1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range...

13
1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historic al Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 A S e r v i c e A U t i l i z a t i o n B U t i l i z a t i o n B S e r v i c e American Electric Power’s Experience with Volt/Var Optimization

Transcript of 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range...

Page 1: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

1

Presentation to:SWEDE Conference

Austin, TXMay 2, 2013

Tom Weaver, PE

Historical VoltageRange

VVO Range

120

124

128

116

112

108

104

“A”

Se

rvic

e

“A” U

tilizatio

n

“B” U

tilizatio

n

“B” S

erv

ice

American Electric Power’s Experience with

Volt/Var Optimization

Page 2: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

2

Volt VAR Impacts on Customer’s Motors

Real Power consumption is 8% lower @ 115V than at

125V

kVAR ↓ ~ 20%

kW ↓ ~ 8%

Page 3: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

3

Volt VAR Optimization Architecture

3

Volt VAR Controllers

Mesh Network

Mesh Master

EOL Monitors

Line Regulators

Line Capacitors

DMS - GENe

Fiber or Mesh

Page 4: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

4

AEP’s Volt / VAR Optimization Technology Deployments

• AEP Ohio :– 17 circuits in service– Additional circuits being considered to meet EE State Targets

• Indiana & Michigan Power Co.:– 9 circuits in service– Planning to include VVO as an EE Program

• Public Service Company Oklahoma :– 11 circuits in service

• Kentucky Power Co. :– 25 circuits going in service in 2013– Planning to include VVO as an EE Program

Page 5: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

55

AEP Ohio: Gahanna – 4505 Voltage Profile

Substation

EOL 2CAP 2 CAP 3

Without AdaptiVolt™ = 6-7-11 @ 4:30 pm With AdaptiVolt™ = 6-6-11 @ 4:30pm

REG

Flatter voltage profile, lower voltage, reduced tap changer operations

Page 6: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

6

AEP Ohio: East Broad 1406 Voltage Profile

Normal Operation = 7-23-10 @4:44pmVolt / Var Control Operating = 7-24-10 @4:44pm

Substation

EOL 55CAP 1 CAP 3 CAP 4REG 1 REG 2CAP 2

116.0

118.0

120.0

122.0

124.0

126.0

Normal Operation With VVC

Page 7: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

7

Demand and Energy Reduction Results

• VVO technology works as-expected Testing demonstrates ~2-4% energy and demand reduction is

achievable.

Page 8: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

8

Example of Energy Savings on Circuit 4503

Page 9: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

9

SCADA / PI View

Page 10: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

10

SCADA / PI View

Page 11: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

11

“Value” of VVO Compared to

Generation Alternatives

Levelized cost of VVO is in the low part of the Energy Efficiency range due to low initial capital cost and no on-going fuel cost

“LEVELIZED COST OF ENERGY ANALYSIS “– VERSION 3.0 Lazard, February 2009

Page 12: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

12

VVO for Energy Efficiency / Capacity Reduction

• Energy Efficiency (24/7 Operation)– Help meet state Energy Efficiency targets– Receive incentives / participate in DR markets – TRCs 2 to 3 – better than many current programs– Reduce Energy Consumption by Customers– Not limited by “participation rates”– Reduce Emissions – Relieve Transmission Congestion

• Capacity (Demand Reduction Only )– Reduce amount of capacity required at peak / critical times– Short payback period if generation charges are based on peak demand– Defer investment in capacity replacement or upgrades– Engage in DR Market– Relieve Transmission Congestion

Page 13: 1 Presentation to: SWEDE Conference Austin, TX May 2, 2013 Tom Weaver, PE Historical Voltage Range VVO Range 120 124 128 116 112 108 104 “A” Service “A”

13

Questions?Tom Weaver – [email protected]