1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

28
1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy Energy

Transcript of 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

Page 1: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

11

Digesters for Managing Animal

WasteWorkshop

August 21, 2002August 21, 2002Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy

Page 2: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

22

Alliant EnergyAlliant Energy

We serve approximately 53,000 ag customers in a four-state territory.

Alliant Energy Resources, Inc., our non-utility business, has operations in Australia, Brazil, China, Mexico and New Zealand

6,000 employees in U.S. and internationally

Page 3: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

33

Generation diversity

Coal Natural Gas Renewable energy sources Distributed resources

== Reliability

Page 4: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

44

Why Alliant Energy ?

53,000 farm accounts, large rural utility Believe in removing economic barriers Rural economic development Believe in distributive generation Strong environmental ethic Tradition of working with the development of

ag. energy technologies

Page 5: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

55

Food processing industry environmental challenge

Page 6: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

66

Seneca Bio-digesterMontgomery, Minn.

Page 7: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

77

Alliant Energy’s - Wisconsin Biogas Project

10 MW generation Farm, food processor, landfill

& sewage treatment sources 3-year project 5-year contracts 6 cent/kWh (customer

owned)

Page 8: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

88

10 Megawatts ?10 Megawatts ?

50,000 tons of coal each year 500 coal cars 5 unit trains Electricity for 11,000 homes

Page 9: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

99

Pilot Project Objectives

Access digester technologies Access generation technologies Remove technology barriers Evaluate utility barriers Access market potential Increase demand for “green energy”

Page 10: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

1010

Deere Ridge Farm, Anaerobic Digester,

Amherst, Wis.

Page 11: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

1111

Double S Dairy, Alto, WI

Flush system Plug flow Hess gen-set Separated solids for bedding and sale

Page 12: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

1212

Topdeck HolsteinsWestgate, IA

Page 13: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

1313

Microturbine

Page 14: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

1414

Engine Monitoring and Switchgear

Page 15: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

1515

Reciprocating Engine

Page 16: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

1616

Heat Recovery System

Utilize heat from exhaust of engine or microturbine

Heat digester Heat buildings Heat hot water heater Heat anything else that needs hot water Refrigeration

Page 17: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

1717

Biomass Lessons Challenges and Opportunities

Page 18: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

1818

Lessons Learned

Digester designs Corrosion Pre-heating costs Soft vs. hard top Local labor and skills Gen-set O&M costs Dewatering Customer expectations Bedding requirements Niche market opportunities BUYER BEWARE, DO YOUR HOMEWORK!

Page 19: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

1919

Barriers to Development of Renewable Energy

Technology

Technology must be solution for the customer and add value to their business

High-risk technologies for customer and utility investment

Utilities have an obligation to energy cost and reliability

Few dominant companies, largely a cottage industry, except for wind

Page 20: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

2020

Economic Barriers

Utilities must satisfy many stakeholders: customers, shareowners, regulators, interest groups

Must weigh “price is everything” vs. “environment is everything,” must blend needs

Marketplace drives price, there must be greater demand

Risk management, need rewards for investment risks

Page 21: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

2121

Social – Political BarriersSocial – Political Barriers

NIMBY’ism “big is bad” attitudes Should societal benefits be paid for by society

or by utility owners and their customers? Many political uncertainties…DOE, USDA,

EPA, State/Local Regulations…

Page 22: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

2222

Institutional BarriersInstitutional Barriers

Uniform interconnection standards across utility and state jurisdictions

Net metering Insurance requirements Some utilities charge high access and/or

interconnection fees Lack of renewable energy credits Difficulty with customer aggregation

Page 23: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

2323

Market BarriersMarket Barriers

Dependency on local utility Access to transmission system can be expensive

and complex Limited “green power” program participation Smaller generators have market disadvantages Risk, purchasing power from inexperienced

energy provider

Page 24: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

2424

Biomass Project Success Requires

Favorable power purchase agreements Partnership development Predictable cash flow Market for secondary products Tradable “green qualities” Incentives de-coupled from cost of fossil fuels Access to financing

Page 25: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

2525

Opportunities

Utilities and customers partnering in addressing environmental and energy challenges

Monies from commodity purchase stays in local communities

May allow delaying or avoidance of utility infrastructure investment

Convert environmental liability into economic assets

rr

Page 26: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

2626

Public Policy

“…We have only scratched the surface of developing farm-based sources of renewable energy—ethanol, biodiesel, biomass, wind, methane, hydrogen. Agriculture is not just about food and fiber. Anything we can produce from a barrel of oil, we can also produce on our farms.”

-- -- Sen. Tom Harkin, IA, Senate Agriculture Committee, June 28, 2001

Page 27: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

2727

Philosophies

““Be a price maker not a price taker.”

--Loren Kruse

“Grow what you can sell, don’t sell what you can grow.”

----Duane Acker

Page 28: 1 Digesters for Managing Animal Waste Workshop August 21, 2002 Bill Johnson, Alliant Energy.

2828

William A. Johnson

Manager, Agriculture Customer Manager, Agriculture Customer ServicesServices

Alliant EnergyAlliant Energy

2777 Columbia Dr.2777 Columbia Dr.

Portage, WI 53901Portage, WI 53901

(608) 742-0824(608) 742-0824

[email protected]@alliantenergy.com