1 MOVING FORWARD: DEVELOPING NEXT STEPS THROUGH INTERACTIVE SURVEY.
-
Upload
hollie-daniels -
Category
Documents
-
view
213 -
download
0
Transcript of 1 MOVING FORWARD: DEVELOPING NEXT STEPS THROUGH INTERACTIVE SURVEY.
1
MOVING FORWARD:DEVELOPING NEXT STEPS
THROUGHINTERACTIVE SURVEY
2
PURPOSE
To have an interactive discussion on priorities for the lobster industry.
To seek your input on where we go from here and how we get there.
3
COLLECTING YOUR INPUTElectronic input:
Everyone has received an “audience response system” (i.e. a handheld device) which you will use to respond to a variety of questions
Collective feedback will be provided immediately
You will not be identified individually in relation to your responses; however, we would like to confirm some general information which will help us to identify common trends
4
COLLECTING YOUR INPUT
28%
12%
7%
3%
8%
22%
3%
8%
9%
1. Fisherman1. Fisherman
2. Processor2. Processor
3. Live shipper3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government5. Provincial government
6. Federal government6. Federal government
7. Science community7. Science community
8. Industry associations8. Industry associations
9. Other9. Other
Which would best describe your affiliation:Which would best describe your affiliation:Which would best describe your affiliation:
5
Do you feel there is enough scienceto demonstrate that Atlantic Canada
lobster stocks are sustainable?
6
Do you feel there is enough scienceto demonstrate that Atlantic Canada
lobster stocks are sustainable?
7
If more science is needed to demonstrate sustainability, who
should pay?
8
37% 4% 59%
9% 91%
17% 17% 66%
100%
100%
16% 11% 73%
100%
25% 75%
33% 67%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Fishermen
2. Processors
3. Government
4. Fishermen/Processors
5. All
If more science is needed to demonstrate sustainability, who
should pay?
9
An MSC pre-assessment identifies gaps in scientific knowledge and effective
management. Do you agree that a pre-assessment should be conducted?
10
72% 16% 12%
84% 8% 8%
83% 17%
67% 33%
100%
95% 5%
50% 50%
57% 14% 29%
74% 13% 13%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
3. No opinion
An MSC pre-assessment identifies gaps in scientific knowledge and effective
management. Do you agree that a pre-assessment should be conducted?
11
What is the most effective way of strengthening compliance in the
lobster fishery?
12
25% 18% 57%
25% 8% 67%
17% 83%
100%
25% 75%
18% 14% 68%
50% 50%
14% 86%
33% 22% 45%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Increased enforcement
2. Stiffer penalties (higher fines)
3. Suspension of licenses
What is the most effective way of strengthening compliance in the
lobster fishery?
13
In order of importance, indicate what is the most effective way to improve lobster quality
on the vessel.
14
In order of importance, indicate what is the most effective way to improve lobster quality
on the vessel. (1st Choice)
15
19% 57% 12% 12%
67% 25% 8%
57% 14% 29%
34% 33% 33%
29% 57% 14%
25% 15% 35% 25%
50% 50%
38% 49% 13%
34% 33% 22% 11%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Education
2. Standardized handling practices
3. Price incentives for quality
4. Slowing down the fishery
In order of importance, indicate what is the most effective way to improve lobster quality
on the vessel. (2nd Choice)
16
54% 27% 15% 4%
25% 34% 33% 8%
14% 28% 29% 29%
33% 67%
29% 42% 29%
42% 32% 21% 5%
100%
14% 57% 29%
25% 13% 37% 25%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Education
2. Standardized handling practices
3. Price incentives for quality
4. Slowing down the fishery
In order of importance, indicate what is the most effective way to improve lobster quality
on the vessel. (3rd Choice)
17
3%10% 13% 74%
31% 69%
13% 13% 25% 49%
33% 67%
100%
5% 23% 18% 54%
50% 50%
22% 78%
20% 30% 50%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Education
2. Standardized handling practices
3. Price incentives for quality
4. Slowing down the fishery
In order of importance, indicate what is the most effective way to improve lobster quality
on the vessel. (4th Choice)
18
What is the most effective way of ensuring the future viability of Atlantic Canada lobster stocks?
19
38% 33% 21% 8%
55% 27% 18%
17% 17% 33% 33%
33% 67%
13% 62% 25%
65% 29% 6%
33% 67%
14% 86%
33% 50% 17%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Increasing carapace size
2. V-notching and returning females
3. Returning large female lobsters
4. Shifting the seasons
What is the most effective way of ensuring the future viability of Atlantic Canada lobster stocks?
20
In order of priority, what would you recommend to undertake collectively to
maximize the value of the resource in the plant.
21
In order of priority, what would you recommend to undertake collectively to
maximize the value of the resource in the plant.(1st Choice)
20% 32% 48%
33% 17% 25% 25%
28% 29% 14% 29%
34% 33% 33%
13% 25% 62%
25% 30% 25% 20%
34% 33% 33%
33% 50% 17%
22% 45% 22% 11%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Better communication from the market
2. More structured and collaborative approach
3. Quality based pricing
4. Best practices for plants.
22
41% 32% 16% 11%
11% 22% 45% 22%
29% 14% 57%
67% 33%
37% 25% 38%
22% 11% 56% 11%
100%
20% 20% 40% 20%
49% 17% 17% 17%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Better communication from the market
2. More structured and collaborative approach
3. Quality based pricing
4. Best practices for plants.
In order of priority, what would you recommend to undertake collectively to
maximize the value of the resource in the plant.(2nd Choice)
23
12% 35% 29% 24%
38% 49% 13%
34% 33% 33%
67% 33%
14% 58% 14% 14%
43% 29% 14% 14%
50% 50%
20% 20% 40% 20%
20% 20% 60%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Better communication from the market
2. More structured and collaborative approach
3. Quality based pricing
4. Best practices for plants.
In order of priority, what would you recommend to undertake collectively to
maximize the value of the resource in the plant.(3rd Choice)
24
31% 8% 8% 53%
13% 13% 13% 61%
17% 83%
33% 67%
50% 17% 33%
17% 25% 8% 50%
50% 50%
25% 25% 50%
60% 40%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Better communication from the market
2. More structured and collaborative approach
3. Quality based pricing
4. Best practices for plants.
In order of priority, what would you recommend to undertake collectively to
maximize the value of the resource in the plant.(4th Choice)
25
In order to improve returns from lobster, do you support the creation of a working group to
address the competitive environment?
26
64% 36%
83% 17%
86% 14%
100%
87% 13%
100%
100%
75% 25%
100%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
In order to improve returns from lobster, do you support the creation of a working group to
address the competitive environment?
27
Do you feel there is merit in launching a generic marketing
campaign in the U.S.?
28
71% 29%
58% 42%
43% 57%
33% 67%
75% 25%
71% 29%
100%
71% 29%
50% 50%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
Do you feel there is merit in launching a generic marketing
campaign in the U.S.?
29
Do you feel there is merit in launching a generic marketing
campaign in the E.U.?
30
93% 7%
92% 8%
71% 29%
67% 33%
100%
86% 14%
100%
86% 14%
100%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
Do you feel there is merit in launching a generic marketing
campaign in the E.U.?
31
Do you feel there is merit in launching a generic marketing
campaign in Asia?
32
96% 4%
75% 25%
71% 29%
33% 67%
87% 13%
81% 19%
67% 33%
86% 14%
56% 44%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
Do you feel there is merit in launching a generic marketing
campaign in the Asia?
33
Does your experience indicate that traceability mechanisms within the Quality
Management Program are adequate to meet modern food safety requirements?
34
28% 44% 28%
67% 33%
43% 43% 14%
100%
62% 13% 25%
20% 80%
50% 50%
72% 14% 14%
13% 13% 74%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
3. Don't know
Does your experience indicate that traceability mechanisms within the Quality
Management Program are adequate to meet modern food safety requirements?
35
Do you believe the Atlantic lobster industry would benefit
from ecolabelling?
36
68% 21% 11%
84% 8% 8%
42% 29% 29%
34% 33% 33%
87% 13%
86% 14%
100%
62% 13% 25%
87% 13%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
3. No opinion
Do you believe the Atlantic lobster industry would benefit
from ecolabelling?
37
Does the industry need to explore the development of a market intelligence
vehicle?
38
68% 11% 21%
84% 8% 8%
100%
100%
86% 14%
79% 21%
100%
87% 13%
74% 13% 13%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
3. No opinion
Does the industry need to explore the development of a market intelligence
vehicle?
39
Would there be an advantage to setting up a lobster council to:
A) Undertake a marketing campaign?
40
71% 22% 7%
92% 8%
86% 14%
67% 33%
72% 14% 14%
95% 5%
100%
74% 13% 13%
87% 13%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
3. No opinion
Would there be an advantage to setting up a lobster council to:
A) Undertake a marketing campaign?
41
Would there be an advantage to setting up a lobster council to:
B) Foster collaborative effort along the value chain?
42
84% 8% 8%
92% 8%
86% 14%
100%
100%
86% 14%
100%
87% 13%
71% 29%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
3. No opinion
Would there be an advantage to setting up a lobster council to:
A) Undertake a marketing campaign?
43
Would there be an advantage to setting up a lobster council to:
C) Look at regulatory issues?
44
53% 43% 4%
75% 25%
71% 29%
100%
49% 38% 13%
67% 14% 19%
33% 67%
25% 62% 13%
74% 13% 13%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
3. No opinion
Would there be an advantage to setting up a lobster council to:
C) Look at regulatory issues?
45
Would there be an advantage to setting up a lobster council to:
D) Develop a market intelligence vehicle?
46
70% 19% 11%
92% 8%
100%
100%
100%
86% 9% 5%
100%
86% 14%
67% 33%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
3. No opinion
Would there be an advantage to setting up a lobster council to:
D) Develop a market intelligence vehicle?
47
Would there be an advantage to setting up a lobster council to:
E) Be the client responsible for application to the Marine Stewardship Council?
48
45% 33% 22%
83% 17%
71% 29%
100%
38% 49% 13%
47% 24% 29%
67% 33%
14% 86%
37% 25% 38%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
3. No opinion
Would there be an advantage to setting up a lobster council to:
E) Be the client responsible for application to
the Marine Stewardship Council?
49
Was the Summit a helpful exercise in bringing industry participants together to discuss common problems and look for
solutions?
50
83% 17%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
100%
86% 14%
100%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
Was the Summit a helpful exercise in bringing industry participants together to discuss common problems and look for
solutions?
51
Would you like to have another Summit in -
52
45% 37% 7% 11%
50% 42% 8%
71% 29%
67% 33%
33% 50% 17%
65% 35%
100%
29% 71%
29% 57% 14%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. 2008 (next year)
2. 2009 (two years)
3. 2010 (three years)
4. Other
5. Never
Would you like to have another Summit in -
53
Did you find that the electronic voting provided valuable insight regarding industry perspectives?
54
61% 39%
92% 8%
100%
100%
100%
71% 29%
50% 50%
87% 13%
89% 11%
1. Fisherman
2. Processor
3. Live shipper
4. Buyer/wholesaler/distributor
5. Provincial government
6. Federal government
7. Science community
8. Industry associations
9. Other
1. Yes
2. No
Did you find that the electronic voting provided valuable insight regarding industry perspectives?
55
Thank you for your excellent participation