within 6.81% to 7.71%

As compared to the standard norm the return on equity of Square is satisfactory and

Beximco is more or less satisfactory.

Page 45: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

5.4 Debt Utilization Ratio

5.4.1 Debt to total asset ratio:

Debt to total assets has been computed by dividing total debt by total asset. This ratio

indicated the greasing position of an enterprise. The graph points out that debt equity ratio

of Square had varied within 29.58% to 31.15% the average being 30.36% during the study

period.

And the Beximco varied within 44.18% to 37.6% the average being 40.89%.

As compared to the standard norm of Debt to total assets of Square and Beximco is more or

less satisfactory.

Page 46: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

6. CONCLUSION

SPL and BPL are long being rival to take the top two positions in pharmaceuticals industry in

Bangladesh. Though other companies like OPL, ACME, RENATA, Essential Drugs etc. are

always logged in fighting for top ten market positioning, these two companies never being

found in third or fourth position since 1990. From the observation, it has been found that

capital investment of Square and Beximco are respectively Tk. 3.53 billion and Tk. 3.36

billion and also sales turnover in 2010 was Tk. 0.03 billion and Tk. 0.12 billion.

It has been found that the volume of marketing expenses always is fewer than selling

expenses. And also it is notified that selling expenses volume is almost four times more than

marketing expenses. It has also found that admin. expense of Square and Beximco

pharmaceuticals was Tk. 0.19 billion and Tk. 0.12 billion. It has also found that the selling

espense of Square and Beximco pharmaceuticals was Tk. 0.80 billion and Tk. 0.72 billion. It

has also identified that the gross turnover of Square and Beximco was Tk. 7.1 billion and Tk.

3.3 billion. The worth of inventory of Square and Beximco was Tk. 1.34 billion and Tk. 1.68

billion. Square and Beximco did pay the amount of Tk. 1.36 billion and Tk. 3.9 million as

taxes.

It has been found that overseas market turnover of Square and Beximco pharmaceuticals

was Tk. 0.11 billion and Tk. 90 million. Currently the local pharmaceutical market is worth

around Tk. 7000 crore. Around 80 percent of total raw materials are imported from mainly

China. Pharmaceutical exports stood at $18.69 million in the July-November period of fiscal

year 2009 -10, a 15.44 percent rise from the same period a year ago, according to the Export

Promotion Bureau. Finally it may be concluded that Pharmaceutical industry is now one of

the highest flourished corporate businesses in Bangladesh.

Page 47: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

7. RECOMMENDATIONS

For Domestic Market,

These two companies should decrease their marketing expenses.

These two companies should highlight the fact that they can produce the same

or better quality at lesser price.

The company’s top management always should be more encouraging to the key

personnel in the company so that they can able to take the best out of them.

They can increase the pay scale of their employees in a sense of increasing the

productivity of the company.

They should not be more aggressive only on the returns of their company.

As the first line market leader in Pharmaceuticals industry the companies should

concentrate maximizing the wealth rather than simply profit of the company.

The financial management must analyze the ROE, ROI, VAV, EPS, and P/E

continuously and circulate these consistently in the capital market.

For International Market,

The Developed world has been stressing on free market policies at one hand and on

the other hand has instituted acts such as TRIPS, which is essentially a “protectionist

law”. It is therefore essential for the third World to seek clarification on WTO.

To maintain country specific comparative advantage specialization based on country

strength and disease pattern of the country can be introduced. This will enable the

countries to produce exclusive Medicines, which can be marketed to other countries.

In the long run countries may also emphasize upon common branding policies to

simplify procedures and standardize the medicines.

Page 48: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

8. REFERENCE

Annual Report of Square and Beximco (2009-2010)

Clausen, James. (2009). “Accounting 101 – Financial Statement Analysis in Accounting: Liquidity Ratio Analysis Balance Sheet Assets and Liabilities , Journal of financial statement.

Clausen, James. (2009), “Accounting 101 – Income Statement: Financial Reporting and Analysis of Profit and Loss , Journal of income statement. Clausen, James. (2009), “Basic A ccounting 101- Asset Turnover Ratio: Inventory, Cash, Equipment and Accounts Receivable Analysis , Journal of asset turnover ratio. Diane, White. (2008), “Accounts Receivable: Analyzing the Turnover Ratio , Journal of account receivable. Hutchinson, James (2010), “Long Term Debt to Equity Ratio of a Business: Understand a Company's Value to its Investors and Owners , Journal of long term debt to equity ratio. Jenkins, Lucia. (2009). “Contribution Margin and Breakeven Analysis: Determining when a Company will Realize a Profit , Journal of contribution margin and breakeven analysis. Marshall, D., McManus, W., Viele, D. (2003).Managerial Accounting and Cost-Volume-Profit Relationships. Accounting: What the numbers mean (6 th ed.). New York: Mtetwa, Munya. (2010). “Fixed Assets: Capital Expenditure , Journal of fixed assets in accounting. Nelgadde, Jo. (2010). “Accounts Receivable Analysis: A Guide to Analyzing Trade Debtors for Small Business Owners , Journal of accounts receivable analysis. Nelgadde, Jo. (2009). “Inventory Analysis: A Guide to Analyzing Inventory for Small Business Owners , Journal of inventory analysis. Nelgadde, Jo. (2010). “Debt Collection and Debt Recovery Tools: Using Credit Insurance and Debt Collection Agencies , Journal of debt collection and debt recovery tools. Thachappilly, Gopinathan. (2009). “Profitability Ratios Measure Margins and Returns: Profit Ratios Work with Gross, Operating, Pretax and Net Profits”. Journal of profitability ratio measure margin and return. Thachappilly, Gopinathan. (2009). “Financial Ratio Analysis for Performance Check: Financial Statement Analysis with Ratios Can Reveal Problem Areas”. Journal of financial ratio analysis for performance evaluation.

Page 49: 1204 - Ratio Analysis Thesis (FINAL)

5

Thachappilly, Gopinathan. (2009). “Liquidity Ratios Help Good Financial Management: Liquidity Analysis reveals likely Short-Term Financial Problems”. Journal of liquidity ratio analysis. Thachappilly, Gopinathan. (2009). “Debt Ratios Look at Financial Viability/Leverage: The Ratio of Debt to Equity Has Implications for Return on Equity”. Journal of debt ratios analysis. Tracy, John A. (2004). How to Read a Financial Report: Wringing Vital Signs Out of the Numbers . John Wiley and Sons. p.173. Weygandt, J. J, Kieso, D. E, & Kell, W. G. (1996). Accounting Principles (4 th ed.). New York, Chichester, Brisbane, Toronto, Singapore: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. p. 800. Weygandt, J. J, Kieso, D. E, & D, Warfield Terry (2001). “Intermediate accounting: cash ratio analysis”. (10 th ed.). Bearcat Company, Vol-1.p.211. Weygandt, J. J, Kieso, D. E., & D, Warfield Terr y (2001). “Intermediate Accounting: Return on assets ratio”. (10 ed.). Bearcat Company, Vol-1.p.361. th Weygandt, J. J, Kieso, D. E., & D, Warfield Terr y (2001). “Intermediate Accounting: Inventory turnover ratio”. (10 th ed.). Bearcat Company, Vol-1.p.470. Weygandt, J. J, Kieso, D. E., & D, Warfield Terr y (2001). “Intermediate Accounting: total asset turnover ratio”. (10 ed.). Bearcat Company, Vol-1 p.572. th

Weygandt, J. J, Kieso, D. E., & D, Warfield Terr y (2001). “Intermediate Accounting: Return on asset ratio”. (10 ed.). Bear cat Company, Vol-1 p.572. th Weygandt, J. J, Kieso, D. E., & D, Warfield Terr y (2001). “Intermediate Accounting: Debt coverage ratio”. (10 th ed.). Bearcat Company, Vol-1 .p.734. Weygandt, J. J, Kieso, D. E., & D, Warfield Terr y (2001). “Intermediate Accounting: Time interest earned ratio”. (10 ed.). Bearcat Company, Vol-1. p. 736. th Weygandt, J. J, Kieso, D. E., & D, Warfield Terr y (2001). “Intermediate Accounting: Return on equity ratio”. (10 th ed.). Bearcat Company, Vol-1.p. 830. Weygandt, J. J, Kieso, D. E., & D ,Warfield Terr y (2001). “Intermediate Accounting: Book value per share”. (10 ed.). Bearcat Company, Vol-1.p. 831 th Weygandt, J. J, Kieso, D. E., & D, Warfield Terr y (2001). “Intermediate Accounting: Earning per share”. (10 th ed.). Bearcat Company, Vol-1.p. 831 Zain, Maria. (2008). “How to Use Profitability Ratios: Different Types of Calculations that Determine a Firm's Profits , Journal of profitability ratio analysis