ˆ! › indexing › wp-content › ...Pnaini’s Ashtadhyayi & Sibawayh’s Al-Kitab between...
Transcript of ˆ! › indexing › wp-content › ...Pnaini’s Ashtadhyayi & Sibawayh’s Al-Kitab between...
-
257
������ �� ������� � �������� ������� ����� ���:
��!" �!�#$
Pnaini’s Ashtadhyayi & Sibawayh’s Al-Kitab
between Similarities and Deferences: A Comparative Study
�������� �� ��*
Abstract
The article deals with the linguistic treasure hidden in the
world historical books Ashtadhyayi of Pnaini; an Indian linguist
of 500 BC born near Attock on the Western side proposed Chota
Lahore of Sawabi Area, the founding figure of Indian Lingistics,
and the Arabic Al-Kitab of Sibawaihi; an Arab linguist of 8 cent
AD born in Beyza; a village in Faras Iran, educated at Al-Basra
Iraq, later on became the most influential figure of Basran School
of Arabic Grammar. These two books are the real bases of
Sanskrit and Arbaic grammar. Being the strong base of grammar
thay have a positive influence over the modern linguistcs and
linguists. Most of modern linguists observed a close resemblance
in phonetics, morphology, syntax, semantics and lexicography
and many other factors between these two treatises.
%&�'� ()*$
����� ��������� ��� !�� "#$�%���& " '����( !�� �"!�)��"* +,�-��� +.��/� 0��1�� 2 34��5&�* +�6�7��� +���7�� 8+��1�� �%��9��� +�:;
-
258
d�G�N� . ?�7N 0���efL ?��g 2 `9h� ��i j�N��� '=�k� ���;�� lmno !�)�� I�3��+��1� ?��N p\& +� �& Y3q��� . �G% d��.��K� ,�N >��1�� �� -�3� ��e&. !�� L&
� !�� �46 '����( +1�� ����N r�3W rLA TL+� ���� �e& FG��U3;�� ��4s �%s tk�� l �� u� vK 4����� G�L 4�_f +� ���� b����, +��(�L '�f +.��/� +��1�� 0(����� �4;��
+.��/� +��1�� b���� `9�L %��e 2 #^�x +��1�, F@ f '�&� ���� #A T)�$L �4s&� �(�(�N +_�� YL @^�(�&'����( !�)� +��< '���ky @���Q 2 � '���9� rk� u
'_�� !�)�� "@. ��H�AD.Gustave Jahn "2 U^� ( F@ 4�6 ��& R�� ?:^�� �(�� R�� �%� +��1�� '���ky ���] �� 0 ((& ����/� +1�� `� . �G% M�e ��6 �H�� S
�G%u� �e+��1�� (�u� 2 �� &. �G�� � ��� !�)q�& �e&�'�u �(�( F@ # �@� +����)H�H�� �@� ��� !�� '���ky �-�&34��. @�W� 3��� ���� �A��> ���
'����(� ���� ' ;� ��-��� � +��1�� T$H�3�N >�� O�� ?��g 2
34� �� . b�N 34�L ��u�"#$�%���& " b�N .��� O��� 2 F�1� !�� ��&"!�)�� " ��&
+��1� +��(�L !���� �� !���� 4�L @^�(�. > �)�� Y�G% +�5& @�@I��� ��i 3>�L Q +6ka +�3�
-
259
+-�-K�T�A �� �@��� `�-�� �q�� �G% �@ ��^�� ^/ ���HL & �)� A]�
� ���)( T3�;� !�)�� �G% !�� & +�� 2 +3H-L ?��N p\& +� �& ��)adhyaya(* T��
�& ��76 +� �& 2 `H-L ! &�IA ) pa:da(* �)�� >3��� Q �H��� YL bN�u * ��f6+=-� ¤ !��� �� ��� �H��� YL @���� .+=-� ¤ T7^�� �� ��� +=-��� �� .�� @����� *
�� @���� ¤ *?��-�� �� ��� +=-��� �� ��.+��� +-��= @��X� 3��� 4��)�: (1.2.3) : !��� ̈ T7^��©¨ ?��-��)©.(
�. ��0'� �,��
+���)H�H�� +1� ��& A]�� ����L ��� �� !�� , F& �@ �$�� � @& S3��j ( �.L .� ��Q Y� O��� I�*mna�� +���3;�� '��H� !� +L��-��� ª�k����*
' �� b��� ��L '��Q ��& 3� *���� ��:���)P��X� �G��()«(* 0������ & pk&�¬�� T); �� Q `Xh& !�)�� �G% f ª�7� +���X�)(. �)�( ���� �H�6�� ��N T-��
)Goldstucker( :"+����)H�H�� +1� ����=�� ³����� �́� YL �% �� D�@ L Q")µ(. �L��-�� +���)H�H�� +1�� 3� �-��� YL ����-�� b��������=�� +�Xa� 6S� +
*+(��-�� ?�9� 4��Q ��9��� *����-�� Y� !�1�� +��9��
-
260
%���� #$� ��7�� F]����¨ �((I-Sing) 6 & '����GL ��] > YL ?:·Á¨·Á© *@S��3� YL L�3� '�6 T3W� M��)�
́�� �1g `K YL +N�� >eSe� Uà ��K '� !�)�� +�� M�)¿ vK ÄSe
*?��%m ��(f L� '�& !��� � YL�*+����)H�H�� +1�� ����N r�3W T �G% TA& YL mna�*�<� @�^�
-
261
���Q Tg� 4� ����(G�3� Q ]�(& YL +�4^;�� +������ +=(�� . F�^;�� THH��� �G% `��7� �1�� O' k� \�' \QT�k ��- ^��(\�� 0c�-�� È� 2)¹(.
". ��� ���� �$ /����� 869
6��K 4��@ Y3q�� R�� ����-� +3$N '��� �H '346 �7� #$�%���&jK���� \�6&� Æ&� . ! ����-�� lG% YL +��3¶ �& +3$N T� �3H� �"����( " É� ��
#-=��� f=V� YL �-��1�� ���N& HK @S� �-6 ��� 3��� L&
¼�� '� ��@�K . 2 P��& ��& �A�� �N>��� YLm *'�)L���Ì � �@��� r��7�� �G% L 4�36
'�N :F@ .#(. ���()D. C. Sircar( إن ��K ��X� !� �» 2 Ñ �N #$����& �%@m� +��N 2 @S�
-
262
ÇL&+3� j=� j��� L :Ashtadhya:yi �&Aṣṭadhyāyī �������� 4-=��6 :Ashtadh‘yaayee’ #$�%@���)©(. � �k < ����� `(\� �G% @�� 2 ?�L ��u ���
�B4L)`N� ����(: ½Á *T76:« *!��:·( ��� !�� �� .�� ª�;�� J����* +����� 0����H�� YL `(\� �G% J�� Î��(6 L HK �:�L�( tk�b. +_�� 2 F:��
+�I�Òa� Q #$�%���& :
`N� ����(: À *T76: * !��: ·* `N� ����(�: ¹* T76: ©* !��:À* ����(�`N�: ©* T76:* !��:* `N� ����(�: µ©* T76:* !��:©* `N� ����(�: µÀ*
T76:* !�� :µ* ��76 +��( 2 F�¸ T3� Q �;� q�&)©©(. #$�%���& +3� `q� �L :*+��3.�� �& +��3.�� 0��G �& +��3.�� �)� ��G� �G��
Y3.
-
263
+��u� �%� #$�%���& `46 2 >�� L�& ������ !@u� 4�3q�� : ����( ¨ sutra ¨ ?��N Õ��¨ vrtti ̈ gloss – +��K
)����� ¨ va:rtika ̈ note ¨ +��K� ?��N > ?���
�B ̈ bha:sha – exposition¨ t�k�� � ª��
����� ̈ brakriya ̈ derivation – +3)�� ¬-���� Î���(�
��%�(¨ siddha:nta ̈ +��9�¨ )©Á( theory
@. =�&*>?,'� AB� C6�
¨ ����( :B @��
-
264
��%�(� *����( b9� ª�� 2 +���L� +-�e� 0�g ����� � Õ�� > �)«©( +3� u �]�"����( "�� �H� �& =�� � FG�� b9��� �% �G%� ��X� á�N G�L �A��)««(.
f ����( +���X� +��1�� 0(���� �V� p�� +1�g �� T3�;� ��efL ��N rL ?�7N *U�� F& YL �x� *p��/� YL Y)Z @�� TN&;�� 2 rN�� ��& �� P��Ì v��� *
*�%�A +�-V�� +����=�� � �� � ����H��?��-)«¹(. D. ,* /�E$ 6������: (Vyakarana)
+3)�� lG% ��Q ÊKS=g :"����� T�Ì "%��L� ��1�: Ç6 æ;�� . �N� Ç̀ � ¤ P�1�� T���� ?�L ��u ML��(� ����-� 4L���(�. +3)� ?@qL ������ +3��
'���)HÆ(Samskarana) P�1�� %��L R��"r�3��� " +�3�
-
265
��K YL +1�� t�, PG�� P�1�� d�H� `9��L ��� ����-�� p;��� �9� +1�� ���A����+L� bS)��� 0L������ 4�� 3�6 0S7�� t�k��� Ï��)L ���Ì +1�� T���� ((& �)�� �460��)
-
266
« ̈ ������" Dhatupata YL >^�u �46 �G% 0LS�� +��G�� ��7^�� 2 43�H-� rL +��^�� ��GW�
+������� +�6�7�� Ï^g ^� R�� ?I�3
-
267
r H��� @H�� !�)��: �7�� �1���� 04�� W�� :+^�q
-
268
̈ ����� Vidhi - ?��N #% +�@��� 0�3��� �7� R�� #$�%���& 2 ���� �.�& �%� +��1;�
`N� ��u� T7^�� @H�� !�)�� 2 ?��-�� & �.��p��/�: (akaḥ savarṇe dīrghaḥ) )·,,½( p��K +��� ) �¨ F– �¨� ̈ � (L��� ��=� �N '�� p�K ÄZ +� (savarṇa))µµ(
© ̈ ��N,� �� ��N�� Sanjñā/Samjna-
46���� ?���W� +��=7
-
269
����( ��%���� �G��`N� :) ̈¨«( >�� Ç& rL TL�� ��.��� .��� ��u� !�)��0-KS�� . +31� 0����H�� lG% T.L +�g �%;�� "�����( " 4��(� �=�� p��� #�
0����H�� YL �.� @�� Q r(��� R�� ,����( #$%@� ¬�6 3��� %��6. µ ̈ �6��� �$��� ¨Niyama Sūtra
��-� ����( L�� j��=� ?��-�� #$%@� ?��N \Q X +- H��. · ̈ �6��� ��
-
270
m ̈ ��( 0�6 �N : ?�7�ä ?�)6 �� R�� +-�� �% ��� b9� 2 #((u� �)� \� Q���-�� ����� ����-�� b9�� ����-�� 0-� Q Tg�� R�� +6���L M)� �N� �
!�1�� 2 p���L �% 3� ðHK T�);� ��)·(. �¨ @ M�N� . ÕB A��()Saroja Bhate( �6�� T -6 +3)�� ë�� \ #$�%@��� &
b9���� ��:�� �G% ��� +���3;�� '�^g� +� H/� '����= � +3W� T���� L9�+3W�� +3)� ������ �)��)�L)·©(.
b¨ +1�� ?:6 & P��& ?I�L '�� YLm &��� � ' �� �q �4��� +���^�� +����)H�H���G% �� +�)�(S)�� +����)H�H��.
�. ��0'� =�Q�6� F:�� á� �:L�( �N)Sumitra M. Katre:( +�I�Òa� Q #$�%���& `A:L : Q
>^�u� 2 ª�� ��& '� �� �N !�)�� �G%.·« 0K��;�� �4�& ��G #^�)�: ̈ )���6)Verttikas( ����� Katayayana
)«½½ ̈½½b ¬( © ̈ �:��� )Katantra( YL�66�( )Sarvavarman(
)½½ b ¬( ) 0��1�� ³���Á·(
« ̈ �B4L )Mahabhashya( J�� )Patanjals( )µ½ b ¬(
̈ ��� ��^��)Vakyapadiya( F�4����B )Bhartrihari( )¹½½ F@S�L(
µ ̈ )�(�)Kasika( ��@�A��L6 )Vamana & Jayaditya( )¹½½ F@S�L(
· ̈F@�3���)�� )Prakriyakaumudi( �����L�� )Ramacandra( )µ½½ F@S�L(
¹ ̈ �(n@ #A��B F@��3���%�( �;� r H�� �-�� +��� F@S�3�
-
271
Siddhantakumvdi Bhattoji Diksita ) 0��1�� ³���Á·b( !. ������ �� RS�6� �P�*N�T� U*'� /'V
`%� ?G�(u� YL @�� #$�%���& +_: bN: ̈ +�( +�I�ÒQ +_�� b�N& �(�� ����A H��( +_��ÀÁ. © ̈+_�� ��H�6�� L�� '�� L�� :K&� >���)H�H�� 3���2 >77�� �1�� ?���� b3�% !�� > '�� +��-
-
272
� & �7� � '����( F�1�� �=����-� ����� c�- ' �� �7�: " ��� `�& �% ÇÆ FG�� ' �� ��& � ���� Ç��� l����� c�N "
)·¹(. Ç���?�.)� ���� @- H�� >.K��� ��7y Q")¹½(.
Çk� �S$N ' �� +�5& t: "L b�N& �46 '����( !�� L&+6� ð���� ����� T$HL r_ ��7* ���f����� ����� �g-L ���Ì* Ç�)� ���@)� O `4 �� '��Q �^�q�L � �] � +LX� 09KS
-
273
+������* T-��� 2 '��L& �� '��g�L ¬^��I�3�?,'� � 5"�,'� X��6�
Ç�� Y T�V� l]�(& YL 4�Æ R�� ?@
-
274
�L��-�� ?���� '��Q 4�H�� R�� +�(��� `( p��� � á�-��� YL + .Ô)À(. ". ��U*'� 5"�,'� !"�?$��0'� �7
ÇT� ?�K 2 ���/�� c�-�� +�5& p��� � '����( & ���� ��] r_ �G46 `HL Ç@
-
275
� . $)
-
276
T�V� & �� �`�6��A ! �k/� MN��� 2 p��� L 6��� �� �L '����( lG�3� Grapheme* `���6� Phoneme* `�6��L� Morpheme)Á¹(.
+��=7?,'� E��Z
& '�Kg ��� 3� ' æL '����H� !�)��� �m¶ �)� & t=7���1� >���L + .Ô 5S� &� G�L ��u� u¾��µ½½ ��X� 2 @S�
-
277
� +�3�3HN 2 43H-�: ��u�: -� ' ;���> �)�� >
.�� -� pS��\�> �)�� > [�\� : ]�#����^'� ����0'� ���
• bN 5S� �)�� 34�6 ��� >��� >�1�� +L�ù • � +L�� ��� !�� rk�� �- +N�=� �)�� ¾L +�K��� lG% Y3
5�7� 2 `)��� ¬�, +L���� +gV� �3� 03)�� b���(��. • ���� Y�G�� 3��� YL +��3¶ �)�� ��] 3��� T$�& YL 2
�1��*+� ����� +����)H�H�� > `X3�& Q ���&�. • �@ �)�� ª���K ?�.) �Ì v 3� ��� p^�Q YL !�1��
34�� `%��� 34����. • %����N� +1�� 0���HL r�_ �)�� K&. • 5S� �)�� T3�;� *+���7�� T$H
-
278
?������ 0\�� ?�7�
-
279
`$��I'�
¨ Bahte, Saroja(2002) Panini, Ahitya Akademi, New Delhi, p.14. ©¨ Sharma, Rama Nath, The Ashtadhyayi of Panini, Motilal Barsi das Dehli, v.1, p.2. «¨William, Monier, Indian Wisdom or Example of the religious philosophical and ethical Doctrine of the Hindues, p.172
¨ Ibid. µ¨ Ibid. p.176. ·¨ Ibid. ¹¨ Sharma, Rama Nath, The Ashtadhyayi of Panini, v.1, p.4.
À¨ ��� YL��� %���� 0��7 >HKÅ *��� B�� 2 ÕBA��( 4�-� * :«. Á¨ William, Monier, Indian Wisdom or Example of the religious philosophical and ethica
Doctrine of the Hindues,p.176.
¨½ Hunter, W.W. (1985), Imperial Gazetter of india,2/263, Trubner & Co. London. ¨ Bahte, Saroja (2002 ), Panini, Ahitya Akademi, New Delhi, p.1.
١٢¨+����)H�H�� +1�� `�� ���\� '(��L ����-���(Nalanda) +���X� b���� 0�LW� �4�& YL M�� v�� http://dilipchandra12.hubpages.com/hub/History-of-Nalanda-University ( 10-9-2013).
«¨ Bahte, Saroja (2002 ), Panini, P. 2, Ahitya Akademi, New Delhi.: +������ ��q�� :?]��f
-
280
©©¨ Katre, Sumitra M. Ashtadhyayi of Panini, Delhi,1989, p. xix. ©«¨ ��* ^�6: Å *0��1�� ³���: Áµ. +)�;�� ��:
www.mohamedrabeea.com/books/book1_1697.pdf ú¨ Sharma, Rama Nath. The Astadhyayi of Panini, v.1, p. 2. úµ¨ Cardona, George (1996) Panini: his work and its importance, v.1, p.2. ú·¨ Hartmute Sharfe (--------) Grammatical literature, p.142. úû¨ Cardona, G. (1996) Panini, His work and its importance, V.1, P.6, Vasu, Sarisa Chandra,(1898) Ashtadhyayi of Panini.
úü¨ Sharma, Rama Nath,The Ashtadhyayi of Panini, v.1.p.3. úý¨ Ibid. v.1, p.1. þ�¨ Ibid. þ�¨ Ibid. þú¨ Ibid. V.1, P.2 þþ¨ Kiparsky, Paul, Paninian Linguistic: http://www.stanford.edu/~kiparsky/Papers/encycl.pdf ( 24-9-2013). þ¨ Sivanarda, Sri Sawami. All about Hinduism by: http://www.rsl.ukans.edu/~pkanagar/divine/, (WWW) Edition: 1999.
þµ¨ Rumer, Sachin. Sandhi Spitter and Nalyzer for 37 Sanskrt. þ·¨ Sharma, Rama Nath, Ashtadhyayi of Panini, v.1, p.45. þû¨ Ibid. v.1, p.46.
¨ þü Panini Sivasutrani extracted from Kasikavrtti and Sidhanta Kaumudi , P.vi. þý¨ Peter M Scharf -71. �¨ Bahte, Saroja (2002 ), Panini, Ahitya Akademi, New Delhi p. 3. �¨ Ibid. ©¨ Ibid.
¨« Sharma, Rama Nath, Ashtadhyayi of Painini, v.1 p.46. ¨ Imperial Gazetter of india,vol. 2, p.263. ¨µ Panini: A servey of research, p. 160. ¨· Ibid. ¨¹ Ibid. ¨À Kiparsky, Paul, Paninian Linguistic:
http://www.stanford.edu/~kiparsky/Papers/encycl.pdf( 24-9-2013). ¨Á The Astadhyayi of Panini , translated by Rama Nath Sharma, v.1, p.75
-
281
µ½¨ Kiparsky & Stall(1969) Sytactic and Semantic Relation in Panini, Foundation of Language,(5: 83-117), Professors of Standford University., Bronkhorst (1979), The role of meaning in Panini grammar, Indian linguistic (40: 146-157). µ¨ The Astadhyayi of Panini , translated by Rama Nath Sharma, v. 1, p. 75.
µ©¨ !���� ��� F�1�� ����� * .À *©½½«* �)�� O�¨ �7LÅ *: «¹µ* � A History of Sanskrit, by MacDonnell, p. 39.
µ«¨A History of Sanskrit Literature, P. 38. µ¨ Ashtadhyayi translated by Sarisa Chandra Vasu, V. VI, Page 1087, A History of
Sanskrit Literature, P. 37.
µµ¨ Ibid. v. VI, p. 1087. µ·¨ Ibid. v. I, p. 178. µ¹¨ Ibid. v. I, p. 35. µÀ¨ Ibid. v. 1, p. 11. µÁ¨ Ibid. vol. 1, p.13. ·½¨ Vasu, Srisa Cahndra(1891), Ashtadhyayi of Panini, v.1 p.1. ·¨ Stall, Firit. Ritual and Mantras: Rules without meaning, p.43. ·©¨ Panini Grammar and Computer Science (pp.-79-94) Annal of the Bhadarkar Oriental
Research Institute vol. 72, 1993. ·«¨ Katre, Sumitra. M. Ashtadhyayi. Book. 1, p.1.
· ̈ �.��/�* ?������� +�� :'����( !�� 2 p�7�� +�� &* Å: ·«. �ى��u� +��=�� ̈ Á·µ ,+q4��� +��)L 0���;�L ̈@��1 .
·µ ̈ ����* á& .#A :'����( *@��^H�& +�LA +��=L *+�LS(a� 0(����� I��L *©½½* Å: « . ·· ̈ '����( :!�)��* ��% bSH�� ���� +L�-L *?�%-�� *#ÒV� +��)L *ÁÀÀ* Å: ©·* ��k* #N�� : ���
-
282
¹« ̈ ��