^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X }...

13
Shareable Dockless Mobility Devices in Athens B Y: S HERRIE H INES , ATHENS -C LARKE C OUNTY A SSISTANT ATTORNEY O CTOBER 15, 2019

Transcript of ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X }...

Page 1: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

Shareable Dockless Mobility Devices in AthensBY: SHERRIE HINES, ATHENS-CLARKE COUNTY ASSISTANT ATTORNEY

O C TO B ER 1 5 , 2 0 1 9

Page 2: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

Overview:1. History of ACC’s involvement with Shareable Devices2. Pilot Program Concerns3. Future of Shareable Devices in ACC

Page 3: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

History of ACC InvolvementMarch 6, 2018 – LRC began exploration of non-traditional motorized devices in response to parking violations, unlawful golf cart use, etc.

August 16, 2018 – Bird scooters arrived with no warning and were deployed on sidewalks primarily in and around downtown Athens and UGA’s campus.

Fall 2018 – ACC and UGA documented issues with the e-scooters including illegal sidewalk parking/riding, reckless driving, injuries, ADA access problems, etc.

Page 4: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

Bird Scooters on UGA Campus:

Images taken from UGA’s compilation video of bus footage available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=3&v=x-P3tgje2ko

UGA Bus Footage on Baldwin Street:

Page 5: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

Bird Scooters on UGA Campus:

Images taken from UGA’s compilation video of bus footage available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=3&v=x-P3tgje2ko

UGA Bus Footage on Sanford Drive near Snelling Dining Hall:

Page 6: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

Bird Scooters on UGA Campus:

Images taken from UGA’s compilation video of bus footage available at: https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=3&v=x-P3tgje2ko

Page 7: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

Observations from Fall 2018 Consistent violations included reckless driving in and around vehicles, sidewalk riding/parking, blocking ADA access, abandoning scooters on private property, driving the wrong way, etc.

Virtually no helmet use

Devices targeted at and used by young college students

Bird Scooters were parked everywhere near downtown and campus

Multiple injuries reported

Page 8: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

History of ACC Involvement (Cont’d)December 4, 2018 – ACC passed a moratorium on all dockless shareable mobility devices out of a concern for public safety and to give staff a chance to research and develop a pilot program.

Throughout 2019 members of the LRC met almost every month to diligently work towards the development of a pilot program.

October 1, 2019 – ACC extended the moratorium to June 4, 2020, to allow for additional time to develop the pilot program’s RFP. ACC also removed e-bikes from the moratorium.

Bird Scooters blocking ADA ramp for ACC Transit Busses

Page 9: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

Pilot Program Concerns Safety: operational safety and device design/maintenance

Geography and Infrastructure challenges / Greenways

ADA accessibility

Parking / Geofencing limitations

Enforcement and compliance with all state and local laws, including lawful use of ACC’s ROW.

Barriers to equitable use (e.g., expense, access, deployment)

Page 10: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

Pilot Program Concerns (cont’d) General Operations: dawn to dusk, helmet use, signaling

Privacy / Data Sharing / Geospatial data

Environmental Impact & Sustainability

Management of the pilot program

Page 11: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

Recent Citizen Feedback “I am so glad we don’t have those e-scooters in Athens anymore.” [In response to the recent Atlanta fatalities]

“Why would we want them back?”

“They are running a dangerous business on our public right of way. This is not good for Athens, young and old.”

“They are a particularly dangerous and volatile mix in ACC due to the proliferation of retirees and students. Our already congested urban and neighborhood streets don’t work for these things. Whatever ‘rules’ the county might design will be unenforceable and stretch already thin enforcement and management budgets.”

Page 12: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

Looking Ahead Continuing to update our proposed pilot program

Soliciting additional feedback from our full Commission

Responding to feedback from citizens

Page 13: ^ Z o } l o D } ] o ] Ç À ] ] v Z v€¦ · Y µ ] } v M & o ( } } v u W ^ Z ] X, ] v P } À X } u ó ì ò r ò í ï r ï ì ï ñ. Title: Microsoft PowerPoint - Senate Commitee

Questions?Feel free to contact me at:[email protected]


u u v ] P o o Z ( · • v l W ] Ì µ u ] µ v l Z o µ v P ] ' o o Z ( À u P v u ] u v µ Z µ Z ] v v ' o o Z ( µ ó ï ô / ï ' o

u u v ] P o o Z ( · • v l W ] Ì µ u ] µ v l Z o µ v P ] ' o o Z ( À u P v u ] u v µ Z µ Z ] v v ' o o Z ( µ ó ï ô / ï ' o

} P : + } v , o Z ] } u u µ v ] Ç W v Z ] D v o , o Z ^ µ v µ …...rE } v o o o ] v } ( D v o / o o v ~E D/ ð î ï ï t X o o ] v , Á Ç U D ] } v ô ì ì r î ï ò r î

} P : + } v , o Z ] } u u µ v ] Ç W v Z ] D v o , o Z ^ µ v µ …...rE } v o o o ] v } ( D v o / o o v ~E D/ ð î ï ï t X o o ] v , Á Ç U D ] } v ô ì ì r î ï ò r î

1 - Industrial Catalogued & ï W Z ^ µ ] o P / v µ ] } v D } } r & u ] Ì ó í } ï ñ ñ> & u ] Ì ï

1 - Industrial Catalogued & ï W Z ^ µ ] o P / v µ ] } v D } } r & u ] Ì ó í } ï ñ ñ> & u ] Ì ï

v o o ] v P ^ Z ]... · 2020. 6. 16. · Z ] À X < ] v Z P E ] } v o W l U Z } u } Z D v ] v > l Ç u Á v Z l Z ] u } Z v ï U ï ï ì

v o o ] v P ^ Z ]... · 2020. 6. 16. · Z ] À X < ] v Z P E ] } v o W l U Z } u } Z D v ] v > l Ç u Á v Z l Z ] u } Z v ï U ï ï ì

ï ñ î ì > l ] v ^ X ^ X í ì î ' v U > ' >

ï ñ î ì > l ] v ^ X ^ X í ì î ' v U > ' >

P v & ] o P v ] ] /^ } } - Michigan · o l u Ç í ï ì î ì ì ð õ ò ó í ï ì ì ì. E u } ( ^ Z } } o & ] o P v ] ] } & ] o P v

P v & ] o P v ] ] /^ } } - Michigan · o l u Ç í ï ì î ì ì ð õ ò ó í ï ì ì ì. E u } ( ^ Z } } o & ] o P v ] ] } & ] o P v

^h : d W & o Z À ] ] } v ( } ^ ] } v ï Z µ ] u v

^h : d W & o Z À ] ] } v ( } ^ ] } v ï Z µ ] u v

v o P Ì µ Z ] Z o ] v ] Ç ] Z v ^ u ] v ] ] µ u ( º h v ] Z µ v < µ o µ Ì µ ... · í l ì ï ò < } Z o P µ U ' u ] v í ï í ï X ì ì ì ¦ ï X î ñ ì ¦ í ...

v o P Ì µ Z ] Z o ] v ] Ç ] Z v ^ u ] v ] ] µ u ( º h v ] Z µ v < µ o µ Ì µ ... · í l ì ï ò < } Z o P µ U ' u ] v í ï í ï X ì ì ì ¦ ï X î ñ ì ¦ í ...

Z P ] } v o v o } l o i } µ v o ] ] l ] v µ ] r, } o o v · î X ï X í K v ( Z v l o ] i l Z ] À v i } µ v o ] ] l v ] µ Á u ] í î î X ï X î : } µ v o ] ] l o u ] P

Z P ] } v o v o } l o i } µ v o ] ] l ] v µ ] r, } o o v · î X ï X í K v ( Z v l o ] i l Z ] À v i } µ v o ] ] l v ] µ Á u ] í î î X ï X î : } µ v o ] ] l o u ] P

P Z o ] P Z ï ð ì ï ì î î í î ð U ò í ï h^ ¨ î í X ôD · 2019-11-30 · ] µ v o Ç ] v P À o } Z ] v o µ µ ] } v U Z ] o } ] } v U v ] o Z } µ Z } o ] u U v

P Z o ] P Z ï ð ì ï ì î î í î ð U ò í ï h^ ¨ î í X ôD · 2019-11-30 · ] µ v o Ç ] v P À o } Z ] v o µ µ ] } v U Z ] o } ] } v U v ] o Z } µ Z } o ] u U v

1DWLRQDO6FLHQFH)RXQGDWLRQ o } v ] Z Z u ] v ] ] } v ~ Z & } µ u … · 2020-05-14 · & } } } u^ µ } U o o = í r ô ï ï r õ ò ò r ò ð ò ô ~ = í r ô ï ï r } } u r'

1DWLRQDO6FLHQFH)RXQGDWLRQ o } v ] Z Z u ] v ] ] } v ~ Z & } µ u … · 2020-05-14 · & } } } u^ µ } U o o = í r ô ï ï r õ ò ò r ò ð ò ô ~ = í r ô ï ï r } } u r'

d Z } } v } o } µ o ] } v } µ v ~ ò ó õ U ð í ï & ] U ...

d Z } } v } o } µ o ] } v } µ v ~ ò ó õ U ð í ï & ] U ...

V T U ] - mcdomanchem.co.zamcdomanchem.co.za/img/McDoman Packaging Price Lists April.pdf · W d ï ô u u & o ] Z ì X ò ï s ] v P o } o s ] v P o r ï ñ ì u o rZ ï ò õ P r

V T U ] - mcdomanchem.co.zamcdomanchem.co.za/img/McDoman Packaging Price Lists April.pdf · W d ï ô u u & o ] Z ì X ò ï s ] v P o } o s ] v P o r ï ñ ì u o rZ ï ò õ P r

o ] } v · s ] } o v v / v i µ Ç W À v } v ð ì ñ î o Ç t Ç U ] v í ï d o o Z U &> ï î ï õ õ r í ó î í

o ] } v · s ] } o v v / v i µ Ç W À v } v ð ì ñ î o Ç t Ç U ] v í ï d o o Z U &> ï î ï õ õ r í ó î í

W^z ï ï, ï& > ì ì î µ v d } ] ] v o ] v ] o W Ç Z } o } P Ç d } ] W D } ] o d ... · 2019-01-24 · Title: Microsoft Word - MobileTechMentalHealth-Syllabus_S19-Jan Author:

W^z ï ï, ï& > ì ì î µ v d } ] ] v o ] v ] o W Ç Z } o } P Ç d } ] W D } ] o d ... · 2019-01-24 · Title: Microsoft Word - MobileTechMentalHealth-Syllabus_S19-Jan Author:

D } v Ç î ñ Z U î ì í ô s o } } u U u v } ( / v ( } u ... · d ï X í < Ç v } ï > Z u v ^ u ^ } o v P Ç ( } Z ^ u ' ] í ð X ï ì d ï X î ô ó : } v W } } v

D } v Ç î ñ Z U î ì í ô s o } } u U u v } ( / v ( } u ... · d ï X í < Ç v } ï > Z u v ^ u ^ } o v P Ç ( } Z ^ u ' ] í ð X ï ì d ï X î ô ó : } v W } } v

< t } v Z µ v o Ç v ò ï , } ] v ] v Z > o o } v ~ µ } r ò ... · < t } v Z µ v o Ç v ò ï , } ] v ] v Z > o o } v ~ µ } r í ñ , } ] v ( } u o ] v P í ] v

< t } v Z µ v o Ç v ò ï , } ] v ] v Z > o o } v ~ µ } r ò ... · < t } v Z µ v o Ç v ò ï , } ] v ] v Z > o o } v ~ µ } r í ñ , } ] v ( } u o ] v P í ] v

' v o ] í ï í ï D ] } o ^ > } v P o U õ ì ì î ï - MASSC OnlineTitle NOV_DEC_16.indd Author elise Created Date 10/31/2016 5:23:17 PM

' v o ] í ï í ï D ] } o ^ > } v P o U õ ì ì î ï - MASSC OnlineTitle NOV_DEC_16.indd Author elise Created Date 10/31/2016 5:23:17 PM

D v µ ] À ] o o ] v v o > ] Ç DULS.pdf/4.2.2 DULS.pdfô í ï î í ñ ô: Ç Z u < Z ]^ Z µ o r ] r Z ô î ï ñ ì ñ õ< u r µ r v/ v l Z Á v , ( ] Ì ô ï ï ñ

D v µ ] À ] o o ] v v o > ] Ç DULS.pdf/4.2.2 DULS.pdfô í ï î í ñ ô: Ç Z u < Z ]^ Z µ o r ] r Z ô î ï ñ ì ñ õ< u r µ r v/ v l Z Á v , ( ] Ì ô ï ï ñ

o u v ^ l ] v v ^ µ ] o Z } í ô ï í t Ç Á Z } u W P P µ Z ... · o u v ^ l ] v v ^ µ ] o Z } í ô ï í t o u v ^ l ] v v ^ µ ] o Z } í ô ï í t

o u v ^ l ] v v ^ µ ] o Z } í ô ï í t Ç Á Z } u W P P µ Z ... · o u v ^ l ] v v ^ µ ] o Z } í ô ï í t o u v ^ l ] v v ^ µ ] o Z } í ô ï í t