01 1I Gill t'QCase 1:07-cv-00588-ODE Document 1 Filed...

~01 c ' 1I Gill t'Qkit.

Plaintiff,

FILE, r10, ~--vs.

C1COM.P'L A L ][]VC

Section 3,3 :1,, as Defendant's liability aiises undcr a tc'u-iff fill2d with the!

UNITED !i"1AIT-S z»US"TRI"E"~rr cOCJRTNORTHERN DISTRic,r GEORGIA

Jp. MrS i v

EUJIuivisioN

AT&T CC r

PLANNED PARENTHOOD 101F

GEOR.G3IA, INC ., a l3w,o :rg:ia nion-profitcorporation,

Def~~ndl~~r~l; .

COMES NOW the Plaintiff, .A,U'c '7` Core. a New York

corporation, by and through its attonieys, and sm..; ith(-, D(-lfinidant, "PLANNED

F'AF;IEl`JTHO C)D OF (-TT" ( DIFZG][A, ][PVC,, a GiE,ar;7 i~~ non - prolfi~~ ~;oil~~~:ralricm, and for

cause says :

J UF: ILS":D»: c J71or1

1 ,

Rir7sdiction in this ouat over Count I ~of t Yv.s, Complaint is prope r under 28

Case 1:07-cv-00588-ODE Document 1 Filed 03/13/07 of 5

s.

Fecie;ra] (;onimranicaticnl ;s Commission (the "F.t,,,C.") arid pursuallit to Section 203

of the Federal Conamiun .icatiorls Act of 193 4, 4-7 IJ . S5 .C. § 2:O 1 , et seq., as, a.menAcId .

,1

Venue in this Court is proper under 28 jJ .S .C' . § ]. :3!a1(b){1) .

3 .

is a New York orpora .tio7n Nvi 1 .h its primipal place of busincss

located at 32 Avenue o f the Ame;ri .c:aS , New York, New Yc»k, andl. was at, all times

pertinent to this actim aiuthorizE ;i3 to do business :iii the Statre of Georgia .

4 .

Upon i .r ii:ormation and[ belief, the lCle ;fe,nda;nt., Planned ]Parenthood of

Eiec~r~ ;ia, lr.~c ., a Georgia neon.-rIre~filt ccOYxro~~~jti{on., with its principal place of bu,~nnf ..>>

lo ~ c: a~tf ;d. at '7 .5 Piedmont Avenue, [~T .~: ., Suite, 800, ~~t1arl' ta, ~~ t~ltori C~ou . rit.y, i~~ec> >r~; :ia

~1O ;303, was at all times pertirif;lit 1:0 1 :Yus action doing business ins the State of

Georgia .

C'ID 1JrJ'T I

5 .

] Pl a: iril.iff restates the al : lf,ga: ti otis cont,ahle~d in F'ua~;ra~~hs 1 through 4 a~rui

in<<:c»'poraite , tlhenn by this irf,i:er'e :ric,e-„


3

6 .

As a result ~of usage by I)ef{endlaiil: ,xndVor thirid-party callers ui ti ll izing

Defendant's outgoing telephone ]L in .e ; s, Twe; ril :y Thousand Five flundred'Fighty

Three and 34110CI Dollars ($2 0,S8.3 .34) ) in 4,1]'nar;ges accrued over the Plaintiff's

network De:c; e , Ynbf ,r 3,11J{05 December 8, 20 i[1.> „

7 .

On or abou t April 1 9, :?+DO16, the Defendant a.c;knovillec igred. tha t these charges

accrued dills to thhrd .-pan.y callers gaining u.riauflho:~~ze ci access to their onsite

te li-li:.ionnriiun.icat: ioias equipment and thereby their alUtg; oirig 1 :e.leprio ,ne limes. (Se, f ;

E:Khibit " A"attached hereto and incorporated herein by re fe;re ;ncel„)

8 .

At all tillne;s relevant to this action, AT&T provided

services, pursuant to, A'I`&7, Tariff F .C.C, No,. 1 or the Business Cloniniunkatimis

>e.rvicE,s Agreement. (See :EJOii ibit " B„ attac-'. hedL hereto and inc;cyjpo :rate ci herein by

reference;.}

9 .

,A:C6i'T Tariff No, ]. § '9' . 4 and Business C'ojaii-riiiiiii(-, :iiticirl,,; Service's

Agreement § 4(a ) make .C) eiFe-ndan ,t responsible fc)r the; payment of bills for

te,lec i :Emffn ,u~ rl i .ratiion calls and serviees ,


L~

~0 .

Rimiaant 1:o ATa4i;T 'T`axi',Ff F.C.(: . No . 'I § 2',.5 and Business

Service:s Agreement § payment is due lzp{one within at most thirty (30) days

fn .-) m th .e; dute of invoice .

11 .

Plaintiff has demandedCmiel»ty 'T'hiomsa ;nd. Five Hundred Eighty Threc and

34/1. 01'.) Dollars {$2,0 , `i8 : 3 . :34} i;rorn. the Defendant fear senricv.; rendered to datf, .

12 .

De :fendai.,it failed and refused o pay thie Twenty Thousand ive FlundLredl

F1igllty Three and 34/100 Dolllus ($'20M,58,211o .34) dernanCied .

13 .

There re,rna .ins unpaid a. balmice dine, and ; 1.0 i'or

tel(-.r,E)nlmiun.icat:ion servires in the amount of Twenty 'mousand. Five Hundred

I :iglity Three arid :3411Ci0 Doll-cu•s ($'2.0,5 8<< .3 <4) .

14 .

WHEREFORE, ,A.TS,.'I' ;prays I:ha l : Tud ~gffie ;riit be lentereld as follows :

a. Awarding A,TBz'T "Cvie;nt;y Thousand Five lHlim3r,ed Eighty Three and

3,11]LI ". I 1 O Dollars ($20,:i 8 3 .34) for the ,>f,rVi .r,E; provided : ,


VVE;ISSM,ATr,1S'0WNC'K , 1 ;: iJ]tR .Y &W:Q,C+O , RC .

3500 L.e,aiox. :R '.oad4'h Floor , GrieAllimice. CenterAtlanta,, Georgia 30-326(404) 9216-4500(~4I)4 ;i 926-4600 (facsinv.le)

5

t) . :l . `i 'I) pe r month interest . on said aniount from 1 . rife demanded du e, date,

until pa id in full, pursuant o the Tariff r1o. 1 , §' "I5A and Business

Conir»unicat:io»s Services Agreement § 4i;c:) ;

c. Awarding AT&T its costs mid dislbursen ients, includlin.g attorneys' feles,

of prosecuting this action, pursuianl: to Tariff No. 1, § and Business

Cornnlunaca.tioms .`3ervicle's Agreement § 4(,,I;

(i. Granting AT'M' such other and furtlue:r relief as this Court may dLeein . j ust

and I)i,-oIper in the c,i.rcuirnstance,s .

This .1 2 t1 11 Ir7 U . ~~ of March 200-7Ll

- - ----------- ----- -----------------------

Sc;ot:t A. . ]IVunsorlGeorgia Bar No . 392092Allorne;yr> for l?lairil;iff


~ «`l ~y .~ p.,.. L10,, Ga,. A1,4 ; .1 ~~a,zcs~,~! , cc

E(10/ ~.'C1O d ~ 1'E ~Z ' I. l! 3Ci 0Z 61 4L+ x .I3I [3IT A, >>

page 1 of 2

aftt~

:Fr; ai111d l RA,-s0ai 1 a14DIa GIMip 3(I; ;Knij0ASla6%r, Rd, Rja oai 31D41,5s Ja 17rain 1'iSNttaway, : Nr Ci8854

32-651.1766f Ts2-652-176181 :1769

1~?rt1 +U'5, 2006 Via .A3irbo»-ne Epres ;sUEay Delliv,Pry

lb-,&a C;ofer1'ian:xxi Parenthood f (ieoigia75 P1< dI1]yi)11t Avenue NF7AtlarAo., GA 30303

3ze : : ]E,-T5 Case if: 1 . 608 1242Account # : 05910, 64991 '7(3i1].

JDtairRe.21-.irM . C,D :EfX :,

lOrn behalf" 4)f .AT'&i'„ we would like, to ac;knowIecigt: recedpt of your tall fraud &q)ik ; and outline tike :prcKedare; :fcsr fonnaLizjin;g your cLaini: We -u:ndasitand the &M-iousness of this va3cof,aunirrmce md zerooommilted to ne ;olvirig; this jaiztter'P:rcreL~p1 :1'V ailld anuGalAY-

' T MS ' ijMrYe: sfi gation is aPYJa;y uniten.d .ed to clck11MnIeI4It Wad sabslm ntiia.te your eiAnL Tim order 6u facilftitit e:CllaImi processing awl p~roaee&W-11% i DiEiir virrel tii g;ati Lan, please dlacuuii.' trt the details of your c :1 ai.na iu udw b[autlo ; lb elow + .

11ra'Ae: .'Y,vu An ,av resvrw ill wi~,^esfi mifflw your Locid Ebee:l4ttage. 1iri7iew ih-0 eo,a,tadn tt :M 7"U'Ving~~,ar~,rECS . ~f74~~ .Lac~a,C ,~xxa~~~~~~ ; e' Can~e~rsr ~~n a~ ~ri~~l,yau e~sr ~a~p~ ibilJ!iu~g ggerr~ H'irEms rr~ucr~e i:e a d(i:epa~xe~dc.harl ;el such cry tnilftaud„ rhe Ixcal Etch:a:nge Carrier may nLMoVeM , TsW c4.Purrges,{•aIM 444P411,MricCand refi~r•m'at be cong.trued as our waiver p fpgyrn:ent.fordaexe cha.q~es.

Toita1 dollar amount of the di.sp1al:ed calls, imluciing La~zc;s :'~1'C~~~~~~'S ?~~~_---------_~Account C~ •_kVlk _i.~~:~~~,___-------_wM------;[~aake a1` .A7'EC Account Exanitive (if a;RP]'.ic4ttil e;K _---------- -------------- ,'Te]EtcQxwyvv car:ioiys P,/jlllp[IIE a I t involved , ~3I18;L1' ~ Fz~cri ~t 'er of yatr itebx;onvnunica#ions sy,>tern I RM ; ,VIAce; nwLi l ctic.} : ~k fex•-f-, e-j-w~~ r? ----____

'To the bell; of .Vcat r laKivvled, g l .', 11aS the frafu0. < < t'DIPPOx l7': _04~`:~L------_--_---~__ _.1 .~eLjg dale af ' fruulud,Mjt calls:

Date vnadv was imtfa ieidl: _ C'C1 S'__ I?, att 9ys1keni was sonzed :A, l b ri.t~.' ; ;wiop sis, of how the fraud cwcurred {plemse attwh aAd 3i.tionai shoet:f, if :~,ev,css~.y)::

---~ .

VV'b; aa: security =a=rcs has your company takw iCo p :errbnl: this type crftruul :&aui havpm~al; a,pin?.

~wati- hdr. 1 ~v4SwIleA3

Case 1:07-cv-00588-ODE Document 1-1 Filed 03/13/07 Page 1 of 2

,Dchda HhuutEnoi€asLure

1141"X .11 UBIT "A"Page 2 (of' 2

S OQIE[I4d 191212 113 ~BfIOZ 614 J dU ' X'e-I

RUSirtecws Name Of di1rerent titan nbcvc): --

Business Acl&~aas : `1::~

C'u .stcrna~~ :3ig~autu~re : _y~6~ R~~.lef ~ x.s~ 1~ __ I'zizua3 bfuae:

Title, tc:---- - - ___-------R.ea,cls Nitralhi-_ 9-U~' _t-exnajl addi:es,s:

'IUs c+o 3 miFibl. form ALONG NVTFB[ +CCI]P]1141,S OF YO Cl"RIBYLYti; DF'.7CAIlC :I]!FGw 'THIE CALLSYQURIEI.IEV1E WENE YJ3lli()]RL;KED {!VOL7 CINGYlNE31:J17CO ]'I EiOV[1):E rm; .PAAx:ES7IIAI ' DIS'PrJOr THE 1DE5 iP0'I'E D '(:ALLS AND 711E 13 IUNCVlDURYOF OlllS ] PACr] ; 1,must t 1c imiadl[ed, or ,famedd on o :r before: eL12Q,l in order to avoid any c ORectiaa Wthlt~t 0In )`d1u:raccount. 'wi7HOUr APPROPRIATE nOCuMFNrA171or% YOUR. CLAIM MAN BIEDTNI]E.D. AU other anioumi:s not 1o dispute ERhoW be Imdd by itheur appro :p:riis#,e due d4fte to theaddress listed an ;y+yiu :euvoicv. Please forward this rloctiniw#ati iom to, the fiRoviing address or thefax number on page on e: :

Detain ]]u:rvnA s.: C&T l7ELG30 Knigttsbriclg; e : 1t,3,, Ro4mn :=t3b411

]Lf } rCrU. lmve. any ilm-stions n .-Irar d:ing, thi:c im, a t tar, you, can reach r rke : at 7132',45 :Z-- 1?b6 .

To be.~~r~r ~ more nboi~ i IV~z1~PRG~I~ : C'T' .~E :d'V~ICC :4 mid how to protect yra~ur oaln~p~ury from future toll fr~ xidl, o oititac• f jjf 'h+z Service k :stgblGsfum :nt Group (it i -1BI704NE"k"-SAFE <r visit +xv web site at

Acfcli'h ilo tmi lly„ A'TST- nWa rttni : ns a `fa ll F' r*A Secwity, Group around the cl ock 'I t o help 6usi nesus that : 3tj9pe .;t urau+rfiaOzea3 use of Ow-if" •rf :haFrhanie sr: ; teuns .. If you believe ya LH• •ca tn ixLny i s*xp:r ~icri ci rg toll fmidl plauase cvn'taict Ml S.curil ar 1 -• 800-i32 ] .-,82 :3'.3.


r

E:X:HPBIT"T"f'a€ ;e 1 of 6

r""""'rN

...__ ., ATWITILWIVSS.,..r.~~.w~ Innava iri~ rc Net+ rro ir~ ~ s ~ IEUic ivati ve 7~ ~ i i ~lcir~g`

~ ,5~. r~~ri c~~~ :~~ i~.gI I CE:~~,~nr i E; r~~1~Your us,e qf the ..9.'M: :T '&y-i)ices,nirvvia!ed ' under th:is ' . f[grEaeme ya if cons ti tuteSly19 urau~icEptance,qfth.e terms Of 'this do not agree with the terms ,of

thh,, l4gree1ne,mt, 4 a?6 not use the S?nf ice and irnrrr.edila:te1y contact your A T& TiC1~~'i i r(a~1~E .̀ 1~`. 1~ care canter, 01, Allow o S to c ,'I' the i)~°rviC'!?,

,.

.a.. S~ewrrices C`0`7erci3, T'lus Ag;reenieiilt ,seirvi.c'e .s ("' `ieileices" ;) not covered under.a tari ffor signed agreement. Thus Ageememt does not apply to .A;'C,&"I"Ccnxi Flan < rrangernen ts;, or toother Ya'~a' ;s earirii c : e;s; ,a ia1: :yoU, jpurcli,),se under a separate contractor ATWT Tariff'

b. Adldi .tional 'Yerni;s. 'b'rie ; ficf&'f Service Guide (`Nhkh includes prices„ se.Priic;e, desicri .ptions and otherteklzns) peitai»iirig to your IS W.1-Aces is incorparattui into this Agqrfse .zn .e;nt by reference atrECd is considered Ixarl .Of'the; Al, rF,e,ine.nI. YOU C,ui review ths. Ya'&T :Service. Guide athit~ )~:Ihovrvvur.atit_,c ,oni!:;e:rviceguli ,deA)l1 S iI3:e :5S. If yrou do not have acces s to the Il3teITLet, you may call yourjam' customer c~ are center for WSSiSIMICZ .

1kT '&.T may frorn tim+e to ii;rtis, cb~ange; time prices apLcE other Ge.rrr,s ()1F this .Rq;,-e;cr~ernt. C:HI~'Nf (.iF~i WILLBE POsIT C ) ,ed THE ,ANA:7rPERIOD Irk WHICH THE CRAr1+GiES BECOME EFFECTIVE . Your use e+#' 1fse; Services after tbechanges are eff" ;tiwe cxnnst:i1hrt :es Y oixr acceptance Of t3ts.~;ri .

.a . XI'&1. . .AT&;f agrees to provide -Services to you subject to the, awiii,alb ili -ty o f ' the required serv icecomponents and in accordance wit.hi th is Agreenlent .

Ili . Cui tonncr . You warrant tln,alk use ofattic; SRe;mices and (;+mIte;nt of ccfrnnnunic,aat io ns by you and thosewho access or use the Services purchased by you ("Users") will at aill times comply with all applicablelaws, , reg;ulatuOrks and[ instructions for use. "Content" includes irdbrmationtliade available, displayed ortaran .>>nii tte .dl in connection w i th the :3errrn c;es. No actions or inaction 13;y A7'13c.7" shall constitute review orapproval of your nor Use& use or Content. You arse responsible, fo r e. r iSuI ri ing 1.h1a1t a1 1 c rf the equipment that


Of 6

you wid IJsers wt is corn;paa.mc iv iai the s e ;rvi'aes .

4--, ]Fraudulent Use. If you suspect Mat the Services p3rcrrii&A to you t 'iavE, been fi-a uciulle;ritly a ,E;cl, :youiT.iwst immediately notify AT&T.

d. Indemnity. AT&T grants to you the right to permit Users to access and use the Services, provided thatyou shall remain solely re:spotmsibli, for the accf ;:>~s and use tayany User of the :ieiMces . You shall df.fie ;rui,,i.ric[emirufy and hold Nanrilf,<<s, ,A .T&7 from and against aR Damages arising out of third party cl,aim~sy-e;latiirtg to Your ~or Users' u :af, of the Service or Content car perfa,mlance of the 'Se ;rvize .

,~.. (Y+e:nera~ll, v„ ~'~r U111 cl~s]'f;e; to pay A~'C.&"r for our and Users' use; of the Se: rviic:es, ,a pt the charges specified Irldie A'T&T Service Guide, as atmerndfxl from t ime to time, without deduction, setoff or delay for anyirewson, P. t ,any tin1e, ~a&Trrta3r require , you. ito pay a deposit c» ° hicireasean existing deposit as :1oOndlit i.c ir i of'prcrAciirEg Services. You authorize, ~cr&T to iu n~vesfig;at-' your credit history a t any 1 . 1 1 1T1f; andto sttasc credit iri .farniation about you with CT-ed1.t reporting R g; e ;nc;ies .

b.']C:aX:e:sffl:e€,i~l~Ei toir;y ~~~rr ~cha.r~g ;es. t ;ly,a~r gE~.; as stated in the P~.f8i'~" Service Guide are exclusive oi' ;a :nyapplic;4U lle; t,,uce,s. You are re;sp<nwsible for all taxes, gross receipts Lurces , i fe;E,s and-sizeliarge-s relating to,the sale, tnuisf~r of awnerslh i p, ii ristallatiio n, lioense, use or provision o f' ifte Services , except to the em: Ktenlrthat you provide AT&T with a inalid taxx em-mYjtiorn certificate tx,-fore .A.7C&'C provides Services to you .You -u:e re,sl 3onsib'le, for papne;nt of , stirrh~qrf.s , including, lout not lintit-ld t ai LICC, 1JET, ]PICC andFiqj)lio ne cl11rj,:,3, ~sj3e~ci ~i~e~d in the ~~''8eF Service Ci~ .~ id~~ .

c. Payment F'a]nritrnlt of all chai ;ges is due within thirty (30) days after the date a3'ix i`ro ii c ; e ;, in s LI.S .cuirency. Restt iatirvE endorsemenlts or other statements on checks accepted by AT'L'z'T -Mll not apply. Youwill be responsible for reimbim-ing ; ,A T&T four all costs (including reasonable atto :niey fees) as,sOc;i atels3iv i1fi col llex ;tuig delinquent o r dlislhoniored p73.~nients. IT.A.Ti4c:']~ does not receive papili e ; rit b, y thLe due date,you may be charged interest on any unpaid balances at the, rate of up 'to I 1 l:Z'% rw;r month or thema:iniiim rate; aliow(K[ by law .

ii , . : ~~ ill ~ing; Cli.sp~ si~ ~e~~ . IF YIDjJ DISPUTE (:IHAR.(3ES ON YOUR BILL, YOU MUST N(YrIFY AT&T IN'WRITING OF THE DISM'IT WITHIN SIX . (6) MONTHS OF 'S 'HE; DATE ON THE AFFT ~C"]C]E,I)BILL1, OR ELSE "YOU WAIVE THE DISPUTE .

You can end this , A,gn•ee;rnen.t at wr~ time{ii :;t by giving us notice and ATM' can +do the : :sair riee l[fany o fthe Services a re 1 tc311 swil :c . hie;cl telephone service, you may tenr i inate these 'Sle-mrii c ;e ;s only by contactlingyour l icK21 e ;c,w ;lhang ;e; provider or by cOr ktact iirig a. new service provider to order SCIrlicz . You will beresponsible fUr payment of all charges due under, this Agreement through th e effective date oftermination. Additionally, Ya'&T ;ma,y i miTie ;diatel l ,~ tenmin .a.te„ restrict oi r suspend your Services withoutnotice, to you if : you fail to pay .A.'1[' .&'r an,( charg;e;s, when due ; :yOu Make, any false sta .teimE ;nll to A'T'M' ;~t'T&'T :su ,sp+ec'b , fraud. abuse or m ; isum, by you, Us eir.> or third parties; AT&T believes your or U:seirs ' useor Content may viOlEft this lkg ;reemenit or any laws or regulations or interi:e; res in any way with AT&Tsprovisionsia» cif ',~~`l["~&_'f,~`l["~&_'f services to ii ts customers or its business opC,171k tiOlns ; or you tx-,come insolvent or aresu,tject to any pro c; <%dilng under bankruptcy or similar laws .


of 6

..»„ For p»rpase-s ui', all iirldeumi.ty oblligafi ciws, exclusive i °e;rnedli +e;s a.nicd limitations of liabii l i ly seat f+xnhl inthis Ag7eenve;nt„ "'AT&T" shall be defined as A7['&']C , i ts afflilliatc;s, wid i ts and their ecnptoyees, directors,U1nkeT:i, agents,,, ,;ub~;ointra,cbpC;i, iint:erconilex,t1011 service providers and, suppliers ;"Customer"shall be defined as Custorrie i•, i t s affiliates, and[ Its q uid their climploye;es, directors, officers,ag~~ir~~ t~~ and. r~~p : r~~sf; : a~t~~ti~r~~.s ;, and. " ' ID~a~rnages" r~vi91 i refer r,U ll ~er~r ivel , y t o all inju~n~,, damage, 'liability, loss,pem. a[ty, interest and. expense incinTed. .

b,. EI7'1H:h'1R .1PAR 7.`"Y"'.S ERE I,UB]':LK7["Y, AND THE OTHE .R. PARTY'S EXCLUSIVE REMEDIES,1F{C>R,A1W [?pL 1VLA .(sE'> CAUSED BY 1krTY' :SF;RNT][CE; DEFECT OR i;,AIL,tJR :L., OR FOR QT1~F; l.ZC'I,iNB/ISA12L,1i CNG) []V C()M.q;CT1 :()N WITH ANY SEIRM[ (;E, OR l ']ERJi01ZN1A14C; 1 3 ()P;NfON4']EF:I7{C ll?.rV0fC_E OF OESILIC[A'T 'IC)]N'~E3 UNfI)F :It 'PEI] rN Ell-'-:FOR 13CfD11,Y INJURY (JF : I)E.KI1i p3jpdVY PERSON OFD REAL OF' TArd(J3iBLE; PF:OF'L•" R.T'Y"

A IP ~~Z'~ ''~, Off: ~ 't}R. .A ,~~1~' D .A ,r vJf~~Cr1JS .A, ~~[ ; ~[3~(i ~~l~C3lN~ THEWILLFUL MISCONDUCT OF PARTY OR FROM A B R1 .A.{,H OF THE T'ROVISIONS OF SECTION1 0.1j.,TUBE OT']HE 'IR.WOR.7"Y' "S RIGHT TO l' IR.UVErl DIRECT IDIAW.LGEa;;(i.i) FOR Ir~l ~7~F:]ti flf~f I~"Y , ~ C;Hffl_ RFr01:lDIE'S S`IC.A,T:ED IN SECT EONS ;3 .d1. AMD, 9 ;(iii) :FUR .AI,L G'rH]EFt D.Alvi[1W:ES OTHER THAN THOSE SET FORTH ABOVE K,~ 1VU 'F':EXCLCUF;D 1[:R1I}:E,FC EACH. ]PpJt1"e ' :i LIABILITY SHALL BE :L,Tr4I'Tk;D ToPROVEN ]D1ZF;}.:C:"f w~tiu.t3Ea NOT `['O EXCEED W TE01 A03FUECs ,A .TI77 ]D1TRlrlti .A.t4y TWELVE(12) MONTH P1?FJUD AN AMOUNT EQUA1L TO THE TOTAL NET PA YVrEN'l[',3 PAYABLE I3 y

C',1 :J SITIDIV1[E-R F`UR:'I'HF; KFF'EDE"]"E-E) SEIRV[I"E DIUWV G' (I) 1V[ONTH F'12E~,( J E,I} UqCJ']C'.H[ l ;MC)]NI[']H[ l7Nf VIF£[C11 'lC]U, I)/d~LA.(i:E 0E"C jJT :]ZF;17. THIS DOES NOT I,]10[IT C;iJ S;'1CC)UJ:lR'S

P'ASi1V.paNFC OF ANY AMD~ .A ,I,]L ]PR.{)P'1`sRL`( DUE (11iA,IZCYIESUNlDE;VC:E[ ] : 'i AGREE:hiE;NT.

c. E:X: t;:E,F''r FCAt SECTIONS 3 .d . and 9.a., IN P40 EVENT S11A.LIL EITHER PARTY FIB LLAB]LE; FORANY INDIRECT, INCIDENTAL, CONSEQUENTIAL, Pfd:["CI'V E,,RELIANCE OR SPECIALI).A,KWJ]ES, l if4C:]1LJ]I7111d13'r VVIIHOUT L.IrAI'T 'A'T' IC)N, 17K[vLA.ti:E,S FOR LOST P'ROFF1C:C;S ,

11VD ()~~ I]Nf(~:R~:A.S ) 1_E1 CQ~~ ~C OFUl?'E1RA:T'ION"Si 'V4T.H[L'I'HEkt OR NOT EITHER PARTY HA.S BEEN ADVISED OF THE

d., Kr&'f ALSO SHA]LL, NOT BE 1L ,LALl3L ,E jkP;l :rS ll'SGr OUT OF CIR1tELA,T,[lqCx TO:1C~1'I '1 ?R{)P'~.1R~~B ~II.l:7~"Y,l.'ROB]~'~,A~1:~ ~ CONTENT iCiR NE "CVVORK S NOT1? ;R .{)`F][I)EI) BY AT&T; ,S~,It~~][(:E; [3V~1 'LR '.IZCI]''T' IC)1Nf~> OR :L ,OSTOlZ .4L'CE', FZE D M1"ISSAGF l3S ~~~~~,r~;~~,r1~ 511~iI~SS~ TC)]Nf'> (~;J(CI P `'1, TO T`HE IE~CTi;l~T ( ,']RI;DIT` .A,'Pf.A ,1Jt,' I JS , .RE,5 P'Ei ~'IF`~E ;D 1.14 THE

3]EP :'VXC : 1; (iU][l]Fi)~ ; OIL IJ[~I ~4LJ'T~~+O~~t[;~~;D ,A.( ~~C:E ,SS 'TO C)R .'THE ,F~"~', AL'J'ERIa'101q, LOSSoR DE:.i 'TP. 1 :J~~:'TI~C1N ~C~F i~~C»~ F~ ;, ~C : r,i IE F 1,.3" +CIR '[' F[liR~1 F'AR'C :[1wS' A1PF'Ll: t:.A ,'][' :[OT1,5, CONTENT,DATA, F'R~C)CiF~Al l[S „ '[lq FOR1~i,AI['][UN„ 'NE'TVi~'URI~ OR .i"Y'~i'fEMS.

4 e„ '7' rie lirnitati ons of Ili abi'lity set iEod!h in this Section 6 shall ~i~~ jply: (i) regardless of the ;Foi-rn of action,,whether in contract, tort„ strict liability, equity or o t9ieinv i .se;, and (ii) -whether or not cla ll aige;s; wereiFoi'e:sc, e,atiile . Iim E itation;s of liability shall smi+ivc: fa i,lum of'an.y exclusive femedics, provided In thisAgreement .


EXHxi3 ;[T "B"']Page 4 of 6

1GXI,:F;I''TA' S EN:l' 3RIsSSI.Y PROVIDED IN ']C1H: IS,A,{JR'.l3lEMEil1T", AT&T MIL1KE;3 NO, EK: F'1.ZF ; 'i ,3 OR1NT]LIE',D l JLrA ftR',md'n' AND l]I SC,IJJrrl:'S KNT 'AFAMZANTIES OF,' OR1?:fI'mES:,.i F~:IFC A 1.'. A ,RTICI:JI,jkF : P'IJR.POISL. pma DOES NOT NV A]RKA.r1'T"T'Fi,A.']["TH:E ~S E" R111(_7 E'SIMLL, BCE iJN',[N "1'EMU11P'TED +3iR E ']RF: I~rF~•-FiRE]E, OR THAT ' i'13 E, SERV][C E;S WILL rrlFE'T YOURm,Q Ui1ZEIVfLhd'rs OR THAT THE SERVICES W ILL PREVENT N.A,UTHC3lUZED,ACCE;SS .1~~~)1: J' IP'mi.,"M[ ' PR_QVIIDk D BY KTB'iT ]N CO]Nf]ZJNfCT' IC>iJ W1E°CF[ A SERVICE IS 1?1R.0Vl :DED ONAN "AS IS" BASIS. A'T&T' :C1UE,S, NOT JUU'n[ORlZ]E ANYONE ' ['O MfiLi{E A W'AR1Uk1qT'Y +C1I~,,4T1Y j:dqZ) ON IT'S BEHALF AND YOU S]H:OM-:Cl NOT RELY ]N )~NTC}NE MAKDR31 SUCH

][i an iritenrup'ti.ori ior failure of Services is c;au:,eci solely by AT&T acrid not b,( you or a third party or oldierGaUs+eS bE;~(~aind. , .'lE',~~'I''s, ~rf ;~~ ,oi~~blLe; ~cionb-ol, you nria:y be entitled to a Credit Allowance s specified. iin ffieAT&T Service Gaide .

a. KT'&3' ageE,s t ai defeiid or settle my c lainn aga imt you and to pay all. : Ciarnag;e.s that a cotat may, awardagainsit yoti bi mq suit i m[islhod wider this Agreement infringes, any United Statespat+,ftmt, Ilad l e ;mark, c ;cipin-ight or trade secret, except where the claim or ,}iiit arises out of or results ftom~ :your o r IJse ;r's Content n the S erv;imL; m.odifi c ;2itio i ns to the Service made yy orconrlbunati .e oris of dLe ; Serv i c%- vfith services or products provided bi( you or offie:rs; KT&T"s a.dlterem;e; toyour ,min .e.ni uks lTuctiom; o r spe;c ;ifiimtiotis ; ; nor use of the .ielndce i~ i vi,o lat.io :n of this A.jn•e ;e :rnen .t. You

s~tiio ~nsagee to -de~feac~~ or settle at Y, our own . expense all claims or soils against q.7"i4c;'~` covered by tYie, exc.e;~~tiio ~nha the. l Pc~~:~e,dv~n; ~ ~~e;nteni~:e: and to :i~nna~e, diai:e ~ l .y cease any ~~~ ~tivilyr which gives rise to the alleged .infi.-ingF;rn.e ,nt. '11c. indemnifying, ipart3, will also pay all Da mages and costs that b3r final ijudgment may be.assessed agmikst the uideirruii ;fiENi part,y clue to infiingE,mte :nit 1),Y the ildemnifY111injy part,

b. ILL the ofa claiirn of un :&ingenielrit for whicli A'MT is flie under Section 1 .,a .,

A'T&T may at its option either procure the right to continue u.> in .g;, or replace or rnodiifi~r;, ithc a.1le,gE.di:nfi rini~;in.g; Service so that t~1~~ ~~e;t~+~i~ c~e bE ;cx»rien, ,non, i ;nfi~ng;i ;ng arid ~~ub:~tantiia~ll~y cximpF l i<uii -with. the:requ1ir+~~mf,nl :s~ in this ~~~,rE, E ,mte.r ~ t. Upon in~a~~~ il iit y~il iity to r~~3son~~b'l~~ p ~ e. rfi~nxi either ofF t~ia ~ for~e ,go~i~ ng ~~~pti e~n~,,A'T'&T nn,ay Le.1Ci111I1ii1 :2; this AA.g ;reemeryt, wildYu»ut liability other xian as stated in Section 9 .a .

c:. 'Arifh rfqwc ; t: to ffie i ndle;rnn.i ficatii cit i obligations 111 d1ii s SectiaTi 9 : ( i ) the i ndenn :nif :ied pair t:y"Ar ilil notifythe iindelrrun i. fy ri,ng party in writing promptly upon learning of afi3t cl;lii rn or suit for which in,demm i i i cati ci rimay, be sought:; (iii) the ii rkcfemxiiFyEng party shall have ontrol'[ of the defense or se, ttlenae nt„ provided thatth ,e , findelluu ified party :3h,311i have the right to participate in suc,h defense or settlement with counsel of ii tsoIRM selection id at its aqpeme ;; ,and (iii) the; indeimnifif,d party shall reasonably cooperale with thecielfe;ns- E:, at ithe indemnifying Par~es expense.


of 6

St.- Ads ]Bvycind 412`0u1nro1l.11F:1'1MEM 13E :LIAMI.E1 FOR 10f it DEIILM',1?A,II,IAUE. ]N lPMF'ORWAI`dCE ,LOSS OR i).A1vJACx]E DIM TO : :FI:RE , ]EXPLOSION, POWER

1BLL•"]NilE.r1'nsoi T'MICE:,l?:MBAR, ~~~{), LABOR IJ~IS~F'IJZ~:~S, ~~~~~'~i OF (CIVIL 4 :R .14'~ :[]~C"T~~IE~.Y A'UT:H[UPJ:7;"Y', `7~T.4F~„ ACTS ()F'G{}'CI, ,A("T`S CSR . ~G~V[la;~:Il7~I'~IS Of. C~~T~IZI~EFC~~ UR~~UP'F'Ll[LR~i, . .AC'FS OF R:EG'ClL,A1fa0RYU:R(10'4TT31MF;NTA.L ACrESINCI :E.S, OF,. OTHER CAUSES) BEYOND THEIR RklEASONABLECONTROL, EXCEPT T'HAT YOUR U :BL][UA'I'ICIN TCI P'AY' F'UR ,CHAkG1ES f1VCIUIRRF,!D FORSERVICES :RECF:CVED BY'Y{}U SHALL NOT BIE EXCUSED .

1). No Third ]Party Wg;tit :s. This .A.greeme:nt does not provide airy third party,inc ;luicling; 'Users, with anyrernedly, clai:m,, :liabili.ty, reiiribtusemetnt, cause of'ac1 :ion or other rightor Faivilege : .

4;. ASsi;gnrnent:. This Agree'llietit irIai3F not be assilnied by you without AT&"I" .s juior written consent .iA.7'i&']C may assign all or jrairtt of ouir rights and duties under ihiis Agreement to a present or f6bire. affiliateoar successor . /cTbiT' may ~subc,c»illact Nvork to be pe ;ffonaif,d under ifis Agreemeint, brut will retainY:e;s,fio11 si .bil ity 1fi v all . such livor'k : .

id . rlraHic:C,s1 . Notices from yott to A'I'&T' ,slh,a'll be made by following die, customer :>i;y-Nrice iUstnuoticrns, oneyour NIL You are ~•e :s~~ro~~:~i.~ile I'm ~i{~'tif'yi~i~, AT&T o~f'<~c~~~ e,l~[a~ril ;f,;, iii your a'lt~li~arizR~l bulling address .and.other contact 'vr~far~riati~~n. y

e„ Se.veralAiq. :[f'.any ]part of this Agreeyn[e:rit is iF6mid invalid, Ilkf: rest of the Agreemeirrt remains

1f. G),verning ][,mv . Stat-. law iss-ties conc ;e ;rnfla;g 1t& cQnsta*ILK;ti0>a, i3iiEe;rpretat.ion mid pEnibrmmioe of this.A,vow;rn.ent -stia1 .1 be grovemed by the scibstanfi.ve ; laws of the S1 ate of New York, excluding; fits choice oflaw Miles.

g. 7'lW[i Y4-,a!r Limit on Ae:fions .. .AirY legal action arising, in connection WWa Ir .EU.,t beginwithin tvro (2) yelaTs after IN .- cause of action afises .

h . . 1'aub~li<~i.fy and :Ma.ri~:~. NO public st~i l:e;nr~~e :nt ~ or ~~v1~~ ,uncenl~~~nts r~~lla~ti~ij; to this 2kg;reen~~e:r~t shall t~e:issued toyyou or AT&;T without the pirior vniti .e;r.t consent of 1ffiE, other., "Y"ou and not todisp llky or use, -hi a .dve,rti :>in ig -or otherwise, any trade names, 1[ogo,s„ itia,dle.rnarks„,sq,-rvic:e: inuirks, or otherfti+di<;iat of c>tY;~in (Collectively "Arl:ar:ks") bdong;i:ng;llo the other without obtaining ffic other"s prior mn7tt:e:rtconiseTit, provided 1fliat ;such consent may f)e revoked at any tinrre .

L 'Waiver of Itii€ ;lits. We may, from time to time waive the Er ifarcennent of'amy of laie lprorrision,s of thisA;gmeimE,I11:. I:f4e: do, this will not aMct cur albility to enforce i:1hat provision in -our dealings ~wridi othercustmers or in our future dealings with you, nor will it be corns idei•eckan atneridrrierit oft his Agreement .

j. Sulrvuualof Obligations. 'I1ie ;respe;c:tive ob!figations of vou and A'T'&T, which by their nature wouldcxinti:nue beyond the tenminaitiono fthis Ag;reenniant, sud'i as I th Ee obligrations re:€;arCling ; linnilation ;3 ofliability, shall survive IEe : C'11llllla l: lon.

IL Entire Agreement. This Ay,rf.f,m~e .r~t, which 'includes the AT&T Service Guide, ca~ri~~titutes the entire

aigre .c;rnent between 1,rou and ATM' with I re.sy iE ;c;t to the Services provided hereunder. In the event o i- any ,

iincorisisilencies I~{etiN~e ;e;ri this .A,gre,e :rnent and the ATM' Service Guide, thus ~,€;E•e .e:rnent will gnvenn . ThisAgroement su p, e:rsedes all prior agreements, jpr olp,osal s , reF iresientations, statements- or iainder,stai rid iirig: ;,


]EXHIBIT "Ft"Page 6 of ~6

Whetl ic-ir vvirihte .n cr cxral, cxmm-lTUng; laic Se ;rvims Col. Il iE, riF ;lius and i3lbl i .gaitims relaling to those lNis,A.gm,mertt shall neat be caxtiadli ctc;cl, exp !<xi.nvl or .q>p lcmtrtted . l b;Y my written cv, cmil.sLatenients,

fitnlIK> :mrls, m-,pre-scinuttions, adve, rti .sememu ; or service c[E,. ;c ,tY;pti .ons na expressly set fart ih ins ith iisAgm-,imt;n 1E .

THANK YOU FOR USING AT4vC .


'SAO Action

V.

C.ASE, NUMBER:

'TO ', ; Name and addrvu-ss o 1 'C )efe rn da .nt)

an answer to t1w complaint which is served on you with this sumrnons, ,within 20 --------, days after Serviceoi'thi ., summons um you, exc1usive of tlif, day of service . IF you fail to do so, jlud;g:rricrkt by default w ill be taken against youfar the relief demancled iM the complaint, Any answer that you serv ., or . the parties 1o1:his actionn must be filed with theClerk oflhis Court within a rf,ason.ablf, period of'time after servicul .

!MA F ' 13 216F------------------------------------------- -------------------------------------------------

LC•RI~ IMl"E.

'6. ---------------------J (Sy ) DE UTY CU: N 'JL

SrI'A.r['E:s D ] ~S'T ]RJCT {CIOLJRTNarl:hern District of CiE~o r g ia

AT&T CORP., a New York corporation

IS5'L 1 PVJ[rV[ OrJS , [N .A . CIVIL ACTUCIN

PLANNED IPAFIE=PJ 'TWC?OQ C)F GEORGIA, I NIC: .,a G i s or4 a non-profit oarporatior

PLANNED PARENTHOOD OF GIE:'ORGIA, INC .PcIti er1: Galci S tUrker, Relgistgred Agent75 Piedmont F kve~nli e, Suite f30(?Atlanta, Georgia .30 .3t) 13

YOU ARE N[ 1;1REI3'Y SIUMN [iDNE'D and required to serve an . ]?1LA .INfTIF'F'S ATTORNEY t»arne andaddress)

Scott jN-JohnsonWelssmari, N omac l<, C urry VWi lco, P.C .3500 l_onc }); Road - 4th FloorOne Alli2 tr ice C ien l:e rF&a . nta , Georgia ,3i) ;3.?G(404) 9 :26-4500


"~:~ AO 44+] ( Ite ;v . 8 10 1 ) 5uir nri on s in a Civil Ac t ion

(1) As to who may serve a sunnrtons sec R u l e 4 o1" the Fedoral Rules of Civi I Procedlu re .


CAVIL COVER SHIEE.ir'f re e J5 4r1 civil cover s heet and the information contained h e r e i n n e l t h er rep l a oe nor supplement h e fili n g and s rr vi . e ~ of p l ea d i ng s or other papers as ri .q u re d

except a s {>rov i [liad by local rule s o '° court This f orm is r equ ir e d for the u s e at the Clerk o f C ou rt fo r t he purpose o f initi ati rsg the civil docket record . (SEE

N 5 T I3lJ Cl ' I (3 W) ,A'."7 A C H E la 1

~ +J~} COUNTY OF RE : 51D Elu (' E :1]i= FIRST us'i-EM,----------PLAINTIFF NEW J Y C}R K

( E ,K C EF'T IN U. S. PI .A N 'f LF F CASH

NOTE : IW LAND G)lspi:MN ATI0 W CAGES, USE THE LOCATION OF TliE

TRACT O F L AN D INVOLVED

Vdf, i ssma.n, Nowacl:, C'uny & IM1c;o, P .C .One /d [i ance Center - 4th Flom-; 350(} Lenox RoadA,t1L anta , +GE ;utgia 30326; (404), 926-4500srnt ~rj o Y~r.~s~~~n(~wmc~v~ a.v,r .r onn

pIX CiEIF PIF OIEF'

r=1 I 1 I;II'I Z EN OF 'f H IS S1A1'E b [-'t4 F UOIEP0126USWOEE$ NINH P 9TATF,~

r_17 r~I 2 C I ' f 12', EI~(fF A~lOTkER :ITATI= ~_, li ID(FflU'o E59OAI N [}PHERSTAIEt

.Af, EL J L L.. 1

r=~ 3 r-~ 3 I I f C FA C_1 i IFOREG V COUNTRY -ORE.IGN NASIOML .J L

2 Li,5) GOVERNMENTMT r=~ 4 D`;NRC~A'E CI TI::EIVSHI P OFL .~

PARTIES IN ~,TF.M III}

V . Ivl" ~Id a : OF ACTION {C S`fI~T1J 'EE: i EINLE~86 I~JER3f1fY` AI

iE FILIN i o , gt~ID 44 'R IITIE /1 EiR1EF :67 ' A'r E,MElIT OF CAUSEG - 1010 NOT C~ If ' EuRISIN/ :TIDN/1L

I)e>fenclant refuses to pay Plaintiff fi r teleeorainunicatim senrices provided at L)efendanl .'s maiaest . 42 1 ;F.S .C. 2001, ct sera .

(1 1 = COMPLEX, I,HE:GK. REASON BELIYNf

El 1 . U nusually large number cif par 4 ias ,El

6 . Problems locating yr preserving ev i da ri ce~~E]_1 2. Unusuzilly large num b er of claims or clefenses ID F Fenii in4~ par~cl l el inveatigaiions or actions h~~ governmentL ! L. .1

r_~ 3. Factual issues are exre p ilionally com~~iax r_, 8 . d dLiltiple u s e of e x perts .L L.J

CD 4 . Greater Than normal volume of o vic l enre . L_, 9 . Need for d i scovery outside Un i ted States bounda r ies

C_1 5 . Extended discovery period is needed . 1 1) , Exislei~t , e of highly technical i 5s ij e~ s and prom .

copuriNLIED ON REVERSE

FOR OFFICE USE. ONLY

/ah1CUI V'I ' :6 .- - - -------• NPF 'L' MJ G, {FP ......,,., .--- iu1F Z . JUIX iE (II-P}_. ., . ... .....---- -

JJIx Jl.la .aEs.----_---... .^ . EVAI~JR€= S F S LMr M CAUSE OI ^f aCTNJrI„5

I .ReTerral) __ -------_--_

~ll'IF ~ F ~ILi)~L (a) F' ILALIh'll' IF ~ F ~ILi)

AT&T C_o •rpl . , aL ]J l-,)V Yc I r1 c Coqwirati on

11) E: F 1E N DAM T(S)

Planned 1 P~ trenthc)nd W'Gror, gia , ][nc , a Gecwgi a, Ei cI n-profi tcoipo iration

C+DUIV7Y OF RESIDENCE OF FIRST LISTED

(IN t1, 5, PI.TI' . 0 ASf5ONLY)

---------------------------

( vr I" iCMRNEYS J FiF :n I MAiME, ADDRESS, TELIEIaWO I VIE ~ A i f'TC112111 E. Yti~ (11F KNOWN)NUMBER, AND E: -MAIL. ~~[)Dlil:.i~i}

----------------------------II IBA;alS OF J IUFtI.iDlC ' T 'IOM

(F 'L4C: E A i N "X" !N 014E BOX OINILY)

1 LL S .G0'JER MIAEDT ' 3 FEDF: R4LQU ES1' I Ci N1E] PLAI NTIFF ~! {U .& .GOVF:RNhI E1VT N i 3 I g PARTY I

1111, CITIZENSHIP OF P'FtIIMiCIIPALI_ F1j4F ;1rIE : :S[PLA CE AIJ "X" IN O NE BOX F OR PLAINTIFF AIV [0 [INE iBOX FOR CIEFE EN DANT)

(FOR DII CASES ONLY)

I'V . ORIGIN ~PLacc,A lV X IN ~oiNr_ BOX oN ILIOTR ANSFERRED FRDM APPEAL TO DISTRICT

C~J' FRpCEE~ I MG [-1 2 SE'

R'fE CJUR!, ~ I i__I P P PEINLT' EFROM UI

2TC-1 ` F lEOPEPIEI I OOR L-I 5 (5 ECIFY`D IS' fRlCfy E] 6 l~TIGAT1i7ryRP3T C-I 7 IUOE EJUD(MEN TIS"R0.T E


35~~' SId1rQ3~~SIWSI0 5t~N1--- .3 5trJ31M 153HJ_ .~ .'1 " hl~JldVL'i9f1; (~ ~a s~ ~ X~'~~ 1Uh1 51 I--I SILj

'iYJ - IS d:I MI ( ]=V1'1CJVJ I A-ISllC1 V3*I 3R f. 3M1M1 =3S'd. ) SIFLL N S . ~fSSS I a+h' S9112fdd ',3LL j 0 -f'i~d 2iCi ?IW 03 knFLL1= 1FIDlF{M

U.w iV•id i uu0.0 iii cHUSA in03N ' nA

asna~MVVt~~ai C.{[.IAlr7is ?vn1;x0D6d l 3rnylrKbs61,

JDuxLLWnre -+1 .oas I C=15~~~~~~a~cr~aiYr~oJ~saa 4 C_I

lOdArnor_w Ls4 C~I0131vui '11t~1;nn MEMiax N D4 C=1

17t/ LI3T11W 07111JI11v M1"I Wt [D

a.x,rayr1swoGti C .!

JvDD-s3l.1.1-irea:ain uW sMK&Onnr srM' [. }

Is .u+GFW3

S3LLf'N 9`dSilC] LMk SW d:IR13M/ SDi1- 1

s.u-ou InD cm, C. ]

sn~x~v~a~uuN~ca~~r~Nns r~~ri em L.]NJC 3 W 3. ql!5 49R[]..[P~0v) Nnnia LneC :]l(iA%ro)0 nnia 09eED

iizs),x 4 rnvH :bN aN[ :3(1k9RW b 7H 1136[

N : O'iI, Ia,a3no3? uFsHiriowZ~.--A TERNs• iv3o9

~N.~ ~ V,OIdW: 3 i :vV [.] : :11~ :3n133 '~fdN313~1eNUwA ivAD JozrJ3waVkEvYDA0t&ar~M_kLN~L=1

IsIAUv3N -XxA)sIAM Jv'=c3ru:a

L9 L 031"1 9Z 'MM1Iti Ht1 IMJNM1 E z1, 17'o VY7(]f Yf - jC)1NwC:1:?liOAN:3

B 3 4 DSf19L " N3cId v i Z1,~~~ '81PJ~Vtillt~d' ~V V~dCIl,i13/fJ :.k 3LI 0~L-tiaU-137 77A 051 3F MN F 91,1213A(3TIO f i illMttlP i 7.o.-0TV 9J.NO;i

00 NO .are a NO N1 X nie-a :ivq a i I. 111 S ;jC1=1» f 11 JL'dN ' l /'1

(ISIM'd0:J:4-W:):30 =fbU.S~T.L1:dL1?R!'dw3( ]f lY,] Plf)0= i1 1Lj A-151 1 03M11lfWI t5 J Nl3f3 (8)9SY7iJJ .=OKi Cf3 LVT3L i 2i O"DIM Pd 'NNXY 'Si [~

' ~:1JW'JWl35C9D,9Q3lbj SAW) =1AWL=Gi3i1 9 C~'3;]~]flf h;)1df1LJiIJC'9

3 V i V53{LA13 /L I 0 1'J:3CI K3'3 EI 311W HOWNQL32J A- LL~iL4r ff3~ l̀ :3 5!l; ~ i WRiQJb ' 3Sil'J A DJtlf Rfl I M?63W ' dS 3FLL= 1011']CI E XJ ISRfd !ilN:Hdtf '1, C3

'L fT,'a `,]FIICIN3ciCM li s38W f 1fJ2Ekl 7t G! Nd I VI¢3CYl'l .^I N INNdI^ 13UIL+LL!l O .W`JI NL AcY03 'A1V =LLVc 1 3WdC; 5A- IL : ICi lN:w 13Jf*2 ljN121,7K1 ][ :Vf1V11 'f: C~

'llf l 9 .̀ ]NION: 3 cICf3ir= 19 1lWYsIZ B- 2iV'3MOlI IT_IOT K71'JITN :XU:V51, fd l3 1_ LIOL lf_IA3 W J 'd5 '3FLLd0 _Lf'i 057 35TdV LiO _LOR/_ d .b3 f1: 51 ?NY1ts : 'i: CD

'.Ul15 C NIa1J= 1dQ3L13 aYW"IIV2l3fki73AJ 'diVICI30f3-0NI,LL2C: 3r:lC)dci 'I. ~~

(A ;GS _Il,tlt21dflld dd'd N Y3 HO) : 53 ,V ICIA, Ni ; 3:M mil !)lJI 1O IV 3 3c l 33FU. .ll 03 .L1 f11 321 QI3W3 41 ] 3SY Si 3 !WO " II j'1 1 D

-------------------- ---- ------T------------------': r•ari .~:aw .~loa .3,.~cinrANlV :I I (SO= 1 IS'a';) {] ;37IIAc121,1t73 1:VlEl2i 'lIIA

( ,L N IH '1dNiC!'I IJI C I 3 aNb'IN ',3 (J ~I a,-IRO Si 3A YO3H ':I~l ON E T] Si3 ),[_] OIV ~ ~V4 :iCl .l 2ffY f

-- - ---~ i--- ------~ ---$ 4NtlW3 13 'E Z ' ' d 'A! J ' ZI ' :j 'tl i3 ( P4fV NOI . L:fb'IMb'iJ c!I :d :)=1h I J~~hf~'£135~ ~~i',$

E•siz

J,l1=1~ ~C1~l~~ II] 31iDH ?ISb '3 11d „

t llaN f ;e }insl a adnt'e Pd IB u iiSpap uri 51a1Ru a Ualld :+ a3o IV 1

Lljp3C7lnll~13i 7iiC~At1'J VNLV211 ~I M 73)nioudawe~~ I.7

71~ 'dtll Ad? IAO:)SIQSH1NijY~. .6,. =S3 ilfSJL+dl! Pt13HJL0

MM":D3! S=ILLIOOINYVCYJ 1 FSa11ki1Y.)35 xB I_ :3

1!Yliil .l. W b DlbC-1

A !!? IAD:)SIQ SHJ.NOIN .8. 5'33 ,fI.LW'1f~i93H.LC~

s 1Xw_3v ucuuv.,s a3tLLo opal =7~aauueas

=ud~s ~c~ ~~.rnMOiuu~ ~n~a~ ail =~l3au_snr

UL >53; xhi " tt'flp~ 3 2f3OFJf

ivcw .vv i ivtiaib3 3- i = o -%s* ra ar. 1 [7joa V)iJ_vM.Kr_4vi =K) ivcxi EERLI GE-9 IC~L

yro NaiNoD-rnHnSrr EI rrEI roURICIs,t1 _tL LewW1N: 3V iNCY-AV3 Of-M C]I

J :) d ivcw .dzrnfra.Ls cmpru )03 vie I C=1s L~ro_T1ra U_Irr.7a 1_ roWeC-1

gU6Easn z:i ~I rvarrA-o a avvcwsyb g :a C =1

a;nr,a31 ; awe :)FF1-is oi.a C~I,v aurr 31wY-Tr R%') (XIV [.I.UMW C#- 3NIf15PJCO PEtb

~ ' ~N~SLt21 M~lzlD l.cif'ii'y0~0rro aaaNamUrri ogeau-x)%,H o,1r C-1

IVC xI .+l.Lrla d_bMr3.LErs 3JvB Mua . )a3vvuQ :)aw[7_1

:MANIrra aMf IEDIM+a aw G~Iirr~vuNau~c~~~y ;~d~s aroC=k

TRW

A ,aPAYti[IfrH1MOW.4« S3JLf1J.1f1S' !l51Hi(1

W92 Cs1 i 50 AJ_avd c raiwl-sai ~ ~aC](J.P 'M a1~a-31 3CI

il0 A lLlNfdld ': . 'fl) snvl10.!8[~

i.a3nonsic? ,i+iniow-.s- sii?o -) ida:aci3 i

uGLord 012C=1WWI

xo~no~~suu swiN~~ri~e. = s~.W~d~u.a~ioa~i

)4bVI1rzM3VHL 0119EDs _a*Z&wioo aeqC:: I

'.N:i11tl.Li~3nu:~s~ia sai N~ ir~.b.M.H~i~ u.a3~ ioa~i

~:ro Kuarax-)N item •iwa uu [.ITIOLL̀ i E'u f3 Li OEI'd1 il3H1~c diL [_ I

L'Jd 2ia3'dl xdM9M1Ri 01rL [_J.Iz M 3ij('IStiY0SI i]

'S `JI VLI.ZIDdRi ' 1W7MiCv6dl Ol l [Dsnx w vr_~ ,lrrDuua jcev1 a2 1:1

~LavSc RaVrrr Ls aa 1v'l •yrdj a LL r_:171~~ ~LIl A1~AIJLiS110 SH1N/!"DI Y.y. = l168Y1

iEkiLC i a39E_ 1HOVfPlAL=Lly5 : Tdll Olldclf4x~ ~ q ~9 m ~

'S~J3lI =NllLlfc ' 0 39 _ 1>01,1iil. Vbra orsC.]Wvi 8arxxi on C=]

MI C91 1 .z kb3ciow4D '. 32lf1Zl'3s, C I3L'V-E Ri oN i C I 5m

wwo 's ow- i assIDmanr inoien , ors[.3

r5t9ia .aaaoNointRH U io w~ti:-A PivNad9 drU1 i3iaioi

(~si rcr rAl Fqj1(S)h101. 3 J{ 1vCY'1 Nd31 74c 1 SSS [_, ]rp;uio a 4q pop-6 ,3jM Dr q",vr_j oss x)vai

(Gs iaki F' alJ) (S)NO LSAO IVOCi NOSfjc l 955 1-1ef H ad p M1- 1S a1H 'JI1 y '1 VU.1055; El

ItU H LC39J Sf II MfCMd I^ J CKC_ . 1A .L"Mnf3d H1X97 :W I dyCX] S 1r19o'FI 5M[.]

swqw srrevri c v;[.]4)NM~G s ;31v )Vn o.L .NO-UM ors C.]

WARIlAlicIAO:)SIOSHINOIN..O, SIVCi13, 113dZ13NUSRld

Lxioo~ti a~dv rda r~z~~ioa~~ ~~: IED3: M~lt/O

,u E_3da3. ~ _1 vr4osRE d &4_do cam: IC 79 v ICrra 1 wi I+LnRL i L s I [7

I7fT1L Li tf3H 11 ) co.-5130' ~dl A'!l3 1M1~ 6 :)SkO

l3H11JCiW.1i. -1Zd?IdUid'1'V~IQS7y31d = S1NOl

A L llf ~'dfl l: XK}J~idl

A»rrr~ rarxxr~~F ~a~s~~sv ase C ~t .~iu~vrt

J,~f1UC~2id ° AZlIVNI? ~t.l[752f-3d '.~E ~~:3 `iLl~̀ lrkfTdW

Td: HC13N - A2tof" Z dhNJ5if:3d ME 1:3A2i(N7JI IMJCI S FJ3d 2i3FiLD U9E C]

/ .1 1-INEI%rfl.uxOc09d =rTrFE n a101cM 9Ss C7

-0n -CA».0A o sc CDkInie01 JDncxwd aruarVA RC El

3rnarvw oce C :11

ti.niavri :;k=1 to1:VG WtSMu oEI~ Chia :Eo,h`K : ir -13Vm'i7rra ,-svcez C]I

kLruevI1 a .ar Kxraa arrncrd nrs Ls CSI3rrdk rd nram LEI

!~~~rda, a~: ~n, ~~~icid :Hroww

JU .N3c1 0 2ic i -M3LIt f~1~3071b0EiZ ~~'nsrusn~~ .~anaxkila~cu sra C ~I

aiIN-1 o_L saaK».rn Z C=1.'1N36'Sla3f3 '8 : 3:V.31L + [= R1 0EZ C_I

3lif ~0'x~3 i ~O3~2 [_Iivcw .VwG(31 vcxD aMn o J,z

N :) V21.LA-1 d3A0-C iSl'~0 SHIHOMKY.1= AJ .LIFIOtl~PIV 31!


01 1I Gill t'QCase 1:07-cv-00588-ODE Document 1 Filed...

Documents

Transcript of 01 1I Gill t'QCase 1:07-cv-00588-ODE Document 1 Filed...