1 STATE OF FLORIDA 2 the State of Florida Siting Board, which is final authority to approve...
Transcript of 1 STATE OF FLORIDA 2 the State of Florida Siting Board, which is final authority to approve...
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
STATE OF FLORIDA
IN RE: MEETING OF THE GOVERNOR ANDCABINET
_________________________________________/
VOLUME 2
CABINET MEMBERS: GOVERNOR RICK SCOTTATTORNEY GENERAL PAM BONDICHIEF FINANCIAL OFFICERJEFF ATWATER
COMMISSIONER OF AGRICULTUREADAM PUTNAM
DATE: TUESDAY, MARCH 29, 2016
LOCATION: CABINET MEETING ROOMLOWER LEVEL, THE CAPITOLTALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA
REPORTED BY: NANCY S. METZKE, RPR, FPRCOURT REPORTER
C & N REPORTERSPOST OFFICE BOX 3093
TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 32315-3093(850) 697-8314 / FAX (850) 697-8715
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
115
INDEX
PAGE NO.
OFFICE OF FINANCIAL REGULATIONBy Commissioner Breakspear 5
DEPARTMENT OF VETERANS AFFAIRSBy Director Prendergast 9
DIVISION OF BOND FINANCEBy Director Watkins 32
STATE BOARD OF ADMINISTRATIONBy Executive Director Williams 35
ADMINISTRATION COMMISSIONBy Director Kruse 59
BOARD OF TRUSTEES OF THE INTERNALIMPROVEMENT TRUST FUND
By Mr. Clark 93
POWER PLANT SITING BOARDBy Mr. Clark 117
CLEMENCY BOARD CLARIFICATION OFCOMMUTATION OF CARLOS DELGADO 187
INTERVIEW AND APPOINTMENT FORDEPARTMENT OF REVENUEEXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
Robert McKee 215
James Evers 226
James Overton 234
Leon Biegalski 241
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
116
INDEX CONTINUING
PAGE NO.
INTERVIEW AND APPOINTMENT FOR THEOFFICE OF INSURANCE REGULATIONCOMMISSIONER
Jeffrey Bragg 258
Bill Hager 280
* * * *
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
117
P R O C E E D I N G S
(CONTINUING IN SEQUENCE FROM VOLUME 1 WITHOUTOMISSION).
POWER PLANT SITING BOARD
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Let's get started
again. We're going to continue with the
Siting Board agenda.
MR. CLARK: Thank you, Governor. There are
two items on the Siting Board agenda today.
Item Number 1 is submittal of the minutes from
the May 13th, 2014, Siting Board meeting.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Is there a motion on the
item?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Move to approve the
minutes.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Is there a second?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Second.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Any comments or objections?
(NO RESPONSE).
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Hearing none, the motion
carries.
MR. CLARK: Item Number 2 is consideration of
a Proposed Final Order approving Florida
Power & Light Company's request to modify the Power
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
118
Plant Siting Act conditions and certifications for
the Turkey Point Power Plant's Units 3 through 5.
At this time I'd like to turn the podium over
to Mr. Craig Varn, General Counsel for DEP, to
present the details of the Final Order for your
consideration today.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Thanks.
Good afternoon, Craig.
MR. VARN: Good afternoon, Governor, Cabinet.
The item before you today is in your capacity
as the State of Florida Siting Board, which is
final authority to approve permitting, siting,
construction of electrical power plant and
transmission lines.
While, as is pointed out, I am General Counsel
for DEP, today I'm here in an advisory role to the
Board. I do similar items with respect to DEP,
where I advise the Secretary separate from the
underlying proceeding, and that's what I'm trying
to do here today.
In this case, we're dealing with a
modification to a previously authorized
certification. We have drafted a Final Order that
has been submitted and in which we recommend
adoption of the ALJ's Recommended Order with
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
119
two minor modifications which I'll describe in a
little bit.
Now the decision before the Siting Board is
somewhat limited. We are operating -- or you are
operating in a quasi judicial proceeding here, and
so you sit in sort of a review capacity. What that
means is you can't consider evidence that was not
included in the record below. That record has been
provided.
And when considering the Order, you also
cannot reject or modify the findings of fact that
the ALJ made, unless you go through the record in
its entirety and make a determination that those
facts are not supported by competent and
substantial evidence in the record. You cannot
change the ALJ's decision, the Administrative Law
Judge's decision on what evidence to accept or
reject; and you cannot delay or defer this
proceeding unless Florida Power & Light agrees to
such a deferral. There are time limitations in
place here.
So let me touch briefly on what the
modification is. Originally Florida Power & Light
submitted an application that had --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So -- Craig, can I stop you
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
120
for a second?
MR. VARN: Sure.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So the only thing we can do
today is approve or not approve?
MR. VARN: There's one -- you can approve, not
approve, or approve with conditions.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And can I just add to
that, Governor and Cabinet members?
So what that means is let's say there's a
study out there on either side, we can't consider
that. We have to basically stick to the four
corners of this document unless there is competent
and substantial evidence to prove otherwise.
We go with the findings of the ALJ, correct?
MR. VARN: Yes, ma'am. And I don't want to
tell you what you can and cannot talk about;
however, the law does lay out some pretty clear
parameters, and you're exactly right.
The evidence is what was established by the
ALJ, and that is what you're to consider. You may
hear discussions about other items, and I will
continue to advise you that we need to get back to
focusing on the record that's here.
I don't want anybody down the road to be able
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
121
to come in and say, based on a comment on an
ancillary issue, you were somehow biased or you
made your decision on a wrong fact.
So, again, the issue before you is somewhat
narrow, although I'm sure someone will disagree. I
would say it's somewhat narrow, and it's based on
the limited record that was put together at the
administrative hearing by the ALJ.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Because what we're --
this is a very interesting position in which we
sit. To me it's very interesting as Cabinet
members when there is an ALJ involved, so --
MR. VARN: Absolutely. Thank you.
If I may continue, on the modification,
originally Florida Power & Light sought basically
three modifications or three projects. Two of
those modifications were not challenged; and
therefore, pursuant to the Board's rules, the
Department, acting on behalf of the Board, issued a
final order in March of last year.
That approved everything that had been applied
for except the one condition -- or excuse me, the
one modification that we're here for today; and
that is, the authorization to use 14 million
gallons per day of water to supplant the existing
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
122
cooling canal system for purposes of temperature
and salinity. And we'll talk a little bit more
about that as I go forward.
So a little background on the wells. There
will be approximately six of them, up to six;
they're approximately a thousand feet deep; and
they'll go around the perimeter, the north and west
perimeter of the cooling canal system. There
should be a picture in your packet of what it looks
like in case you wanted to know. It's a fairly
large system.
So the administrative hearing, because the
application for modification for the third
modification was challenged, at the request of
Florida Power & Light, we forwarded that
application to the Division of Administrative
Hearings for a proceeding before an Administrative
Law Judge.
In January of this year, the Administrative
Law Judge issued his Recommended Order essentially
recommending approval of the modification with the
addition of one condition that was agreed to by the
parties. That condition requires additional
monitoring of some of the wells -- or of the
proposed production wells.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
123
Atlantic Civil, Inc., and the Department filed
exceptions to the Recommended Order, which are
addressed in the Draft Final Order in the agenda
item.
The Draft Final Order adopts the ALJ's
recommendation that Florida Power & Light's request
be approved with one modification that does not
affect the outcome. The Draft Final Order also
grants the Department's only exception, and that's
with respect to a terminology issue that also does
not affect the outcome.
With respect to the Recommended Order,
Section 403.059 -- or excuse me, 403.509 provides
the criteria for determining whether or not to
authorize this modification. ACI raised a number
of issues with respect to that request, but it also
raised a number of issues with respect to current
conditions; and I'll talk about that a little bit
later also and the distinction between them.
In addressing the issues raised by ACI,
Atlantic Civil, the ALJ found that the evidence
supported an affirmative determination that
Florida Power & Light had met the criteria under
the Power Plant Siting Act. If you want, I can go
through them. I won't unless you ask though.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
124
The ALJ also found that ACI did not raise any
issues regarding the issue of need. Now ACI has
clearly rejected that suggestion; nevertheless, the
Administrative Law Judge went through the criteria
and made a determination that Florida Power & Light
had nevertheless provided sufficient information to
meet the criteria -- or to show that it had met all
of the water-use criteria.
I want to point out that I think the most
important thing that we're here talking about is
that the ALJ found the modification would improve
groundwater conditions. And we have, again, the
existing conditions and then the results from
whatever this modification will do. And in the
eyes of the Judge, and I think it's fair to say
that the majority of the testimony was that it
would improve water conditions.
So I'd like to touch now on what our proposed
changes are to the Recommended Order, and this is
something that ACI and I have gone back and forth
with earlier, but I'm sure they'll be more than
happy to explain their position on this.
But in moving forward, the ALJ was required to
find that ACI had standing. That being a
conclusion of law, the Board does have the ability
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
125
to provide some input in that determination.
In Paragraph 63, the ALJ stated that standing
was based upon -- was because the conditions of
certification acknowledge and address the potential
for harm to water resources by the CCS or the
cooling canal system.
Now let me be clear, I agree that ACI has
standing in this issue. That I do not suggest you
find otherwise. What I'm trying to point out,
however, is that when a modification application
comes in, I believe your focus should only be on
the modification and the impacts or those ancillary
issues related to that modification.
My thought in reading this is that the Judge
has basically said, once you're in, anything
related to that permit, in this case Section 10 of
the conditions, are open for discussions. And I
disagree with that. I don't think the case law
supports that. In fact, I'm positive the case law
doesn't support it, and your rules specifically do
not support that. As such, I would suggest that
the standing be limited to those substantial
interests that will be affected by the
modification.
And, again, while I agree that ACI does have
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
126
standing here, I just want to refer you back to
your two rules, 62-17.211, two sections in there
regarding partial issuance of a Final Order, which
I mentioned we already did; and then the
application of administrative res judicata. I
think those go to my point that the modification or
the review is limited to the modification itself.
Therefore, as provided in the draft, we
recommend that Paragraph 63 and 64 be modified
consistent with the Board's rules as reflected in
that draft, and that the Board find that this
substituted con -- this substituted conclusion is
more reasonable than that which was modified.
And finally, I want to touch briefly on the
exceptions that were filed. Generally in Florida,
the Agencies are allowed to file exceptions. If no
exception is filed to a finding, that party is
deemed to either have agreed or at least accepted
them. In this case, ACI filed a total of seven
objections. I'll try to -- or exceptions. I'll
try to combine those. The Department filed one,
and Florida Power & Light filed zero.
The Department's exception, as I mentioned,
dealt with a terminology issue, and we recommended
granting that exception. Again, it has no impact
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
127
on the final decision.
Moving on to ACI's. ACI's first two
exceptions deal with the salinity in the cooling
canal and the impact of the modification on the
hypersaline plume. If you've read through, you've
read a lot about the hypersaline plume that's
currently occurring under the area.
However, despite ACI's suggestion, those
findings by the Judge are supported by competent
and substantial evidence in the record. With
respect to salinity, the ALJ determined that that
recent spike in salinity and the reflective
influence of contributing factors is a complex
subject. And I'm reading in somewhat, but he
wasn't able to come to the conclusion that ACI
wished him to.
Finally, ACI argues that the difference
between the testimony of Florida Power & Light's
witness and ACI's witness were contradictory and
somehow ACI's witness should be accepted. I will
say you simply cannot do that. The case law is
very clear on that. You cannot reweigh the
evidence; that is the purpose of the Administrative
Law Judge.
Further, there's competent and substantial
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
128
evidence to support the ALJ's finding, and it's
irrelevant that there may be opposite competent
substantial evidence. So if you have two -- the
two experts coming in and testifying, both of them
you believe, it is up to the Judge to weigh and
make that decision that that's where you are left.
So I'd say reweighing, as they suggest, would be
improper.
ACI's third and fourth exceptions deal with
the ALJ's finding that ACI did not raise the issue
of need. Again, as I mentioned earlier, the
Judge -- despite his finding that ACI did not
agree, the Judge still went through all of the
elements and made a determination that they did
meet all the criteria, including need being one of
those.
While we give a number of reasons in the draft
as to why that exception is invalid, the simplest
is the ALJ's findings in Paragraph 60 and 61 that
FPL's proposal met all of the applicable water
quality criteria; therefore, even if the issue was
raised, the ALJ found that ACI did not meet its
burden on that issue.
ACI's fifth exception argues that it's
contradicted. This deals with an NPDS permit. I
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
129
would argue here that ACI is confusing existing
conditions with the impacts from the modification.
The fundamental issue here is the modification
should improve water quality; therefore, that would
not make it inconsistent with an existing permit.
So in order to agree with that exception, the Board
would have to simply pretty much refute all of the
evidence that the ALJ found, and I would not
recommend doing that.
ACI takes exception to Paragraph 72 where the
ALJ took I guess exception with the ACI not
proposing a condition under which the proposal
could be approved. ACI has, in a number of
instances, suggested some general thoughts.
Regardless, ACI's argument was that the Judge
improperly placed the burden on ACI.
That, I would suggest, is incorrect. The
case law and the statute placed the burden on
Florida Power & Light to go forward. Once it's
done so, it is up to ACI to refute.
The Administrative Law Judge found that they
did not do so adequately; therefore, in all, as I
mentioned, we recommend adoption with the
modifications as mentioned: One being the
terminology issue; and two being the limitation or
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
130
simply clarification, as I would like to say, with
respect to the issues that are before you, that
being simply the modification, and recommend
approval of the Judge's Recommended Order.
And I'm obviously available for questions.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Why don't we go ahead
and hear -- if it's all right, we'll just go ahead
and hear from the other speaker.
MR. VARN: Yeah, I know we have some others
that are very happy to speak.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Did you have a question
first, Attorney General?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: No, we're going to
hear from ACI I assume?
MR. VARN: Yes, ma'am.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Who are we going
to hear --
MR. CLARK: Next we're going to hear from
Mr. Peter Cunningham with Florida Power & Light,
and then we have two more speakers following that.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Good afternoon.
MR. CUNNINGHAM: Good afternoon.
I am Peter Cunningham with Hopping Green &
Sams representing FPL. Also here today, in case
there are questions, are Mike Soul, who is Vice
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
131
President for Governmental Affairs for FPL; and
Steve Scroggs, who is the Senior Project Director
responsible for this project.
I'll be brief. FPL supports the Draft Final
Order that's now before you. We agree with the
sound legal reasoning on which it's based.
This case is about FPL's proposal to freshen
the Turkey Point Cooling Canal System with brackish
water from the Floridan wells; it's about a
thousand feet deep wells.
The Administrative Law Judge who heard all the
evidence recommended that you approve this proposal
because it meets all the standards, all the
applicable standards of all of the agencies,
including the South Florida Water Management
District; and that it meets the criteria under the
Power Plant Siting Act.
He also found specifically that this proposal
would eliminate the source of hypersaline water,
would improve groundwater conditions, and would
slow the migration of saline water westward.
FPL joins the DEP, the South Florida Water
Management District, and the Administrative Law
Judge in recommending approval of this item. We
ask that you adopt the Final Order to let this good
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
132
project go forward.
Thank you. I'd be happy to try to answer any
questions.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Does anybody have any
questions?
(NO RESPONSE).
GOVERNOR SCOTT: We're good right now. We
might have some later.
MR. CUNNINGHAM: Thank you.
MR. CLARK: Next up is Mr. Andy Bowman
representing ACI.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Good afternoon.
MR. BOWMAN: Good afternoon, Governor, members
of the Cabinet.
My name is Andy Bowman. I'm an attorney
representing Atlantic Civil who was the Intervenor
in this proceeding.
I was not here for the Cabinet Aides' meeting,
but I'm here today to talk about the
Recommended Order and the exceptions that have been
placed in front of you.
Just a brief background on this. It was
inferred to you that this is a large feature, this
cooling canal system. That is putting it mildly.
The cooling canal system is larger than some
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
133
municipalities in the State of Florida. It's
enormous; it looks like a giant radiator. And it
is massive in size, and in effect is the only one
operating in the nation.
It's cut into the porous fractured limerock
that sits atop the Biscayne Aquifer, which itself
is a very porous fractured aquifer. Water moves
very easily through this aquifer, both up and down
and horizontally. And the cooling canal system is
directly connected to this aquifer.
By design, huge pumps draw water in from the
cooling canal into the power plant to cool the
power plant. That happens on the east side. By
design, the cooling canal draws water in from
Biscayne Bay and from immediately beneath the
cooling canal system next to Biscayne Bay,
saltwater. It produces steam.
At the point where it's drawn in, it's a
vortex, the water level is a foot below sea level,
and this is all in the record. We had multiple
witnesses testify at length about how this system
operates.
So it draws saltwater into the system, runs it
through the plants, produces steam, and what comes
out on the northwest portion of the cooling canal
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
134
system is very hot and even more salty because,
of course, when the steam is gone, the salt doesn't
go anywhere, it stays in the water. It's blasted
out into the cooling canal system on the northwest
portion, and it's blasted out in such volumes that
at the northwest portion of the cooling canal
system, the water is a foot -- or is almost
two feet above sea level.
Now that's important because that's how the
system works; water flows downhill. So it goes
from the output on the northwest portion through
this little labyrinth -- or this large labyrinth
and then back in the other side.
Now the water piles up here by design because
that's what pushes it through the system, and yet
the proposal in front of you, what we find is that
water seeps into the cooling canal system from
Biscayne Bay and from the aquifer, saltwater, at
the point where the water is lowest where it's
being pulled into the plant; and it seeps out of
the cooling canal system through the bottom on the
north and the west side where the water is highest.
And this is the exact location where we're
going to add 14 million gallons a day of water,
where the water is already the highest, and where
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
135
it already seeps out of the bottom of the cooling
canal system at its -- at the north and the western
side of the cooling canal system. So you're going
to add to that piling of water. You're going to
add to that seepage. That was testified to. The
seepage will increase.
The cooling canal system currently discharges
three million pounds of salt a day into the
aquifer. That's in the record. The seepage from
the cooling canal system, principally in the
northwest portion of it, is over 16 million gallons
of water a day, carrying three million pounds of
salt with it.
Now anybody here could take a bucket of brine
and fill it -- or a bucket and fill it up halfway
with brine, pour it into the ground, you've poured
that brine into the ground.
You could take that same bucket, you could
have it filled halfway up with the brine and add
some fresh water to it, pour it into the ground,
it's the same salt, it's just accompanied by more
water. It does nothing to change the operation.
It does nothing to change -- or the impact in that
regard.
So we have a current system where we have
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
136
three million pounds of salt a day going with
16 million gallons of water a day into the aquifer,
and it moves very easily through this aquifer, it's
heavy; it sinks to the bottom. Think of a lava
lamp. And it goes down to the bottom of the
aquifer and sits there, it's dense, and it spreads.
Now this salt, we had a huge amount of
evidence to deal with the salt and the fact that
it, in fact, was FPL's saltwater. The Judge, in
the order that's in front of you, found that it's
FPL's saltwater. It's FPL's saltwater because it's
saltier than seawater, so where the heck else does
it come from? And it's laced with tritium which is
an ionized form of hydrogen. Tritium is what makes
your watch dial glow at night when you need to see
what time it is. It's a naturally occurring
isotope that occurs in greater levels as a result
of being run through a nuclear reactor.
So the witnesses from the Water Management
District and DEP both testified that finding the
tritium in the water, looking at the salinity in
the water, the tritium was a fingerprint. This was
FPL's water. And this FPL water with tritium of,
in some cases, hundreds, but at the very least,
20 times the background level, was delineated in
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
137
the evidence to be in an area approximately
25 square miles in size; extending four miles to
the west; extending to the north underneath the
Homestead International Speedway.
It's in all the maps, it's in all the
evidence. It was delineated out by multiple
witnesses. We have a witness that literally
drilled wells for the City of Homestead and
watched them turn salty one after another as this
advanced.
Now the ALJ found that despite all of this, it
was Florida Power & Light's water. And the
Administrative Law Judge further found that the
water from the cooling canal system had moved four
to five miles west of the cooling canal and was and
continues and will continue to violate State water
standards, it's in the order. It will violate
State minimum groundwater quality standards at the
very least. What us former DEP employees used to
call the "free-from standards"; that groundwater is
supposed to be free from discharges containing
pollutants that impair other's reasonable use of
adjacent groundwater.
This water, as it moves, pushes the natural
saltwater that was supposed to be four miles back
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
138
west under the cooling canal out in front of it,
and you watch in the monitoring wells as one after
another they have tripped and gone from fresh to
salt in a row. The latest one to go salty went
salty in 2013; it's in the record. It's one
quarter of a mile from my client's property.
My client is a legal existing user of water.
He holds water-use permits and DEP permits to
conduct mining and agriculture on his property, and
his damage -- his business will be severely
damaged; and his rights under his permits will be
severely impaired, if not destroyed, if he is
overrun by saltwater.
The Administrative Law Judge also found that
the cooling canal system is the primary cause of
the movement of saltwater and the saltwater front
to the west in southeastern Miami-Dade County, and
that in the remainder of Miami-Dade County, the
saltwater front is stable, except here. That is
all in the Recommended Order, and it was all found
by the Judge.
So the first question was: What is before you
today? A Recommended Order on a modification to
add 14 million gallons of water a day to this
system, added at the spot where the water is
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
139
already the highest, the pressure is already the
greatest pushing down, creating the most seepage.
And 14 millions gallons a day is not insignificant.
Fourteen million gallons a day is 5.11 billion
gallons of water a year. That is in the record
that's before you, roughly equivalent to replacing
all of the water in the cooling canal system on a
yearly basis.
So you're going to fill the cooling canal
system up, you're going to flush it out and fill it
up. Well, where is it flushing out to? It's
flushing out to the aquifer.
All of the witnesses testified that the water
from the cooling canal system, with this
modification, would have to go down. It has to go
somewhere. It would have to go down. It would
encounter the existing plume of contaminants from
the cooling canal system and it would press down on
that plume -- like pressing your hand down on a
balloon and the balloon bulges up on the sides and
pushes outward -- and the water would move out and
away from the cooling canal system.
This was testified to by
Mr. Jefferson Giddings of the South Florida Water
Management District; it was testified to by ACI's
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
140
own witnesses, and it is in the record.
And the end result of this is the plume, the
existing contaminant plume is displaced out and
away from the cooling canal system.
So Florida Power & Light has solved their
problem, their water is fresher, their water is
cooler and runs the plants better; and they've
just pushed the problem outward and away from
them.
We took issue in one of our exceptions with
the finding of fact that the plume would shrink and
disperse. And the reason for that exception was
actually that it was a twist or it was a poor
wording of the result of the evidence. Because the
evidence actually shows the models run by Florida
Power & Light and by the South Florida Water
Management District of the results of this
modification go out to 2040, so 25 years.
And every single witness testified that at
2040, 25 years out, the saltwater is still moving
and the plume is still spreading. So I don't know
how we get to the shrink and disappear.
Someone eventually testified that, yes,
eventually it will shrink and disappear. I don't
know if that's 50 years; I don't know if it's a
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
141
hundred years; I don't know if it's 30 years or
40 years. But we do know from the evidence that
was in front of the Judge that at the end of
25 years with the solution, the plume is being
pushed and spread and pushing the saltwater out in
front of it, and it continues to move. In fact,
Mr. Giddings testified that under either scenario
it will not stop until it encounters the higher
water levels and heads of the Everglades.
So with all of that in mind, the
Administrative Law Judge gave this Board a
recommendation, and the last page of the Judge's
order is rather telling.
Paragraph 74 of the order says that:
Respondents, being DEP and the Water Management
District, are probably correct that in this
certification proceeding it is sufficient for the
Siting Board's approval of FPL's proposed
modification that the modification would result in
an improvement over current groundwater conditions;
however, it is appropriate to inform the
Siting Board that the operation of the Turkey Point
Power Plant, as authorized by the Siting Board
under conditions of certification, has caused harm
to water resources because of the effects of the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
142
cooling canal system and the modification requested
by FPL will not prevent further harm from
occurring.
The same Administrative Law Judge also ruled
early in the case, and it's part of the record,
it's the Judge's ruling on November 13, 2015, when
our standing in this case was yet again questioned
by Florida Power & Light, that -- and I'm quoting
the ALJ's November 13, 2015, order: The
Siting Board has authority to determine under what
conditions the certified facilities will be
operated. The proposed modification is directly
related to ACI's alleged harm. ACI's allegations
are sufficient to establish its standing in this
modification proceeding to request that the
Siting Board impose conditions that will prevent
the harm.
Now Mr. Varn is correct in citing to the
well-established body of administrative case law
that a modification of a permit is limited to the
modifications. That comes from what we called the
Mirasol Wars, a series of cases down in Naples; and
I believe the one that was cited here was from the
G. L. Holmes property. Saturnia I believe was the
name of that property.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
143
And I was actually present at the Saturnia
trial. Actually Mr. Cunningham, one of his
partners, tried that case. And it's interesting
because in that case the Saturnia project had a
permit. They modified their water control system,
and as a result, they had to defend the entire
water control system again, because they had
changed how one part of it would operate.
What you have here is a cooling canal system
that is an integral part of the power plant that
this Board licenses, and you have a modification in
front of you that has been challenged by ACI; and
this modification makes a permanent change in the
operation of this cooling canal system to allow it
to function and determine how it functions and how
it integrates and supports the certified power
plant.
The change is permanent. The power plant, it
was testified in the hearing, can't operate without
the cooling canal system. The cooling canal
system's dysfunction even threatened the plant's
shutdown at one point during the process.
The ALJ's order states that the cooling canal
system is -- the operation of it is being changed.
You, as a Board, looking at a modification on how
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
144
this system is going to be operated in the future
-- and bear in mind, for 40 years this system has
never used a permanent supplemental supply of water
until now.
The ALJ has already ruled that you, in
determining how to modify this license, to change
the operation of the cooling canal system, can
impose conditions upon the modification to address
the harm. The harm is caused now. The harm is
caused under the modification, it's just from a
different physical or mechanical source. Instead
of adding the hypersaline water, you're just
spreading it by putting somewhat less saline water
on top of it, but the harm is the harm. It's like
being shot by a different caliber bullet if you're
ACI.
The Administrative Law Judge found that we had
standing; Mr. Varn hasn't disputed that. But we
have standing to attack the modification. We have
standing to ask you to place reasonable conditions
upon the modification, and I do take issue with
part of DEP's administrative -- or I'm sorry,
Final Order.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Mr. Bowman, can I interrupt
you for a second?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
145
MR. BOWMAN: Yes.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: What do you want?
MR. BOWMAN: What do I want? Thank you,
Governor, if we will just cut to the chase.
We would like the Siting Board to approve
conditions, along with this modification, that stop
the saltwater front -- that require the saltwater
front to be stopped before it reaches our client's
property, before it does any more damage.
That's what we've asked for. That's what
we've continually asked for from FPL; that's what
we've continually asked for from DEP and the Water
Management District.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Why didn't you --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: But --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Excuse me a second.
Why didn't you -- why didn't the
Administrative Law Judge agree with you?
MR. BOWMAN: In which term?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So I assume you asked for
something from the Administrative Law Judge, right?
MR. BOWMAN: Yeah, I guess -- I guess that's
a --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Why didn't they -- why didn't
they give it to you?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
146
MR. BOWMAN: And that's a very good question
because we took issue with that; it's Exception 7.
And the Administrative Law Judge, I -- you know, I
have a great deal of respect for the Administrative
Law Judge, I've known him a long time, and I just
disagree frankly with this -- with this point. And
the point is that the burden is on us to determine
whether or not the permit should be denied.
Once they provide --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: By law.
MR. BOWMAN: -- a prima facie case, the burden
shifts to the challenger. I agree with that law.
The burden, however, is not on me to come up with
modifications to a permit. The permit -- the
burden is on me to either determine that they
haven't proven their point or they have.
I have proven my point. My point was that
this system is violating water quality standards,
it has created a massive saltwater plume, it is
damaging groundwater and groundwater resources, and
that this modification will perpetuate that. And
from that -- I did prove that point, and that's why
the Administrative Law Judge put that in there and
wanted you advised.
But that's not really my role. It would
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
147
almost be disrespectful for me. That's -- to be
perfectly honest, that's this body's role, with the
DEP's assistance, to place conditions in the
permit. It's not the challenger's job to write
FPL's permit for them. So I kind of disagree on
that point.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: I think the Attorney General
had a question.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Yeah, I do.
And, Mr. Bowman --
MR. BOWMAN: Yes.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: -- you're a very
great advocate for your client, and everything
you've said to us today, you've argued this in
front of the ALJ, correct?
MR. BOWMAN: Correct.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: You said all of this
is in the record?
MR. BOWMAN: It is.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Multiple witnesses
were presented from you and from the other side,
correct?
MR. BOWMAN: Yes, ma'am.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Okay. Governor, may
I ask Craig a question?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
148
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Sure.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Craig, is it our role
to weigh the evidence again and basically
relitigate this matter?
MR. VARN: No, ma'am, I would say it is not,
and that's somewhat to my point that that is not
your job; that you're bound by the facts as they
were laid out by the ALJ. You have very limited
discretion in those unless you review the entire
record, and I will submit that the evidence that he
is trying to contradict is supported -- the
findings are supported by other competent and
substantial -- I'm not saying that he's wrong and
that -- his experts put on testimony that was
competent and substantial; but I will say that
whatever he's saying, there were other experts who
said the opposite.
The Judge made the determination -- for
whatever reason took one over the other, and that's
what you're stuck with, or that's what you have
before you.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Okay.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Let me just make sure. Let's
go back and tell us exactly what our --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Right. We would have
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
149
to -- my question is: So we would -- and I think
Mr. Bowman is nodding in agreement.
MR. BOWMAN: I believe that's the standard.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: We would have to find
that the other -- and, Mr. Bowman, I think you
agree, our role is very limited here.
And, Craig, we would have to find that there
is no competent and substantial evidence presented
by the other side, and basically ignore the
findings, the very detailed findings of the ALJ,
correct.
MR. VARN: You said it perfectly, yes, ma'am.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Thank you.
MR. VARN: I can sit down now. Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. And I interrupted you,
so I just want to make sure you --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I'm sorry,
Mr. Bowman.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: You finish so --
MR. BOWMAN: Are you referring --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: No, no, Mr. Bowman, you
finish because if we have any more questions -- I
interrupted you.
MR. BOWMAN: No, and thank you, Governor and
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
150
Attorney General. You're exactly right, you're not
to be reweighing evidence.
The Judge saw the demeanor of the witnesses,
chose who to believe and who not to believe, which
evidence he found more compelling. And truthfully,
almost all of the items that I recited to you are
in his order: He did find that they are the cause
of saltwater intrusion -- I'm sorry, he said the
primary cause; he did find that they are violating
water quality standards; he did find that the harm
will continue.
These are all in the order. And what he said
was -- and really the tenor of the order is, he put
that in there to let this body know that while he
gave somewhat of a lukewarm -- and I have to say,
in 20 years of doing administrative cases, I've not
seen as lukewarm an endorsement of a permit where
it at least appears that they've met their burden.
But he did, he went there; but he wanted this Board
advised that they have the role and they have the
right to impose additional conditions upon this
modification.
That is what we have been asking for. And in
response to the Governor, my only issue was that
it's not my role to come up with the solutions,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
151
it's your role. I shouldn't be doing your job,
Governor, and the rest of the Cabinet.
On the last point on the standing, I would
just point out that Mr. Varn wanted to change
Findings of Fact 63 and 64, and I would just
respectfully suggest that standing is one of those
things where it's the role of the Administrative
Law Judge, it's the application of general
principles of administrative law. It's not within
the particular or peculiar expertise of the
Department or, respectfully, the Siting Board.
It's not a technical issue within your body of
expertise. It's a general application of law.
The Judge's conclusions of law in 63 and 64,
for example, you don't have that ability to
overturn those because they're not in your, quote,
substantive jurisdiction under Chapter 120 of the
Administrative Procedures Act. And we believe that
the changing of the standing standard, as requested
here, would invade the province of the
Administrative Law Judge.
So we're here today asking that if you are
going to approve this, that you approve this with
conditions to actually halt the damage and the harm
and the violations that are occurring as a result
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
152
of the operation of the system that you are
changing and modifying through this approval.
Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Before you leave, does
anybody have any questions for Mr. Bowman? Do you,
Commissioner?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: I do.
The specific condition that we're considering
is Condition 12, right?
MR. BOWMAN: Correct.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: And that relates to the
withdrawal of water from the upper Floridan?
MR. BOWMAN: Yes.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Your free-from
standard -- I'd never heard that before so it's --
every now and then as I listen in this job, every
now and then -- every now and then I'll think maybe
I wish I'd gone to law school, and then days like
today cure me of that feeling.
MR. BOWMAN: Me, too.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: But the free-from
principle, isn't that related to your other
proceeding that you have going on in DOAH on
Condition 10?
MR. BOWMAN: That's a good point. There is a
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
153
separate proceeding on the administrative order
that the Department entered -- which the Judge
actually has recommended be invalidated because it
doesn't effectively constitutes I think -- what did
he say -- a reasonable exercise of enforcement
discretion.
What's happening here though is that the
administrative order case dealt with an
administrative order that's not part of this
license, it's not part of this permit that is
approved by this body. We initially argued that it
should be, and we lost that, so the two cases are
being handled separately.
But the permit is an entire permit, so
Section 10 deals with the cooling canal system.
Section 12 deals with the Water Management District
permits for pulling water out of the ground. You
have to read your permit as a whole. Just because
someone elects to put the words for the
modification in Section 12 of your license that
you've issued to Florida Power & Light does not
mean that you can't look at what the effect of that
modification is in Section 10. And Section 10
deals with the cooling canals and deals with the
groundwater.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
154
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Well, I agree that it
deals with that, but I thought we had to limit our
consideration to the --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: We do.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: -- 12th condition.
MR. BOWMAN: Well, no, you have to limit your
consideration to the effects of the modification.
And the modification, in its simplest form, is the
addition of 14 million gallons of water a day to
the cooling canal system, changing the operation of
the cooling canal system.
Where it appears in the license is sort of
a -- it's a form-over-substance kind of thing,
respectfully. It's -- you could put it in -- it
goes there because that provision deals with
everything that comes from the Water Management
District. There's another section where everything
that comes from a different department goes in that
Roman Numeral.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: You said that the harm
to ACI is that this modification, if approved,
perpetuates the migration of the plume?
MR. BOWMAN: Yes.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Do you believe that it
accelerates the migration of the plume?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
155
MR. BOWMAN: No. The plume continues to move
but it moves at a somewhat reduced rate, and I
believe that was where the Judge came up with the,
quote, improves the condition but wanted the
Siting Board advised.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: So, so --
MR. BOWMAN: Instead of going 400 feet a year,
it goes 250 feet a year.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: So this does have an
ameliorative effect on the existing problem that
admittedly is a big problem? And I'm going to get
to that with DEP in a minute. But you would
stipulate that this withdrawal would slow the
migration of the plume?
MR. BOWMAN: I, I -- that was what the
evidence at the hearing was. I'm bound by the
evidence.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Okay. Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Does anybody have any other
questions for Mr. Bowman?
MR. BOWMAN: Any other questions?
(NO RESPONSE).
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Thank you.
MR. BOWMAN: Thank you very much.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Thanks.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
156
MR. CLARK: Our next speaker is
Mr. Steve Teresi with ACI also.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Good afternoon.
MR. TERESI: Good afternoon, Governor,
Cabinet members.
A good deal of the questions have been asked
and answered, so I'm going to present my position
here in a little bit different format, but I'm
going to answer, hopefully, the Governor's question
at the end.
Again, my name is Steve Teresi, and I'm
President of Atlantic Civil. I very much thank you
for the opportunity to share my little story this
morning because the decision you make here today
affects me and my livelihood. And if you'll
indulge me, I should be able to compress my 12-year
struggle into about 4 or 5 minutes.
My family and I have been residents of
southeast Miami-Dade County long before there was a
nuclear power plant and the Turkey Point Cooling
Canal System. We are just west of the Turkey Point
Cooling Canal System, and we have been farming this
property since the 1920s and have been in the
mining business since as late as the 1960s.
Along the way, our business grew and
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
157
diversified in today Atlantic Civil, is also in the
rock mining business, the beach-compatible sand
business, and we are in the castor oil agriculture
business. We supply beach-compatible sand to
Miami-Dade County, Broward County, and
Monroe County, and provide that for the tourist
industry.
We also provide FDOT grade limerock for use on
our road and infrastructure and have been issued by
the permits -- have been issued permits by the
federal, state, and local agencies for these
activities. These permits took me 12 years to
acquire.
Today I come before you as a private citizen
and a property holder, a business person and a
concerned citizen of Miami-Dade County over the
very troubling issues at FPL's Turkey Point Cooling
Canal System.
While these issues are just appearing in the
papers, I have been attempting to bring light to
this massive hypersaline plume causing saltwater
intrusion into the Biscayne Bay aquifer since 2004
when I was asked to prove that my mine would not
cause saltwater intrusion as part of my permit
application. I not only found out that the mine
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
158
wouldn't cause saltwater intrusion, I found out
what was: The cooling canal system.
Over the last 12 years, I've worked with FPL,
DEP, the Water Management District, and Miami-Dade
County to address the significant loss of aquifer
and to protect my property and my business all the
while the plume has continued to march ever
landward. In the '80s, the plume was just outside
the cooling canal system. In the '90s and 2000s,
it had traveled three and a half miles west towards
my property. And all of this was prior to the
unit's upgrade approval in 2008.
This, as we know now, exacerbated the
situation by orders of magnitude as you are now
seeing. It is now four and a half miles west of
the cooling canal system and is likely the cause of
the request of water before you.
Today, eight years later, the saltwater/fresh
water interface has been documented at TPGW-7, less
than 1,250 feet from my ag property. Under my
permits for mining, if the salt/fresh water
interface reaches my mining property, I will be
forced to shut down all of my mining operations.
Every time I take samples from our monitoring
wells, I'm sick thinking of: My results are going
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
159
to come back demonstrating that the chloride has
finally hit my sentinel wells. If my limerock mine
becomes contaminated with salt concentrations, I
lose the saleability and integrity of my mine that
I have been there -- that our family has been there
for 90 years.
With the South Florida Water Management
District study of 2008, they concluded five years
later, and three years later than expected, FPL's
data shows that there's a 25 square mile tritium
and salt plume in the aquifer on the west side of
the cooling canal alone and moving rapidly. In two
closely related actions, I felt forced to bring --
in light of the State's failure to act, an
Administrative Law Judge definitively found exactly
what we've been saying for years.
While the Judge found that FPL probably does
need this water, he doesn't think that DEP has
adequately studied or understood the underlying
questions for the need of this water or the
downstream consequences or all of the other
non-permitted actions in this hearing that would
have a profound effect on your decision today. FPL
desperately wants for you to find -- to look only
at one small piece of the pie at any given time but
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
160
never the big picture, because the big picture is a
big problem.
The CCS is causing harm to the water and
resources of the State, to private property rights;
and even after this modification, it will steadily
convert drinking water for six to 12,000 people
each and every day into an undrinkable water. What
you don't see in this memo is that even with this
saltwater, FPL, DEP, and the Water Management
experts at the hearing unanimously said that the
salt front would move west for at least 25 more
years and consume at least one acre of aquifer a
day.
This was FPL's total solution for their
pollution. Coupled with the AO, it was a license
to continue polluting outside the CCS for 25 more
years. You see, Judge Cantor found it necessary to
inform you as the Siting Board whose job it is to
ensure the power plants in Florida are not causing
harm that nothing -- this modification stops the
harm.
For FPL to say it's better than doing nothing
cannot be an excuse when it has now been proven
that they are the cause, and the problem is worse
than anyone could have expected. In any other
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
161
permitting context, that excuse would be
inexcusable.
In isolation and based on this DEP memo, I
might have approved this request as well. But
based on the big picture, Judge Cantor's rulings in
the hearing of eight days, and testimony, and the
administrative order, I wouldn't grant this in a
million years.
To the Governor's point, what I'm asking is
that you, as the Siting Board who have the
authority to add conditions to FPL's siting
license, even if you're inclined to give them the
water, require FPL to fully remediate the pollution
plume that they have created in the aquifer and to
stop this plume from infringing upon my existing
legal use of water, my business and property
rights, and the drinking water for south Florida,
Biscayne Bay, and the Florida Keys.
Thank you very much.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Thank you.
Does anybody have any questions?
(NO RESPONSE).
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And, sir, you said
eight days of testimony, correct, in front of
Judge Cantor, the Administrative Law Judge? And
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
162
I --
MR. TERESI: Over two hearings.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And I assume you gave
this compelling testimony to him as well, and you
said in addition more testimony?
MR. TERESI: Yes.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And you do understand
though that we did not hear those eight days of
testimony and that it is our job to review this
document?
MR. TERESI: It is, but I believe what
Mr. Bowman said was very simple to our point: Even
if you provide them the water, it does not mean
that you cannot add conditions to prevent the harm
of the existing plume as part of this condition,
which is what the ask is here today: Stop the
plume. It's only 1,250 feet from my property, and
it's moving, you know, at whatever feet per year it
is. This alone will not stop the problem, but you
can add a modification to correct it.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Does anybody have
any questions?
(NO RESPONSE).
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Thank you.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
163
MR. TERESI: Thank you.
MR. CLARK: Our final speaker is Mr. Mike Sole
with Florida Power & Light.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Good afternoon.
MR. SOLE: Good afternoon, Governor,
Cabinet members, I'll try to be brief. I don't
intend to try to relitigate this issue, but I do
want to put some context to this issue.
This is but one effort that FPL is pursuing to
address the hypersaline plume at Turkey Point.
It's very clear by the record that the Judge found
that this improves the conditions, it meets all the
requirements for issuance and approval; and as part
of this, it will reduce the rate of saltwater
intrusion associated with the cooling canal
systems.
There are several other venues in which FPL
are working transparently with local government,
state government, and even federal governments to
identify measures to also eliminate our
contribution to saltwater intrusion; but because
those are not part of this record, I do not want to
go into detail at this time. But to be clear, FPL
is committed to eliminating its source contribution
to that saltwater intrusion.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
164
I'll be glad to answer any questions.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: CFO.
CFO ATWATER: Mr. Sole. Thank you.
I appreciate -- and like the Commissioner
said, I'm no attorney here, all right? So if I
wander into an area we can't talk about, if someone
can raise a hand.
But you've mentioned that you're working on
several other initiatives, but because they're not
an ingredient to the present order, your desire is
not to go too deep into that conversation, yet --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Can we stop you for a second?
CFO ATWATER: Yes.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Is the reason is that we
can't take -- can't consider those issues --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Correct.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: -- when we make our
determination today?
MR. VARN: That's exactly right.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Correct.
CFO ATWATER: Let me ask it this way then:
It's been said several times that we can input into
this additional conditions. Is that an inaccurate
statement?
MR. VARN: I would say that to the extent you
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
165
could -- yes, you can put conditions, that the
statute is very clear; however, I would suggest
that those -- any conditions would be limited to
the modification that is before you, which is the
use of 14 mgd.
What I understand the suggestions to be, and
they aren't very clear on what those modifications
would be, but would be more towards actual
operations that are existing whether or not you
authorize this modification. In other words, take
away the modification, what they're complaining
about primarily -- there are other things; I'm not
saying it's only -- is about the activities that
occur today.
The ALJ's finding was that they met the
criteria and it would improve water quality, so
this seems to be a benefit. What conditions you
would put on that benefit, I'm not sure; and I'll
be quite frank, I thought about this to try to
provide items for you to think about, and I just
simply don't know what you can condition the use of
the 14 mgd. If anything, it would be a negative.
And so I obviously would not recommend that.
And so I'm limited in what I can advise you
because I just -- my mind could not come up with
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
166
what conditions that you would look for.
CFO ATWATER: Well, don't go away yet.
MR. VARN: Okay.
CFO ATWATER: Again, I'm not the attorney
here, okay, but I think I just want to understand.
When I'm looking at a specific sentence in the
order that no party believes -- and I take it that
means no party -- that the proposal is going to
halt westward movement. You have someone who has
just presented, and I think in a -- probably as
respectful a manner as I can think of after the
time and 90 years of family activity on that
property, respectfully saying to us: This thing is
headed my way.
And so I would be curious, again, not subject
to -- I understand a possible condition to this,
but does anybody care that it's moving that
direction? And I'm asking --
MR. VARN: Absolutely. From the Department --
CFO ATWATER: Yeah.
MR. VARN: -- again, the Department, yes,
we've had internal discussions about that. There
are a number of other things that are going on,
which you are free to talk about; however, in
making your decision, those should never -- those
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
167
should neither favor nor rule against your
decisionmaking. So I want to bring you back into
the record that you have. I would never tell you
you cannot ask a question, but the law is very
specific.
CFO ATWATER: And I appreciate that.
MR. SOLE: So, CFO, can I --
CFO ATWATER: Yeah, please, but here's the
point, okay --
MR. SOLE: Yes, sir.
CFO ATWATER: -- is that we -- I understand
you're trying to keep me inside the box, okay?
MR. VARN: Right.
CFO ATWATER: But I think you deserve to
inform those of us sitting here in this capacity,
at least me, that my ignorance doesn't constrain me
to the box, okay? If I were an attorney, maybe I'd
feel constrained here today, but I'm not.
So it would at least be helpful, from the
perspective of the corporation, to say something
more than we've got a few other things in the
hopper but we just don't want to talk about them
today when somebody else is making just a -- I
think a reasoned point: Could there be conditions?
And then someone else says, well, no conditions
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
168
that could apply to the State's conversation.
So why don't you just help me a little bit
with that?
MR. SOLE: Thank you, CFO, I appreciate it,
and I appreciate the question.
So as it relates to this issue, first job,
Number 1, is eliminate the continued contribution
to the saltwater intrusion. The 14 million gallons
a day proposal that we have put forward, and
required a modification to the conditions of
certification, does that very thing. The Judge
agreed that it does that very thing. The Judge
also agrees that it slows the rate of saltwater
intrusion. So that's what's in front of us today.
Other actions that are more than just what's
in the hopper include a consent agreement with
Miami-Dade County that actually has FPL removing
the hypersaline plume and an obligation -- legal
obligation to bring that hypersaline plume back to
our property boundaries. Those are not in the
hopper, they're commitments; they're established;
they're legally binding with us and Miami-Dade; and
but for final resolution of other enforcement that
DEP has yet to finish, I expect additional binding
obligations with the Florida Department of
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
169
Environmental Protection.
Does that give you the meat on the bone that
you're looking for?
CFO ATWATER: That's very helpful. If
Mr. Varn could come back, or someone who might
speak for DEP could come back up, I would
appreciate that.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Will you just confirm
something, Mike or Craig?
MR. SOLE: I'm sorry?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Either one of you. Is
anybody involved saying that if we had a choice,
just put no more water in this, are we better off
or worse off?
MR. SOLE: Much worse off.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Does anybody disagree? Does
anybody in the room disagree?
(NEGATIVE INDICATIONS).
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. All right. I just
want to make sure.
MR. SOLE: Yes, sir.
CFO ATWATER: Mr. Varn, would you acknowledge
that those activities are underway and that you all
are --
MR. VARN: I will, but I would ask that you
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
170
assume that they are not going to take place for
purposes of your decisionmaking here today
because --
CFO ATWATER: I'm fine with that, I'm fine
with that.
MR. VARN: Okay.
CFO ATWATER: I'm just --
MR. VARN: Then, yes, the things --
CFO ATWATER: -- asking. You said I could ask
any question. I've asked a question.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Can I just offer -- can I ask
a question real quick?
MR. VARN: Yes.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So is this appealable, what
we're doing right now?
MR. VARN: Everything is appealable, as you
know.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: To -- how would this be
appealed?
MR. VARN: I would say that consideration of
more information would not constitute reversible
error as long as you are very clear in your
decisionmaking that it's limited to the record that
was presented before you. So I would, again,
err -- you're better off erring on the side of
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
171
caution and not getting into this while you are
debating these issues.
If I had to give you advice, I would suggest
that you end the discussion on this topic. If you
want to ask additional questions after you've made
a decision, then obviously it could not go into,
but I would not -- I'd be very -- you know, I can't
answer your question as to the appeal because I'm
not an appellate attorney and I never will be, but
I will say that the less you go outside of the
record, the much better you will be.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Are you okay right
now?
CFO ATWATER: Yeah.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Attorney General, you
want to --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And, CFO, I think as
a compassionate human being, I would hope there is
not a person in the State of Florida that does not
feel for the property owner right now, and we
listen -- I see FPL nodding in agreement.
And, sir, we listened to your -- I mean we
listened to your very moving testimony; however,
legally -- now the lawyer in me is stepping in --
legally I think everyone in this -- all the lawyers
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
172
in this room agree that we are bound by this
document.
And we're headed into dangerous territory if
we start -- and because you are the property owner
and we do care, we let you continue further, but we
are bound by what is in this order unless we find
complete lack of substantial -- I'm sorry,
competent and substantial evidence.
And from what we're hearing, that's what --
these hearings -- this is such an interesting
dynamic what we do here, but it's not our job to
relitigate this. And, you know, days and days of
testimony on both sides were heard.
And I think what you're saying, CFO, is we're
all hoping that there are -- and we're hearing that
there are additional options to help this property
owner out there, but we have to follow
Judge Cantor's ruling without -- unless we find
lack of competent and substantial evidence.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. So do -- are there any
other speakers?
MR. CLARK: No, sir.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. All right. There --
does anybody have any other questions for any of
the speakers?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
173
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: No.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: I do.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay, Commissioner.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: For DEP.
The 14 mgd --
MR. VARN: Yes, sir.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: -- that was approved by
Water Management?
MR. VARN: The four -- well, technically it's
a -- they are the entity that handles it. Again,
it's the Siting Board that approved it, but they
are the ones that had the primary input in that
decision-making process.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Yeah, the science behind
whether the aquifer can withstand 14 mgd --
MR. VARN: Correct.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: -- withdrawal, the
Water Management determined that it could handle
it?
MR. VARN: Right. And one clarification here,
the 14 mgd is coming from the upper Floridan. A
lot of the impacts that we're talking about are
occurring in the Biscayne. There's a separation
between the two, so the --
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
174
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: I get that.
MR. VARN: Okay. I'll shut up.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: And it is for up to
14 mgd, correct?
MR. VARN: Correct.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: So in a rainy season,
you can't -- you don't multiply 14 times 365. This
is like a citrus grower who needs maximum
protection for one freeze night a year, right?
MR. VARN: Yes, sir.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: It would be up to
14 mgd. It's not 6,000 houses every day of the
year; is that correct or incorrect?
MR. VARN: That is correct.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: And am I allowed to ask
that question or not?
MR. VARN: That is in the record. I will
point out, however, the permit does allow that full
allocation without differentiation. Now there is a
requirement --
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: That's correct.
MR. VARN: Okay.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: But it is -- the purpose
of the withdrawal is to lower the salinity of the
cooling canal system, correct?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
175
MR. VARN: Right.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Okay. So if you had
summer rains presumably, you would need less
withdrawals from the aquifer to reduce the
salinity, right?
MR. VARN: Correct.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: And the cooling canal
system was designed as required by law, right, by
the NRC, by the State? I mean the attorney for ACI
said it was by design.
MR. VARN: I'm not sure -- yes, it was
designed to some standard. I know it did have to
do with a historical issue with respect to the ERC.
I don't know all the specifics on that.
MR. SOLE: Just for clarification, it actually
was an obligation required on us by the Department
of Justice through a consent decree to eliminate
what was at that time once-through cooling. So
this is -- basically was imposed on us by the
Federal Government if we wanted to continue to
operate.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: But clearly it needs --
the 1970's design needs work. Am I allowed to say
that?
MR. VARN: I think the addition of the 14 mgd
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
176
suggests that, yes, there is a need for additional
water.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Yeah, there's a -- we've
got a problem.
Okay. So are we allowed to discuss the
consent agreement that was made with the other
intervening party, Miami-Dade?
MR. VARN: Again, discussions, I'm not going
to tell you what you can and cannot ask. I will
tell you that in consideration of the final
determination, it should be limited to the record.
I do not believe the specifics of that
consent order were part of it; however, I will
defer to the actual attorneys that were part of it.
I don't recall seeing that as part of the --
and I don't recall reading about it as part of the
record. So I would suggest, no; however, I feel a
little reluctant to tell my bosses not to do
things, so I'm going to leave that to you. I just
would recommend against doing so.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Okay.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Attorney General, did you
want to add anything?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: No, and I think
Mr. Bowman agreed with that as well. I saw him
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
177
nodding, and he's a very ethical attorney. I just
didn't want him not to be heard or the other side.
Did you want to add something, Mr. Bowman?
MR. BOWMAN: Yes, just, just --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Is that okay,
Governor?
MR. BOWMAN: Two items briefly: One was, that
is correct, the cooling canal system was built as a
result of a consent decree with the Department of
Justice in I believe 1971. It predates virtually
every environmental regulation in the State of
Florida. So when I said "by design," I meant by
the physical construction design of the system, not
by design to comply with a particular regulation.
On the other issue, you are correct, the
consent decree with Miami-Dade County was not part
of the record. The Judge made it very clear that
he was not considering other alternatives, that
that was your job to consider those items.
To Mr. Putnam's point, the need of the water
issue was something that we did raise -- we did
argue that we raised. The Judge didn't feel that
we raised it enough, but that was a point, was that
the water is essentially 14 million gallons a day,
every day, 365; whether it's, you know, a hurricane
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
178
or a drought, there's nothing that controls it.
Conditions, you know, you could condition this
water as being a one-year allocation and force them
to come back with a plan to have the saltwater
intrusion halted. You could -- you can put all
kinds of conditions on your modification.
It doesn't have to be a physical solution now,
but you can -- you know, this is your opportunity,
when you're adding something to the license, to
bring them back to you with a final solution, not
through an Administrative Order with the Department
but through the Board that's supposed to be
regulating this facility.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Just to clarify for
the record, I think you've argued that, Mr. Bowman;
but I don't think the ALJ asked us to make
modifications in any way.
MR. BOWMAN: I actually quoted the Judge's
order to you --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I've read it.
MR. BOWMAN: -- that we had the right to come
before you --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Well, you had the
right to come before us.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
179
MR. BOWMAN: -- and ask, and he had --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And ask.
MR. BOWMAN: Correct.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Okay.
MR. BOWMAN: And he stated in that final
paragraph that I read to you that he recommended
the approval and recommended that you be advised
that the problem was occurring.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Advised, thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Thank you.
MR. CLARK: That concludes all of our
speakers.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Does anybody have any
other questions?
(NO RESPONSE).
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Is there a motion
on the item?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I'm not sure how to
word it.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. So let's make sure we
know our options.
MR. CLARK: The Department is recommending
approval of the Final Order as presented.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. So it would be, we
would -- the recommendation would be: We adopt the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
180
Judge's recommendation that the request be approved
with the limited modifications and grants one of
the ACI's exceptions and DEP's modification for a
terminology clarification.
Is that accurate?
MR. VARN: No, sir, we do not grant any of
ACI's exceptions.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. So that's not --
MR. VARN: And there was a modification on the
standing issue and the DEP terminology issue. And
if you go with the recommendation on the standing
issue, you would need to make a determination that
it is a more reasonable interpretation than that of
the Administrative Law Judge.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Why don't you restate
your recommendation then and just make sure I have
it right?
MR. VARN: The Department would recommend the
adoption of the Recommended Order, with the
modifications being the adoption of the exception
by the Department, the rejection of the exceptions
filed by ACI, the modification of the standing
issue as prepared in the document, with a finding
that the change in the standing is a more
reasonable interpretation than that of the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
181
Administrative Law Judge.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: I have one last
question: On your amendment to the
Recommended Order, specifically Number 64, why did
you strike the last sentence?
MR. VARN: Well, the -- I didn't think that
went to the fundamental issue of standing. Again,
we find standing. I felt that that was more of a
dicta. Once you get in -- once you address
standing, and I believe standing is limited to --
Standing cannot exceed the issue that is
before you. In other words, you can't go beyond --
what our issue here is the modification and the
ancillary issues related thereto. So the language
that he had in there, and I don't recall it off the
top of my head, but it was --
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: ACI's injury is no less
immediate than the injury that would be suffered by
anyone downstream of a pollution source when the
timing of the impact and the concentration of the
pollution at the time of impact can be calculated
by accepted scientific methods.
MR. VARN: Right. I don't think it adds to
nor takes away from. I don't feel strongly one way
or the other on that language, so if it makes no
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
182
difference -- I just don't think it added to the
conclusion from our standpoint; and therefore, it
was redundant information. I think the -- that ACI
proved it has standing. It's an existing -- it has
an existing legal use, and they made allegations
that suggested -- the ALJ did not agree, but
suggested that they would be impacted by the
modification.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So, Craig, your
recommendation is we just approve the Final Order?
MR. VARN: Yes, sir.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: That would be the simplest
way of saying it?
MR. VARN: With a finding that the
interpretation is more reasonable than that of the
ALJ. There's a terminology -- there's language in
120 that requires you to make that finding if
you're going to make a change on the conclusions of
law. So, yes, I recommend though you adopt the
Draft Final Order as prepared.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. All right. Is there a
motion on the item?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: The proper motion would
be that we adopt --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: We adopt the --
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
183
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: -- the Final Order as
prepared?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: With the
modification.
MR. VARN: With the modification -- well, with
the finding that the modified conclusion is more
reasonable than that of the Administrative Law
Judge's.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: It's just it --
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: I'm leaving that to you.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I think, I think --
let me try to simplify it, because that's a
question of law and not a question of fact; is that
correct?
MR. VARN: Yes, ma'am.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I'm not asking a
leading question. I'm --
MR. VARN: It's absolutely correct.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Is that why?
MR. VARN: Yes, absolutely.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Okay. Mr. Bowman,
attorneys, do you agree that that's a question of
law and not a question of fact?
MR. BOWMAN: I agree that it's a question of
law.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
184
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Okay.
MR. BOWMAN: I don't agree that it's a
question of law over which this Board has
substantive jurisdiction. The standing of my
client and the test for evaluating it is a general
principal of administrative law. It is not a
technical issue of power plant siting or
environmental protection, which is the only aspect
where you can overturn an Administrative Law
Judge's conclusion. Just saying that that sentence
didn't add anything isn't enough to overturn a
conclusion of law.
MR. VARN: Okay. But that's not actually what
I said. But I will say that I disagree with that
in that infused in this determination of standing
is more scientific determinations. 403.412 --
under Chapter 403 and 373, the standing of those,
the Department has consistently held that in making
those determinations of standing, it does take a
certain level of expertise.
So I think that while in general standing may
be a fairly administrative proceeding in terms of
environmental issues, such as this one, there are
infused in those decision makings certain skills
that the general lay person does not have. So I
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
185
would disagree -- generally I agree with his
provision; however, in this situation I would say
that it is infused with those specialities that we
do have, or the Board has sitting as the
Siting Board.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: So, Governor, would it
be appropriate to say that I move that we adopt the
ALJ's Recommended Order, including the conditions
stipulated by the parties, and with the two
amendments recommended by DEP?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Yes.
MR. VARN: Yes, sir.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Is that --
MR. VARN: And a finding that the Board's
conclusion regarding standing is more reasonable
than that of the Administrative Law Judge.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Are you okay with that?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Yes.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: The Board's
conclusion regarding standing is more reasonable
than that of the ALJ.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Right. So you're okay with
that? It's your motion.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Yes.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
186
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Is there a second?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Second.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Any comments or objections?
(NO RESPONSE).
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Hearing none, the motion
carries.
MR. CLARK: That concludes the Siting Board
agenda.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Thank you.
MR. BOWMAN: Thank you all very much. I
appreciate your --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Mr. Bowman, thank you
for --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Thanks a lot. You did a good
job.
* * * *
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
187
CLEMENCY BOARD CLARIFICATION OF
COMMUTATION OF CARLOS DELGADO
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Now I'd like to
recognize Julie McCall with the Commission on
Offender Review.
MS. MCCALL: Yes. We're here at the Board's
request to address the specifics of a commutation
of sentence for Inmate Carlos Manuel Delgado, which
was heard at our Clemency meeting on March the 3rd,
2016.
The Commission on Offender Review is here
today, and Inmate Delgado is also represented by
his family and his attorneys.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Say it one more time,
Chairman.
MS. MCCALL: Which part?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Just the last, just say your
last sentence.
MS. MCCALL: Okay. The Commission on
Offender Review is here, in case you have
questions; and also the family of Inmate Delgado is
here if you had questions.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. That's fine.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
188
MS. MCCALL: And his attorney.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: That's great. Is Jack here?
MS. MCCALL: Yes.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. All right. Jack, do
you want to just go explain why we're having to do
this so everybody understands it?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Governor, I think
this is what I had originally suggested, just to be
safe.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Right. Yeah.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: But I think everyone,
as the Clemency Board --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: I just want to make sure we
all have a conversation why we're doing this.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: If I can speak for
all of us, I think we all were trying to help the
defendant as much as we could, but this may be,
after talking to Ms. Snurkowski, the best way to
go.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So what we did -- so, Jack,
why don't you tell us why we're doing -- why we're
having to come back and talk about this.
MR. HEEKIN: In granting the conditional
commutation, one of the conditions that was agreed
upon was that the defendant would not have to
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
189
register as a sex offender.
In order to remove the registration
requirement by FDLE, there are a number of paths
that can be taken, but the only one available to us
is to grant an immediate full pardon. Now if we a
grant a full pardon, we're granting unconditional
release from guilt and from punishment. So we
could not place conditions of supervision on the
defendant in this case.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Right.
MR. HEEKIN: So what we need to clarify is
whether or not we want to grant an immediate
full pardon, or whether we wish to grant a
conditional commutation with conditions of
supervision that he must fulfill, and then we can
consider a full pardon at a future date.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So there are three options.
All right. Do you want to go through the options,
or do you want me to go through them?
MR. HEEKIN: I'd be happy to go through them.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Why don't you go
through the three options really quick?
MR. HEEKIN: The options as I see are: We
grant immediately a conditional commutation alone.
We've already established the special conditions of
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
190
supervision at the Clemency meeting, and those
would still apply. What that would require is he
would still have to register and go through the
reporting requirements as a sex offender while he's
supervised; however, we would not be placing
conditions of sex offender probation on the
defendant. That was not part of the special
conditions of supervision.
So he would go under six months of immediate
house arrest; 36 months of probation, which would
run concurrent with the house arrests; and then the
remaining special conditions. That would be the
first option.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: With no monitoring?
Excuse me, Governor. With no monitoring?
MR. HEEKIN: The sex offender probation
requirements, the ankle monitoring, and I believe
the residency requirements would not have to apply.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay.
MR. HEEKIN: The second option would be
granting a conditional commutation and a
conditional pardon at this time. Those special
conditions would apply.
Now this would have the effect that upon
successful completion of those conditions at the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
191
end of his term of supervision, a pardon could be
granted and would be granted because he
successfully completed those --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: But he can't be -- it can't
happen without the Clemency Board making a decision
at the end?
MR. HEEKIN: Correct, the Clemency Board would
need to execute an executive order granting the
full pardon at the end.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Which means that would be
after we're out of office, in these positions at
least; and then another Clemency Board would still
have to make that determination. So we're taking
the risk that another Clemency Board wants to take
a different action or takes no action, right?
MR. HEEKIN: Correct, that's correct.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Or we could do it at
our last Clemency meeting ourselves.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Yeah, that was --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: That was my
suggestion early on, that we do it.
MR. HEEKIN: And if we want to do that, then
under the first option, granting the conditional
commutation alone, we could set this for the
December 2018 Clemency agenda. That would be the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
192
last meeting of this administration.
At that time you can then consider whether you
wish to grant a full pardon. If the defendant has
been successful in the terms of supervision, if
he's presented a compelling case that a full pardon
should be granted, we can consider it and grant it
at that time.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So the bottom line is we
can -- if we want to say he has -- we can give him
a full pardon, and then -- I think the Commissioner
was the one that was adamant that he not have to
register as a sex offender. We can't do that and
have any supervision, so that's their choice.
Right, Commissioner?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Given the choice between
supervision of someone whose crime was, you know,
having a child with -- someone who misled him about
his age and having him miss the next three years
with his daughter because he will be a
sex offender, I would support an immediate pardon
so that he can move on with his life without the
stigma of sex offender and count on his family to
keep him out of trouble with the different
conditions that we believed that community
control would provide, or -- no, no, no, that's
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
193
my -- that would be my preference; that we all
trust him enough to let him out of jail a month
ago, he's still in jail, which is disturbing enough
as it is.
But we all trusted him enough to let him out
of jail, let's trust him the extra little bit and
put the burden on his family, as it should be, so
that he can reacquaint himself with his daughter.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Let's go back. So he went to
jail ultimately because of a drug problem.
MR. HEEKIN: That's correct, Governor. He
violated probation by committing a new felony:
Possession of cocaine. Now he had adjudication
withheld on the possession of cocaine, but that was
ultimately the violation of probation on which he
was sentenced to a term of incarceration.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: And how long has he served
again?
MR. HEEKIN: A little over 11 years at this
point.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: And if he had gone into jail
simply for the drug issue, how long would he have
gone in for?
MR. HEEKIN: It would have been a maximum of
five years. It was a third degree felony.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
194
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. All right. Okay.
Attorney General, do you have --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I do, I do. And,
Commissioner Putnam, we are letting him out
14 years early, and that's why I believe in reentry
programs. I see your point, but I believe in
reentry programs because we don't want to set
someone up to fail.
I think this administration needs to handle
this. I do firmly believe he needs some
conditions. He's been in prison for 11 years.
We're letting him out 14 years early. It's more
than -- I mean, yes, she lied about her age, but
she still said she was underage, and at that time
it was a crime. It's not now, but at the time it
was; and he did cocaine.
And he has been in prison for 11 years. I
don't want to see him fail, none of us did. I
think that's why we wanted to put some conditions
on him. We all want to see him succeed. But I do
think he needs some -- you know, he originally got
probation.
And I know this was 11, 12 years ago, he was
younger then. He originally got probation,
probation for something he could have been locked
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
195
up almost forever on, and he did cocaine. And I
know he was much younger, but I don't want to see
him fail again, and I do think he needs some
conditions on him, placed on him.
Ultimately -- he's still going to get out,
he's still going to be able to reacquaint himself
with his daughter, but just that stigma of a
sex offender won't be removed. And I mean I would
be happy if we want to modify it to two years.
I hate even pushing it to our very last
Clemency meeting actually, if we could even do it
one before that. Just to be sure so this Board can
be certain that he is pardoned, I would have no
problem even moving it up sooner.
But when someone -- you know, this is what
I've done my entire career. When someone has been
in prison for that long -- and he does have family
support, but I do think he needs some conditions on
him. We're giving him --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Can I ask a question?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: -- a tremendous break
that he deserves.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So the Commissioner said that
he would be limited in his ability to be with his
daughter, okay? What are --
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
196
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: School activities and
things like that.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Yeah. What are the
limitations; do we know?
MR. HEEKIN: And I'll defer to Sara Rumph on
this point. I know that she's looked into this
recently.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Thank you.
MS. RUMPH: Good afternoon. So the
limitations that would be restrictive would be
anything that is municipally imposed which may have
a residence restriction.
But as far as participating in school events
and participating in like going to a park or,
you know, anything along those lines, there would
not be any restrictions. Now that's not to say
that the school would not refuse to have him
involved in like a field trip. They could refuse
permission for him to be a chaperone, but that's
different -- based solely on his conviction, not
necessarily based on his sex offender registration.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: But isn't his family
home a problem because of its distance to a school
or something like that?
MS. RUMPH: I don't know what the municipal
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
197
code is, but not under State statute, it would only
be under municipal statute.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Chairman Pate, based on
your experience with a case like this, what length
of time of supervision or community control would
you think is appropriate?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: A nice easy question.
COMMISSIONER PATE: Really.
Based on his criminal history, I think that
clearly the six months; and I think if you look at
12 months to 15 months, I think you could satisfy
what you're trying to accomplish. I also
understand the desire to have him on a longer
period.
Again, as I mentioned at the last clemency
meeting, we know supervision works, but it can also
be a detriment if it's too long or too restrictive
for someone that does not pose a great risk. It
depends on how you evaluate the case.
Do you think he's at a risk of reoffending in
this type of behavior or another violent offense,
or do you think that his greatest risk is maybe
using drugs again? So then that's the treatment
that you've ordered. So you have to take --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: I think that the risk is
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
198
drugs, right?
COMMISSIONER PATE: -- those things into
consideration.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All of us think the biggest
risk is drugs, right?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And you've got
someone who, in essence, has grown up in Florida
State Prison and, you know, before cell phones,
before technology, before computers. And now he's
getting out in the world, and that's why we have
reentry programs.
So we're kind of -- we're creating our own
reentry program. And I agree, like I said, I don't
think we actually even need to wait until the very
last Clemency meeting. I don't want to even cut it
that close because I want to be sure we fully
pardon him.
Now when you do -- we could do six months
house arrest followed by 12 months probation --
COMMISSIONER PATE: If I gave you my very best
advice -- and I have to serve every member of the
Board, and this is based on years and years and
years of working in the criminal justice system.
And I know you've had exposure working with the
Clemency cases and you, as a prosecutor. With this
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
199
particular case, I honestly believe if you go
outside of 12 months -- six months community
control and then if you wanted to have six months
of probation or this supervision to follow, you
could satisfy what it is you're trying to
accomplish.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I'm great with that.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: So next March -- so he
would be released as immediately as possible --
COMMISSIONER PATE: As possible.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: -- and eligible for a
pardon at the March 2017 meeting?
COMMISSIONER PATE: Whenever y'all want him to
come back before you, you could consider that.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Let's be sure we're saying
the same thing. He's got six months of house
arrest, six months of probation. Let's say that we
decide not -- we don't take any action a year from
now, what happens? He just doesn't get -- he
doesn't get a full pardon?
COMMISSIONER PATE: Correct.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: He just -- he's out?
COMMISSIONER PATE: Correct.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. That's the only thing
that happens then. So we have a chance to look at
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
200
the full pardon at that point?
COMMISSIONER PATE: Correct.
CFO ATWATER: Governor, may I ask a question?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Sure.
CFO ATWATER: And I do appreciate everyone's
perspective, particularly those who have been far
closer to this as professionals.
So I would be curious though, I think we all
have -- our goal here is in the right spot. What
does house arrest achieve that just 12 months
straight probation would not achieve?
COMMISSIONER PATE: Primarily he'll be
confined to the residence except for employment.
He'll have to come straight home after work. Any
time he leaves, he'll have to have special
permission to do that. You're not going to find
him in the local grocery store, others will have to
take care of that for him. He's going to be under
close supervision.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Actually,
Commissioner, I disagree. You can go to the
grocery store, you can go to church, you can go
to -- I'm positive. On community control, you can
go to church, you can go to the grocery store, you
can -- we can set those conditions as part of his
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
201
house arrest --
COMMISSIONER PATE: Yes, you can.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: -- absolutely.
COMMISSIONER PATE: Yes, you can do that.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: You just -- he's just
not going to get out as an adult and be able to go
out and stay out in a bar all night long.
COMMISSIONER PATE: Right.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And
Commissioner Putnam originally had asked --
suggested a halfway house. We're doing our version
of a halfway house, which is much easier than a
halfway house. And, yes, you can go to the grocery
store; you can go to church; you can go to school;
you can go to work; you can --
COMMISSIONER PATE: Absolutely.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: -- go to your
parents' house.
COMMISSIONER PATE: The language we use at the
Commission is: You're confined to your residence
except for religious, education, medical purposes,
I mean we give them those exceptions. So they can
participate in society, but then other than that,
they're supposed to be at home.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: CFO, are you okay?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
202
CFO ATWATER: Yeah, I think that
Commissioner Putnam and I -- again, I know we're
all trying to do the right thing here. He makes --
you know, his earliest point I thought was very
compelling to me, so I'm just -- I could have been
swayed; but again, I appreciate all the history and
the value of the reentry because our concern last
month was, boy, don't let this person slip and fall
right out of the gate with temptations, you know,
whatever it may be.
So I guess I would have been thinking, if we
did one year probation, a year from March, a year
from right now, the opportunity would be in front
of us had all gone well. But if people feel
strongly that house arrest adds an additional
element, I get that. But I would like to believe
that this individual could be believed to integrate
back as quickly as possible and begin to be exposed
to things under a probationary arrangement that
they understood they couldn't slip.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Can I suggest
something, Governor? Why don't we do this -- and I
may need you to help me structure this.
But we could do -- we do this all the time --
used to do this all the time -- six months CC,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
203
followed by six months probation. If he's had no
violations of community control in three months,
you can roll that to probation; and then he'll go
nine months of probation. How is that?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So it's a total year. It
starts at six months, six months, but it could
go -- the six months could go to three, but you
still have a total year?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Total year. I feel
very strongly -- I don't want him to fail. I feel
very strongly about a reentry program, and if we
do -- I think that's a good compromise, if you
gentlemen agree with that.
But can I ask the Commissioner just one other
thing? Technically is it better to do a year
probation with six months of community control, or
six months CC followed by six months probation?
I'm just asking a structuring --
COMMISSIONER PATE: I would do the tougher
part up front, the six months community control
first and then probation to follow.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: You would do a year
probation to include six months of CC on the end,
or do you do six months followed by six months?
It's been a while since I've been in the courtroom.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
204
COMMISSIONER PATE: I've seen it both ways. I
think you're accomplishing the same thing.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Okay. Well, then may
I make a motion with our some conditions?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Yeah.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: We do six months of
house arrest followed by -- I mean followed by
six months of probation. If he has no violations
three months on house arrest, he can automatically
roll over to nine months probation. And then we
will see him again a year from now, our closest
Clemency meeting, give or take a few weeks --
COMMISSIONER PATE: Uh-huh, sure.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: -- a year from now,
and hopefully we will all pardon him.
I would ask that we add to his house arrest
that he be allowed to go to the grocery store,
Commissioner, you know --
COMMISSIONER PATE: Religious, medical --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Yes, medical,
grocery store.
COMMISSIONER PATE: -- education.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: That's how we always
structured it.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: If he's on house arrest,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
205
can he go to school activities?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Absolutely.
COMMISSIONER PATE: Yes, we add that in there,
and that's what she's suggesting, is that we put
the education clause; or if you want to say if he's
approved by the school -- I'm assuming you're
trying to get to the activities with the daughter.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Right, we can.
COMMISSIONER PATE: Okay. So you can say
that -- actually I think you're doing it by your
language. It's just going to be up to the school
authorities whether or not they allow him. I don't
--
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: What if you did the
six months of all of the things you just said,
bring him up in the September meeting, this year?
Six months, if he's a good boy for six months --
we've already let him out of prison. We already
believe in him to let him out of prison 14 years
early by one view or --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Eleven years late --
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: -- eleven years late in
somebody else's view, but you're letting him out of
prison, put him on all -- whatever restrictions you
want to put him on from -- you know, we're now
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
206
basically April through September; bring him up in
the September meeting, and evaluate where he is.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I -- Governor, may I?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Uh-huh.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I firmly believe he
needs a full year. The house arrested -- you're
transitioning him slowly, otherwise you would
almost be doing -- you're going then from
house arrest to just scott free, just free for all.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: House arrest --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I'd rather him be on
probation.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: -- as you've described,
it is pretty loose. I mean as you've described
house arrest, you can go to the grocery store, you
can go to church, you can go to school, you can go
to work. I'm not sure what part of house is in
that -- what part of arrest is in that house?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Stay out late.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: You can't stay out
late, Commissioner, and then after three months --
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: So if you did that for
six months, then --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I'd rather do that
for three months, if he can complete it; and then
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
207
put him on probation, just where he has some
structure, some reporting, we have some hook over
him in case he tests positive, in case something
happens, not to send him back to prison. Our goal
is to help him. And, again, this is what I've seen
so often. I don't want to set him up to fail,
that's why --
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: I understand.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: -- it's a gentle
decline.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: So can the family --
I was -- maybe I was misinformed. I was under the
impression that the housing situation was
complicated if he retains his sex offender status.
COMMISSIONER PATE: If he was on sex offender
probation, but he won't be because you're imposing
the conditions, not the Court.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Okay. So we've solved
that problem --
COMMISSIONER PATE: Yes, sir.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: -- by the
Attorney General's efforts.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. So the motion is --
and I'll make the motion: The motion is -- it's
basically six months house arrest, six months
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
208
probation; but if he doesn't have any violation in
three months, it's just three months of house and
nine months of probation, he'll come back the
closest to next March on the Clemency Board with
right now our belief is we would give him a
full pardon.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And with the terms we
previously imposed --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Right. Yeah.
COMMISSIONER PATE: Correct.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: -- except on
house arrest with the additional conditions, I
didn't -- you know how to fix it -- or the
additional conditions, we're going to give him even
more free reign, more freedom on house arrest to go
shopping, and we're slowly integrating him back --
fastly integrating him back.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. So that's my motion.
What's everybody else want to do?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I second it.
CFO ATWATER: Agreed.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: So is all this good? We
can do all this? Because the last time we did all
this, and then a month later we were told we can't
do it.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
209
COMMISSIONER PATE: I believe the conflict
was -- it was clear what you wanted to do, you did
not want him to have to register; but the statute
said that it had to be a full pardon and he
couldn't have been on supervision.
Jack, you want to address this?
MR. HEEKIN: That's correct.
COMMISSIONER PATE: Okay.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Are we on good ground
right now with his motion?
MR. HEEKIN: Yes.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: We're done.
MR. HEEKIN: We clarify that he will have to
register and report as a sex offender. He will not
be subject to the sex offender probation
requirements, which are more onerous, but he will
nonetheless have to register and report as a
sex offender every time -- I think it's annual
reporting, but it shouldn't be a problem that we're
doing it over a year now.
COMMISSIONER PATE: He might have to do it
twice.
MR. HEEKIN: Maybe twice a year? Okay, so
twice annually, and when he changes address, he
would have to notify the local authorities.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
210
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Okay. So when will
he -- if we adopt the Governor's motion, when will
he walk out?
MR. HEEKIN: As soon as we draft and sign the
Executive Order granting his
Conditional Commutation.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Well, we're going to be
here a while, so if you want to pass it down today,
I'll sign it today.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And, Commissioner,
he'll still have to go through the processing
center and be released. What's your guess,
24 hours on that, 48 hours to be reasonable?
COMMISSIONER PATE: He should be out Thursday
afternoon.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Allison can work on
that. Yeah, they can get him out. Realistically,
he's not going to walk out the door tonight. I
mean he has to be processed. Real --
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: I get it, but I mean we
did this a month --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Realistically by the
end of the week.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: -- we did this a month
ago and --
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
211
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Right.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: -- here we are, so I
want to -- if there's any question about what we're
doing, let's talk about it now.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I think what -- well,
this is what I wanted originally, so --
MR. HEEKIN: We'll have that drafted and
circulated to your offices as soon as possible.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Are we done?
MR. HEEKIN: Yes.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Thank you.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: We haven't voted I don't
think.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So we -- the motion is done
and everybody agreed, right?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Okay. Yes.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Everybody is agreed.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: We all did, except
Commissioner Putnam. I don't think he voted. Did
you vote?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: I agree.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Yeah, you agreed, right?
Okay. We're done. And, finally, when do you
think he'll get out?
MR. HEEKIN: We expect it will be probably
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
212
24 to 48 hours. We have to process it, we're
circulating --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Congratulations, everybody.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Thanks everybody for your
hard work on this.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: It just -- one more
minute.
Commissioner Putnam, Governor, has suggested
they do the order really fast. Frankly, I would
rather Commissioner Pate and the Commission put
more detail in it. I'd rather sign the
order tomorrow morning --
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: They're smart, they work
fast. We're all --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: -- tomorrow morning
to make sure we're on solid legal ground.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: We will scatter. We've
got to sign this.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: We'll still sign it.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: They are smart, capable.
I'll give you my office. We can do this before we
finish all the work we've got done.
COMMISSIONER PATE: We'll get it done.
Thank you.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
213
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Commissioner, your goal is to
get it done today? That's what you're hoping --
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: I see no reason why they
can't take your eloquent motion and put it on paper
and have it available for our signature by close of
business today.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Yeah, good luck.
UNIDENTIFIED SPEAKER: I want to thank
everyone. Thank you very much. Our family will be
eternally indebted.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: May I say something?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Yeah.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: He's blessed to have
all of you in his life.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Yeah, good luck.
* * * *
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
214
INTERVIEW AND APPOINTMENT FOR
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Everybody is
ready?
Next we have the interviews and appointment
for the Executive Director of the Department of
Revenue.
As you know, the position was opened and
advertised from January 25th through March 11th.
During that time, we received 110 applications, and
posted those applications online. Last week each
of our Cabinet Aides scheduled their selected
candidates to come to today's meeting for a public
interview. Today we have four candidates to
interview: Number 94, Robert McKee; Number 102,
James Evers; Number 103, James Overton; and
Number 105, Leon Biegalski.
I want to thank everybody who applied, and I
want to thank the four candidates for being here
today.
* * * *
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
215
ROBERT MCKEE
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So now first I would like to
recognize Robert McKee.
Thanks for being here. Do you want to say
something before we ask questions? You don't have
to. We all have questions I'm sure.
MR. MCKEE: I appreciate that. I wanted to
thank you, Governor Scott, Attorney General Bondi,
CFO Atwater, and Commissioner Putnam for having me
here today. As a Floridian from the age of two,
there is no greater honor than being able to stand
before you today for your consideration, and I
thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Great.
All right. Let me just start. So when I look
at your background, give me the -- tell me how you
manage; and, you know, in your different roles
you've had, the most number of people you've
managed, okay?
MR. MCKEE: The most people I've managed,
taking the latter question first, when I returned
to the Department in 2007, I headed up the Office
of Tax Research and the Office of Resource
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
216
Management, I also had the Budget Office under me.
I believe at that point in time I had over 20
direct reports, and so I had about 20 direct
reports in that role. That was the largest number
of folks that I managed.
My management style I think is somewhat -- I'm
a very active person, and so to some degree it is
in my wake that I pull people along as I move
forward. I'm very active. I try to get in front
of issues, I do not -- I try to work very hard to
not let issues grow.
I have a legislative background, meaning that
you have to respond very quickly, a quick
timeframe. I have to push my own department in my
current role to give me an idea of what is current
law, what the change in law will do, how the
Department will administer it; and then figure out
some way to measure it, usually within three or
four days' period of time. And then I have to
present the result, manage my staff to produce the
results, and then present them in a legislative
setting within that timeframe.
So generally, I tend to pull people along in
my current role. I understand in a position like
this you also have to create a vision and you have
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
217
to lead people in the job I'm applying for.
And so with that, I understand you have to lay
out a path; you have to every day make sure that
you're progressing down that path to get them where
we are today to where we want to be tomorrow, and
you have to work towards that goal. You also have
to push the people who need to be pushed, because
some folks get settled, they're comfortable within
their roles and they're not happy being challenged.
And so there are folks you need to bring along and
you need to foster their ability to understand that
change is inevitable; that where we don't change,
we don't grow, and we don't progress.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So, Robert, in your time at
DOR, have you had a lot of interaction with the
taxpayers and businesses, or has it been mostly
dealing with, you know, other issues?
MR. MCKEE: In both my role when I was the
Deputy Executive Director under Lisa Vickers, and
as the Chief Economist, I've had different
interactions with taxpayers. When I was the
Deputy, I did meet with taxpayers on certain
issues; we would have issues with the taxpayers.
The representatives would -- we would deal with
those issues that had risen to the executive staff
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
218
level.
In my current role as the Chief Economist,
when legislation is brought forward, I have a very
firm rule that more information makes for better
estimates and better outcomes. And so I work very
hard to work with members of the business community
to make sure I'm understanding the things that I
need to understand in order to present estimates to
the Revenue Estimating Conference for their
consideration to use in the official planning
documents of the State.
I seek out information. I don't wait for it
to come to me, and I work very hard to make sure
that in the limited amount of time I have to
produce those forecasts that I have engaged with as
many experts as I possibly can, because myself or
my staff will never know the situation as well as
those folks who live it and are seeking a solution
before the legislative process.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. That's all I had.
Any other questions? Commissioner.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: You've been around a
long time, you know the Agency, you know this
process, you've seen Cabinet. Working with Lisa,
you've seen the legislature at F & T. So I would
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
219
have a higher standard for you because you know
what you have. So assess for me the strengths and
weaknesses of the Department as you see them now
and what your first hundred days would look like.
MR. MCKEE: I've talked to a lot of folks in
preparing to be before you today, and I've heard a
common theme: That the Department has lost some of
the sense of responsiveness that is necessary and
hasn't gone in front of issues at times the way
that they needed to prevent things from growing to
the point where their folks felt it necessary to
engage their statewide leaders or their legislative
leaders.
So I think one of the issues that I would
address immediately is responsiveness, and part of
that would be that the Department has been very
good in the past, particularly on the guidance of
Doctor Jim Zingale, and then Lisa Vickers as she
succeeded him. To develop measures on ourselves;
to manage by those measures, to look at those.
And my sense has been that to some degree
those measures have been laid down in recent years.
They need to be picked up again, but they also need
to be looked -- developed for the executive
program, the part of the Department that the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
220
Executive Director directly leads.
Where I hear we're particularly not responsive
is in our ability to answer questions of taxpayers,
to give them certainty, and also with respect to
our informal protest process. We have some very
specific measures, for example, in our refund
process.
I think there are similar measures we could
put on the protest process in order to create
accountability, to drive resources to that
direction if it's, indeed, where we're slow, and to
develop the process to make sure what is causing
the bottleneck. I think that's certainly something
that I would bring back to you with respect to
those measures in the first hundred days.
I would also look to strengthen the
Taxpayer Advocate Office. That office is given
certain statutory powers today to invoke
extraordinary measures to provide relief or remedy
on behalf of taxpayers.
But in talking to our Taxpayer Advocate, I've
been advised that they've only used those
extraordinary powers four times in the last
15 years. I would seek to strengthen that office
and to give them some power to do things in
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
221
ordinary situations on behalf of Florida
businesses, particularly where they can stop the
clock, act as a check on the operating program, and
get the business more time in order to respond to
the Department. I think that that should be an
ordinary part, and I would look to our legislative
package to bring that initiative forward.
I think there are other areas, particularly in
the Taxpayer Bill of Rights, where there's not
clarity. There's, for example, a provision that
says a taxpayer should have available to them an
exemption that they were not aware of if they
didn't apply for it at the time; but then there's a
reference that says it only applies to sales tax.
Is it the policy of the State that that should
apply to all the taxes as the Taxpayer Bill of
Rights implies, or should it only be in sales tax?
I think that's another initiative that I would
bring before you to consider, whether that should
be a principle that -- the business has the same
three-year period to go back and realize, gee, I
missed the opportunity to apply for an exemption
that the State has to go back and audit; that there
should be balance in that -- from that standpoint
on behalf of the taxpayer.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
222
So that's another proposal that I would bring
before you for 100 days.
I have not been on the budget side since I was
the Deputy Executive Director back in 2008, but I
think it's also important that we look for
opportunities to privatize, and I would work with
my folks to look for those and bring something
before you back in our legislative budget request.
And those are some of the things that I would
do.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Attorney General.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Are you finished,
Commissioner?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Yes, ma'am.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Okay. Robert, we
know you have a significant amount of experience
working with the DOR, but how working with the
Legislature and the Florida League of Cities (sic)
has uniquely qualified you to be
Executive Director?
MR. MCKEE: I have spent the last 15 years
working with and for --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: League of Counties.
MR. MCKEE: I'm sorry. Yes, Association of
Counties, yes.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
223
I've spent the last 15 years working with and
for elected officials. I understand the deference
that needs to be given, the timely response, the
idea that, while patience is a virtue, it is always
a mistake to try someone's patience; and that as
you work with elected officials, a significant
customer base of which -- of the Department's are
the clerk of courts, the property appraisers, and
the tax collectors; that when you work with these
elected officials, you have to understand that your
timeframe may not be their timeframe. And you have
to maintain these relationships, communicate
effectively, and create a vision, and move it
forward.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Briefly, and I think
you may have answered this, but you received
obviously a great endorsement from the Florida
Property Appraisers Association. Why do you
believe you received that endorsement?
MR. MCKEE: I have worked with the property
appraisers in my various capacities. I worked with
them when I was with the Association of Counties, I
worked with them when I was the Deputy Executive
Director, and in my role as Chief Economist; and
when I was able to serve as part of CFO Atwater's
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
224
Senate staff, we worked with the appraisers then.
I think they understand that I am a person who
will listen; I will not come quick to judgment,
although recognizing there is a timeframe within
which answers need to happen; and that at the end
of the day, whatever I determine is reasoned and
communicated. And so that's why I believe that
I've gotten their support.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: CFO.
CFO ATWATER: Bob, how about if you would take
a minute and talk about a historical time in your
life work experience where you have had to take a
team, recognize there may have been
under-performance or not yet the efficiencies and
the effectiveness that you would have looked for?
What did you do to turn that around or advance it
forward to where you were satisfied? What were the
things that had to be part of the element of your
plan to make it work?
MR. MCKEE: Well, I think the most recent
example would be my current office in the
Chief Economist's Office. We had lost staff, as
many agencies had to during the Great Recession.
When I came back to the Department, we'd also
had some experience drain, we'd lost a number of
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
225
experienced individuals; and I had to bring on new
staff, train the staff, get them to understand the
timeframes, that we were different than other
Department employees because we had to respond to
the Session needs and the Session timeframe.
So we worked to understand how we had to move
quickly; how we had to be responsive; how we had to
find within us the ability to break down barriers,
ask questions, call into various agencies and
offices even when we did not have a contact; that
we had to be fearless, so to speak, in moving
things forward.
It's very much so in my current office. I
think there were some similar experience with
rising into the Deputy Executive Director role,
leading the Legislative Services Department after
Lisa Vickers had risen to be the
Executive Director, and establishing myself within
the Department as a leader.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Thank you.
MR. MCKEE: Thank you very much, Governor, and
Cabinet.
* * * *
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
226
JAMES EVERS
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Next we have James Evers.
Good afternoon.
MR. EVERS: How are you? And I do want to
thank you for the honor and the privilege of being
able to interview, at least for the
Executive Director position of the Florida
Department of Revenue.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So what changes would you
make based on the knowledge you have of DOR?
MR. EVERS: Well, if you looked at my resume,
I was the Director of the General Tax Program for
12 years and in senior management in the Florida
Department of Revenue for over 20 years.
During that time, I think Florida Department
of Revenue's tax program was recognized around the
world in governing magazines as being one of the
top revenue agencies in the country. And so had an
opportunity to host 31 different foreign countries
as they viewed the Florida Department of Revenue as
one of the best in the country.
I think they've kind of lost that edge,
you know, that push. If you look back at some of
the most significant things that we have done,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
227
technology has changed in the Tax Department from
top to end. You know, back in the old days, you
used to process paper and nine tons of mail, and
now it's all electronic.
E-auditing, you don't have to go physically
into a taxpayer's business to bother them; they can
turn it around to you electronically. All of those
initiatives were accomplished when I was in there
driving some of those metrics and some of those
performances.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: And so I guess that goes to
if you had two or three things you think you're
going to do -- if you were the Executive Director,
you could do a lot better?
MR. EVERS: Well, I think I've been gone for
almost close to four years, so I think I'd have to
talk to your offices about what your perception is,
what's changed in the Department, what's moved in
there. And certainly from my experience in the
Department, I think I have a good opportunity to go
back there and revisit them because I don't know
exactly what's changed since I left four and a half
years -- or almost four years ago.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Anybody have any
questions?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
228
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Go ahead,
Commissioner.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: No, no, go ahead.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Okay. You went back
to school to get your accounting degree, very
impressive; and why do you feel passionately about
that? Why did you do that?
MR. EVERS: Well, when I first went to
college, I probably changed my major a
hundred times, you know?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Me, too.
MR. EVERS: And I really wanted to get in
med school, but back in those days it was really
tough. So I had a degree in biology and ran out of
money because I was self-funded.
So I did go back and went to work for the
Department of Revenue, and they allowed me to
work -- you know, go to school at night in the
night program, and that was accomplished in several
years, and then the Department kept promoting me.
But anyhow the accounting degree --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Yes, that's --
MR. EVERS: I mean to me it provides the
foundation for, you know, managing big-picture
systems, modernizing efficiency. I think it gave
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
229
me some basic level of understanding.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Commissioner.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Yeah, you've mentioned
in your comments today and in the interview with my
Cabinet staff that DOR seems to have lost its edge,
and what does that mean? What specifically needs
to be corrected to regain that edge?
MR. EVERS: Well, first of all, like I've
said, I would have to have an opportunity to go
back to see if that's really my perception or if
that really -- if they have lost their edge,
because when we were there, you know, one of the
more remarkable things that we did was -- and it
goes back to the accounting degree.
Nobody in the Department of Revenue prior --
before we integrated our tax system knew what the
receivable balance was in the Florida Department
of Revenue. Once he started measuring the
Florida -- the outstanding receivable balance, we
had an opportunity to reduce it almost, you know,
from, I want to say $2 billion to $600 million, I
don't know the exact number.
So I think some of the commitment and some of
the drive, if you don't have strong leadership at
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
230
the top, you know, is missing there. Are they
going to take the risk? Are they going to go
outside, push the envelope, make sure that we're
doing the kind of things that are responsive to not
only large associations but making it easier for
not only employers to comply with Florida tax laws
improve the child support program, and the property
tax program.
I would add that when I had an opportunity to
work private for a short period of my time, I did
have an opportunity to go talk with all of the
property appraisers, because I think Florida has a
problem, you know, with homestead exemption fraud.
I think the Lieutenant Governor was a property
tax appraiser down in Miami-Dade. And one of the
things that we were marketing when I was out there
trying to sell to potentially property appraisers
is the ability to detect homestead exemption fraud
from using either the LexisNexis Accurint product
or the Thomson Reuters CLEAR product because
basically they know where people live and what
abuse is going on.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Anything else, Commissioner?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Yes.
Tell me what you see as being the greatest
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
231
contingent liability out there for the State.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I mean you're running
a -- you know, DOR is accounts receivable. What's
the -- what are the kinds of things that the
Executive Director ought to be laying awake at
night worrying about?
MR. EVERS: Well, first of all, if you've got
public assistance fraud, you've got identity theft.
The Florida Department of Revenue is in possession
of nine million Social Security numbers from all of
the Florida wages, not only in the child support
program but in the tax program. So certainly
keeping that safe and harboring that keeps
executives up at night.
I've had the opportunity for the last
three years to work for the Department of Economic
Opportunity, which has given me a different
perspective because I went to a different agency
and viewed revenue from a different agency's
perspective. They face the same challenges. They
have identity theft, public assistance fraud going
on. It's common in DCF; it's common in Department
of Health; it's common with most State agencies.
And I think there has to be a concerted effort
to improve that overall because too often agencies
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
232
try to do it themselves because they think they can
do it better rather than enlist the support of
experts, particularly from outside.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: CFO.
CFO ATWATER: Yeah, thank you.
Jim, you've spoken about the reduction of that
receivables that was out there, you've spoken about
the word leadership. How about walking me through
a specific where it was your responsibility to take
that team, what were the elements, what were the
skill sets that you had to deploy, and how did you
do it for that to be successful?
MR. EVERS: Well, I think I had several
different opportunities. I think everybody in the
room has probably heard about the Florida Suntax
System. That's a very complex system, and I think
the State has tried to put a statewide accounting
system in several times. So it takes a dedicated
team; it takes the passion; it takes the
leadership.
And more importantly to me, you've got to
determine a strategy of how to implement some of
that stuff because too often too many people try to
do too much at one time, as opposed to a phased
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
233
approach where you can bring together the right
management team, provide them with not only the
backbone and support for making sure they do that
concentrated effort.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Thank you very
much.
MR. EVERS: Thank you for the opportunity.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Next we have James Overton.
* * * *
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
234
JAMES OVERTON
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Good afternoon.
MR. OVERTON: And I don't think I'll open this
with a statement, I'll just say thank you for
consideration and you can ask questions.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Can you first
sort of talk about how many people you've managed
and what your management style is?
MR. OVERTON: My management style is kind of
participatory. I like to get people interested in
what the decision is and how they're going to be
impacted by the decision.
The most people I've ever managed, I guess, if
you can look at the City of Jacksonville, that's
about 7,000 people. I was the City Council
President, so we were managing -- I was managing --
helping the mayor manage all those folks. But the
largest direct management job I've had is about
130 people in the property appraiser's office in
Jacksonville.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. And now you've never
been at DOR, so --
MR. OVERTON: No, I've been a victim of DOR.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So not ever being there, do
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
235
you have any perceptions of things that you think
you would already change?
MR. OVERTON: Well, from the property tax
standpoint, I think that the Agency needs to take a
more sympathetic view, kind of like what Jim was
just saying, of the property appraisers and their
job and how they are impacted by what the DOR does.
From the public standpoint, I think that the
Agency needs to develop a sense of trust in the
public; and that is, that the public can trust us
to be accurate and fair, and we're not out to get
you. We're out to be fair and have you pay your
fair share but we're not asking you to kowtow to
us, or we're not asking you to -- or we're not
intimidating you, for example.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So what -- in your
background, you've done a few different things, but
in your professional background what prepares you
to do DOR, be Executive Director of DOR do you
think? The property, I mean --
MR. OVERTON: Yeah, being a property appraiser
obviously. That's only -- you know, it's a small
percentage of the budget. If you counted all of
the property appraisers' employees across the
state, it would be a big chunk of folks, a couple
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
236
of thousand I would guess.
Specifically what prepares me for this is
public service. I've seen a large government in
action. You know, the City of Jacksonville is a
billion-dollar budget, so I've seen that kind of
bureaucracy and how it works. That's the best
example of how I would be prepared to take on
5,100 employees.
But I really do think that one of the things
that the Director needs to do is to get out in the
field, see the offices, talk to folks, see how it's
going. I'd spend the first hundred days, as you'd
asked the question earlier, getting out in the
field and seeing what was going on and seeing if I
couldn't put my ear to the rail and go at it that
way.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Attorney General.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I was going to ask
you, as the Duval Property Appraiser, when have you
worked with DOR; but I think I'm going to ask you:
as the Duval Property Appraiser, when have you been
a victim of DOR?
MR. OVERTON: Well, you know, DOR has had a
tendency to make rule interpretations that didn't
favor the property appraisers, they sort of favored
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
237
the tax representatives around the state. That's
been largely brought into, I think, some control in
this last legislative session. Y'all passed a
bill, I don't know if you signed it yet, to
register and to put those folks under Chapter 475
of the Statutes.
So that's the -- victimization I guess is a
strong word for that.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I was teasing.
MR. OVERTON: Oh, I'm being a little humorous,
too.
But, you know, my experience with DOR as a
taxpayer has been, I had a sales tax audit one
time, and I thought they were unreasonable. I mean
the fellow who did the audit was brusque, he was
not helpful. He wanted to look at three years of
back records when I had closed that particular
business. He lived in my office for about
two months. He looked at every invoice over a
three-year period. He found initially $15,000 he
wanted from us, and by the time we finished, it was
about $1,200.
So that particular -- that's general tax now,
not property tax. That experience, you know, kind
of got me interested in: What are these folks in
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
238
Tallahassee doing and how am I as a business person
supposed to interface with them?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Commissioner.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: So tell me what you
think they're doing right? What do you think --
MR. OVERTON: I like their website.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Okay.
MR. OVERTON: You know, I think that every
Director has had pluses and minuses, from Zingale
forward. I mean I think they do a very good job in
some of the statistical work they do. I think that
-- well, McKee does a great job with economics and
budget and revenue projections.
I think they're reasonably well organized, I
think. I don't know that for a fact. I don't know
how flat the organization is, I don't know what
kind of levels of management they have. I strongly
believe in a flat organization. I strongly believe
in educating folks and asking people to make
decisions appropriate to their level in the
organization, and expecting them to act like adults
with those decisions and to own those decisions and
to try things. It might work -- try it, it might
work. If it doesn't work, we'll try something
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
239
else, or we'll get rid of that and try something
else.
I do think in that kind of thinking about
that, it's okay to ask people to do things and then
expect that they're going to make mistakes
occasionally and be willing to accept that as
management.
Does that answer your question?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: It does, thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: CFO.
CFO ATWATER: Jim, you've had a diverse
career: You have built a business, you've served
in elected office in a couple of different
capacities, so I'd like to ask -- you've heard the
question. You've had to take teams before from the
mundane to the high performance, to the
underachievers to excellence. What skill sets have
you had to deploy to achieve that?
MR. OVERTON: To bring people up, that are
underachievers? Well, if you believe in the GE
method, you just get rid of some of those folks.
But, you know, at the lower end of the scale, you
sometimes have to ask people to retire or leave the
organization or find something else to do.
At the other end, I do -- I strongly believe
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
240
that you have to engage folks in a dialogue and you
don't wait until the performance appraisal at the
end of the year to say, hey, Fred, you're doing
something wrong and here it is.
You constantly have that crucial conversation
during the course of the year to make sure that
you're on the same page and things are going okay.
And you have to tell people that things are going
okay and that things may be -- other things are not
going so well.
So I think of the things I like about
participatory management, to use kind of a buzz
word, is that you kind of get into people's stuff
all the time and -- the best you can, and you don't
wait until the end and surprise people with a
decision at the end of the day.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Thank you.
MR. OVERTON: Thank you, Governor.
* * * *
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
241
LEON BIEGALSKI
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Last we have Leon Biegalski.
So, Leon, can you tell me, why do you want to
be Executive Director, and what's your -- give me
your background as to why you think you would fit
in the role.
MR. BIEGALSKI: Thank you, Governor Scott,
Attorney General Bondi, CFO Atwater,
Commissioner Putnam.
I want to start by saying, being at this point
in the process is truly an honor.
The simple question: Why? It's because I
care. I'm a native Floridian. I'm proud of the
state. I'm proud of the fact that I've been able
to serve the people and the businesses of Florida.
My career has taken me on a journey that's
given me a good spectrum and experience in taking
this step. I've grown from simply using my legal
background to managing and organizing to now being
in a leadership position at an agency with a large
statewide footprint.
I want you to know that my personal approach
to my professional responsibilities have to do with
clarity, communication, compliance. I think those
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
242
are all things that can be applied to all facets of
the Department of Revenue.
There are things that -- there are things that
once put in place -- and I'm sure I'll get to this
point in some other question regarding dealing with
customers. My goal is to serve the Agency on your
behalf as the Executive Director.
Shifting gears back to the question about my
experiences. Currently at DBPR I'm responsible for
four divisions with close to a thousand employees
in 13 regions -- or 13 regional offices around the
state, but we've also got several hundred of those
people that are out in the field every day, in and
out of people's businesses. And part of making
sure that they're doing what they need to do comes
back to these principles of: Clarity,
communication, compliance; and so I'll come back to
this customer idea.
The taxpayers are customers; people seeking
child support payments are customers; people making
child support payments are customers; the people
that deal with the Department on an everyday basis,
they're customers. And that customer-centric
approach, recognizing that, sets the tone for how
the employees deal with these customers.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
243
And that's what we do at DBPR. We've done it
effectively. It's what I've done over the course
of my entire career.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Has Ken Lawson done anything
positive at DBPR that you would bring over? Oh, I
didn't see you there.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: He's not in the room,
by the way. He's not in the room, by the way.
MR. BIEGALSKI: Yeah, I'm going to ignore that
he's over there. He has done so many things, and
like I said, these are things that I've carried
throughout my entire career; but being with him has
just helped foster that it works. He comes from
that same mindset.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So do you think your legal
background would help you, or is it a hindrance?
Some people up here have argued earlier today that
it might be a hindrance. You probably weren't in
the room then.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Governor, I don't
think Commissioner Putnam is too happy with me
right now.
MR. BIEGALSKI: This is one of those things
where, yes, it helps tremendously. In some
instances, I don't know how you can do some of
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
244
these -- some of the positions I've had that didn't
require you to be an attorney, but being one
certainly helps. It helps make sure that I'm
asking -- that I'm asking the right questions when
issues are being presented to me because,
ultimately, I've got to have those conversations
with each of you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Attorney General.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And lawyer to lawyer,
can you explain to the two non-lawyers over there
exactly how as head of DOR -- we're getting punchy
-- exactly as head of DOR how you work directly
with my office, in what ways and why that is so
very important.
MR. BIEGALSKI: Well, I think it goes back to,
like I was just saying, about making sure that I'm
asking the right questions to convey the right
information to you. In particular, you know, we're
going to be dealing with child support enforcement
issues. The Department contracts with the
Attorney General's Office in certain counties to
perform those functions.
In taking it a little bit out of the lawyer
sphere, some of it goes back to what I've mentioned
before, and I'm going to sound like a broken
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
245
record, but talking about clarity and communication
and compliance. It's making sure that that
communication is clear and making sure that what
the Department is conveying to -- whether they be,
again, people expecting child support payments or
those making those payments, that they're getting
the right information from the Agency, and
consistent information from both the main office
and the local office. But that also has to
translate in making sure that we're communicating
with your office to make sure that they're getting
that same information out.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And as, you know, I
hope you know, it's actually a large part of the
state. It's Broward, Hillsborough, Manatee,
Sarasota, here, most of the Panhandle where we
handle child support and we also handle paternity.
So that relationship is extremely important to me
and my attorneys as well.
Could you also just -- could you describe some
of the tax-related issues that you've worked on
while at DBPR?
MR. BIEGALSKI: Sure. two of the divisions
that are within my purview collect -- or collected
last year alone in excess of $2 billion in taxes
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
246
and fees. I think that's one of the functions that
some of the people don't realize that DBPR does,
but -- and they're not necessarily the easiest of
tax statutes to read.
So, again, from the lawyer side, understanding
that certainly makes it a lot easier to get through
those. And like I said, some of the statutes are a
little bit complex, but I think that that gives me
good experience and background in understanding the
broader tax laws of the State of Florida, and there
are similarities.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Thanks.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Commissioner or CFO?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Tell me about your
observations of Revenue, what they get right, what
their reputation is, and what your first
hundred days would look like.
MR. BIEGALSKI: I'm going to say this
generally because, you know, you hear things here
and there, you go online and you read things; and
generally a lot of times the things that you read
are complaints. You sometimes have to take it with
a grain of salt about how true it is.
But from what I'm gathering, is that some of
it goes back to the message that's going out to the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
247
customers is not always clear, or it's conflicting:
You get one answer one place, another answer
another place. And that's where we want to make
sure that we've got consistency in that answer.
Because at the end of the day, most people want to
be in compliance, and how do you help them get in
compliance? You get them the right answer.
So those are some of the general observations,
and like I said, sometimes I think some of the
conflict is that field offices may be giving
different information than the main office. And so
that communication, that clarity has got to filter
all the way down.
Going to the first hundred days, it's not in
my nature to sit behind a desk, bury myself in
paperwork. So what I would be doing is getting out
into the field, getting together with employees,
customers, other stakeholders to try to get their
perspective on just those types of things that you
asked, Commissioner.
I think once you kind of gauge that to figure
out exactly where this communication is -- maybe
the communication is great, maybe it's just a
couple of people. But once you figure that out,
then you can set the tone for getting that open
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
248
communication and making sure that people
understand that they're going to be treated
equally, treated fairly.
One of the other things though, at that same
time, it's my intention to be in contact with each
of you to try to determine where you think there
might be room for improvement; because ultimately,
at the end of the day, I want to be the guy that
when you're out and you have a constituent ask you
a question you can give them my card and say: Call
him, and have confidence to know that it's going to
get taken care of and that I'll follow up with you
to make sure you know that it got taken care of and
how.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Tell me about your
interaction with stakeholders in your previous
roles. You were over at Surveyors and Mappers,
obviously in parimutuel. We're not talking about
shrinking violets who have an interest in you
having to make a decision one way or another.
Tell me how those experiences have prepared
you to run an agency the size of Revenue.
MR. BIEGALSKI: I'll go with parimutuel first.
I believe that I've got a good reputation with
those stakeholders; and as you've said, they're not
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
249
shrinking violets, they're some of the more
prominent representatives in the state. And,
you know, I would be willing to ask you, if you
want to take a poll of them, that they'll say that
I'm honest with them. You know, sometimes the
answer is no, but I'll tell them why and they'll
know that I thought it through and that it's -- you
know, they're treated equally and fairly, much like
I would want to do at Revenue. Sometimes the
answer is yes and everybody is happy. In that
arena though, usually nobody is happy, parimutuel,
so -- we've all seen that.
But we'll go back to being at Surveyors and
Mappers, and I was with professional boards at DBPR
in a previous position. What being an
executive director for those boards did was it
helped me learn and understand what it's like to
get direction from multiple principals at one time
and understanding that being responsive to each
principal and the body as a whole is a necessity.
I don't understand how you can not operate
without keeping that constantly, constantly in your
thought process. And to me that translates to the
same -- the same concept in terms of interacting
with all of you.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
250
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: CFO.
CFO ATWATER: Yeah, Leon, again, quite
distinguished roles that you've played, leadership
roles up to today.
MR. BIEGALSKI: Thank you.
CFO ATWATER: There have been occasions where
you had to take a team that was not achieving to
your expectations or the expectations of
management. What are the skill sets? How did you
do it? Give me an example of where you've done
this in the past.
MR. BIEGALSKI: The example that I'll give you
actually, I'm going to say, probably started with
me. My first real learning experience of,
you know, semi being in charge of an issue that was
going on that had some legal challenges to it and,
you know, as part of going down the path, my
questions to the people that were a little bit more
in the weeds on it were: So what are we going to
do if we lose here? And the answer was: Well,
we're going to do this. Okay, great. And that was
my response to my supervisor at the time.
Unfortunately, that did happen, and when I
said, okay, so we'll do this. And their response
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
251
was, oh, well, that's just the plan generally, we
don't have any details to it. And this was the
type of thing that it was happening the next day.
That was my first learning experience in terms
of making sure that using these things that I've
talked about, communication and clarity, that I was
getting that across to them so that I'm making sure
that they know my expectations.
So from there it just -- that helped kind of
foster, hey, I've got to tap into all of these --
all of these skills, all of these experiences, and
do a better job even with these principles that
I've talked about to move forward and make sure
that it doesn't happen again.
CFO ATWATER: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Thank you, Leon.
MR. BIEGALSKI: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Unless anybody has any more?
(NO RESPONSE).
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Does anybody have
any comments?
(NO RESPONSE).
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. I move to appoint
Leon Biegalski as Executive Director of the
Department of Revenue with a compensation of
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
252
$150,000 per year. Is there a second?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I think we all had
our individual picks, and it's frankly hard to come
to a consensus, so I --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: We have four good choices.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: We have four very
good choices. I frankly am pleasantly surprised.
I think Leon hit it out of the park, and I'll
second it.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All in favor.
CFO ATWATER: Governor, can I -- you mentioned
comments first. I do want to just say the same
thing. This was really impressive. We have four
really talented --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Great.
CFO ATWATER: -- really talented leaders, and
so I'm very impressed. So I'm trying to see how
this is -- this process why it's playing out, not
to slow us down, but I certainly consider Leon a
top candidate for the job and feel stronger even
more so after hearing his presentation to the
question and answer.
I still might have a candidate that I might
feel more strongly about but I don't know if this
is -- I don't know. I guess that's the point here.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
253
If you're making that motion and Leon gets that
majority vote, then I take it that that's how we're
moving forward. I don't know if we were going to
have a dialogue of four down to two, two
conversation, but I'm willing to follow the process
however you want to take it, Governor.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: And, Governor, I mean
I wouldn't mind having a dialogue because, again,
there are four of us. And Commissioner Putnam, you
know, I --
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Sure.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: There are four of us,
and frankly, I liked Leon's answer about he
realizes, you know, that there will be four of us
he will be working with.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: You know, one thing I liked
is --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: -- strong feelings --
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Why I like, Leon, is that
he's -- he's had success, he has run a lot of --
he's managed a lot of people. So I think Ken
Lawson has done a good job at DBPR and put together
a good team of people. You know, I can tell you
that as I travel the state -- you know, we all meet
people. I don't hear a lot of complaints from DBPR
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
254
from around the state.
I think probably Ken can tell you, but I think
it was probably my first year in office I had
somebody complain down in Miami about the Miami
office; and within a day, you know, Ken, I think
you had gone down and met with the person. And I
think that's the reputation they have.
So I think Leon respects the process, because
I think the process is, you know, that he
doesn't -- he works for -- you know, we all -- he
works with every one of us, and so I think he's got
the right background to be able to do the job.
Yeah, I think we have good candidates, I mean --
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: We have exceptional
candidates. Leon was on my list coming into this
process as someone who had played a leadership
role, managed people, and more than just in a
general counsel capacity, but overseeing people in
parimutuel wagering.
And, you know, the thing about these jobs is
they're hot, I mean these are hot jobs and very
much under scrutiny with four principals to report
to; and so I think that it is important that he
have that. You know, the absence of a finance or
accounting background for Revenue was the only
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
255
hesitation that I had.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: You're anti-lawyer,
aren't you?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Huh?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I'm kidding.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Well --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: I'm joking.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: I think it was a yes.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: But fundamentally,
you know, this is a management -- this is a
leadership role; and so, you know, while that was a
concern that I had coming into this process, as he
stacked up against other candidates, I'm
comfortable with his track record, his leadership
abilities, and the way that he performed in the
interview; so I would be prepared to support your
motion. I'm just supporting it sooner than I
thought we were, but --
CFO ATWATER: Then, Governor, why don't we do
this -- I can count, and I --
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: That's why you're the
CFO.
CFO ATWATER: I would want -- I think we had
four good candidates, I think we've all said that;
and I'm proud of every one of them that stepped up,
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
256
and I'm proud of the job they did here in front of
us.
I'd like Leon to know that if he's stepping in
to work for four of us this is a unanimous, you
know, conclusion; and I'm high on his candidacy and
I'm willing to support that motion as well.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Congratulations, Leon.
(APPLAUSE).
GOVERNOR SCOTT: I did want to say that -- I
want to thank everybody that went through the
process; I want to thank everybody that applied; I
want to thank the four individuals that came today
because every one of them could have done this job.
And everybody brought different backgrounds to
this, but we had -- this process worked. We had
good candidates; and thanks, everybody, for being
here and doing this.
But congratulations, Leon.
* * * *
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
257
INTERVIEW AND APPOINTMENT FOR THE
OFFICE OF INSURANCE REGULATION COMMISSIONER
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Last we have the interviews
and appointment for the Commissioner of the Office
of Insurance Regulation. Similar to DOR, the
position was open and advertised from January 25th
to March 11th. During that time, we received
55 applications and posted those applications
online.
Each of our Cabinet Aides also scheduled their
selected candidates to come to today's meeting for
a public interview. The candidates are Number 16,
Jeffrey Bragg; and Number 52, Representative
Bill Hager.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
258
JEFFREY BRAGG
GOVERNOR SCOTT: First I'd like to recognize
Jeffrey Bragg. Good haircut.
MR. BRAGG: Thanks, Governor.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Thanks for being here. Can
you first just say, why would you like to have a
job like this?
MR. BRAGG: Well, I think any of us who have
had any public sector experience at all recognizes
the opportunity to do some good. I've been really
honored to have had several opportunities to serve
the public in Washington, and I -- when this
position became open, I saw it as another
opportunity to continue my public service.
And I think the rewards that come from
public service are second to none. I have been in
the private sector and in the public sector, and I
think that the opportunity to do good for more
people lies in the public sector and I'm looking
forward to continuing that.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Can you talk a little bit
about how many employees you've managed and just
sort of a little bit of your management style?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
259
MR. BRAGG: Yeah, the most employees I've
managed in terms of just numbers over an enterprise
was 1,500 employees, and that represented about
$200 million in revenue.
My management style is entirely
consensus-building. I seek all of the input from
all of the leadership in the organization. I seek
input from all of the stakeholders that have an
interest in the outcome of whatever decision is
being made.
I proactively reach out to everybody that has
an opinion on the topic. I listen to them, I
respect their views, I consider their views, and
really don't make a decision or recommend a
decision until I have heard all of that input and
am able to come up with a considered and valued
view as to what should be done.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: What do you see the Number 1
role of the Commissioner?
MR. BRAGG: Well, I see the Commissioner's
role as being like a chief operating officer. I
think the Legislature enacts legislation. I think
this Cabinet acts as a board of directors; I think
this Cabinet sets policy; and I believe that it's
my role to carry out that policy. As the COO, I
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
260
don't make policy, I implement your policy, and I'm
responsible to you, and each and every one of you,
in some cases, on a daily basis to make sure that
your policies are carried out.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Have you ever been -- have
you been in a role where you had four individuals
in a similar situation?
MR. BRAGG: 435 members of Congress all
thought that I worked for them, but apart from
that, no. I think that's going to be a unique
challenge to this position. I'm looking forward to
it. I don't think it's a challenge that I cannot
overcome because my style is, again,
consensus-building.
In addition to seeking input from
stakeholders, I will work every day with your
staffs and with you, if you prefer, to try to build
the consensus that we're all looking for. At the
end of the day, we're all trying to serve the
consumer, and you don't do that just by making
decisions on your own. You don't do that by not
implementing the policy of the policymakers.
You do that by following policy, gathering
information from all stakeholders, and then trying
to either recommend the decision back to the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
261
policymakers or implementing it if it's an
operational issue on your own.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So what's your vision of what
the insurance market should be like in Florida?
MR. BRAGG: Well, you know, insurance is a
huge market in Florida. It's the third largest
insurance market in the United States. It's the
12th largest insurance market in the world.
The best thing to do for the insurance market
is to continue to let it grow, to let it -- to
bring in as many companies as we can, to create as
big a private-sector solution to the insurance
issues that face us as we can, to really create an
atmosphere and an environment where you have a
vigorous, active, competitive -- the more the
competitive, the better -- insurance market. And
that is one way I think that you can best serve the
consumers.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Attorney General.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Yes. Something that
is very important to me, of course, is, as the
healthcare marketplace gets more complex with the
Affordable Care Act, how would you ensure that our
consumers are protected?
MR. BRAGG: Well, I think you -- the best way
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
262
to do that is to really get your hands around the
Affordable Care Act. You know that a lot of the
policies and forms that originally are approved by
the Department of Insurance now have to also be
compatible with the Affordable Care Act, so you
have to become more and more knowledgeable of the
Affordable Care Act and the fact that if benefits
are not paid at a certain percentage, for example,
85% of premiums have to go back in the form of
benefits to group health insureds, and it's 80% for
individuals.
I think you have to monitor that closely so
that you don't get a huge disproportion of payback
necessarily. You have to continually manage the
concept that a huge percentage of the premiums have
to go back in the form of benefits to the insured.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: What about the
Navigators?
MR. BRAGG: I'm sorry?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: The Navigators in the
Affordable Healthcare Act.
MR. BRAGG: I guess I'm not familiar with what
you're asking.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Okay. What would
your plan be to make sure that seniors have a
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
263
long-term healthcare coverage?
MR. BRAGG: Well, you know, there are several
aspects of that. There is long-term healthcare,
that's generally considered to be very expensive.
And I know that there is a new trend among
life insurers to -- through a rider primarily -- to
allow seniors to access their life insurance
benefits over a period of time rather than wait for
a death benefit. And I think that's one good way
to help seniors manage their incomes by accessing
their life insurance proceeds earlier and over a
longer period of time.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: CFO or Commissioner?
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Talk to me a little bit
about the flood insurance market. You come from
the Federal background on TRIA. Florida is
exploring ways to find new vehicles that aren't as
connected to the Washington solution on flood.
Talk to me about your vision for that in our state.
MR. BRAGG: Well, as -- you may be aware that
I did run the flood insurance program for many
years in Washington, and one of my initiatives at
the time was to create the write-your-own program.
Up until that time, all of the administration of
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
264
the Flood Insurance Program was handled in
Washington by either government employees or
government contractors.
What I said we needed to do was to put the
administration of the flood insurance program into
the hands of the private sector and let them sell
and service and pay claims against the flood
insurance program harnessing all of the experience,
expertise, and people that normally work in
insurance and put them to work on the flood
insurance program.
That was resulted in over 200 companies
selling -- servicing -- selling and servicing flood
insurance in the private sector. 95% of the
policies that were in the public sector were moved
to the private sector. And the private sector grew
those policies from two million to over
five million flood insurance policyholders today.
Now I do think Florida has a unique problem in
the sense that they are paying much more in
premiums than they're getting back in benefits from
the flood insurance program.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Four to one.
MR. BRAGG: Pardon me?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Four to one, that's what
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
265
we've paid since it started, the national flood
insurance.
MR. BRAGG: Yeah, and my goal in that regard
would be two-fold: One is to continue to encourage
private sectors not just to service the
write-your-own program, but to actively get them to
participate in doing the flood insurance business
independently.
I also think I could go to Washington and work
with people who are in FEMA, people who run the
flood insurance program today, and present some
concepts to them in an attempt to lower flood
insurance premiums for Floridians. For example,
one idea I have is -- you know, it's hard to get
those actuaries up there to get off of their
tables. But if you can go up and talk to those
actuaries, and say, look, here is our loss ratio,
it's nowhere near getting the benefits that we
deserve for our premium. Why don't we construct a
system that allows us to -- for example, if you
have so many years of hurricane-free experience or
flood-free experience, you get a 10% reduction in
your rate, or a 20% reduction in your rate; and
that escalates up and down based upon your actual
experience.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
266
And that's something I think they would listen
to because it's not something that they would have
to do just for Florida, they could do it in any
other state that had good flood insurance
experience, and it could be a mechanism that really
allowed the policy premium to go up and down based
upon experience.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: How do you assess the
office today? What's it really doing well, what do
you really see as the things that need to be
tackled immediately to improve?
MR. BRAGG: Well, it's doing very well. All
of you, Kevin McCarty, the people who work at the
Department, really share an excellent reputation in
the state. But I can tell you from my experience
in Washington and from spending a lot of time
outside of the state, that it's really a national
view that Florida is doing a good job regulating
insurance.
Having said that, the problems that you're
going to have in insurance will always be with us,
and it's an ongoing and daily chore to try to solve
those problems. And like any organization, I think
fresh eyes, fresh blood, a fresh perspective can
help bring new ideas to the table on how to solve
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
267
the problems that face Florida, and that's what I'm
looking forward to.
But in terms of the Department, they're doing
a very good job. My goal would not be to go over
there and wholesale change the organization or to
get rid of people. Any changes I would make would
be extremely surgical, just based upon the
philosophy that I bring about leadership and
responsiveness and consensus-building.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: You said your vision was
to let our market grow, more companies, vigorous,
active, competitive market. How do we get there,
especially on the property side?
MR. BRAGG: Well, you know, that's a
challenge, and I think it just requires constant
working with the private sector. I think it
reaches out to some of the national companies and
trying to convince them that our loss experience
isn't four hurricanes every year, it was four
hurricanes in one year, and that you need to expand
your writing in Florida, and that it's a profitable
state.
I think we need to make the Florida companies,
the domestic companies more profitable by
encouraging them to go outside the state as well.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
268
The more business that you can write that becomes
not high risk, the more opportunity you can write
other risk within the state.
So kind of a two-pronged approach, both with
the domestic or the companies based in Florida and
the companies from outside the state, encouraging
both to expand and write more insurance.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: My final question, and
I'm going to give both applicants the opportunity
to answer the same question. And this is a very
difficult, hot position, not only because of four
principals but the nature of it and the nature of
our state and the nature of everything involved in
it, and you've got to be pretty tough. And as
you've already seen, just as the other applicant
has seen it, you know, just being a finalist has
generated scrutiny that you may or may not have had
in other positions.
So I would give you the opportunity to respond
to the criticisms that have been leveled your way
in the public space.
MR. BRAGG: Yeah, it's an unfortunate aspect
of American business that every business in America
is going to be sued, that's particularly true with
companies that have had an initial public offering;
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
269
and it's also characteristic that when they file
those lawsuits, they're not particularly
complimentary of management.
But I will tell you that the lawsuit that has
been referenced in the media was a typical lawsuit
as a result of an initial public offering; that it
was settled out of court 13 years ago; that,
frankly, it was part of the review that the FBI did
when they granted me top secret clearances to run
the programs in Washington, and they found nothing
wrong with my leadership or background. And it's
not -- it's not good, but it is part of what we
face every day as businessmen and leaders.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: CFO.
CFO ATWATER: Thank you, Governor.
Jeff, how about if we could go back. You laid
out to the very good -- and almost opening an
appropriate question there as to how do you look at
our markets down the road and what do you see and
what are the ways to create a stronger marketplace.
How about if you can give me, how do you cover
that balancing act? There is a consumer involved
here, you noted that at the end. All of us who
share a view of a good capitalist system that more
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
270
choice, more opportunity, people competing, greater
value; but how do you walk this balancing act in
this position, creating a robust market and being
sure that 20 million people are getting the best
and fairest care that they should be getting.
MR. BRAGG: Well, I think you start by making
certain and making a firm commitment that you're
willing to listen to everybody, and that means
people on both far ends of the spectrum, as well as
those people more in the middle.
Secondly, you know, it is the proverbial
three-legged stool. You really have to balance the
health of the insurers against the happiness of the
consumer. And, you know, the third leg of that
chair are the employees and the Cabinet that we
report to.
So any time you have any part of that that's
just a little off balance, the stool is not going
to work, and the only way to keep that on balance
is to make sure that you have consulted just
absolutely as many people as you can in making your
decisions and in consulting leadership before you
make a decision as to the direction that they would
like to go.
There are policy decisions and there are
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
271
operational decisions, and I wouldn't begin to make
a policy decision without consulting this group; or
if you said a particular operating decision was
policy, then that becomes policy.
But it's a balancing act, and you can only do
that -- and that's what I did, you know, when I did
the write-your-own program, it wasn't just I had to
go out and write up this program, I had to get the
Department of Commerce to agree to it; I had to get
the Department of Labor to agree to it; I had to
get OMB to agree to it; I had to get the Treasury
Department to agree to it; I had to get the
carriers to agree to it; I had to get the agents to
agree to it.
And it's not like -- these problems are not
like peeling off a corner and sticking them in a
microwave for 30 seconds. These problems require a
Viking range, lots of cooks, lots of ingredients;
but you bring them all together and you bake it for
as long as it needs to bake, and out comes your
result, and hopefully it's a good one.
CFO ATWATER: Jeff, are you familiar with
Florida's personal injury protection on the auto
side? And then let me follow with a question, and
if you're not as familiar with it -- we went
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
272
through a process a couple of years ago, you talk
about the public policy making. Many of us I think
agreed that it was the right thing to do, I still
believe we had to do something.
And we went in and we did an analysis where
the driving costs were which, of course, the
consumer would have considered that word benefits,
certain benefits. And we narrowed some of those
cost drivers with an aspirational expectation that
the consumer would begin to get some relief, and it
hasn't come to pass.
How would you take a look at that situation,
or do you have an experience with it historically,
seeing how it's played out in other states, know it
well enough to give us maybe a suggested future
direction?
MR. BRAGG: Well, the balancing act, it's the
800-pound gorilla in the room. It really has to do
with an insured's right for coverage and right for
benefits against an insured's -- and low cost
premiums against the right of consumers to seek
redress in the courts. And you have that problem
with PIP; you have that problem with medical
malpractice; you have that problem with workers'
compensation, and it's not just in Florida, it's
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
273
nationwide.
And I think you were right to create the PIP
statute. I think it did temporarily solve some of
the high-loss issues that have surrounded not only
auto but these other lines of insurance as well,
but I think it's going to require another look; and
I think, you know, just like -- you know, if the
Supreme Court overturns the three -- or overturns
some of the statutes in the workers' comp area or
the medical malpractice area.
That's what I meant when I said insurance
problems will always be part of Florida. It's a
moving target and has to be looked at every day
with new eyes, a fresh approach, and new ideas.
CFO ATWATER: My office represents the Florida
consumer, insurance consumer advocate, and so I
would say this clearly, Jeff, looking at your
resume and this conversation, you know, exceptional
background, exceptional career, and the -- how
about though, if you would, offer some insights
into -- let me say this again, your answers I think
addressing and creating -- going out and talking to
the national players, getting Florida domestics to
continue to grow and diversify their risk by moving
into other geographies. All of this speaks very
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
274
well again, I think, to that mindset of the greater
participation, greater the choice, lower the price
points.
But how about speaking directly to the Florida
consumers for a moment. How do you maintain
that -- or what is that same perspective that they
are sure that the person sitting in that spot,
standing in that position is going to hold players
accountable to deliver, again, on the claims side,
on the accuracy and the care of their -- setting
their forms and their pricing, that you're able to
do right by all parties here?
MR. BRAGG: Well, at the end of the day,
that's the job. The job is to protect the
consumers in the State of Florida and to give them
good coverage at a good price where claims are paid
in a timely fashion. That is the job. What I've
been describing to you is how my -- what my
approach to the job would be.
So I think if we keep in mind always that our
jobs are to protect the consumers, that's the only
reason government exists, it exists to protect
consumers. And while we can talk in terms of
reducing the government footprint, you know,
privatizing certain lines of business as we've
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
275
done, at the end of the day, we do that because
it's better for the consumer.
We spread the risk of the flood insurance
program not to make insurance companies wealthy but
because we were able to keep rates lower because we
had a bigger policyholder base. So the point is,
the job is to protect the consumer. How you do it
is to involve everybody in the process.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Thank you.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Can I ask one more
question, Governor?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Sure.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Commissioner Putnam
had asked you a question and I just want to follow
up on regarding insurance solutions management.
You said that was part of doing big business, we
all understand that, but I'd like to know a little
bit more about the settlement.
MR. BRAGG: Well, the suit was filed with the
allegation that management had somehow misled
shareholders in representing the direction and the
future of the company. Now the truth of the matter
is, what we disclosed in the prospectus was,
frankly, all of the risks involved, including the
company that we had acquired called Geotrack, which
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
276
was a flood zone determination company. And one of
the things we said in the prospectus was housing
starts could dramatically impact the revenue base
for Geotrack, for example.
And so, you know, what -- and then when
Geotrack failed to achieve -- when that subsidiary
failed to achieve what we had hoped it would,
revenues did not reach their goals and, therefore,
the stock price declined. It was based upon that
that the -- largely, that the shareholder suit was
filed. And, you know, again they -- I think what
they said was that we misled shareholders.
I don't believe that anybody misled
shareholders. I think if you were to go back and
read the prospectus, you would see all of the risks
that we outlined as part of the business plan.
Nevertheless, it is true that any IPO, if
their shares drop, get sued, I mean that just
happens. And it was unfortunate that our shares
dropped.
I personally lost money in that transaction.
I owned shares of the stock. I lost money. I
wasn't happy about it, but that is business, and it
was largely the Geotrack subsidiary that did not
measure up as we had hoped.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
277
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Okay. Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Did any of the Board members
or any of the management have to pay part of the
settlement?
MR. BRAGG: No.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. So did y'all have a
DNO?
MR. BRAGG: Yes.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. So they paid all of
it?
MR. BRAGG: They paid all of it, yeah.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: It was a settlement and
didn't go to trial?
MR. BRAGG: It did not go to trial.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: How long did it take to
settle?
MR. BRAGG: I think a couple of years.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. Does anybody have any
other questions?
Commissioner.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Sort of the typical
thing I ask people when we're interviewing them.
Is there anything we didn't ask you that you wish
that we had? It's your last opportunity to put
something on the table.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
278
MR. BRAGG: No, I guess -- no, I thought it
was a good interview process. I didn't get a
chance too much to talk about my time as head of
the Terrorism Risk Insurance Program. I would just
say that that's another kind of chapter in my
background.
That was a chapter where I started with a
blank sheet of paper. They hired me to set up the
program. I was alone with a computer, and from
that, I was able to hire the people I needed, put
forth the regulations to not only regulate the
program but to regulate the companies that
participated in the program. We hired contractors
to pay claims. We decided rather than hire 300
staff people in Washington, we decided to outsource
our back office processing.
So I'm proud of that achievement. We were
able to take, you know, a blank sheet of paper, by
myself in an office, and I created the whole
program. So I take -- I'm proud of that, as well
as my other accomplishments that I've outlined
before you today.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Anybody else?
(NO RESPONSE).
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
279
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Thank you.
* * * *
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
280
BILL HAGER
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Now I'd like to recognize
Representative Bill Hager.
So, Representative, you have -- I can just
tell you from all of the phone calls I've received,
you have -- a lot of people appreciate what you've
accomplished in the Legislature that has improved
our insurance market, and so you have a significant
amount of support from the insurance industry
because, you know, the things you've done and how
you've handled yourself in the Legislature. So
thanks for doing that.
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: Pleased to do it,
honored to do it.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So why would you want to do
this job? You've got this great job, it's easy,
you know --
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: Thank you, Governor.
Thank you, Cabinet members.
By way of background, I'm a Florida lawyer, a
reinsurance and insurance lawyer. I'm an expert
witness. I testify throughout the United States as
an expert witness in those areas. I'm a
reinsurance arbitrator. I'm a former commissioner
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
281
of insurance, former general counsel to the
American Academy of Actuaries, and former chief
executive officer of a major property casualty
company based in Florida doing business throughout
the United States. I have a degree in mathematics.
Governor and Cabinet members, I believe that I
would be prepared on day one to implement the best
public policy as it relates to insurance in this
state. My philosophy is aligned with that of the
Cabinet. I know insurance. I know all lines of
insurance, and I know them in depth and in detail.
I know insurance regulation. I know Florida; I
know Florida's politics.
I've been an elected official in this state
since the year 2002. I know Florida consumers. I
know significant executive leadership; I have
experience leading; I'm unafraid, I'm unafraid to
lead. I'm unafraid, consistent with the discussion
previously, to take the heat. I have been in hot,
politically charged environments a good share of my
career, whether it is in the Legislature where I am
in the most purple of districts; whether it has
been as CEO of an insurance company that
intersected with 40 states; whether it was in
previous regulatory positions.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
282
Cabinet, Governor, I'm a team player. I'm
open; I'm accessible; I'm reasonable; I'm
responsible. I believe that under the guidance and
the tutelage of this Cabinet, I can move OIR
forward; I can move Florida's insurance markets
forward. And with that and with the fact that I
know Florida's consumers, I represent now 200,000
of them, I believe I could do an effective job and
continue along the line of public service.
That is my answer to your question.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So, Representative, right now
you don't manage a significant number of people but
you have in the past. Tell me, how big has your
team been and what's your style? How do you do it?
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: In terms of management,
I've managed entities ranging from 1,500 employees
with intense actuarial divisions, accounting
divisions, legal divisions. I've managed as
Commissioner of Insurance about a hundred people.
Right now I'm very happy to report I manage one
person and you're looking at that person. So that
is the scope of my management.
In terms of my style, my style is very
straightforward. In terms of personnel, I am
interested, Governor, in competent people, highly
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
283
competent people. I'm interested in individuals
who are loyal, would be loyal.
In terms of chief executive officer
leadership, I believe the position is to attract
resources, run interference, take responsibility,
and take the heat. So my management style is that
of openness, management by walking around. You
learn enormous things walking up to any desk in
your shop, sitting down and talking and listening
to the individual. I'm also an individual that
from a leadership standpoint I believe people can
believe in and follow.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Why would you want to do
this? What's -- you know, you've got a good life
in what you're doing now. Why would you want to do
this?
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: You know, Governor,
like many people that serve, like each of the four
of you, you have profound options in the private
sector, every one of you, and yet you serve, I feel
exactly the same way.
I grew up in the corn fields of Iowa, a town
of 400 people, where there were no government
apparatuses. The people that led the 4H were
people that volunteered. The people that ran the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
284
Fourth of July parade were people that volunteered.
On Memorial Day, my father marched and played the
Taps at the cemetery, so I come from an environment
where the way things get done is through public
service.
Along the way in life, when I could, I have
served. And I'm prepared now to serve, obviously
at the volition of the people I'm looking at.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: How do you see the role?
What do you see as the role of the
Insurance Commissioner?
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: I think the role of the
Insurance Commissioner needs to be one of
identifying challenges in the marketplace;
articulating what those challenges are, to the
extent being forewarned can deal with those
challenges, such as hurricanes; assuring there's
total preparedness communication with the
Legislature in terms of issues that deserve and
merit a legislative solution; dealing with this
Cabinet as it relates to guidance.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So you've had -- right now
you have success as a small business owner, and
you --
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: That's correct.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
285
GOVERNOR SCOTT: And you're working for
yourself.
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: That's correct.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: And you've had success as a
legislator and you have the reputation of being
extremely independent. So how would you transition
to go from that position now to a position where
you have four people that are constantly going to
give you advice on how you can do your job better?
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: Well, in terms of the
independence, that's an accurate statement in terms
of thought. In terms of working collegially with
groups, with people, within an employment
environment, my reputation is, in fact, one of
cooperation, one of responding to direction, one of
responding to oversight.
I was chief executive officer of a major
company that I've referenced. I had 15 board
members, all of whom themselves were CEOs of very
large companies. So I'm amenable to direction and
have shown it, shown it in any number of
capacities.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Attorney General.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Thank you.
Bill, frankly, I was looking at your
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
286
application, and I had no idea of your vast
history, an insurance commissioner in Iowa, that's
great. You have a great background.
I'm going to ask you the same questions. I
think you're probably aware of my role in the
Affordable Healthcare Act and the Navigators and my
concern with that. As healthcare -- as the
marketplace in our healthcare system gets even more
complex, what would you do to ensure that our
consumers are protected?
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: Well, let's just take
the Navigator issue. You're looking at an
individual that's voted for doing background checks
on Navigators for all of the reasons that this
Cabinet is aware of; and that is, some of these
individuals have unleashed unprofessional behavior
on potential enrollees, so I was one of the
sponsors in background on it.
Another issue, General Bondi, that I see
arising is with Obama Care, there's been an
expansion of individuals to whom coverage is
available. Part of the challenges though is
concurrently, concurrent with that, entities like
centers of excellence have been squeezed out of
that process. So when you look at the coverage
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
287
involved, just because of the pricing, you don't
see names like Sloan Kettering, you don't see names
like Mayo Clinic in Jacksonville.
And one of the things I would do as
Commissioner of Insurance is work diligently to get
that kind of care in front of our people on a daily
basis, on a regular basis. And when I say "in
front of our people," I'm talking about dealing
with insurers with respect to their offering.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Thank you.
And what would your plan be to ensure that our
seniors have affordable healthcare --
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: You know, the same --
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: -- long-term care and
affordable?
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: Okay. Excuse me.
Excuse me for interrupting you.
There are currently a number of good products
as it relates to long-term care. The challenge,
frankly, in long-term is that of pricing.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Exactly.
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: And the actuarial
science is pretty simple: People are living
significantly longer on the back end of life, if
you will, than in previous years. The longevity
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
288
has jumped significantly in the last 20 years. So
getting pricing on this stuff -- by "this stuff," I
mean the long-term care policy -- is, in fact, a
big challenge.
I would work -- for example, one of the things
I would like to see from a creative standpoint is
life insurance. There's no reason why we ought not
to be able to work with the industry to, as people
get older, see some kind of a conversion from the
cash value in life policies converted -- have the
flexibility to convert it into long-term care
policies, whether through a rider, et cetera.
So those would be some of the tools I'd be
willing to bring to the table immediately.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Thank you.
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: You're welcome.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Commissioner.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Representative, you said
in your opening comments that, quote, I can move
OIR forward, I can move the Florida insurance
markets forward. What does that mean? How and
what does that mean?
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: Here's what it means.
First of all, OIR is well positioned. It has
competent people. It has an outstanding mix of
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
289
skill sets, but nothing in our world that we deal
with is static. And as such, were I to be
appointed to that position, I would bring vigor to
that position, I would bring decisiveness to that
position. I'm unafraid, I'm unafraid in legal
arenas.
And I don't mean anything reckless by that. I
mean that I'm more than prepared to decide, I'm
more than prepared to assess issues. A good
example of that is the assignment of benefit
issues. I believe a very direct approach in terms
of moving OIR forward is changes in connection with
the homeowners forms, changes that limit the amount
of dollars that can be meted out before
communication with the insurer.
But those are things that can be dealt with
directly. I use that, Commissioner, as an
anecdotal example of the kind of things that can be
done.
The second part of your question is moving the
markets forward. We have vibrant markets now, but
we need to be ever vigilant. We need to continue
constantly to have into perpetuity a sign out, and
that sign needs to read: Florida, Florida's
insurance markets, Florida is open for business.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
290
And we encourage insurers to examine the state as a
place to do business.
I used to sit in rooms when insurance
companies made decisions about their allocation of
capital, and they have a spreadsheet. And on that
spreadsheet are variables, and those variables are:
Quality of regulation, quality of the legislature,
overall political environment, profitability.
Those are all issues that on a daily basis are
determined.
In terms of moving Florida's markets forward,
in direct answer to your question, I'll do
everything that I can do within that position,
within the tutelage of this Cabinet, to assure that
the marketplace understands that we want insurers
here.
And there's a caveat to that; and that is, we
want insurers who show solvency and meet all of our
requirements, but we want them here because we
understand free markets, capital markets, which is
vigorous competition, delivers the most products at
the best price.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Where does Florida score
poorly in the analysis that you just used as an
example that companies go through?
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
291
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: In the past, there has
been some reservation for Florida in terms of its
politics. And I'm thinking about prior
administrations, frankly, and there is no question
that insurers, as they made capital decisions in
that time, in that environment, took into account
what they believed to be a less-than-constructive
environment.
From my part, to the extent I could, to the
extent I would be moved into this position, I would
deliver from the regulatory standpoint the
unequivocal message that we're open for business.
And let me stop there and be responsive.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Well, tell me the --
you've been a regulator, I mean that's a really
intriguing qualification, having done this in
another state, a very different state, so what
lessons carry over easiest from having done this in
Iowa, and what are the things that just don't
really transfer at all?
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: You know, the insurance
codes of the various states overlap at a rate of
about 95% simply because insurance is conducted
across state lines, so a lot of comparability.
In terms of lessons learned, I learned these
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
292
lessons as a regulator, some of them through my
mistakes, some of them through hard work: One,
once an insurance company starts to teeter in the
direction of insolvency, if, in fact, it shows that
insolvency is likely, move rapidly. If you do not
move rapidly, the negative net worth of the company
and the harm that can be visited on consumers is
mind-bending, so I would say that.
The other is be proactive. And when I say
"proactive," there are all kinds of tools available
to the Commissioner of Insurance with respect to
protecting consumers. And those tools have names,
they're called the Unfair Claims Practices Act;
they're called Market Regulation of Insurers, going
into the bowels of insurance companies to assure,
based on audit, that they're performing as they
should, that they're paying claims as they should.
So those are a couple of vehicles, tools, lessons
learned, if you will.
The other -- I guess the third is, you've
heard me say it three times now, but be unafraid,
be proactive in terms of action. It's not a
position for one to stand by and watch the world go
by because, in fact, there are bad actors, not
many, but the whole reason for affirmative
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
293
regulation is, in fact, there are actors,
sometimes, who do not meet their obligations.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: And finally, let me give
you the opportunity to comment, just as the other
applicant had. As you know, this job brings a lot
of heat and a lot of light, and you've got to --
you know, it is a very difficult position to be in,
in addition to the normal responsibilities of
reporting to the Cabinet the nature of the business
in a state like Florida.
And so each of you should be given the
opportunity to respond to the criticism that has
been leveled at you in the media in the run-up to
your interview here today.
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: Well, the criticism
that I saw was that I participate in the insurance
marketplace, and that was essentially it; that I do
business in the insurance market place, which as
you read the statutory requirements, actually is
one of the statutory requirements to qualify for
the job. So that's my response, nothing more
complicated than that.
COMMISSIONER PUTNAM: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: CFO.
CFO ATWATER: Thank you, Governor.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
294
Representative, you've touched on it a couple
of times, but I'd like to go ahead and come at it
again; and that is, this balancing act. Your
responsibilities, as you mentioned, to be sure that
we're ever vigilant, that nothing is never set in
place and set in perfect motion; and that is,
creating the opportunity for this market to be an
attractive market for people to bring capital and
deploy capital, as well as 20 million individuals
that are wanting to be sure that someone is looking
out for them.
How do you manage that balancing act? How do
you see the balancing act.
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: First of all, the two
functions you're talking about are not mutually
exclusive, they're not inconsistent. One can have
concurrently, at the same time, both a vigorous
market, an optimum market, a maximum market; while
concurrently, from a regulatory standpoint,
bringing all of the tools to bear on errant
behavior and assuring that insurers, as they go
about their business, are, in fact, toeing the
line.
Insurance is the only product sold in the U.S.
market in which the vendor, namely the insurance
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
295
company, gets the money from the consumer, called
the policyholder, before delivering the product;
and the product is paying the claim. And all kinds
of mischief can happen in that process.
So I'm confident of my abilities to
concurrently attract the most vigorous market but
concurrently function in a proactive way in terms
of protecting consumer rights. I'd cite along
those lines the Unclaimed Property Bill that I was
the sponsor of and moved through the House. And
thanks, CFO, for your work on that and to OIR.
That bill assures that a half billion dollars
of life benefits are paid to our consumers, and
another quarter billion, at least, will be paid on
a go-forward basis. So I'm very comfortable
walking that fine line, and walking that fine line
does not require inconsistent behavior.
CFO ATWATER: You're familiar with personal
injury protection?
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: I am.
CFO ATWATER: So we worked hard. That whole
initiative was about the consumer, that and runaway
costs that were occurring, all being backed,
embedded into the next rate increase to be sure
that they were getting and handling the loss costs
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
296
that those insurers were putting -- tolerating,
accepting with doing business; and after all that,
very little change for the consumer.
The key is, and it was mentioned earlier, we
did arrest 40% increases two years in a row prior.
We certainly had anticipated that all of that
effort would extract certain costs that, again, I
want to say that the consumer would have looked at
as a benefit that would have -- we anticipated
greater relief to the consumer.
Is PIP worth trying to fix again, or is it
time the consumer gets an opportunity to look at
something different?
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: I co-sponsored the 2013
bill that put in fixes in PIP. I want to
compliment your team for continuing to ferret out
fraud in the area of PIP.
I filed this year a bill to junk PIP. I
believe that its time has come and gone. I think
we need to look at better patterns. Forty-five
other states have mandatory bodily injury property
damage coverage. I think that's a more appropriate
approach. There's pretty strong data to support
that, so that would be a direction worthy of
consideration, obviously as consistent with the
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
297
appetite of the Legislature.
CFO ATWATER: Representative, we are
constantly working on the issues that are in front
of us, PIP as being one of those, life insurance
was one of those. We've talked earlier today in
this Cabinet meeting about reinsurance and the
Cat Fund.
Is there something that's not on the radar
screen that you've looked at, thought about,
wondered about, that maybe it should start moving
up on the agenda so it doesn't catch us by
surprise?
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: We've discussed many of
the issues. Obviously homeowners, continuing to
assure that market is vigorous, and getting ready
for Katrina 2. Katrina 2 is coming, we just don't
know the day. Nobody has called us up and given us
the date, so we need to be prepared. We need to
make sure that we're girded both in terms of our
insurers we regulate, OIR, and et cetera, so I
would cite that.
My position on Citizens, continuing to walk
down the size of Citizens is well known. I think
we need to continue to walk down the Cat Fund,
consistent with Executive Director Williams'
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
298
comments to you earlier in the day.
Those are -- issues in the workers'
compensation area, we've got three decisions
forthcoming from the Supreme Court of Florida, and
if those go the wrong way, any one of those, those
will be an immediate tax on workers' compensation
insurance. Workers' compensation rates are down
50% from 2003, thanks in part to your work in the
Legislature at that time. So we need to be
prepared immediately if there are challenges
relating to workers' comp.
Medical malpractice, there's also an item up
before the Florida Supreme Court as well in
connection with our caps.
CFO ATWATER: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: All right. Thank you.
REPRESENTATIVE HAGER: Thank you.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: So does anybody have any
thoughts?
CFO ATWATER: Well, Governor, I would say,
once again, we've had two very professional,
competent, very competent, talented people step
forward. And of that original application
grouping, I feel that this is some of the two most
talented insurance minds I've had a chance to be
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
299
around.
If -- there may be others who want to say
something. I'll try to be quicker on the draw this
time around, but out of courtesy, I'll hold off and
just make those comments for now.
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Well, this time you
two have to agree, so it's nice to be in
Switzerland for a few minutes and see if I think
the two of you come to consensus before -- I mean
I --
CFO ATWATER: Governor, might I?
I'd like to make a motion that the position of
the Commissioner of Insurance Regulation be
extended to Representative Bill Hager, with a
salary of $190,000.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: And so I won't second it. I
think what we ought to do is, because I don't think
we're going to come -- I'm not going to come to
agreement right now -- is we ought to open it up.
We've got another month, a little over a
month, open up the -- until we see if we get more
applications. Let's do it through maybe the middle
of April. I think our next meeting is -- let's
check with Kristin -- is April 26th and see if we
can come to agreement on the 26th.
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
300
Does that work for everybody?
ATTORNEY GENERAL BONDI: Sure.
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Okay. So we open up the
application through April 15th, and then we'll all
come back and have a discussion on the 26th.
CFO ATWATER: Governor, that would be open it
up for consideration for applicants to put their
name in the hat?
GOVERNOR SCOTT: Right. Yeah, see if we have
somebody new.
All right. That adjourns the meeting. Our
next meeting is April 26th in Tallahassee.
(WHEREUPON, THE MEETING WAS ADJOURNED).
* * * *
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
301
CERTIFICATE
STATE OF FLORIDA )COUNTY OF LEON )
I, NANCY S. METZKE, RPR, FPR, certify that Iwas authorized to and did stenographically report theforegoing proceedings and that the transcript is a trueand complete record of my stenographic notes.
DATED this 7th day of April, 2016.
_________________________
NANCY S. METZKE, RPR, FPRCourt Reporter
$
$1,200 [1] - 237:22
$15,000 [1] - 237:20
$150,000 [1] - 252:1
$190,000 [1] - 299:15
$200 [1] - 259:4
$600 [1] - 229:22
'
'80s [1] - 158:8
'90s [1] - 158:9
1
1 [4] - 117:2, 117:11,
168:7, 259:18
1,250 [2] - 158:20,
162:17
1,500 [2] - 259:3,
282:16
10 [5] - 125:16,
152:24, 153:15,
153:23
10% [1] - 265:22
100 [1] - 222:2
102 [1] - 214:17
103 [1] - 214:18
105 [1] - 214:19
11 [4] - 193:19,
194:11, 194:17,
194:23
110 [1] - 214:12
117 [1] - 115:16
11th [2] - 214:11,
257:9
12 [11] - 152:9,
153:16, 153:20,
157:12, 158:3,
194:23, 197:11,
198:19, 199:2,
200:10, 226:14
12,000 [1] - 160:6
12-year [1] - 156:16
120 [2] - 151:17,
182:17
12th [2] - 154:5,
261:8
13 [5] - 142:6, 142:9,
242:11, 269:7
130 [1] - 234:20
13th [1] - 117:12
14 [19] - 121:24,
134:24, 138:24,
139:3, 154:9, 165:5,
165:22, 168:8, 173:6,
173:16, 173:22,
174:4, 174:7, 174:12,
175:25, 177:24,
194:5, 194:12, 205:19
15 [5] - 197:11,
220:24, 222:21,
223:1, 285:18
15th [1] - 300:4
16 [3] - 135:11,
136:2, 257:14
187 [1] - 115:18
1920s [1] - 156:23
1960s [1] - 156:24
1970's [1] - 175:23
1971 [1] - 177:10
2
2 [6] - 114:7, 117:23,
229:22, 245:25,
297:16
20 [8] - 136:25,
150:16, 216:2, 216:3,
226:15, 270:4, 288:1,
294:9
20% [1] - 265:23
200 [1] - 264:12
200,000 [1] - 282:7
2000s [1] - 158:9
2002 [1] - 281:15
2003 [1] - 298:8
2004 [1] - 157:22
2007 [1] - 215:24
2008 [3] - 158:12,
159:8, 222:4
2013 [2] - 138:5,
296:14
2014 [1] - 117:12
2015 [2] - 142:6,
142:9
2016 [3] - 114:14,
187:12, 301:7
2017 [1] - 199:12
2018 [1] - 191:25
2040 [2] - 140:18,
140:20
215 [1] - 115:22
226 [1] - 115:23
234 [1] - 115:24
24 [2] - 210:13, 212:1
241 [1] - 115:25
25 [7] - 137:2,
140:18, 140:20,
141:4, 159:10,
160:11, 160:16
250 [1] - 155:8
258 [1] - 116:6
25th [2] - 214:11,
257:8
26th [4] - 299:24,
299:25, 300:5, 300:12
280 [1] - 116:7
29 [1] - 114:14
3
3 [1] - 118:2
30 [2] - 141:1, 271:17
300 [1] - 278:14
3093 [1] - 114:22
31 [1] - 226:20
32 [1] - 115:8
32315-3093 [1] -
114:23
35 [1] - 115:10
36 [1] - 190:10
365 [2] - 174:7,
177:25
373 [1] - 184:17
3rd [1] - 187:11
4
4 [1] - 156:17
40 [3] - 141:2, 144:2,
281:24
40% [1] - 296:5
400 [2] - 155:7,
283:23
403 [1] - 184:17
403.059 [1] - 123:13
403.412 [1] - 184:16
403.509 [1] - 123:13
435 [1] - 260:8
475 [1] - 237:5
48 [2] - 210:13, 212:1
4H [1] - 283:24
5
5 [3] - 115:4, 118:2,
156:17
5,100 [1] - 236:8
5.11 [1] - 139:4
50 [1] - 140:25
50% [1] - 298:8
52 [1] - 257:15
55 [1] - 257:10
59 [1] - 115:12
6
6,000 [1] - 174:12
60 [1] - 128:19
61 [1] - 128:19
62-17.211 [1] - 126:2
63 [4] - 125:2, 126:9,
151:5, 151:14
64 [4] - 126:9, 151:5,
151:14, 181:4
697-8314 [1] - 114:23
697-8715 [1] - 114:23
7
7 [1] - 146:2
7,000 [1] - 234:16
72 [1] - 129:10
74 [1] - 141:14
7th [1] - 301:7
8
80% [1] - 262:10
800-pound [1] -
272:18
85% [1] - 262:9
850 [2] - 114:23
9
9 [1] - 115:6
90 [2] - 159:6, 166:12
93 [1] - 115:14
94 [1] - 214:17
95% [2] - 264:14,
291:23
A
abilities [2] - 255:15,
295:5
ability [7] - 124:25,
151:15, 195:24,
217:11, 220:3, 225:8,
230:18
able [16] - 120:25,
127:15, 156:16,
195:6, 201:6, 215:13,
223:25, 226:7,
241:15, 254:12,
259:16, 274:11,
275:5, 278:10,
278:18, 288:8
absence [1] - 254:24
absolutely [8] -
121:13, 166:19,
183:18, 183:20,
201:3, 201:16, 205:2,
270:21
abuse [1] - 230:22
Academy [1] - 281:2
accelerates [1] -
154:25
accept [2] - 119:17,
239:6
accepted [3] -
126:18, 127:20,
181:22
accepting [1] - 296:2
access [1] - 263:7
accessible [1] -
282:2
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
1
accessing [1] -
263:10
accompanied [1] -
135:21
accomplish [2] -
197:12, 199:6
accomplished [3] -
227:8, 228:19, 280:8
accomplishing [1] -
204:2
accomplishments
[1] - 278:21
account [1] - 291:6
accountability [1] -
220:10
accountable [1] -
274:9
accounting [6] -
228:5, 228:21,
229:15, 232:18,
254:25, 282:17
accounts [1] - 231:3
accuracy [1] -
274:10
accurate [3] - 180:5,
235:11, 285:11
Accurint [1] - 230:19
achieve [5] - 200:10,
200:11, 239:18,
276:6, 276:7
achievement [1] -
278:17
achieving [1] - 250:8
ACI [29] - 123:15,
123:20, 124:1, 124:2,
124:20, 124:24,
125:7, 125:25,
126:19, 127:15,
127:17, 128:10,
128:12, 128:22,
129:1, 129:10,
129:11, 129:13,
129:16, 129:20,
130:14, 132:11,
143:12, 144:16,
154:21, 156:2, 175:9,
180:22, 182:3
aCI's [1] - 181:17
ACI's [13] - 127:2,
127:8, 127:19,
127:20, 128:9,
128:24, 129:15,
139:25, 142:13,
180:3, 180:7
acknowledge [2] -
125:4, 169:22
acquire [1] - 157:13
acquired [1] - 275:25
acre [1] - 160:12
Act [11] - 118:1,
123:24, 131:17,
151:18, 261:23,
262:2, 262:5, 262:7,
262:21, 286:6, 292:13
act [10] - 159:14,
221:3, 238:22,
269:23, 270:2, 271:5,
272:17, 294:3,
294:12, 294:13
acting [1] - 121:19
action [5] - 191:15,
199:18, 236:4, 292:22
actions [3] - 159:13,
159:22, 168:15
active [4] - 216:7,
216:9, 261:15, 267:12
actively [1] - 265:6
activities [6] -
157:12, 165:13,
169:23, 196:1, 205:1,
205:7
activity [1] - 166:12
actors [2] - 292:24,
293:1
acts [1] - 259:23
actual [3] - 165:8,
176:14, 265:24
actuarial [2] -
282:17, 287:22
actuaries [2] -
265:15, 265:17
Actuaries [1] - 281:2
ADAM [1] - 114:12
adamant [1] - 192:11
add [15] - 120:8,
134:24, 135:4, 135:5,
135:19, 138:24,
161:11, 162:14,
162:20, 176:23,
177:3, 184:11,
204:16, 205:3, 230:9
added [2] - 138:25,
182:1
adding [2] - 144:12,
178:9
addition [6] - 122:22,
154:9, 162:5, 175:25,
260:15, 293:8
additional [10] -
122:23, 150:21,
164:23, 168:24,
171:5, 172:16, 176:1,
202:15, 208:12,
208:14
address [9] - 125:4,
144:8, 158:5, 163:10,
181:9, 187:9, 209:6,
209:24, 219:15
addressed [1] -
123:3
addressing [2] -
123:20, 273:22
adds [2] - 181:23,
202:15
adequately [2] -
129:22, 159:19
adjacent [1] - 137:23
ADJOURNED) [1] -
300:13
adjourns [1] - 300:11
adjudication [1] -
193:13
administer [1] -
216:17
administration [4] -
192:1, 194:9, 263:25,
264:5
ADMINISTRATION
[2] - 115:9, 115:11
administrations [1] -
291:4
Administrative [30] -
119:16, 122:16,
122:17, 122:19,
124:4, 127:23,
129:21, 131:11,
131:23, 137:13,
138:14, 141:11,
142:4, 144:17,
145:18, 145:21,
146:3, 146:4, 146:23,
151:7, 151:18,
151:21, 159:15,
161:25, 178:11,
180:14, 181:1, 183:7,
184:9, 185:16
administrative [13] -
121:8, 122:12, 126:5,
142:19, 144:22,
150:16, 151:9, 153:1,
153:8, 153:9, 161:7,
184:6, 184:22
admittedly [1] -
155:11
adopt [7] - 131:25,
179:25, 182:19,
182:24, 182:25,
185:7, 210:2
adoption [4] -
118:25, 129:23,
180:19, 180:20
adopts [1] - 123:5
adult [1] - 201:6
adults [1] - 238:22
advance [1] - 224:16
advanced [1] -
137:10
advertised [2] -
214:11, 257:8
advice [3] - 171:3,
198:21, 285:9
advise [3] - 118:18,
120:23, 165:24
advised [6] - 146:24,
150:20, 155:5, 179:7,
179:9, 220:22
advisory [1] - 118:16
advocate [2] -
147:13, 273:16
Advocate [2] -
220:17, 220:21
AFFAIRS [1] - 115:5
Affairs [1] - 131:1
affect [2] - 123:8,
123:11
affected [1] - 125:23
affects [1] - 156:15
Affordable [6] -
261:23, 262:2, 262:5,
262:7, 262:21, 286:6
affordable [2] -
287:12, 287:15
afternoon [14] -
118:8, 118:9, 130:21,
130:22, 132:12,
132:13, 156:3, 156:4,
163:4, 163:5, 196:9,
210:15, 226:4, 234:3
ag [1] - 158:20
age [3] - 192:18,
194:13, 215:12
Agencies [1] -
126:16
agencies [7] -
131:14, 157:11,
224:23, 225:9,
226:19, 231:23,
231:25
Agency [5] - 218:23,
235:4, 235:9, 242:6,
245:7
agency [3] - 231:18,
241:21, 248:22
agency's [1] - 231:19
agenda [6] - 117:8,
117:10, 123:3, 186:8,
191:25, 297:11
agents [1] - 271:13
ago [6] - 193:3,
194:23, 210:25,
227:23, 269:7, 272:1
agree [25] - 125:7,
125:25, 128:13,
129:6, 131:5, 145:18,
146:12, 149:6, 154:1,
172:1, 182:6, 183:22,
183:24, 184:2, 185:1,
198:13, 203:13,
211:21, 271:9,
271:10, 271:11,
271:12, 271:13,
271:14, 299:7
agreed [10] - 122:22,
126:18, 168:12,
176:25, 188:24,
208:21, 211:15,
211:17, 211:22, 272:3
agreement [6] -
149:2, 168:16,
171:21, 176:6,
299:19, 299:25
agrees [2] - 119:19,
168:13
agriculture [2] -
138:9, 157:3
AGRICULTURE [1] -
114:12
ahead [5] - 130:6,
130:7, 228:1, 228:3,
294:2
Aides [2] - 214:14,
257:12
Aides' [1] - 132:18
aligned [1] - 281:9
ALJ [23] - 119:12,
120:15, 120:21,
121:8, 121:12,
123:21, 124:1,
124:11, 124:23,
125:2, 127:11,
128:22, 129:8,
129:11, 137:11,
144:5, 147:15, 148:8,
149:10, 178:17,
182:6, 182:16, 185:22
ALJ's [10] - 118:25,
119:16, 123:5, 128:1,
128:10, 128:19,
142:9, 143:23,
165:15, 185:8
allegation [1] -
275:20
allegations [2] -
142:13, 182:5
alleged [1] - 142:13
Allison [1] - 210:16
allocation [3] -
174:19, 178:3, 290:4
allow [4] - 143:14,
174:18, 205:12, 263:7
allowed [7] - 126:16,
174:15, 175:23,
176:5, 204:17,
228:17, 266:6
allows [1] - 265:20
almost [9] - 134:7,
147:1, 150:6, 195:1,
206:8, 227:16,
227:23, 229:21,
269:18
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
2
alone [6] - 159:12,
162:19, 189:24,
191:24, 245:25, 278:9
alternatives [1] -
177:18
ameliorative [1] -
155:10
amenable [1] -
285:20
amendment [1] -
181:3
amendments [1] -
185:10
America [1] - 268:23
American [2] -
268:23, 281:2
amount [5] - 136:7,
218:14, 222:16,
280:10, 289:13
analysis [2] - 272:5,
290:24
ancillary [3] - 121:2,
125:12, 181:14
AND [5] - 114:4,
115:20, 116:4, 214:2,
257:2
Andy [2] - 132:10,
132:15
anecdotal [1] -
289:18
ankle [1] - 190:17
annual [1] - 209:18
annually [1] - 209:24
answer [18] - 132:2,
156:9, 164:1, 171:8,
220:3, 239:8, 247:2,
247:4, 247:7, 249:6,
249:10, 250:21,
252:22, 253:13,
268:10, 282:10,
290:12
answered [2] -
156:7, 223:16
answers [2] - 224:5,
273:21
anti [1] - 255:2
anti-lawyer [1] -
255:2
anticipated [2] -
296:6, 296:9
anyhow [1] - 228:21
AO [1] - 160:15
apart [1] - 260:9
apparatuses [1] -
283:24
appeal [1] - 171:8
appealable [2] -
170:14, 170:16
appealed [1] -
170:19
appearing [1] -
157:19
appellate [1] - 171:9
appetite [1] - 297:1
APPLAUSE) [1] -
256:8
applicable [2] -
128:20, 131:14
applicant [2] -
268:15, 293:5
applicants [2] -
268:9, 300:7
application [11] -
119:24, 122:13,
122:16, 125:10,
126:5, 151:8, 151:13,
157:25, 286:1,
298:23, 300:4
applications [5] -
214:12, 214:13,
257:10, 299:22
applied [4] - 121:21,
214:20, 242:1, 256:11
applies [1] - 221:14
apply [7] - 168:1,
190:2, 190:18,
190:23, 221:13,
221:16, 221:22
applying [1] - 217:1
appoint [1] - 251:23
appointed [1] - 289:3
APPOINTMENT [4] -
115:20, 116:4, 214:2,
257:2
appointment [2] -
214:7, 257:6
appraisal [1] - 240:2
appraiser [2] -
230:15, 235:21
Appraiser [2] -
236:19, 236:21
appraiser's [1] -
234:20
Appraisers [1] -
223:18
appraisers [7] -
223:8, 223:21, 224:1,
230:12, 230:17,
235:6, 236:25
appraisers' [1] -
235:24
appreciate [10] -
164:4, 167:6, 168:4,
168:5, 169:7, 186:11,
200:5, 202:6, 215:9,
280:7
approach [8] - 233:1,
241:23, 242:24,
268:4, 273:14,
274:19, 289:11,
296:23
appropriate [6] -
141:21, 185:7, 197:6,
238:21, 269:19,
296:22
approval [9] -
122:21, 130:4,
131:24, 141:18,
152:2, 158:12,
163:13, 179:7, 179:23
approve [12] -
117:15, 118:12,
120:4, 120:5, 120:6,
131:12, 145:5,
151:23, 182:10
approved [11] -
121:21, 123:7,
129:13, 153:11,
154:21, 161:4, 173:8,
173:12, 180:1, 205:6,
262:3
approving [1] -
117:24
April [6] - 206:1,
299:23, 299:24,
300:4, 300:12, 301:7
Aquifer [1] - 133:6
aquifer [16] - 133:7,
133:8, 133:10,
134:18, 135:9, 136:2,
136:3, 136:6, 139:12,
157:22, 158:5,
159:11, 160:12,
161:14, 173:16, 175:4
arbitrator [1] -
280:25
area [7] - 127:7,
137:1, 164:6, 273:9,
273:10, 296:17, 298:3
areas [2] - 221:8,
280:24
arena [1] - 249:11
arenas [1] - 289:6
argue [2] - 129:1,
177:22
argued [4] - 147:14,
153:11, 178:16,
243:17
argues [2] - 127:17,
128:24
argument [1] -
129:15
arising [1] - 286:20
arrangement [1] -
202:19
arrest [18] - 190:10,
198:19, 199:17,
200:10, 201:1,
202:15, 204:7, 204:9,
204:16, 204:25,
206:9, 206:10,
206:15, 206:18,
207:25, 208:12,
208:15, 296:5
arrested [1] - 206:6
arrests [1] - 190:11
articulating [1] -
284:15
aspect [2] - 184:8,
268:22
aspects [1] - 263:3
aspirational [1] -
272:9
assess [3] - 219:2,
266:8, 289:9
assignment [1] -
289:10
assistance [3] -
147:3, 231:8, 231:21
associated [1] -
163:15
Association [3] -
222:24, 223:18,
223:22
associations [1] -
230:5
assume [4] - 130:14,
145:20, 162:3, 170:1
assuming [1] - 205:6
assure [3] - 290:14,
292:15, 297:15
assures [1] - 295:12
assuring [2] -
284:17, 294:21
Atlantic [5] - 123:1,
123:21, 132:16,
156:12, 157:1
atmosphere [1] -
261:14
atop [1] - 133:6
attack [1] - 144:19
attempt [1] - 265:12
attempting [1] -
157:20
Attorney [15] -
130:12, 147:7, 150:1,
171:15, 176:22,
194:2, 207:22,
215:10, 222:11,
236:17, 241:9, 244:8,
244:21, 261:19,
285:23
attorney [9] - 132:15,
164:5, 166:4, 167:17,
171:9, 175:9, 177:1,
188:1, 244:2
ATTORNEY [134] -
114:10, 117:18,
120:8, 121:9, 130:13,
145:15, 147:9,
147:12, 147:17,
147:20, 147:24,
148:2, 148:22,
148:25, 149:4,
149:14, 149:18,
154:4, 161:23, 162:3,
162:7, 162:21,
164:16, 164:20,
171:17, 173:1,
176:24, 177:5,
178:15, 178:21,
178:24, 179:2, 179:4,
179:9, 179:18, 183:3,
183:9, 183:11,
183:16, 183:19,
183:21, 184:1,
185:11, 185:20,
186:2, 186:12, 188:7,
188:11, 188:15,
190:14, 191:17,
191:20, 194:3,
195:21, 198:6, 199:7,
200:20, 201:3, 201:5,
201:9, 201:17,
202:21, 203:9,
203:22, 204:3, 204:6,
204:14, 204:20,
204:23, 205:2, 205:8,
206:3, 206:5, 206:11,
206:20, 206:24,
207:9, 208:7, 208:11,
208:20, 210:10,
210:16, 210:22,
211:1, 211:5, 211:18,
212:4, 212:7, 212:16,
212:20, 213:11,
213:13, 222:12,
222:15, 222:23,
223:15, 228:1, 228:4,
228:11, 228:22,
229:2, 231:2, 236:18,
237:9, 238:3, 243:7,
243:20, 244:9,
245:13, 246:12,
252:2, 252:6, 252:15,
253:7, 253:12,
253:18, 255:2, 255:5,
255:7, 261:20,
262:17, 262:20,
262:24, 263:13,
275:10, 275:13,
277:1, 285:24,
287:10, 287:14,
287:21, 288:15,
299:6, 300:2
attorneys [4] -
176:14, 183:22,
187:15, 245:19
attract [2] - 283:4,
295:6
attractive [1] - 294:8
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
3
Atwater [2] - 215:11,
241:9
ATWATER [42] -
114:11, 164:3,
164:13, 164:21,
166:2, 166:4, 166:20,
167:6, 167:8, 167:11,
167:14, 169:4,
169:22, 170:4, 170:7,
170:9, 171:14, 200:3,
200:5, 202:1, 208:21,
224:10, 232:6,
239:11, 250:3, 250:7,
251:15, 252:11,
252:16, 255:19,
255:23, 269:16,
271:22, 273:15,
293:25, 295:18,
295:21, 297:2,
298:15, 298:20,
299:11, 300:6
Atwater's [1] -
223:25
audit [4] - 221:23,
237:13, 237:15,
292:16
auditing [1] - 227:5
authorities [2] -
205:12, 209:25
authority [3] -
118:12, 142:10,
161:11
authorization [1] -
121:24
authorize [2] -
123:15, 165:10
authorized [3] -
118:22, 141:23, 301:5
auto [2] - 271:23,
273:5
automatically [1] -
204:9
available [6] - 130:5,
189:4, 213:5, 221:11,
286:22, 292:10
awake [1] - 231:5
aware [4] - 221:12,
263:21, 286:5, 286:15
B
backbone [1] - 233:3
backed [1] - 295:23
background [21] -
122:4, 132:22,
136:25, 215:18,
216:12, 235:17,
235:18, 241:6,
241:20, 243:16,
246:9, 254:12,
254:25, 263:17,
269:11, 273:19,
278:6, 280:21, 286:3,
286:13, 286:18
backgrounds [1] -
256:14
bad [1] - 292:24
bake [2] - 271:19,
271:20
balance [6] - 221:24,
229:18, 229:20,
270:12, 270:18,
270:19
balancing [7] -
269:23, 270:2, 271:5,
272:17, 294:3,
294:12, 294:13
balloon [2] - 139:20
bar [1] - 201:7
barriers [1] - 225:8
base [3] - 223:7,
275:6, 276:3
based [19] - 121:1,
121:6, 125:3, 131:6,
161:3, 161:5, 196:20,
196:21, 197:3, 197:9,
198:22, 226:11,
265:24, 266:6, 267:7,
268:5, 276:9, 281:4,
292:16
basic [1] - 229:1
basis [7] - 139:8,
242:22, 260:3, 287:7,
290:9, 295:15
Bay [5] - 133:15,
133:16, 134:18,
157:22, 161:18
beach [2] - 157:2,
157:4
beach-compatible
[2] - 157:2, 157:4
bear [2] - 144:2,
294:20
became [1] - 258:15
become [1] - 262:6
becomes [3] - 159:3,
268:1, 271:4
begin [3] - 202:18,
271:1, 272:10
behalf [5] - 121:19,
220:20, 221:1,
221:25, 242:7
behavior [4] -
197:21, 286:16,
294:21, 295:17
behind [2] - 173:15,
247:15
belief [1] - 208:5
believes [1] - 166:7
below [2] - 119:8,
133:19
bending [1] - 292:8
beneath [1] - 133:15
benefit [5] - 165:17,
165:18, 263:9,
289:10, 296:9
benefits [10] - 262:7,
262:10, 262:16,
263:8, 264:21,
265:18, 272:7, 272:8,
272:20, 295:13
best [11] - 188:18,
198:20, 226:22,
236:6, 240:14, 261:9,
261:17, 261:25,
270:4, 281:7, 290:22
better [15] - 140:7,
160:22, 169:13,
170:25, 171:11,
203:15, 218:4, 218:5,
227:14, 232:2,
251:12, 261:16,
275:2, 285:9, 296:20
between [4] -
123:19, 127:18,
173:25, 192:15
beyond [1] - 181:12
biased [1] - 121:2
BIEGALSKI [11] -
241:1, 241:8, 243:9,
243:23, 244:15,
245:23, 246:18,
248:23, 250:6,
250:13, 251:17
Biegalski [4] -
115:25, 214:19,
241:3, 251:24
big [11] - 155:11,
160:1, 160:2, 161:5,
228:24, 235:25,
261:12, 275:16,
282:13, 288:4
big-picture [1] -
228:24
bigger [1] - 275:6
biggest [1] - 198:4
BILL [1] - 280:1
bill [5] - 237:4,
285:25, 295:12,
296:15, 296:18
Bill [7] - 116:7,
221:9, 221:16,
257:16, 280:4, 295:9,
299:14
billion [6] - 139:4,
229:22, 236:5,
245:25, 295:12,
295:14
billion-dollar [1] -
236:5
binding [2] - 168:22,
168:24
biology [1] - 228:14
Biscayne [7] - 133:6,
133:15, 133:16,
134:18, 157:22,
161:18, 173:24
bit [13] - 119:2,
122:2, 123:18, 156:8,
168:2, 193:6, 244:23,
246:8, 250:19,
258:23, 258:25,
263:15, 275:18
blank [2] - 278:8,
278:18
blasted [2] - 134:3,
134:5
blessed [1] - 213:13
blood [1] - 266:24
board [2] - 259:23,
285:18
Board [38] - 117:8,
117:10, 117:12,
118:11, 118:17,
119:3, 121:19,
124:25, 126:11,
129:6, 141:11,
141:22, 141:23,
142:10, 142:16,
143:11, 143:25,
145:5, 150:19,
151:11, 155:5,
160:18, 161:10,
173:12, 178:12,
184:3, 185:4, 185:5,
186:7, 188:12, 191:5,
191:7, 191:12,
191:14, 195:12,
198:22, 208:4, 277:2
BOARD [6] - 115:9,
115:13, 115:16,
115:18, 117:4, 187:2
Board's [6] - 121:18,
126:10, 141:18,
185:14, 185:20, 187:8
boards [2] - 249:14,
249:16
bob [1] - 224:10
bodily [1] - 296:21
body [5] - 142:19,
150:14, 151:12,
153:11, 249:20
body's [1] - 147:2
BOND [1] - 115:7
BONDI [134] -
114:10, 117:18,
120:8, 121:9, 130:13,
145:15, 147:9,
147:12, 147:17,
147:20, 147:24,
148:2, 148:22,
148:25, 149:4,
149:14, 149:18,
154:4, 161:23, 162:3,
162:7, 162:21,
164:16, 164:20,
171:17, 173:1,
176:24, 177:5,
178:15, 178:21,
178:24, 179:2, 179:4,
179:9, 179:18, 183:3,
183:9, 183:11,
183:16, 183:19,
183:21, 184:1,
185:11, 185:20,
186:2, 186:12, 188:7,
188:11, 188:15,
190:14, 191:17,
191:20, 194:3,
195:21, 198:6, 199:7,
200:20, 201:3, 201:5,
201:9, 201:17,
202:21, 203:9,
203:22, 204:3, 204:6,
204:14, 204:20,
204:23, 205:2, 205:8,
206:3, 206:5, 206:11,
206:20, 206:24,
207:9, 208:7, 208:11,
208:20, 210:10,
210:16, 210:22,
211:1, 211:5, 211:18,
212:4, 212:7, 212:16,
212:20, 213:11,
213:13, 222:12,
222:15, 222:23,
223:15, 228:1, 228:4,
228:11, 228:22,
229:2, 231:2, 236:18,
237:9, 238:3, 243:7,
243:20, 244:9,
245:13, 246:12,
252:2, 252:6, 252:15,
253:7, 253:12,
253:18, 255:2, 255:5,
255:7, 261:20,
262:17, 262:20,
262:24, 263:13,
275:10, 275:13,
277:1, 285:24,
287:10, 287:14,
287:21, 288:15,
299:6, 300:2
Bondi [3] - 215:10,
241:9, 286:19
bone [1] - 169:2
bosses [1] - 176:18
bother [1] - 227:6
bottleneck [1] -
220:13
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
4
bottom [5] - 134:21,
135:1, 136:4, 136:5,
192:8
bound [4] - 148:7,
155:16, 172:1, 172:6
boundaries [1] -
168:20
bowels [1] - 292:15
Bowman [16] -
132:10, 132:15,
144:24, 147:10,
149:2, 149:5, 149:19,
149:22, 152:5,
155:20, 162:12,
176:25, 177:3,
178:16, 183:21,
186:12
BOWMAN [35] -
132:13, 145:1, 145:3,
145:19, 145:22,
146:1, 146:11,
147:11, 147:16,
147:19, 147:23,
149:3, 149:21,
149:25, 152:10,
152:13, 152:20,
152:25, 154:6,
154:23, 155:1, 155:7,
155:15, 155:21,
155:24, 177:4, 177:7,
178:19, 178:22,
179:1, 179:3, 179:5,
183:24, 184:2, 186:10
box [2] - 167:12,
167:17
BOX [1] - 114:22
boy [2] - 202:8,
205:17
brackish [1] - 131:8
Bragg [3] - 116:6,
257:15, 258:5
BRAGG [27] - 258:2,
258:6, 258:10, 259:1,
259:20, 260:8, 261:5,
261:25, 262:19,
262:22, 263:2,
263:21, 264:24,
265:3, 266:12,
267:14, 268:22,
270:6, 272:17,
274:13, 275:19,
277:5, 277:8, 277:11,
277:14, 277:17, 278:1
break [2] - 195:21,
225:8
Breakspear [1] -
115:4
brief [3] - 131:4,
132:22, 163:6
briefly [4] - 119:22,
126:14, 177:7, 223:15
brine [4] - 135:14,
135:16, 135:17,
135:19
bring [25] - 157:20,
159:13, 167:2,
168:19, 178:10,
205:16, 206:1,
217:10, 220:14,
221:7, 221:19, 222:1,
222:7, 225:1, 233:1,
239:19, 243:5,
261:11, 266:25,
267:8, 271:19,
288:14, 289:3, 289:4,
294:8
bringing [1] - 294:20
brings [1] - 293:5
broader [1] - 246:10
broken [1] - 244:25
brought [3] - 218:3,
237:2, 256:14
Broward [2] - 157:5,
245:15
brusque [1] - 237:15
bucket [3] - 135:14,
135:15, 135:18
budget [5] - 222:3,
222:8, 235:23, 236:5,
238:14
Budget [1] - 216:1
build [1] - 260:17
building [3] - 259:6,
260:14, 267:9
built [2] - 177:8,
239:12
bulges [1] - 139:20
bullet [1] - 144:15
burden [9] - 128:23,
129:16, 129:18,
146:7, 146:11,
146:13, 146:15,
150:18, 193:7
bureaucracy [1] -
236:6
bury [1] - 247:15
business [34] -
138:10, 156:24,
156:25, 157:2, 157:3,
157:4, 157:15, 158:6,
161:16, 213:6, 218:6,
221:4, 221:20, 227:6,
237:18, 238:1,
239:12, 265:7, 268:1,
268:23, 274:25,
275:16, 276:16,
276:23, 281:4,
284:23, 289:25,
290:2, 291:12, 293:9,
293:18, 294:22, 296:2
businesses [4] -
217:16, 221:2,
241:16, 242:14
businessmen [1] -
269:13
buzz [1] - 240:12
BY [1] - 114:18
C
Cabinet [26] - 118:9,
120:9, 121:11,
132:14, 132:18,
151:2, 156:5, 163:6,
214:14, 218:24,
225:22, 229:6,
257:12, 259:23,
259:24, 270:15,
280:20, 281:6,
281:10, 282:1, 282:4,
284:21, 286:15,
290:14, 293:9, 297:6
CABINET [3] - 114:4,
114:10, 114:15
calculated [1] -
181:21
caliber [1] - 144:15
Canal [4] - 131:8,
156:21, 156:22,
157:18
canal [47] - 122:1,
122:8, 125:6, 127:4,
132:24, 132:25,
133:9, 133:12,
133:14, 133:16,
133:25, 134:4, 134:6,
134:17, 134:21,
135:2, 135:3, 135:7,
135:10, 137:14,
137:15, 138:1,
138:15, 139:7, 139:9,
139:14, 139:18,
139:22, 140:4, 142:1,
143:9, 143:14,
143:20, 143:23,
144:7, 153:15,
154:10, 154:11,
158:2, 158:9, 158:16,
159:12, 163:15,
174:25, 175:7, 177:8
canals [1] - 153:24
candidacy [1] -
256:5
candidate [2] -
252:20, 252:23
candidates [10] -
214:15, 214:16,
214:21, 254:13,
254:15, 255:13,
255:24, 256:16,
257:13, 257:14
candnreporters.
com [1] - 114:24
cannot [12] - 119:11,
119:15, 119:18,
120:17, 127:21,
127:22, 160:23,
162:14, 167:4, 176:9,
181:11, 260:12
Cantor [2] - 160:17,
161:25
Cantor's [2] - 161:5,
172:18
capable [1] - 212:21
capacities [3] -
223:21, 239:14,
285:22
capacity [4] - 118:10,
119:6, 167:15, 254:18
capital [5] - 290:5,
290:20, 291:5, 294:8,
294:9
capitalist [1] -
269:25
CAPITOL [1] -
114:16
caps [1] - 298:14
card [1] - 248:10
Care [5] - 261:23,
262:2, 262:5, 262:7,
286:20
care [13] - 166:17,
172:5, 200:18,
241:14, 248:12,
248:13, 270:5,
274:10, 287:6,
287:14, 287:19,
288:3, 288:11
career [7] - 195:16,
239:12, 241:17,
243:3, 243:12,
273:19, 281:21
CARLOS [2] -
115:18, 187:3
Carlos [1] - 187:10
carried [2] - 243:11,
260:4
carriers [1] - 271:13
carries [2] - 117:22,
186:6
carry [2] - 259:25,
291:18
carrying [1] - 135:12
case [25] - 118:21,
122:10, 125:16,
125:18, 125:19,
126:19, 127:21,
129:18, 130:24,
131:7, 142:5, 142:7,
142:19, 143:3, 143:4,
146:11, 153:8,
187:22, 189:9, 192:5,
197:4, 197:19, 199:1,
207:3
cases [6] - 136:24,
142:22, 150:16,
153:12, 198:25, 260:3
cash [1] - 288:10
castor [1] - 157:3
casualty [1] - 281:3
Cat [2] - 297:7,
297:24
catch [1] - 297:11
caused [3] - 141:24,
144:9, 144:10
causing [4] - 157:21,
160:3, 160:19, 220:12
caution [1] - 171:1
caveat [1] - 290:17
CC [3] - 202:25,
203:17, 203:23
CCS [3] - 125:5,
160:3, 160:16
cell [1] - 198:8
cemetery [1] - 284:3
center [1] - 210:12
centers [1] - 286:24
centric [1] - 242:23
CEO [1] - 281:23
CEOs [1] - 285:19
certain [11] - 184:20,
184:24, 195:13,
217:22, 220:18,
244:21, 262:8, 270:7,
272:8, 274:25, 296:7
certainly [7] -
220:13, 227:19,
231:12, 244:3, 246:6,
252:19, 296:6
certainty [1] - 220:4
CERTIFICATE [1] -
301:1
certification [5] -
118:23, 125:4,
141:17, 141:24,
168:11
certifications [1] -
118:1
certified [2] - 142:11,
143:16
certify [1] - 301:5
cetera [2] - 288:12,
297:20
CFO [60] - 164:2,
164:3, 164:13,
164:21, 166:2, 166:4,
166:20, 167:6, 167:7,
167:8, 167:11,
167:14, 168:4, 169:4,
169:22, 170:4, 170:7,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
5
170:9, 171:14,
171:17, 172:14,
200:3, 200:5, 201:25,
202:1, 208:21,
215:11, 223:25,
224:9, 224:10, 232:5,
232:6, 239:10,
239:11, 241:9,
246:13, 250:2, 250:3,
250:7, 251:15,
252:11, 252:16,
255:19, 255:22,
255:23, 263:14,
269:15, 269:16,
271:22, 273:15,
293:24, 293:25,
295:11, 295:18,
295:21, 297:2,
298:15, 298:20,
299:11, 300:6
chair [1] - 270:15
Chairman [2] -
187:17, 197:3
challenge [5] -
260:11, 260:12,
267:15, 287:19, 288:4
challenged [4] -
121:17, 122:14,
143:12, 217:9
challenger [1] -
146:12
challenger's [1] -
147:4
challenges [7] -
231:20, 250:17,
284:14, 284:15,
284:17, 286:22,
298:10
chance [3] - 199:25,
278:3, 298:25
change [15] - 119:16,
135:22, 135:23,
143:13, 143:18,
144:6, 151:4, 180:24,
182:18, 216:16,
217:12, 235:2, 267:5,
296:3
changed [6] - 143:8,
143:24, 227:1,
227:18, 227:22, 228:9
changes [6] -
124:19, 209:24,
226:10, 267:6,
289:12, 289:13
changing [3] -
151:19, 152:2, 154:10
chaperone [1] -
196:19
chapter [2] - 278:5,
278:7
Chapter [3] - 151:17,
184:17, 237:5
characteristic [1] -
269:1
charge [1] - 250:16
charged [1] - 281:20
chase [1] - 145:4
check [2] - 221:3,
299:24
checks [1] - 286:13
CHIEF [1] - 114:11
Chief [4] - 217:20,
218:2, 223:24, 224:22
chief [4] - 259:21,
281:2, 283:3, 285:17
child [8] - 192:17,
230:7, 231:11,
242:20, 242:21,
244:19, 245:5, 245:17
chloride [1] - 159:1
choice [5] - 169:12,
192:13, 192:15,
270:1, 274:2
choices [2] - 252:5,
252:7
chore [1] - 266:22
chose [1] - 150:4
chunk [1] - 235:25
church [4] - 200:22,
200:24, 201:14,
206:16
circulated [1] - 211:8
circulating [1] -
212:2
cite [2] - 295:8,
297:21
cited [1] - 142:23
Cities [1] - 222:18
citing [1] - 142:18
citizen [2] - 157:14,
157:16
Citizens [2] - 297:22,
297:23
citrus [1] - 174:8
City [4] - 137:8,
234:15, 234:16, 236:4
Civil [5] - 123:1,
123:21, 132:16,
156:12, 157:1
claim [1] - 295:3
claims [5] - 264:7,
274:9, 274:16,
278:14, 292:17
Claims [1] - 292:13
clarification [4] -
130:1, 173:21,
175:15, 180:4
CLARIFICATION [2]
- 115:18, 187:2
clarify [3] - 178:15,
189:11, 209:13
clarity [6] - 221:10,
241:25, 242:16,
245:1, 247:12, 251:6
Clark [2] - 115:14,
115:16
CLARK [10] - 117:9,
117:23, 130:18,
132:10, 156:1, 163:2,
172:22, 179:11,
179:22, 186:7
clause [1] - 205:5
clear [12] - 120:18,
125:7, 127:22,
163:11, 163:23,
165:2, 165:7, 170:22,
177:17, 209:2, 245:3,
247:1
CLEAR [1] - 230:20
clearances [1] -
269:9
clearly [4] - 124:3,
175:22, 197:10,
273:17
clemency [1] -
197:15
Clemency [14] -
187:11, 188:12,
190:1, 191:5, 191:7,
191:12, 191:14,
191:18, 191:25,
195:11, 198:15,
198:25, 204:12, 208:4
CLEMENCY [2] -
115:18, 187:2
clerk [1] - 223:8
client [3] - 138:7,
147:13, 184:5
client's [2] - 138:6,
145:8
Clinic [1] - 287:3
clock [1] - 221:3
close [5] - 198:16,
200:19, 213:5,
227:16, 242:10
closed [1] - 237:17
closely [2] - 159:13,
262:12
closer [1] - 200:7
closest [2] - 204:11,
208:4
co [1] - 296:14
co-sponsored [1] -
296:14
cocaine [4] - 193:13,
193:14, 194:16, 195:1
code [1] - 197:1
codes [1] - 291:22
collect [1] - 245:24
collected [1] -
245:24
collectors [1] - 223:9
college [1] - 228:9
collegially [1] -
285:12
combine [1] - 126:21
comfortable [3] -
217:8, 255:14, 295:15
coming [5] - 128:4,
173:22, 254:15,
255:12, 297:16
comment [2] - 121:1,
293:4
comments [8] -
117:19, 186:3, 229:5,
251:21, 252:12,
288:19, 298:1, 299:5
Commerce [1] -
271:9
Commission [5] -
187:6, 187:13,
187:21, 201:20,
212:11
COMMISSION [1] -
115:11
COMMISSIONER
[129] - 114:12, 116:5,
117:15, 152:7,
152:11, 152:14,
152:21, 154:1, 154:5,
154:20, 154:24,
155:6, 155:9, 155:18,
173:3, 173:5, 173:8,
173:15, 173:18,
174:1, 174:3, 174:6,
174:11, 174:15,
174:21, 174:23,
175:2, 175:7, 175:22,
176:3, 176:21, 181:2,
181:17, 182:23,
183:1, 183:10, 185:6,
185:18, 185:25,
192:15, 196:1,
196:22, 197:3, 197:8,
198:2, 198:20, 199:8,
199:10, 199:11,
199:13, 199:21,
199:23, 200:2,
200:12, 201:2, 201:4,
201:8, 201:16,
201:19, 203:19,
204:1, 204:13,
204:19, 204:22,
204:25, 205:3, 205:9,
205:14, 205:22,
206:10, 206:13,
206:22, 207:8,
207:11, 207:15,
207:18, 207:20,
207:21, 208:10,
208:22, 209:1, 209:8,
209:9, 209:21, 210:1,
210:7, 210:14,
210:20, 210:24,
211:2, 211:12,
211:16, 211:21,
212:14, 212:18,
212:21, 212:24,
213:3, 218:22,
222:14, 228:3, 229:4,
230:24, 232:4, 238:5,
238:8, 239:9, 246:14,
248:15, 250:1,
253:11, 254:14,
255:4, 255:6, 255:9,
255:21, 257:3,
263:15, 266:8,
267:10, 268:8,
269:14, 277:21,
278:23, 288:18,
290:23, 291:14,
293:3, 293:23
commissioner [8] -
213:1, 218:21, 229:3,
246:13, 277:20,
280:25, 286:2, 288:17
Commissioner [38] -
115:4, 152:6, 164:4,
173:4, 192:10,
192:14, 194:4,
195:23, 200:21,
201:10, 202:2,
203:14, 204:18,
206:21, 210:10,
211:19, 212:9,
212:11, 215:11,
222:13, 228:2,
230:23, 238:4,
241:10, 243:21,
247:20, 253:9, 257:6,
259:19, 263:14,
275:13, 282:19,
284:11, 284:13,
287:5, 289:17,
292:11, 299:13
Commissioner's [1]
- 259:20
commitment [2] -
229:24, 270:7
commitments [1] -
168:21
committed [1] -
163:24
committing [1] -
193:12
common [4] - 219:7,
231:22, 231:23
communicate [1] -
223:12
communicated [1] -
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
6
224:7
communicating [1] -
245:10
communication [11]
- 241:25, 242:17,
245:1, 245:3, 247:12,
247:22, 247:23,
248:1, 251:6, 284:18,
289:15
community [8] -
192:24, 197:5, 199:2,
200:23, 203:2,
203:16, 203:20, 218:6
commutation [6] -
187:9, 188:24,
189:14, 189:24,
190:21, 191:24
Commutation [1] -
210:6
COMMUTATION [2] -
115:18, 187:3
comp [2] - 273:9,
298:11
companies [15] -
261:11, 264:12,
267:11, 267:17,
267:23, 267:24,
268:5, 268:6, 268:25,
275:4, 278:12,
285:20, 290:4,
290:25, 292:15
company [9] -
275:22, 275:25,
276:1, 281:4, 281:23,
285:18, 292:3, 292:6,
295:1
Company's [1] -
117:25
comparability [1] -
291:24
compassionate [1] -
171:18
compatible [3] -
157:2, 157:4, 262:5
compelling [4] -
150:5, 162:4, 192:5,
202:5
compensation [5] -
251:25, 272:25,
298:3, 298:6, 298:7
competent [15] -
119:14, 120:13,
127:9, 127:25, 128:2,
148:12, 148:15,
149:8, 172:8, 172:19,
282:25, 283:1,
288:25, 298:22
competing [1] -
270:1
competition [1] -
290:21
competitive [3] -
261:15, 261:16,
267:12
complain [1] - 254:4
complaining [1] -
165:11
complaints [2] -
246:22, 253:25
complete [3] - 172:7,
206:25, 301:6
completed [1] -
191:3
completion [1] -
190:25
complex [5] -
127:13, 232:17,
246:8, 261:22, 286:9
compliance [5] -
241:25, 242:17,
245:2, 247:6, 247:7
complicated [2] -
207:14, 293:22
compliment [1] -
296:16
complimentary [1] -
269:3
comply [2] - 177:14,
230:6
compress [1] -
156:16
compromise [1] -
203:12
computer [1] - 278:9
computers [1] -
198:9
con [1] - 126:12
concentrated [1] -
233:4
concentration [1] -
181:20
concentrations [1] -
159:3
concept [2] - 249:24,
262:15
concepts [1] -
265:12
concern [3] - 202:7,
255:12, 286:7
concerned [1] -
157:16
concerted [1] -
231:24
concluded [1] -
159:8
concludes [2] -
179:11, 186:7
conclusion [10] -
124:25, 126:12,
127:15, 182:2, 183:6,
184:10, 184:12,
185:15, 185:21, 256:5
conclusions [2] -
151:14, 182:18
concurrent [2] -
190:11, 286:23
concurrently [5] -
286:23, 294:17,
294:19, 295:6, 295:7
condition [11] -
121:22, 122:22,
122:23, 129:12,
152:8, 154:5, 155:4,
162:15, 165:21,
166:16, 178:2
Condition [2] -
152:9, 152:24
conditional [6] -
188:23, 189:14,
189:24, 190:21,
190:22, 191:23
Conditional [1] -
210:6
conditions [53] -
118:1, 120:6, 123:18,
124:12, 124:13,
124:17, 125:3,
125:17, 129:2,
131:20, 141:20,
141:24, 142:11,
142:16, 144:8,
144:20, 145:6, 147:3,
150:21, 151:24,
161:11, 162:14,
163:12, 164:23,
165:1, 165:3, 165:17,
166:1, 167:24,
167:25, 168:10,
178:2, 178:6, 185:8,
188:24, 189:8,
189:14, 189:25,
190:6, 190:8, 190:12,
190:23, 190:25,
192:24, 194:11,
194:19, 195:4,
195:18, 200:25,
204:4, 207:17,
208:12, 208:14
conduct [1] - 138:9
conducted [1] -
291:23
Conference [1] -
218:9
confidence [1] -
248:11
confident [1] - 295:5
confined [2] -
200:13, 201:20
confirm [1] - 169:8
conflict [2] - 209:1,
247:10
conflicting [1] -
247:1
confusing [1] - 129:1
congratulations [1] -
256:18
Congratulations [2]
- 212:3, 256:7
Congress [1] - 260:8
connected [2] -
133:10, 263:19
connection [2] -
289:12, 298:14
consensus [6] -
252:4, 259:6, 260:14,
260:18, 267:9, 299:9
consensus-
building [3] - 259:6,
260:14, 267:9
consent [6] - 168:16,
175:17, 176:6,
176:13, 177:9, 177:16
consequences [1] -
159:21
consider [12] -
119:7, 120:11,
120:21, 164:15,
177:19, 189:16,
192:2, 192:6, 199:14,
221:19, 252:19,
259:13
consideration [12] -
117:23, 118:6, 154:3,
154:7, 170:20,
176:10, 198:3,
215:14, 218:10,
234:6, 296:25, 300:7
considered [3] -
259:16, 263:4, 272:7
considering [3] -
119:10, 152:8, 177:18
consistency [1] -
247:4
consistent [5] -
126:10, 245:8,
281:18, 296:25,
297:25
consistently [1] -
184:18
constant [1] - 267:15
constantly [6] -
240:5, 249:22, 285:8,
289:23, 297:3
constituent [1] -
248:9
constitute [1] -
170:21
constitutes [1] -
153:4
constrain [1] -
167:16
constrained [1] -
167:18
construct [1] -
265:19
construction [2] -
118:13, 177:13
constructive [1] -
291:7
consulted [1] -
270:20
consulting [2] -
270:22, 271:2
consume [1] -
160:12
consumer [16] -
260:20, 269:23,
270:14, 272:7,
272:10, 273:16,
275:2, 275:7, 295:1,
295:8, 295:22, 296:3,
296:8, 296:10, 296:12
consumers [13] -
261:18, 261:24,
272:21, 274:5,
274:15, 274:21,
274:23, 281:15,
282:7, 286:10, 292:7,
292:12, 295:13
contact [2] - 225:10,
248:5
containing [1] -
137:21
contaminant [1] -
140:3
contaminants [1] -
139:17
contaminated [1] -
159:3
context [2] - 161:1,
163:8
contingent [1] -
231:1
continually [3] -
145:11, 145:12,
262:14
continue [15] -
117:7, 120:23,
121:14, 137:16,
150:11, 160:16,
172:5, 175:20,
258:16, 261:10,
265:4, 273:24, 282:9,
289:22, 297:24
continued [2] -
158:7, 168:7
continues [3] -
137:16, 141:6, 155:1
CONTINUING [2] -
116:2, 117:2
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
7
continuing [4] -
258:22, 296:16,
297:14, 297:22
contractors [2] -
264:3, 278:13
contracts [1] -
244:20
contradict [1] -
148:11
contradicted [1] -
128:25
contradictory [1] -
127:19
contributing [1] -
127:13
contribution [3] -
163:21, 163:24, 168:7
control [10] - 143:5,
143:7, 192:25, 197:5,
199:3, 200:23, 203:2,
203:16, 203:20, 237:2
controls [1] - 178:1
conversation [6] -
164:11, 168:1,
188:14, 240:5, 253:5,
273:18
conversations [1] -
244:6
conversion [1] -
288:9
convert [2] - 160:6,
288:11
converted [1] -
288:10
convey [1] - 244:17
conveying [1] -
245:4
conviction [1] -
196:20
convince [1] -
267:18
COO [1] - 259:25
cooks [1] - 271:18
cool [1] - 133:12
cooler [1] - 140:7
cooling [49] - 122:1,
122:8, 125:6, 127:3,
132:24, 132:25,
133:9, 133:12,
133:14, 133:16,
133:25, 134:4, 134:6,
134:17, 134:21,
135:1, 135:3, 135:7,
135:10, 137:14,
137:15, 138:1,
138:15, 139:7, 139:9,
139:14, 139:18,
139:22, 140:4, 142:1,
143:9, 143:14,
143:20, 143:23,
144:7, 153:15,
153:24, 154:10,
154:11, 158:2, 158:9,
158:16, 159:12,
163:15, 174:25,
175:7, 175:18, 177:8
Cooling [4] - 131:8,
156:20, 156:22,
157:17
cooperation [1] -
285:15
corn [1] - 283:22
corner [1] - 271:16
corners [1] - 120:13
corporation [1] -
167:20
Correct [4] - 173:17,
179:3, 191:16, 208:10
correct [32] - 120:15,
141:16, 142:18,
147:15, 147:16,
147:22, 149:11,
152:10, 161:24,
162:20, 164:16,
164:20, 174:4, 174:5,
174:13, 174:14,
174:21, 174:25,
175:6, 177:8, 177:15,
183:14, 183:18,
191:7, 191:16,
193:11, 199:21,
199:23, 200:2, 209:7,
284:25, 285:3
corrected [1] - 229:8
cost [2] - 272:9,
272:20
costs [4] - 272:6,
295:23, 295:25, 296:7
Council [1] - 234:16
counsel [2] - 254:18,
281:1
Counsel [2] - 118:4,
118:15
count [2] - 192:22,
255:20
counted [1] - 235:23
Counties [3] -
222:23, 222:25,
223:22
counties [1] - 244:21
countries [1] -
226:20
country [2] - 226:19,
226:22
COUNTY [1] - 301:3
County [10] - 138:17,
138:18, 156:19,
157:5, 157:6, 157:16,
158:5, 168:17, 177:16
couple [7] - 235:25,
239:13, 247:24,
272:1, 277:17,
292:18, 294:1
coupled [1] - 160:15
course [5] - 134:2,
240:6, 243:2, 261:21,
272:6
Court [5] - 207:17,
273:8, 298:4, 298:13,
301:11
COURT [1] - 114:18
court [1] - 269:7
courtesy [1] - 299:4
courtroom [1] -
203:25
courts [2] - 223:8,
272:22
cover [1] - 269:22
coverage [6] - 263:1,
272:19, 274:16,
286:21, 286:25,
296:22
Craig [8] - 118:4,
118:8, 119:25,
147:25, 148:2, 149:7,
169:9, 182:9
create [8] - 216:25,
220:9, 223:13,
261:11, 261:13,
263:24, 269:21, 273:2
created [3] - 146:19,
161:14, 278:19
creating [5] - 139:2,
198:12, 270:3,
273:22, 294:7
creative [1] - 288:6
crime [2] - 192:16,
194:15
criminal [2] - 197:9,
198:23
criteria [9] - 123:14,
123:23, 124:4, 124:7,
124:8, 128:15,
128:21, 131:16,
165:16
criticism [2] -
293:12, 293:15
criticisms [1] -
268:20
crucial [1] - 240:5
Cunningham [3] -
130:19, 130:23, 143:2
CUNNINGHAM [2] -
130:22, 132:9
cure [1] - 152:19
curious [2] - 166:15,
200:8
current [9] - 123:17,
135:25, 141:20,
216:15, 216:24,
218:2, 224:21, 225:13
customer [3] - 223:7,
242:18, 242:23
customer-centric [1]
- 242:23
customers [8] -
242:6, 242:19,
242:20, 242:21,
242:23, 242:25,
247:1, 247:18
cut [3] - 133:5,
145:4, 198:15
D
Dade [11] - 138:17,
138:18, 156:19,
157:5, 157:16, 158:4,
168:17, 168:22,
176:7, 177:16, 230:15
daily [4] - 260:3,
266:22, 287:6, 290:9
damage [4] - 138:10,
145:9, 151:24, 296:22
damaged [1] -
138:11
damaging [1] -
146:20
dangerous [1] -
172:3
data [2] - 159:10,
296:23
date [2] - 189:16,
297:18
DATE [1] - 114:14
DATED [1] - 301:7
daughter [5] -
192:19, 193:8, 195:7,
195:25, 205:7
days [14] - 152:18,
161:6, 161:24, 162:8,
172:12, 219:4,
220:15, 222:2, 227:2,
228:13, 236:12,
246:17, 247:14
days' [1] - 216:19
DBPR [8] - 242:9,
243:1, 243:5, 245:22,
246:2, 249:14,
253:22, 253:25
DCF [1] - 231:22
deal [10] - 127:3,
128:9, 136:8, 146:4,
156:6, 217:24,
242:22, 242:25,
284:16, 289:1
dealing [6] - 118:21,
217:17, 242:5,
244:19, 284:20, 287:8
deals [7] - 128:25,
153:15, 153:16,
153:24, 154:2, 154:15
dealt [3] - 126:24,
153:8, 289:16
death [1] - 263:9
debating [1] - 171:2
December [1] -
191:25
decide [2] - 199:18,
289:8
decided [2] - 278:14,
278:15
decision [24] - 119:3,
119:16, 119:17,
121:3, 127:1, 128:6,
156:14, 159:23,
166:25, 171:6,
173:14, 184:24,
191:5, 234:12,
234:13, 240:16,
248:20, 259:9,
259:14, 259:15,
260:25, 270:23,
271:2, 271:3
decision-making [1]
- 173:14
decisionmaking [3] -
167:2, 170:2, 170:23
decisions [10] -
238:21, 238:23,
260:21, 270:22,
270:25, 271:1, 290:4,
291:5, 298:3
decisiveness [1] -
289:4
decline [1] - 207:10
declined [1] - 276:9
decree [3] - 175:17,
177:9, 177:16
dedicated [1] -
232:19
deemed [1] - 126:18
deep [3] - 122:6,
131:10, 164:11
defend [1] - 143:6
defendant [5] -
188:17, 188:25,
189:9, 190:7, 192:3
defer [3] - 119:18,
176:14, 196:5
deference [1] - 223:2
deferral [1] - 119:20
definitively [1] -
159:15
degree [8] - 193:25,
216:7, 219:21, 228:5,
228:14, 228:21,
229:15, 281:5
delay [1] - 119:18
DELGADO [2] -
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
8
115:18, 187:3
Delgado [3] - 187:10,
187:14, 187:23
delineated [2] -
136:25, 137:6
deliver [2] - 274:9,
291:11
delivering [1] - 295:2
delivers [1] - 290:21
demeanor [1] - 150:3
demonstrating [1] -
159:1
denied [1] - 146:8
dense [1] - 136:6
DEP [19] - 118:4,
118:16, 118:17,
131:22, 136:20,
137:19, 138:8,
141:15, 145:12,
155:12, 158:4,
159:18, 160:9, 161:3,
168:24, 169:6, 173:5,
180:10, 185:10
DEP's [3] - 144:22,
147:3, 180:3
Department [52] -
121:19, 123:1,
126:21, 151:11,
153:2, 166:19,
166:21, 168:25,
175:16, 177:9,
178:11, 179:22,
180:18, 180:21,
184:18, 214:8,
215:24, 216:17,
219:3, 219:7, 219:16,
219:25, 221:5,
224:24, 225:4,
225:16, 225:19,
226:9, 226:15,
226:16, 226:21,
227:1, 227:18,
227:20, 228:17,
228:20, 229:16,
229:18, 231:9,
231:16, 231:22,
242:2, 242:22,
244:20, 245:4,
251:25, 262:4,
266:14, 267:3, 271:9,
271:10, 271:12
DEPARTMENT [3] -
115:5, 115:20, 214:3
department [2] -
154:18, 216:14
Department's [3] -
123:9, 126:23, 223:7
deploy [3] - 232:12,
239:18, 294:9
depth [1] - 281:11
Deputy [5] - 217:19,
217:22, 222:4,
223:23, 225:15
describe [2] - 119:1,
245:20
described [2] -
206:13, 206:14
describing [1] -
274:18
deserve [3] - 167:14,
265:19, 284:19
deserves [1] -
195:22
design [8] - 133:11,
133:14, 134:14,
175:10, 175:23,
177:12, 177:13,
177:14
designed [2] - 175:8,
175:12
desire [2] - 164:10,
197:13
desk [2] - 247:15,
283:8
desperately [1] -
159:24
despite [3] - 127:8,
128:12, 137:11
destroyed [1] -
138:12
detail [3] - 163:23,
212:12, 281:11
detailed [1] - 149:10
details [2] - 118:5,
251:2
detect [1] - 230:18
determination [12] -
119:13, 123:22,
124:5, 125:1, 128:14,
148:18, 164:18,
176:11, 180:12,
184:15, 191:13, 276:1
determinations [2] -
184:16, 184:19
determine [7] -
142:10, 143:15,
146:7, 146:15, 224:6,
232:23, 248:6
determined [3] -
127:11, 173:19,
290:10
determining [2] -
123:14, 144:6
detriment [1] -
197:17
develop [3] - 219:19,
220:12, 235:9
developed [1] -
219:24
dial [1] - 136:15
dialogue [3] - 240:1,
253:4, 253:8
dicta [1] - 181:9
difference [2] -
127:17, 182:1
different [21] -
144:11, 144:15,
154:18, 156:8,
191:15, 192:23,
196:20, 215:19,
217:20, 225:3,
226:20, 231:17,
231:18, 231:19,
232:15, 235:17,
239:13, 247:11,
256:14, 291:17,
296:13
differentiation [1] -
174:19
difficult [2] - 268:11,
293:7
diligently [1] - 287:5
direct [5] - 216:3,
234:19, 289:11,
290:12
direction [10] -
166:18, 220:11,
249:18, 270:23,
272:16, 275:21,
285:15, 285:20,
292:4, 296:24
directly [6] - 133:10,
142:12, 220:1,
244:12, 274:4, 289:17
director [1] - 249:16
Director [24] - 115:6,
115:8, 115:10,
115:12, 131:2, 214:8,
217:19, 220:1, 222:4,
222:20, 223:24,
225:15, 225:18,
226:8, 226:13,
227:13, 231:5,
235:19, 236:10,
238:10, 241:5, 242:7,
251:24, 297:25
DIRECTOR [2] -
115:21, 214:3
directors [1] -
259:23
disagree [9] - 121:5,
125:18, 146:6, 147:5,
169:16, 169:17,
184:14, 185:1, 200:21
disappear [2] -
140:22, 140:24
discharges [2] -
135:7, 137:21
disclosed [1] -
275:23
discretion [2] -
148:9, 153:6
discuss [1] - 176:5
discussed [1] -
297:13
discussion [3] -
171:4, 281:18, 300:5
discussions [4] -
120:22, 125:17,
166:22, 176:8
disperse [1] - 140:12
displaced [1] - 140:3
disproportion [1] -
262:13
disputed [1] - 144:18
disrespectful [1] -
147:1
distance [1] - 196:23
distinction [1] -
123:19
distinguished [1] -
250:4
District [11] - 131:16,
131:23, 136:20,
139:25, 140:17,
141:16, 145:13,
153:16, 154:17,
158:4, 159:8
districts [1] - 281:22
disturbing [1] -
193:3
diverse [1] - 239:11
diversified [1] -
157:1
diversify [1] - 273:24
Division [1] - 122:16
DIVISION [1] - 115:7
divisions [5] -
242:10, 245:23,
282:17, 282:18
DNO [1] - 277:7
DOAH [1] - 152:23
Doctor [1] - 219:18
document [4] -
120:13, 162:10,
172:2, 180:23
documented [1] -
158:19
documents [1] -
218:11
dollar [1] - 236:5
dollars [2] - 289:14,
295:12
domestic [2] -
267:24, 268:5
domestics [1] -
273:23
done [25] - 129:20,
195:16, 209:12,
211:9, 211:14,
211:23, 212:23,
212:24, 213:2,
226:25, 235:17,
243:1, 243:2, 243:4,
243:10, 250:11,
253:22, 256:13,
259:17, 275:1,
280:11, 284:4,
289:19, 291:16,
291:18
door [1] - 210:18
DOR [17] - 217:15,
222:17, 226:11,
229:6, 231:3, 234:23,
234:24, 235:7,
235:19, 236:20,
236:22, 236:23,
237:12, 244:11,
244:12, 257:7
down [29] - 120:25,
133:8, 136:5, 139:2,
139:15, 139:16,
139:18, 139:19,
142:22, 149:15,
158:23, 210:8, 217:4,
219:22, 225:8,
230:15, 247:13,
250:18, 252:19,
253:4, 254:4, 254:6,
265:24, 266:6,
269:20, 283:9,
297:23, 297:24, 298:7
downhill [1] - 134:10
downstream [2] -
159:21, 181:19
draft [4] - 126:8,
126:11, 128:17, 210:4
Draft [5] - 123:3,
123:5, 123:8, 131:4,
182:20
drafted [2] - 118:23,
211:7
drain [1] - 224:25
dramatically [1] -
276:3
draw [2] - 133:11,
299:3
drawn [1] - 133:18
draws [2] - 133:14,
133:23
drilled [1] - 137:8
drinking [2] - 160:6,
161:17
drive [2] - 220:10,
229:25
drivers [1] - 272:9
driving [2] - 227:9,
272:6
drop [1] - 276:18
dropped [1] - 276:20
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
9
drought [1] - 178:1
drug [2] - 193:10,
193:22
drugs [3] - 197:23,
198:1, 198:5
during [6] - 143:22,
214:12, 224:23,
226:16, 240:6, 257:9
Duval [2] - 236:19,
236:21
dynamic [1] - 172:11
dysfunction [1] -
143:21
E
e-auditing [1] - 227:5
ear [1] - 236:15
earliest [1] - 202:4
early [5] - 142:5,
191:21, 194:5,
194:12, 205:20
easier [3] - 201:12,
230:5, 246:6
easiest [2] - 246:3,
291:18
easily [2] - 133:8,
136:3
east [1] - 133:13
easy [2] - 197:7,
280:17
Economic [1] -
231:16
economics [1] -
238:13
Economist [3] -
217:20, 218:2, 223:24
Economist's [1] -
224:22
edge [4] - 226:23,
229:6, 229:8, 229:12
educating [1] -
238:20
education [3] -
201:21, 204:22, 205:5
effect [5] - 133:3,
153:22, 155:10,
159:23, 190:24
effective [1] - 282:8
effectively [3] -
153:4, 223:13, 243:2
effectiveness [1] -
224:15
effects [2] - 141:25,
154:7
efficiencies [1] -
224:14
efficiency [1] -
228:25
effort [4] - 163:9,
231:24, 233:4, 296:7
efforts [1] - 207:22
eight [4] - 158:18,
161:6, 161:24, 162:8
either [8] - 120:11,
126:18, 141:7,
146:15, 169:11,
230:19, 260:25, 264:2
elected [5] - 223:2,
223:6, 223:10,
239:13, 281:14
electrical [1] -
118:13
electronic [1] - 227:4
electronically [1] -
227:7
elects [1] - 153:19
element [2] - 202:16,
224:18
elements [2] -
128:14, 232:11
eleven [2] - 205:21,
205:22
eligible [1] - 199:11
eliminate [4] -
131:19, 163:20,
168:7, 175:17
eliminating [1] -
163:24
eloquent [1] - 213:4
embedded [1] -
295:24
employees [13] -
137:19, 225:4,
235:24, 236:8,
242:10, 242:25,
247:17, 258:24,
259:1, 259:3, 264:2,
270:15, 282:16
employers [1] -
230:6
employment [2] -
200:13, 285:13
enacts [1] - 259:22
encounter [1] -
139:17
encounters [1] -
141:8
encourage [2] -
265:4, 290:1
encouraging [2] -
267:25, 268:6
end [23] - 140:2,
141:3, 156:10, 171:4,
191:1, 191:6, 191:9,
203:23, 210:23,
224:5, 227:2, 239:22,
239:25, 240:3,
240:15, 240:16,
247:5, 248:8, 260:19,
269:24, 274:13,
275:1, 287:24
endorsement [3] -
150:17, 223:17,
223:19
ends [1] - 270:9
enforcement [3] -
153:5, 168:23, 244:19
engage [2] - 219:12,
240:1
engaged [1] - 218:15
enlist [1] - 232:2
enormous [2] -
133:2, 283:8
enrollees [1] -
286:17
ensure [4] - 160:19,
261:23, 286:9, 287:11
entered [1] - 153:2
enterprise [1] -
259:2
entire [6] - 143:6,
148:9, 153:14,
195:16, 243:3, 243:12
entirely [1] - 259:5
entirety [1] - 119:13
entities [2] - 282:16,
286:23
entity [1] - 173:11
envelope [1] - 230:3
environment [6] -
261:14, 284:3,
285:14, 290:8, 291:6,
291:8
Environmental [1] -
169:1
environmental [3] -
177:11, 184:8, 184:23
environments [1] -
281:20
equally [2] - 248:3,
249:8
equivalent [1] -
139:6
ERC [1] - 175:13
err [1] - 170:25
errant [1] - 294:20
erring [1] - 170:25
error [1] - 170:22
escalates [1] -
265:24
especially [1] -
267:13
essence [1] - 198:7
essentially [3] -
122:20, 177:24,
293:17
establish [1] -
142:14
established [4] -
120:20, 142:19,
168:21, 189:25
establishing [1] -
225:18
estimates [2] -
218:5, 218:8
Estimating [1] -
218:9
et [2] - 288:12,
297:20
eternally [1] - 213:10
ethical [1] - 177:1
evaluate [2] -
197:19, 206:2
evaluating [1] -
184:5
events [1] - 196:13
eventually [2] -
140:23, 140:24
Everglades [1] -
141:9
Evers [3] - 115:23,
214:18, 226:3
EVERS [11] - 226:1,
226:5, 226:12,
227:15, 228:8,
228:12, 228:23,
229:9, 231:7, 232:14,
233:7
everyday [1] -
242:22
evidence [27] -
119:7, 119:15,
119:17, 120:14,
120:20, 123:21,
127:10, 127:23,
128:1, 128:3, 129:8,
131:12, 136:8, 137:1,
137:6, 140:14,
140:15, 141:2, 148:3,
148:10, 149:8, 150:2,
150:5, 155:16,
155:17, 172:8, 172:19
exacerbated [1] -
158:13
exact [2] - 134:23,
229:23
exactly [11] - 120:19,
148:24, 150:1,
159:15, 164:19,
227:22, 244:11,
244:12, 247:22,
283:21, 287:21
examine [1] - 290:1
example [16] -
151:15, 220:6,
221:10, 224:21,
235:15, 236:7,
250:11, 250:13,
262:8, 265:13,
265:20, 276:4, 288:5,
289:10, 289:18,
290:25
exceed [1] - 181:11
excellence [2] -
239:17, 286:24
excellent [1] -
266:14
except [6] - 121:22,
138:19, 200:13,
201:21, 208:11,
211:18
exception [11] -
123:9, 126:17,
126:23, 126:25,
128:18, 128:24,
129:6, 129:10,
129:11, 140:12,
180:20
Exception [1] - 146:2
exceptional [3] -
254:14, 273:18,
273:19
exceptions [12] -
123:2, 126:15,
126:16, 126:20,
127:3, 128:9, 132:20,
140:10, 180:3, 180:7,
180:21, 201:22
excess [1] - 245:25
exclusive [1] -
294:16
Excuse [1] - 287:16
excuse [7] - 121:22,
123:13, 145:16,
160:23, 161:1,
190:15, 287:17
execute [1] - 191:8
Executive [18] -
115:10, 210:5, 214:8,
217:19, 220:1, 222:4,
222:20, 223:23,
225:15, 225:18,
226:8, 227:13, 231:5,
235:19, 241:5, 242:7,
251:24, 297:25
executive [8] -
191:8, 217:25,
219:24, 249:16,
281:3, 281:16, 283:3,
285:17
EXECUTIVE [2] -
115:21, 214:3
executives [1] -
231:14
exemption [4] -
221:12, 221:22,
230:13, 230:18
exercise [1] - 153:5
existing [13] -
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
10
121:25, 124:13,
129:1, 129:5, 138:7,
139:17, 140:3,
155:10, 161:15,
162:15, 165:9, 182:4,
182:5
exists [2] - 274:22
expand [2] - 267:20,
268:7
expansion [1] -
286:21
expect [3] - 168:24,
211:25, 239:5
expectation [1] -
272:9
expectations [3] -
250:9, 251:8
expected [2] - 159:9,
160:25
expecting [2] -
238:22, 245:5
expensive [1] -
263:4
experience [23] -
197:4, 222:16,
224:12, 224:25,
225:14, 227:19,
237:12, 237:24,
241:18, 246:9,
250:15, 251:4,
258:11, 264:8,
265:21, 265:22,
265:25, 266:5, 266:7,
266:15, 267:18,
272:13, 281:17
experienced [1] -
225:1
experiences [3] -
242:9, 248:21, 251:11
expert [2] - 280:22,
280:24
expertise [4] -
151:10, 151:13,
184:20, 264:9
experts [6] - 128:4,
148:14, 148:16,
160:10, 218:16, 232:3
explain [3] - 124:22,
188:5, 244:10
exploring [1] -
263:18
exposed [1] - 202:18
exposure [1] -
198:24
extended [1] -
299:14
extending [2] -
137:2, 137:3
extent [4] - 164:25,
284:16, 291:9, 291:10
extra [1] - 193:6
extract [1] - 296:7
extraordinary [2] -
220:19, 220:23
extremely [3] -
245:18, 267:7, 285:6
eyes [3] - 124:15,
266:24, 273:14
F
face [4] - 231:20,
261:13, 267:1, 269:13
facets [1] - 242:1
facie [1] - 146:11
facilities [1] - 142:11
facility [1] - 178:13
Fact [1] - 151:5
fact [19] - 119:11,
121:3, 125:19, 136:8,
136:9, 140:11, 141:6,
183:13, 183:23,
238:16, 241:15,
262:7, 282:6, 285:14,
288:3, 292:4, 292:24,
293:1, 294:22
factors [1] - 127:13
facts [2] - 119:14,
148:7
fail [5] - 194:8,
194:18, 195:3,
203:10, 207:6
failed [2] - 276:6,
276:7
failure [1] - 159:14
fair [4] - 124:15,
235:11, 235:12,
235:13
fairest [1] - 270:5
fairly [4] - 122:10,
184:22, 248:3, 249:8
fall [1] - 202:8
familiar [4] - 262:22,
271:22, 271:25,
295:18
family [11] - 156:18,
159:5, 166:12,
187:15, 187:23,
192:22, 193:7,
195:17, 196:22,
207:11, 213:9
far [3] - 196:13,
200:6, 270:9
farming [1] - 156:22
fashion [1] - 274:17
fast [2] - 212:10,
212:15
fastly [1] - 208:17
father [1] - 284:2
favor [3] - 167:1,
236:25, 252:10
favored [1] - 236:25
FAX [1] - 114:23
FBI [1] - 269:8
FDLE [1] - 189:3
FDOT [1] - 157:8
fearless [1] - 225:11
feature [1] - 132:23
federal [2] - 157:11,
163:19
Federal [2] - 175:20,
263:17
feelings [1] - 253:18
fees [1] - 246:1
feet [8] - 122:6,
131:10, 134:8, 155:7,
155:8, 158:20,
162:17, 162:18
fellow [1] - 237:15
felony [2] - 193:12,
193:25
felt [3] - 159:13,
181:8, 219:11
FEMA [1] - 265:10
ferret [1] - 296:16
few [4] - 167:21,
204:12, 235:17, 299:8
field [6] - 196:18,
236:11, 236:14,
242:13, 247:10,
247:17
fields [1] - 283:22
fifth [1] - 128:24
figure [3] - 216:17,
247:21, 247:24
file [2] - 126:16,
269:1
filed [10] - 123:1,
126:15, 126:17,
126:19, 126:21,
126:22, 180:22,
275:19, 276:11,
296:18
fill [4] - 135:15,
139:9, 139:10
filled [1] - 135:19
filter [1] - 247:12
final [9] - 118:12,
121:20, 127:1, 163:2,
168:23, 176:10,
178:10, 179:5, 268:8
Final [14] - 117:24,
118:5, 118:23, 123:3,
123:5, 123:8, 126:3,
131:4, 131:25,
144:23, 179:23,
182:10, 182:20, 183:1
finalist [1] - 268:16
finally [5] - 126:14,
127:17, 159:2,
211:23, 293:3
finance [1] - 254:24
FINANCE [1] - 115:7
FINANCIAL [2] -
114:11, 115:3
Findings [1] - 151:5
findings [7] - 119:11,
120:15, 127:9,
128:19, 148:12,
149:10
fine [5] - 170:4,
187:25, 295:16
fingerprint [1] -
136:22
finish [4] - 149:20,
149:23, 168:24,
212:23
finished [2] - 222:12,
237:21
firm [2] - 218:4,
270:7
firmly [2] - 194:10,
206:5
first [27] - 127:2,
130:12, 138:22,
168:6, 190:13,
191:23, 203:21,
215:4, 215:23, 219:4,
220:15, 228:8, 229:9,
231:7, 234:7, 236:12,
246:16, 247:14,
248:23, 250:15,
251:4, 252:12, 254:3,
258:4, 258:8, 288:24,
294:14
fit [1] - 241:6
five [5] - 137:15,
159:8, 193:25,
264:18, 296:20
fix [2] - 208:13,
296:11
fixes [1] - 296:15
flat [2] - 238:17,
238:19
flexibility [1] -
288:11
flood [17] - 263:16,
263:19, 263:22,
264:5, 264:7, 264:10,
264:13, 264:18,
264:22, 265:1, 265:7,
265:11, 265:12,
265:22, 266:4, 275:3,
276:1
Flood [1] - 264:1
flood-free [1] -
265:22
Florida [77] - 117:24,
118:11, 119:19,
119:23, 121:15,
122:15, 123:6,
123:23, 124:5,
126:15, 126:22,
127:18, 129:19,
130:19, 131:15,
131:22, 133:1,
137:12, 139:24,
140:5, 140:15,
140:16, 142:8,
153:21, 159:7,
160:19, 161:17,
161:18, 163:3,
168:25, 171:19,
177:12, 198:7, 221:1,
222:18, 223:17,
226:8, 226:14,
226:16, 226:21,
229:18, 229:20,
230:6, 230:12, 231:9,
231:11, 232:16,
241:16, 246:10,
261:4, 261:6, 263:17,
264:19, 266:3,
266:18, 267:1,
267:21, 267:23,
268:5, 272:25,
273:12, 273:15,
273:23, 274:4,
274:15, 280:21,
281:4, 281:12,
281:15, 288:20,
289:24, 289:25,
290:23, 291:2,
293:10, 298:4, 298:13
FLORIDA [4] - 114:1,
114:16, 114:23, 301:3
Florida's [6] -
271:23, 281:13,
282:5, 282:7, 289:24,
290:11
Floridan [3] - 131:9,
152:12, 173:22
Floridian [2] -
215:12, 241:14
Floridians [1] -
265:13
flows [1] - 134:10
flush [1] - 139:10
flushing [2] - 139:11,
139:12
focus [1] - 125:11
focusing [1] - 120:24
fold [1] - 265:4
folks [15] - 216:5,
217:8, 217:10,
218:18, 219:5,
219:11, 222:7,
234:18, 235:25,
236:11, 237:5,
237:25, 238:20,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
11
239:21, 240:1
follow [8] - 172:17,
199:4, 203:21,
248:12, 253:5,
271:24, 275:14,
283:12
followed [6] -
198:19, 203:1,
203:17, 203:24, 204:7
following [2] -
130:20, 260:23
foot [2] - 133:19,
134:7
footprint [2] -
241:22, 274:24
FOR [4] - 115:20,
116:4, 214:2, 257:2
force [1] - 178:3
forced [2] - 158:23,
159:13
forecasts [1] -
218:15
foregoing [1] - 301:6
foreign [1] - 226:20
forever [1] - 195:1
forewarned [1] -
284:16
form [5] - 136:14,
154:8, 154:13, 262:9,
262:16
form-over-
substance [1] -
154:13
format [1] - 156:8
former [4] - 137:19,
280:25, 281:1, 281:2
forms [3] - 262:3,
274:11, 289:13
forth [2] - 124:20,
278:11
forthcoming [1] -
298:4
forty [1] - 296:20
forty-five [1] - 296:20
forward [26] - 122:3,
124:23, 129:19,
132:1, 168:9, 216:9,
218:3, 221:7, 223:14,
224:17, 225:12,
238:11, 251:13,
253:3, 258:22,
260:11, 267:2, 282:5,
282:6, 288:20,
288:21, 289:12,
289:21, 290:11,
295:15, 298:23
forwarded [1] -
122:15
foster [3] - 217:11,
243:13, 251:10
foundation [1] -
228:24
four [33] - 120:12,
137:2, 137:14,
137:25, 158:15,
173:10, 214:16,
214:21, 216:19,
220:23, 227:16,
227:22, 227:23,
242:10, 252:5, 252:6,
252:13, 253:4, 253:9,
253:12, 253:14,
254:22, 255:24,
256:4, 256:12, 260:6,
264:23, 264:25,
267:19, 268:11,
283:18, 285:8
fourteen [1] - 139:4
Fourth [1] - 284:1
fourth [1] - 128:9
FPL [18] - 130:24,
131:1, 131:4, 131:22,
136:23, 142:2,
145:11, 158:3,
159:17, 159:23,
160:9, 160:22,
161:13, 163:9,
163:17, 163:23,
168:17, 171:21
FPL's [12] - 128:20,
131:7, 136:9, 136:11,
136:23, 141:18,
147:5, 157:17, 159:9,
160:14, 161:11
FPR [3] - 114:18,
301:5, 301:11
fractured [2] - 133:5,
133:7
frank [1] - 165:19
frankly [9] - 146:6,
252:3, 252:7, 253:13,
269:8, 275:24,
285:25, 287:20, 291:4
Frankly [1] - 212:10
fraud [5] - 230:13,
230:18, 231:8,
231:21, 296:17
Fred [1] - 240:3
free [11] - 137:20,
137:21, 152:14,
152:21, 166:24,
206:9, 208:15,
265:21, 265:22,
290:20
free-from [3] -
137:20, 152:14,
152:21
freedom [1] - 208:15
freeze [1] - 174:9
fresh [6] - 135:20,
138:3, 266:24, 273:14
freshen [1] - 131:7
fresher [1] - 140:6
FROM [1] - 117:2
front [23] - 132:21,
134:16, 136:10,
138:1, 138:16,
138:19, 141:3, 141:6,
143:12, 145:7, 145:8,
147:15, 160:11,
161:24, 168:14,
202:13, 203:20,
216:9, 219:9, 256:1,
287:6, 287:8, 297:3
fulfill [1] - 189:15
full [14] - 174:18,
189:5, 189:6, 189:13,
189:16, 191:9, 192:3,
192:5, 192:10,
199:20, 200:1, 206:6,
208:6, 209:4
fully [2] - 161:13,
198:16
function [2] - 143:15,
295:7
functions [4] -
143:15, 244:22,
246:1, 294:15
FUND [1] - 115:14
Fund [2] - 297:7,
297:24
fundamental [2] -
129:3, 181:7
fundamentally [1] -
255:9
funded [1] - 228:15
future [4] - 144:1,
189:16, 272:15,
275:22
G
gallons [11] - 121:25,
134:24, 135:11,
136:2, 138:24, 139:3,
139:4, 139:5, 154:9,
168:8, 177:24
gate [1] - 202:9
gathering [2] -
246:24, 260:23
gauge [1] - 247:21
GE [1] - 239:20
gears [1] - 242:8
gee [1] - 221:21
general [10] - 129:14,
151:8, 151:13, 184:5,
184:21, 184:25,
237:23, 247:8,
254:18, 281:1
General [17] - 118:4,
118:15, 130:12,
147:7, 150:1, 171:15,
176:22, 194:2,
215:10, 222:11,
226:13, 236:17,
241:9, 244:8, 261:19,
285:23, 286:19
GENERAL [134] -
114:10, 117:18,
120:8, 121:9, 130:13,
145:15, 147:9,
147:12, 147:17,
147:20, 147:24,
148:2, 148:22,
148:25, 149:4,
149:14, 149:18,
154:4, 161:23, 162:3,
162:7, 162:21,
164:16, 164:20,
171:17, 173:1,
176:24, 177:5,
178:15, 178:21,
178:24, 179:2, 179:4,
179:9, 179:18, 183:3,
183:9, 183:11,
183:16, 183:19,
183:21, 184:1,
185:11, 185:20,
186:2, 186:12, 188:7,
188:11, 188:15,
190:14, 191:17,
191:20, 194:3,
195:21, 198:6, 199:7,
200:20, 201:3, 201:5,
201:9, 201:17,
202:21, 203:9,
203:22, 204:3, 204:6,
204:14, 204:20,
204:23, 205:2, 205:8,
206:3, 206:5, 206:11,
206:20, 206:24,
207:9, 208:7, 208:11,
208:20, 210:10,
210:16, 210:22,
211:1, 211:5, 211:18,
212:4, 212:7, 212:16,
212:20, 213:11,
213:13, 222:12,
222:15, 222:23,
223:15, 228:1, 228:4,
228:11, 228:22,
229:2, 231:2, 236:18,
237:9, 238:3, 243:7,
243:20, 244:9,
245:13, 246:12,
252:2, 252:6, 252:15,
253:7, 253:12,
253:18, 255:2, 255:5,
255:7, 261:20,
262:17, 262:20,
262:24, 263:13,
275:10, 275:13,
277:1, 285:24,
287:10, 287:14,
287:21, 288:15,
299:6, 300:2
General's [2] -
207:22, 244:21
generally [7] -
126:15, 185:1,
216:23, 246:19,
246:21, 251:1, 263:4
generated [1] -
268:17
gentle [1] - 207:9
gentlemen [1] -
203:13
geographies [1] -
273:25
Geotrack [4] -
275:25, 276:4, 276:6,
276:24
giant [1] - 133:2
Giddings [2] -
139:24, 141:7
girded [1] - 297:19
given [8] - 159:25,
192:15, 220:17,
223:3, 231:17,
241:18, 293:11,
297:17
glad [1] - 164:1
glow [1] - 136:15
go-forward [1] -
295:15
goal [7] - 200:9,
207:4, 213:1, 217:6,
242:6, 265:3, 267:4
goals [1] - 276:8
gorilla [1] - 272:18
governing [1] -
226:18
Government [1] -
175:20
government [8] -
163:18, 163:19,
236:3, 264:2, 264:3,
274:22, 274:24,
283:23
Governmental [1] -
131:1
governments [1] -
163:19
GOVERNOR [214] -
114:4, 114:10, 117:6,
117:13, 117:17,
117:19, 117:21,
118:7, 119:25, 120:3,
120:7, 130:6, 130:11,
130:16, 130:21,
132:4, 132:7, 132:12,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
12
144:24, 145:2,
145:14, 145:16,
145:20, 145:24,
146:10, 147:7, 148:1,
148:23, 149:13,
149:16, 149:20,
149:22, 152:4,
155:19, 155:23,
155:25, 156:3,
161:20, 162:22,
162:25, 163:4, 164:2,
164:12, 164:14,
164:17, 169:8,
169:11, 169:16,
169:19, 170:11,
170:14, 170:18,
171:12, 171:15,
172:20, 172:23,
173:2, 173:4, 176:22,
178:14, 179:10,
179:13, 179:16,
179:20, 179:24,
180:8, 180:15, 182:9,
182:12, 182:21,
182:25, 185:13,
185:17, 185:19,
185:23, 186:1, 186:3,
186:5, 186:9, 186:14,
187:5, 187:16,
187:19, 187:25,
188:2, 188:4, 188:10,
188:13, 188:20,
189:10, 189:17,
189:21, 190:19,
191:4, 191:10,
191:19, 192:8, 193:9,
193:17, 193:21,
194:1, 195:20,
195:23, 196:3, 196:8,
197:7, 197:25, 198:4,
199:15, 199:22,
199:24, 200:4,
201:25, 203:5, 204:5,
205:21, 206:4,
206:19, 207:23,
208:9, 208:18,
209:12, 211:9,
211:11, 211:14,
211:17, 211:22,
212:3, 212:5, 213:1,
213:7, 213:12,
213:15, 214:5, 215:4,
215:16, 217:14,
218:20, 222:11,
224:9, 225:20, 226:3,
226:10, 227:11,
227:24, 229:3,
230:23, 232:5, 233:5,
233:8, 234:3, 234:7,
234:22, 234:25,
235:16, 236:17,
238:4, 239:10,
240:17, 241:3, 243:4,
243:15, 244:8,
246:13, 250:2,
251:16, 251:18,
251:20, 251:23,
252:5, 252:10,
253:16, 253:19,
255:8, 256:7, 256:9,
257:5, 258:4, 258:7,
258:23, 259:18,
260:5, 261:3, 261:19,
263:14, 264:23,
264:25, 269:15,
275:9, 275:12, 277:2,
277:6, 277:9, 277:12,
277:15, 277:18,
278:24, 279:1, 280:3,
280:16, 282:11,
283:13, 284:9,
284:22, 285:1, 285:4,
285:23, 288:17,
293:24, 298:16,
298:18, 299:16,
300:3, 300:9
Governor [42] -
117:9, 118:9, 120:9,
132:13, 145:4,
147:24, 149:25,
150:24, 151:2, 156:4,
163:5, 177:6, 185:6,
188:7, 190:15,
193:11, 200:3,
202:22, 206:3, 212:9,
215:10, 225:21,
230:14, 240:18,
241:8, 243:20,
252:11, 253:6, 253:7,
255:19, 258:6,
269:16, 275:11,
280:19, 281:6, 282:1,
282:25, 283:17,
293:25, 298:20,
299:11, 300:6
Governor's [3] -
156:9, 161:9, 210:2
grade [1] - 157:8
grain [1] - 246:23
grant [9] - 161:7,
180:6, 189:5, 189:6,
189:12, 189:13,
189:24, 192:3, 192:6
granted [4] - 191:2,
192:6, 269:9
granting [7] -
126:25, 188:23,
189:6, 190:21, 191:8,
191:23, 210:5
grants [2] - 123:9,
180:2
great [13] - 146:4,
147:13, 188:2,
197:18, 199:7,
223:17, 238:13,
247:23, 250:22,
252:15, 280:17, 286:3
Great [2] - 215:16,
224:23
greater [6] - 136:17,
215:13, 270:1, 274:1,
274:2, 296:10
greatest [3] - 139:2,
197:22, 230:25
Green [1] - 130:23
grew [3] - 156:25,
264:16, 283:22
grocery [7] - 200:17,
200:22, 200:24,
201:13, 204:17,
204:21, 206:15
ground [6] - 135:16,
135:17, 135:20,
153:17, 209:9, 212:17
groundwater [9] -
124:12, 131:20,
137:18, 137:20,
137:23, 141:20,
146:20, 153:25
group [2] - 262:10,
271:2
grouping [1] -
298:24
groups [1] - 285:13
grow [5] - 216:11,
217:13, 261:10,
267:11, 273:24
grower [1] - 174:8
growing [1] - 219:10
grown [2] - 198:7,
241:19
guess [13] - 129:11,
145:22, 202:11,
210:12, 227:11,
234:14, 236:1, 237:7,
252:25, 262:22,
278:1, 292:20
guidance [3] -
219:17, 282:3, 284:21
guilt [1] - 189:7
guy [1] - 248:8
H
HAGER [23] - 280:1,
280:14, 280:19,
282:15, 283:17,
284:12, 284:25,
285:3, 285:10,
286:11, 287:13,
287:16, 287:22,
288:16, 288:23,
291:1, 291:21,
293:15, 294:14,
295:20, 296:14,
297:13, 298:17
Hager [4] - 116:7,
257:16, 280:4, 299:14
haircut [1] - 258:5
half [4] - 158:10,
158:15, 227:22,
295:12
halfway [5] - 135:15,
135:19, 201:11,
201:12, 201:13
halt [2] - 151:24,
166:9
halted [1] - 178:5
hand [2] - 139:19,
164:7
handle [4] - 173:19,
194:9, 245:17
handled [3] - 153:13,
264:1, 280:12
handles [1] - 173:11
handling [1] - 295:25
hands [2] - 262:1,
264:6
happiness [1] -
270:13
happy [11] - 124:22,
130:10, 132:2,
189:20, 195:9, 217:9,
243:21, 249:10,
249:11, 276:23,
282:20
harboring [1] -
231:13
hard [8] - 212:6,
216:10, 218:6,
218:13, 252:3,
265:14, 292:2, 295:21
harm [18] - 125:5,
141:24, 142:2,
142:13, 142:17,
144:9, 144:14,
150:10, 151:24,
154:20, 160:3,
160:20, 160:21,
162:14, 292:7
harnessing [1] -
264:8
hat [1] - 300:8
hate [1] - 195:10
head [4] - 181:16,
244:11, 244:12, 278:3
headed [3] - 166:14,
172:3, 215:24
heads [1] - 141:9
Health [1] - 231:23
health [2] - 262:10,
270:13
healthcare [6] -
261:22, 263:1, 263:3,
286:7, 286:8, 287:12
Healthcare [2] -
262:21, 286:6
hear [10] - 120:22,
130:7, 130:8, 130:14,
130:17, 130:18,
162:8, 220:2, 246:19,
253:25
heard [10] - 131:11,
152:15, 172:13,
177:2, 187:11, 219:6,
232:16, 239:14,
259:15, 292:21
hearing [11] -
117:21, 121:8,
122:12, 143:19,
155:16, 159:22,
160:10, 161:6, 172:9,
172:15, 252:21
Hearing [1] - 186:5
hearings [2] - 162:2,
172:10
Hearings [1] -
122:17
heat [3] - 281:19,
283:6, 293:6
heavy [1] - 136:4
heck [1] - 136:12
HEEKIN [21] -
188:23, 189:11,
189:20, 189:23,
190:16, 190:20,
191:7, 191:16,
191:22, 193:11,
193:19, 193:24,
196:5, 209:7, 209:11,
209:13, 209:23,
210:4, 211:7, 211:10,
211:25
held [1] - 184:18
help [9] - 168:2,
172:16, 188:16,
202:23, 207:5,
243:16, 247:6,
263:10, 266:25
helped [3] - 243:13,
249:17, 251:9
helpful [3] - 167:19,
169:4, 237:16
helping [1] - 234:18
helps [3] - 243:24,
244:3
hesitation [1] - 255:1
high [4] - 239:16,
256:5, 268:2, 273:4
high-loss [1] - 273:4
higher [2] - 141:8,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
13
219:1
highest [3] - 134:22,
134:25, 139:1
highly [1] - 282:25
Hillsborough [1] -
245:15
himself [2] - 193:8,
195:6
hindrance [2] -
243:16, 243:18
hire [2] - 278:10,
278:14
hired [2] - 278:8,
278:13
historical [2] -
175:13, 224:11
historically [1] -
272:13
history [3] - 197:9,
202:6, 286:2
hit [2] - 159:2, 252:8
hold [2] - 274:8,
299:4
holder [1] - 157:15
holds [1] - 138:8
Holmes [1] - 142:24
home [3] - 196:23,
200:14, 201:24
homeowners [2] -
289:13, 297:14
homestead [2] -
230:13, 230:18
Homestead [2] -
137:4, 137:8
honest [2] - 147:2,
249:5
honestly [1] - 199:1
honor [3] - 215:13,
226:6, 241:12
honored [2] -
258:13, 280:15
hook [1] - 207:2
hope [2] - 171:18,
245:14
hoped [2] - 276:7,
276:25
hopefully [3] - 156:9,
204:15, 271:21
hoping [2] - 172:15,
213:2
hopper [3] - 167:22,
168:16, 168:21
Hopping [1] - 130:23
horizontally [1] -
133:9
host [1] - 226:20
hot [5] - 134:1,
254:21, 268:11,
281:19
hours [3] - 210:13,
212:1
House [1] - 295:10
house [25] - 190:10,
190:11, 198:19,
199:16, 200:10,
201:1, 201:11,
201:12, 201:13,
201:18, 202:15,
204:7, 204:9, 204:16,
204:25, 206:6, 206:9,
206:10, 206:15,
206:17, 206:18,
207:25, 208:2,
208:12, 208:15
houses [1] - 174:12
housing [2] - 207:13,
276:2
huge [5] - 133:11,
136:7, 261:6, 262:13,
262:15
human [1] - 171:18
humorous [1] -
237:10
hundred [9] - 141:1,
219:4, 220:15,
228:10, 236:12,
242:12, 246:17,
247:14, 282:19
hundreds [1] -
136:24
hurricane [2] -
177:25, 265:21
hurricane-free [1] -
265:21
hurricanes [3] -
267:19, 267:20,
284:17
hydrogen [1] -
136:14
hypersaline [8] -
127:5, 127:6, 131:19,
144:12, 157:21,
163:10, 168:18,
168:19
I
idea [5] - 216:15,
223:4, 242:18,
265:14, 286:1
ideas [2] - 266:25,
273:14
identify [1] - 163:20
identifying [1] -
284:14
identity [2] - 231:8,
231:21
ignorance [1] -
167:16
ignore [2] - 149:9,
243:9
immediate [6] -
181:18, 189:5,
189:12, 190:9,
192:20, 298:6
immediately [7] -
133:15, 189:24,
199:9, 219:15,
266:11, 288:14,
298:10
impact [6] - 126:25,
127:4, 135:23,
181:20, 181:21, 276:3
impacted [3] - 182:7,
234:13, 235:7
impacts [3] - 125:12,
129:2, 173:23
impair [1] - 137:22
impaired [1] - 138:12
implement [3] -
232:23, 260:1, 281:7
implementing [2] -
260:22, 261:1
implies [1] - 221:17
important [7] -
124:10, 134:9, 222:5,
244:14, 245:18,
254:23, 261:21
importantly [1] -
232:22
impose [3] - 142:16,
144:8, 150:21
imposed [3] -
175:19, 196:11, 208:8
imposing [1] -
207:16
impressed [1] -
252:17
impression [1] -
207:13
impressive [2] -
228:6, 252:13
improper [1] - 128:8
improperly [1] -
129:16
improve [8] - 124:11,
124:17, 129:4,
131:20, 165:16,
230:7, 231:25, 266:11
improved [1] - 280:8
IMPROVEMENT [1] -
115:14
improvement [2] -
141:20, 248:7
improves [2] - 155:4,
163:12
IN [2] - 114:4, 117:2
inaccurate [1] -
164:23
Inc [1] - 123:1
incarceration [1] -
193:16
inclined [1] - 161:12
include [2] - 168:16,
203:23
included [1] - 119:8
including [4] -
128:15, 131:15,
185:8, 275:24
incomes [1] - 263:10
inconsistent [3] -
129:5, 294:16, 295:17
incorrect [2] -
129:17, 174:13
increase [2] - 135:6,
295:24
increases [1] - 296:5
indebted [1] - 213:10
indeed [1] - 220:11
independence [1] -
285:11
independent [1] -
285:6
independently [1] -
265:8
INDEX [2] - 115:1,
116:2
INDICATIONS) [1] -
169:18
individual [5] -
202:17, 252:3,
283:10, 286:13
individuals [8] -
225:1, 256:12, 260:6,
262:11, 283:1,
286:16, 286:21, 294:9
indulge [1] - 156:16
industry [3] - 157:7,
280:10, 288:8
inevitable [1] -
217:12
inexcusable [1] -
161:2
inferred [1] - 132:23
influence [1] -
127:13
inform [3] - 141:21,
160:18, 167:15
informal [1] - 220:5
information [11] -
124:6, 170:21, 182:3,
218:4, 218:12,
244:18, 245:7, 245:8,
245:12, 247:11,
260:24
infrastructure [1] -
157:9
infringing [1] -
161:15
infused [3] - 184:15,
184:24, 185:3
ingredient [1] -
164:10
ingredients [1] -
271:18
initial [2] - 268:25,
269:6
initiative [3] - 221:7,
221:18, 295:22
initiatives [3] -
164:9, 227:8, 263:23
injury [5] - 181:17,
181:18, 271:23,
295:19, 296:21
Inmate [3] - 187:10,
187:14, 187:23
input [7] - 125:1,
164:22, 173:13,
259:6, 259:8, 259:15,
260:15
inside [1] - 167:12
insights [1] - 273:20
insignificant [1] -
139:3
insolvency [2] -
292:4, 292:5
instances [2] -
129:14, 243:25
instead [2] - 144:11,
155:7
Insurance [10] -
257:7, 262:4, 264:1,
278:4, 282:19,
284:11, 284:13,
287:5, 292:11, 299:13
insurance [58] -
261:4, 261:5, 261:7,
261:8, 261:9, 261:12,
261:16, 263:7,
263:11, 263:16,
263:22, 264:5, 264:8,
264:10, 264:11,
264:14, 264:18,
264:22, 265:2, 265:7,
265:11, 265:13,
266:4, 266:19,
266:21, 268:7, 273:5,
273:11, 273:16,
275:3, 275:4, 275:15,
280:9, 280:10,
280:22, 281:1, 281:8,
281:10, 281:11,
281:12, 281:23,
282:5, 286:2, 288:7,
288:20, 289:25,
290:3, 291:21,
291:23, 292:3,
292:15, 293:16,
293:18, 294:24,
294:25, 297:4, 298:7,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
14
298:25
INSURANCE [2] -
116:5, 257:3
insured [1] - 262:16
insured's [2] -
272:19, 272:20
insureds [1] - 262:10
insurer [1] - 289:15
insurers [10] - 263:6,
270:13, 287:9, 290:1,
290:15, 290:18,
291:5, 294:21, 296:1,
297:20
Insurers [1] - 292:14
integral [1] - 143:10
integrate [1] - 202:17
integrated [1] -
229:17
integrates [1] -
143:16
integrating [2] -
208:16, 208:17
integrity [1] - 159:4
intend [1] - 163:7
intense [1] - 282:17
intention [1] - 248:5
interacting [1] -
249:24
interaction [2] -
217:15, 248:16
interactions [1] -
217:21
interest [2] - 248:19,
259:9
interested [4] -
234:11, 237:25,
282:25, 283:1
interesting [4] -
121:10, 121:11,
143:3, 172:10
interests [1] - 125:23
interface [3] -
158:19, 158:22, 238:2
interference [1] -
283:5
internal [1] - 166:22
INTERNAL [1] -
115:13
International [1] -
137:4
interpretation [3] -
180:13, 180:25,
182:15
interpretations [1] -
236:24
interrupt [1] - 144:24
interrupted [2] -
149:16, 149:24
interrupting [1] -
287:17
intersected [1] -
281:24
intervening [1] -
176:7
Intervenor [1] -
132:16
interview [8] -
214:16, 214:17,
226:7, 229:5, 255:16,
257:14, 278:2, 293:14
INTERVIEW [4] -
115:20, 116:4, 214:2,
257:2
interviewing [1] -
277:22
interviews [2] -
214:7, 257:5
intimidating [1] -
235:15
intriguing [1] -
291:16
intrusion [10] -
150:8, 157:22,
157:24, 158:1,
163:15, 163:21,
163:25, 168:8,
168:14, 178:5
invade [1] - 151:20
invalid [1] - 128:18
invalidated [1] -
153:3
invoice [1] - 237:19
invoke [1] - 220:18
involve [1] - 275:8
involved [7] -
121:12, 169:12,
196:18, 268:13,
269:23, 275:24, 287:1
ionized [1] - 136:14
Iowa [3] - 283:22,
286:2, 291:19
IPO [1] - 276:17
irrelevant [1] - 128:2
isolation [1] - 161:3
isotope [1] - 136:17
issuance [2] - 126:3,
163:13
issue [35] - 121:2,
121:4, 123:10, 124:2,
125:8, 126:24,
128:10, 128:21,
128:23, 129:3,
129:25, 140:10,
144:21, 146:2,
150:24, 151:12,
163:7, 163:8, 168:6,
175:13, 177:15,
177:21, 180:10,
180:12, 180:23,
181:7, 181:11,
181:13, 184:7,
193:22, 250:16,
261:2, 286:12, 286:19
issued [5] - 121:19,
122:20, 153:21,
157:9, 157:10
issues [32] - 123:16,
123:17, 123:20,
124:2, 125:13, 130:2,
157:17, 157:19,
164:15, 171:2,
181:14, 184:23,
216:10, 216:11,
217:17, 217:23,
217:25, 219:9,
219:14, 244:5,
244:20, 245:21,
261:13, 273:4,
284:19, 289:9,
289:11, 290:9, 297:3,
297:14, 298:2
Item [2] - 117:11,
117:23
item [7] - 117:14,
118:10, 123:4,
131:24, 179:17,
182:22, 298:12
items [7] - 117:10,
118:17, 120:22,
150:6, 165:20, 177:7,
177:19
itself [2] - 126:7,
133:6
J
Jack [4] - 188:2,
188:4, 188:20, 209:6
Jacksonville [4] -
234:15, 234:21,
236:4, 287:3
jail [5] - 193:2, 193:3,
193:6, 193:10, 193:21
James [6] - 115:23,
115:24, 214:18,
226:3, 233:8
JAMES [2] - 226:1,
234:1
January [3] - 122:19,
214:11, 257:8
JEFF [1] - 114:11
Jeff [3] - 269:17,
271:22, 273:17
Jefferson [1] -
139:24
JEFFREY [1] - 258:2
Jeffrey [3] - 116:6,
257:15, 258:5
Jim [4] - 219:18,
232:7, 235:5, 239:11
job [35] - 147:4,
148:7, 151:1, 152:16,
160:18, 162:9, 168:6,
172:11, 177:19,
186:15, 217:1,
234:19, 235:7,
238:11, 238:13,
251:12, 252:20,
253:22, 254:12,
256:1, 256:13, 258:9,
266:18, 267:4,
274:14, 274:17,
274:19, 275:7,
280:17, 282:8, 285:9,
293:5, 293:21
jobs [3] - 254:20,
254:21, 274:21
joins [1] - 131:22
joking [1] - 255:7
journey [1] - 241:17
Judge [48] - 122:18,
122:20, 124:4,
124:15, 125:14,
127:9, 127:24, 128:5,
128:12, 128:13,
129:15, 129:21,
131:11, 131:24,
136:9, 137:13,
138:14, 138:21,
141:3, 141:11, 142:4,
144:17, 145:18,
145:21, 146:3, 146:5,
146:23, 148:18,
150:3, 151:8, 151:21,
153:2, 155:3, 159:15,
159:17, 160:17,
161:5, 161:25,
163:11, 168:11,
168:12, 172:18,
177:17, 177:22,
180:14, 181:1, 185:16
Judge's [9] - 119:17,
130:4, 141:12, 142:6,
151:14, 178:19,
180:1, 183:8, 184:10
judgment [1] - 224:3
judicata [1] - 126:5
judicial [1] - 119:5
Julie [1] - 187:6
July [1] - 284:1
jumped [1] - 288:1
junk [1] - 296:18
jurisdiction [2] -
151:17, 184:4
justice [1] - 198:23
Justice [2] - 175:17,
177:10
K
Katrina [2] - 297:16
keep [5] - 167:12,
192:23, 270:19,
274:20, 275:5
keeping [2] - 231:13,
249:22
keeps [1] - 231:13
Ken [4] - 243:4,
253:21, 254:2, 254:5
kept [1] - 228:20
Kettering [1] - 287:2
Kevin [1] - 266:13
key [1] - 296:4
Keys [1] - 161:18
kidding [1] - 255:5
kind [20] - 147:5,
154:13, 198:12,
226:23, 230:4,
234:10, 235:5, 236:5,
237:24, 238:18,
239:3, 240:12,
240:13, 247:21,
251:9, 268:4, 278:5,
287:6, 288:9, 289:18
kinds [4] - 178:6,
231:4, 292:10, 295:3
knowledge [1] -
226:11
knowledgeable [1] -
262:6
known [2] - 146:5,
297:23
kowtow [1] - 235:13
Kristin [1] - 299:24
Kruse [1] - 115:12
L
Labor [1] - 271:10
labyrinth [2] - 134:12
laced [1] - 136:13
lack [2] - 172:7,
172:19
laid [3] - 148:8,
219:22, 269:17
lamp [1] - 136:5
landward [1] - 158:8
language [5] -
181:14, 181:25,
182:16, 201:19,
205:11
large [8] - 122:11,
132:23, 134:12,
230:5, 236:3, 241:21,
245:14, 285:20
largely [3] - 237:2,
276:10, 276:24
larger [1] - 132:25
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
15
largest [4] - 216:4,
234:19, 261:6, 261:8
last [26] - 121:20,
141:12, 151:3, 158:3,
181:2, 181:5, 187:19,
187:20, 191:18,
192:1, 195:10,
197:15, 198:15,
202:7, 208:23,
214:13, 220:23,
222:21, 223:1,
231:15, 237:3, 241:3,
245:25, 257:5,
277:24, 288:1
late [5] - 156:24,
205:21, 205:22,
206:19, 206:21
latest [1] - 138:4
latter [1] - 215:23
lava [1] - 136:4
Law [27] - 119:16,
122:18, 122:20,
124:4, 127:24,
129:21, 131:11,
131:23, 137:13,
138:14, 141:11,
142:4, 144:17,
145:18, 145:21,
146:3, 146:5, 146:23,
151:8, 151:21,
159:15, 161:25,
180:14, 181:1, 183:7,
184:9, 185:16
law [24] - 120:18,
124:25, 125:18,
125:19, 127:21,
129:18, 142:19,
146:10, 146:12,
151:9, 151:13,
151:14, 152:18,
167:4, 175:8, 182:19,
183:13, 183:23,
183:25, 184:3, 184:6,
184:12, 216:16
laws [2] - 230:6,
246:10
Lawson [2] - 243:4,
253:22
lawsuit [2] - 269:4,
269:5
lawsuits [1] - 269:2
lawyer [8] - 171:24,
244:9, 244:23, 246:5,
255:2, 280:21, 280:22
lawyers [2] - 171:25,
244:10
lay [3] - 120:18,
184:25, 217:2
laying [1] - 231:5
lead [2] - 217:1,
281:18
leader [1] - 225:19
leaders [4] - 219:12,
219:13, 252:16,
269:13
leadership [15] -
229:25, 232:9,
232:21, 241:21,
250:4, 254:16,
255:11, 255:14,
259:7, 267:8, 269:11,
270:22, 281:16,
283:4, 283:11
leading [3] - 183:17,
225:16, 281:17
leads [1] - 220:1
League [1] - 222:18
league [1] - 222:23
learn [2] - 249:17,
283:8
learned [3] - 291:25,
292:19
learning [2] - 250:15,
251:4
least [11] - 126:18,
136:24, 137:19,
150:18, 160:11,
160:12, 167:16,
167:19, 191:12,
226:7, 295:14
leave [3] - 152:4,
176:19, 239:23
leaves [1] - 200:15
leaving [1] - 183:10
led [1] - 283:24
left [2] - 128:6,
227:22
leg [1] - 270:14
legal [11] - 131:6,
138:7, 161:16,
168:18, 182:5,
212:17, 241:19,
243:15, 250:17,
282:18, 289:5
legally [3] - 168:22,
171:24, 171:25
legged [1] - 270:12
legislation [2] -
218:3, 259:22
Legislative [1] -
225:16
legislative [8] -
216:12, 216:21,
218:19, 219:12,
221:6, 222:8, 237:3,
284:20
legislator [1] - 285:5
Legislature [8] -
222:18, 259:22,
280:8, 280:12,
281:21, 284:19,
297:1, 298:9
legislature [2] -
218:25, 290:7
length [2] - 133:21,
197:4
Leon [16] - 115:25,
214:19, 241:3, 241:4,
250:3, 251:16,
251:24, 252:8,
252:19, 253:1,
253:19, 254:8,
254:15, 256:3, 256:7,
256:18
LEON [2] - 241:1,
301:3
Leon's [1] - 253:13
less [6] - 144:13,
158:19, 171:10,
175:3, 181:17, 291:7
less-than-
constructive [1] -
291:7
lessons [4] - 291:18,
291:25, 292:1, 292:18
letting [3] - 194:4,
194:12, 205:23
level [8] - 133:19,
134:8, 136:25,
184:20, 218:1, 229:1,
238:21
LEVEL [1] - 114:16
leveled [2] - 268:20,
293:13
levels [3] - 136:17,
141:9, 238:18
LexisNexis [1] -
230:19
liability [1] - 231:1
license [7] - 144:6,
153:10, 153:20,
154:12, 160:15,
161:12, 178:9
licenses [1] - 143:11
lied [1] - 194:13
lies [1] - 258:21
Lieutenant [1] -
230:14
life [13] - 192:21,
213:14, 224:12,
263:6, 263:7, 263:11,
283:14, 284:6,
287:24, 288:7,
288:10, 295:13, 297:4
light [3] - 157:20,
159:14, 293:6
Light [15] - 117:25,
119:19, 119:23,
121:15, 122:15,
123:23, 124:5,
126:22, 129:19,
130:19, 140:5,
140:16, 142:8,
153:21, 163:3
Light's [3] - 123:6,
127:18, 137:12
likely [2] - 158:16,
292:5
limerock [3] - 133:5,
157:8, 159:2
limit [3] - 154:2,
154:6, 289:13
limitation [1] -
129:25
limitations [3] -
119:20, 196:4, 196:10
limited [15] - 119:4,
121:7, 125:22, 126:7,
142:20, 148:8, 149:6,
165:3, 165:24,
170:23, 176:11,
180:2, 181:10,
195:24, 218:14
line [5] - 192:8,
282:9, 294:23, 295:16
lines [7] - 118:14,
196:15, 273:5,
274:25, 281:10,
291:24, 295:9
Lisa [4] - 217:19,
218:24, 219:18,
225:17
list [1] - 254:15
listen [6] - 152:16,
171:21, 224:3,
259:12, 266:1, 270:8
listened [2] - 171:22,
171:23
listening [1] - 283:9
literally [1] - 137:7
live [2] - 218:18,
230:21
lived [1] - 237:18
livelihood [1] -
156:15
living [1] - 287:23
local [5] - 157:11,
163:18, 200:17,
209:25, 245:9
location [1] - 134:23
LOCATION [1] -
114:15
locked [1] - 194:25
long-term [7] -
263:1, 263:3, 287:14,
287:19, 287:20,
288:3, 288:11
longevity [1] -
287:25
look [23] - 153:22,
159:24, 166:1,
197:10, 199:25,
215:17, 219:4,
219:20, 220:16,
221:6, 222:5, 222:7,
226:24, 234:15,
237:16, 246:17,
265:17, 269:19,
272:12, 273:6,
286:25, 296:12,
296:20
looked [8] - 196:6,
219:24, 224:15,
226:12, 237:19,
273:13, 296:8, 297:9
looking [14] -
136:21, 143:25,
166:6, 169:3, 258:21,
260:11, 260:18,
267:2, 273:17,
282:21, 284:8,
285:25, 286:12,
294:10
looks [2] - 122:9,
133:2
loose [1] - 206:14
lose [2] - 159:4,
250:21
loss [5] - 158:5,
265:17, 267:18,
273:4, 295:25
lost [9] - 153:12,
219:7, 224:22,
224:25, 226:23,
229:6, 229:12,
276:21, 276:22
low [1] - 272:20
LOWER [1] - 114:16
lower [5] - 174:24,
239:22, 265:12,
274:2, 275:5
lowest [1] - 134:19
loyal [2] - 283:2
luck [2] - 213:7,
213:15
lukewarm [2] -
150:15, 150:17
M
ma'am [7] - 120:16,
130:15, 147:23,
148:5, 149:12,
183:15, 222:14
magazines [1] -
226:18
magnitude [1] -
158:14
mail [1] - 227:3
main [2] - 245:8,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
16
247:11
maintain [2] -
223:12, 274:5
major [3] - 228:9,
281:3, 285:17
majority [2] - 124:16,
253:2
makings [1] - 184:24
malpractice [3] -
272:24, 273:10,
298:12
manage [9] - 215:19,
216:20, 219:20,
234:18, 262:14,
263:10, 282:12,
282:20, 294:12
managed [11] -
215:21, 215:22,
216:5, 234:8, 234:14,
253:21, 254:17,
258:24, 259:2,
282:16, 282:18
Management [15] -
131:15, 131:23,
136:19, 139:25,
140:17, 141:15,
145:13, 153:16,
154:16, 158:4, 159:7,
160:9, 173:9, 173:19,
216:1
management [21] -
216:6, 226:14, 233:2,
234:9, 234:10,
234:19, 238:18,
239:7, 240:12,
250:10, 255:10,
258:25, 259:5, 269:3,
275:15, 275:20,
277:3, 282:15,
282:22, 283:6, 283:7
managing [4] -
228:24, 234:17,
241:20
Manatee [1] - 245:15
mandatory [1] -
296:21
manner [1] - 166:11
Manuel [1] - 187:10
Mappers [2] -
248:17, 249:14
maps [1] - 137:5
march [1] - 158:7
March [8] - 121:20,
187:11, 199:8,
199:12, 202:12,
208:4, 214:11, 257:9
MARCH [1] - 114:14
marched [1] - 284:2
Market [1] - 292:14
market [20] - 261:4,
261:6, 261:7, 261:8,
261:9, 261:16,
263:16, 267:11,
267:12, 270:3, 280:9,
293:18, 294:7, 294:8,
294:18, 294:25,
295:6, 297:15
marketing [1] -
230:16
marketplace [6] -
261:22, 269:21,
284:14, 286:8,
290:15, 293:17
markets [9] - 269:20,
282:5, 288:21,
289:21, 289:25,
290:11, 290:20
massive [3] - 133:3,
146:19, 157:21
mathematics [1] -
281:5
matter [2] - 148:4,
275:22
maximum [3] -
174:8, 193:24, 294:18
Mayo [1] - 287:3
mayor [1] - 234:18
McCall [1] - 187:6
MCCALL [5] - 187:8,
187:18, 187:21,
188:1, 188:3
McCarty [1] - 266:13
MCKEE [10] - 215:2,
215:9, 215:22,
217:18, 219:5,
222:21, 222:24,
223:20, 224:20,
225:21
McKee [4] - 115:22,
214:17, 215:5, 238:13
mean [28] - 153:22,
162:13, 171:22,
175:9, 194:13, 195:8,
201:22, 204:7,
206:14, 210:19,
210:20, 228:23,
229:7, 231:2, 235:20,
237:14, 238:11,
253:7, 254:13,
254:21, 276:18,
288:3, 288:21,
288:22, 289:7, 289:8,
291:15, 299:9
meaning [1] - 216:12
means [6] - 119:7,
120:10, 166:8,
191:10, 270:8, 288:23
meant [2] - 177:12,
273:11
measure [2] -
216:18, 276:25
measures [8] -
163:20, 219:19,
219:20, 219:22,
220:6, 220:8, 220:15,
220:19
measuring [1] -
229:19
meat [1] - 169:2
mechanical [1] -
144:11
mechanism [1] -
266:5
med [1] - 228:13
media [2] - 269:5,
293:13
medical [6] - 201:21,
204:19, 204:20,
272:23, 273:10,
298:12
meet [7] - 124:7,
128:15, 128:22,
217:22, 253:24,
290:18, 293:2
MEETING [3] -
114:4, 114:15, 300:13
meeting [19] -
117:12, 132:18,
187:11, 190:1,
191:18, 192:1,
195:11, 197:16,
198:15, 199:12,
204:12, 205:16,
206:2, 214:15,
257:13, 297:6,
299:23, 300:11,
300:12
meets [3] - 131:13,
131:16, 163:12
member [1] - 198:21
members [11] -
120:9, 121:12,
132:13, 156:5, 163:6,
218:6, 260:8, 277:2,
280:20, 281:6, 285:19
MEMBERS [1] -
114:10
memo [2] - 160:8,
161:3
Memorial [1] - 284:2
mentioned [12] -
126:4, 126:23,
128:11, 129:23,
129:24, 164:8,
197:15, 229:4,
244:24, 252:11,
294:4, 296:4
merit [1] - 284:20
message [2] -
246:25, 291:12
met [6] - 123:23,
124:7, 128:20,
150:18, 165:15, 254:6
meted [1] - 289:14
method [1] - 239:21
methods [1] - 181:22
metrics [1] - 227:9
METZKE [3] -
114:18, 301:5, 301:11
mgd [8] - 165:5,
165:22, 173:6,
173:16, 173:22,
174:4, 174:12, 175:25
Miami [13] - 138:17,
138:18, 156:19,
157:5, 157:16, 158:4,
168:17, 168:22,
176:7, 177:16,
230:15, 254:4
Miami-Dade [11] -
138:17, 138:18,
156:19, 157:5,
157:16, 158:4,
168:17, 168:22,
176:7, 177:16, 230:15
microwave [1] -
271:17
middle [2] - 270:10,
299:22
might [11] - 132:8,
161:4, 169:5, 209:21,
238:24, 243:18,
248:7, 252:23, 299:11
migration [4] -
131:21, 154:22,
154:25, 155:14
Mike [3] - 130:25,
163:2, 169:9
mildly [1] - 132:24
mile [2] - 138:6,
159:10
miles [6] - 137:2,
137:15, 137:25,
158:10, 158:15
million [20] - 121:24,
134:24, 135:8,
135:11, 135:12,
136:1, 136:2, 138:24,
139:4, 154:9, 161:8,
168:8, 177:24,
229:22, 231:10,
259:4, 264:17,
264:18, 270:4, 294:9
millions [1] - 139:3
mind [6] - 141:10,
144:2, 165:25, 253:8,
274:20, 292:8
mind-bending [1] -
292:8
minds [1] - 298:25
mindset [2] - 243:14,
274:1
mine [4] - 157:23,
157:25, 159:2, 159:4
minimum [1] -
137:18
mining [6] - 138:9,
156:24, 157:2,
158:21, 158:22,
158:23
minor [1] - 119:1
minuses [1] - 238:10
minute [3] - 155:12,
212:8, 224:11
minutes [4] - 117:11,
117:16, 156:17, 299:8
Mirasol [1] - 142:22
mischief [1] - 295:4
misinformed [1] -
207:12
misled [4] - 192:17,
275:20, 276:12,
276:13
miss [1] - 192:18
missed [1] - 221:22
missing [1] - 230:1
mistake [1] - 223:5
mistakes [2] - 239:5,
292:2
mix [1] - 288:25
models [1] - 140:15
modernizing [1] -
228:25
modification [60] -
118:22, 119:23,
121:14, 121:23,
122:13, 122:14,
122:21, 123:7,
123:15, 124:11,
124:14, 125:10,
125:12, 125:13,
125:24, 126:6, 126:7,
127:4, 129:2, 129:3,
130:3, 138:23,
139:15, 140:18,
141:19, 142:1,
142:12, 142:15,
142:20, 143:11,
143:13, 143:25,
144:8, 144:10,
144:19, 144:21,
145:6, 146:21,
150:22, 153:20,
153:23, 154:7, 154:8,
154:21, 160:5,
160:20, 162:20,
165:4, 165:10,
165:11, 168:10,
178:6, 180:3, 180:9,
180:22, 181:13,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
17
182:8, 183:4, 183:5
modifications [10] -
119:1, 121:16,
121:17, 129:24,
142:21, 146:14,
165:7, 178:18, 180:2,
180:20
modified [4] - 126:9,
126:13, 143:5, 183:6
modify [4] - 117:25,
119:11, 144:6, 195:9
modifying [1] - 152:2
moment [1] - 274:5
money [4] - 228:15,
276:21, 276:22, 295:1
monitor [1] - 262:12
monitoring [6] -
122:24, 138:2,
158:24, 190:14,
190:15, 190:17
Monroe [1] - 157:6
month [7] - 193:2,
202:8, 208:24,
210:21, 210:24,
299:20, 299:21
months [43] - 190:9,
190:10, 197:10,
197:11, 198:18,
198:19, 199:2, 199:3,
199:16, 199:17,
200:10, 202:25,
203:1, 203:2, 203:4,
203:6, 203:7, 203:16,
203:17, 203:20,
203:23, 203:24,
204:6, 204:8, 204:9,
204:10, 205:15,
205:17, 206:21,
206:23, 206:25,
207:25, 208:2, 208:3,
237:19
morning [3] -
156:14, 212:13,
212:16
most [15] - 124:9,
139:2, 215:20,
215:22, 224:20,
226:25, 231:23,
234:14, 245:16,
247:5, 259:1, 281:22,
290:21, 295:6, 298:24
mostly [1] - 217:16
motion [21] - 117:13,
117:21, 179:16,
182:22, 182:23,
185:24, 186:5, 204:4,
207:23, 207:24,
208:18, 209:10,
210:2, 211:14, 213:4,
253:1, 255:17, 256:6,
294:6, 299:12
move [18] - 117:15,
139:21, 141:6, 155:1,
160:11, 185:7,
192:21, 216:8,
223:13, 225:6,
251:13, 251:23,
282:4, 282:5, 288:19,
288:20, 292:5, 292:6
moved [5] - 137:14,
227:18, 264:15,
291:10, 295:10
movement [2] -
138:16, 166:9
moves [4] - 133:7,
136:3, 137:24, 155:2
moving [16] - 124:23,
127:2, 140:20,
159:12, 162:18,
166:17, 171:23,
195:14, 225:11,
253:3, 273:13,
273:24, 289:12,
289:20, 290:11,
297:10
MR [197] - 117:9,
117:23, 118:9, 120:2,
120:5, 120:16,
121:13, 130:9,
130:15, 130:18,
130:22, 132:9,
132:10, 132:13,
145:1, 145:3, 145:19,
145:22, 146:1,
146:11, 147:11,
147:16, 147:19,
147:23, 148:5, 149:3,
149:12, 149:15,
149:21, 149:25,
152:10, 152:13,
152:20, 152:25,
154:6, 154:23, 155:1,
155:7, 155:15,
155:21, 155:24,
156:1, 156:4, 162:2,
162:6, 162:11, 163:1,
163:2, 163:5, 164:19,
164:25, 166:3,
166:19, 166:21,
167:7, 167:10,
167:13, 168:4,
169:10, 169:15,
169:25, 170:6, 170:8,
170:13, 170:16,
170:20, 172:22,
173:7, 173:10,
173:17, 173:21,
174:2, 174:5, 174:10,
174:14, 174:17,
174:22, 175:1, 175:6,
175:11, 175:15,
175:25, 176:8, 177:4,
177:7, 178:19,
178:22, 179:1, 179:3,
179:5, 179:11,
179:22, 180:6, 180:9,
180:18, 181:6,
181:23, 182:11,
182:14, 183:5,
183:15, 183:18,
183:20, 183:24,
184:2, 184:13,
185:12, 185:14,
186:7, 186:10,
188:23, 189:11,
189:20, 189:23,
190:16, 190:20,
191:7, 191:16,
191:22, 193:11,
193:19, 193:24,
196:5, 209:7, 209:11,
209:13, 209:23,
210:4, 211:7, 211:10,
211:25, 215:9,
215:22, 217:18,
219:5, 222:21,
222:24, 223:20,
224:20, 225:21,
226:5, 226:12,
227:15, 228:8,
228:12, 228:23,
229:9, 231:7, 232:14,
233:7, 234:4, 234:10,
234:24, 235:3,
235:21, 236:23,
237:10, 238:7, 238:9,
239:19, 240:18,
241:8, 243:9, 243:23,
244:15, 245:23,
246:18, 248:23,
250:6, 250:13,
251:17, 258:6,
258:10, 259:1,
259:20, 260:8, 261:5,
261:25, 262:19,
262:22, 263:2,
263:21, 264:24,
265:3, 266:12,
267:14, 268:22,
270:6, 272:17,
274:13, 275:19,
277:5, 277:8, 277:11,
277:14, 277:17, 278:1
MS [7] - 187:8,
187:18, 187:21,
188:1, 188:3, 196:9,
196:25
multiple [3] - 133:20,
137:6, 249:18
Multiple [1] - 147:20
multiply [1] - 174:7
mundane [1] -
239:16
municipal [2] -
196:25, 197:2
municipalities [1] -
133:1
municipally [1] -
196:11
must [1] - 189:15
mutually [1] - 294:15
N
name [4] - 132:15,
142:25, 156:11, 300:8
namely [1] - 294:25
names [3] - 287:2,
292:12
NANCY [3] - 114:18,
301:5, 301:11
nancy@metzke.
com [1] - 114:24
Naples [1] - 142:22
narrow [2] - 121:5,
121:6
narrowed [1] - 272:8
nation [1] - 133:4
national [4] - 265:1,
266:17, 267:17,
273:23
nationwide [1] -
273:1
native [1] - 241:14
natural [1] - 137:24
naturally [1] - 136:16
nature [5] - 247:15,
268:12, 268:13, 293:9
Navigator [1] -
286:12
Navigators [4] -
262:18, 262:20,
286:6, 286:14
near [1] - 265:18
necessarily [3] -
196:21, 246:3, 262:14
necessary [3] -
160:17, 219:8, 219:11
necessity [1] -
249:20
need [33] - 120:23,
124:2, 128:11,
128:15, 136:15,
159:18, 159:20,
175:3, 176:1, 177:20,
180:12, 189:11,
191:8, 198:14,
202:23, 217:7,
217:10, 217:11,
218:8, 219:23, 224:5,
242:15, 266:10,
267:20, 267:23,
289:22, 296:20,
297:18, 297:24, 298:9
needed [3] - 219:10,
264:4, 278:10
needs [18] - 174:8,
175:22, 175:23,
194:9, 194:10,
194:21, 195:3,
195:18, 206:6, 223:3,
225:5, 229:7, 235:4,
235:9, 236:10,
271:20, 284:13,
289:24
NEGATIVE [1] -
169:18
negative [2] -
165:22, 292:6
net [1] - 292:6
never [9] - 144:3,
152:15, 160:1,
166:25, 167:3, 171:9,
218:17, 234:22, 294:5
nevertheless [3] -
124:3, 124:6, 276:17
new [8] - 193:12,
225:1, 263:5, 263:18,
266:25, 273:14,
300:10
next [14] - 130:18,
132:10, 133:16,
156:1, 192:18, 199:8,
208:4, 214:7, 226:3,
233:8, 251:3, 295:24,
299:23, 300:12
nice [2] - 197:7,
299:7
night [7] - 136:15,
174:9, 201:7, 228:18,
228:19, 231:6, 231:14
nine [5] - 203:4,
204:10, 208:3, 227:3,
231:10
NO [8] - 115:2,
116:3, 117:20, 132:6,
161:22, 162:24,
186:4, 278:25
nobody [3] - 229:16,
249:11, 297:17
non [2] - 159:22,
244:10
non-lawyers [1] -
244:10
non-permitted [1] -
159:22
none [4] - 117:21,
186:5, 194:18, 258:18
nonetheless [1] -
209:17
normal [1] - 293:8
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
18
normally [1] - 264:9
north [4] - 122:7,
134:22, 135:2, 137:3
northwest [5] -
133:25, 134:4, 134:6,
134:11, 135:11
noted [1] - 269:24
notes [1] - 301:6
nothing [9] - 135:22,
135:23, 160:20,
160:22, 178:1,
269:10, 289:1,
293:21, 294:5
notify [1] - 209:25
November [2] -
142:6, 142:9
nowhere [1] - 265:18
NPDS [1] - 128:25
NRC [1] - 175:9
nuclear [2] - 136:18,
156:20
Number [10] -
117:11, 117:23,
168:7, 181:4, 214:17,
214:18, 214:19,
257:14, 257:15,
259:18
number [14] -
123:15, 123:17,
128:17, 129:13,
166:23, 189:3,
214:17, 215:20,
216:4, 224:25,
229:23, 282:12,
285:21, 287:18
numbers [2] -
231:10, 259:2
Numeral [1] - 154:19
O
Obama [1] - 286:20
objections [3] -
117:19, 126:20, 186:3
obligation [3] -
168:18, 168:19,
175:16
obligations [2] -
168:25, 293:2
observations [2] -
246:15, 247:8
obviously [9] -
130:5, 165:23, 171:6,
223:17, 235:22,
248:18, 284:7,
296:25, 297:14
occasionally [1] -
239:6
occasions [1] -
250:7
occur [1] - 165:14
occurring [7] -
127:7, 136:16, 142:3,
151:25, 173:24,
179:8, 295:23
occurs [1] - 136:17
OF [19] - 114:1,
114:4, 114:12, 115:3,
115:5, 115:7, 115:9,
115:13, 115:18,
115:18, 115:20,
116:5, 187:2, 187:3,
214:3, 257:3, 301:3,
301:3
Offender [3] - 187:7,
187:13, 187:22
offender [14] - 189:1,
190:4, 190:6, 190:16,
192:12, 192:20,
192:22, 195:8,
196:21, 207:14,
207:15, 209:14,
209:15, 209:18
offense [1] - 197:21
offer [2] - 170:11,
273:20
offering [3] - 268:25,
269:6, 287:9
OFFICE [4] - 114:22,
115:3, 116:5, 257:3
Office [7] - 215:24,
215:25, 216:1,
220:17, 224:22,
244:21, 257:6
office [20] - 191:11,
212:22, 220:17,
220:24, 224:21,
225:13, 234:20,
237:18, 239:13,
244:13, 245:8, 245:9,
245:11, 247:11,
254:3, 254:5, 266:9,
273:15, 278:16,
278:19
officer [4] - 259:21,
281:3, 283:3, 285:17
OFFICER [1] -
114:11
offices [6] - 211:8,
225:10, 227:17,
236:11, 242:11,
247:10
official [2] - 218:10,
281:14
officials [3] - 223:2,
223:6, 223:10
often [3] - 207:6,
231:25, 232:24
oil [1] - 157:3
OIR [6] - 282:4,
288:20, 288:24,
289:12, 295:11,
297:20
old [1] - 227:2
older [1] - 288:9
OMB [1] - 271:11
OMISSION) [1] -
117:3
once [12] - 125:15,
129:19, 146:9,
175:18, 181:9,
229:19, 242:4,
247:21, 247:24,
292:3, 298:21
once-through [1] -
175:18
One [1] - 177:7
one [89] - 120:5,
121:22, 121:23,
122:22, 123:7,
126:21, 128:15,
129:24, 133:3, 137:9,
138:2, 138:4, 138:5,
140:10, 142:23,
143:2, 143:8, 143:22,
148:19, 151:6,
159:25, 160:12,
163:9, 169:11,
173:21, 174:9, 178:3,
180:2, 181:2, 181:24,
184:23, 187:16,
188:24, 189:4,
192:11, 195:12,
202:12, 203:14,
205:20, 212:7,
219:14, 226:18,
226:22, 229:13,
230:15, 232:25,
236:9, 237:13,
243:23, 244:2, 246:1,
247:2, 248:4, 248:20,
249:18, 253:16,
254:11, 255:25,
256:13, 260:2,
261:17, 263:9,
263:23, 264:23,
264:25, 265:4,
265:14, 267:20,
271:21, 275:10,
276:1, 281:7, 282:20,
283:20, 284:13,
285:14, 285:15,
286:17, 287:4, 288:5,
292:2, 292:23,
293:20, 294:16,
297:4, 297:5, 298:5
one-year [1] - 178:3
onerous [1] - 209:16
ones [1] - 173:13
ongoing [1] - 266:22
online [3] - 214:13,
246:20, 257:11
open [12] - 125:17,
234:4, 247:25, 257:8,
258:15, 282:2,
289:25, 291:12,
299:19, 299:21,
300:3, 300:6
opened [1] - 214:10
opening [2] - 269:18,
288:19
openness [1] - 283:7
operate [4] - 143:8,
143:19, 175:21,
249:21
operated [2] -
142:12, 144:1
operates [1] - 133:22
operating [6] -
119:4, 119:5, 133:4,
221:3, 259:21, 271:3
operation [7] -
135:22, 141:22,
143:14, 143:24,
144:7, 152:1, 154:10
operational [2] -
261:2, 271:1
operations [2] -
158:23, 165:9
opinion [1] - 259:12
opportunities [3] -
222:6, 232:15, 258:13
opportunity [24] -
156:13, 178:8,
202:13, 221:22,
226:20, 227:20,
229:10, 229:21,
230:9, 230:11,
231:15, 233:7,
258:12, 258:16,
258:20, 268:2, 268:9,
268:19, 270:1,
277:24, 293:4,
293:12, 294:7, 296:12
Opportunity [1] -
231:17
opposed [1] - 232:25
opposite [2] - 128:2,
148:17
optimum [1] - 294:18
option [3] - 190:13,
190:20, 191:23
options [7] - 172:16,
179:21, 189:17,
189:18, 189:22,
189:23, 283:19
order [27] - 121:20,
129:6, 136:10,
137:17, 141:13,
141:14, 142:9,
143:23, 150:7,
150:12, 150:13,
153:1, 153:8, 153:9,
161:7, 164:10, 166:7,
172:6, 176:13,
178:20, 189:2, 191:8,
212:10, 212:13,
218:8, 220:9, 221:4
Order [29] - 117:24,
118:5, 118:23,
118:25, 119:10,
122:20, 123:2, 123:3,
123:5, 123:8, 123:12,
124:19, 126:3, 130:4,
131:5, 131:25,
132:20, 138:20,
138:23, 144:23,
178:11, 179:23,
180:19, 181:4,
182:10, 182:20,
183:1, 185:8, 210:5
ordered [1] - 197:24
orders [1] - 158:14
ordinary [2] - 221:1,
221:6
organization [7] -
238:17, 238:19,
238:22, 239:24,
259:7, 266:23, 267:5
organized [1] -
238:15
organizing [1] -
241:20
original [1] - 298:23
originally [8] -
119:23, 121:15,
188:8, 194:21,
194:24, 201:10,
211:6, 262:3
otherwise [3] -
120:14, 125:9, 206:7
ought [4] - 231:5,
288:7, 299:17, 299:19
ourselves [2] -
191:18, 219:19
outcome [3] - 123:8,
123:11, 259:9
outcomes [1] - 218:5
outlined [2] - 276:16,
278:21
output [1] - 134:11
outside [9] - 158:8,
160:16, 171:10,
199:2, 230:3, 232:3,
266:17, 267:25, 268:6
outsource [1] -
278:15
outstanding [2] -
229:20, 288:25
outward [2] - 139:21,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
19
140:8
overall [2] - 231:25,
290:8
overcome [1] -
260:13
overlap [1] - 291:22
overrun [1] - 138:13
overseeing [1] -
254:18
oversight [1] -
285:16
OVERTON [12] -
234:1, 234:4, 234:10,
234:24, 235:3,
235:21, 236:23,
237:10, 238:7, 238:9,
239:19, 240:18
Overton [3] - 115:24,
214:18, 233:8
overturn [3] -
151:16, 184:9, 184:11
overturns [2] - 273:8
own [9] - 140:1,
198:12, 216:14,
238:23, 260:21,
261:2, 263:24, 265:6,
271:7
owned [1] - 276:22
owner [4] - 171:20,
172:4, 172:17, 284:23
P
package [1] - 221:7
packet [1] - 122:9
page [2] - 141:12,
240:7
PAGE [2] - 115:2,
116:3
paid [7] - 262:8,
265:1, 274:16, 277:9,
277:11, 295:13,
295:14
PAM [1] - 114:10
Panhandle [1] -
245:16
paper [4] - 213:4,
227:3, 278:8, 278:18
papers [1] - 157:20
paperwork [1] -
247:16
parade [1] - 284:1
Paragraph [5] -
125:2, 126:9, 128:19,
129:10, 141:14
paragraph [1] -
179:6
parameters [1] -
120:19
pardon [19] - 189:5,
189:6, 189:13,
189:16, 190:22,
191:1, 191:9, 192:3,
192:5, 192:10,
192:20, 198:17,
199:12, 199:20,
200:1, 204:15, 208:6,
209:4, 264:24
pardoned [1] -
195:13
parents' [1] - 201:18
parimutuel [4] -
248:18, 248:23,
249:11, 254:19
park [2] - 196:14,
252:8
part [40] - 142:5,
143:8, 143:10,
144:22, 153:9,
153:10, 157:24,
162:15, 163:13,
163:22, 176:13,
176:14, 176:15,
176:16, 177:16,
187:18, 190:7,
200:25, 203:20,
206:17, 206:18,
219:15, 219:25,
221:6, 223:25,
224:18, 242:14,
245:14, 250:18,
269:8, 269:12,
270:17, 273:12,
275:16, 276:16,
277:3, 286:22,
289:20, 291:9, 298:8
partial [1] - 126:3
participate [3] -
201:23, 265:7, 293:16
participated [1] -
278:13
participating [2] -
196:13, 196:14
participation [1] -
274:2
participatory [2] -
234:11, 240:12
particular [7] -
151:10, 177:14,
199:1, 237:17,
237:23, 244:18, 271:3
particularly [8] -
200:6, 219:17, 220:2,
221:2, 221:8, 232:3,
268:24, 269:2
parties [3] - 122:23,
185:9, 274:12
partners [1] - 143:3
party [4] - 126:17,
166:7, 166:8, 176:7
pass [2] - 210:8,
272:11
passed [1] - 237:3
passion [1] - 232:20
passionately [1] -
228:6
past [4] - 219:17,
250:12, 282:13, 291:1
Pate [2] - 197:3,
212:11
PATE [29] - 197:8,
198:2, 198:20,
199:10, 199:13,
199:21, 199:23,
200:2, 200:12, 201:2,
201:4, 201:8, 201:16,
201:19, 203:19,
204:1, 204:13,
204:19, 204:22,
205:3, 205:9, 207:15,
207:20, 208:10,
209:1, 209:8, 209:21,
210:14, 212:24
paternity [1] - 245:17
path [3] - 217:3,
217:4, 250:18
paths [1] - 189:3
patience [2] - 223:4,
223:5
patterns [1] - 296:20
pay [4] - 235:12,
264:7, 277:3, 278:14
payback [1] - 262:13
paying [3] - 264:20,
292:17, 295:3
payments [4] -
242:20, 242:21,
245:5, 245:6
peculiar [1] - 151:10
peeling [1] - 271:16
people [74] - 160:6,
202:14, 215:20,
215:22, 216:8,
216:23, 217:1, 217:7,
230:21, 232:24,
234:8, 234:11,
234:14, 234:16,
234:20, 238:20,
239:4, 239:19,
239:23, 240:8,
240:15, 241:16,
242:13, 242:19,
242:20, 242:21,
243:17, 245:5, 246:2,
247:5, 247:24, 248:1,
250:19, 253:21,
253:23, 253:25,
254:17, 254:18,
258:21, 264:9,
265:10, 266:13,
267:6, 270:1, 270:4,
270:9, 270:10,
270:21, 277:22,
278:10, 278:15,
280:7, 282:12,
282:19, 282:25,
283:1, 283:11,
283:18, 283:23,
283:24, 283:25,
284:1, 284:8, 285:8,
285:13, 287:6, 287:8,
287:23, 288:8,
288:25, 294:8, 298:22
people's [2] -
240:13, 242:14
per [3] - 121:25,
162:18, 252:1
percentage [3] -
235:23, 262:8, 262:15
perception [2] -
227:17, 229:11
perceptions [1] -
235:1
perfect [1] - 294:6
perfectly [2] - 147:2,
149:12
perform [1] - 244:22
performance [3] -
224:14, 239:16, 240:2
performances [1] -
227:10
performed [1] -
255:15
performing [1] -
292:16
perimeter [2] -
122:7, 122:8
period [7] - 197:14,
216:19, 221:21,
230:10, 237:20,
263:8, 263:12
permanent [3] -
143:13, 143:18, 144:3
permission [2] -
196:19, 200:16
permit [17] - 125:16,
128:25, 129:5,
142:20, 143:5, 146:8,
146:14, 147:4, 147:5,
150:17, 153:10,
153:14, 153:18,
157:24, 174:18
permits [8] - 138:8,
138:11, 153:17,
157:10, 157:12,
158:21
permitted [1] -
159:22
permitting [2] -
118:12, 161:1
perpetuate [1] -
146:21
perpetuates [1] -
154:22
perpetuity [1] -
289:23
person [11] - 157:15,
171:19, 184:25,
202:8, 216:7, 224:2,
238:1, 254:6, 274:7,
282:21
personal [3] -
241:23, 271:23,
295:18
personally [1] -
276:21
personnel [1] -
282:24
perspective [7] -
167:20, 200:6,
231:18, 231:20,
247:19, 266:24, 274:6
Peter [2] - 130:19,
130:23
phased [1] - 232:25
philosophy [2] -
267:8, 281:9
phone [1] - 280:6
phones [1] - 198:8
physical [3] -
144:11, 177:13, 178:7
physically [1] - 227:5
picked [1] - 219:23
picks [1] - 252:3
picture [5] - 122:9,
160:1, 161:5, 228:24
pie [1] - 159:25
piece [1] - 159:25
piles [1] - 134:14
piling [1] - 135:4
PIP [7] - 272:23,
273:2, 296:11,
296:15, 296:17,
296:18, 297:4
place [11] - 119:21,
144:20, 147:3, 170:1,
189:8, 242:4, 247:2,
247:3, 290:2, 293:18,
294:6
placed [4] - 129:16,
129:18, 132:21, 195:4
placing [1] - 190:5
plan [6] - 178:4,
224:19, 251:1,
262:25, 276:16,
287:11
planning [1] - 218:10
PLANT [2] - 115:16,
117:4
Plant [4] - 118:1,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
20
123:24, 131:17,
141:23
plant [9] - 118:13,
133:12, 133:13,
134:20, 143:10,
143:17, 143:18,
156:20, 184:7
Plant's [1] - 118:2
plant's [1] - 143:21
plants [3] - 133:24,
140:7, 160:19
played [4] - 250:4,
254:16, 272:14, 284:2
player [1] - 282:1
players [2] - 273:23,
274:8
playing [1] - 252:18
pleasantly [1] -
252:7
pleased [1] - 280:14
plume [25] - 127:5,
127:6, 139:17,
139:19, 140:2, 140:3,
140:11, 140:21,
141:4, 146:19,
154:22, 154:25,
155:1, 155:14,
157:21, 158:7, 158:8,
159:11, 161:14,
161:15, 162:15,
162:17, 163:10,
168:18, 168:19
pluses [1] - 238:10
podium [1] - 118:3
point [35] - 124:9,
125:9, 126:6, 133:18,
134:19, 143:22,
146:6, 146:7, 146:16,
146:17, 146:22,
147:6, 148:6, 151:3,
151:4, 152:25, 161:9,
162:12, 167:9,
167:24, 174:18,
177:20, 177:23,
193:20, 194:6, 196:6,
200:1, 202:4, 216:2,
219:11, 241:11,
242:5, 252:25, 275:6
Point [7] - 118:2,
131:8, 141:22,
156:20, 156:21,
157:17, 163:10
pointed [1] - 118:15
points [1] - 274:3
policies [6] - 260:4,
262:3, 264:15,
264:17, 288:10,
288:12
policy [15] - 221:15,
259:24, 259:25,
260:1, 260:22,
260:23, 266:6,
270:25, 271:2, 271:4,
272:2, 281:8, 288:3
policyholder [2] -
275:6, 295:2
policyholders [1] -
264:18
policymakers [2] -
260:22, 261:1
political [1] - 290:8
politically [1] -
281:20
politics [2] - 281:13,
291:3
poll [1] - 249:4
pollutants [1] -
137:22
polluting [1] - 160:16
pollution [4] -
160:15, 161:13,
181:19, 181:21
poor [1] - 140:13
poorly [1] - 290:24
porous [2] - 133:5,
133:7
portion [5] - 133:25,
134:5, 134:6, 134:11,
135:11
pose [1] - 197:18
position [26] -
121:10, 124:22,
156:7, 214:10,
216:24, 226:8,
241:21, 249:15,
257:8, 258:15,
260:11, 268:11,
270:3, 274:8, 283:4,
285:7, 289:3, 289:4,
289:5, 290:13,
291:10, 292:23,
293:7, 297:22, 299:12
positioned [1] -
288:24
positions [4] -
191:11, 244:1,
268:18, 281:25
positive [4] - 125:19,
200:23, 207:3, 243:5
possession [3] -
193:13, 193:14, 231:9
possible [5] -
166:16, 199:9,
199:10, 202:18, 211:8
possibly [1] - 218:16
POST [1] - 114:22
posted [2] - 214:13,
257:10
potential [2] - 125:4,
286:17
potentially [1] -
230:17
pounds [3] - 135:8,
135:12, 136:1
pour [2] - 135:16,
135:20
poured [1] - 135:16
Power [23] - 117:25,
118:2, 119:19,
119:23, 121:15,
122:15, 123:6,
123:23, 123:24,
124:5, 126:22,
127:18, 129:19,
130:19, 131:17,
137:12, 140:5,
140:16, 141:23,
142:8, 153:21, 163:3
POWER [2] - 115:16,
117:4
power [10] - 118:13,
133:12, 133:13,
143:10, 143:16,
143:18, 156:20,
160:19, 184:7, 220:25
powers [2] - 220:18,
220:23
Practices [1] -
292:13
predates [1] - 177:10
prefer [1] - 260:17
preference [1] -
193:1
premium [2] -
265:19, 266:6
premiums [5] -
262:9, 262:15,
264:21, 265:13,
272:21
Prendergast [1] -
115:6
prepared [12] -
180:23, 182:20,
183:2, 236:7, 248:21,
255:16, 281:7, 284:7,
289:8, 289:9, 297:18,
298:10
preparedness [1] -
284:18
prepares [2] -
235:18, 236:2
preparing [1] - 219:6
present [8] - 118:5,
143:1, 156:7, 164:10,
216:20, 216:21,
218:8, 265:11
presentation [1] -
252:21
presented [7] -
147:21, 149:8,
166:10, 170:24,
179:23, 192:5, 244:5
President [3] -
131:1, 156:12, 234:17
press [1] - 139:18
pressing [1] - 139:19
pressure [1] - 139:1
presumably [1] -
175:3
pretty [6] - 120:18,
129:7, 206:14,
268:14, 287:23,
296:23
prevent [4] - 142:2,
142:16, 162:14,
219:10
previous [4] -
248:16, 249:15,
281:25, 287:25
previously [3] -
118:22, 208:8, 281:19
price [4] - 274:2,
274:16, 276:9, 290:22
pricing [4] - 274:11,
287:1, 287:20, 288:2
prima [1] - 146:11
primarily [3] -
165:12, 200:12, 263:6
primary [3] - 138:15,
150:9, 173:13
principal [2] - 184:6,
249:20
principally [1] -
135:10
principals [3] -
249:18, 254:22,
268:12
principle [2] -
152:22, 221:20
principles [3] -
151:9, 242:16, 251:12
prison [7] - 194:11,
194:17, 195:17,
205:18, 205:19,
205:24, 207:4
Prison [1] - 198:8
private [12] - 157:14,
160:4, 230:10,
258:19, 261:12,
264:6, 264:14,
264:16, 265:5,
267:16, 283:19
private-sector [1] -
261:12
privatize [1] - 222:6
privatizing [1] -
274:25
privilege [1] - 226:6
proactive [4] - 292:9,
292:10, 292:22, 295:7
proactively [1] -
259:11
probation [28] -
190:6, 190:10,
190:16, 193:12,
193:15, 194:22,
194:24, 194:25,
198:19, 199:4,
199:17, 200:11,
202:12, 203:1, 203:3,
203:4, 203:16,
203:17, 203:21,
203:23, 204:8,
204:10, 206:12,
207:1, 207:16, 208:1,
208:3, 209:15
probationary [1] -
202:19
problem [19] - 140:6,
140:8, 155:10,
155:11, 160:2,
160:24, 162:19,
176:4, 179:8, 193:10,
195:14, 196:23,
207:19, 209:19,
230:13, 264:19,
272:22, 272:23,
272:24
problems [6] -
266:20, 266:23,
267:1, 271:15,
271:17, 273:12
Procedures [1] -
151:18
proceeding [10] -
118:19, 119:5,
119:19, 122:17,
132:17, 141:17,
142:15, 152:23,
153:1, 184:22
proceedings [1] -
301:6
proceeds [1] -
263:11
process [25] -
143:22, 173:14,
212:1, 218:19,
218:24, 220:5, 220:7,
220:9, 220:12, 227:3,
241:12, 249:23,
252:18, 253:5, 254:8,
254:9, 254:16,
255:12, 256:11,
256:15, 272:1, 275:8,
278:2, 286:25, 295:4
processed [1] -
210:19
processing [2] -
210:11, 278:16
produce [2] - 216:20,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
21
218:15
produces [2] -
133:17, 133:24
product [5] - 230:19,
230:20, 294:24,
295:2, 295:3
production [1] -
122:25
products [2] -
287:18, 290:21
professional [4] -
235:18, 241:24,
249:14, 298:21
professionals [1] -
200:7
profitability [1] -
290:8
profitable [2] -
267:21, 267:24
profound [2] -
159:23, 283:19
Program [3] -
226:13, 264:1, 278:4
program [25] -
198:13, 203:11,
219:25, 221:3,
226:17, 228:19,
230:7, 230:8, 231:12,
263:22, 263:24,
264:5, 264:8, 264:11,
264:22, 265:6,
265:11, 271:7, 271:8,
275:4, 278:9, 278:12,
278:13, 278:20
programs [4] -
194:6, 194:7, 198:11,
269:10
progress [1] -
217:13
progressing [1] -
217:4
Project [1] - 131:2
project [3] - 131:3,
132:1, 143:4
projections [1] -
238:14
projects [1] - 121:16
prominent [1] -
249:2
promoting [1] -
228:20
pronged [1] - 268:4
proper [1] - 182:23
property [36] - 138:6,
138:9, 142:24,
142:25, 145:9,
156:23, 157:15,
158:6, 158:11,
158:20, 158:22,
160:4, 161:16,
162:17, 166:13,
168:20, 171:20,
172:4, 172:16, 223:8,
223:20, 230:7,
230:12, 230:14,
230:17, 234:20,
235:3, 235:6, 235:20,
235:21, 235:24,
236:25, 237:24,
267:13, 281:3, 296:21
Property [4] -
223:18, 236:19,
236:21, 295:9
proposal [9] -
128:20, 129:12,
131:7, 131:12,
131:18, 134:16,
166:8, 168:9, 222:1
proposed [4] -
122:25, 124:18,
141:18, 142:12
Proposed [1] -
117:24
proposing [1] -
129:12
prosecutor [1] -
198:25
prospectus [3] -
275:23, 276:2, 276:15
protect [5] - 158:6,
274:14, 274:21,
274:22, 275:7
protected [2] -
261:24, 286:10
protecting [2] -
292:12, 295:8
Protection [1] -
169:1
protection [4] -
174:9, 184:8, 271:23,
295:19
protest [2] - 220:5,
220:9
proud [6] - 241:14,
241:15, 255:25,
256:1, 278:17, 278:20
prove [3] - 120:14,
146:22, 157:23
proved [1] - 182:4
proven [3] - 146:16,
146:17, 160:23
proverbial [1] -
270:11
provide [9] - 125:1,
146:9, 157:6, 157:8,
162:13, 165:20,
192:25, 220:19, 233:2
provided [3] - 119:9,
124:6, 126:8
provides [2] -
123:13, 228:23
province [1] - 151:20
provision [3] -
154:15, 185:2, 221:10
public [22] - 214:15,
231:8, 231:21, 235:8,
235:10, 236:3,
257:14, 258:11,
258:14, 258:16,
258:18, 258:19,
258:21, 264:15,
268:21, 268:25,
269:6, 272:2, 281:8,
282:9, 284:4
pull [2] - 216:8,
216:23
pulled [1] - 134:20
pulling [1] - 153:17
pumps [1] - 133:11
punchy [1] - 244:11
punishment [1] -
189:7
purple [1] - 281:22
purpose [2] - 127:23,
174:23
purposes [3] - 122:1,
170:2, 201:21
pursuant [1] -
121:18
pursuing [1] - 163:9
purview [1] - 245:24
push [4] - 216:14,
217:7, 226:24, 230:3
pushed [3] - 140:8,
141:5, 217:7
pushes [3] - 134:15,
137:24, 139:21
pushing [3] - 139:2,
141:5, 195:10
put [32] - 121:7,
146:23, 148:14,
150:13, 153:19,
154:14, 163:8, 165:1,
165:18, 168:9,
169:13, 178:5, 193:7,
194:19, 205:4,
205:24, 205:25,
207:1, 212:11, 213:4,
220:9, 232:18,
236:15, 237:5, 242:4,
253:22, 264:4,
264:10, 277:24,
278:10, 296:15, 300:7
Putnam [10] - 194:4,
201:10, 202:2,
211:19, 212:9,
215:11, 241:10,
243:21, 253:9, 275:13
PUTNAM [98] -
114:12, 117:15,
152:7, 152:11,
152:14, 152:21,
154:1, 154:5, 154:20,
154:24, 155:6, 155:9,
155:18, 173:3, 173:5,
173:8, 173:15,
173:18, 174:1, 174:3,
174:6, 174:11,
174:15, 174:21,
174:23, 175:2, 175:7,
175:22, 176:3,
176:21, 181:2,
181:17, 182:23,
183:1, 183:10, 185:6,
185:18, 185:25,
192:15, 196:1,
196:22, 197:3, 199:8,
199:11, 204:25,
205:14, 205:22,
206:10, 206:13,
206:22, 207:8,
207:11, 207:18,
207:21, 208:22,
209:9, 210:1, 210:7,
210:20, 210:24,
211:2, 211:12,
211:16, 211:21,
212:14, 212:18,
212:21, 213:3,
218:22, 222:14,
228:3, 229:4, 230:24,
232:4, 238:5, 238:8,
239:9, 246:14,
248:15, 250:1,
253:11, 254:14,
255:4, 255:6, 255:9,
255:21, 263:15,
266:8, 267:10, 268:8,
269:14, 277:21,
278:23, 288:18,
290:23, 291:14,
293:3, 293:23
Putnam's [1] -
177:20
putting [3] - 132:24,
144:13, 296:1
Q
qualification [1] -
291:16
qualified [1] - 222:19
qualify [1] - 293:20
quality [8] - 128:21,
129:4, 137:18,
146:18, 150:10,
165:16, 290:7
quarter [2] - 138:6,
295:14
quasi [1] - 119:5
questioned [1] -
142:7
questions [30] -
130:5, 130:25, 132:3,
132:5, 149:23, 152:5,
155:20, 155:21,
156:6, 159:20,
161:21, 162:23,
164:1, 171:5, 172:24,
179:14, 187:23,
187:24, 215:7, 215:8,
218:21, 220:3, 225:9,
227:25, 234:6, 244:4,
244:17, 250:19,
277:19, 286:4
quick [4] - 170:12,
189:22, 216:13, 224:3
quicker [1] - 299:3
quickly [3] - 202:18,
216:13, 225:7
quite [2] - 165:19,
250:3
quote [3] - 151:16,
155:4, 288:19
quoted [1] - 178:19
quoting [1] - 142:8
R
radar [1] - 297:8
radiator [1] - 133:2
rail [1] - 236:15
rains [1] - 175:3
rainy [1] - 174:6
raise [4] - 124:1,
128:10, 164:7, 177:21
raised [6] - 123:15,
123:17, 123:20,
128:22, 177:22,
177:23
ran [2] - 228:14,
283:25
range [1] - 271:18
ranging [1] - 282:16
rapidly [3] - 159:12,
292:5, 292:6
rate [7] - 155:2,
163:14, 168:13,
265:23, 291:22,
295:24
rates [2] - 275:5,
298:7
rather [8] - 141:13,
206:11, 206:24,
212:11, 212:12,
232:2, 263:8, 278:14
ratio [1] - 265:17
RE [1] - 114:4
reach [2] - 259:11,
276:8
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
22
reaches [3] - 145:8,
158:22, 267:17
reacquaint [2] -
193:8, 195:6
reactor [1] - 136:18
read [11] - 127:5,
127:6, 153:18,
178:21, 179:6, 246:4,
246:20, 246:21,
276:15, 289:24,
293:19
reading [3] - 125:14,
127:14, 176:16
ready [2] - 214:6,
297:15
real [2] - 170:12,
250:15
Real [1] - 210:19
realistically [2] -
210:17, 210:22
realize [2] - 221:21,
246:2
realizes [1] - 253:14
really [26] - 146:25,
150:13, 189:22,
197:8, 212:10,
228:12, 228:13,
229:11, 229:12,
236:9, 252:13,
252:14, 252:16,
258:12, 259:14,
261:13, 262:1, 266:5,
266:9, 266:10,
266:14, 266:17,
270:12, 272:18,
291:15, 291:20
reason [7] - 140:12,
148:19, 164:14,
213:3, 274:22, 288:7,
292:25
reasonable [12] -
126:13, 137:22,
144:20, 153:5,
180:13, 180:25,
182:15, 183:7,
185:15, 185:21,
210:13, 282:2
reasonably [1] -
238:15
reasoned [2] -
167:24, 224:6
reasoning [1] - 131:6
reasons [2] - 128:17,
286:14
receivable [3] -
229:18, 229:20, 231:3
receivables [1] -
232:8
received [5] -
214:12, 223:16,
223:19, 257:9, 280:6
recent [3] - 127:12,
219:22, 224:20
recently [1] - 196:7
Recession [1] -
224:23
recited [1] - 150:6
reckless [1] - 289:7
recognize [5] -
187:6, 215:5, 224:13,
258:4, 280:3
recognized [1] -
226:17
recognizes [1] -
258:11
recognizing [2] -
224:4, 242:24
recommend [11] -
118:24, 126:9, 129:9,
129:23, 130:3,
165:23, 176:20,
180:18, 182:19,
259:14, 260:25
recommendation [7]
- 123:6, 141:12,
179:25, 180:1,
180:11, 180:16,
182:10
Recommended [12] -
118:25, 122:20,
123:2, 123:12,
124:19, 130:4,
132:20, 138:20,
138:23, 180:19,
181:4, 185:8
recommended [6] -
126:24, 131:12,
153:3, 179:6, 179:7,
185:10
recommending [3] -
122:21, 131:24,
179:22
record [28] - 119:8,
119:12, 119:15,
120:24, 121:7,
127:10, 133:20,
135:9, 138:5, 139:5,
140:1, 142:5, 147:18,
148:10, 163:11,
163:22, 167:3,
170:23, 171:11,
174:17, 176:11,
176:17, 177:17,
178:16, 245:1,
255:14, 301:6
records [1] - 237:17
redress [1] - 272:22
reduce [3] - 163:14,
175:4, 229:21
reduced [1] - 155:2
reducing [1] - 274:24
reduction [3] -
232:7, 265:22, 265:23
redundant [1] -
182:3
reentry [6] - 194:5,
194:7, 198:11,
198:13, 202:7, 203:11
refer [1] - 126:1
reference [1] -
221:14
referenced [2] -
269:5, 285:18
referring [1] - 149:21
reflected [1] - 126:10
reflective [1] -
127:12
refund [1] - 220:6
refuse [2] - 196:17,
196:18
refute [2] - 129:7,
129:20
regain [1] - 229:8
regard [2] - 135:24,
265:3
regarding [6] -
124:2, 126:3, 185:15,
185:21, 242:5, 275:15
regardless [1] -
129:15
regional [1] - 242:11
regions [1] - 242:11
register [7] - 189:1,
190:3, 192:12, 209:3,
209:14, 209:17, 237:5
registration [2] -
189:2, 196:21
regular [1] - 287:7
regulate [3] - 278:11,
278:12, 297:20
regulating [2] -
178:13, 266:18
REGULATION [3] -
115:3, 116:5, 257:3
Regulation [3] -
257:7, 292:14, 299:13
regulation [5] -
177:11, 177:14,
281:12, 290:7, 293:1
regulations [1] -
278:11
regulator [2] -
291:15, 292:1
regulatory [3] -
281:25, 291:11,
294:19
reign [1] - 208:15
reinsurance [3] -
280:22, 280:25, 297:6
reject [2] - 119:11,
119:18
rejected [1] - 124:3
rejection [1] - 180:21
related [7] - 125:13,
125:16, 142:13,
152:22, 159:13,
181:14, 245:21
relates [5] - 152:11,
168:6, 281:8, 284:21,
287:19
relating [1] - 298:11
relationship [1] -
245:18
relationships [1] -
223:12
release [1] - 189:7
released [2] - 199:9,
210:12
relief [3] - 220:19,
272:10, 296:10
religious [2] -
201:21, 204:19
relitigate [3] - 148:4,
163:7, 172:12
reluctant [1] - 176:18
remainder [1] -
138:18
remaining [1] -
190:12
remarkable [1] -
229:14
remediate [1] -
161:13
remedy [1] - 220:19
remove [1] - 189:2
removed [1] - 195:8
removing [1] -
168:17
reoffending [1] -
197:20
replacing [1] - 139:6
report [6] - 209:14,
209:17, 254:22,
270:16, 282:20, 301:5
REPORTED [1] -
114:18
Reporter [1] - 301:11
REPORTER [1] -
114:18
REPORTERS [1] -
114:22
reporting [4] - 190:4,
207:2, 209:19, 293:9
reports [2] - 216:3,
216:4
represent [1] - 282:7
Representative [6] -
257:15, 280:4, 280:5,
282:11, 294:1, 299:14
representative [2] -
288:18, 297:2
REPRESENTATIVE
[22] - 280:14, 280:19,
282:15, 283:17,
284:12, 284:25,
285:3, 285:10,
286:11, 287:13,
287:16, 287:22,
288:16, 288:23,
291:1, 291:21,
293:15, 294:14,
295:20, 296:14,
297:13, 298:17
representatives [3] -
217:24, 237:1, 249:2
represented [2] -
187:14, 259:3
representing [4] -
130:24, 132:11,
132:16, 275:21
represents [1] -
273:15
reputation [6] -
246:16, 248:24,
254:7, 266:14, 285:5,
285:14
request [10] -
117:25, 122:14,
123:6, 123:16,
142:15, 158:17,
161:4, 180:1, 187:9,
222:8
requested [2] -
142:1, 151:19
require [7] - 145:7,
161:13, 190:2, 244:2,
271:17, 273:6, 295:17
required [4] -
124:23, 168:10,
175:8, 175:16
requirement [2] -
174:20, 189:3
requirements [8] -
163:13, 190:4,
190:17, 190:18,
209:16, 290:19,
293:19, 293:20
requires [3] - 122:23,
182:17, 267:15
res [1] - 126:5
Research [1] -
215:25
reservation [1] -
291:2
residence [3] -
196:12, 200:13,
201:20
residency [1] -
190:18
residents [1] -
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
23
156:18
resolution [1] -
168:23
Resource [1] -
215:25
resources [6] -
125:5, 141:25,
146:20, 160:4,
220:10, 283:5
respect [14] - 118:17,
123:10, 123:12,
123:16, 123:17,
127:11, 130:2, 146:4,
175:13, 220:4,
220:14, 259:13,
287:9, 292:11
respectful [1] -
166:11
respectfully [4] -
151:6, 151:11,
154:14, 166:13
respects [1] - 254:8
respond [5] - 216:13,
221:4, 225:4, 268:19,
293:12
respondents [1] -
141:15
responding [2] -
285:15, 285:16
response [5] -
150:24, 223:3,
250:23, 250:25,
293:21
RESPONSE) [10] -
117:20, 132:6,
155:22, 161:22,
162:24, 179:15,
186:4, 251:19,
251:22, 278:25
responsibilities [3] -
241:24, 293:8, 294:4
responsibility [2] -
232:10, 283:5
responsible [4] -
131:3, 242:9, 260:2,
282:3
responsive [5] -
220:2, 225:7, 230:4,
249:19, 291:13
responsiveness [3] -
219:8, 219:15, 267:9
rest [1] - 151:2
restate [1] - 180:15
restriction [1] -
196:12
restrictions [2] -
196:16, 205:24
restrictive [2] -
196:10, 197:17
result [10] - 136:17,
140:2, 140:14,
141:19, 143:6,
151:25, 177:9,
216:20, 269:6, 271:21
resulted [1] - 264:12
results [4] - 124:13,
140:17, 158:25,
216:21
resume [2] - 226:12,
273:18
retains [1] - 207:14
retire [1] - 239:23
returned [1] - 215:23
Reuters [1] - 230:20
REVENUE [2] -
115:20, 214:3
Revenue [15] -
214:9, 218:9, 226:9,
226:15, 226:21,
228:17, 229:16,
229:19, 231:9, 242:2,
246:15, 248:22,
249:9, 251:25, 254:25
revenue [5] - 226:19,
231:19, 238:14,
259:4, 276:3
Revenue's [1] -
226:17
revenues [1] - 276:8
reversible [1] -
170:21
review [5] - 119:6,
126:7, 148:9, 162:9,
269:8
Review [3] - 187:7,
187:13, 187:22
revisit [1] - 227:21
rewards [1] - 258:17
reweigh [1] - 127:22
reweighing [2] -
128:7, 150:2
RICK [1] - 114:10
rid [3] - 239:1,
239:21, 267:6
rider [2] - 263:6,
288:12
rights [4] - 138:11,
160:4, 161:17, 295:8
Rights [2] - 221:9,
221:17
risen [2] - 217:25,
225:17
rising [1] - 225:15
Risk [1] - 278:4
risk [11] - 191:14,
197:18, 197:20,
197:22, 197:25,
198:5, 230:2, 268:2,
268:3, 273:24, 275:3
risks [2] - 275:24,
276:15
road [3] - 120:25,
157:9, 269:20
Robert [5] - 115:22,
214:17, 215:5,
217:14, 222:15
ROBERT [1] - 215:2
robust [1] - 270:3
rock [1] - 157:2
role [27] - 118:16,
146:25, 147:2, 148:2,
149:6, 150:20,
150:25, 151:1, 151:7,
216:4, 216:15,
216:24, 217:18,
218:2, 223:24,
225:15, 241:7,
254:17, 255:11,
259:19, 259:21,
259:25, 260:6, 284:9,
284:10, 284:12, 286:5
roles [5] - 215:19,
217:9, 248:17, 250:4,
250:5
roll [2] - 203:3,
204:10
Roman [1] - 154:19
room [8] - 169:17,
172:1, 232:16, 243:7,
243:8, 243:19, 248:7,
272:18
ROOM [1] - 114:15
rooms [1] - 290:3
roughly [1] - 139:6
row [2] - 138:4,
296:5
RPR [3] - 114:18,
301:5, 301:11
rule [3] - 167:1,
218:4, 236:24
ruled [2] - 142:4,
144:5
rules [4] - 121:18,
125:20, 126:2, 126:10
ruling [2] - 142:6,
172:18
rulings [1] - 161:5
Rumph [1] - 196:5
RUMPH [2] - 196:9,
196:25
run [10] - 136:18,
140:15, 190:11,
248:22, 253:20,
263:22, 265:10,
269:9, 283:5, 293:13
run-up [1] - 293:13
runaway [1] - 295:22
running [1] - 231:2
runs [2] - 133:23,
140:7
S
safe [2] - 188:9,
231:13
salary [1] - 299:15
saleability [1] -
159:4
sales [3] - 221:14,
221:17, 237:13
saline [2] - 131:21,
144:13
salinity [7] - 122:2,
127:3, 127:11,
127:12, 136:21,
174:24, 175:5
salt [12] - 134:2,
135:8, 135:13,
135:21, 136:1, 136:7,
136:8, 138:4, 159:3,
159:11, 160:11,
246:23
salt/fresh [1] -
158:21
saltier [1] - 136:12
saltwater [27] -
133:17, 133:23,
134:18, 136:9,
136:11, 137:25,
138:13, 138:16,
138:19, 140:20,
141:5, 145:7, 146:19,
150:8, 157:21,
157:24, 158:1, 160:9,
163:14, 163:21,
163:25, 168:8,
168:13, 178:4
saltwater/fresh [1] -
158:18
salty [4] - 134:1,
137:9, 138:4, 138:5
samples [1] - 158:24
Sams [1] - 130:24
sand [2] - 157:2,
157:4
Sara [1] - 196:5
Sarasota [1] - 245:16
satisfied [1] - 224:17
satisfy [2] - 197:11,
199:5
Saturnia [3] -
142:24, 143:1, 143:4
saw [4] - 150:3,
176:25, 258:15,
293:16
scale [1] - 239:22
scatter [1] - 212:18
scenario [1] - 141:7
scheduled [2] -
214:14, 257:12
school [13] - 152:18,
196:1, 196:13,
196:17, 196:23,
201:14, 205:1, 205:6,
205:11, 206:16,
228:5, 228:13, 228:18
science [2] - 173:15,
287:23
scientific [2] -
181:22, 184:16
scope [1] - 282:22
score [1] - 290:23
Scott [2] - 215:10,
241:8
scott [1] - 206:9
SCOTT [213] -
114:10, 117:6,
117:13, 117:17,
117:19, 117:21,
118:7, 119:25, 120:3,
120:7, 130:6, 130:11,
130:16, 130:21,
132:4, 132:7, 132:12,
144:24, 145:2,
145:14, 145:16,
145:20, 145:24,
146:10, 147:7, 148:1,
148:23, 149:13,
149:16, 149:20,
149:22, 152:4,
155:19, 155:23,
155:25, 156:3,
161:20, 162:22,
162:25, 163:4, 164:2,
164:12, 164:14,
164:17, 169:8,
169:11, 169:16,
169:19, 170:11,
170:14, 170:18,
171:12, 171:15,
172:20, 172:23,
173:2, 173:4, 176:22,
178:14, 179:10,
179:13, 179:16,
179:20, 179:24,
180:8, 180:15, 182:9,
182:12, 182:21,
182:25, 185:13,
185:17, 185:19,
185:23, 186:1, 186:3,
186:5, 186:9, 186:14,
187:5, 187:16,
187:19, 187:25,
188:2, 188:4, 188:10,
188:13, 188:20,
189:10, 189:17,
189:21, 190:19,
191:4, 191:10,
191:19, 192:8, 193:9,
193:17, 193:21,
194:1, 195:20,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
24
195:23, 196:3, 196:8,
197:7, 197:25, 198:4,
199:15, 199:22,
199:24, 200:4,
201:25, 203:5, 204:5,
205:21, 206:4,
206:19, 207:23,
208:9, 208:18,
209:12, 211:9,
211:11, 211:14,
211:17, 211:22,
212:3, 212:5, 213:1,
213:7, 213:12,
213:15, 214:5, 215:4,
215:16, 217:14,
218:20, 222:11,
224:9, 225:20, 226:3,
226:10, 227:11,
227:24, 229:3,
230:23, 232:5, 233:5,
233:8, 234:3, 234:7,
234:22, 234:25,
235:16, 236:17,
238:4, 239:10,
240:17, 241:3, 243:4,
243:15, 244:8,
246:13, 250:2,
251:16, 251:18,
251:20, 251:23,
252:5, 252:10,
253:16, 253:19,
255:8, 256:7, 256:9,
257:5, 258:4, 258:7,
258:23, 259:18,
260:5, 261:3, 261:19,
263:14, 264:23,
264:25, 269:15,
275:9, 275:12, 277:2,
277:6, 277:9, 277:12,
277:15, 277:18,
278:24, 279:1, 280:3,
280:16, 282:11,
283:13, 284:9,
284:22, 285:1, 285:4,
285:23, 288:17,
293:24, 298:16,
298:18, 299:16,
300:3, 300:9
screen [1] - 297:9
Scroggs [1] - 131:2
scrutiny [2] - 254:22,
268:17
sea [2] - 133:19,
134:8
season [1] - 174:6
seawater [1] -
136:12
second [15] - 117:17,
117:18, 120:1,
144:25, 145:16,
164:12, 186:1, 186:2,
190:20, 208:20,
252:1, 252:9, 258:18,
289:20, 299:16
secondly [1] -
270:11
seconds [1] - 271:17
secret [1] - 269:9
Secretary [1] -
118:18
section [2] - 153:16,
154:17
Section [6] - 123:13,
125:16, 153:15,
153:20, 153:23
sections [1] - 126:2
sector [12] - 258:11,
258:19, 258:21,
261:12, 264:6,
264:14, 264:15,
264:16, 267:16,
283:20
sectors [1] - 265:5
Security [1] - 231:10
see [35] - 136:15,
160:8, 160:17,
171:21, 189:23,
194:6, 194:18,
194:20, 195:2,
204:11, 213:3, 219:3,
229:11, 230:25,
236:11, 243:6,
252:17, 259:18,
259:20, 266:10,
269:20, 276:15,
284:9, 284:10,
286:19, 287:2, 288:6,
288:9, 294:13, 299:8,
299:21, 299:24, 300:9
seeing [5] - 158:15,
176:15, 236:14,
272:14
seek [5] - 218:12,
220:24, 259:6, 259:7,
272:21
seeking [3] - 218:18,
242:19, 260:15
seepage [4] - 135:5,
135:6, 135:9, 139:2
seeps [3] - 134:17,
134:20, 135:1
selected [2] -
214:14, 257:13
self [1] - 228:15
self-funded [1] -
228:15
sell [2] - 230:17,
264:6
selling [2] - 264:13
semi [1] - 250:16
Senate [1] - 224:1
send [1] - 207:4
Senior [1] - 131:2
senior [1] - 226:14
seniors [4] - 262:25,
263:7, 263:10, 287:12
sense [4] - 219:8,
219:21, 235:9, 264:20
sentence [5] - 166:6,
181:5, 184:10,
187:10, 187:20
sentenced [1] -
193:16
sentinel [1] - 159:2
separate [2] -
118:18, 153:1
separately [1] -
153:13
separation [1] -
173:24
September [3] -
205:16, 206:1, 206:2
SEQUENCE [1] -
117:2
series [1] - 142:22
serve [10] - 198:21,
223:25, 241:16,
242:6, 258:13,
260:19, 261:17,
283:18, 283:20, 284:7
served [3] - 193:17,
239:12, 284:7
service [7] - 236:3,
258:16, 258:18,
264:7, 265:5, 282:9,
284:5
Services [1] - 225:16
servicing [2] -
264:13
Session [2] - 225:5
session [1] - 237:3
set [8] - 191:24,
194:7, 200:25, 207:6,
247:25, 278:8, 294:5,
294:6
sets [6] - 232:12,
239:17, 242:24,
250:10, 259:24, 289:1
setting [2] - 216:22,
274:10
settle [1] - 277:16
settled [2] - 217:8,
269:7
settlement [3] -
275:18, 277:4, 277:12
seven [1] - 126:19
several [9] - 163:17,
164:9, 164:22,
228:19, 232:14,
232:19, 242:12,
258:13, 263:2
severely [2] - 138:10,
138:12
sex [14] - 189:1,
190:4, 190:6, 190:16,
192:12, 192:20,
192:22, 195:8,
196:21, 207:14,
207:15, 209:14,
209:15, 209:18
share [5] - 156:13,
235:13, 266:14,
269:25, 281:20
shareholder [1] -
276:10
shareholders [3] -
275:21, 276:12,
276:14
shares [3] - 276:18,
276:19, 276:22
sheet [2] - 278:8,
278:18
shifting [1] - 242:8
shifts [1] - 146:12
shop [1] - 283:9
shopping [1] -
208:16
short [1] - 230:10
shot [1] - 144:15
show [2] - 124:7,
290:18
shown [2] - 285:21
shows [3] - 140:15,
159:10, 292:4
shrink [3] - 140:11,
140:22, 140:24
shrinking [2] -
248:19, 249:1
shut [2] - 158:23,
174:2
shutdown [1] -
143:22
sic [1] - 222:18
sick [1] - 158:25
side [15] - 120:11,
133:13, 134:13,
134:22, 135:3,
147:21, 149:9,
159:11, 170:25,
177:2, 222:3, 246:5,
267:13, 271:24, 274:9
sides [2] - 139:20,
172:13
sign [7] - 210:4,
210:9, 212:12,
212:19, 212:20,
289:23, 289:24
signature [1] - 213:5
signed [1] - 237:4
significant [7] -
158:5, 222:16, 223:6,
226:25, 280:9,
281:16, 282:12
significantly [2] -
287:24, 288:1
similar [5] - 118:17,
220:8, 225:14, 257:7,
260:7
similarities [1] -
246:11
simple [3] - 162:12,
241:13, 287:23
simplest [3] -
128:18, 154:8, 182:12
simplify [1] - 183:12
simply [8] - 127:21,
129:7, 130:1, 130:3,
165:21, 193:22,
241:19, 291:23
single [1] - 140:19
sinks [1] - 136:4
sit [5] - 119:6,
121:11, 149:15,
247:15, 290:3
SITING [2] - 115:16,
117:4
Siting [21] - 117:8,
117:10, 117:12,
118:1, 118:11, 119:3,
123:24, 131:17,
141:18, 141:22,
141:23, 142:10,
142:16, 145:5,
151:11, 155:5,
160:18, 161:10,
173:12, 185:5, 186:7
siting [3] - 118:12,
161:11, 184:7
sits [2] - 133:6, 136:6
sitting [4] - 167:15,
185:4, 274:7, 283:9
situation [6] -
158:14, 185:2,
207:13, 218:17,
260:7, 272:12
situations [1] - 221:1
six [30] - 122:5,
160:6, 190:9, 197:10,
198:18, 199:2, 199:3,
199:16, 199:17,
202:25, 203:1, 203:6,
203:7, 203:16,
203:17, 203:20,
203:23, 203:24,
204:6, 204:8, 205:15,
205:17, 206:23,
207:25
size [4] - 133:3,
137:2, 248:22, 297:23
skill [4] - 232:12,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
25
239:17, 250:10, 289:1
skills [2] - 184:24,
251:11
slip [2] - 202:8,
202:20
Sloan [1] - 287:2
slow [4] - 131:21,
155:13, 220:11,
252:19
slowly [2] - 206:7,
208:16
slows [1] - 168:13
small [3] - 159:25,
235:22, 284:23
smart [2] - 212:14,
212:21
Snurkowski [1] -
188:18
Social [1] - 231:10
society [1] - 201:23
sold [1] - 294:24
Sole [2] - 163:2,
164:3
SOLE [8] - 163:5,
167:7, 167:10, 168:4,
169:10, 169:15,
169:21, 175:15
solely [1] - 196:20
solid [1] - 212:17
solution [8] - 141:4,
160:14, 178:7,
178:10, 218:18,
261:12, 263:19,
284:20
solutions [2] -
150:25, 275:15
solve [3] - 266:22,
266:25, 273:3
solved [2] - 140:5,
207:18
solvency [1] - 290:18
someone [16] -
121:5, 140:23,
153:19, 164:6, 166:9,
167:25, 169:5,
192:16, 192:17,
194:8, 195:15,
195:16, 197:18,
198:7, 254:16, 294:10
sometimes [6] -
239:23, 246:22,
247:9, 249:5, 249:9,
293:2
somewhat [9] -
119:4, 121:4, 121:6,
127:14, 144:13,
148:6, 150:15, 155:2,
216:6
somewhere [1] -
139:16
soon [2] - 210:4,
211:8
sooner [2] - 195:14,
255:17
sorry [7] - 144:22,
149:18, 150:8,
169:10, 172:7,
222:24, 262:19
sort [6] - 119:6,
154:12, 234:8,
236:25, 258:25,
277:21
sought [1] - 121:15
Soul [1] - 130:25
sound [2] - 131:6,
244:25
source [4] - 131:19,
144:11, 163:24,
181:19
south [1] - 161:17
South [5] - 131:15,
131:22, 139:24,
140:16, 159:7
southeast [1] -
156:19
southeastern [1] -
138:17
space [1] - 268:21
speaker [3] - 130:8,
156:1, 163:2
SPEAKER [1] - 213:8
speakers [4] -
130:20, 172:21,
172:25, 179:12
speaking [1] - 274:4
speaks [1] - 273:25
special [5] - 189:25,
190:7, 190:12,
190:22, 200:15
specialities [1] -
185:3
specific [5] - 152:8,
166:6, 167:5, 220:6,
232:10
specifically [5] -
125:20, 131:18,
181:4, 229:7, 236:2
specifics [3] -
175:14, 176:12, 187:9
spectrum [2] -
241:18, 270:9
Speedway [1] -
137:4
spend [1] - 236:12
spending [1] -
266:16
spent [2] - 222:21,
223:1
sphere [1] - 244:24
spike [1] - 127:12
spoken [2] - 232:7,
232:8
sponsor [1] - 295:10
sponsored [1] -
296:14
sponsors [1] -
286:18
spot [3] - 138:25,
200:9, 274:7
spread [2] - 141:5,
275:3
spreading [2] -
140:21, 144:13
spreads [1] - 136:6
spreadsheet [2] -
290:5, 290:6
square [2] - 137:2,
159:10
squeezed [1] -
286:24
stable [1] - 138:19
stacked [1] - 255:13
staff [9] - 216:20,
217:25, 218:17,
224:1, 224:22, 225:2,
229:6, 278:15
staffs [1] - 260:17
stakeholders [6] -
247:18, 248:16,
248:25, 259:8,
260:16, 260:24
stand [2] - 215:13,
292:23
standard [5] - 149:3,
151:19, 152:15,
175:12, 219:1
standards [7] -
131:13, 131:14,
137:17, 137:18,
137:20, 146:18,
150:10
standing [31] -
124:24, 125:2, 125:8,
125:22, 126:1, 142:7,
142:14, 144:18,
144:19, 144:20,
151:3, 151:6, 151:19,
180:10, 180:11,
180:22, 180:24,
181:7, 181:8, 181:10,
181:11, 182:4, 184:4,
184:15, 184:17,
184:19, 184:21,
185:15, 185:21, 274:8
standpoint [8] -
182:2, 221:24, 235:4,
235:8, 283:11, 288:6,
291:11, 294:19
start [5] - 172:4,
215:17, 241:11,
270:6, 297:10
started [5] - 117:6,
229:19, 250:14,
265:1, 278:7
starts [3] - 203:6,
276:3, 292:3
STATE [3] - 114:1,
115:9, 301:3
State [18] - 118:11,
133:1, 137:16,
137:18, 160:4,
171:19, 175:9,
177:11, 197:1, 198:8,
218:11, 221:15,
221:23, 231:1,
231:23, 232:18,
246:10, 274:15
state [26] - 157:11,
163:19, 235:25,
237:1, 241:15,
242:12, 245:15,
249:2, 253:24, 254:1,
263:20, 266:4,
266:15, 266:17,
267:22, 267:25,
268:3, 268:6, 268:13,
281:9, 281:14, 290:1,
291:17, 291:24,
293:10
State's [2] - 159:14,
168:1
statement [3] -
164:24, 234:5, 285:11
states [5] - 143:23,
272:14, 281:24,
291:22, 296:21
States [3] - 261:7,
280:23, 281:5
statewide [3] -
219:12, 232:18,
241:22
static [1] - 289:2
statistical [1] -
238:12
status [1] - 207:14
statute [6] - 129:18,
165:2, 197:1, 197:2,
209:3, 273:3
Statutes [1] - 237:6
statutes [3] - 246:4,
246:7, 273:9
statutory [3] -
220:18, 293:19,
293:20
Stay [1] - 206:19
stay [2] - 201:7,
206:20
stays [1] - 134:3
steadily [1] - 160:5
steam [3] - 133:17,
133:24, 134:2
stenographic [1] -
301:6
stenographically [1]
- 301:5
step [2] - 241:19,
298:22
stepped [1] - 255:25
stepping [2] -
171:24, 256:3
Steve [3] - 131:2,
156:2, 156:11
stick [1] - 120:12
sticking [1] - 271:16
stigma [2] - 192:22,
195:7
still [15] - 128:13,
140:20, 140:21,
190:2, 190:3, 191:12,
193:3, 194:14, 195:5,
195:6, 203:8, 210:11,
212:20, 252:23, 272:3
stipulate [1] - 155:13
stipulated [1] - 185:9
stock [2] - 276:9,
276:22
stool [2] - 270:12,
270:18
stop [9] - 119:25,
141:8, 145:6, 161:15,
162:16, 162:19,
164:12, 221:2, 291:13
stopped [1] - 145:8
stops [1] - 160:20
store [7] - 200:17,
200:22, 200:24,
201:14, 204:17,
204:21, 206:15
story [1] - 156:13
straight [2] - 200:11,
200:14
straightforward [1] -
282:24
strategy [1] - 232:23
strengthen [2] -
220:16, 220:24
strengths [1] - 219:2
strike [1] - 181:5
strong [4] - 229:25,
237:8, 253:18, 296:23
stronger [2] -
252:20, 269:21
strongly [8] - 181:24,
202:15, 203:10,
203:11, 238:18,
238:19, 239:25,
252:24
structure [2] -
202:23, 207:2
structured [1] -
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
26
204:24
structuring [1] -
203:18
struggle [1] - 156:17
stuck [1] - 148:20
studied [1] - 159:19
study [2] - 120:11,
159:8
stuff [4] - 232:24,
240:13, 288:2
style [10] - 216:6,
234:9, 234:10,
258:25, 259:5,
260:13, 282:14,
282:23, 283:6
subject [3] - 127:14,
166:15, 209:15
submit [1] - 148:10
submittal [1] -
117:11
submitted [2] -
118:24, 119:24
subsidiary [2] -
276:6, 276:24
substance [1] -
154:13
substantial [12] -
119:15, 120:14,
125:22, 127:10,
127:25, 128:3,
148:13, 148:15,
149:8, 172:7, 172:8,
172:19
substantive [2] -
151:17, 184:4
substituted [2] -
126:12
succeed [1] - 194:20
succeeded [1] -
219:19
success [3] - 253:20,
284:23, 285:4
successful [3] -
190:25, 192:4, 232:13
successfully [1] -
191:3
sued [2] - 268:24,
276:18
suffered [1] - 181:18
sufficient [3] - 124:6,
141:17, 142:14
suggest [9] - 125:8,
125:21, 128:7,
129:17, 151:6, 165:2,
171:3, 176:17, 202:21
suggested [7] -
129:14, 182:6, 182:7,
188:8, 201:11, 212:9,
272:15
suggesting [1] -
205:4
suggestion [3] -
124:3, 127:8, 191:21
suggestions [1] -
165:6
suggests [1] - 176:1
suit [2] - 275:19,
276:10
summer [1] - 175:3
Suntax [1] - 232:16
supervised [1] -
190:5
supervision [13] -
189:8, 189:15, 190:1,
190:8, 191:1, 192:4,
192:13, 192:16,
197:5, 197:16, 199:4,
200:19, 209:5
supervisor [1] -
250:23
supplant [1] - 121:25
supplemental [1] -
144:3
supply [2] - 144:3,
157:4
support [19] -
125:20, 125:21,
128:1, 192:20,
195:18, 224:8, 230:7,
231:11, 232:2, 233:3,
242:20, 242:21,
244:19, 245:5,
245:17, 255:16,
256:6, 280:10, 296:23
supported [5] -
119:14, 123:22,
127:9, 148:11, 148:12
supporting [1] -
255:17
supports [3] -
125:19, 131:4, 143:16
supposed [5] -
137:21, 137:25,
178:12, 201:24, 238:2
Supreme [3] - 273:8,
298:4, 298:13
surgical [1] - 267:7
surprise [2] - 240:15,
297:12
surprised [1] - 252:7
surrounded [1] -
273:4
Surveyors [2] -
248:17, 249:13
swayed [1] - 202:6
Switzerland [1] -
299:8
sympathetic [1] -
235:5
System [5] - 131:8,
156:21, 156:22,
157:18, 232:17
system [60] - 122:1,
122:8, 122:11, 125:6,
132:24, 132:25,
133:9, 133:16,
133:21, 133:23,
134:1, 134:4, 134:7,
134:10, 134:15,
134:17, 134:21,
135:2, 135:3, 135:7,
135:10, 135:25,
137:14, 138:15,
138:25, 139:7,
139:10, 139:14,
139:18, 139:22,
140:4, 142:1, 143:5,
143:7, 143:9, 143:14,
143:20, 143:24,
144:1, 144:2, 144:7,
146:18, 152:1,
153:15, 154:10,
154:11, 158:2, 158:9,
158:16, 174:25,
175:8, 177:8, 177:13,
198:23, 229:17,
232:17, 232:19,
265:20, 269:25, 286:8
system's [1] - 143:21
systems [2] - 163:16,
228:25
T
table [3] - 266:25,
277:25, 288:14
tables [1] - 265:16
tackled [1] - 266:11
talented [4] - 252:14,
252:16, 298:22,
298:25
TALLAHASSEE [2] -
114:16, 114:23
Tallahassee [2] -
238:1, 300:12
tap [1] - 251:10
Taps [1] - 284:3
target [1] - 273:13
tax [18] - 221:14,
221:17, 223:9,
226:17, 229:17,
230:6, 230:8, 230:15,
231:12, 235:3, 237:1,
237:13, 237:23,
237:24, 245:21,
246:4, 246:10, 298:6
Tax [3] - 215:25,
226:13, 227:1
tax-related [1] -
245:21
taxes [2] - 221:16,
245:25
Taxpayer [4] -
220:17, 220:21,
221:9, 221:16
taxpayer [3] -
221:11, 221:25,
237:13
taxpayer's [1] -
227:6
taxpayers [7] -
217:16, 217:21,
217:22, 217:23,
220:3, 220:20, 242:19
team [9] - 224:13,
232:11, 232:20,
233:2, 250:8, 253:23,
282:1, 282:14, 296:16
teams [1] - 239:15
teasing [1] - 237:9
technical [2] -
151:12, 184:7
technically [2] -
173:10, 203:15
technology [2] -
198:9, 227:1
teeter [1] - 292:3
temperature [1] -
122:1
temporarily [1] -
273:3
temptations [1] -
202:9
tend [1] - 216:23
tendency [1] -
236:24
tenor [1] - 150:13
Teresi [2] - 156:2,
156:11
TERESI [5] - 156:4,
162:2, 162:6, 162:11,
163:1
term [10] - 145:19,
191:1, 193:16, 263:1,
263:3, 287:14,
287:19, 287:20,
288:3, 288:11
terminology [6] -
123:10, 126:24,
129:25, 180:4,
180:10, 182:16
terms [23] - 184:22,
192:4, 208:7, 249:24,
251:4, 259:2, 267:3,
274:23, 282:15,
282:23, 282:24,
283:3, 284:19,
285:10, 285:11,
285:12, 289:11,
290:11, 291:2,
291:25, 292:22,
295:7, 297:19
territory [1] - 172:3
Terrorism [1] - 278:4
test [1] - 184:5
testified [9] - 135:5,
136:20, 139:13,
139:23, 139:25,
140:19, 140:23,
141:7, 143:19
testify [2] - 133:21,
280:23
testifying [1] - 128:4
testimony [10] -
124:16, 127:18,
148:14, 161:6,
161:24, 162:4, 162:5,
162:9, 171:23, 172:13
tests [1] - 207:3
THE [6] - 114:4,
114:16, 115:13,
116:4, 257:2, 300:13
theft [2] - 231:8,
231:21
theme [1] - 219:7
themselves [2] -
232:1, 285:19
therefore [7] -
121:18, 126:8,
128:21, 129:4,
129:22, 182:2, 276:8
thereto [1] - 181:14
they've [4] - 140:7,
150:18, 220:22,
226:23
thinking [4] - 158:25,
202:11, 239:3, 291:3
third [6] - 122:13,
128:9, 193:25, 261:6,
270:14, 292:20
Thomson [1] -
230:20
thoughts [2] -
129:14, 298:19
thousand [4] - 122:6,
131:10, 236:1, 242:10
threatened [1] -
143:21
three [27] - 121:16,
135:8, 135:12, 136:1,
158:10, 159:9,
189:17, 189:22,
192:18, 203:2, 203:7,
204:9, 206:21,
206:25, 208:2,
216:18, 221:21,
227:12, 231:16,
237:16, 237:20,
270:12, 273:8,
292:21, 298:3
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
27
three-legged [1] -
270:12
three-year [2] -
221:21, 237:20
throughout [3] -
243:12, 280:23, 281:4
Thursday [1] -
210:14
timeframe [6] -
216:14, 216:22,
223:11, 224:4, 225:5
timeframes [1] -
225:3
timely [2] - 223:3,
274:17
timing [1] - 181:20
today [47] - 117:10,
118:6, 118:10,
118:16, 118:20,
120:4, 121:23,
130:24, 132:19,
138:23, 147:14,
151:22, 152:19,
156:14, 157:1,
157:14, 158:18,
159:23, 162:16,
164:18, 165:14,
167:18, 167:23,
168:14, 170:2,
187:14, 210:8, 210:9,
213:2, 213:6, 214:16,
214:22, 215:12,
215:14, 217:5, 219:6,
220:18, 229:5,
243:17, 250:5,
256:12, 264:18,
265:11, 266:9,
278:22, 293:14, 297:5
today's [2] - 214:15,
257:13
toeing [1] - 294:22
together [5] - 121:7,
233:1, 247:17,
253:22, 271:19
tolerating [1] - 296:1
tomorrow [3] -
212:13, 212:16, 217:5
tone [2] - 242:24,
247:25
tonight [1] - 210:18
tons [1] - 227:3
took [6] - 129:11,
140:10, 146:2,
148:19, 157:12, 291:6
tools [5] - 288:13,
292:10, 292:12,
292:18, 294:20
top [7] - 144:14,
181:16, 226:19,
227:2, 230:1, 252:20,
269:9
topic [2] - 171:4,
259:12
total [6] - 126:19,
160:14, 203:5, 203:8,
203:9, 284:18
touch [3] - 119:22,
124:18, 126:14
touched [1] - 294:1
tough [2] - 228:14,
268:14
tougher [1] - 203:19
tourist [1] - 157:6
towards [3] - 158:10,
165:8, 217:6
town [1] - 283:22
TPGW-7 [1] - 158:19
track [1] - 255:14
train [1] - 225:2
transaction [1] -
276:21
transcript [1] - 301:6
transfer [1] - 291:20
transition [1] - 285:6
transitioning [1] -
206:7
translate [1] - 245:10
translates [1] -
249:23
transmission [1] -
118:14
transparently [1] -
163:18
travel [1] - 253:24
traveled [1] - 158:10
Treasury [1] - 271:11
treated [3] - 248:2,
248:3, 249:8
treatment [1] -
197:23
tremendous [1] -
195:21
tremendously [1] -
243:24
trend [1] - 263:5
TRIA [1] - 263:17
trial [3] - 143:2,
277:13, 277:14
tried [2] - 143:3,
232:18
trip [1] - 196:18
tripped [1] - 138:3
tritium [6] - 136:13,
136:14, 136:21,
136:22, 136:23,
159:10
trouble [1] - 192:23
troubling [1] -
157:17
true [4] - 246:23,
268:24, 276:17, 301:6
truly [1] - 241:12
TRUST [1] - 115:14
trust [4] - 193:2,
193:6, 235:9, 235:10
trusted [1] - 193:5
TRUSTEES [1] -
115:13
truth [1] - 275:22
truthfully [1] - 150:5
try [21] - 126:20,
126:21, 132:2, 163:6,
163:7, 165:19,
183:12, 216:9,
216:10, 223:5, 232:1,
232:24, 238:24,
238:25, 239:1,
247:18, 248:6,
260:17, 266:22, 299:3
trying [15] - 118:19,
125:9, 148:11,
167:12, 188:16,
197:12, 199:5, 202:3,
205:7, 230:17,
252:17, 260:19,
260:24, 267:18,
296:11
tUESDAY [1] -
114:14
Turkey [7] - 118:2,
131:8, 141:22,
156:20, 156:21,
157:17, 163:10
turn [4] - 118:3,
137:9, 224:16, 227:7
tutelage [2] - 282:4,
290:14
twice [3] - 209:22,
209:23, 209:24
twist [1] - 140:13
two [34] - 117:10,
119:1, 121:16, 126:2,
127:2, 128:3, 128:4,
129:25, 130:20,
134:8, 153:12,
159:12, 162:2,
173:25, 177:7, 185:9,
195:9, 215:12,
227:12, 237:19,
244:10, 245:23,
253:4, 264:17, 265:4,
268:4, 294:14, 296:5,
298:21, 298:24,
299:7, 299:9
two-fold [1] - 265:4
two-pronged [1] -
268:4
type [2] - 197:21,
251:3
types [1] - 247:19
typical [2] - 269:5,
277:21
U
U.S [1] - 294:24
ultimately [5] -
193:10, 193:15,
195:5, 244:6, 248:7
unafraid [6] - 281:17,
281:18, 289:5, 292:21
unanimous [1] -
256:4
unanimously [1] -
160:10
Unclaimed [1] -
295:9
unconditional [1] -
189:6
under [26] - 123:23,
127:7, 129:12,
131:16, 138:1,
138:11, 141:7,
141:24, 142:10,
144:10, 151:17,
158:20, 184:17,
190:9, 191:23, 197:1,
197:2, 200:18,
202:19, 207:12,
216:1, 217:19,
224:14, 237:5,
254:22, 282:3
under-performance
[1] - 224:14
underachievers [2] -
239:17, 239:20
underage [1] -
194:14
underlying [2] -
118:19, 159:19
underneath [1] -
137:3
understood [2] -
159:19, 202:20
underway [1] -
169:23
undrinkable [1] -
160:7
unequivocal [1] -
291:12
Unfair [1] - 292:13
unfortunate [2] -
268:22, 276:19
unfortunately [1] -
250:24
UNIDENTIFIED [1] -
213:8
unique [2] - 260:10,
264:19
uniquely [1] - 222:19
unit's [1] - 158:12
United [3] - 261:7,
280:23, 281:5
Units [1] - 118:2
unleashed [1] -
286:16
unless [8] - 119:12,
119:19, 120:13,
123:25, 148:9, 172:6,
172:18, 251:18
unprofessional [1] -
286:16
unreasonable [1] -
237:14
up [57] - 122:5,
128:5, 129:20,
132:10, 133:8,
134:14, 135:15,
135:19, 139:10,
139:11, 139:20,
146:13, 150:25,
155:3, 165:25, 169:6,
174:2, 174:3, 174:11,
194:8, 195:1, 195:14,
198:7, 203:20,
205:11, 205:16,
206:1, 207:6, 215:24,
219:23, 231:14,
239:19, 243:17,
248:12, 250:5,
255:13, 255:25,
259:16, 263:25,
265:15, 265:16,
265:24, 266:6, 271:8,
275:15, 276:25,
278:8, 283:8, 283:22,
293:13, 297:11,
297:17, 298:12,
299:19, 299:21,
300:3, 300:7
upgrade [1] - 158:12
upper [2] - 152:12,
173:22
user [1] - 138:7
V
value [3] - 202:7,
270:2, 288:10
valued [1] - 259:16
variables [2] - 290:6
various [3] - 223:21,
225:9, 291:22
Varn [6] - 118:4,
142:18, 144:18,
151:4, 169:5, 169:22
VARN [51] - 118:9,
120:2, 120:5, 120:16,
121:13, 130:9,
130:15, 148:5,
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
28
149:12, 149:15,
164:19, 164:25,
166:3, 166:19,
166:21, 167:13,
169:25, 170:6, 170:8,
170:13, 170:16,
170:20, 173:7,
173:10, 173:17,
173:21, 174:2, 174:5,
174:10, 174:14,
174:17, 174:22,
175:1, 175:6, 175:11,
175:25, 176:8, 180:6,
180:9, 180:18, 181:6,
181:23, 182:11,
182:14, 183:5,
183:15, 183:18,
183:20, 184:13,
185:12, 185:14
vast [1] - 286:1
vehicles [2] - 263:18,
292:18
vendor [1] - 294:25
venues [1] - 163:17
version [1] - 201:11
VETERANS [1] -
115:5
vibrant [1] - 289:21
Vice [1] - 130:25
Vickers [3] - 217:19,
219:18, 225:17
victim [2] - 234:24,
236:22
victimization [1] -
237:7
view [6] - 205:20,
205:23, 235:5,
259:17, 266:18,
269:25
viewed [2] - 226:21,
231:19
views [2] - 259:13
vigilant [2] - 289:22,
294:5
vigor [1] - 289:3
vigorous [6] -
261:15, 267:11,
290:21, 294:17,
295:6, 297:15
Viking [1] - 271:18
violate [2] - 137:16,
137:17
violated [1] - 193:12
violating [2] -
146:18, 150:9
violation [2] -
193:15, 208:1
violations [3] -
151:25, 203:2, 204:8
violent [1] - 197:21
violets [2] - 248:19,
249:1
virtually [1] - 177:10
virtue [1] - 223:4
vision [5] - 216:25,
223:13, 261:3,
263:20, 267:10
visited [1] - 292:7
volition [1] - 284:8
VOLUME [2] - 114:7,
117:2
volumes [1] - 134:5
volunteered [2] -
283:25, 284:1
vortex [1] - 133:19
vote [2] - 211:20,
253:2
voted [3] - 211:12,
211:19, 286:13
W
wagering [1] -
254:19
wages [1] - 231:11
wait [5] - 198:14,
218:12, 240:2,
240:15, 263:8
wake [1] - 216:8
walk [5] - 210:3,
210:18, 270:2,
297:22, 297:24
walking [5] - 232:9,
283:7, 283:8, 295:16
wander [1] - 164:6
wants [2] - 159:24,
191:14
Wars [1] - 142:22
WAS [1] - 300:13
Washington [8] -
258:14, 263:19,
263:23, 264:2, 265:9,
266:16, 269:10,
278:15
watch [3] - 136:15,
138:2, 292:23
watched [1] - 137:9
water [75] - 121:25,
124:8, 124:17, 125:5,
128:20, 129:4, 131:9,
131:19, 131:21,
133:7, 133:11,
133:14, 133:19,
134:3, 134:7, 134:10,
134:14, 134:17,
134:19, 134:22,
134:24, 134:25,
135:4, 135:12,
135:20, 135:22,
136:2, 136:21,
136:22, 136:23,
137:12, 137:14,
137:16, 137:24,
138:7, 138:8, 138:24,
138:25, 139:5, 139:7,
139:13, 139:21,
140:6, 141:9, 141:25,
143:5, 143:7, 144:3,
144:12, 144:13,
146:18, 150:10,
152:12, 153:17,
154:9, 158:17,
158:19, 158:21,
159:18, 159:20,
160:3, 160:6, 160:7,
161:13, 161:16,
161:17, 162:13,
165:16, 169:13,
176:2, 177:20,
177:24, 178:3
Water [14] - 131:15,
131:22, 136:19,
139:24, 140:16,
141:15, 145:12,
153:16, 154:16,
158:4, 159:7, 160:9,
173:9, 173:19
water-use [2] -
124:8, 138:8
Watkins [1] - 115:8
ways [4] - 204:1,
244:13, 263:18,
269:21
weaknesses [1] -
219:3
wealthy [1] - 275:4
website [1] - 238:7
weeds [1] - 250:20
week [2] - 210:23,
214:13
weeks [1] - 204:12
weigh [2] - 128:5,
148:3
welcome [1] - 288:16
well-established [1]
- 142:19
wells [9] - 122:4,
122:24, 122:25,
131:9, 131:10, 137:8,
138:2, 158:25, 159:2
west [11] - 122:7,
134:22, 137:3,
137:15, 138:1,
138:17, 156:21,
158:10, 158:15,
159:11, 160:11
western [1] - 135:2
westward [2] -
131:21, 166:9
WHEREUPON [1] -
300:13
whole [5] - 153:18,
249:20, 278:19,
292:25, 295:21
wholesale [1] - 267:5
Williams [1] - 115:10
Williams' [1] -
297:25
willing [6] - 239:6,
249:3, 253:5, 256:6,
270:8, 288:14
wish [4] - 152:18,
189:13, 192:3, 277:23
wished [1] - 127:16
withdrawal [4] -
152:12, 155:13,
173:18, 174:24
withdrawals [1] -
175:4
withheld [1] - 193:14
WITHOUT [1] - 117:2
withstand [1] -
173:16
witness [7] - 127:19,
127:20, 137:7,
140:19, 280:23,
280:24
witnesses [7] -
133:21, 136:19,
137:7, 139:13, 140:1,
147:20, 150:3
wondered [1] -
297:10
word [5] - 179:19,
232:9, 237:8, 240:13,
272:7
wording [1] - 140:14
words [3] - 153:19,
165:10, 181:12
workers' [6] -
272:24, 273:9, 298:2,
298:6, 298:7, 298:11
works [6] - 134:10,
197:16, 236:6,
243:13, 254:10,
254:11
world [5] - 198:10,
226:18, 261:8, 289:1,
292:23
worrying [1] - 231:6
worse [3] - 160:24,
169:14, 169:15
worth [2] - 292:6,
296:11
worthy [1] - 296:24
write [8] - 147:4,
263:24, 265:6, 268:1,
268:2, 268:7, 271:7,
271:8
write-your-own [3] -
C & N REPORTERS TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA 850-697-8314
29
263:24, 265:6, 271:7
writing [1] - 267:21
Y
y'all [3] - 199:13,
237:3, 277:6
year [35] - 121:20,
122:19, 139:5, 155:7,
155:8, 162:18, 174:9,
174:13, 178:3,
199:18, 202:12,
203:5, 203:8, 203:9,
203:15, 203:22,
204:11, 204:14,
205:16, 206:6,
209:20, 209:23,
221:21, 237:20,
240:3, 240:6, 245:25,
252:1, 254:3, 267:19,
267:20, 281:15,
296:18
yearly [1] - 139:8
years [55] - 140:18,
140:20, 140:25,
141:1, 141:2, 141:4,
144:2, 150:16,
157:12, 158:3,
158:18, 159:6, 159:8,
159:9, 159:16,
160:12, 160:17,
161:8, 166:12,
192:18, 193:19,
193:25, 194:5,
194:11, 194:12,
194:17, 194:23,
195:9, 198:22,
198:23, 205:19,
205:21, 205:22,
219:22, 220:24,
222:21, 223:1,
226:14, 226:15,
227:16, 227:23,
228:20, 231:16,
237:16, 263:23,
265:21, 269:7, 272:1,
277:17, 287:25,
288:1, 296:5
younger [2] - 194:24,
195:2
yourself [2] - 280:12,
285:2
Z
zero [1] - 126:22
Zingale [2] - 219:18,
238:10
zone [1] - 276:1