1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

67
1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin

Transcript of 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

Page 1: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

1

Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun

What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too

Ben Mullin

Page 2: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

2

Why Am I Here

• Talk about how much fun I’ve been having visual variable star observing (VSO)

• Basics of VSO and how you could get involved• What you can observe

– including some variables close to objects you probably already observe

• How VSO has improved my observing• What the data you collect might mean• Not going to be a technical talk (I’m not an expert)

– A little math can add to the fun

Page 3: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

3

My Road To VSO

• Always known VSO was an option• Deep Space Objects are cool• What could be fun about observing a single

star?• Imaging is also fun• Eventually I got interested in the

processing, plotting, and analyzing aspects of CCD VSO

Page 4: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

4

My Road Continued

• Theoretically I have all of the equipment necessary to do CCD VSO

• Prime focus imaging with a narrow field of view is really hard

• So VSO sat on the back burner while I worked on getting things together

• Somehow decided visual observations would be too difficult

Page 5: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

5

My First Observation

• Realized that it was still going to be a while before I got CCD all sorted out

• I knew Algol was a regular eclipsing binary that was pretty easy to observe

• Started with the American Association of Variable Star Observers (AAVSO) Manual for Visual Observing of Variable Stars

• This gave the basics on how to make an observation.

Page 6: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

6

Observing Algol

• First step is to know when the eclipse is expected– Published in S&T also an

applet on the S&T website

• Get a chart from the AAVSO with comparison stars

Page 7: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

7

Page 8: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

8

My Observations

• In and out of the house while getting the kids ready for bed (did I mention STI?)

• 8 observations over 3.5 hours

Algol 9/28/2007

2

2.2

2.4

2.6

2.8

3

3.2

3.4

2454372.55 2454372.6 2454372.65 2454372.7 2454372.75

J ulian Date

Page 9: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

9

Global Collaboration

• Looks like I missed the minimum

• But, what about collaborating with others?

• Between me and Stanislaw Swierczynski from Poland we captured the minimum.

Algol 9/28/2007

2

2.2

2.4

2.6

2.8

3

3.2

3.4

2E+06 2E+06 2E+06 2E+06 2E+06 2E+06

Julian DateM

agn

itu

de My Observations

StanislawSw ierczynski, Poland

Page 10: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

10

Historical Data

• How does this compare to historical AAVSO data?

Phase Plot of Beta Per

1.5

2

2.5

3

3.5

4

4.5

0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1

Phase

Ma

g

AAVSO Data

Observation Set 1

Observation Set 2

Page 11: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

11

Wasn’t That Fun?

• Collected real data on an astronomical event• Collaborated with another observer on

another continent• Made cool graphs and had data to play with

when it was cloudy• Increased my observing skills• Any excuse to go out and look up is a good

one

Page 12: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

12

So How Did I Do That?

• Already mentioned the Manual for Visual Observing, eclipse predictions, and chart

• What about the actual observations?

• Is it hard?

• It’s easy and you can learn to do it in just a few minutes.

Page 13: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

13

Making Estimates

• Making estimates

Page 14: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

14

Told You So!

• Pretty easy isn’t it

• Other things to consider– Avoid biasing your estimate– Report what you see– Don’t stare at red stars– Number one source of error is mis-

identification of the variable

Page 15: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

15

Now What?

• Register as an AAVSO observer

• It’s easy and free

• Report your estimate

• Your estimates could be used by professional astronomers doing cutting edge research

Page 16: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

16

What You Need To Report An Observation

• Your observer initials (free registration with the AAVSO)

• Designation or name of the star observed

• Your estimate

• The chart used

• The comparison stars used

• Julian date of the observation

Page 17: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

17

Online Submission

Page 18: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

18

Putting It All Together

• Pick a star

• Get a chart from the AAVSO

• Make and record your observation

• Register as an AAVSO observer

• Report your observation

Page 19: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

19

See Your Contribution To Science

Page 20: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

20

What Could You Observe?

• A very brief overview of variable star types and their representative light curves– Not a strength of mine yet

• Interesting/easy variables you could try

Page 21: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

21

Broad Categorization

• Intrinsic– Pulsating– Cataclysmic

• Extrinsic– Eclipsing– Rotating

Page 22: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

22

Pulsating

• Cepheid – 1 to 70 days, 0.1 to 2.0 mags• RR Lyrae – 0.05 to 1.2 days, 0.3 to 2.0 mags• RV Tauri – 30 to 150 days, up to 3 mags,

alternating deep/shallow minimum• Long Period Variables (LPV) – 30 to 1000 days

– Mira – 80 to 1000 days, more than 2.5 mags– Semiregular – 30 to 1000 days, less than 2.5 mags,

intervals of semi or irregular variation

• Irregular

Page 23: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

23

Cepheid Light Curve

Page 24: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

24

RR Lyrae Light Curve

From Koppelman, Huziak, Cooney, Petriew

Page 25: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

25

Mira Light Curve

Page 26: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

26

Semiregular Light Curve

Page 27: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

27

Cataclysmic• Super Novae – One in Antennae Galaxy announced

12/19/2007, or M51 a few years ago• Novae – One in Puppis announced in November, one in

Vulpecula in December• Recurrent Novae• Dwarf Novae

– U Gem – Periods of quiescence then erupt– Z Cam – Like U Gem, but with “standstills”– SU UMa – Like U Gem, but with regular outbursts and super-

outbursts

• Symbiotic stars – Close binary systems• R CrB – Dwarf novae in reverse

Page 28: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

28

Super Novae Light Curve

Page 29: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

29

Novae Light Curve

Page 30: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

30

Recurrent Novae Light Curve

Page 31: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

31

U Gem Light Curve

Page 32: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

32

Z Cam Light Curve

Page 33: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

33

SU UMa Light Curve

Page 34: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

34

R CrB Light Curve

Page 35: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

35

Variables You Might Observe

• Noteworthy

• Easy

• Near other commonly observed objects

• Interesting

• We already talked about Algol

Page 36: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

36

Omi Cet - Mira

• Maximum predicted near Feb 3, 2008

• Going to become naked eye quickly

Page 37: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

37

Page 38: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

38

Delta Cep

• Bright

• Only a 5 day period

Page 39: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

39

Page 40: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

40

Zeta Gem

Page 41: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

41

Zeta Gem

• Cepheid

• Period 10.15 days

• Magnitude range 3.62-4.18

• Easy to find, hard to estimate

Page 42: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

42

M31/RX And

Page 43: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

43

RX And

• UGZ• Z Cam• Very Active• Outbursts and

standstills• Magnitude range 10.3-

14.0

Page 44: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

44

Page 45: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

45

M42/S Ori

Page 46: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

46

S Ori

• Mira• Period 419 days• Magnitude range 8.4-

12.9• Also a double star

Page 47: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

47

Page 48: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

48

M81/M82/R UMa

Page 49: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

49

R UMa

• Mira• Period 301 days• Magnitude range 6.6-

14.3

Page 50: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

50

Page 51: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

51

Double Cluster/S Per

Page 52: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

52

S Per

• SRC• Period 822 days• Magnitude range 7.9-

12.

Page 53: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

53

Page 54: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

54

RZ Cas

Page 55: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

55

RZ Cas

• Eclipsing binary• 4 hours to complete

cycle• Binocular object

Page 56: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

56

Page 57: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

57

How VSO Has Helped My Observing

• Admittedly not an advanced observer to begin with

• Star hopping• Averted vision• Contrast, magnification, and eyepieces• Concentration• Most importantly it has added a fun purpose

to my observing

Page 58: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

58

Are Math and Astrophysics Fun?

• They certainly can be

• Let’s see what my 19 observations of X Cyg can tell us

Page 59: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

59

Cepheid Variables

• A class of variable stars• Prototype star is Delta Cepheid discovered

in 1784 by John Goodricke• Henriette Leavitt discovered that their

period is closely correlated to their absolute magnitude

• Can be used as a standard candle to measure astronomical distances

Page 60: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

60

X Cyg is a Cepheid

• So if we can determine the period we can determine the absolute magnitude of the star

• Arne Henden, AAVSO director, pointed me to a primer paper, “Time-Series Analysis of Variable Star Data” by Matthew Templeton published in the Journal of the AAVSO

• Among other techniques, it described the ANOVA (analysis of variance) method for determining the period

Page 61: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

61

My Data

• 19 Observations over 5 cycles in 72 days

My X Cyg Observed Magnitudes

5.8

6

6.2

6.4

6.6

6.8

7

7.2

2454370 2454385 2454400 2454415 2454430 2454445 2454460

Julian Date

Mag

nit

ud

e

X Cyg

Page 62: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

62

ANOVA Analysis• My 19 points versus all 20000+ AAVSO

points

• My 16.36 days versus all AAVSO 16.3859 days versus reported 16.386332 days

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

14 15 16 17 18

Analysis of All AAVSO Data

Analysis of My Data

Page 63: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

63

Period-Luminosity Relationship

• We have determined the period, we can now calculate the absolute magnitude

• Period-Luminosity relationshipMv = -3.141*Log(P)-.826

• Mv = -3.141*Log(16.36)-.826 = -4.674 mag

• Now we know how bright it actually is and we know how bright we see it as…

Page 64: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

64

Magnitude Equation

• m - Mv - Av*d/1000 = 5*log(d/10)• m is the observed magnitude (average) – 6.38• Mv is the absolute magnitude - -4.674• d is the distance in parsecs - unknown• Av is extinction in mags/kparsec – 2.8 mags/kpc• Use Excel’s Goal-Seek function to find d• d = 716.68pc = 2339ly

Page 65: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

65

Compare That To The Professionals

• ESA Hipparcos satellite measured the parallax of many stars including X Cyg

• 1.47 +/- 0.72 milli arcseconds annual parallax for X Cyg

• d = 1000/mas• 456pc-1333pc “centered” at 680pc• 680pc compared to 716pc, not too shabby

for a set of binoculars!

Page 66: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

66

Almost Treat Time

• I have been having more fun observing than ever

• Possibly contributing to science

• Improving my observing skills

• Adds some fun things to do on cloudy nights

Page 67: 1 Visual Variable Star Observing Is Fun What I’ve Been Doing And What You Could Do Too Ben Mullin.

67

Thank You