˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ”...

24
2013 9 (3-1 ) 56 Peter Marsh Stanford, “The Work of Sir Julian Corbett in the Dreadnought Era,” U. S. Naval Institute Proceedings, Vol. 77, No. 1, January 1951. 30 (Donald M. Schurman) 1867-1914 7 1 1951 ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 Donald M. Schurman, The Education of a Navy: The Development of British Naval Strategic Thought, 1867-1914, London: Cassell, 1965, Chapter 7, Civilian Historian, Sir Julian Corbett, pp. 147-184.

Transcript of ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ”...

Page 1: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

56

�� ���������

������� !��"#$%

&�'��('�)*�

����� ��� ��

Peter Marsh Stanford, “The Work of Sir Julian Corbett in the Dreadnought Era,” U. S. Naval Institute Proceedings, Vol. 77, No. 1, January 1951. +,#-./,01

2#3456� !��789 30 �:;6<=#>?@5AB;CDE�� !��FGHIJ:KL#@M�N2#34#OPQR5STU;V�

L##6W#XY�ZV;56[\��V;L]^_`abcU;VdVN:

e:dfT6[\��V;gh�ijcU;V�� !����#kl6m�

n�(Donald M. Schurman)#o�p#qrss[t�p��FG#uv1867-1914wxy 7 z 4{|}~6������� !��"�1562#3

4H�I�:;V�N�K6������# 1951 ��cUK34@M?62#��#\�pf� !��FG�ZV;6`#��d��HL�K#eH

�VS�2^f@��34@M�^F�U�N d�6�34�����5��TU;VdVf6�0#�����KB6,

4��#��?^W#����,�H6,0f ¡¢:KN�K6£ ¤X56

,0f¥¦:K§@M�N ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- ¨ � !��f©ª:K�� |}^��FG#«¬����������� !��"#��562#�

1 Donald M. Schurman, The Education of a Navy: The Development of British Naval Strategic Thought, 1867-1914, London: Cassell, 1965, Chapter 7, Civilian Historian, Sir Julian Corbett, pp. 147-184.

Page 2: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

57

�#­®d¯°@M�n±�(Alfred T. Mahan)#��^²³�6y´µ¶·®�¸u¹^ºf���#»¼^3�#�@°½cUKNWU5�c�6100¾#�¿)À Á�®��ÂÃ@AB;6[t#m�ÄÅ�f»®dÆ�HÇ

�K�8#ÈÉd 10 Ê@M�KN2#��6[t#m�ÄÅ�5ËÌÍÎ#ÏÐ#ÑÒÓ@M�Kf61914#ÔÂÃ62#ÏÐ5Õ:;Ö«�×ØcU�2^5de�KNx[t���ÏÐ(Pax Britannica)�#�8# 10Ê#Ùv�^�;»Úd2^56m�ÄÅ��ZV;Û�ÜÝ:6WU���;p

ÞHßàcá�2^@M�KNW:;6[t#uv^´â#hãHLKT�Ï

Ð562#m�ÄÅ��®�äåO:;VK#@M�KN t~æç#èéE@êëEdìí^:;#��#��562#��#[tt

îeTïð�ñò#ó@=TU;VKN8�ôõ�ô (Winston Churchill)fö÷K���6xø�Kù56úû�ü���H[tî#ýþ#��^:;q�

TUKNW:;6�T5Å� ���^�¿)À Á�H�^�����

[tp#�#½ë^=d:K#@M�K�N�¿� (���(William E.Gladstone)� 561890 �#x�®�:KpÞ���:ä��:;��:KN�K619¶�8�#[t��V;��Edæ�FG^d�KQ���^����E� f6tî��:;6|}HÏÐE�=�2^H!"��#$�%

j:KNW#��#�L®�d&'H()��^V���#*+^6W#,-

Ed./56����(John R. Green)#��d0Kd12#|}~°���;�àcUK6¶·534E�uv:;Vä^V���#53� 6:de�K

#@M�KN xWU7��6��8d[t#p9}~f:�����6

£0Kd|}12���¤W#;;56�<#|}����£��#¤»Ú.H=

B�KB�>�U6�K�Ê#Ù?#�@6@ð5A�BbdCDÚE@M?6W:

;6FLGÕ:dV^HIcUKN

�fJ3^:K2^56xÏÐ��0^����0#K=f6W#��#C�#

LMHN�^V�2^@M�NWU56A�|}#OP@M��N � !��f68��QQfx�p}#ØR�^S_T©U#�@V9H>

�K#56�c�2#��d��WX��:;@M�KNWU56|}#YZ

^«[f\]cU;Vä�@6��E6æ�E6>æ#^_��ZV;��

^`3HÛR:6aR���®�dbU@M�KNn±�#­®d|}3456

Page 3: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

58

��#«¬���� �d|}��#ìcHITe�:Kf6:e:6�#|

}Ed�Hve:62#��#^_�#KB�¥f���@6gä#2^fh

?icU;VKN2UHj½:��^:K[t#|}~°#�@6� !��

f6�c�W#kl0^d�K#@M�N�����mV��HLù6���

���no�@c�Q���#æ��pE@M�K� !��56��¸u

���;�p}�����L»Úd[t#qr^stcU����d?62U

�@#uV|}H@v;�®#w]�xù$e�÷ä�pHyz:6£���$

�;¤{Þ:��^:;VK�pp|}¹®�d~�þH��:KNè�#�

p}~@M�'�(�� (Brian Tunstall)56µ#���L:KN

�������� (John Laughton) "6��ü���±��(M. Oppenheim)6�

�����¿� (John Leyland)6���������� (William L. Clowes) "#

��d��#$%fd�U�6�p}5��:;VK@M��N������� !

��"�ZV;���6�#�%^qr56�p#��^���Íä0Kd=GH¢

�:KT�@dä6�pæç�ïð�»Úd~�H��:K^��;L��@5dVN

n±�#o�qþ}3wh���(Philip H. Colomb)#o�p#��w2f

¶��K862UT#�ö~5�÷;61893 ���cUK�pLM��(Navy Record Society)#V9���:;VKN´#@62UT#�%561889#�pt�c(Naval Defence Act)����`3��?��cU;VK�p#_�¹#��H®�äØ©cá�2^���;6�p����^2�^d�

KN2#�pt�c56������ÂÃ6� :;¡R�:6¢£�:;:

��K[t�pHØ©cá�2^H¤¥:;VK#@M�N2#¤¥56¦´

cUK§¨eT½�©®�§ª#�A#®¤¥@M�;6«������p^

_�������562#��eTuv:;V�K#eL:UdVNn±�^

���#¬�56­®�?L¯°@«[Ed±²eT�p}H³?´V6WU

�@5Íäµ�cU;VKe6�ä;L�«¶°:e5GcU;Vde�K�

p��#_�¹#·¸d��H¹�:KN� !��f6o�qþ}3w�Z

V;L:K���6x�p}fº1E»¼#�½eUK�A#���@M�KN 2 ,¾¿Philip H. Colomb, Naval Warfare: Its Rruling Principles and Practice Historically Treated, London: W. H. Allen and Co., 1891.

Page 4: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

59

À � !��¾#[t�p}�� [t�p#|}56����#o|}w#y´ÁfÂÃcU�¾@c�L/8

# 1897�Ã>cUKÁ@5n±�LÄÅ:;V�16 �eZB;ÆÇE��öcU;VKN:e:6�pLM�����;ÙBTUKÈ1Ed|}ì

c�ÉT:;=�^6gä#Ê}Ëff3Ú@M�2^fITe^d�KNW

:;6[t#m�ÄÅ�#½u����éÌ#��56Í��6ÎH=;ÏH

=dVÐÑ^d�KN 1400�AÒ�����Ó��Ô�Õ���((Adam de Moleyns)#oÖ6Ed[t} (Libelle of English Polycye)w/1598 �±� � (Richard Hakluyt)���;Ø×1®62#«¬#�%f6¶·æ�����[t#ØÙH»¼�6W#��EéÑHèéE�ÚÛ:;Ü�2^5Ýd���=��N

��Þ�(Colliber)6±�!�(Hervey)6ßõ�! (Campbell)6ôõ����(Charnock)6à�á�(Southey)5�÷;6�T#Aâ#�%@6geUãdeUäLEd��cHjV;VKNà�á�56WUHxåæ�[t�p}H

çäKB#�L��dèÑ�̂ S_TN1790��éäL6ôõ����5�êþ�ëB�[t#Ù½^tì#íîd.DHÖ«�5G:;VKf6:e:6

�#�%@M�o�p}(Biographia Navalis)w(1794)#xï4�562#����:;ð"E�LöcU;VKNWU�? 10 éä6±�!�56ñ�#��Hòö���?L6�#o�p}w(1780)H��2^##f»Ú@M�2^Hst:;VKf6:e:6�?®�dóôÒ#�@WUHÖ«�õ

B�J3H]^_`çede�KNW#´#@62UT# 19 ¶������p�����ö~Kù56WUQRö÷d�p}^:;øeU;VK����

#�%#·f?�ù°:de�KNµ#ï4#Lö#�@6úû�ü���Â

¾# 18 ¶��ZV;çVKßõ�! #��dïð�EúT:V��0@c�6ïð�«�E@�¬#·VûüHÜ�´#6��äLE��cHjVK#

@M�KN

ý�f¶·@�?��gä#L#6W:;ý�#þ^~�þ#·f?#®}«5�

pþ�þ�;�?6ý�56hã:;Vä�îØh·f?7ä[t#8���:;L6

�pþ#��HÇ�;V�NW#�?®�dJë^:;6¶·#���@[t5Q�

�����2^f@��#@M�N

Page 5: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

60

x[t���ÏÐ�#Iâ�ZV;çVKn±�56W#x[t���Ï

Ð�#»¼^d�m�ÄÅ�f6`#���®�d·f?^~�þHZ��

�d�K#eHÜ:KN�K6����#��d��h�pLM��¹#Aâ

#ÄÅ0°56W#uv�¶����9éHf��L�^V�»�H�x:K

#@M�KN8�6� !��56����H Ò^��2#��#óE�Z

V;6µ#���ö÷;V�N/�����ZV;56n±�L�eT��HÇ

�K^sB;V�N1

éÌ�ý�56�p}f´ÎEd|}#´}«^:;#ØÙH��2^H�_@V

�NF�?L6ý�5�����÷;#qr�ZV;#�Í@��Ed��H»¼^

:K�p}HùKV#@M�N�p}#ØR���;����L#56�c�2#

#$#U�d#@M�N

W:;62#U�6�d�ù�p}^�p��#��#�CEdËf^Û#

$��^V�®�d©U#�@6� !��562#«¬��������#

¯�E$%^n±�#º1Ed��HÇ���kl0@M�^sBTU���

�d�KN��£y´µ¶·®�¤f¸u:K�6� !��56Â�#�p

}Hçä���� cU6WU56®�8�o�p%�w3^:;Ã>cUKN

� !��56�WTä!"@5£1951��¤6��2#®�d#$f%�K®�#�0^:;STU;V�N :e:dfT6� !��f�A��#8H¯B�2^^d�KíQ#��

56y´µ¶·®�¾6î�[t#m�ÄÅ�f®�÷���#KB�pÞß

à�@M�K��Ê«# 10 Ê���>�UKN2#$%#�@6�p}��¹� !��5&�'(:K#@M�KN2#«¬�����#�Lm)@

íîdFG56oØ������[tw46o*������[tw56W:;

klE8�@M�o�ê��#^��w6d`#�%@ÜcUKN�pFG^}

3 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Naval Operations, 3vols., London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1920-22. 4 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, England in the Mediterranean: A Study of the Rise and Influence of British Power within the Straits 1603-1713, 2vols., London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1904. 5 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, England in the Seven years’ war: A Study in Combined Strategy, 2vols., London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1907. 6 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Some Principles of Maritime Strategy, London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1911.

Page 6: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

61

+,-#gäf62UT#�%^�pLM��@�f,�:K�./�þ�;

V�´#@62UT#�%fçeUKÐ0h6`#���Ã>cUKe�ZV

;56]^_`STU;VdVN2#13@56��� !��#$%#2U

T#±²�ZV;����N 2 Aâ#�%#Ã>

7�ä?^6W:;é53?4@5dä6� !��5­®d�%#5 �

ºf�©U�i�6UTU;V�KNVä7_8�cf¦?dV9:;^:;

�<H=BK� !��5645>@�#�dýþH�p}#«¬�?¾��2^HÕ����@56Ik1H1�6@A#BC1HH5 ��D�~#��

dOP@M�KN 1854�EFdGH#I�<�UK� !��561882�@�cJH<K#V9^��2^HL+:6D�6Ik1hM�N�6�� 6OúÓ6W

:;\td`¶·�ع#P>d`�8�:KN8#(QEdp����V

9^5ïð��ÉE@M�K62#��dQ:V�Ê#�@6� !��56

��|}1HHç�=B618866RS%^:;o�(Á #7 w^V�� �T�UV�����#��HW?X_T1HHuY:KNW#Z�Ã

>:KoU^[#KB�w56M�\!(�#]U�ZV;#��H��^:

;�?6[tH¶·^!¹#_�`eá�ab^V�cdEd(Q^$2�

=edC#fgdh6føeU;VKN2#�%56M�\!(���¹#m

VSt^6��#41�^�;5Íä0fd�ê<©#òÊ�ZV;6f�d

iJHÜ:;V�N2#�%���;6� !��#��f6jkM�V5I

k1EFIH3?l�;6�#_��tH�?ö÷d|}E��¹^lV;V

�K2^5ITe@M�KNW:;618896[t�#©U~m����6Õ��(George Monk, 1st Duke of Albemarle)#<KHÄÅ:62#«¬@AB;mn@5dV�%HÃ>:KNoV;Z�56 ���(Francis Drake)#<K�����%HÃ>:KN2#ÀZ#1cdäL��56|}¹#��

HØ©cá6W#��¹#StHmB�2^�ed?p�x�KNq#^L6

2#«¬�0KdrHs�XtL#@M?6È1E��#¯Vu{HÜ�L#

@M�KNo)¿�m(� ���"w/1890175î�v�:;�Òh�ä6

7 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Sir Francis Drake, London: Macmillan and Co., 1890.

Page 7: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

62

wÒ�n½cUK��@M?6 ���#<K�ZV;åæ�çeUK!"@

L6ìxüd�%#�@�y#L#@M�N 2#86� !��5L�´z1HH�:6W:; 1898644>#���p}#«¬@�f�A�Ö«düþHu{:K��@M�o ���^ô��

Ó��#�pss�êt~^:;#[tR|#|}^}�w8HÃ>:KN2#

�%@56äLEÚE5wÒ�¾²�~KU�´#@6��^�»Údæ�~

hp��fø�cU;VKN²³�62#«¬#cTd�$%����»¼^

:;pxZM�\!(���#�h��#òÊdIk1E��@LM�KN:

e:dfT6�WTä2#�%f|}1¹�:K�®#'(56­®5�nM

�|}~@c��n�ô��@µcdµÑ�^=d:;VK ���#&é#

�H�V�:;VK6äTTdVäHH�V��K2^@M�KN²��62

#�%��?� !��5y´�#�p}~#´�^:;sBTU����d

�KN2#í�Ed� !��#�%56ôW#!�dþ6W:;� à�

(Horatio Nelson)#���@����0fèUde�Kpo¹#(QE5G^��Eklþ������#ûü^}�6y´�#��~^:;# ���#

&#�HITe�:KN2#�%H{Þ��KB#·¸�d��#�e�@6

� !��5�pLM��^��d��HL�KN²6� !��5²��

eTo(�������4ç61585�87w9H,���2^HåÑcUKN

�pLM��eTÃ>cUKm���# 11 �ó@M�K2#Á56�}+f»Úd�6� !��#�»d¾�f¢cU6\]cUKìc@¾�mä,

�cU;VKN�K62#Á562#«¬#kl^:;icU;V�����

,o1588#(���µ�§�#������t~4çw�����A#ÀÁ¹#ï4#p LëK:;VKN��561893#�x®6¡:e¢�:;Vde�Kf6W#£�Þ�562UT�A#ÄÅH¤¥^:;62#«¬

@� !��fcT�¦V;äU�2^H�_TN :e:dfT62#Z#J§���;6­¨@LM�K0©MÔ�(��

�ߪ�Ó�(Edith Alexander)�H�cU;6� !��5µ#�%��dM� «�H¾VTNWUfoô��Ó��#�pw#o,@6Z 1900�

8 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor Navy: with a History of the Rise of England as a Maritime Power, 2vols., London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1898.

9 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, ed., Papers Relating to The Navy during The Spanish War 1585-1587, London: Navy Records Society, 1898.

Page 8: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

63

Ã>cUKo ���#8�0°w10@M�N2#�%@´�K��56µ�

§���¾�?L6́ Î#|}~#Ê@5·ä¬GcU;VKN1588#£� nÓ������¤­e:Vñ�#86´ÎE�56�5jÍ�®¯cUK

^=dcU;V�f6éÌ�56M�\!(�#��5 16 8#M�\!(#°��@6�UódäoVK#@M�KN� !��fk±:K���62

#��5[t±��V;éÌ�5x®²��#´Z@M?6)T��³¶(Pelipe ³)#0�p´�6W:;6ª�¿(����(&�¿(Ambrosio Spinola)#µl:Kklþ#I@6(���#Á���f[¶�·@©U:K2^��?6

:&#¸¹5(����##�?V;VKN x2#��fq�;äU�®�dqº56�êþ#>·@M��^� !�

�5L:;V�f1162#�%52#�êþf%j��Ð0#»¼Ed��@

M?6W#>·#5�HGI:;V�N ���#µl:Kûü#Òf��H

5G��2^f@�6W#�L½½:K�pH¤¥:6¾#`_d0�?L�

�äW#�pH¿>@�K���=��f6W#��d ���#��Ed~

�eTGÀcU;6� !��5��WUQR#Ð0HL�^wÒ�IJ��

2^f@�K#@M�KN2#�%f61596ÂÃ���Hkl:KMÁ��((Robert Devereux, Earl of Essex)6����(Walter Raleigh)6Â��(Francis Vere)6Õ�����(Charles B. Montjoy)h¾#���ZV;#&'M�0Kd��h6M�\!(���#�hÃ#òÊd¢MHÄt´#@6�

�#äLE6Ik1E±²5!h6 ����ZV;Åö:K¾%H@v;Æ

?�VK6�?ö4K���«[hW#Ä��¢Ç��L#^d?=BKN È oØ������[tw#Ã> 1904�Ã>cUK� !��#µ#®%oØ������[tw@6�5Aâ#�%������HÉ�½�6[t�ê}������ÍR#»¼Ed

��«[H>�KNCç@56n±�#|}«[#ìcHVä7_�Ê:;V

Kf6Vä�äe#ð"h®�dËffM�KN� !��56�p}#�C

�M�1cd�®9H��:6W#ËÅ#»¼Ed}«�®�d$þH¾ÌX

Ò60Kd=ØeT2#�%HçVK#@M�KNxý�56om�ÄÅ�w�

10 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, The Successors of Drake, London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1900. 11 ,¾¿Ibid., Preface Í.

Page 9: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

64

ZV;6ίT�@V:;V��^6� !��5o ���#8�0°w#

J3@L:KN

W:;6ý�56m�ÄÅ�#&#&'56�p#%�����W#~��M�2

^HÏÐ:;V�N�ÑE����V;6�p5Aí@Ö«@M�eL:UdVN:

e:6WU5Íä½ëfdä6ÒÓfgä6��5uâ����ÔVdVNÖ«d�

p#Õ 56�ÑE����V;L��cU�^V�2^56ý�f ���#8�

0°#²�eT1�d�U�dTdV®�dqº@M�12N

2#�%£oØ������[tw¤#�@� !��56[tfZV�¶·

E^!¹#��pE@oEdy´?HÖÒ�:=BK¶�HIJ:d�U

�dTde�KN2#�%@56���p%�^�p��#��f³?�cU

;øeU;�?62#��#­®dkl0f6�p��H�L¯µ#×ØóE

�­Ùcá�KB�¤¥:Kt~æçH6`#���xÚ:KeêëE�Ü�

2^H;Û:;VKN2#æç#veHÜ�KB�6� !��56����

T (Oliver Cromwell)h�����ܶ(William Ü)#��dkl0���;leUKØ������[t#þ#½u#��6W#kl�5HÝBKN�

T56xËÌ����[t#ØÙf6̀ _d�®�ä§�>U#üþ�åÞ:;

V�#e�H5G:;VK#@M�N� !��fiK���6��56�

TËÌ#ßà^æ�#�á#Øâ@M?6[tf�LêëE�W#½u:ZZ

M�þH j@��Ø @M�KN �T���ã¶(James I)¦�I# 17¶�AÒ�@�:e�Km�ÄÅ�5Ø��Øâ�ù°:6ËÌæ�����[t#®�dp ¹#äJ^}�6�

���T ���;cT�å��klcU;6oäôõ� �³¶(Charles ³)�LyÀµ��y2µ[æ��H@v;�cUKN:e:6� !��fk±�����62#Øâ����[t#þ#èéEd»Ú.562#¶�ç

è�d�;6��hä:&cU����d�K#@M�NW#�6ËÌæ�¹

®�d��HL�K�����ܶf=BKØ��æç���;6x&é56ó

�=��èH^�K�N

�£�����ܶ¤5éêt#�@ëxcU�^6�#£�p¤®�f°½@�

12 ,¾¿Corbett, The Successors of Drake, p. 410.

Page 10: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

65

de�K2^H6�죧�¤fVe����2^f@��#eH6íhe�5G:

KN�56�}#m�ÄÅ�fkäeT#uâ#��qHýfL#����@6ËÌ

#ñîP@0:Vt~R�f6Õ:;îP�:dV2^Hï�?Léä5G:K13N

� !��fG������62#=#@»Úd2^56��M�p9þ

f6ÖðdËÌæ�#f����$�TUK^V�2^@M�KNW:;6×

}#þ���;wÒ�>ñcU�2^@62#p9þ5@ð#þHl�;êë

Hu{��2^f@�6®�#òïH×Ø��2^f@�KNuÏó#��$

2��6¶·ô�#��#^_�fõGcU��@6Ø��5ötßà#<d

ó^:;0K��®��»Ú.Â�62#m)d��E»Ú.H~ùo��

^� !��5�à:o�KNxý�#����^� !��5ç�=B�N

ËÌ#0Kd£t~¤R�f6ïð�å��½u:;V�K#@62UHC��L

#5FLdVe�=�K�62#0KdR�56÷®#R�H]^_`jÍ�ø?�

�;:��KN¶·ùú#^ötHý�5G�:fù@M�N:e:6WUT5ûT

�ËÌ#R���Hà�;�?6WUfUü���6�÷;#L#fUü��2^�

d�T��NW#îPH�^:;~ý:;V�#5Ø������[t#þ@M?6

�þ¿ ' �·��V;������9f=BKÐ0H6�·ä�oE�ËÌf�

s:K2^56�d�ùW#��E&éHÊs:K2^d#@M�14N

22��V;6� !��5A���#¬�K*+Hf:KT�@dä62

#«¬@�L�#U�V9�����QQ#:&#»¼HVK#@M�N

cT�5·¸eZoEdYZ^[tî�2UH»¼§?e����HZ�6

£[t#¤tÌEØÙ5����ecU�^V���EèéH�T�STáKN

xW2��V;6Ve�X}« f<�:��^L6[t#ìH�þ¿ '

�·�@lVK2#��#��~Kù#L�H<�:ä~Z2^f6ý�#�

od#@M��^� !��5J3��KN ¡ �� ���#`p^)��mõ�������p#yz Lù�_2#�6� !��56¶#U�^µ���2UT�÷;#V9H

13 ,¾¿Corbett, England in the Mediterranean, Vol.³, p. 567. 14 ,¾¿Ibid., p. 568.

Page 11: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

66

>�K��@5dVN1889#�pßà561894#(��ª�¤¥���;¥¦cUKN2#(��ª�¤¥56�¶�p²������#��H�à

:;6�§}�#o:K®�dßàH�~:62U� �:K�¿� (�

��� 5��:KN18956�p©U#2#®�dØ©^n±�#RS%�����#���6�p²�(Navy League)f��cU6�� ß�à�(Wilkinson)h!�()*� (Charles Beresford) "#��d�����0Kd�p����µ��@®�d8�LM?62#�p��5W#8L�Y�

uv:;V�KNoØ������[twfÃ>cUK 1904�@�6¶�#��?ó�çPcUK®§�´�N��¿�#Jë^:;6 ��5y´�#

�p®t^d?6W# ��#�è��?6ËÌ#�þÛ5-E���:KN

2## 12 �6[�p�56Ctuâ��§}�H��:=BKN2#2^562U�@#��Ê#æçeT ���pþ#¸R���;3Ú^d�K

0Kd�½¹#34Ed��HÜ:;VKN9é6[t5 19 ¶�#æ�eT20¶�#æ�¹ �:K#@M�KN� !��fÅö:KËÌ#òï56�@�!"�#cU;�?6ËÌòïf®�äåÞ:Km�ÄÅ�56W#�

$¹^�?�cUK#@M�KN 2#æçf=��Kù%�`À8@M� 1906 12��6 �� ���f`p:KN�®#�ppÞßà&�f=�?61914 8 ��¶·®�f¸u:K�6WU5�¯'�°:K#@M�KN 2#´§&�H=BcáK§£ �� ���¤#|}E�(56³�d(

)�*�2^f@��f62#§QR56��)�mõ� (John Fisher) "#$%���L#@M�KN`p�#�÷;#�§H��+U#L#^:;:�

�@M��²´Î,#©ÃH-.:K�§#�è56/�E�5Ö«�IØf

@�;V�^I�TU;VKN1904�y´�p"�`n:Kyz2#)��mõ���56�é�[tfW#��d§H�A�`pcá�2^H�_@V

KN190562#0¨�§#´ÎEî0fITe�d�K�62#�â#�p1H]Z�U�ITed���6�Úd�p^!#´§¤¥5®�ä�2c

UKNKT:6cTd�34f6ìxü^d��@6éÌ�5 ���p#´

§¤¥5�ocUK#@M�KN 2U�@ö÷;�K���62#0¨�§56�÷;#P®§H»ù���

+U�:K��@5de�Kf6¾5��§����[t#6�:K7Ù��

�±�Ôßõ�NHãdä:;6 ���[t^#�p´§&��3?��"

�H��KNW:;62#�eT[t^ ��#�8��56�pH9�3�

Page 12: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

67

#»ÚdÚE^d�KN �� ���f`p:K�i::K�p®;f6

±N(þ ��þ <�²�f[t��8:;VK����(HLZ=8d�

p´�����¬t>{��15#�8#�IH�:KN1908�@�6 ��#�r�»²:;62#æç5Â��À?cUKN1912�60K��p®;�`n:Kôõ�ô 56��^V�9Ñ��V;60:V ��#m�ÄÅ

�HI��@ùþe�#�Ö«d]`�[t�pH!þ���2^H¤¥:K

æçHÂY:KN 2#®�dpÞßà��æç �^}�6�pÍR#ôWnAH@v;yz

#U�f=��KNWU5��6)��mõ�"^W#�0���;leU6

�T5�p�X×@2BHè½:6�Ldäx)��mõ�£�£)��mõ

�H³?Áä��¤�#@C@S�U6q�H������d�KN)��mõ

�5619026y¬�p"^:;�p�@Do:6²��#:0#�EHF?U�6x�p�@56­¾#ÏGd���5Õ:;>�UdV��d©UfW#

8oVK�N1904�6y´�p"�ndcU/kVp�8¹#Ø©@M�f62Uf`n8�A��f>�K2^T�K16)��mõ�5íhe� ��

���#´AHHÙ:6�#IJHî0���KCEdyz^ôWy,bU�

3?�:KN L [�p®1������ !��^o*������[tw Ad�/�EdyzhôW#y,T�@5dä62#bU5�pX}��

����FG#0Kd��^Û:&�ºf��pæç#KCEdyzeT=B

TUKNW:;62#�â#� !��56��2#V9�������d�

KN¾�ÙBd�U�dTdVV95M®@M?6«��NOI������

{Þ�$�K�pÍR#êëEdÛqrHÄ_@VKNM�;{f6��E¢

PeTµ#���LM:;V�N

1901¾6�p�56��6��6M�V5ÍR^:;#��kl#�����

�Q�5FLde�KN������6þ��R(Bridge)6�¿�� (George Clarke) "

#��dSä�eed��f62UT#���ZV;��H¹������ýBKf6

�p#qÈT¶�2UT#L#fl6cU�2^56Íäde�KN 15 ,¾¿[t#�pþH¶·y 2Ù^y 3Ù#�pþHZtH6�áKL#�?L7Ù�:;�äæçN

Page 13: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

68

19016ZV��p®1�fû��n(��xcU/8���U�R�V 16Z6�p}#WX^:;#üþfY�U6� !��562#�p®1��

���NoØ������[tw#Ã>86� !��#µ#�Ú�%56o*

������[tw@M?6WU5�p®1������#W�Huvcá

KL#@M�KN2#��56­®#�3H�ý��KB#��^qr^V�

uvEdóEHÜ�^}�6öt�$#«�EÐ0���;3Ú^cUK�p

��#ä¦EFG#Û:&HóE^:;VK#@M�KN �p®1�@W�H=B;À8�Ã>cUKoØ������[tw56

ITe�6µ%#o*������[tw¹^ºf�uv##$.HÜZ:

;�?6�WTä6»Úd��FG~^:;#� !��#8�H�x:K^

���T��Nn±�568# 1911 �o�p��w^:;ÂÃcU�2^�d�\�p®1�#W�@6[?\:� !��#�%���:KN�K6

1905�6�� �T (C. E. Caldwell)�p®]56�p��H6[t�^�;ð�7ÙHëB��ÔVdVñxÕ#�ê���¦6cá�AB;#^

_:KwÒH5 ��f6� !��H6x�ê����m)dStfK$��

2^H`cde�Koþ ��*�'�2w16#´��^:;ij:KN o*������[tw56­®dôõ'�(William Pitt, 1st Earl of Chatham)a#��kl������#kl^:;!"5sBTU;V�f6M�¶°5|}Åöfbd�U;L6W#��n^:;��klÍR#^_E

@c»d��«[��dH½V;VKN2#�%��V;6oØ������[

tw�?L¯V�! #��#e HÜZ��2^@6� !��56m�Ä

Å�H»¼^:K��������0KdfâHI��P�:K#@M�KN

@ð#5G�?L¯°@�·VL#^��2^��?6�p��5�pp��^�

;^²³�æ�~�^�;6�pp��^�;^²³�×Ø{�^�;ñxÕ#/c

^d�NW:;6WU5|}���;#Òg�@��#@M�Ný�56WUH��

����§�#"ü^S_@L�V17N

[tf�L½½:K��£*��¤����ôõ'�a#kl�6� !

��56h:ÝB;VK0Kd��*+����5GEdYèH=VT:KN

16 ,¾¿22@5®ê�p��^V���@5dä6�ê�ZV;Si:;V�^V���@jVTU;V�^F�U�N 17 ,¾¿Corbett, England in the Seven years’ war, Vol. I, p. 1.

Page 14: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

69

[t�ê}HW#�(@M�M�\!(���eT��:;6� !��QQ

#I�56MKeL�fW#�pæçh×ØæçH1_T­®dkl0Kù#

*+#���è½cUK#@M�NW:;6W#����^2�HjÍ�ÆÄ

��#�Ö«d]`®�d53Eóô#�@6ZV�®&��(the elder Pitt)£ôõ'�a¤#=9d��ÍR#��Hö÷�2^f@�K#@M�KN�

p������­®#��56����V;"�5§�#�#óE@M�^

��L#@M�KNx:e:�6� !��fk±�����6x|}Eìc56

²��"�5óE#KB#ìí��ÌdV^V�2^HITe�:;V��18N

��*+féÌ�5`#������ jcU�#eHj´ö÷�2^f@�

�|}«[eT#����?6� !��56µ#��dJ3�°:KN

[tf�A5ËÌ��V;6W:;8�5¶·��V;6W#ØÙH�xcáKu

���K�´�#��#�÷;��:;6k�5Aö@ñ�@M�N§�#"ü^§

�fð�ñjcU�óE562Z�«<cU�Ny´�6£Qt#¤×ØýþH�l:6

£�t#×ØýþH¤C��2^6y¬�6£Qt#¤@mH~::6£�t#@mH¤

()��2^6yn�6op����£Qt#¤�p%�Hqu:6£�t#�p%�

H¤C��2^@M�19N

cT�6� !��5x��HjÍdL#^��2^��¬H>P:6WU

Hñj��/cHµ������d�pFG#!bd?$�rsHÆT:K20N

W:;6®&��f2UT|}E�5�ZV;]�jt�«VG�H:K2^

¹#8udv�^}�6ï4����«[@µ#���J3��KN

&���^�;6�p^�p56´Z#w�#xQ^y@M�KNW:;6�fW

#w�Hì�³�KzÊeT6�5ì�#ìí#!c^¸�HÜ:=B�#@M�KN

&��56�#�p�þH()��2^dä6�êHl�;�L»Údó>H{�@

�KT�@dä6Ct��V;�56)¿�(#ä¦E��H|}:6)¿�(H�

�Ed~{��?x;�2^��?6)¿�(#�þ§�HQT#ì���TáK#

@M�K21N

18 ,¾¿Ibid., p. 6. 19 ,¾¿Ibid. 20 ,¾¿Ibid. 21 ,¾¿Ibid., p. 8.

Page 15: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

70

� o�ê��#^��w^��p#�² y´¶·®�¾�çeUK�8#6W:;�L3�HS_T�%@M�o�

ê��#^��w/1911 1��V;6� !��56[t#�ê}����QT#��#�÷;H3ö:KN2#�%����� !��#óE56kl

Ed�p��^�p��f6óE����ìí^=dcU�´Z#��53H

n��2^@M�KNéÌ�WUT#��56[tH¶·^!��:��

��#��#�@6W#���´�UK#@M�KN��FG56M�?�L

uVÊ6��#>#HÕP���´Z#��Ed��������#ÚE6�

d�ù�p��^�p��5íx:;¾ócU;VK^� !��5�v;V

KNxWUT£��p��¤#�¼d��HLKT�L#f��53@M��̂

� !��5L:KN

�p��^�p��#q#HÆÇ��L#f6�?®�d��@M?6W#�@§

�^�p5´Z#w�^:;ÒdcU6q##©UfY�cU6WU�Uq##Ö«

dþfu{cU�KB�­�d�U�dTdV��fÜcU;V�2^H6WU£�

�53¤5IT�:;V�22N

2#o�ê��#^��wfçeUK����V;62#��#»Ú.56

VäT!Y:;L¦?de�KN19116[t5��¾��M?6¶·�Ø@W#�nf>�@wcU;VKN[tfW#8ÊLdä�6:K��56

1930�#!"H¢;6y¬µ¶·®���?6èP£1951¤#ÈÉd��#���@oVKN[t56cT����[§�¶·ÍR56WUT#t�

H2U�@Â�J�Z�;Vä�ê�$#®�d_�������÷;#�

�FGH3Ú^:KN� !��56��E���5�2TdVT��^�ò

��´#@6�#]þ#�÷;H2#0KdV9�?¾:K#@M�KN � � !��^[�p#yz )��mõ�f�A��p�@Do:K#^²v��p®1�#WX^

d�;6� !��5 �� ���#`p�%�yz#�#~�H���

22 ,¾¿Corbett, Some Principles of Maritime Strategy, p. 8.

Page 16: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

71

H�de�KN)��mõ�5éäL 1893 �56n±�#$%^��:K�6m�ÄÅ�#��^W#ñjH:&��7UK�pFG~fÕ�:;V�

^L:6VZL#�udh?#@62#��#���#$%H6x�5�p#q

r@5dV:6Õ:;����UK2^5dV�^��:KN� !���Z

V;���6�5)��mõ�#æçH5G:6�I����KBÖ«��·

V=tHL�;6)��mõ��V�K���=��NW#´#@6���Z

V;56� !��QQ#íQ.H~�K#@M�KN̂ Leä� !��56

2#�â6)��mõ�^����þ:;¦VKNW:;6)��mõ�#þ

���#�@��Ed�/^d?6 �� ���æç#ë:H5 :Kf6

8�)��mõ���52U��:;!V��#�HY:KN�p����y

´µ¶·®�8#�8d5 ~fL:K���6x� !��56geUãde

U6)��mõ�#%�¤¥��:6�#FG�~�H��:K�NW:;6�

!����:;��Ed:056�VK��#��FG�³?�ä��#

��dL#^:;6�H=d:K��@M�KN ��#�ï5�^:;6� !��f2#�â#�pæç#è½��V;»

Údp HëK:K2^5�e@M�KNW#´#@6�pLM��#V9L

o�;�?6o��q¸ss1503-1815w(1905)236oò�^q¸ 1776-1794w(1908)246o(��ª�4çw(1913-14)25d`#´�#ç�HÃ>:Kf6

2#m���#j½5��#¸u���;�L:KN� !��5�K61910�o�¿)À Á���w26HÃ>:KN2U561805#­®dñ�H��:K6������ à�^�pC}����Þ�±�(Charles M. Barham)� #�þ�ZV;6ïð�R�mä6wÒ�çeUK��@M?62#�%eT� !��56Z���o�ê��#^��w����0Kd

E�Hi��:K#@M�KNW:;6x������=� #¡¢�̂ V�

z56n±�#,�:Ko��@=�ScUK±²w(1907)�ÄÅ:KL# @M�K27N2#ÍâÊH@v;6� !��5�p®1�^#��H�o:6

23 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, ed., Fighting Instructions 1530-1816, London: Navy Records Society, 1905. 24 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, ed., Signals and Instructions 1776-1794, London: Navy Records Society, 1908. 25 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, ed., Private Papers of George, Second Earl Spencer, First Lord of the admiralty 1794-1801, 2vols., London: Navy Records Society, 1913-14. 26 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, The Campaign of Trafalgar, 2vols., London: Longmans, Green and Co., 1910. 27 ,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, “The Capture of Private Property at Sea: The Nineteenth

Page 17: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

72

£¤�^:;�p%�#�Íd5GH�é���´q^d�KB�¦VKNW

#´#@6�QQ#��FGLi�o�uvcá;V�KN2#�6� !�

�5¥��p}ÍR#ØR�®�ä���;VKf6��#������qr

#0KdbU#y´�0^:;�pX@stcU����d�KNM�:0f

y´µ¶·®�8�6µ#���L:KN

������� !�����;=BTUK1256C/E�6�p�h§�6W

:;6|}i�»�ä�pFG#�(^���J�ZVK�p12@M�NW#£�

�¤#c56�pLM�����;{ÞcUKN2#��56�p#kVXÒ6�K

4(#����H�?6¦#��Kù# ����HØ©cá�#�®V�px�KN

2#��Kù56m�ÄÅ�#�I�H=ZB6§<:Köt#nAH��:K#@

M�KNWU5¨©Ed«¬@5dVf6�pqr#C/Ed}«@M�N

éÌ�62#¯���»²��w]��:;6[t#m�ÄÅ�#nAÍR

�0:V©þH���Ö«d�Ê56]^_`de�KN2#âÊH@v;6

� !��5��E%�#ÍRE#$.^V�»Úd_���d��HÄáKN

î�6pªÊ#�þ#_�fyzbU#F«mV£�Þ�#�HëB;VKN

éäL 1890 �56M�ê¬�­�f2#_�HYZ:6� ���;¦ÇcUK¦6�`H�Ú:KN:e:6t�X®�­�f�xcU� 1895 �@5"üf5��?áe6éÌ�êë5de�KN19036Þ )*�(Arthur J. Balfour)� 5+��dfT6ött��­�(Committee of Imperial Defence: C.I.D.)H�x:6WU561904�5êëE�"ü:=BKN�p®;@M�Kôõ�ô 562#ött��­�Hxý�#pÞ#�a�^S

_TN� !��56éäeT2#���òÑcU6y´µ¶·®��56�

­�#|}}¤#�n0^V�x¯@6Â�d�p#|}~^:;¦VKNO

(���((Raoul V. P. Castex)2856xgeUãdeU6� !��#KB��

TUK{�"°(institution et poste crees plus ou moins pour lui)�^L:;

Century and after,” in Alfred T. Mahan ed., Some Neglected Aspects of War, Boston: Little, Brown and Co., 1907, pp. 115-153. 28 ,¾¿1878°1968N)¿�(#�pp�@M?6��FG~Ngä#�%634fM�f6Théories Straétgiques, Paris: Société Géographques, Maritimes et Coloniales, 1929-1935 56"C@L+,Ã>cU;V�N¿� �O(���(o��53w±²»Ð,6Í¡Á6³´uص6�p�qr¶61933-1937N/y¨Á5³´uصeT6yÀ°¡Á5�p�qr¶eTÃ>cU;V�N1

Page 18: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

73

V�29N :e:dfT6�pp|}ÍÎ��K���ÍR#éÌ#Y�561911#ôõ�ô #�p®;`nH·Kd�U�dTde�KN2#ôõ�ô #�

`n56�p®;#¸� Ô� (Richard B. Haldane) "#�e�@M?62#��H<Ò�:K#@M�f6WU5�ÁÔ� !"���;6�p^�

p#��¤¥f6V�T�Íäñ¦´@M�2^fITe�d�K8#2^@

M�KNéÌ62#�#�p%�¤¥56V�T� ��#op�«¼:;2

UH¹º��^V�I��»�V;VK���=��Nü¿�ÓeT� �T

��@»��6ËfcUK�ÊEd¹ºÚ#�2561914 7 �6y´µ¶·®�¸u#´¼�¾�@6��E�À?cUde�K���Ò��N� !

��562#�6�pp|}#òÑ#I6�p#Û½gHR����2^H

q�dfT6�#V95¾VLdä6«�Ed��#Ð0�ZV;6�?èé

Ed=#H�p��LKT�´q^d�KN:e:dfT6W#¯�M��p

ÍÎ������#^_��ZV;#qr56��fÜ�èéeT5+U�?

$�M?6Ï�����FGEg¿få4^:;��E@M�KNôõ�ô

fÂf�iJ:K���6

[t�p56�p#���»Úd'(H:;2de�KNm�ÄÅ�����P:

#M��%56\t#��Àn±�Á���;çeUKL#@M�KN[t#��

�^�p��#�y#HI56[t#4{À������� !��"Á���;,

�cUKNx��#§�(Silent Service)30�^56FGh���8���KB�µ�@

M�^V�2^@5dä6"ð#Õ�?��K$ohÖð�:g³�:K/����

;¼ÂcUKKB@M�KNý�£[t�p¤�56=üd>æ{6�÷;#ª<#

EúT:V£¤~6����0fdVÃ�u6Ä:«#dVº]kl{6ÒS^d§

ÅDo#;{6(QEdÆ0fV�f6��#ì=B��V;6��#k{{�?L6

§Å#k{{##fge�KN

Ç y´µ¶·®�^� !�� ss o�p%�w#Ã> ��f=��^6� !��5(�� (William Slade) "^}�6ött��­��0K�ôWcUK|}}¤#�n0^d�Kf6Ç�³�K�÷;

29 ,¾¿O(���(o��53wy¨Á670ÈN 30 ,¾¿µ�Hä¦^��[t�p#2^N

Page 19: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

74

#>U4ÉHÉ6:����2^H�Ê^:KN2#>U4É56�Úd��

0���;LMcU6�:cU6�p�#kÜ��?Â��Ã>cUKN2#

¤¥#�dóE^½ë56��8�ÂÃcUKo�p%�w@M?6� !�

�5W#�0^:;6·ä[tX@STU����d�KN2#�%QR5M

���6� !��#|}�%#�¯#ù° H�Y��L#@5M�Kf6

W#./eT6�íQ#��^FG#gäHaR�@�de�K#@M�KN

�WTä62U�@�¤¥cUK2^#dV]`#ùú@éQcUK2^��

®��no#ÈÉc^î�d!b.��?634E�Yè5">cU6ñÖ«

dLö^d�KN2#2^5��86î���kl#½%H3�:K��Ë2

#�@6!V��HÇ�����KN W�@M��Lee�Te6CDcU6»VþÌ@M�K2#�%#½%56

�8d�:~H:;6�0£� !��¤5xÍ]ÎD#�=0�@M�^�

�:B�#�Ö«@M�KNZV�6�����(John R. Jellicoe)56Á��2cUKË2E3�Hl�;6� !��#$%HÏÐ:KN�����5�

T��¿� ��#:&@6µ#���L:;V�N

4É6Ñ�4ç6ò�#�����;6� !��f�#�ÛHm�Ò:K#c56

é�EúT:VN

��#�p����;Ò8@Ã>cUK2#ÏÐ#AÅ#�e�@6� !

��5Z6ú��#C�HÓ�cUKN8�M�ó�0fLM:K^2��

�U�6xL�Êe��Ê#Ê@M�K^F�f6ý�56WU£� !��#

ÅÔ¤H6WU£� !��#$%¤fD�%Õ�'��2^H6W:;�f

2U�@½:¿�K�@�L&é@ÂfdLM@M�2^Hïð�Ö_TN� � !��562#�����gä#13H5 :KNWU5[t#¹ºæ

çH9:��¬Z#13HÄ_@VKf6\t�#�3¹#��#�«eT6

Â��}eT2#13H×Øá��H�de�KN�K6� !��56�Ê

H=Z�;x�p}#ØR�^�:KW�H>�Kf62U5�fþH¾V@

VK©U#^óE^½ë�ZV;#I�HHI��L#@M�KNW#�@6

� !��fïð�gä#}«HÙh:K#56���tî#5GH��2^

5&'fM�^V�2^@M?62#�#�à5=8@M�Nxe��"eT�

� !��56µ#���o�;çV;V�N

Page 20: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

75

Ö«d5G^jÍdò+HL�;6�÷;#·4{f�p}#ØReT1_T2^

H·B��^wÒ;VKNW:;6tî5µ�#&'M�Jë^}�6��kl0K

ù#��2^�ÚH?�KN

� !��52#13#�@6©®@�÷;H():Ûä���^V��®

956WUf�J:K8�dTd�U�6Õ:; ��5GcU�2^5dä6

�K&é#ùúHGP@�e6W:;|}5W#��#��HQ��:&��

^J3��KN� !��QQ562#V9��<H�;VK��@5de

�Kf62#«¬�����#j´#�%@M�o�p%�w�ZV;���6

�#� #íQ.M�V5jJ.HDí�Ü�L#@5de�KNM�qrM

�:3~#´�562#�%����� !��#��Á#ÂÃ�Ì:;6µ

#���L:KN

������� !��"#$%56´�E�5|}��@M�N�#=üd �

eeU�ïð�&'M�L#^d�@M��»Úd����56£2#C�5¤]^_

`j��;V����

2#V9����®�dþÌ#KB�6� !��f��¾�Ý�:;VK

íQ#��^FG##$.H6cT�uvcá�2^5ÈÉ@M�KN19216� !��56x�¿)À Á�8#úû�ü�^[t�p�̂ ���åæ

@{ÞEd��HÞÅ:62#���Øß��2^Hð��_@VKf61922 9� 21"�Ñà:KNWU56�#�T��¿� ��¹#:&HÄto�p%�wy 3ÁÞÅ#��Ê8#2^@M�K31N L:6�@Luä� !��f<�K#dT�6¾VLdä�52#��

#:&6á�Æ�U;]^_`�Hè�2^#dV�Ú9é6W#8�uä3

�^d�K���ZV;6L�^gä#2^H¢����2^f@�K@M�

�No�p%�w56�p}��®��� !��#£�p����¤âV#ã

®dýÞ^:;i?6W#ÆÇEd=G^4z#/��?6�Òo�TUKN

:e:6�pFG^1_#uv¹#&#Ä�56��£y´µ¶·®�¤¾�

31 ,¾¿Cç56� !��#ä8LU��< �(Henry Newbolt)�i��fU;Ã>fo�TU6��E�5%�, 5Á6@m~:, 3Á6m�©ª, 3Á#¤ 11Á^d�KNW#X6� !��f�:K#56%�,#y 1°3Á@M�N÷"C�p��V;L�p®1�@%�,f+,Ã>cU;�pX��åcUKNæç�è,oËé�� [t�p�}wÍ¡Á6³´uص61927°35N

Page 21: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

76

j½:KAâ#�%#��=VTcU��ÔVdVN ¨ê � !��#FG¹#:& 2#«¬����8¶#�%����� !��#'(#»Ú.56·äs

tcU;V�Nþ�Ô� (Bernard Brodie) ë;56o�ê��#^��wHx�p������kl�@M�^6�#P:M�o�p��¹#ìi�w@:&

:;V�32N�K6W#Aâ#�%@M�o"ì�������m�ÄÅ�w

@56n±�#Ëf0^:;6� !�����:K33NW#´#@6�í�

à�îï(the Robinsons)56�p��H|}E�ðÇ:K�T#��@6�Lgä� !��#�%H�É:;V�N����ÍR¹#� !��#'(56

�#ïø@M���ôÕ� (Herbert Richmond)#��d2#«¬#8�0#�%#�@�L�ä=TU�N��ôÕ� 56� !��#ä�J_@6

µ#���L:;V�N

�56��}��ssWU56;{�^�;6W:;æ�~�^�;��Ed��

ssHÍä0:Víñ¹^�:�KN�÷;#�%#�@� !��56ð���

#¦´.H�¬�6U;VKN

:e:dfT6G®�Ê#�â�����p#�L»Údqr@M�O(�

��(5653E�p��#�}HL:K�#o��53w#�@6� !�

�#��¾������FG#nAÍR�ò`Hó�KNxôõ�^V�ìí�

��;6¶�eT¶�¹[?\:ç��fU;ä�TUKäH�HÝ�:62

UH3(:K� !��#½%HjÍ�sB�´#@6O(���(56�

!��#$%f*:;C/E��:E@M?6xgä#��H3?l�;¾V#

dV&é@M�^V��ò���K����:;5#�:ä6iö@M�K�

^�v;VKNO(���(56� !��Hxñò#��6x÷f:Vøù�6

W:;x�����ú�ì(franc-tireur de la strategie)�^S�6x´#@62#ûg@(056�QQ#£53¤n0^:;56t:�Ïü@M��^J

32 ,¾¿Bernard Brodie, A Guide to Naval Strategy, 3rd ed., Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1944, p. 297. 33 ,¾¿Bernard Brodie, SeaPower in the Machineage, Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1941, p. 92.

Page 22: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

77

3��K34N O(���(f3vK���6��¾�����pFGè½¹#� !��

#~�56�÷;yVL#�e?@5dV^V�2^5ÍäM?��2^@M

�N�e�6� !��561915��p�#KB���:K"���@Iý�ÜcUK0Kd/�f6�þ§��LKT�!b.�þ�@M�KNW:;6

��ñj������ !��#�PEd��¾#�L563vTU;V��

��6�������@m~:#èÑ£��¤H�p�f�j��2^HC�

K#eL:Ude�KN�K6)��mõ�#yz#�÷;fy�@��:V

L#@M�K��@5dä6� !��56��¾�����p�#V9#�

@6�6¬�KæçH�:K2^LM�KN :e:dfT6�ê������� !��#*+#�Úd¡ 56O(�

��(���;L=�ScU;�?62#������]^_`�÷;#�p

_�����5 0���;}=cUKL#@M�KN2#5 0Kù56�

��c(guerre de course)35�ZV;�4^GP:6M�V5µ">#@m()

æç5ÕPE@dV^�P:Kn±��Ý­:;VKN1917^ 1942# ���u§�#½½�!bd]`<:;V�2#æç£���c¤560R

12(jeune ecole)#�Úd`3H»¼^:;�?62U5[tH@ùþe:6`_d�ê����ýþ#êëHLOP��KB#L#@M�KNWU��U

�6����V;W#^!¹#��^d�@mQRH<"��#@5dä6

t:�WUT#<"HOP��2^T�f3Úd#@M�KN��¾#[t#

��FG~#�@6�T��(Jane)T�f 1906 #�%@M�oò�(Heresies)w#�@6xéÌ����c5Õ:;wÒTUK2^5dV^V�2^56ð�L���B;�ed�U�dTdV�^[t�rÉ:K2^56�

#Òf2#èÑ#��#xü.H:&:K���=��N :e:dfT6æç#2UT#_�H l:;6W:;6]^_`�÷;#

2#��#�����;}=cUK2#��i#Õ H l:;6� !��

#$%�f�.fM?6��FG^��#uv¹#&'H=��2^�`3#

�Ø5dV@M��No*������[tw5xæ������#K$�̂

V�53H�:K^V�O(���(#ïÉ5366��#æ�óE¹#34

34 ,¾¿O(���(o��53wy¨Á671-72ÈN 35 ,¾¿���îP#����`H��6�t§�hm�H¡¢��2^H`Y:K�H���^S7N1856#Ä���@c�cUKN 36 ,¾¿O(���(o��53wy¨Á669ÈN

Page 23: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

78

Ed­Ù^V��¿�áÂ���(Karl von Clausewitz)# ����H6�p��#��klÍR¹#­Ù¹^uvcáK� !��£#53¤H���¬

G:;V�^����H�dVN2#53HuvcáK� !��#óE56

¾V#�Ødä­®@M?6£W#53#uvf¤�#���@°��2^H;

Û:;VKN�f6o�ê��#^��w@L:K���6

�¿�áÂ���^���U(Antoine H. Jomini)fù°:K��EdØ �x�;

Ò�^6ý�5Íä2#��#��#�V�T�@M�Ný�56�Tfxù��

K^2�eT=Bd�U�dTe6¶·ùú#öt#«�EÐ0��:;G0#FG

fF^ö÷�eH_���dTdVNW2@56�ê5»¼E@ä©EdÚE^d�

#@M�37N

�¿�áÂ���fo��3(Der Krieg)w#�@6p9��H�?®�d*+@M���#��ÆÄcá6W#��Hæ�#óôÍR#�¹ÆÄcáK#

^²³�6£� !��#¤2#��56x�ê���#*+#���p��H

ÆÄ:;�?62#x�ê���56m�ÄÅ�#î�d~�� �cá�2

^f@�K#@M�KN:e:6¶·ùú#ßà6×Ø6W:;6®�÷��

�Hî0��K©®d�×}�#�6^��^V�î�#Ð056|}Hmä

35E��ÒXt2^���;� !��fQ«#L#^:K´Z#«¬Hj

½cáKNC/E�6�#V95�Úd�ê»��������#�#óE

^�µEd#cHÄtäJ#ßà@M�KN2U56� !��f��kl0

#�#5G^:K®&��##c@M?62#®&��5®��������

ñZKB�6[t#�×ßà#�Hñ�K#@M�KNW#´#@6´�# 74¤-.�^§H�e÷�#�Ö«duâfMU�6¶·�`2@L�#�FH

¦eáKNW:;62U5 1940eT 1945�@#Ê6ôõ�ô #I#[tf ��#~{H�V�B6�6:K\[#�ê����ýþf6!°5�

��:6~{H��6W#2^fy¬µ¶·®�Hñ��läìí^d�KN Lù�_62#ª#ö÷d53E$%#»Ú.56�®�:&cU;:��

2^LM�NW:;6��#��#Òf6èP#�$_�HGÕ����@5

dVT��N:e:6� !��QQfo�p}#ØRw@L:K���6x®

��5��H��áe60Kd<dH���#@M�N

37 ,¾¿Corbett, Some Principles of Maritime Strategy, p. 48.

Page 24: ˘ ˇˆ˙˝˛˚˜ - MOD · 2016-06-28 · ß“˛Ó (Edith Alexander) H cU;6˜ ! 5µ#⁄% ˙dM ” « H¾VTNWUfoôˆ Ó ‡#pw# o,@6Z1900 8,¾¿Julian S. Corbett, Drake and the Tudor

������� 2013 9�(3-1�)

79

WU£��¤56>U�����^�;56»Ú@5dä����&'LdV��

#® 9#���=��eL:UdVN���:e:6W�@5dVN�Ê5ý��!

"H���#@6ý�5#uH$)�%U�&#�#K_d�´Z#®�d'Ò#�

��=�#@M�NWUf`_d�®�ä;L6L:6ý�f&#uÍR^W#%

(H~ZKB�%U��÷;#�%#./HSTd�U�62#'Ò#èÊH5G�

�2^5@�dV#@M�N

W:;6WU52#C/#��@M?6[t#�ê����¢P#|}ÍR

H¸�^:;V�#@M�KN� !��562#[t#�ê����¢P¹

�#�LmVFGH)�6ð�5G^V�2#x0Kd<d�#KB�¦VK

#@M�KN2#2^56m�ÄÅ��ëB�\t#&#tìHk±:K��6

n±�f¦VK5�@M?6�5xtÌEd9Ê#�#�L»Údæ�Úû@

M?6¨©*^V��?L6:�:�+Ð*�^:;#�pþ#*+H�à:

KNm�ÄÅ��ëB�\t#tì^V�2#*+f&�t~�! @5Gc

U;VU�6,x��hx-�.#�$�^V��²T�#&éh6W#Jë

^:; 1941eT 45�@#Ê6ý�fÖ«dÞ�H:de�K�����;LKTcUK#�eT6ý�£\t�¤5/�UK#eL:Ude�KN2

#è�#ô�#=�?#��£1951��¤H=0�;6� !��#$%56�ê#�$^V�2#_�HêëE�´V6õäÚHZ���¤?SUdV

&'H��KN)��mõ�"56yz^pÞßà#ýþ#�c�����?6

WU���;[t/þ���1^[t�p562#1�#e=�â��V;6

��Ep HÌ�;��:KNW#)��mõ�56� !��H¯äÏÐ:6

!"£1951¤�c�FV�2cU�eL:UdVrÉHL:KNW#�6�5µ#���L:K#@M�KN

������� !��56æ�^p9���ZV;6ý�#�§@�y#ç/#

�#´zHçVKNMT7�ª<#qºh¤?SUdV]`#&'f6W#ç/eT

�BTU�eL:UdVN:e:dfT6�WTäù%�`!6WUH»Ú�:;V

����(���ôõ�ô HØV;6ïLWUH�_@c�VdVNWU�Lee

�Te6MdK#^�562#��#��E|}�ZV;k3H�:;V�NIT

e�|}56qXh2#��~#KB�ÅöcU;V�Næ�~^p�5634U

#56f?#�@6?ÒHÙB;V�#@M�N