אוניברסיטת ת"א | אוניברסיטת ת"א · 2008. 7. 22. · Created Date: 3/27/2008...

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!"#

&'(*!-./(!")'"4 %)*)+,-*!"&.//0!#&'#0.(

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(,

%&($2#&-3#0!,).+

#"13%

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

.!,!.,& '98-&"1+$". !'$(!)& *+,-& ., "!"'$7-& &,!8& "8)$- '-4-& ., !,!.,& #.%(

,2$*.$# !3$*8$ *'4$!*7 ,"1 2$%*!($ *+,-. &'3"#& "3#+$- ,2!!6-& 2- '$7+$'+ +

2'1 ,,-,)2( (#1! ,#6.( !,!. &3$- !64 .(!(4)." "*!7'(!6$4 ,0!*+,-. &*.$#+& !1$' ,8.+ .!4 ,',!+ &!.* ,&6!3- #'( ,4!(. !, ,'!-9 #%)! ,$!9 1*6 ,!31.8 261' ,2.$8 0!*+,-. &*.$#+& ., !"#.%-& '6!-7( 0!+"",-.$ '$, 3$3 ,!())29$' !7!4 ,'6*!!'#

.&"'91 .1 !"'+4 &63. 08 "$3$" .0&!"$'1& .1 (!(4)." "*!7'(!6$4(

!"#(&(

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!"&

&'!/& 4!& .&*'+&. 7%!( "!"#$% "<!.'*!6 ., &3-1 .1 &77("& $9 &,!8 .&*'+&& &33!) '(3 ., $'#!1( :4 ,"$-!$7- "$!*+,- "$.4, 3!.$&. &!$,1 &*'+&&, :/( 0!*(!&( "$3#-"& :$" ,&9 0$%"( "$*.%&( "-)-$)- "!*$+!,$ "!*+,- "$('1"&(

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

0!!"#$% "$.$(8 (!)&. !$4' &!+., &7!+"& "'87-( 08 !/ %!6- 2$!3& .(0!!"$&- ('!- !/ '&($- :/. 04"&( .(%' 4$& &*'+&. 2"!6& 0!4,$6& 0$%" ,&*'+&.

.0!*'+$-& 0!+$8& .1 %$#!+.$ &*'+&& :!.&. ",3#$- "$!&. &/!') (.&)"-$," "$!&. &4'6/ :!,-" &*'+&& %2$!3& ., 4)$-&)"3$#6. '9$% 0$/!7& #'+ ."$'%4 "$!('1- "$6!3-( 08)$-/ ,.4',!( &'(%&$ &././& !!%( "!9/'- &1+$" ,(8. &'$-4 $9 "$/'1!& .!'$(!)& *+,-& ., ",3$%- "$/'1!& "(!!%- :/( &'/&&

.&*'+&& ., !'$(!)& *+,-& %,3% 0$%" 2-9& :.&-(

!"#$%& '(#)'' :"*&+ ."',%-+' !*'%,& '(#)'! #&.+' .1

/%()$+' /*#)0& '(#)'! #&.+' .2'(#)' !$ 1%!-*+ .&

%20. %)*" /!.& /*!%.) 3#*4! /*#&5 /+2' .1/%#*&%4 /*!.&& /*#&5 !$ '#%6+ .2

!"#$% %.2#2+ !$ '#65'' /*%,%-+& /*#*+/ .3(7*5–#*2%+) 1%%(#) 1%,!&2 /*.4+"& /%,*(!$ /*!%.) .*4%& .4

1%%(#) 1%+8% /*.4+"& /*%#*&%4 /*%/$/ /+2' .51%$-5 1%+*5/& /*,*%68 /2,.'* %*$%# .6

/+4+*4+ /%,*(!$ /*!%.) /*.4+"& !-5+ 3#-–!. '(#)' .71*!$/& 1%/*#%$ /2)0' .8%#*&%4' &5#+' !$ #*50+ .9

%$%!$' #89+' /*.4+"& 1%%#*&%4 1%-%2)/ %*!%+ .10'(#)'! /%/#*0+' '$%9' .9

/*))*# /*!&9' :'(#)'' /*!*&9 .1/%/2*5 /:%!#(%, !$ "4*+–/-*2, (")

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!"'

!',;+' /*%2*5 <*#2. (&)1%%(#) 1%)*9! '!%4" %&9! /*!&9' (9)

1%#8 1%+#*9! /*%*68 /#&.' %&9! /*!&9' (-)/*,%9'* /*%*,+-8' <*%**$ :'(#)'' 3%!' .2

8#6+' /&*5* /*%*,+-8' <*%**$ (")1%,%%,. -*9%, !$ #*0%"'* /%/-&*. /%/$/ :%!',+' 3%!'& /*,%9' (&)

1%(#)*+ 1%)*9 !. 5*2%)' .31%%/*'+–*- 1%)*9 :/%/2%0) '%4!*9# (")

'2%25 5*6+ /%!',+ '%4!*9# (&)1%%,*5(&* 1%%+*"! 1%0#(,%" !. ',9' 1$! '2%25 (9)

'(#)'' #9/" .-/*%/2%25* /*%/2*5 /*!&9' :'(#)'' /*!*&9 .1

/*%*68' #*$%+* %-0*+' #*$%+' :%/2*5' ()$+& '(#)'' /*!*&9 (")1%%,*$"# 1%#-0='* '2%25 :%!',+' ()$+& '(#)'' /*!*&9 (&)

'20;.' % >",/ !. /#*2%&* '%(#2*+- ,?*/%$ :'(#)'' 3%!' .2/*%,%-+ $&9! '&*5' (")%!',+' 3%!'& ?*/%$ (&)

.-%+ $)*5* <*%. /*%*68 (9)'20;.' /*%"-6* '#*+/' /:!%2$ !. /%(*)%$ /#*2%& (-) 1'%/*6!$' /,%5&+ 8#6+' % >",/ !. /%(*)%$ /#*2%& (')

/*%/#&5'* /*%#*&%4' /*#5/' -*-%. (*)

/##*.+ "%'$ 1%-5*%+' 1%%$2'* !-5+ 3#-–!. '(#)' (8)5*2%)' /*,*6/+ !$ <2*8%5 :1%(#)*+ 1%)*9 !. 5*2%)' .3

1%%/*'+–*- 1%)*9 !$ 1*5/' /#-9' :/%/2%0) '%4!*9# (")'2%25& '%4!*9#! '-%+'–/*+" 2*8%5 :/%/2%25 '%4!*9# (&)

1%#5/+ !$ '-%+.' /*68* 8#6+' % >",/ !. 5*2%) :/%8#6+ '%4!*9# (9)/%8*5 ')%6"* 1%%8*5 1%4%#+/ :/%8*5 '%4!*9# (-)

'(#)' !$ %#*&%4 ()$+ /"#2! :1*6%0 .'

*&#/"0!,-#.,,!#&'0(!%&

.4',!( !'$(!)& *+,-& !6+( &(!)- &*'+&& "1+$", 0!'8"4( 2$3. ,#(- &9 '-4- "$!$,' .1 .%& *+,-& 4$& !'$(!)& *+,-& 1.!.&6-& '$,!-( 2&$ !"#$%& '$,!-( 2&

*+,- 2$8/ ,0!'%4 *+,- !+61 ., 0',#&( 08 .!(#-( "!"$1-,- &*'+&& "1+$" 1 26!!61, "$.4, "''$1- 0!!*'+ 0!-'$8 !3!. 0!.1+-( "$.1(& "'(1& ,.,-. .&3$(1&

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!"!

!'$(!)& *+,-& .1 ,"!6$*.,& &'!9( "!9/'- &1+$". &/+&6 &*'+&&, 2$$!/- .2$*.,& "$-9$! .1 $.$%!, "$-'$6 %"+. 2/$ ,"$!$,'( "..$%- 4!&, "$'$-". $-)1 "4 0!4"&. 2"!6 &*'+&& "1+$"( (%' !*+,- 2$!3( 0!!#& '7%& 2.2($)!1 "4 $6$$/!$ &*'+&& 0$%" ., $4 0!7/6 ., &-4.& .&-4.& ., :$+&& :!.&"& 2- &-83& "$1)-4( &,%-&. '#!1( ,0!!"#$% ($')!+).1 ,0!!*+,- 0!*(!& ".1( &!8$7 ,"$13& ./. ,"(,%6 "$.!1+ ., :!.&" 08 ,&3!- &"$4( ."$!9$% "$!$',#"&$ 2!!6# "$!$/9 .1 "$!$+)& "$/.,&& .,(

.0!#&($- 0!!*+,- 0!*(!& $. ,!, 4,$6 4.4 ,"$!6!3- ., 2!!61 #' $6!4 &*'+&

,)"+(,!*',")0!,-#.,*!#04(,!1*

0!6$-,& "$6,- .&*'+& ., :!.&" "'($1 ,"$'%4 "$!('1- "$6!3- $-/ ,.4',! 2- $*7 :/($ ,"$6",- "$-)$1( ,&*'+& ., "$!6!3-( .4',! "$.,-- ./ $/-" :.!4$ &/-" '(1( .&6!3-& ., "$6$,4'& 0!6,& 0!,$., :.&-( &+!/( &.,-, "$!6!3-& "!".,-- "$('$1-( ,1.// "6,. 31 &+!)' "!*!.$+ &!6$-8&- &"6&6, ,&3$(1& "8.+- $6!!+4, 0!)$.!4& 2- 2&$ &!8$.$4!3!4- 2& &1(6 $9 "$!6!3- 3.0!!././& 0!!%( "!"$1-,- 0!('& 0!'8&-. &3$(1 "$-$#- "'!)!( :'$)&) &6!3-& ., "$6$,4'& &!"$6, "4

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

.(1..2) "4'$&" 9'4)#'( &6+3 $$,& ,$"4'$&$ !.&6-& *+,-& ., !9/'- '8"4/ &*'+&( 2$!3. 2

.(2001) 703 &/ 64+- ",&". "&*'+&. "$!"#$% 2!( %!.&6!-& *+,-& 0%6- ((1..3) "#*'+"% 64+-/ 3"$'.% !""#.& 32"#-'&4% !("'" '6*$4- 0%6- $4' !3

.(2002) 627 $/ 64+- ",&". "&3'%& "$6, — 0!6$-,& "$6," '6*$4-

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!"(

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

."!,+$% "$'%". 0!!-$4.)2!(& 0!#$$,& "%!"+$

%"-./(,!%'#.30!,-#.,*!#04(,!1.

*+,-( &!"$!$1-,-.$ &*'+&& "1+$". 7%!!"&. &.%& '(/ "!*+,-& &(!"/& '%4 $4 &9/ !,$#. !'$(!)& *+,-& ., $"-4"&( 2$!3& 3#-"& &/ 31 ,"49 01 .!'$(!)& /,0!*'+$- 0!+$8 .1 "$!'$(!) "$-'$6 ., &.%&& ".4, $6$3!6 $9 %$'( ."''$1- &*'+&&,

.("$!".,--& "$'(%& #$% %2.&.) 132 %"7 ,1./7)&".,"& ,"$!".,--& "$'(%& #$% 2

.(.4',! !1#'#- .&6>- #$% %2.&.) 7/ %"7 ,1.60):","& ,.4',! !1#'#- .&6!- #$% 7.76 %"7 ,.4',! !1#'#- %3$7!)#$% ., $!"$4'$& !+).1 6

9'4)#'( %2.&.) (1..7) 2/3 *! 64+- ",&". "0!!'$(!) 0!3!84"" 9'4)#'( &6+3 $4' / %'/1 $%(&/. "&*'+& ., 23!1( 034 "$!$/9" 9'4)#'( &6+3 (("0!!'$(!) 0!3!84""

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!""

"-$1. .."$!+!)+7 &*'+& "$-9$! 2/$ 8&*'+&& 0$%"( &/!-7- &#!#%. "13$6& "$(!,%& *+,-( "$-!$7- "$-4"& "(!!%-& &1+$" #' &6!4 &*'+&& !/ %!6- !%/$6& '-4-& ,"49 !*+,- =61 %$"!+. &'!"% :$" ,$!.1 ,3%- &(!,% (!!%-, !9/'- :!.&" 4.4 ,!'$(!)& ., &"*'+&- 0!1($6& 0!6$<8-& 0!'8"4& 01 33$-"!, (!'$(!)& *+,-& :$"() 3%$!- !'$(!)& *+,-& %$"!+. !6$,4' &$$"- 1!)- '-4-& ,:/ :'$). 10."!'$(!)& "$.!1+&

.&*'+&& ., "''$1- &*'+&& "1+$", "$.4,( 2$!3. "..$/ "'87- 1!)&. 4!& '-4-& ., $"'*- 0!'8"4& ., 0"$(/'$- "4 =#,. &'$-4 "!*+,-& "'87-& .!'$(!)& *+,-& 0$%"( "$*.%& ., 2".(#. 0!4"&. &'$-4 4!& .&($%( "6-$* &*'+&&, 0!!././&$ 0!!"'(%&

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

.!*'+& *+,-& ., 0!.!8'& 0!../. '(1- "$3%$!- "$.(8& !+/ .&*'+&& "1+$" ., !$4'& &+#!&. ',4( "!(!*-'$6 &3-1 8!)- $6!4 '-4-&

%6'4%% 8.+ .!4 (("&*'+& ., 23!1( 034 "$!$/9" 9'4)#'( %2.&.) (2001) 20. % 64+-&.(2007) "'&/"7% 64+-/ 3"6'4&- 3"4&8 " %'/7%$

07'+"&. !$+)) "0!!'$(!) 0!"$'!, "#+74 ., &*'+&& "$!#$%" &6!3- #'($ 2"$3 (4$! $4' 8.((200/) 9. 3"64+-(

— .4',!( *2!76$#7!$ "!6/$"9 0$,!!" ,!6( !,!(4 $4' &%$$' "$!6/$" ., 0$%"( &*'+&. . (("2!76$#7!$ "!6/$"" ,!6( %2.&.) (2007) 121 4! 64+-& %'/1 $%(&/. "0!!*+,- 0!*(!& "!!1($ *&3$(1. &%$$'-* "$!6/" "*'+& %!'$(!)& *+,-& !4'( 5$% '$#!-" ,!6( !,!(4

.("5$% '$#!-" ,!6( %2.&.) (3"64+-( 07'+"&. !$+)) "%$#!+& !.,/ 1#' .1 ,$-)1 !6+( !*+,- =61)""/ 0!9'/-& !6!3 $%"$+ 0!6,& :.&-( ,&4$$,& 0,. 10 !.$#!, ., 2$$8-& 2- 2&$ 9'/-& :!.& ., &#!6/*& 2- 2& "1($6& "$(/'$-( &'/&& ., "$!'$(!) "$-'$6.$ ,3%4 3)- ,"$',#"&( ".1$". &'!"%&) $"$4 0!()1-, "$!6!3-& &. ,!$ ,'"$! "(/'$- &*'+&& "1+$" ,:,-&( '&($!, !+/ .('%4 3)- ,"$6!8&$ 2$!$$, .$%!, *+,-& %$"!+ .1 1!+,&. &/!') :/( &'/&& .&6!3-( 0!!%& !-$%" ../ .1 "$/.,&

.&!.1 "$!"#$.% "$/.,& 2&. ,!, "$*.%& ".(#. !.&6-& :!.&& ., $"-4"&. "13$6& "$(!,%. 11 "$1#'#& 5"8( "$(#1( %.4',! !1#'#-( !"#$.% #3)" 9'4)#'( &6+3 $$,& ,"$!"'(%)../

.(2007) 2.1 ! 64+-% ""$!4.#%&

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!")

12."!*+,-)5$% 0.$1)"+#,&- 4)$! .1$+ ../):'3( 4!& $9 &.4, ,:,-&( '(7$!, 4. 4!& ../):'3(, !$4' =4$ ,"!'$(!)& &'!9( .(#"" &!(8. &1'/&& ,:/. 04"&( "8)& 2!( &6%(&& .1 '$-,. ($,% ."!*+,-& &'!9& !3!).1 "!*!.$+& &'?+7& 2- 1#+$" ',4( "!*+,- &3-1 "8)& 2!(. *!'+&. !$4' 4., "$.$1+. ',4( "!%'94 &+#,& &'$-4 &6!4 !"#$% !+$4 !.1( 0!!*+,- "$.$(8 ., 0"()& .*!'+&. '$74, "$.$1+.

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

.&*'+& ., !'$(!)

,-#.,!*/!!"*+'(!%0

.&"$4 2!!+4.$ 0!3#&. ,! ,&*'+&& "1+$"( 2$!3. "..$/ "'87- 1!)&. "6-).1 — &.,--& ., 0!7/6( "$.1( "'(1& ., 0!/!.&" 01 &*'+&& "$!6!3- "4 0!&9- 0!(' 0!'&)$-& 0!*(!&&, :/- 1($6 &9 !$&!9 ."!*'+ "$.1(. — "$!".,-- "$'(% ($')!+).1 &*'+&&, :/- 08)$-/ ,0!7/6( "$.1( "'(1&( $3#-"& &*'+&& "$!6!3- ., 0!!6$,4'& #$%. &*'+&& 4,$6( #'+ =!7$&, 2$#!" "$(#1( '$'( !"#!#% '37&( &"/9 $9 "6$/"-( "$!$-7 $'"$6 ',4 ,"$'%4& &*'+&& "$6$/"-- #.%- .!3(&.) 13"$!".,--& "$'(%& ,'(3 ., $"!-4. .("!'$(!) "<*.$@ ".1( $4 "'3$7- &#!#%( $/9 4. ,0$#- ./-$ ,'"$!

7%!( "*#66& &3-1& .1 1!+,&. "$!$,1 "$!*+,- "$7!+" 08 0!"!1. !/ ,!83&. ($,% 12 0!!"'(% 0!"$'!, "*'+& ., &1+$". 7%!( &3-1 "*!#6 ,.,-. ."$-!$7- &*'+& "$*.%&. !*+,-& 23-1-. 7%!( $9 &1+$" .1 26$("-& ., $-.$1)"7!+"- "1+,$- "$!&. &!$+) "$1)-4( 08 "$!"'(% "$!$/9 .1 28&. 2"!6 0!(' 0!'#-( ,"49 01 ."$!"'(% "$!$/9 ., &3-1& ,'(3 ., $'#!1( ,2/. .!"6!3- 2$-!-( 0!!*'+ 0!+$8 !3!).1 0!"$'!, "#+7& "$7!+"- '#!1( "1+,$- "$!&. &!$+) (&"6$/"-- .!3(&.) &*'+&& ., "$!-!*!8.. 7%!(

."$!*+,-)5$% ,(/ *7- 2$#!") "$!".,--& "$'(%& #$%( =7$&, ,"$!".,--& "$'(%& #$%. 1% #'+ 13

.162 %"7 ,1..3)8"6,"&

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!"*

12.&!(8. "-/7$- &'38& "$'+7( 2!4 ,:/. 04"&($ ,&('&( "(/'$- &*'+&& "1+$" "!".,--& "$('$1-& ""%+&. "6$</-& "$!6!3- 4!& &*'+& !/ '-$. 2"!6 ,!../ 2+$4( "$('. ,0!6$<8- 0!1)-4( ,$-!, :$" "8,$- "$!&. &.$/! $9 &'*- .&'(%&$ &././& !!%( !/ &'$(7 &6!3-&, 0!!'$(!) 0!3!#+" !$.!- 0,. "$!*'+ "$'(% ., 2&!"$'!, "'!/, "<.!(7 "$1)-4( 0!,3% 0!-$%"( "!*'+ "$.!1+. ".3& "%!"+ 17,#+7. "(!$%- 4!& &*'+&& "1+$" ., 0!6+& !$(!' "4 8!)&. 31$!- &9 #'+ .3$1$ "!6$*., ("$!(!7+)

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

.0&., "!.7'$$!6$4$ &$$, &#+7&. .&*'+&& "1+$" ., 0!6$, 0!6+ 0!$$&-& 0!()- ., &(%' ",# 8!)- &9 #'+( 2$!3& 2/).1 .&!.$,( '"$! 0!4)-6 0#.%$ ,&*'+&& "1+$" ., 2!1'8. '"$! 0!($'# 0&- #.% 2!( ,! 0.$4 .&&9 &-)$1( "$.4,6 26!4 =4$ "$3!%4 26!4 0"'87-( "$''$1"-& "$.4,& !!%( "$.!1+( 0!!*'+ 0!-'$8 ., 0#.% ".38& — "$($,% 2$!-3 "$3$#6 0!6$,& 0!()-&

+aul Starr2 "#$ %$&'(') %$4' 2/ .(1../) 30—23 3#&./& #*'+"/ %6'4% 5"/ #%)! $4' 12.*+ ,-(.&/(0&/(*'2 " 3AL6 L. 8 +9L:3 ;6<. " =#>**?

04"&( 2& &6",- #+7. "$(!$%- 2-)1 "4 "$4$' "$!$,'& 0!"$'!, $.!4 &.4,. &($,"& 17 $6!8(, 4,$6) 0!6$, 0!-$%"( &!%'94. &6!3-& ., &"$(!$%- "3!- !(8. 0.$1&)"+#,&. ., "!././& &7!+". 04"&( 2&$ ("#$.%-( "$!$6, 0!"!1. "$(,%6 "$!"'(%& "$!$/9& 0!')$-"/ 0!-!$7- 0!"$'!, ., &7!+". ',4( 08 ."0!!'$(!) 0!')$-"/ 0!-!$7- 0!"$'!, 3%4/ !"'$7- 2+$4( 7+"6 '$.38-& ,.,-. ,:/ ."#$.%- ''$1"&. &!$,1 "0!!'$(!) :$" ,"49 &7!+" .1 "'$#!( &%"-6 :,-&( 0.$4 ,!'$(!) ')$- ., 0!!7.#& 0!'#-& ;onald H. %$4' .&!'$*7!&& :.&-( 0!!*'+ 0!'$.38- ., 0".1+&. "$-8<3 .1 &1()& Coase2 "#$ 1()#/#*23$ (' 45*'*6(532 #) J. L. 8 6C9H. '() =#>)!?I David 6. <an Mandt2 "#$ 1$33*'3 *+ /#$ 1()#/#*23$: 89*.$-'6$'/8 *- 8,-(.&/$8 ,-*.(3(*' *+ 9**:2

.&& J. L6GAL SOPD. !) =#>>'? %$3( 4,$6( 2$!3 .1 "77$(- &*'+&& ., "$6$,& "$6$/"-& 2!( 24/ "1)$-& &6%(&& 16 Daphne %$4' .2002 "6,( 0!!#"&, !"4$$,& *+,-. !-$4.)2!(& 76/& "4'#. 2/$&, BarakU6reV2 ;<<=>(') ;:6('(3/-&/(.$ 1&? /* ,-(.&/(0&/(*' (' @3-&$=2 IS;A6LI ;6+9;OS

.,( ,"49 01 .O9 OH6 X<I IHO6;HAOI9HAL C9HG;6SS 9Y C9M+A;AOI<6 LA[ !) =&\\"? "$6$,$ '"$! "$*'$+- !%/$6& '-4-( "$4($-& "$6%(&& ,&*'+&& 0$%"( "$!$%"+"&& ()#

.%$3( ../6, 2$!3& 2- 2&!*'+- #.%(

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!">

$".%&$ (0!!*'+ 0!-'$8 01 "$!$,'& ., !(!76*6!4 &.$1+)=$"!, (&'(%&$ &././& "'*- &9 (.,(, '%4- !/ 2!!). !$4' ."$!$,'& ., 2"$.!1+ .1 !*'+)!#$, 2$!8!& ., "'$7-& "4 4)$-)"3$#6/ .(#- 4$& ,&*'+&& "1+$" ., 0!6$,& &!6+ '$4!" 4!& 2$!3& .0!6$, "$.!1+ !-$%"( "$!$,'& ., 2"$('$1- "3!- !(8. .4',!)"6!3- ., "!6$*.,&

1/.&*'+&. (,%!" '(1( "$.!1+ $!& 2& 0&(, 0!-$%"( "$.!1+- "$!$,' ., 2"8!76

"634!".'&!%*40!%'*"4.!7#'1*!%'#02!%(6,!1*

0$9!! :'$). "$'(% "-#& ., &#!*#'+( "$&9. 2"!6 &*'+&& "$!6!3- ., &!6)!6 "4 '($3- ',4/ 18"$!".,-- "$'(% !3!).1 ,!'# ,"$!$,'& !3!).1 "!#71 "$.!1+ ., ., "$.!1+( '($3- ',4/ "$!6$'!1 "$'(% !3!).1 $4 ,!9/'-& 2$*.,& ., "$.!1+( 4#$$3 "$(' "$!".,-- "$'(% ., 2"-#& &4*!( !'$*7!& 2+$4( ,2/4 1.."$!-$#- "$!$,' "'87-( &'!%( :$" 08 04 ,&././& !!%( !9/'-& 2$*.,& ., &&$(8& $"$('$1- "4

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

.Michael J. Ore^ilcock et al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

.&.,--& !3!).1 "$'(% ., 23$7!!. "!31.( :'3 &$$"-.("$!'!1& "3$#+ %2.&.) 1./ %"6 ,;,3% %7$6< "$!'!1& "3$#+. 422.)$ (30)22. *7 !+. 1.

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!)\

2"$.!1+ &,-!, :,-&( 0.$4 20.&'(%& "'87- — "!#71 "$.!1+. &-!4"-& "!*+,- "$'(% ., 2-$!# ,"!,4' .&*'+& "$-9$!. 7!7( "$!6$'!1 "$'(%$ "$!".,-- "$'(% ., .2"*!.,(, "$'(%& .4 "$!$,'& 2- "$.!1+ !-$%" "'(1&. 3!-"- !$"!+ ')$! &.4 "6$/"-( ,3%- "68'$4- 4!& ,&'(% ., &.$&!6. "'($1 "-!$7- "$.!1+ ',4/ "'$-" 0$.," "!!(8 4!& $9 &'*- "8,&. :'3& 0!(' 0!'#-( 21.0!%$$' "#+&. "6$</-& "'!/- ., "$!6!3-& &.!,(& ',4/ ,"!6, 22.&'$-" 4.. $#+$7 '(1( ',4 0!"$'!, "$'(% ., 2&!"$!6- "'!/- &"!!& &,$-!-. '"$!( &%$6& :'3& ,0!!*'+ 0!-'$8. 0!7/6 &.&6"& 4. &*'+&. "31$!-& "!".,-- "$.!1+ ',4/ .0!!*'+ 0!1!#,-. "$!".,-- ',4/) "!".,-- &'(% ., "'87-( &6$8'4 &!& &9 2$$!/( 2$,4'& 31)& ,&'(% "$1)-4( 23.(:,-&( *'$+!, !+/ ,:!.&"( 4(& (.,& "$!&. &31$6 &'(%& ., &!"$!6- "'!/- &-83&. 2"!6 ,"$!%$$' ., 0!.$#!, '"$! &,!83-& ,0!3!84" "$1)-4( "$.!1+. '(1-& .1 1!()&. 2"!6 !-$#-& '$,!-( 22.0!!".,--& 0!.$%&)!"( "3$84!"". &-9$!& "$1)-4( 27"$!-$#-& "$!$,'& ., 2"$.1(( "$'(% "$1)-4( ($!(&$ 0!-& "/'1- .$&!6. '(1-&

26.(&.4 "$'(%( 2"*!., "4 '$/-. $./$! :,-&( ',4)

&#!#% !'#%-. 2$/-&) !&"!#+-- !&'/1 0&1 !.7% #+ %!,$%# %(.&&% 1#&( $4' 20 "$'(%& #$% ., $"#!#%. 1#' ,-!,, ,&31$$& %$3 .10 (4".," ,!"4$$,& *+,-.$ !1)-4/ .4',!( "$!".,--& "$'(%& $-#$& !"'$7- 2+$4( !/ 2!!)- ,"$!".,--&

.&././& !!%( &.,--& ., &"$('1"&. "$'(%& #$% ,$9 %$'( ."$'(% .$&!6 ., !9/'-& 7$"4& 4!& 0!%$$' "#+& ,'(3 ., $'#!1( 21 &-)1 "4 "$%6&. &'$-4 ,"!.&6- "$,'- .!3(&. ,"!".,-- &'(% !/ '!&(- "$!".,--& "!".,-- &'(%" %&9 2!!61( 1($# #$%. (4)2 *7 .0!!#71 0!.$#!, ., 0'$4. .!8'& &'#-( &1(# 04 ".$9 ,"!".,--)4. &'(% .$1+. "8&$6 0&!+ .1, 0!!#71& 0!.$#!,& !+. .1+" "!".,-- &'(% .1 .$%" 4. $9 &4'$& (0!'%4 &.$1+ !.$#!, ,&31$& '$,!4( ,&.,--& &.

".0!%$$' "#$.% 0!'7$4 &., 3$7!& !/-7-, +'&1 66624.2 5"8( $4' ".!4 ., "!././& &'(%& !3!).1 "&6!81 !-3" "!!(8. ,&-8$3. 22

.(1..2) 3/2 (1)46 3"+ ,%#+--# "64+-% :.&"% &, ., $"$.!1+ "'(1& !3!).1 &,16 &!6$+.*& 0$%"( "$-'$+'& ., 2$,4'& (.,& ,.,-. 23 ."!".,-- &'(%/ &-#$&, ,(#9( %2.&.) -"1( #9( "'(%. &9 0$%"( "'$,#"& 3',- &9 #$% .(#9(& #$% %2.&.) 218 %"7 ,1.82)("-,"& ,#9(& #$% &!& !$6!,& "4 ..$%, #$%& ,(0!'$3!,$ #9() "'$,#"& #$%. $-, 08 &6$, :,-&($ ,0!6,& :.&-( 0!(' 0!!$6!, '(1

.("'$,#"& #$% %2.&.) 1.82)("-,"&.18 ,"& .!1. ,"#"2'/ 2!!61 $4' 22

.(($!($ 0!- !3!84" #$% %2.&.) 2001)4"7,"& ,($!($ 0!- !3!84" #$%. 2—3 *7 !+. 27 "$($,"$ "$.4, %"!1(* &-!'9" .* 2$.4 3$1 $4' .($!($ 0!- !3!84" #$%. /6)$ /2 *7 !+. 26 361—360 ,31/ 8/ 64+- "'01- "&,3% "!"(!(7 "$4!)-. 0!-& #$% "-4"& '(3(

.(200/)

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!)#

%"#'0"1!%'*400!%'#02!*/!,#"8(!1.

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

32."$!".,--& "$'(%& :'1- ., ".83&)"$'(%"- #.% &9 ../($

*&#/"!"46#6(!*/!,#82,,!%'")"+(0!%'#'(%!1'

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

#*'+"/ !&'/1 !6'4% 5!(9$' 2$1-,$ ('+'(.!9 2$!))2( ,2!!*,#4 &-., $4' !../ 2+$4( 2/.(1..8) 3#&./&

.#$%. $7.—47. *7 "4 ..$/ &9 #'+ 28."$!".,--& "$'(%& #$%. 47. *7 2.."$!".,--& "$'(%& #$%. (7. *7 30

."$!".,--& "$'(%& #$%. 76—71 *7 31."$!".,--& "$'(%& #$%. 72 *7 32

."$!".,--& "$'(%& #$%. (()(7. *7 33..1).4 — &+$1"& 0$%"($ (#9( — "'$,#"& 0$%"( %.,-. 32

..4',! !1#'#- %3$7!)#$%. 1 *7 37

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!)&

., 0!(%'6 0!%*, !(8. "!../& &-8-& ,2/ .1 '"! .2!*$.%. "!*'+ 4!& 2!1#'#-( &1#,&( 0!/$'/& ,0!!'%7- 0!,$-!,. 0!!4.#% 0!,$-!,- '(1- 4!& .4',! !1#'#- 0&( 0!,$-!,& !$6!, ., "$',+4& "4 "/+$& :/($ 362!1#'#-& !6+ "4 &6,- ',4 .%& !6$'!1& '98-( !/ =!7$&. 2"!6 3/..!.1( "!"$4!)-)!".(. &'/%&& "+$#" 0$"( !7/6 ., 0!'/$%. "$.1(& "'(1& :'3).1 ,!.-'$+& '$,!-( 08 &*'+& ., :!.&" '(/

38.0!!"%+,- 0!'$8-

&9'2-#'6"((!!""-#.!!")*06!%'41(&0!%")'-*/!%'*"4.!4'1"0!1,

"$,16& "$!.&6-& "$.$1+& ., !"8'3& 0$)-)( "4*("- &*'+& ., "+7$6 "6$/"- 21$)!( 0,. 0!!*'+ 0!6.(# "'!/,. "'($8 &!!6+ 3). ,2-)1 2$*.,& "$!$,' "$1)-4( "!6/* "$.!1+ "'(1&( ./)03$# &4*("& &9 8$7- &*'+&& ., &"!,4' ."$3$(1 ., ,&!!6( "-8$3 0!-$%"( ,0!!*'+ 0!6.(# !3!. 43!'8 1$)!( ., 0!'$'( 0!*(!& ".1(

"7%!!"- ,%$"!+$ &!!6( .1 =7$6 ,2!1#'#-& ()- "4 &6,-& ,$-!,. "!6$)!# &-8$3 36 2"!6 &9 ',#&( .2!3 !+).1 0!'"!&. 2($-/ &+$+/ ',4 ,"$()%- ., "!*'+ "$.!1+. 4"1 ,.,-. ,$4' .&(!)%& 0$%"( "$.!1+& .1 %$#!+& "'(8& ., &-8- .1 1!()&. 4#$$3

.(2001) 63 (2)$6 3"+ ,!&"!+!% ('+- &, '!#/8&- !&4!&+( !',$ !&/71- 1807400 "$!4.#%& "$!+$"!,& "$3$84. &9 ../($ ,0!!*'+ 0!-'$8. .4',! !1#'#- $'/%$& '(1( 08 3/ "$.(8&& 1#' .1 ,"49 01 ."$.$38 1#'# "$3$"1( .1$+( $#!9%& ',4 ,(0!(,$-&$ 0!)$(!#&) &!+., "%$$'& &7!+"& %/$6.$ ,(0!!4.#% 0!,$-!,. '#!1() 1#'#( 0!,$-!,& .1 $.*$&, !'$(!)& 23-1- "4 &.4 "$'/%& $6!, 4. ,"$!-$4. "$'*- 0$3!# 0,. 4!& "$1#'#( &#9%&& 2-9 "$+$#". %$"!+$ &!!6( !/'$). "$'/%$- "$1#'#& ',4/ ,"49 "-$1. ."$1#'#& ., 7%!!"- #$,& =4$ ,3(.( "!.-'$+ "'"$6 2&!.4 .4',! !1#'#- .&6>- ., $"#!9 ,"$/$'4 "$!$%"+"&& '$4!". .(&"6",& 4. 2&( "$.1(&, =4) "$!*'+ "$1#'# .4/ ,&(' &3!-( ,2&!.4 !1#'#- .&6!- %0, 06$3$ &+ 06$3" 9'4)#'( &6+3 08 $4' "".%$9 &*'+&"/ .4',! !1#'#-(

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

.(&9 #$%. 12 *7()

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!)'

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

23.!*'+ 3!84" "$1)-4( ,3% '&$7)"!( ".1+&$ 22,"2!76$#7!$ "!6/$"" &6$/-&

!""-#.!!"(5"!%'41(&0!%'"#'0"1!%'"%/%!%(6,!1)

"$,3% "$!"," "-#&( "3#-"- 0!!*'+ 0!-'$8 01 "$',#"& ., "3%$!- "6$/"- 0!1!#,-/ 0!.1$+ 08 4.4 ,&!!6(& "$3$(1 "4 0!1)(- #' 4. ',4 ,0!-9! "$1)-4()=$"!, ,&9 ',#&( .0!3%$!- "$6$!/9 %$/- ,2"-#& '%4. ,"$!","& ., 0!.!1+-/$ "$!","& "-#&. !*'+ 2$-!- 8!,&. 2$)'& 2- '#!1( 1($6 0!!*'+& 0!-9!& 01 &.$1+& '9%& "4 0!%!*(- ,*#!$'+& ., $"-#& "$.1( 0!4,$6& ,"$6$!/9& !.1( .2$,4'& (.,( 2- 0!($8 0& &(, ,&/$'4 &+$#" :,-( *#!$'+& ., $.$&!6 "$1)-4( %$$'( &1#,&& Build2? B9O &6</-& ,&9 .3$- "'87-( .&,3%& "!","( ,$-!,& "'$-" &'84 '$(!)& .!1+- ,=Build? $6$(,% .1 "!","& "4 &6$( !*'+& 1!#,-& ,=9perate and Oransfer "4 $4 "$.1(& "4 '!(1- &+$7($ ,=9perate? ,4'- "%*($- &/$'4 &+$#" :,-( &"$4 2& &9 .3$-( ,$-!,. "$#&($-& "$-8<3& 22.=Oransfer? &6!3-& !3!. "!","( &*!.,&

2!!61 %2.&.) (1..2) 210 (1)$- 3"+ ,!&'/1% 3+' &, :"/&4"#"4 23034.0 5"8( ,.,-. ,$4' 3..(:"/&4"#"4

&, -#./ 3"#0"-"$ %4"1 1/83400 5"8(( $6!3)#7+( $9 &#!*#'+. 7%!!"& #'( *+$,& !20 ,$!'(3. .(3"#0"-"$ %4"1 2!!61 %2.&.) (2003) 672 (3)96 3"+ ,%#+--# "64+-% :.&"% ., &"$!#$%( #+7 ".*& .&.4 0!1($" !3!).1 .4',!( $.&$6 0!!.!.+ 0!*+,- !+.4" "+!/4 "$/'1- "4 $,(,! ',4 '"$!( "$,# "$4)$" &!'%4 '$'8" $9 =#!& "(%' "$.!1+

.676 *-1( ,0, ."!.!.+& #$%& /&+1- )')*)!)- 26.0406 0"11 $4' 0!!6$'!1 "$($% "!!(8 ., 0!"$'!, 2"-. 9'/-. 21

.(2.7.2006 ,07'$+ 0'*) (&(+* !""'". &, -#./ 5&8'*& 5&,$! ,2002)3"7,"& ,(&#!#% !6$#!") 2002 0!+7/& "6,. "!././& "$!6!3-& #$%. 9 #'+ $4' 22

.. ,"& .!1. ,"2!76$#7!$ "!6/$"" ,!6( $4' $9 "!6/$"( 2$!3. ... %"7 =!7$& 2$#!"& .328 %"7 ,2002)3"7,"& ,(28 *7-) '&$7& !"( "3$#+ 2$#!". #$% $4' 23 "4 ('&$7&)!"( "3$#+ %2.&.) 27. %"6 ,1./2)(".," ,;,3% %7$6< '&$7&)!"( "3$#+(

."!*'+ .$&!6( '&$7 "!(" 4!& $"'"$/, 28 #'+ !"",/# *&/- " !&"!+! !6'4% ($3! .!!4 $4' "$!"," "*'+&. 0!.3$- ., =7$6 *$'!+. 22

.(2001) !&"6'4%!&"'&/"7 !&"&4!&+

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!)!

"$-8<3 26..-'/& "'&6- 2/$ 27.4',! &)$% ,!(/ — 0!,3% 0!,!(/ ".!.7 ., 0$%"& 2- ,*'+$- '&$7)"!( "-#& ., 09!-& 08 2/.($!($ 0!- !.1+- ., 0$%"( "$-!!# "$+7$6 .(8$- $6!4 4$& :4 ,B9O ., "6$/"-( "$!"," "-#& ., *(!& ..$/ ,.!1. '/9$&, &+$#"( !*'+& 09!& !3!).1 0!!6$*., 0!3!#+" !$.!- ., 0!*(!& 08 ('1- 4.4 ,:/.

.&!!6(& "3$(1 ., &"-.,& '%4.,

!"/+2!!"('2%0!%')'"85!%6)4,'!"'/"#!1-

0!+$8. "$6$!,' "#61& !3!).1 08 "',+4"- "!*'+& "$.!1+& ., (%'-& ".38& &4)$"/ $3.$6,) 2!*$.%. 0!,3% 0!-$%" 2& —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

.2.0 %"7 ,1..7)&"6,"& ,(.4',!. !)'4 ,!(/) &'84 ,!(/ #$% 27.2.3 %"7 ,1..7)&"6,"& ,(.-'/& "$'&6-) &'84 !,!(/ #$% 26

,-#./ 3",/# !-' 3"$4+/ #&4"6# %'/1% &, -#./ 5",/ #0 31.0402 0"11 ,.,-. ,$4' 2/ !6'4% 4!.4)2( 0$%6 $4' !../ 2+$4( .(5",/ #0 2!!61 %2.&.) (2003) 7.0 (1)%6 3"+

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

."'$,#"& 3',- '"4( 2$!1. 0!6"!6 #9(& #$%. 2 *7 !+. $6"!6, "$6$!,'& .0!%!!6 0!!)'4.`` .̀moc.gov.il/moc/doadiis.dll/Serve/item/6nglish/#.#.&#.#\.#.html $4'

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!)(

&!9!$$.*. &!!6,& "$,'& #$% !+. ,0$!/ 2..'$3!,& "$,' #$% !+. !'$*$**7 3!84"/ !'$3!, 2/$ "$!'$94 $!3' "$6%" ,0!!'%7- &!9!$$.* !)$'1 .4',!( 0!.1$+ 70,$!3'.$

."!*'+ "$.1(( 0.$/ — 2!!$$.($ 0!.(/( &!9!$$.* !6, '#!1( '(1( $*., $(, ,"!'$(!)& &'$(%"& =61 4$& "$'%". %"+6, =7$6 0$%" 2!() "!'$(!)& &'$(%"& !$$#- #.% $%"+6 0!6,& 01 .23$ 384 0!.$38& 0!(!*'+$4$#& 23$ 384, 2$$!/- ,06-$4 71.0!9'/- "$1)-4( "$'%". (0!-!!# 0!$$# 2!($ 0!,3% 0!$$# =61( &-'$+'& !/ 2$1*. 2"!6 ,"$!$,' !3!).1 0!*.,6 06!4 =4$ ,"$!.&6- "$!$,' 06!4 .'(1( 08 0!!*'+ 0!-'$8 !3!).1 *.,6, 0$%" ,3%- &()!1 #' "!'$(!)& &'$(%"& "$1)-4( ,&&$(8 "!".,-- "$('$1-( 23$ 384 ., 0"$.!1+ &6!!+4"& .1$+( 0.$4

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

.!"3& :$6!%( 2&$ ("$6$1-$ 0!68) !'+7)"!()03#& :$6!%( 2& — 0!6, 4$& !$,!' "$1)-4( &*'+& 2!(. 5$%)'$#!- "$1)-4( &*'+& 2!( !9/'-& .3(&& "4 #+7. "!7!7(& &"$!'%4( 2!!31 &'!/- 4!& ,5$%)'$#!-. &6$+ "$,'& ',4/, :/():'3( "!,16 !$,!' "$1)-4( &*'+& ,"49 "-$1. .(0!3!-.". "$17& ,.,-.) "$'!,& 0$%"( ,&-8$3.) "$'!,& "#+7&. "!4'%4 &-)1 &4$' &6!4 "$,'& 0&(, 0!-$%"( ../

.(0!,!,#. 28$- '$!3 .,

%(1('1(!%")'-*/!%'*"4.!%'41(&0!*+2(!7#+-*4!,-#.,!12

"$!$,'$ &.,--&, :/( "4*("- 0$%" ., $"*'+&. &6!3-& ., &"-$'" 0!"!1. :$6!%& 0$%" ."$!*'+ "$-9$!. 0$#-& "4 "$6+- :/($ ,$( .$1+. "$#!7+- "$'%4 .&*'+&. 0!31$!- 06!4 0& !-,' 2+$4(, =4 ,"$($* "$-8<3 0!#+7- "$4!'(& "/'1-$ .'"$!( #&($- !'$(!)& 0!!+$4, "$.!1+ !-$%" !6, &.4 ,!.-'$+& '$,!-( ,&('34 "$4!'(& 0$%"($ 72(&6!3-& "-#& '%4. :$-7 #$%( 28$1 06!% &($%):$6!% ., 2$'#!1&

.106 %"7 ,1.67)&"/,"& ,'$3!,& "$,' #$% 2. &!!6,& "$,'& #$% %2.&.) 78 %"7 ,1..0)2","& ,$!3'$ &!9!$.*. &!6,& "$,'& #$% 70

.($!3'.$ &!9!$$.*. 3"+ ,%'&/1!% '+ &, -#./ #*'+"/ %'&/1!# !"4&!"+ %(&8* (8* 31364.8 5"8( $4' 71

.(1...) /07 (7)(6.28/ %"7 ,1.2.)*","& ,&($% 3$-!. #$% 72

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!)"

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— 0!6"!6 0!!'$(!)& 0!.$%&)!"(( ."!-,'& "$4!'(& "/'1- ., '$)!#" ',+4"- 2/$ ,=7$6 0$.," "'$-" (+"',) 0!!*'+ &4$+' !"$'!, — "!-,' &.4 0!-$%"( 78.("0!'#%- 2'#". &-$'" "-8$3) 0!6$, 0!'37B& "$1)-4( "0!'$" &8!76 08 4.4 ,"$.!1+& 1$)!(- &6!3-& ., &8!76. !$*!( #' 4. 4$+4 "4*(- &*'+&&

7..!"'(% 2$!$$,. "$(!$%-& 2- '(1( #+$7, "$'!,- &8!76 ., &4)$" &6!4 &'7%& "!6$*.,& "$.!1+& 0!"!1. ,3% !'$(!) :'$). &61- 2"-- "$!$,'& ., "$16-!&- "1($6 4.4 ,'"$! &&$(8 &-'( .!$.!( "$-$#-$ "$317- ., "!*'+& &%*(4& 4!& :/. &-8$3 .'(1( 0!!# &!& 4., &68& "-'( "$/9. "!%'94& &!!7$./$4& ., !"!-4 :'$) "4*(- &.4 "$-$#- ., &%*(4& ,,3% :'$) $&9 .0!3(4"- 0!.(%- ., '$'*& "$+#"& ., 2"$'(8"& %/$6. '"$! &&$(8 &4)$"& .$-!1 "$33$-"&. "$!'%4 &-)1 .1 .$*!.- &.,--& &16-6 ,')$6 4$& ',4/$

."$!*'+ &%*(4 "$'(% ., 2"$.!1+. %$"+ '"$6 0$%"&, 4!&

.176 %"7 ,1..2)3"6,"& ,!"/.-- "$4!'( %$*!( #$% 73 $%(&/. "&!*'#$'$!(. &#!#% 2!( — .4',!( &%$$'& "6!3-" 9'4)#'( &6+3 $4' &(%'&. 72

.(2002) 1/7 * 64+-& %'/1 !,"(- &, *'#.+ "7'* 3"'&% 5&8'* 6.12406 )"8( 08 $4' ,:$6!%& "/'1-( 0!'$& !-$.,". 77

.(12.8.200/ ,07'$+ 0'*) 6'&4)%& !&/'!% $9&,"1% ('+- " #*'+" '#&" " 6'&4)%& !&/'!% 9&,"1% !'+ &, "/'8 110/7402 5"8( $4' $9 "$%"+"&( 2$!3. !76

.(7.12.200/ ,07'$+ 0'*) %%&/8 %#$+%# %7.&-%)#'+( '(7$&, !+/ ,!$,!' "$1)-4( 4!& "$!$,'& ., "'"$6& "$('$1-& &.4 0!-$%"( 7/

..!1. 6( &6,- "/'1- ., &'$%7-" #.!+ !63 $4' "$4!'(& "/'1-( &*'+&& !7$+3( '"$! *'$+- 2$!3. 78

.(2006) 2// $ 3"0).& 64+- "=!$8, $4 !$4' :!.&" — "$4!'(& ,"#+7- &-'( 06!4 0!!'$(!)& 0!"$'!,& ',4/ 0!!*'+ 0!"$'!,. "$##9!& ., &#!-6!3. 7. Clayton +. Gillette2 C</(') C2/ *+ ,2A=(5 ,-*.(3(*'2 )' D6H<. P. L. ;6<. ##*( %08 $4'

.=#>>"?

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!))

!'*/%0!!"%'#"/!%6.3,!10

:4 $( .$1+. &/!,-- "!.&6-& "$,'& ',4/ 08 ",%'"- "$.!1+ 0$%" ., &*'+& "'(1&( &($., $9 &1+$" 0!"!1. ,2!$) '(/, !+/ .&!"$'!, '$(1( 0$.," "$(8. "'%$( 04"&( '$87 !(!)#" #,-/ .&6"-$ &"*!.,( 4)-6& 3!84". "$,'& 2- "$.!1+ !-$%" "!!(8 !3!).1 08 "$,1!&. &.$/! &9 8$7- &*'+& 0.$4 60.0!!#71 37+&$ %$$' !.$#!,. &'$-" 4.. '(1( $6"!6, 0!"$'!, '$(1( 2-)1 "$!$,'& !3!).1 2!',!-( 0!-$.,"

61.(!../& !$7!-& :'1-( $'$#-, 2$-!-( ,$-!, :$") "!+7/ "6!%(- "$!$.1( 0!/$'/ $!& 4. '(1(, 0!"$'!, '$(1( 0!-$.," "!!(8 ., &1+$"& 0!#'4+. &7!6/ '$(1( 0$.," "!!(8 &9 ../($ ,0!6$, 0!',#&( !$*!( !3!. &4( %'94& 0!6"!6& 0!"$'!, "'$-" ,'36 0$.,"& ($')!+).1 62.0!'%4 &(!(7 !(4,-.$ 0!!'$(!) 0!!*'+ &4$+' !"$'!, ., ',#&( $-/ ,.($#-& !'$(!)& *'36*7& 2- '"$! &&$(8 &-'( ,&&$(8 &./,&. "$37$-( "$!(!)#")5$% 0!3$-!. "$!6/$" =4 $4) 0!!'$(!) 0!.$%)!"((

.('"$! 0!%$6 0!46"( 0!3$-!. "'$-" '"$! &$(8 3$-!. '/, &(86 2&(,

"#'0"1,!02#(,!*/!#'23(!13

3$8!6( ."!'%7- "$.!1+- =% &!&, 0$%" !"'$7- 2+$4( &6-!7 "$!$,'& ., 2"$.!1+ &7!6/-, &.$1+ "6$/"- &8'3&( "$)-4- "$!$,'& ,(!)#"( '$7%- ., 0!46"( ,:/.

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

.&., &4.- &*'+& 4.. :4 ,#&($-& !'$(!)& !""'". &, %/"/)% !,8%# !"#*'+" %(&8* 5"(& ./6 3(* 86/6400 5"8( ,.,-. ,$4' 62 "!!(8 &''$1, &4%-& "$(#1( .(%,,.' 0'*4 2!!61 %2.&.) (2002) 210 (2)*6 3"+ ,%,,.' #$%& .;,3% %7$6< "$!'!1& "3$#+. 2$#!"( &#!#%( 4,$6& '37$& ,0!#'4+. &7!6/& !-3 (8)22. *7( '$-4& .1 =!7$& ,122 %"7 ,200/)9"7,"& ,(10. *7-) "$!'!1& "3$#+ 2$#!". :'3 ./( $4 '91 #$%( ,"$-$#- 0"$4. &7!6/ !-3 $(8!! 4...." &!+., &4'$& &3$#+. (&7!6/ !-3 — $9 &#7+() $&,./ 0$.," $4 .*!& ,7- ,&'84 ".*& "$1)-4( "$('. ,"'%4 !+.$ ,0!8!'% 0!'#-( '$-4/ "$-$#-. &7!6/ !-3 "$(8. &!'!1. '!"&. ',& !4,' 0.$4$

.""76/& ., &(!(7& "68&$ 0!6+& "31$ '$,!4( 1(#, 0!../

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!)*

0!-$7'+ '$(1( 0$.," "$($8 "$!$,' ',4/ ,.,-. .!'$(!)& (%'-. 08 0!!'%7- 0!*(!& :/- &4)$"/ .!'$(!)& (%'-& ., &*'+& &,1-. "$1)(- 2& ,"$)$%)!*., !(8).1 0!-'$8 ., 0&!"$+31&$ 0&!"$.4,- !+).1 ,'"!& 2!( ,1(#6 !'$(!)& (%'-& ., $($)!1 ., 2"()& "',+4"- ',4/ ,:/. &-$3( .0!('& "$,'( 0$7'+ '$(1( 0.,. 0!.$/!, (%'-& ., "!#.% &*'+& ",%'"- ,"!+7/ &'$-" 386/ :$6!% "$37$-( "$!$7%$ "$-$7'+

63.#$,& 2$686- ., $"$('$1-- =% &!& 2/. 03$# ',4 ,'+7&)"!( ., !'$(!)&

"/"*/,!#5$(,!%'41(&0!!""#'0"1!!"+"6.%!"'*"(!1*/

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

.$*#+)&3 !'$(!)& :'1-&

,-#.,*!%"%#'4(,!,/"$,!%$

',4 ,"$!6!3- ., 2!!61 $&9, &"!!& &*'+&& "1+$"( 2$!3. "!"'$7-& 4)$-&)"3$#6 "1+$"( !*+,-& #$7!1& 0)-*)& :/. 04"&( .$( $"$('1"& "4 0)-). :!') *+,-& "(!!%-& &1+$"/ &*'+&& ., "!"*!, &7!+"- .!3(&. 62,"$.(8& ., "0!!>4". &*'+&& "1+$" &6$3!6 $(, "&9'"& 2+$4& "4 8!)! &9 #'+ .!'$(!)& *+,-& ., ",3$%- "$/'1!& &(!,%$ &-.,& 2$1C*& "4 =$,%. "6-).1 ,!"'$7-& !'$(!)& *+,-& "'87-( &*'+&&

.,3%-

%'..'#!%'*0$,!#,-#.,,!%'*'0$!1*

$*(!&- 2&) &*'+&& "$.$(8 ., &!8$7( !.4',!& *+,-& ., "!"'$7-& $"3-1 ,..// &6!4 "-!$7- "$.!1+ *!'+&. 04 &*.%&&, &"!!& (*+$,& ., $*(!&- 2&$ ##$%-& ., 2!$&!9- $1(6 &*'+& "$*.%& .1 $.%$&, "$*1-& "$.(8&& ."$!*+,- "$.4, "''$1-

"!'%7- "$.!1+ '$7!4 #$% "1)& $4' &9 8$7- "$.!1+ '$74. "6$</-& "!*'+ #$% "1)&. 63..2 "76/& %"& ,200/)9"7,"& ,'+7 !"((

,5&('&8 &, 3"#+&'" !""'". 223483 4"1( #'( *+$,& ., $6!3)#7+- &.$4, $9 &'$+*- 62.(1.87) 127 ,113 (1)*. 3"+

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!)>

*'$+-/ ,0!6!$1 0!-'$8 !6+- "$66$8"& $4 0!6!!61 3$8!6 2$8/ ,"$!+!)+7 "$!1( .,.:,-&(

!"!#$%!!&"'()"*!'+!,-$."!/$#*!#,$

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

6/.",3$%- &6!%( "(!!%- &*'+&& .4 $9 "$7%!!"& ,0!#&($- 0!!"'(% 0!"$'!,.

'0*1.0!!$"#$%!2$(#3!#4$

"'87-- "8'$%/ "!#71 "6$/"-( "$!$,'& ., "$.!1+ &(,%6 0!-!$7- 0!'#-(

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— 034 "$!$/9( "18$+& — "!#,-& "$.!1+&, 386 ,36/ (2)46 3"+ ,'7&*% '+ &, #*'+"/ !&.0+%% "#%,- !$+# 1/174./ 5"8(

.(1../).37 ,"& .!1. $4' 66

*+,-& ../):'3( !/ !64 =4 !"'(7 ,'"$! ".(8$- &"!!& &*'+&& "1+$" ',4/ ,'(1( 6/ "$.4,( #' 3#-"&. 4.4 ,*!'+&. &*.%&& 0)1 .1 "$.(8& .!*&. '$-4 $6!4 !"#$%& Daphne BarakU6reV2 D*'3/(/2/(*'&= 1(6(/&/(*'3 %$4' .&*'+&& "$4)$" 26!!61, *' ,-(.&/(0&/(*' (' @3-&$=2 IS;A6LI ;6+9;OS O9 OH6 X< IHO6;HAOI9HAL C9HG;6SS 9Y

./ ,"& .!1. ,"&*'+& ., 23!1( 034 "$!$/9" 9'4)#'( (C9M+A;AOI<6 LA[ '#) =#>>>? 3$1 0!',+4- 06!4 &*'+&& "1+$" ., 0!,3%& 0!7$+3& ,'-4-& :,-&( '(7$-, !+/ "$!6!3-& 0$%"- "$.4, #' 4.4 ,"$!*+,- "$.4, "''$1- &6!4 &*'+&&, &,!8( #$(3.

."!././&

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!*\

2$'#1 .1 :-"7&. "$',+4& ,"49 01 ..&6>-& "$!#$% 2$'#1. "38$6-/ 2/.$ ,2&!"$!$/-7 "$!$,'& ., 2&!"$!$/-7 "'38&( 3$4- &!$." &*'+&& ".(8&. !1)-4/ .&6>-& "$!#$% 01*- &*'+& "$-9$! $.7+6 "!7%! 0!8!'% 0!'#-( #', 4!& &4)$"& ."-!!#& &#!#%( ,0!-7'+-. '$3!, 2-9 '$/-. &.$/! &6!4 '$3!,& "$,', #7+6 ,.,-. ,:/ .&9 !.-'$+):'3( ,"49 01 68.#$% !+).1 &., &/-7&& !-$%"- "8'$% $9 "!'%7- "$.!1+, '%4-

(,%6 4. 0!!6$*., 0!+$8 !3!).1 "!'%7-)2!1- $4 "!'%7- "$.!1+ ., %$"!+ ,../ 06!4 0!6$,& &.,--& !3',-, '!/9&. ,! &9 ',#&( .0!.1$+ 0& $%$/-, #$%. 38$6-/ :/ .1 =7$6 6..0&- 3%4 ./ ., 0!#!$3-& "$.!1+& !-$%" "4 '!38-& #$% %$/- 0!.1$+ "$!.&6- "$!$,' !3!).1 "!#$, "$.!1+ ., %$"!+ !(8. "!6'!"- &,!8 *+,-&)"!( 5-!4 &7!6/ '$(1( 0$.," "!!(8 ., ',#&( ,.,-. — &.!8'& 2"$.!1+ .1 "+7$"!- $9 ',4/ /0.'!1& !-$%"( 0!.1$+& 0!.!8'& 0!!'$(!)& 0!68. "+7$"/ &6(6 ',4 !'$(!) #'4+. ',#&( $-/ ,0$.,"( 0!"$'!, "#+7& ., "$',+4. !$*!( "6"$6 &-)1 &#!#%& 0!"!1. 0!'#-( /1.0!+7$6 '$*!, !"$'!, "!!6# "$1)-4( &'*,-& !3!).1 0!1$'!4 "%*(4 .,

33/ (2)4- 3"+ ,!&/'!%& 9&,"1% '+ &, #*'+"/ 3""-&"% 3",&!".% (&8"* /7/482 5"8( 68.(1.8/)

%(1.61) 2002 ,1.8. $* 3"+ ,%'&/1!% '+ &, '#"- 311460 5"8(( 2-7$9 *+$,& !'(3/ 6. '7$4$ 0!-!!$7- 0!3!#+" &. &)#-& — &3$1" $4 #$% — :-7- !+).1 &-#$& 4. &6!3-&" &!& 04 ,&.4,& ''$1"&. &.$.1 !6$.+ &6!3- 3($1 ., $!,1- !(8. .0!'%4 4.-. &!.1 "8'$% 4&", .$/! 08 &#7!1 ...$"$/-7 "'87-- 8'% 04 $4 &,1 ',4 "4 "$,1. :-7$- 06!4, &6!3-& ., &!"$%$/ '38- 4. :4 ,'%4 3!84" $4 ,&!'!1 ,&'(% ., &!"$%$/ '38-

".0!.(8$-$ 0!'38$- &-9$!& 2- 4!(&. 2"!6 "+7$6 &-8$3 .62 ,"& .!1. ,%,,.' 0'*4 2!!61( &6$3!6 $9 &-8$3 /0 $4' .&#!7+( "!#$%/ &',$4 $9 &-9$! ."0,$ 3!" "'87-( 0$.,"( "+7$6 &%)6& ',+4. .(1..2) 373 (3)%- 3"+ ,%'&/8#& %*&+# 5&'$"2% !&+' $#3+& ("# &, 6'4&% 73.24.2 5"8( "$$,&. 2!!61- ."!'$(!) "-$1'" .,( 0$.,"( &%)6&& &.*$( '(3 ., $+$7( ,"49 01 &,!8. — "$!$,' ., 2&!"$76/&. 7%!( ,$6!!&3 — 0!"$'!, "'!/-. 7%!( $9 "!6'!"- &,!8 ., "$!+7/& 2&!"$4)$&( "$18$6& "$!$/-7 ., 2,$'!+. 7%!( &)-$4, 3$4- "!6#$$3& %(&/. "-$)%& '$+% #. %,&--% &, #*'+"/ 3&(* (&( 58- .67/403 4"1 $4' ."$!$,'

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

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!*#

&,1!" $9, :/ .1 &3+#&( #' &#!7+& &#+"7& ,&#!#%( &'37$& 0$.,"& "!!(8 0&(,/2.&/!-7-& &#!#%( $1(#6, 0!46". 04"&(

!3!).1 0!!31.( "$6$!/9 "#61& !/ 1(#6 .&6>-& "$!#$% 2$'#1. 04"&( ,:/ .1 =7$6 ,+$%( 0"1!8+ .,() :/. "!#$% &/-7& "-!!# 0&(, 0!'#-( #' &,1!" "$!$,'& ',4/ &!1( &$$&- &6!4 "$!31.( "$!$/9 "#61&, &13& &#!7+( &1($& &.!%" /3.(#$7!1& 9'/- ., ',#&( 08 !/ 1(#6 :,-&( :4 /2,"$!$6-39& 2$!$$, .1 &'!-, :$" "!,16 4!&

/7.#$%( &/-7& 4.. "$!31.( "$!$/9 "". ',+4)!4

5"")(6!5"6$7'!0'"-,!"47'!!$'470!#7$

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

/8.0!!1$)!()0!!6/* 0!6!!61( &.4 0!-'$8( 4.$ ,!"#$% 2$'#!1/ =4 !#.% 2+$4( (,%!&. .$/! 0!!*'+ 0!-'$8. &.!)4 386 ../& "$!$/-7 ".!)4 !/ 1($# &.,--& %3$7!)#$%, :/( (,%"&( ,"!.&6- &6!'*#$3/ #'

!4,$6 0!1$'!4 2!(. %$$' "'*-. 06!4, 0!1$'!4 2!($ ("$68+& "-8$3 ,!'$(!)& '$,!-( .%$$'

%7.&-% &, %/"/)% !,8%# !"#*'+" %(&8* " 5"(& ./6 3(* 83/7403 5"8(( ,.,-. ,:/ /2 &7!6/( 0$.," "!!(8 386 &'!"1& &77("& ,(2003) ./ (2)%6 3"+ ,#-'$% ;&1 !"'&2*% "$-$#- "'37& #$%. (4)6 *7( 0!1$(#& 0!46". 04"&( &",16 4. 4!&, :/ .1 0! =$%. &'$7- &( 2$3. "$/-7& !/ 1(#6, '%4. ,&+$8. &6$3!6 4. $9 &'!"1 .1.62)3"/,"& ,&)%'

.0!!.&6- 0!6!!61. *+,-&)"!(..(1.7/) 12.0 4! 3"+ ,'7&*% '+ &, -#./ *+-& #$"- !&",* 12747/ 5"8( ,.,-. ,$4' /3.(1./3) 30. (1)9/ 3"+ ,#*'+" !'6+- #+ !&",0% '&(- +*' &, '&7 33/4/2 5"8( $4' /2

$%""+.!%& %$*#-% "#./ !&(1*!% /32488 5"8(( &1(#6 &9 2!!61( "!6/31& &/.&& /7.(1.8.) 667 (3)8- 3"+ ,5&#0+* !""'". &, 5&#0+*

.(1.82) 73/ (2)$. 3"+ ,(&(+* !""'". +*' &, 8,"#4,% 3.482 5"8( /6 ##$%-& 1(# 4. 3$1 ./ ,2($-/ ,4$&$" %2!3&)#7+ "4 ("/, '8-, *+$,& ., $6$,.( //

.721 *-1( ,0, "."'%4 "$,'$+- ,//6 (6)*6 3"+ ,:"/&'&/ &, #*'+" !,"(- 2877402 +"1 (3. ,"& .!1. ,:"/&4"#"4 2!!61 /8

.(:"/&'&/ 2!!61 %2.&.) (2007) 833

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!*&

&.$%"& =#!&. (. 0!,. ,! 0.$4 /..'$(!) 3($1. ,.!8'& &'#-( ,"$!&. &/!') ', ., (0!',. $6"!6, "$!$/-7 ".!)4 .1 #' &.% 4!& ,"!,4' %"!"#$%& &4'$&& ., 0)-$)-&

80.""1-",- "'%4 &6$$/ 04" &6-- &!!*7 ., "$',+4. &+$+/ 4!& ,"!6,

5"(8!5".($7'!!$"$98!!(430!"47'!!$'470!#/$

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

.178 %"7 ,&.,--& %3$7!)#$%. (()33 *7 /..&.,--& %3$7!)#$%. (&)33 *7 80

,$-!, &,16 &9 2$686-( .(1..3) 138 4- 6"#0'4% "&*'+&&$ *(&9 "!!6-*" 2$-84 ./!- $4' 81.(&'(%& =!#,". 6.20 *7) -"1( .4',!. 0!.#!-!/ "*'+&(

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— *+6. #$#!9& "!( "'(%( &6!3-.)9"7," ,(-"1( *+6. #$#!9 !"( "'(%( &6!3-. 0!!6$!% 0!7'*6!4 .1 &9'/&) "$!".,--&

.710 ""# ,200/ ,4' ,"'$,#"& #$%. 32 *7 !+. .0!!+!)+7 0!#$%( &9 0$%"( 0!'37B& 0!-!!# :/ .1 =7$6 ,!6$!% "$'!, 4$& $( *'$+-& #9( "$'!, !/ $)( 1$(#. 0!4,' "'$,#"& ',$ &.,--& !6$!% "$'!, "1!(#) #9(& $) $4' .$( "$.1(& !(8. "$6$, "$.(8& 1$(#. :/. :,-&($ #$% ,:/ .1 =7$6 .1../)9"6,"& ,(-"1( "'$,#". "!.4',!& &'(%& ,"#9(" "6"$6,

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!*'

&6!4 0!6!$1 0!-'$8 !3!).1 2!1#'#- ",!/' ., &!1(& 83.3%$!- #$%( ##%6 0!!6$%*( .4',! !1#'#-( "$.1(& "'(1& '$7!4 ., 2$'#!1. "$3$& ,&"1 "1. ,&#!#%. ",'36

82.0!!*'+ 0!-'$8 !3!.

%')"$,'!%'"')(+5,!:'"''/!#,-#.,,!7"*,!1.

8(9.0!!4$%$!!$"$*./80!2$"$$+!#,$

"$.4,( 3#-"& ,!'$(!)& *+,-& ., $*(-)"3$#6- ,&*'+&& "1+$"( !"'$7-& #$7!1& ($')!+).1) *+,-& 3)!/ &"!!& &6$3!6, "!'#!1& &.4,& ,&9 ',#&( ."$!$6-39& 2$!$$, ., $)#$! &*'+&& 23!1( $%"+6, "$,3%& "$!$6-39&& !/ %!*(- (!.&6-& *+,-& '$,!-( "!././& ".1$"& 0$7#- ., *(!&& 2- 2&$ 2$!$$,. "$/9& ., *(!&& 2- 2& — !(*!- 2+$4( 7/6 '$(1( '"$!( ($*& '!%-& "4 1!)!, &6$#. &'!/- "$1)-4( ,.,-.) &*'+&& ., ., 4,$6( "$',#"& "$*.%&, :/( &'/&& %/$6. #$9!% .(!# $9 &.4,( 2$!3& .(!".,-- 4$,-( .%& — 0!.$7+$ 0!'9 0!.$#!,- "$*.%& ".(#. !"$1-,- !$"!+ "$')$! &*'+&

87.&46&)"$($* ".(# .1 "77$(-& "$"!%,( &./$ 0!('$#-. 7%!( 0!6+

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— .4',!( 0$,' 3!84" 4$& 04 $4 ,.4',! (,$" $4 !.4',! %'94" &!&! 2$!,!'& .1( !/ =!17( '$-4/ "$6#"( ',& 1(#, '$1!,( ,2!+!#1( $4 2!',!-( ,$( &*!.,& !1)-4 18$6( "$!6,'+ "$.4, $6$3!6 '(1( .".4',! (,$" $4 !.4',! %'94 !3!( 0!#9%$- ,(8)%-6 #*'+" !&+(1 6372401 0"11( '$3!,& 0$%"( "$'(%( &*!.,& ",!'3 ., &"$1-,-.

.(#*'+" !&+(1 2!!61 %2.&.) (2001) ./ (2)$6 3"+ ,!'&+0!% '+ &, -#./ '"))5*)"*)"6( &*!.,& "'(1& "4 =!+/- #', ,"$%+ *'$+- '37& ..$/ ($!($ 0!- !3!84" #$%. /6 *7

.!.&6- '$,!4. '!37- #$%&, 3!84"(.1/2 %"7 ,2006)$"7,"& ,(0!!6$%*!( 0!7'*6!4 .1 &68&) 0!!6$%*!(& 0!3!84"& #$% 83

Joshua [eisman2 E$3/-(5/(*'3 *' /#$ ;5F2(3(/(*' %$$,& 0!'9. 2!1#'#- "'!/- ., &!8$7. 82.*+ 1&': A> ;=($'32 &* AM. J. C9M+. L. '> =#>*\?

SPSAH ;9S6UACf6;MAH2 C9;;P+OI9H AHD G9<6;HM6HO g CAPS6S2 %.,-. ,$4' 87.C9HS6hP6HC6S AHD ;6Y9;M '(i'* =#>>>?

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!*!

&4)#& ./, 4$& &9 0$%"( 2$!.1& *+,-&)"!( ., $"#!7+( 1(#6, !7!7(& 2$'#!1& "$',#"& 0$, ,..// ,2/).1 ."$$, "$!$6-39& .1 "77$(- "$!&. &/!') '$(!) !7/6 ., 2$'#!1 86."'%4 :'3( 2!($ %$"+ 9'/- "$1)-4( 2!( ,"$'%" 4.. "$,1!&. &.$/! &6!4 2+$4( 8/.1..2 "6,( 0!9'/-& "($% #$% ., $"#!#% 01 !'$*$**7 2$8!1($ #$9!%( &/9 &9 ., $-$7'+ "$1)-4( =4 0!"!1. ,&*'+& !/!.&( "$!$6-39& 2$!$$, 0!!#. &($%& ,!../ !+/ ,4,$6& ., '%4 *(!& ./- '"$! ,&#!7+($ &#!#%( "(%'6 "$7%!!"&( &"/9 ,9'/-

.:,-&( 2$!3& 0!83-, &6!4 "$!$6-39& 2$!$$, ., &.4,& — "0). "4&* !#./ !&#".4 9'&7# !&'/1 !-0% .1 ,&"$1)-4( .$1+.$ &'(% 0!#&. "'%$( "$,'& 0&(, 0!()-( ../):'3( "''$1"- "-$1. 88."!-!*!8. &+31&. (,%6 $9 &'(% 01 "$,'& ., &.$1+&)=$"!,, 0$,- *'$+!, !+/ ,&*'+& ., 0!1+$-/ $&$9, 0!'%4& 0!()-& ($'( "''$1"- 4!& ,"49

.2.&. "$*.,6& "$'(%( "$!6- ., 2"'!/- :!.& — !"'&/"7 !&#.// !&'/1 #+ %'"$- .2 ='% &.% $9 &($% ."!../& 2$!$$,& "($%. ,!6$'#1 2+$4( ,=$+/ "$!$,' !3!).1

61/64.3 5"8( ((1..2) /.3 (2)$- 3"+ ,5&$"+%& "&,"/% '+ &, 2'&4 70234.1 5"8( '#!1( $4' 86 3"+ ,#*'+" ".0'0- #%,"- &, -#./ !&/+""!%# !"*#01 !"4&!"+ %(&8* " ./01 3"0"#* '(/ "$!$6-39& 2$!$$, ., 2$'#!1( &'/&. "$3$7!& "4 %!6& #'( *+$,& .(1..2) 178 (2)%- '#!1( $4' ."!"#!7+ "#$.%-( &!$6, $9 &3-1 &"!!& "1 &"$4( :4 ,0!-3$# 2!3)!#7+ &-/( ((1.80) /2. (3)3. 3"+ ,#*'+" !#+-- &, #*'+"/ 3",&/%& 3",#/0% 2$'- 8204/. 5"8(

.(1.80) 221 (1)&. 3"+ ,'&("+% !&+' &, -#./ /%2 "4( 38.480 5"8(.(0!9'/-& "($% #$% %2.&.) 112 %"7 ,1..2)("6,"& ,0!9'/-& "($% #$% 8/

"($%- ,.!8'& &'#-( ,"$'$*+ &"*!.,(, &'(%& 2!(. "$,'& 2!( "$!$',#"&& ,&9 01*- 88 %2.&.) 826 ""# ,1..3)8"6,"& ,0!9'/- "($% "$6#". (7)3 *#" !+. ,.,-. ,:/ .9'/- 9'/-& "($%- &'$*+ "!".,-- &'(% 01 &.,--& ., "$',#"& ,(0!9'/-& "($% "$6#" &-!#&, &.,--& "*.%& !+ .1$ &., 3$7!& !/-7- !+ .1 &$$&- "!".,--& &'(%&" ',4/ 1$)!( 0,. "!,16 "$',#"&&$ &.,--& ., "$'38$-$ "$'!,! "$.*- 1$)!(. 1$'9 ,&"$4 "$'!, "#+7- $4 ,2!3 !+. &!.1 $.*$&, "$'!, $4 &.*- "1)(- &'(%& — $4 (&.4 "$.*- 0!!#"&($) "&.4 "$'!, $4 &.*- 1$)!( 0,. "!,16 "$',#"&&$ ,'$(!). 0!!6$!% :')- $4

.($9 &6#"( 0!*'$+-& 0!+7$6& 0!46"& =$#". ',+4 &!&! ,0!-!!#"- 06!4 9'/- "($%- '$*+. 0!46"& 0&(, 0!'#-( ,"49 01 (&.") !&*"'/ "!&'"+ 5!- 70124./ 5"8( ,.,-. ,$4' .9'/- 4.. ',#"&. &*.%&& "4 386 &'!"1& &,8$& &9 &'#-( .(1..8) 2. (1)(6 3"+ ,!&*"'/% ('+- &, -#./ %1&&'& "$4!'( !"$'!, 21-. &3$84&" &"$-1& "$1)-4( '+7&)!"(( "$4!'(& !"$'!, "#+7& 0$,- ,9'/- 0!!#. (!!% $6!4 4$& !/ 21* "$4!'(& 3',- .9'/- :'16, !.(- "'$(!)& &., .&6-& 31$$( ,&6!3-& (!)#"- 4( &(!)#"- 67: — &/$'4& $3!/ ".1$+ &"$-1&,).1)=4 ."$4!'(& "/'1-( 0!3($1 &#!71- 4!&$ ,'(1($ &$$&( 3',-& ., 0!3($1 0!6&/-

.9'/-- '$*+. 0!46"& $-!!#"& 4., 0$,- ,&'!"1& &.(#"& 2/)!+

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!*(

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

.&#!7+( $1(#6, "$6$'#1& %$/- !94 ,&#!#% %$/- 4. 04 — 2/ !1#'#-( "$#71. 18$6& ./( —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

.2.%$"+ ., "$',#"&& ',4/ 08 &.$1 0!'/$%& "'!%(( "$!$6-39& 2$!$$, ., &.4,& .*$6, '%4 3!84" $4 "!+$"!, &3$84 "-8$3 ,:$$"- 0'$8 "$1)-4( "!,16 .&6>-& !/ 1(#6 /25*(.0 2!!61( .1#'#& .1 0!(,!!"-& "'!%( ., 3!#+"& "4 $-)1 .1 &.+- "$!6!3- 8!&6- ',4 3!84" 01 &.$1+ =",.- 1$6- .4',! !1#'#- .&6>-

.2.0!'/$%& "'!%(( ., &"$1-,- ,2$!.1& *+,-&)"!( ., &,3%& $"#!7+ !+).1 !/ =!7$&. ($,% ,0!*'+ 2!( 2$!$$, 0!!#. &($%& #' &6!4 .4',! !1#'#- .$&!6( 2$!$$, 0!!#. &($%&

."0!!,%$- 0!7/6" 0& "2!($*" ,302 %"7 ,1.81)4"-,"& ,"$6,'+& #$%. 3 *7 !+. 8. 2"- &6!!61, &#7!1( "$',#"&" ./ 9'/- "($%- "'*$+ 0!9'/-& "($% "$6#". (12)3 *#" .0 "$'!!6 ., &,!/' $4 &'!/- ,0!!4#6( 0!"$'!, ".(# ,0!+7/ "1#,& ,$".(# $4 !4',4.""49 ',!4 :!-7& 4$&, !- $4 !../& (,%&, 3(.($ (2$&& #$,( "$'%4 "$.$1+ $4 ,:'1

.86 ,"& .!1. $4' .1 ,2$!.1& *+,-&)"!( ., $"#!7+ !+).1 !/ 2!!). ,! .0!9'/-& "($% "$6#". 27 *#" $4' .2 ".0'0- #%,"- &, !#"* !""'". 12224.7 4"1 $4' .&($% 4.$ ,"$,' 0!(,%6 &.4 0!'D*E

.(1..7) /2. (3)*- 3"+ ,#*'+".(2000) 278 (1)36 3"+ ,#*'+" ".0'0- #%,"- &, 5*(.0 66.84.7 5"8( .3

&"3-1 !/ #7+6 0!(,$-& "$(%'& "'87-( 0!(,!!"-& "'!%(. 18$6& ./( !/ =!7$&. 2"!6 .2 $3""!&'*/ 3.624./ 4"1 $4' .3(.( &).-& '38( 4!& 0!3-1$-& !(8. "!+$"!,& &3$84& .,

.(1..8) 612 (2)(6 3"+ ,('* &, -#./ !"4&!"+ !"*#01 !&/+""!%# 3"(/&. /+&-

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!*"

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

."$!","( "$!*'+ "$1#,&( 0!/$'/ 3!+#&. &($%& — ':&1%'&0"-( 3""6'4 3",#/0 !&.7-*/ !",&6#+ !&#".4 .&7"/ .2 '$'( !$*!( !3!. &4( !.-'$+ 9'/- 0!!#. =4$ 0!',#"- 2!( "$!$6-39& 2$!$$, .1 $'#!1( ."$!+!)+7 "$.*- 1$)!( :'$). 0!!6$)!% 0!6.(# 01 "$',#"& ., ',#&( 2!!61/ &#!7+( &6$3!6 0!!6$)!% 0!-'$8 ., 01$)!(. "$3$(1 "'!7- ,'(3 .,

./.3(.( "!././ "$.!1! ., "$.4, "''$1- $( &1'/&&, !(8. "$(!!%-& "$,!'3& ./ — 3""6'4 3"-2" !&.7-*/ !&"'&/"7 !&"!+! !-0% .7 "$.1($ "$(/'$-& "$!$',#"&. 7%!( "4, '"!( =4 "$.% 0!9'/- 0$7'+$ 2$!$$, ',#( 08 ,:/. 04"&( ."$!"," "-#& ., 0$%"( "(%'6& "!+7/& "$1-,-& !/ 2!!). !$4' ,"49 01 .8.0!9'/- 07'+. "$8&$6 "$!$,'& B9O 8$7- 0!*#!$'+. ., (/'$-& 2!!+$4. &-4"& ., 4.- :!.&" $'(1 0'* 0!!'$(!)& 0!9'/-& !6!3 0$#- ,! ,../( 04 ,&3!- $9!4( '&($& 0'* ,.,-. ,:/ .$9 "6$/"-( "$!$',#"&&

3$1!!& !$6!, 4,$6( "$*.%&&, &61*( &3#-"& "!%'9-& "!*'#$-3& ",#& ., &"'!"1 .7 ., "!7%! 2*# %.+. 0!!'$(!) 0!(4,- ., 0&!"$'!+ "4 $#.!% "!4.#%& 1#'#& ., $,8$&, "$+7$6 "$'!"1 $$."& $9 &'!"1. .0!!"'(%& 0!'1+& "(%'&. $-'" :/($ ,&'(%&

.1(*& "68&. &'(%& "-8$3 ,0!+7$6 0!+$8$ "$)$(# !3!).1 3"+ ,!&"-&*#% !&"!+!% '+ &, "6'0&-(% 1"+% 5.-# $+(1 1"+ !!&-. 222400 5"8( .6 !1#'#- ")1$- ., &!"$*.%& ,2!3&)#7+ !+).1 .(+(1 1"+ 2!!61 %2.&.) (2002) 27 (6)$6 !+!)+7 2+$4($ ,!"#$.%& #3)& 2$'#1( $(,%"& 4. 2&, '%4- "$-$8+ $!& &9 4,$6( .4',! $(!*!& &.4 "$*.%& ..4',!( &!!7$./$4& ., 0!6$, 0!#.% .1 2&., &1+,&( — '"$! "$)$(# 2$(,%).1 (0!!%/$6& 0!'/$%&) "$-!$7- "$)$(# 01 "!.6$!)'$+$'+)4. &'$)( 2!1#'#-& "$'$#- "4 '$-,. !$4' &!& $!+).1,) $"$../( !'$(!)& 7'*6!4&$ "$'%4

.11 ,"& .!1. ,9'4)#'( 3$1 $4' .(&.4 0!'!36 "$'$#-( '"!),$-!,- 16-!&.$ ,3!"1. ',4/ !6$)!% 1$)!(. &3$(1 '$7-. &*.%&- &( '$9%. &.$/! "$,' !/ #7+6 ,04"&( ./ 1014/2 5"8( $4' .$-)1 !'$(!)& .&6>-& "'87-( '"$! :$-6 '!%-( "$,1!&. &.$/! &3$(1&

.(1./2) 22. (2)%/ 3"+ ,5&16"/% '+ &, -#./ /8,/ 1&!"4& "&,"/ .3$- $4 >?@ ., .3$-& !+. "$!"," "-#& ., 4,$6( 0!9'/- 26!!61, "$!$6!!3"&. .8 2!!61 ((12.1.2000 ,07'$+ 4.) ./+ '*/ !""'". &, '+#/( 3&'%"- 71614.. 4"1 $4' ,&-$3

.2/ ,"& .!1. ,5",/ #0

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!*)

!$(!'($ &&$(8 "!6/* "$(/'$-( 0!6!!+4"-, 0!9'/-( '"$! &&$(8 "$,!-8 "8'3....0!*'+

"$!$6-39& 2$!$$, .1 3!+#&. &($%& — 3"+(1 3"-&1!/ !"6'4 !&#".4 #+ "&+"' .6 0!9'/-& "($% #$% .0!,3% 0!-$%"( "$.!1+. "$6$!,' "#$.% ., ',#&( 08 &.% ,"$6$!,' "#61&- .!3(&. ,"$!$,' ., "!9$% "$',#"& ., 0!()-( #' 06-$4 .% "$!&. .$/!,) "$!$6-39& 2$!$$, ., !"#!7+& 2$'#!1. 0!+$+/ !$,!'& !/!.& 0.$4 .1 &.%, "!+!)+7& &#!#%& ,:/. '(1- 100.("'%4 :'3( $4 9'/- ., :'3( 0,8$-

101.9'/- "/!'1 26!!61, "$4'$& 0!(' 0!'#-( "..$/ 0!,3%& 0!-$%"( "$.!1+& ., &!-$%" "(%'& —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

102.&$$,& "$6-39&& "($%- "$-3$# "$!$',#"& $'*+, ,0!9'/-& "''$1- &6!4 0!"$'!, '$(1( 0$.," "!!(8 ., &!8$7& — 3&#+!/ 3"!&'"+ !04)% .8 "!!(8 ,"$!$,'& ., "'%4 "$.!1+ ./ $-/ ,"49 01 .0!9'/-& !6!3 0$%"- "$.4,

103.0!!6$!$$, 0!../ !+).1 "$,1!&. &'$-4 0!-$.,"&

2!!61 $4' .&9 8$7- 9'/-( "$'&(&& :!.& ., $+#!&. 18$6& ./( ,.,-. ,&''$1"& $9 &.4, ...0, ,5",/ #0

&, -#./ #*'6"- 78/14.2 5"8( $4' 4$(!! "$6$!,' ., &.'8& "$1)-4( 2$!$$, "%*(&. 100.(1..3) 721 (1)9- 3"+ ,%""+.!%& '1)-% '+

#$%. 20 *7 ,"49 "-$1. .9'/- "($% 1($# $!3'.$ &!9!$$.*. &!!6,& "$,'& #$%. 38 *7 101 "'$,#"& 0$%"( 0!9'/- 4,$6( &#!7+. .&9 2!!61( "13).$#!, &6#- (27 *7- 2$#!") #9(& +(1% "#*'+"% :&'.% " 3&' 0"4* &, -#./ 5(. "'&("+ 76/8401 0"11 ,.,-. ,$4'

.82 ,"& .!1. ,#*'+" !&+(1 2!!61 ((2001) .1/ (1)$6 3"+ ,-#./ '0 2/214.2 5"8( $4' .108 %"7 ,1..3)8"6,"& ,(3 *7- 2$#!") 0!9'/-& "($% #$%. 2 *7 102

.(1..7) 2. (1)46 3"+ ,!&*"'/% '+ &, -#./ %*&4' "!&'+ ,:/ .!"$&- 2$!$$,. !.-'$+ 2$!$$, 2!( &6%(& 26!!61, "$.4, ''$1"&. "$!$,1 &9 ',#&( 103 ,3%& !'$(!)& #'4+. &7!6/& '$(1( 0$.,"& ,62 ,"& .!1. ,%,,.' 0'*4 2!!61( ,.,-.

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!**

,!'$(!)& (%'-( 0$.,"( "$!$/9 &)#- "$,'& ',4/ — "'&/"7% /1'-% #+ '&1)- .. #$% !6+. 08 ,:/. 04"&( ."$!$6-39& 2$!$$, ., 7!7( .1 "$,1!&. "(!!% $9 &4)#& ., 7!7( .1 "$,1!&. &'$-4 0$.,"( 0!-7'+-( &'!%(& !/ #7+6 0!9'/-& "($%

102."$'%" 0!-'$8 ',4/ ,&'$4/. — "+"#+% '28-% !&.7-*/ 3""'&/"7 3"("04! "&#"- .10 2$!$$, ".4, ,&!3!#+" "4 4.-. "$,'. 0!',+4-& 0!(4,- 0!-'$" 0!!*'+ "$,'. &46&)"($* ., !+$4 ,! &#61&., 0$,- ,"''$1"- &6!4 "$!$6-39&& 0!()- "13& .1 "$.1&. 2"!6 ,"49 01 .("$!#71 "$!$6-39& .1 "$'%"- .!3(&.) $9 "$6-39& .1 "$'%"&.$ "$,'& 01 &.$1+ =",. ,#(! 3%4 0'$8- '"$! 0&(,

.(0!!8$.$4!3!4 0!-1*- $4 &'#$! ., 0!-1*- ,.,-.)

5"*""*3!/$7"*!'+!($:",0$!!"!/4$3!!"!+!!%"'0*.0!;"'04!!$*"70!#4$

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

10..&( "$*.%&& ".(# !/!.&"(

.&'!(7 $9 &*.%&, '(7 *+,-&)"!( .&661' !(,$" 06!4, !-- #' &(86 &661'( //2 (3)9. 3"+ ,/"/*%#! !""'". +*' &, -#./ 6&#"+/ 3&)'4 " %-., 7/0482 5"8( 102

.(1.83) 212 (7)%- 3"+ ,!'&+0!% !'+ &, -#./ './/,( /%2 "&&0 6,&'&" .8/4.2 5"8( $4' 107

.(1..2).71 ,"& .!1. ,(8* 2!!61 ,.,-. ,$4' 106

3"+ ,%&0! 1!4 !""'". !7.&- &, %&0! 1!4 !""'"./ #(&$"#%# !.") 7314/. 5"8( $4' 10/.(1.80) 766 (2)3.

267 (2)&- 3"+ ,3"64+-% ('+- &, -#./ #*'+" )-)/)" 2024.0 5"8( ,.,-. ,$4' 108.*+,-&)!"( "/'1- ., ($,%-& 9'/-( #71 2!3&)#7+ .(1..0)

(3)*- 3"+ ,5&$"+%& "&,"/% ('+- $#*'+" !#+-- &, -#./ 5"'(%- 77/74.2 5"8( $4' 10..(1..7) 133

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!*>

!"-#.'(!!".'$!*4!2'6".,!1'

!*+,-& '*,-& ., $(!*. 7%!( "$!*+,- "$.4, "$''$1"- &*'+&& :!.& ., $-$!7( "$18$6& "$/.&& %$"!+ "$1)-4( $9 &.4,( &#71 &#!7+& ."*'+$-& "$.!1+& .1 .$%!, 0!!(!*.$8' 0!'37B& "1!(# "$1)-4( &-!1 &33$-"& &#!#%& $.!4$ ,0!!"$&-)$3 0!+$8(

."!*'+ "$.!1+ "-!!#"- 0&(, 0!6$, 0!!././ 0!-$%"( 0!.%,

5""!$0."$/!5"6$7!%!"!#":6!0"-'$7(!#,$

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

111.&-$3/$ !*7!.$+$6$-& &3-1- ,&'(%& "$!$.!1+ !(8. 3%$!-( "$!*6$$.' 0!!"$&-)$3 0!+$8. 18$6& ./( $%"+"&, "$/.&& $4 !'$(!) !+$4 !.1( 0!-$%"( 2& &.4 "$!$.!1+ 0!(' 0!'#-(, 0$,- ,&*'+& $'(1, "$3-1$- 2& ,!"$&-& '$,!-( ,2&( '-",&, !'$(!)& !+$4& .,( ."!'$(!) "$1-,- ,&.4 "$/.& ., 2".1+&( !,$# 0!!# ,"49 01 .0!!"$&-)$3& 0!+$8& !6!3 ., 0".$%". "$($%& ,2/)$-/ .!"$&-)$3/ =$8( &'/&. =7&)!46" 0&- &'!38& 0'* &#!7+&, 0$,- *+,-& ., 3$7!&)"$6$'#1 26!!61, ,3(.( "$!7!7( "$($% 2& &9 8$7- 0!+$8 .1 "$.%$-&

112."$!#$3#3$ $!*'+"- .!3(&. ,!'$(!)&

0#"#%!%$9.!!"'0*.!0"-'$7(!#4$

0!+$8 ., 0"$.!1+ .1 08)$-/ ,0!*'+$-& 0!+$8& ., 0"$.!1+ .1 =*$,& %$#!+& :.&-( .&#!#%( :/. $/-7$&, "$!.&6- "$!$,' !3!).1 &,16 ,0.$1-$ 94- 0!!*'+ $!&, &8'3&( &'(1 "!.&6-& &6!3-&$ ,0!+7$6 0!!(!*.$8' 0!+$8 .4',!( $-#$& &*'+&& "$6,

%2.&.) (1.8/) 22. (2)4- 3"+ ,-#./ #*'+"# #-+1% !'/1 &, ;( &'0"- /31486 5"8( 110.(;( &'0"- 2!!61

262 (2)$- 3"+ ,3&*/,6)0 &, #3"#+&'" !#"%0# *#+18 *+"(0 %'/1 2.24.1 4"1 $4' 111 './13( 3"-&#%"% !)'&/ "#.4- &, 5&* 32124.3 4"1 ((3&*/,6)0 2!!61 %2.&.) (1..2) (/ ,"& .!1. ,"0!!'$(!) 0!3!84"" 9'4)#'( $4' &(%'&. .(1..7) 1.6 (3)*- 3"+ ,-#./

./ ,"& .!1. ,"&*'+& ., 23!1( 034 "$!$/9" 9'4)#'( 2!!61( #'( *+$,& ., $6!3)#7+( &1(*6 2!3& !*'+ 2!(. 3$7!&)"$6$'#1 2!( $9 &6%(& 112

.263 *-1( ,110 ,"& .!1. ,;( &'0"-

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!>\

,'!-9 *+$,& '!(7&, !+/ 113.&.1-( 2$,4' 3!#+" ,! %$#!+. &(, "$.!1+ "6$/"-. %$#!+( &$$.- "$!&. &/!') 0!/')-$ 0!"$'!, #+7 ., 3!#+"& 2- &6!3-& "$#'+"&..." #,-. "$6-39& 2"$6 !,+$%& #$,& .!*'+& #,-& !3!).1 0!/')-$ 0!"$'!, "#+74 .1 #$, ., 0!46"( 4#$$3 ..."!%,&. .$.1 !././ %$/ 08 .(' !././ %$/ '$(). !*'+& ,!, 0$%"( &,3% "!(!*.$8' &#!#%. &-8$3 112."0!,.% .1 28&. &6!3-& ",'36 !,+$% .-,%& "'(% ., &*'+&& 117..-,%& #,- ., 0$%"& 2- 4!(&. 2"!6 &*'+&. "$!+!) $( #$%& ,"49 01 .#+$4( 2!!31 "!4'6 &6!4 ,&( &.,--& ., &!"$!6- "'!/- "$1)-4( ,&-)1 .-,% '$)!!. !$,!'& 2!( &6%(& !3!).1 0$%"( &*'+&& !/!.&". 7!7(& "4 %!6- ,3%& '$)!! !-'$8 ., "$.!1+. :'3& "4 &%"+, &6%(& — .-,%& "/.$& ., 0$%"( !$,!'& 2!(.

116.!1(*& 98& #,- "*'+&( &)-$4 &/.$&. '$)!!& 2!( &-$3 &3'+& .0!!4-)1

5""*$%)4$!5"".$,'!5":()*",!'3!0*70!5+'!0#"#%!#7$

.1( ., $"$&9 ".(8&( !3 2!4 ,'$(!). !6$!% 0$%"( "*'+$- "$.!1+ "-!!#"- ',4/ 2+$4 !(8. "$-!$7- "$4'$& "". "$,'& ., &%$/ "4 08 '-,. ($,% 4.4 ,&( "$!$/9&

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

64+- ""!*'+ "$.!1+ .1 !'$(!) %$#!+" '!-9 #%)! $4' "$!$,'& ., %$#!+& !3!#+". 113.(2007) 6/ ( 3"0).&

,627 (3)&6 3"+ ,1&6"/% #. !104-% &, #*'+"/ 1&6"/% "*-+ (&8"* //214.6 5"8( 112.(2001) 670

.(.-,%& #,- #$% %2.&.) 208 %"7 ,1..6)$"6,"& ,.-,%& #,- #$% 117 ('+-/ 64,% ","",. #. %,&--% &, !"#$%"&'($%)*$++"&$"&'!$" 7812400 5"8( $4' 116 "4 2$!.1& *+,-&)"!( .(!# 4. &9 &'#-( .(2001) 312 (2)&6 3"+ ,!&"-&*#% !&"!+!% #$% ##%6 :/. :,-&( .&/.$& "/'1- "$6(. &. '!"&. &,#!(, 98 "!6')! ., &"'!"1

.0!-$3 "$6$'#1 5-!4, ,2002)("7,"& ,!1(*& 98& #,-.&.,--& %3$7!)#$%. 3. *7 11/

..-,%& #,- #$%. 78 *7 ("'$,#"& #$%. &2—32 *7 118 "$'(%( "$.1(& "'(1& .1 "$.(8& ".*& ',+4- &9 '37B& ,82 ,"&( .!1. 2!$) '(/, !+/ 11. 06!4, 0!'%4 "$.(8-$ 0!8!!7 08 &*'+&( "$'(% .1 .!*&. ',+4- 4$& ,"49 01 ."$*'+$- &6!3-. !6$!% 7'*6!4 .1 &9'/&) "$!".,--& "$'(%& $) ,.,-. ,:/ ."$.1(& ".4,( 0!18$6 .1 .4" !/ ($). 3 *7() 1($# ,178 ""# ,2007)&"7," ,(-"1( .4',!. '!$$4 !(!"6 .1 .4(

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!>#

)$"7," ,(0!!6$%*!( 0!7'*6!4 .1 &68&) 0!!6$%*!(& 0!3!84"& #$% ##%6$.2006

"$.(8& &.!*-, &#!#%. "3%$!- &-8$3 4$& ,1..2)3"6," ,$!')$-$ ',( 4$(! #$% ',/)4. ',( 4$(!! '7$4& ,&9 #$% ., $"#!#%( :'$)& .&*'+& &'(1, "$.!1+ .1 4. 2/.$ ,.4',!. ',(& 4$(!! "4 *!'+&. &*!.%& &.,--&, '%4. #' ''$1"& ,.4',!. "!64$(!/ &.(!#, "$*.%&& "$1)-4( 4($!-& ',(& ., $"$',/ "4 %!*(&. 3$1 &./!

120."!31.(

,-#.,,!#$%&!%+

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

.&*'+&& "1+$"( ,!, 3$7!&)"$.4,. '"$! "..$/ "$7%!!"& 8!)&. ,#(- &9 '-4- ,:/. :,-&( &'/9$& '(/, &6%(&( 1!!"7! 2$!3& .&*'+&& 4,$6( !"*!, 2$!3 "'87-( 2-!1 33$-"&. *!'+&. "$!$,'& ., 2".$/! .1 "$.%& "$.(8&& %"$.(8& ., 0!6$, 0!'$,!- &,$., 2!( "$*.%& ., 2".(# :!.&" "6!%(-) &*'+&& :!.& .1 "$.%& "$.(8&& ("$-!$7- "$!$.!1+ $"-.,& '%4. 0!*'+$-& 0!-'$8& ., 0"$.!1+ .1 "$.%, "$.(8&&$ ((&*'+& 26!!61,

.&*'+&& :!.& ., "!+!)+7 "$7%!!"& 0$#-( 4$(. &'$-4 &6!4 2$!3. "1)$-& "'87-& !/ ,!83&. ($,% 31$!-& 0$%"& "-8$3 ,0!!3$%!!& &!6!!+4- "4 2$(,%( 4!(!, 2+$4( &*'+& "-9$! ./. '($1 "$.!1+& ., 0!!37$-& 0!6!!+4-& ,(3$1$ "$4!'( ,:$6!% ,"!.!.+ &+!/4) &*'+&.

.!.$/$ ("$!-$#-& "$!$,'. "'9$(- $4 &6!3-& "'87-( "!9$/!') &*'+&.

!.1( 0&, ,0!.4',! 1#'# "$$) !,64 .4',!($ ,0!.4',! '!$$4 "$$) !,64 ,"1 ./( ,#!71" &.1+&. ,'36&- "%+! 4., '+7-( ./&$ ,0!!6$!%& 0!7/6& ".1+&. ,'36/ !$,!'$ &',/&

."!6$%*!( :'$) $4 0$'!% "1,( 0!!6$!%& 0!7/6& ./ ., "!6-9 $($ &+!)' &, -#./ #*'6"- 38/24.3 5"8( $4' ='* ',( 4$(!!. 7%!( "$.(8& ., 2"$!"#$% ".4,. 120 !),$ &, -#./ #*'6"- 26/64.2 5"8( ((1..3) 287 (7)9- 3"+ ,!&!(% '+& %#+--% +*'

.(1..6) 17 (7)6 3"+ ,#*'+".1 ,"& .!1. $4' 121

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!>&

%'"%6"62'!%'"%6'2!%'*0$,!#,-#.,,!%'*'0$!1*

2"!6 &- &.4,( &*.%&&, &"!!& !'$(!)& *+,-& ., "!"'$7-& &%6&& ,2!$), !+/ 0!)$.!4 ., &3.$" 4.$ ,"!*+,-)5$% 0.$1)"+#,& ., !'+ "$!&. &'$-4 *!'+&. "$*.%&, #+7 2!4 ,0!'(3& %"+( 2!$), !+/ ,2/4 .=7$6 2$!1 "(!!%- $9 &%6& .0!!*+,- !*!.$+& 0$%"& 2- 2"$4 1!#+&. 2!4 .!8'& &'#-( !/$ ,"$!6!3- "$4*(- &*'+& .1 &-/7$-& 04 2$%(. ,! ,3$7!&)"%6& $9 ',4/ 08 0.$4 ."!*+,-& &'!9& .4 2'!(1&.$ $9 &,!8. 08 4-, $4 3!-" &6$/6 3(.( "$!6!3- ., &.4, 4!& &*'+&& ".4, &!+., 2"!6 04& =*+,-&)!"( "4 *!'+&. 2"!6 04& =4()& "4 *!'+&. 2"!6 04& ."$.(8- ,! '!(1&. ,.,-. — 0!$7- &3,( "$.!1+. "!../& "$!'%4& "4 *!'+&. ("!*+,- &6!%(-) &9 2!!61. =!.%!,) !*'+ 3!84" !3!. $!.1 %$#!+.$ "$4!'(& 0$%" .$&!6. "$!'%4& "4

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

0'*) '1)-%& %""+.!% !'+ &, #*'+"/ '1)-% !&$+# (&8"* /228401 5"8( $4' 122 "$3(1-. 08 ',+4. &'!"1) ('1)-% !&$+# (&8"* 2!!61 %2.&.) (..6.2007 ,07'$+ ((0!6#"& 2$/-. #' 4.$ ,!.4',!& 2#". 0!4($!- 2!($* ., 0"-4"& "4 #$3(. "$!*'+ ,07'$+ 0'*) 5"#/.* !"-&0-% %7.&-% &, 5"#/.* 3"#(8-% !&4!&+ 2262402 5"8( ., $".1+& "4 ',+4. &'!"1) (5"#/.* 3"#(8-% !&4!&+ 2!!61 %2.&.) (12.12.2006

.(&)1$-& !3!).1 4.$ ,!*'+ 0'$8 !3!).1 "!-$#- "$,'(, 0!!%(*-&)"!(./7 ,"& .!1. $4' 123

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

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!>'

04 2$%(. ,#("- &9 1#' .1 4#$$3 .&*'+&& "!!8$7. 7%!( "$!.'*!6)4. "$!$1-,- ,!.&*'+& "$-9$!. 7%!( "$!.4!)6*$+ "$.(8& 08 0!..$/ 3$7!&)!#$%

., &*'+& 1)(. "6-).1 !/ '$/9. ,! &*'+&& "$.$(8 ., &.4,( 2$!3. 7!7(/ ('&$7&)!"( "$'!, !3!).1 .1+$-& ,&4!./& "$'!, ,.,-.) #$%( "68$1-& "$.!1+ ., "!(!*#+4 &.(8& &$$&- &-)1.,/ $9 &3($1$ ,"76/& ., "!"#!#% "$.!1+ ",'36 $9 &($," 0.$4 .&+!#- &*'+&- "!'$(!) "$8!!"7&. "$+). 2"!6, '%4- ,!$6!,& "$.$(8 0!!$6!, 2&(, "$(!76( 2!3& &!&! &- &.4,& "''$1"- ,"!,4' ."$6!%( &-/- "#+7- &6!4 "*'+& 2$8/ ,0!-!$7- 0!-$%"( &'# 2/4, !+/) "76/& ., &"13 .1 $.(#"! &9 8$7- 7%!( 2!3& &- &.4,& "''$1"- ,"!6, .("!+!)+7 &#!#% %$/- :'3. &4)!, ,'&$7&)!"( &6!4 &"*'+& 2/.$ (0!7"6"-& "$.!1+ "-8$3) &#!#%( &'37$& 4. &.!%"/.-, "$.!1+. 4!& 2&!6!(- &6$,4'& .&.4 "$.4, !", 2!( 2!%(&. 2($-/ ($,% .&#!#%. .$/!(/ ",'36

.!.&6-& *+,-& 0$%"- &.4, 4!& &!!6,& $.!4$ ,!"#$%& *+,-& 0$%"- &.4,

!$"$980!($+".$!"/:$.0!($+".0!%"!#$%0!)6+.4!0)(600!!$'$47!#,$

!37$-& '$,!-( .0!'$,!- !6,( "''$1"- !"#$%& *+,-( &*'+&& "$.$(8 ., &.4,& 3'+6)!".( #.% 2"$!&( ,../ &*'+&. "$6"!6 26!4, "$.$1+ "$-!!# 04 4!& &.4,& 3$7!)"$!$/9( "$18$+ "$*'+& $.!4 4!& &.4,& "$!$/9& '$,!-( .&6!3-& ., &"$&-- &'/&& "$'-. ,:,-&( '&($!, !+/ ,"49 01 .0!!"#$% 0!6%(-( 3-$1 $6!4, 2+$4( $6!4 !"#$%& %!,& .$+#!& "4 .!(8&. ,! ,&*'+&& "$.$(8( !"#$%& 2$!3& ., $"$(!,%( ".(8&. !1)-4 ,-,. 0!/!') 0!!"#$% "$6$'#1 2/).1 .!'$(!)& %!,& "4 =!.%&. '$-4

."!7%! 0!!6$)!# 0!'#-( #' &*'+&& ,&,# &-!,- 4!& !37$-& *(!&& 2- &*'+&& ., &!"$.$(8 "1!(# — "()&-% '&+"-% .1 "!*!.$+ &!'$4!" ., &,$(!8. 4.$) "$!*+,- "$.(8& ., 2"1!(#. &6$$/&, .// 2!1'8& "'38& !(8. &-/7& 2!4 ,"!,4' .("!'$(!)& &'!9( %$/!$$. 7!7( ,-,", &7!+"( .%& —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

.1 "$,'& 01*- !"4$'(" %$#!+ "$1)-4( 08 $9 &'*- 8!,&. 2"!6 !/ #7+6 ."!-$#-& &,!8& "4 .(#. &*$6 *+,-&)"!( !/ "3-.- 0!'#-& 2!( &4$$,&& ."!*'+& "$.!1+&

.2$*.,& !3!( '"$6 2&!.1 %$#!+& 3$1 ./ "!*'+ "$.!1+. "$6$!,' 2"-( "/-$"&.;9B6;O H9MICf2 AHA;CH32 SOAO6 AHD PO9+IA =#>>&? %$4' 127

&$$"- 1!)& ,:$6!%& 0$%"( 08 !,+$% #$, ., "$6$'#1& ".%&( .83, ,2-3!'+ 2$*.!- 126

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!>!

!*'#$-3 !%'94 :$6!% ., 0!31!&, :/ .1 0!1!()- &*'+&. 0!386"-& ,"49 "-$1. 0!!*'+ 0!-'$8 !3!).1 $#+$7! :$6!%& !"$'!, 04 0.1!&.$ #%,!&. 0!.$.1 !6$!$$,$ ., &'38& .!1$" &-/ 31 ../ '$'( 4. ,"!6, 12/.(%$#!+( 0!6$"6 $!&! 0& 04 =4) &!$+) $9 &'38& ,4,$6( "$13&)!#$.!% %/$6. %&*'+&. 2"!6 $6!4, "$.!1+& 0$%"

128.!3-. &') "$!&. &'!"1& "$1)-4( !37$-& '$,!-( &*'+&& "$.$(8 ., &.4,& "4 0!83&. 2"!6 &".1& &'!"1& 12...4',!( !*'+ .$&!6( '&$7)"!( "-#&. &-9$!& 386 &,8$&, "$,'& 4!& &.,--&" !/ &'$- &.,--& %3$7!)#$%. 1 *7 !/ "!6$'#1& &61*& "4 &-)1( .$1+. "(!!% &.,--&, 4!& $9 &4'$& ., &"$1-,- !/$ ,""1)(-& ..$/ &9 2!1'8 ,0!'"$1& ., 0"*!,. .1$)!(& "$!$/-7 ., "2!1'8"& ".1+&( "$6$(!'& !6--7- $6!&, ,!.!.+& *+,-& ., $"+!/4. '$,#& ,&4!./& 0$%" "4

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— 0&.,

.(("7,"& ,"-8'"- 2&/ .9-) 87 !&'"1& 32"#6"40 2-3!'+ 2$*.!- $4' ".&4$'(" ., ,0!.&$6- '+7&)!"( $(, 2+$4( &!$." :$6!%& ., "$!*'#$-3&)"$!%'94& "$'*-& "-,8& 12/ 0!3!-." ".(# ., !.-'$+& 2+( #' 4.) &!)'8*6!4 0&( "-,8$- $(, 2+$4( &9 ../($ "$"!/. &#$.%& "!,16 $(, 2+$4( ,.,-. — =*$,& .$&!6& '$,!-( 08 4.4 ,'+7&)"!(. .(2002 ,08'"- 2-'#$) '!-4) 82—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— '+7 !"(. !'$(!) 3$7(7 "#3)&. !%'/& !46" .3.! ./. !'+7)"!( :$6!% 37(7. $6!.1 ,0, ".3!"1& !%'94 :$6!%( ="$,-$ ($,% 2!!61 ,! 0!%'94., &3($1& 4$& — "$317-. 4.

.83 *-1( "$!$/9& ., !$4'& 2+#!& 4,$6( "$13&)!#$.!%, :/ .1 1!()&. 2"!6 ,&4$$,& 0,. 128 366403 5"8( $4' .3$(/( 0$!#. "$/9& ., "!*7!.-!6!- "$6,'+. $.!($& "$!"'(%&

.(12.12.2007 ,07'$+ 0'*) '7&*% '+ &, "!'/1 0(7& 3&#+# !&/"&1- !!&-. &!$.") '7&*% '+ &, 3"64+-# !"-(0*% %##$-% $3(*% !&"&$2 !/"61 2607407 5"8( 12.

.("3-$1$

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!>(

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

.!6$*.,& &!+., &3-1& .(#"" 04 08 ,"!"#$%& "'$#!(& ., &!(., "6!%(- ,&'#- ./( &*'+&. '$74 &9 2!1'8 !/$ ,!1$)!(& 2!1'8& ., $-$%"( 4!& "-!$7- &*'+& "-9$! 2- 8$'%. 2"!6 04 &.4,& 01 33$-"&. 2!!31 :!') &!&! ,&.,--& %3$7!)#$% !+. ,'-$./) "!*$+!,& &.(8&& "#7+ ., &!"$,!'3( &3!-1 :$" "!"#$%& &-'$6& ., &!/'1 "4 "-.$& ,&!$4' "!./". ,#$% !+).1 4!& &8!'%&, &#!3(. =$+/( ., &+#!&. "$(!,% "13$6 &9 ',#&( 131.("!"3!-)!".( &6!4$ .4',!)"6!3- ,4./)"!(. 0!#+$7-& 0!-!$7- 0!"$'!, ., &*'+& &-$3 2!4 .&( '($3-, &*'+&&

132.&.4 "$.!1+ !-$%"( "$!'%4& ., &+!#- &*'+&. ,4(). =4 $4

:!-7&. "$',+4& !(8. "!63,% &3-1 &*#6 &#!7+&, :/ .1 1!()&. 2"!6 ,&4$$,& 0,. 130 !/ 04) '(7$& ,/8 ,"& .!1. ,:"/&'&/ 2!!61( .0!!.!.+ 0!'#$%/ '$(!) !3($1 06!4, 0!,64 "/'$/ &".1+&, ,"!"'!#%& &!)#6$+& ., 3%$!-& &!!+$4 0$,-" !/ (!"#$%& '$,!-( 4. *-1( ,0, ."'$(!) !3($1 !3!( &3!#+&. !$4'& 2- ,*'+& ., 3$7! "$!$/9( &1!8+. ,,% 2!3)!/'$1. "$##9!&& 0$)-) ., "$!6!3- 5$-!4 .1 &#!7+& 2- 3$-.. 2"!6 2/)$-/ .833 .(2!*$.%. &..,6 $9 &#!*#'+, !.(- 08 04) 0!!.!.+ 0$,!4)!("/ ",8& :'$). 0!!*'+ ,%#+--# "64+-% :.&"% &, 5"(%"$'&. ('+- " &!&+& 51&$ "#'&8 83204.. 5"8( $4' "$!6!3- .4/ "-)-)-& "$!6!3-. *+,-&)"!( 7%!!"& &9 &'#-() (2001) /. (3)&6 3"+ '98-&- 2!3):'$1 "/-7& ., "$',+4& "4 .7+ 4. 2$!.1& *+,-&)"!( ,"49 01 .("&!$4'" ,1.82)("-," ,;(.$,- %7$6< !.!.+& 2!3& '37 #$%. (()(1)(4)12 *7 :'$). "1($""/ !*'+& ., $*#+)&3 &'(1&. &3!'*- &-8$3 .20 ,"& .!1. ,3"#0"-"$ %4"1 2!!61 $4' .23 %"7 !+. .1./2)3".,"& ,.4',!. &7!6/& "$6#"( 4$)-. 2"!6 0!!*'+ 0!-'$8. &+!/4 "$!$/-7 &/.& ."$.)4 $"3$(1 0$" 01 ...$"4!)!. !4'%4 &!&!" '9 3($1 #!71-& 3!(1- ,(&)7 *#" .0!'9 0!3($1 .1 %$/ ".1+& ., "$1+$". .!($&. =4 &.$.1 $9 &($% ., &"1!(# ,&,1-. 08 ,"49 01 .(21.2.2007 ,07'$+ 0'*) #*'+" !,"(- &, &"/"# 2280402 +"1 ,.,-. ,$4' 0&!3!(1- "4 =",. 2"!6 04 "!6$'#1& &.4,& "''$1"- ,"$.$7+ 0!/'3( &+!/4 '31&(

..4',!( 0"3$(1 "+$#" 0$" 01 5'4& 2- 0"4!)! "+!/4( 0!'9& 0!3($1& ., !&'"1/% !(.& +*'%/+&" &, 24&- .2403 ("1 $4' "!*$+!, &.(8& "#7+ ., &".1+&. 131

.(2003) /.3 (3)96 3"+ ,%'+.%++% !),$# !"2$'-% '%4. "'$#!(. 4,$6 &"!!& "!'(&)"$)'4 4() !3!).1 "$.!1+ ., "!7%! "(%'6& &*'+&& 132

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!>"

.&*!+, "$!$/-7 ., 0$%"& 2- 4!(&. 2"!6 "!37$-& "!"#$%& &.4,. "+7$6 &-8$3 "!!8$7. ,'$+-( 7%!!"- $6!4 &*!+,& %3$7!)#$% 08 ,&.,--& %3$7!)#$%. &-$3( !3!).1 $.1+$! &*!+, "$!$/-7, 1($# &*!+,& %3$7!)#$% ,2/ .1 '"! .&*'+&& "$',+4. "38$6- &6!4 $9 &1!(# ,&'$4/. 133.#$%( $1(#!!, 0!.6$(!'*$ *+,-)!"( "$!&. &/!') &1'/&&, &4'6 24/ 08 .*'+$- *+,-)"!( ., '37&( '!/" &#!#%&, =% "$!&. :!'), ,&*!+,& :!.& ., $"$&-. ',4( "!6$'#1 &7!+" .1 "77$(- !3!).1 *$+!, 01 3%4 &6#( &.$1 &6!4 &9/ :!.& .1 &3+#& .0!!././ 0!)!'-"-

132.0!/$7/7( 2$!3 $!.4 '!(1&. $/!,-! "$!$,'&, :/( 7'*6!4 $. ,!, 034 0!6$!3& "$'-.) :/. 3%$!-& 3$7!)#$%( 2!!31 '37$- $6!4 &#!#% "$!$/-7 ., 0$%"& .$./. !$+) 4$& ,##%!! &9 ',4/ .(&#!#%& %3$7!)#$% ., $"#!#%. "$(' "$1)&( "$/-7&, &1!(#& 2$8/ ,&#!#% "$!$/-7 ., 2"*'+&. 7%!( 08 "$!37$- "$.(8&

137.'$(!) 3($1 ., $!3!( 3#+$" &6,-)"#!#% ##$%. &*'+& "$-9$! 04 2$%(. ,! "$!"#$% "$!$/9 .1 &68&& '$,!-( — !&"&$2% '&+"- .2 "#7+ ., &!6%(-( "3-$1 $9 &1!8+ 04 — 2/ 04$ ,3$7!)"$!$/9( 1$8+. "$!$+)

.&.(8&& (%'& .$./-. 7%!( 2%(!&. "$/!') 034 "$!$/9 .1 &*'+& "$-9$! ., 2&!"$/.,& "$!7.#& "$!$'!%& 2& — !.4',!& *+,-( 0$!/ "$'/$-& "$!"#$%& 3$7!&)"$!$/9 ., %$/()0$!4 &$$&- &,!61$ &+!/4 "$!$/-7 ., &*'+& ,.,-. ."$!"'(%& "$!$/9& 2&$ ., $"-#& 386 &'!"1& ., &',#&( 08 $61*6 &9 8$7- "$61* .3$(/&$ "$'!%& .1 0'$8 !3!).1 '&$7)"!( ".1+&, 4$& ,,%& ,'"$! !+!)+7 2+$4( .*'+$- '&$7)"!( 2+$4( 0!'!74 ., 03$(/($ 0"$'!%( %'/&( 18+" ,0!%$$' "#+&. '"$%& ,!*'+ "". 2"!6 ,&'$4/. .2!!/9& ., %$$'& 0$7#-. "3-"-& &'!"%& .,( ,!"3!- $6!4,

Martha Mino 2̀ C2/3*2-5(') %.,-. ,$4' .#'!1 "-%.-( 0!'$#'9& '$4 .4 &1!8&, ,*?$-: G*? ,-(.&/(0(') %(=(/&-> 4++*-/3 D#&==$')$3 ;55*2'/&A(=(/>H ,-*+$33(*'&=(36H

.&': I$6*5-&5>2 !" B. C. L. ;6<. >*> =&\\(?./8 %"7 ,&*!+,& %3$7!)#$%. 1 *7 133

"!.-!6!- "$('$1-( "33)-& ,2-3!'+ 2$*.!- ., "!*7!.*!+#& $",!8 !+. =4 !/ 2!!61- 132 2!!6#& "$!$/9 ., 2"'38& 4$& 0!#&($-& &!3!#+"- 3%4 ,&'(%&$ &././& !!%( &6!3-& ., &%6&& .1 77$(- 0!!,+$% 2!+!.% "$1)-4( "!././& "$.!1+& ., &6$8'4" ,$!'(3. .2,$'!+$ $6$)' "4 "$+/. 3%4 034- 1$6-. !3/ '37$ #$% .1 &'!-,. ,.,--& "$1)-4( ,$6843 $64, 2,$'!+. ,2!!6#& "$!$/9 "$1-,- "'38&. (!,+$% 2+$4( $-"%6, 0!9$% "+!/4. ('%4 .1 &,!8. .28 *-1( ,126 ,"& .!1. ,2-3!'+ $4' .""!'*!6$- "'87- ., &"1!(#.$ (2"+!/4.$ $4' — &#!#%& '$,!-( 2&$ &*!+,& '$,!-( 2& — *+,-& ., '"$! "(%'6 &*'+&( "33)-&

.($9 "'($%() 64+- ",&". "!*'+ !*+,- '37 ., $6$6!/ %*+,-& "*'+&" ',!+ &!.* .$/! #$%" %77/ ,776 4"7,"& %"& ,&#!#%& %3$7!)#$% "1)&. (()11 *7 !+. ,.,-. ,:/ 137 2!#"&. ,0&( 3!#+" 4.-- $4 &',- 4,$6 $4 ,#$%( $-#$&, =$8 $4 "$,' 08 :!-7!,

".&/-7&( 1(#6, '%4 2!61. $4 #$%& 1$)!(. "$6#"

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!>)

.1 "$!$,'& 3)- 0!!"$1-,- %$#!+ !6$686- ".1+& "$1)-4( &9 ,,%. &61- 08 2"!6 0.$4 136.("'%4 "*'+$- "$.!1+ ./ $4) *'+$-& '&$7&)"!( ., $".1+& ,%$#!+ "%" $.!+4 ,0!!*'+ 0!-'$8 !3!).1 2".1+& 0)1, "$!$/-7 ,! !/ '$(7. %$#!+ "13& .1 "$.1&. &,# ,.,-. ,:/) "$!$/9( "!"3!-)4. &1!8+( &/$'/ "$!&. .$/! &!1(. '%4 &61- 13/.('&$7&)"!( ., "!-$!-$!& $"$.&6"& .1 !(!*#+4 0".1+& 08 :4 ,0!'!74& "$!$/9 .1 &68&. 0!!././ 0!)!'-" "'!)! .1 77$(- ,'&$7&)"!( ., "+*$,& "$.!1+& .1 !6$)!% %$#!+( &!$." "$!&. &'$-4 &.4 .,

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

Gillian 6. MetVger2 ,-(.&/(0&/(*' %$4' &*'+&& "$!"#$%. !46"/ %$#!+ ., 2+& ",83&. 136.&3 I$=$)&/(*'2 #\' C9LPM. L. ;6<. #'") =&\\'?

2#"- ., $.$&!6 .1 %#+. "$!4#!'-4& "$!$,'& ., 26$.,/ "4 &9 ',#&( '/94. !$4' 13/ Steven L. Schooner2 %$4' .!*'+ 2.(# "$1)-4( .1+$& ',4 ,#'!1( (!!'8)$(4 &4!./& D*'/-&5/*- ;/-*5(/($3 &/ ;A2 9#-&(A: D*6<-*6(3$: ;55*2'/&A(=(/> (' & J/-$&6=('$:H ., 4,$6( &(%'&. .C2/3*2-5$: 9*.$-'6$'/2 #" SOAH. L. 8 +9L:3 ;6<. (!> =&\\(? "!!1(, :/- 0.1"&. 2!4 ,.!(#-( .. ,"& .!1. ,"5$% '$#!-" ,!6( $4' %$#!+ !.,/

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

$"-4"& ".4, "4 0!33)& $6%(! &(, ,',8- !3!).1 .&$6", &(!,!( "$()!!"& "($% 2!3&.('$,!8. :$7/7& .,

(2007) 607 ,281 (2)*6 3"+ ,#*'+" !),$ &, %2. ;&1 !"'&2*% %7.&-% 1661407 5"8( 13..(%2. ;&1 2!!61 %2.&.)

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!>*

"<%!"E 2!8+& *+,-&)"!( !/ 2!!). ($,% 0.$4 120."$!'$*$**7 "$.(*( $1(#6, (,%!&. &!$,1 7'*6!4 !.1( 0!-'$8 !3!).1 &*!+, "$!$/-7 ".1+& !/ &61*. 0!-'$8 "$('$1- ., "'$7- "-!!# !/ 2!!). ,! .!(#-( ."!"#$% &6!%(- "!"!!1( ''1 "$31$$. 0!!$6!- ., ',#&( ,.,-.) 0!-!$7- 0!6!!61( &*!+, !/!.&( 0!!*'+

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

.(&-1*- 3$7(7( $4 &6!3-&

5""*$+,(!5"(/:<0$!0#"#%!%"'0*.0!)6+.4!0)(600!!$'$47!#4$

., "$!#71 "$-9$! .$7+. 4. &8&6 !.&6-& *+,-& 0$%"( "!"'$7-& &#!7+& :/ !3!. &4!(& $9 "!7!7( &3-1 .#$%& "'87-- ,'$+-( $8'% 4. 2& 3$1 ./ "$!$,'& 2"$3 (4$! .!.&6-& '$,!-( 08 "!*+,- &.4,/ &6$3!6 4. &*'+&& "$.$(8 ., &!8$7&, :'$)& .&#!#% (!!%" &*'+& ., "$.!1+ ./ &!+., &6$, &,!8 5-4. 0!1!)- &6!3- #'($ :!.& (84 ,&*'+& "$-9$! (!(7 !'$(!) 2$!3 ., $-$!#. 0$'". !$+) !"#!#%& 5$'1. "$6+.

123."76/( &#!#%& 06$8!1 "(!!%-& &#!7+& .1 "77$(- "$!9/'- &*'+& "$*.%&. 7%!( &#!#%. &,!'3& 2$!3. 0$'". !$+) 2/4 0!-!4"- 0!'#-( &-$,!!$ 122,&#!#%( "0!!6$,4' 0!'37B&" .,

.60/—606 *-1( ,0, 120 0!6!!61 3$8!6 '$7!4 26!!61, "$4'$&. ..0 %"7 ,1..2)("6," ,0!!".&6!- 2!3 !"( #$% $4' 121

.&9 #$%. 10—. *7 $4' 0!!.&6>-& 2!3&)!"(( 0!'(% .,.(12.12.2006 ,07'$+ 0'*) #*'+" !'6+- &, /&'% %6- 277/407 5"8( 122

.8 ,"& .!1. ,&6!3-$ 2"$3 123 2$!.1& *+,-&)"!( ., $"#!7+( &#9%"& &#!#%( 0!!6$,4' 0!'37B& ., 06$8!1. &,!'3& 122 ((1..8) 281 (7)(6 3"+ ,5&16"/% '+ &, 5""6+,"/&' 326/4./ 5"8( $4' ."$6$'%4& 0!6,( #*'+" !#+-- +*' &, #*'+"/ 3"/'.% ","",.# %,&"#.% /0.-% !(.& 11163403 5"8( ., 0"$(!,%. "$7%!!"&& &'"$6 0!'#-& 2- #.%( ,"49 01 .(2/.2.2006 ,07'$+ 0'*) !#+-- &, #*",0 3./74.7 5"8( ,.,-. ,$4' .3(.( !$)' *+,- '38( 0!!6$,4' 0!'37B&

..6 ,"& .!1. ,+(1 1"+ 2!!61 ((1...) 27. (7)86 3"+ ,#*'+"

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

!>>

4!& ,"!,4' .&*'+&& !'8"4. 0., &61- #+7. &.$/! &6!4 4!& ,"49 01 .4,$6( !'$(!)& "$1)-4( 08 "$.!1+ "',+4- "-!!#& &#!#%& 0&(, 0!('& 0!'#-. 7%!( &-!,! &6!4 &/.& 0".1+&( #' 4*("- &*'+&. '(1-&$ ,0$.," "!!(8 :$" $4 0!!*'+ 0!-'$8 !9/'- !,$#. &61- "6"$6 &6!4 4!& ,"!6, 127."0!-$3'" 0!!"#!#% 0!'37B& ., &,1-. ,"76/( $##%6, 0!'37B& .1 &*'+& "$-9$! ., 27$7!( — "$6$'%4& 0!6,( &.8"&, "$('1"& ., "$',+4( &'/&& ='% ,1$3!/ 126.#!+7- !'$(!) 2$!3 4..$ '!&- :!.&( :4 "$!&. 0!'$-4 *+,-&)"!( "49 &,1! 0&(, 0!'#-& ,!$4' :!.& &'(1 4., &#!#%( 0!8)$-& 0!!$6!,. 7%!( "!,1-)4. "!4'6 &#!#%. &,!'3& ,"!,!., 12/.../( 04 ,0!'!36)"$+$#. &6!3-& 2- "(.% "+!*" !"$'!,. "$!'%4& "'(1& 2$8/ ,43!'8 "0!!6$8'4"/

#.%( &($,% "$!&. &.$/! &#!#% .1 &*'+& "$-9$! 77(. &,!'3& &.4 0!-1*- .0!.$%& "1+$" ., &"$(/'$- 4$.- 01 "$33$-"&. 0., &61- #+7. &.$/! &6!4 :4 ,0!'#-& 2-

.&*'+&&

,63;4,!" <&)%!*4!%#'6"0'!,"-#6'(+!"='%"/!#,-#.,,!7"*,!1.

:!.&". &6$!.1 "$(!,% "13$6 ,!6$'#1 2+$4( *!'+&. 2"!6, "$.!1+( '($3- ',4/ !/ $(!!%!, *+,- !../ %"+. ,! &9 ',#&( .&*'+&& 1$)!( .1 &*.%&& ".(#"- $(, (%' =$"!, :$" ,4,$6( !'$(!) 2$!3 0$!# %!*(!, %$"+ :!.&( $.(#"! &*'+& .1 "$*.%&

./1 ,"& .!1. $4' .'$*!,& 0$%"( ,.,-. 127 &#!#%( 2&$ (23 ,"& .!1.) !*'+ .$&!6( '&$7)"!(. 18$6( &#!#%( 2& 0!'$-4 0!'(3& 126 "3$#+( &"!!& '(/ &4!./& 0$%"(, 2!!61- .(22 ,"& .!1.) 2!76$#7!$ "!6/$". 18$6( 034 ,'-$./) '&$7 $6!4, "034" :!-7&. "$',+4( &'$4/. &'!/&, &4'$& '&$7&)!"( .1 &77("& 4. &*'+&& "-9$! .'!/( '&$7 3!#+". ('&$7&)!"( "$'!, 01 &6-6 $6!4, .'&$7&)!"( "3$#+. *'$+- 2$#!" ., $"#!#% .1 4.4 ,$9 "!../ &4'$& ., &(%' "$6,'+ ",#(. *+,-&)"!( &616 &9 1#' .1 .,-- ., !'$(!) 2$!3 &$$."& 4. &#!#%. ,"49 01 2$!3& ., $"-.,& "4 ',+4. "6-).1 ,#$%& 386 &'!"1( 2$!3& "4 "$&,&. 0!(!,-& .(31.8.2006 ,07'$+ 0'*) '7&*% '+ &, 3(*% !&"&$2 !/"61 2607407 5"8( $4' .#$%( &#!#%& !/!.&. ',+4. !$4'" !/ &"!!& ,*+,-&)"!( !3!).1 &%7$6, !+/ ,0!(!,-& "61* ."&'!"1& 4$,6 2!!61( !'$(!)& %!,& "4 '!38&. 0"$1)-4($ ,0-)1 "$)-. "76/( $%"+6, $6. '7-!" 0!,3$% &,!, 3$1( ....(#"&. &,#(& 2!3" !/ *!.%&$ ,:/. &616 *+,-&)"!( "$-8<3 4!(&. 2"!6 ."&'!"1( .$+!*& :,-& 2+$4 .1 *!.%6 &6/$" !+ .1 ...&-!.,- &13$& ,'4$3& #6( ., $"*'+& 2$8/ ,,-- ., !'$(!) 2$!3 4.. &#!#%( $68$1, 0!!$6!,. "$+7$6 "6,. "!././& "$!6!3-& #$%( "$4'$& %$/- ,0!6*# 0!#71$ "!()!#,- '#!1( ,-,-&

./1 ,/0 %"7 ,2002)3"7,"& ,(&#!#% !6$#!") 2002 0!+7/& 3"+ ,#*'+" !#+-- &, !"*#01 %(&8* #*'+"/ !&4&.% "#(8- 5&8'* 2887403 5"8( $4' 12/

.(2002) 12 (2)*6

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(\\

!"'$7-& #$7!1& .1 =7$6 ,2/)$-/ 128.'$(!)& !3!. "$*.%&. 7!7( ,-,-& 13!-& "'!7-$ 04 2$%(. ,! ,&*'+&& "#71 .1 0!6$,& 0!33$-"-& .4 "$7%!!"&( "$6!8&($ 2$!$$,( 0!"$'!,& "$/!4 .1 &*'+&& "*.%& ., &!"$/.,&( (,%"& "$*.%&& ".(# :!.& 4.$ ,0!*.%$- 0!%6$-() &#7>1& "'87-( ".(#- "$,'&, &'$-"& .1$ '$(!). 0!6"!6&

.(&!6+. $!&, "$'%4 "$1)&. &4$$,&( #'

!$"*"/.!+47'!04$%0!#,$

.1 ".*$-& &($%( '!/&. ,! ,./,$- 2+$4( $.(#"! &*'+& "$*.%&, "6-).1 &*'+& !9$%( "$',#"- 2&, !6+. &*'+& ., 4,$6( "!6$'#1 "$!6!3- ,(8. "$!$,' 12..2"$.!1+. 0!6$!'*!'# 1$(#. &($% "$!.&6- "$!$,' .1 ".*$- 4. ,.!8'( .0!!+!)+7 "$/!-" ., &#$.%. 7%!!"&( ,.,-. — $9/ &($% &.*$& 0&!.4 7%!(, 0!()- ,! ,"49 01 ., 0!'$'(& 0!!"#$.%& 0!*(!&& .,( 171."!'$(!) 1#'# ., &"4)#&. $4 170"$!.&6-

.0!6$!'*!'# .1 &.$1+ 77(. "(!!%-& &/.&& "4 2&!.1 .!%&. ,! ,&*'+& "$*.%& '+7)!"( "'!7- ., 4,$6( "!6$'#1 "$!6!3- ,(8. "(!!% &!&" "$,'& ,.,-. ,:/ '+7)"!( ., $"*'+&. 18$6( &9$% ""!'/ ',+4"", !6+. 0!!*'+ 0!-'$8 ., 0.$&!6. 2- &.$1 &/.&& ., &9 %$"!+( :'$)& 172."!*'+ :$6!% ",' 01 "$',#"& "$1)-4( 0!$7- '!1( 3!%!& !"/.--& 2$/!"& '+7&)"!( ., $.$&!6 "4 '$7-. &*.%&& 2!!61( "$6!!3"&& '%4- 3%$!-( &,# &"!!& $9 &*.%& ,0!'"$1& ., 0*(!&- .""!-4 ",' ., &.$&!6. "$'3, &%3 *+,-&)"!( .!"3 !+$4 ".1(/ &1$3! '+7&)"!( "4 &.$&!6. &.(!#, :$6!%& ",', '(3( 0!(!,-& !+- 1-,, "$'&)&. "$7%!!"& :$" ,3$4- !.4$*7#*6$# 2+$4( &'!"1& "4 8$&6. ,!" !/ 08 2!!) 4$& ,"49 01 .'+7&)"!( ., !"/.--& $6$!() .1 '$-,. &6$$/& !/$6!% 37$- .$&!6 &'!(1-$ &!"$!$/-7- "#'+"- "!-$#- :$6!% "$,' ',4/ &(' "$'!&9

)#'( $$,& ,.4',! !1#'#-. 18$6( "$*.%&& ".(# !/!.&". 18$6& ./( $9 %$'( "$1)&. 128 "$,1!&. "(!!% &*'+& !/!.& .1 "$+!#,$ =$"!, ., "$6$'#1& ".%& .11 ,"& .!1. ,9'4 ., "$+"",&. :!.&& "%!"+ .!.&6-& :!.&( '$(!)& =$"!, ., "$.(8-. "$13$- :$" ,0!1)-4 !.1($ 0!7$6- 0!6#%, !3!).1 '"$! !(!*#+4 2+$4( ".)$6- 0!7'*6!4)"$)$(# "!.&6!-& *+,-& ., !*'#$-3& '8"4&" 9'4)#'( &6+3 ,.,-. ,$4' ."$!$.1( &/$'/$ *+,-& ., !*'#$-3& '8"4&" 9'4)#'( %2.&.) (2000) 212—207 ,36. 3/ 64+- ",&". ., $6!!61- &6!4, ""!.$&!6" &!8$7 .4/ &*'+&& .4 "$7%!!"&. ,2/)!+).1)=4 .("!.&6!-&

.'"$! =4 "$'$-% "$/.,& ,! ../ '$(!)&.(1../) /2 ,1 (2)46 3"+ ,%'&/1!% '+ &, /'&1 70164.6 5"8( ,.,-. ,$4' 12.

.(1.8.) /07 (2)(- 3"+ ,'7&*% '+ &, 5/7 7.488 5"8( 170.(2000) 228 ,220 (2)36 3"+ ,!&/&1' !""'". &, #6,-&#/ 36384.. 5"8( 171

., 3$7! "$!6!3-& "'87-( .$./. "$',+4& "4 %'/&( "'"$7 &6!4 "$!6!3- ,(8. &($%& 172 &.4 ',4/ 0.$4 ."!G!$7!6$ "-)-$)- "'87-( &.%"& "$1)-4( ,.,-. — !$7!6$ "$!"8'3& 04 &.4,& 2%(!" $(, :!.&& "4$ 2$,4'& (.,& ., $!"$'*- "4 '!38&. ,! ,0!'(3& !6+

.&+! &.1 4$&

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(\#

"$!6!3-. ',4( "!6$'#1 &3-1 ,(8! :$6!%& 3',-, !$4'& 2- &9 2!61( ...&"$-1 !3!. =7$6 31) 3$1). 2"!6 ."!$4'"& '38( $8)$& &.4 0!'(3 173."&9 2!61. "$!$,'& "4 &%6-&172.:'3. "4)$! $9, !6+. &*'+& ., 0!4,$6( "$!6!3- ,(8. "!*+,- &($%( '!/&.$ &-!3#

4!& &*'+& ./, :/. !$*!( "6"$6 &*'+& ., 4,$6( "$!6!3- ,(8. &($%& ",83& (!!%- 4$& ,"49 01 .!.!., %'/&( $6!4 0!!# $$#)7$**7 ., !$6!, .0!!# ()- ., !$6!, ".4,( "$3#-"&& "4 &+!.%- &*'+& ., 4,$6( "$!6!3- ,(8. &($%& .2$!3$ &(!,% &+!7$- &6!3-& ',4/ 08) !$6!,& "4 #!3)&. &($%H@ #+7. "(!!% &6!3-&, "0$-!6!-"&

.(&6-- ,'36& 0$-!6!-& "4 #+7.

"'0*.0!;"'04!=$!"+!#4$

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

4.) 6'&4)%& !&/'!% 9&,"1% !'+ &, !&'(+ '".% #+ 3"'&%% (.& '#&" /.2/407 5"8( 173.(28.8.2007 ,07'$+

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

".&6!3-& 01*- "$('$1-( 2!#" .&6!- !../ .1 &'!-, $%!*(!$ 8$&6. 3)!/.128 ,"& .!1. ,"!.&6!-& *+,-& ., !*'#$-3& '8"4&" 9'4)#'( $4' 177

4"1' $4' $9 &,!8 .1 "'$#!(. .(1.78) 12.3 (2)(! 3"+ ,3",4% '+ &, 5-'/ 3478 5"8( $4' 176 '$,!4. .(1..2) /0 (2)%- 3"+ ,&,*"'&- &, -#./ 1&6"/# %'/1 "#*'+"% )0",4% 37//4.3 .1 "'$#!(. ./1. *-1( ,13. ,"& .!1. ,%2. ;&1 2!!61 $4' ,&"1 "1. ,"!"'$7-& &/.&& 1661407 5"8( "$(#1( ="$6#" "6#"& !/!.&( 08 %2$1!*& "$/9" &/'( :$'( $4' $9 &#!7+

.(200/) 223 $ 64+- ",2*- ".4',! "76/ *6 &91 =$% "!'$94& &)1$-&

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(\&

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— 9'/- ,9'/-& !46" ., 03#$- 0$7'+ .1 08 3!+#&. ,! 4.4 ,"$6#" "1)& ., 0$9! 0$7'+. ,.,-.) "!'$(!) "$1-,- !.1( 0!6!!61 .$./. 0!!$,1 &.4 0!46" 08 .2$!,!'&$ &9$%& 4. .2$)' 1!(,&.- #$%' &9 0$%"( ()-& ,&"1 "1. .(*'+$- '&$7)"!(( 0!'$8-& "$+!+) "$!$,'& ,!'$(!) %$#!+ ',+4-, 2+$4( 0!9'/-& !46" ., !(!*#4 0$7'+ 2!4, 3(.( $9 0$.,"& 4.. 9'/- !/-7- ., 0!#"$1 .(#. 0!-'$8 ., 0",#(. "$.#( "$'"16 26!4 =4

178.0!+"",-& 2- .!8'( &(86&

"$6#" "*$!*. 03#$- 0$7'+ "". !$)'" ,&.,--. !*+,-& 51$!& "$!%6& !+. ,0$!/ 08 17/ '$(!) .1 "!,-- &1+,& $4 !"$1-,- ,$3!% $( ,!, ,=!#-$ !6$,4' '37B& "1($#& 38 ,2.3100 %#+--# "64+-% :.&"% !&"1,% ""$!%6&$ .&$6 %&6,- "#!#%" $4' ."'/!6

.(3"7,"&) &'#-& 2- 4!(&. 2"!6 &*'+& 9'/- ., 0!/-7-( 2$!1. &,!'3 .1 &(76, "$6!!3"&. &-8$3 178 2!!1. &,#(( %'94& "$!$/9. &3$84& &"6+ ',4/ .*'+$- '&$7)"!( "-#&. 9'/-& ., &!3',-( #' "49 08$ ,0!/-7-& 2- #.%( 2!!1. &. '"<! !/ &"616 4!& ,9'/-& !/-7-( 0!6!!61. *+,-&)"!( !3!).1 &"%36 4,$6( &'!"1& .#"$1 .(#. !.(-$ 0!9'/-& "31$ ., 0!/-7-& 2- #.%( 0$.!) :'3).1 2!!1. "'"$1. ',+4. &).-& =$'!)( !/ 04 ,0!!.&6- 0!#.%& 2- .!3(&. ,'!74. 0!"$'!,.$ '!74( .$+!*. ,0!'!74 "$!$/9. 0!7%!!"-& 0!#.%() !&"&$2# %(&8*% 28.8402 (4"" !9$%-) 0""1 $4' .('&$7&)"!( ., $.$&!6. 0!7%!!"-, ,'$1'1 ,8$& 2!3&)#7+ .1 .(22.3.2007 ,07'$+ 4.) '7&*% ('+- &, #*'+"/ 1'2*% %(&8*% 363/407 0"11 $4' .4,$6( "!6$'#1 &1'/& 4.. "$6!!3"&& 0$!7 !3!. 4!(&, 2!!61( 2"!6, ')#& 2!3&)#7+( .(1..12.2007 ,07'$+ 4.) '7&*% ('+- &, 1'2*% !&"&$2# :$"- ,0!/-7-& "!('- 4. 04 (' '-$% "'1'1-. '7-6 ...$6"*.%& "$(#1(" !/ '(7$& &9 ',4/ ,$'7-6 4., 3(.( 0!-!!$7- 0!/-7-. 7%!( "#$.%-& &-)-$) 0$!/$ ,9'/-& !/-7- .13!-& ,+$% #$%. . =!17( 1$(#& '$*+& "%" &7$% ',4 '-$%( '($3- 0!(!,-& "61*. &4)$"& .=7$6& '-$%& "4 '$7-. 0!(!,-. "$'$&. !3/ "49& "1. ('1"&. $6!4' 4. 0!6!!61. *+,-& "!( ., 2!3& #7+ !/ &9 '$1'1 "'87-( &8,$&, &-/7&& ., "!,1-& &!6+ #!3)" "'1'1-& "61*. ',4 ,&.4, ''$1"" 04 .$6/ .1 3$1 3-$1 $6!4 0!!.&6!- 0!33)& ., 0&!"$61*$ 2/ "$,1. ./$" 4!& ,0!!.&6!- 0!6!!61. *+,-& "!(. ",3$%-

.",3% :!.& 0!!#"! 04 ,0&. "$'$-,

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(\'

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

.034 "$!$/9 .1 &!$+)& $"1+,&$ :.&-& ., $"$1-,- "'&(&.

3/".!+6$%$!2$"3!!$"$98!#7$

$( .$*!. ./$! '$(!)&, :/( !3 2!4 ,&*'+&& :!.& ., &!)9!*'#$-3& 0$3!# 0,. "",$- "$!&. (!!% !"$&-& $6($-( =$"!, ."$($8"$ "$!$386"& ",8& "$1)-4( #.% ., $+$"!, .1 "77$(- "$!&. "(!!% &*'+&& :!.& ., &!)9!*'#$-3 2/).1 .13!- .1 "31$!-& "$',#"&& !46"( 2& — !*'+& 0'$8& 01 "$',#"&& !*'+( 2!!6$1-& '$(!)& 2& &($,% '$(!)& "1!3!. "$',#"&& !*'+ "4(& .&",16, !+/ "$',#"&& !46"( 2&$ 0!!'$(!) 0!"$'!, $4 0!!'$(!) 0!7/6 &'!(1-& &#71( "$'$-"& "<.!#, ., &/'1& 0,. 0!*'36*7( !*'+& ',#"-& ., $"3!-1 .1 %$#!+ ',+4. !3/ 2&$ ,"$!*'+ 0!!3!. &*'+&& 0&(, 0!'#- 0"$4() '$(!). 2"$6 4$&, 0!"$'!,& !(8. "$',#"&( $1(#6, .!1+-, &6$9"& "$/!4 !&- "13. ($,% ,.,-. .(0!7/6 "'!/- ., (!/'- #' "..$/ &6!4 !$4' 4$&, #+7 2!4$ ,!'$(!) 2$!3. 0!4"- 4,$6 $&9 .#+7. (!!%"& *'+$- 4./ .,

.!'$(!) (#1-. $6!!&3 ,!(!*#4 2+$4( 2& "$,1!&. "(!!% "$*'+&. 7%!( '$(!). 13!-& "'(1& .1 &($8"/ ,'-$./ ,(!(!7+) .!(7 2+$4( 2&$ ,2-)1 "$!$,'& ., 0$9! 0$7'+ "$1)-4(

."$',#"& !46"( $4 9'/- !46"( 2$!1 ',+4. &,#(( &!!6+ 01 2&., "$',#"&& !*'+ "4 (%'& '$(!)& !6+. =$,%. 4. "$!$,'& $*6 &/ 31 0!"!1.$ ,2-!1 0!',#"-& ., !#71& 13!-& .1 28&. !3/ '#!1( —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

.178 ,"&( .!1. 0!4($- &!*'+, ,4,$6( "$6!!3"&& "'87-( $.1 &.4 0!4,$6 17..0!+!#," 0$7'+. 7%!( "$(%'6 !$.!8 "$,!'3 .!%- ,1.68)%"/,"& ,:'1 "$'!!6 #$% 160

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(\!

'$(!). $-7'$+ 0'* &/ 31 .&*'+& ., "$#71 .1 08 "$+!#, ., "$6$'#1 .!%&.$ !$.!8. "$,#( $1!8& 0!'#-& ($'( ,2/ .1 '"! .&*'+& !9'/- $4 &*'+& !9$% 0$9! 2+$4( "6-).1 ."13& "4 %!6- $6!4 &9 ()- 161."!*$+!, "$6!!3"& ../. &*'+& !9$% ., 06/$" '(3( "$($%& ., 2,$(!8( 2& &,$%6 "$!6!3- 4*(. 2$!.1& *+,-&)"!( .1 ,$"$6,. &9 ',#&( .&*'+& ., 0$%"( 13!-& ,+$% !6!3 ., 0-$,!!. 18$6& ./( 2&$ 0$9! 0$7'+ !/ 0!'"$1& $61* "$'3,( 2$/!"& '+7&)"!( "*'+& ., &'#-( !/ ,.,-. ,2!!). !$4'

162."&.4 0!-!( #' 0"1!3!. 4($& 0/7&& ., !+$7& $%7$6"

0#:130!!$",/9$!0($.!0!!&'"#+!'3!!")$6"+!!($#"4!#/$

.!($&, "$*.%&& ".(# :!.& "4 #' 4. '#(. .$/! *+,-&)"!( ,!6$'#1 2+$4( "<.!#, "6!%(- &-)1 "$',#"&& ., &"$'!(7 "4 08 4.4 ,&*'+& &9$%( "$',#"&. ,"!"$'%" 4!& "$',#"&& ',4/ .&#7>1& ., "!././& &"$!43/$ "$!$,'& $.(!#, &'$-"& &-$!#. "$3$& — !#.% 2+$4( "$%+. —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

,81/ (7)$6 3"+ ,5'"# &, -#./ )3*)"4)") #+ %(&)"- 3&2""# %'/1% 67/6401 4"1 $4' 161 4$.& .#&($- !'$(!) !+$4 .1( 13!- 4$& (!,-& !3!).1 ,#("6, 13!-&") (2002) 822 0!-$.,"& !*'+($ !*'+)!#71 0'$8 2!(. "!'$(!) "$,' 2!( "!9$% "$',#"& !46"( '($3-& $"%$.,/ "$,'& ".1$+ &9/ &9$% .1 &"-!"%( .&9$%& %$/- "$,'. !#71& 0'$8& '!(1&, !4/9$ — '$(!)& !4/9 ,"'%4 &6#7- #!3)&. 0%$/(, 0!3%$!- 0!-1* '31!&($ ,'$(!)& ., .2/2400 5"8( (("0!1)$(- $..& 3)!/$ "$',#"&& !46" 0& &- "13. —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

.(*+,-&)"!( !3!).1 '(3 ., $+$7( &"%36 ',4 ,"$!6!!/9& ., 2"$386"& .,(.173 ,"& .!1. $4' 162

0'*) %#+--% +*' &, #*'+"/ 5&6#+% !&$"*# %.&,!% 2...403 5"8(( ,.,-. ,:/ 163 !"( "'(%. &4,'& $6!!61, 0/7& %0!-/7& !6, &+#", &'!"1 &"%36 (10.7.2006 ,07'$+

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(\(

"!*$+!, "'$#!( ., &".1+&. '"$! &(' "<%!"+. .!($&. &/!') "$.$38 &*'+& "$#71.&.4 0!4,$6( 08 "!,--

!50"!$9'+0!!*"%4.!8(9.0!">,*!!'3!!")$6"+!!($#"4 !#0$!$"!(4%0$!!$"($4"-0 !

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

167.("$',#"&( &"/9, &'(%& !3($1 ., 0&!"$!$/9( &1!8+. 08 0!(' 0!'#-($) "$1($6& "$.!8'& "$.(8&. ,2($-/ ,&+$+/ &!&" 9'/-& !46" .1 "!*$+!,& "'$#!(& ($,% ."'$#!( ., &'31& .1 &+!31 &+#!&( ".(8$- "'$#!( ,"49 01 ."$'!(7& 0%"-- %/$6. 0$!/ !',+4 $6!& 9'/-& !46" ., !"'(%& 2+( "$18$6& "$'!"1( 2$!3& !/ =!7$&.

166.0!9'/- !6!3 ., 0$%"( 08 &3!-1& "$/9. 18$6& ./( &(!%'-& "$!6!3-&

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— 0!4(& "$'$3& "($*. .(8$-& !1#'#& (4,-( ,$-!,& 2+$4 — 0!'"$1& !3! .1 &.$*!( #!3)", 31 &'!(7 !".( &/" &6!4 &.,--& "*.%& !/ 1(# '(3 ., $+$7(

.12 *7+( ,0, ."*+,-& "!( #*'+" !/$' " !&/$'%& 3"#-,% !&+' &, '01-& :&." 5&,$! " 5&," 68/402 0"11 $4' 162 &, -#./ 1&!"4& 3"+"/$ '4. !&(&/. "07"#&* 7.33407 0"11 ((17.6.2006 ,07'$+ 0'*)

.(3.8.2006 ,07'$+ 0'*) !&"&'+0!%& +$' ;8* $-#./ #*'+" !/$' ., "!"'$#!( &6!%( %:')- "$!&. "'9$% &3$(1& ',4/" !"+') !1$'$ ,!6( !,!(4 3$1 $4' 167

.(2008) .3 4 64+- "+.- "034 %$/ !'!"1 0!"$'!, ",!/'( 37+& !9'/- -#./ './//( "40"% (&"7& 3"/+1- )0",&'60#* 3*)""*)"* 82164.. 4"1 '#!1( $4' 166

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(\"

!$(%!0!/$/"3!#$$

31!. "$7%!!"& 08 — 0!%'94& '$(!) ., $"%$$'. —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

.&*'+& ., ',#&( "$'%"( !'$(!)& "$!8$7( &#71, &#!7+( !$*!( !3!. 4( "$'%" 3$3!1 ., .$#!,& ,&,1-. &/.& &'!/&, &#!7+& .1 1!+,& 4$& ,.,-. ,:/ .!(#1 2+$4( 3!-" 4. :4 ,&*'+& ., .1(. 0!+!31 0!46" "#61& ,'-$./ ,"4#$6! "68&" ., 8$7& 2- &!).$8' ., "$!-!*!8.( 2!3)!#7+ ,"49 "-$1. 1/0.0!-!!# 0!-'$8( "$'%"&.$ #$,. 76/!&. :!'), ,3% 2$!,!' 2$'#1 ., $".$%" "4 $%3, :/( *'+$-& #$,( "$'%"& .1 #+7- 2+$4( $68& 4. 0!'%4

,! "49 01 .()0",&'60#* 3*)""*)"* 2!!61 %2.&.) (2000) 227 (3)36 3"+ ,)"4% #.4- &, $.*$&, "$.(8& ., 2"'7&. $7%!!"&, "$'!"1 &9 ',#&( &#!7+( $6$3!6 &/ 31 !/ '!1&.

.9'/-& "$4)$"( '!,! !././ 7'*6!4 !.1( 0!-'$8 ., &3!-1& "$/9 .1 0!'%"-& 2- 3%4 ./ ., #$7!1& ,+$% .1 &68& 2!( &6%(&. 0$#- ,! !6$'#1& '$,!-( 16/ 22674.8 4"63 $$,& .(%'& '$(!)& "($*. "!,+$%& "$'%"& .1 &68& 2!(. #$,( ,.1$+( 0.$4 .(2001) 76 (1)$6 3"+ ,-#./ './/4( 3"%%;+ &, -#./ './/2( #&./6 08 &68& ..$/, ,(%' 2+$4( #$7!1& ,+$% "4 &,'!+ !"#$%& *+,-& 0$%"( &#!7+& "$'%"&9 &"!& 3)!/" 7$'8 .!!4 $4' $9 "$6,'+ .1 "'$#!(. ."!,+$%& "$'%"& .1.(2000) 22. 8/ 64+- ",&". "#$7!1& ,+$%. "$/9& !.$"+6( — ="!"#$% "$/9. *"!,+$%&

.&!.4 &$$.6& *7#*&$ 116 ,"& .!1. $$,& 168.128 %"7 ,1.88)%"-,"& ,0!!#71& 0!.(8&& #$% 16.

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

.(10 5$'1 ,&'%"-& 5$'1&

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(\)

., &-$!# %!*(&. "6-).1 1/1."0!!6$*., 0!3!#+"" ., 0"*'+&. 7%!( #$7!1& ,+$% 0!-$%". 08 #$7!1& ,+$% ., $".$%" "4 (!%'&. !$4' ,('$(!)& ., $"%$$'.) "$'%" ",!/'. =7)!46" "1!(#( !$*!( !3!. &4( "$'%"& .1 &.,--& ., "'%4 &1+,& .&.4 "$(!76( .3!%!& $4 !'#!1& ,/'& 0'$8 4!& &.,--& 0&(, 0!#$$,( 0!"$'!, $4 0!')$- "13$6 2/.$ ,0$%"( #$7!1. 0!-7%/ .1$+( 0!3#+"- 0!!".,--& =7&)!46" &.4

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

(1)$- 3"+ ,%'&/1!% '+ &, #*'+"/ !&'""!& !&."), ",$&) !&(1*!% 27074.0 5"8( $4' 1/1 3"+ ,%'&/1!% '+ &, -#./ './01( 7##+*' 6)6&"4-&0 10624.2 5"8( ((1..2) 723

.(1..7) 808 (2)*- !&/'!% $9&,"1% ('+- ##$,- &, 3# 7.364./ 5"8( 4$& &9 2$$!/( :.$&, ($,% 2!3)#7+ 1/2 !!$#!. ., 0!6$%(4( &'/&. 0!6$!'*!'# $6$3!6 &9 &'#-( .(1...) 6/3 (2)86 3"+ ,6'&4)%&)"!( .&%-$- !/$6!% 8$.$/!7+ ., 2$%(4 #' '/$! !/ $'$&, :$6!%& 3',- !3!).1 &3!-. &6!3-.", :/( (,%"&( ,#$7!1& ,+$%( $18+ &.4 0!6$!'*!'#, &61*& "4 .(!# *+,-& "4 "..$, #!71&.- &"$16-!&$ ,#$7!1& !')$"( ,$-!,& .1 $4 &#71&& .1 .$+$6$- %(&/.% '+ &, 5-0/ 7636401 5"8(( ,"49 "-$1. .682 *-1( ,0, ."#$7!1& "$',+4 $1(#6, 0!6$!'*!'#& 386 0!(./ 2-4- ., $"'!"1 &"%36 ,(2002) 8.0 (7)%6 3"+ ,%1&&'%& 0!(./. #' 3$7(7& "4 $.!(8& ',4 ,&!!%6)!(./ ., &#9%&&$ =$.!4& "$!$.1 3$7(7. &'/$& 4. &9 &'#-( .5'4.)5$%( &9 0$%"( 0"./,& "4 $,/', 0!6-4- !3!).1 $6-$4, #$71.- '"$1& .7+6 4." !/ &1!(#& 3$7! .1 ,'"$1& ., #$7!1& ,+$%( &1!8+ ., &61*& ., &"*!., "$'-. ,(8./ *-1( ,0,) "!'$(!)& 3$7(7& $6-- 16-6 4.4 ,$( '%(, 1$)#-( 37($7", "6$/"-( &!!%6)!(./ ",!/'. &'$'(& &+31&( (,%"&() !*6$$.'& #$,( &6!3-&

.(&!3!).1 20/ (2)%6 3"+ ,%'&/1!% '+ &, -#./ 3""#*'+" %4&.! "&&0 ."0'* 1008.401 5"8( 1/3 0$3!# — &6$'%4& &*.%&& 3$7!( &3-1, "!./"&" %:/ &9 2!!61( '!(7& '$4 *+$,& .(2002) &'!37& &+$1"& #$, ., $!+$4( (,%"&( ,&!$4' "!./" &6!& — .1).4 ., &"*'+& $-!!#"& &.4, !+/$ ,..// .4',! "6!3- ., 0!3%$!-& 0!!"+$1"& 0!/')($ !.4',!& &!',# '#!1 .!3$%!! !*!.$+$4!8 ()-( "4)-6 .4',! "6!3- .&6$'%4& &*.%&& ".(# 0$!( $4 ,"!',+4 !".( &6!& .4',!- "!",(!& &4!)!&$ ,&-!1 "$.($8 26!4, "$6!3- 01 06!& "$"1(, 3$1( .'!$$4& :'3 $6& .4',!. !9/'-& &7!6/& '1,, 4!& &4)$"& .&,# '1)-.

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(\*

!(!"6- #.% &%"+, &,3% &*.%& &.(#"& ,"!'$#-& &*.%&( '$-4& ='% ,:,-&( ., &-1*- 01+&) &,3%& &*.%&& 386 &'!"1& 08 ."$'%". &!.4$ .4',!- &+$1"& &"!!&$ ,&%*(& &-.!8 4. "!'$#-& &*.%&& !/ &1!(#& 3$7! .1 ,&"%36 (.1).4 "'(% "3-.- $9 &-8$3 1/2."$6",-& "$(!76. 04"&( "$!6!3- !$6!, ., !../& 2$'#!1. &+$+/ .,$(!8( &/9 0'* &*'+&& :!.&- #.%/ 0!!"$'%" 0!'37B& "1!(# ., 4,$6( .$+!*& !/)"$$% 2!/&. &($% %$"!+ "$!&. &.$/! &9 0$%"( ''$,& ()-& '$+!,. "!',+4 :'3 &/9! 4,$6&, "6-).1 ,#,-( "$'%"& .1 "66/$"-& &*'+&& ., &"/.,& 4,$6( "13 &'(% ., &"'!/- .1 &*.%&, '%4- ,2/)$-/ ..(#"", &*.%& ./( "*'$+- "$7%!!"&( &3!-1- &6!3-& "$.1(( &"!!& ',4/ "$!31.( ., (0!-!$7- $4 0!(') 0!*(!&- &"6&6, 2!(. &'!/-& 2- %$$'& "4 07#-. &"+!4, 2!( — 0!6!!61 3$8!6 ., ()-( &.,--& "4 .1 $.$%!, 0!'37&& "1!(#. "$/-7& "4 #!61&. !$4' — "$'%"( !'$(!)& 7'*6!4& :'3).1) &.,--. 4.$ ,0!!#71& 0!.(8&& .1 &6$--. &*'+&& ., 0!!"$'%"& 0!*(!&&

1/7.(&#!#%( 0!4"- 2$#!"

!(($3.!,"0+!5"/%$".0!5""+#0$!'/%.!;(/"'3!0)(60!#8$

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

,"$'9 "$'(% ., 2&!"$'!, "$1)-4( &,16 &6--$ .4',! .4 &+$1"&- .$38 #.% &'8!, ...&6--$ .4',! .4 &'9& "!'!$$4& &+$1"& 2!*$.%. *1-/ "#7$+ 0$'!% "$"1(, !'& #!9%", ,&(!)!$ &.$38 "!'%7- &+$1" "'(% ., &-$!#( $6!& '$(!)& 7'*6!4 &.4 "$(!76(

.21/ *-1( ,0, ".&6!3-& !/'$) ./ .1 &61", "#+7- "$-/( 0!7$*- &"$.1(( ,07'$+ 0'*) !&'""!% ('+- &, -#./ #*'+"# '"&* "/"!, #.%#* .00406 5"8( 1/2

.(22.8.2006 &!.$#!, 2!(. &.,--& ., 0!!'$(!)& &!3!#+" 2!( !.4!)6*$+& 0!6!!61& 3$8!6 ,&,1-. 1/7 &9 0!6!!61 3$8!6, '1,. 2"!6 ,"49 01 .&*'+&. ',# 4.. 08 0!!#"&. !$,1 0!7/6 ".1(/ !$4' .0!7/6 "'!/-- &!%$$' "4 07#-. "6!!6$1- &.,--& ',4/ ,&*'+& ., 0!()-( =!'%!

.!*'+ 0'$8 !3!).1 .1+$- 4$& ',4/ '($8 .$+$6$-& ., &1'. .$)!6. ,,%& !/ =!7$&.

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(\>

"4 0!-4$" 2&!6$!+4 04$ "$!6$.!% $4 "$!"3 2& 04 &.4,. 7%!!"&( ,.,-.) "$!*'+& 04 '"$! .$38 &!&! "!*$+!, "$('1"&. !$/!7& &.4 0!'#-( .(($,!!( &!!7$./$4& !/'$) ./( ,"49 "-$1. .(($,!!& !/'$) ., &#!3()!4 2$8/) :!.&( &.#" .1 1!()&. ',+4 &!&! "$'!(7& 0%"-, :/( "!*$+!, &'/&. "$+). 2"!6 ,$-)1 !.&6-& "13&).$#!,. 18$6&

.(%' 4$& &9 ',#&( "$,'& .,

2'6".,!%')'8%(!*/!:6'5"2!#!"-#.'(!!".'$!*4!2'6".,!1'

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

1/8.(0&!"$!$/9( &1!8+ !6+- 0!3!%! .1 &68&- .!3(&. ,"!*'#$-3& &6$, 0"$.!1+ &!&" ,0!*'+$-& 0!+$8& .1 "$+7$6& "$($%& ".*& '%4. 08 ,2($-/ 0&!.1 0!1!+,-, 0!6$,& 0!)!'-"& !6$686- %/$6. ,1'.$ ($*. ,0!!'$(!) 0!+$8 ., $9-

!'$(!)& 0$%"( 0!*'+$-& 0!+$8& ., 0"$.!1+ .1 %$#!+( "$3#-"&& "$/9( 2$1!*. 1/6 MA;OHA MIH9[2 +A;OH6;S2 H9O ;I<ALS g +;I<AOIMAOI9H AHD %$4' ,!4#!'-4& ',#&(

.OH6 +PBLIC G99D =&\\&? 3). ,&*'+&& &9$%($ &#!#%( 08 0!*'+$-& 0!+$8& ., &!).$8'& #$9!% "$/9( 2$1!*. 1//

./ ,"& .!1. ,8.+ $4' ,&#!7+& 2- "$1($6& "$($%& 0!+$8( "$*.%&& ".(# !/!.&" !(8. "$,,%( &(' &3!-( &3#-"& "!'(&)"$)'4( &(!"/& 1/8 Jody Yreeman2 ,-(.&/$ ,&-/($3H ,2A=(5 K2'5/(*'3 &': /#$ L$? %.,-. ,$4' .0!*'+$-& ;:6('(3/-&/(.$ 1&?2 (' ;6C;AYOIHG OH6 ;PL6 9Y LA[j OH6 LIMIOS 9Y L6GAL 9;D6; ''#

.=David DyVenhaus ed.2 #>>>?

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(#\

:!.&" "4 2$%(. 4!& 2$!3( &9 #.% ., $"'*- ,0$/!7. .0&., &6$,& !6$8'4& 7$"4&$ ,!'$(!) %$#!+.$ "$!'$(!) "$-'$6. 0"++/& "4 $6!!&3 ,0!*'+$-& 0!+$8& ., "&'()&"&

1/..!'$(!)& (%'-& .1 '(1, "&*'+&"& :!.&" 3).

5""!$0."$/!5"6$7!'+!5$%!0!!(/70!%!"!#":6!0"-'$7(!#,$

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

182."$!'$*$**7 "$!$/-7 &.!1+- 4,!3# &'(%, :/ .1 $9 &6#7- 77(. 2+$4( *+,-&)"!( 16-6 &#!7+( 2$!3. &!8$7& &1!8& 0&(, 0!'%4& 0!'#-& ./( 08 #+"7&$ ,0!!"$&-)$3 0!+$8 ., 4,$6( &/.&& ., &".$%" !-$%" "4 1$(#.- !(#1 %/$6. "6($- "!*$+!,& "$'!&9& .&9 2!!61. 2$(,%( 4!(&. !$4', 0!.$#!, "8)&( .,$(!8 !(.,( 2!!31 "4)-6 &*'+& ., "$4!)-& &(, &+$#"( "$'-7- "1!(#- ,,%& .0!*'+$-& 0!+$8& .1 %$#!+& 4,$6. "$43$)!4 ., 3!'*- 3-!- &7!6/- 08 4!& 0.$4)"!( ., $"$16-!& .1 '1*)&. ,! 3%$!-( .&9 0$%"( &/.&& "4 ,(8. ($,% 2/).1

Jody Yreeman2 4M/$':(') ,2A=(5 1&? L*-63 "#-*2)# ,-(.&/(0&/(*'2 ##" HA;<. %$$,& 1/../ ,"& .!1. ,8.+ (L. ;6<. #&*( =&\\'?

.110 ,"& .!1. 180

.111 ,"& .!1. 181

.2.1 *-1( ,0, 182

.282 *-1( ,0, 183

.718 *-1( ,0, 182

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(##

"$37$-& "-8$3 ,0!'$'( 0"$.!1+ ., 0!6!!+4-&, 0!+$8 ., 06!!61( 1!'/&.- *+,-&187.&&$(8 &./,&. 0!!'$(!)&

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

.(0!!'&)&)'%4 "$1,( "$!*'+ "$'87-( 0!.,-

0#"#%4!0"-'$7('!0/".0"!$.,!#$8"%!%!"!#"#%!0"-'$7(!#4$

0!+$8 ., 0"++/&. "7%!!"- 0!!"$&-)$3& 0!+$8& !6!3 $')!, "!"#!7+& &!).$8'& 0!6/". "!9/'- "$(!,% "13$6 2/).1 .!'$(!)& *+,-& ., 0!!7!7(& "$6$'#1. #' &.4 $9 &#!#% .0!!*'+ 0!-'$8 ., 0"$.!1+ .1 %#+. "$!$,'& "4 &/!-7-& &#!#%& .,

.'"$! "$*'$+- "$($% .$./. &/!')$ &.$/! ,! 0.$4 18..&*'+& $'(1, 0!-$%"( "$('. ,"!(!*.$8' &#!#% 2($-/ "-!!# .4',!(

#*'+"# "8&#&,$6 5&$- " 5&",$6% /171402 0"11( 2$!1 :!')( '4,$& 2$!6/*& ., $6!!61 187.(2007) 233 (6)*6 3"+ ,:( &,

!+).1 .0!!'$(!)/ 0'!38&. ,!, 0!4,$6& !(8. "!"$&- &7!+" 2($-/ "(!!%- $9 &3!-)"-4 186 "$'!, .1 "3#+$- 4!& ',4/ "!'$(!) "$.!1+. =!.%" &6!& "!*'+ "$.!1+ ,!"7!+"

.("$4!'( $4 :$6!% "-8$3) "!"'(% 3$7!)"$/9 '38( 4!& $"#+7&,./ ,"& .!1. ,"0!!'$(!) 0!3!84"" 9'4)#'( $4' *$'!+. 18/

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

.('$#-( &,83&& (21 *7+( ,0,) ".&!.+4( "$1$86 "$!$,'& 2"$!'%4. "$1-,- &6"6 2$!.1& *+,-&)"!( ., "!6/31& $"#!7+ ,2/ .1 '"! 18.

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(#&

0!!6$,4' 0!'37B& 0!,'36 ,"$'%4 0!.!-( ."!1$)#-$ "*'$+- &!&" $9 &#!#%, 3!+#&. 08 4.4 ,("&*'+&& "$.$(8" "'"$/& "%" &6$3!6,) *!'+&. "$,'& 0)1 !(8. #' 4. 3)- %$#!+& 06!!61, 0!'37B&) &*'+&& :!.&" ., $"-.,& '%4. 0!.%& 0!'37&& !(8. 3)- ,0!*'+$-& 0!+$8& ., "+*$,& 0"$.&6"& .1 0!.%& 0!../&$ ,3%4 3)- ,&6!3-&

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

.$9 "$.!1+ *!'+&. &*.%&& ., ,3%- &.!#, !3!. 4!(&. &.$/! &*'+&. "31$!-& ,&'$,# 0!*'+$-& 0!+$8& ., 0"$.!1+ .1 "'$#!(& !6$686- ., 0"$(!,%( &'/&& 0!3!84"( '($3- "$($'# 0!"!1. .&.4 0!+$8 2!(- 0!(' ., 0!!+$4. ,!#.% 2+$4( 0!($,# "$!&. 0!!$+) 06!4 &9 8$7- 0!3!84" ."!.4',! &*!.,( 4#$$3 $4. ,0!.$38 !$.!8 .1 0!77$(-& "$*.%& ".(# !/!.&". 0!(!$%- $!&! 2/ 04 4.4 ,"!'$(!) "'$#!(.

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

"$!$/-7 ., 2".1+&( "$6.,'. 7%!!"&( 08 2!#!96( "$!'%4( &'/& :'3).1 "$%#+-& ,07'$+ 0'*) -#./ 1&6"/# %'/1 %'&,- &, %4"1 !"'". 2.06401 4"1 $4' .%$#!+

.(27.7.2006 *.+ .(#. &,#(( 0!6+& 3',- .4 13!-& ,+$%. &1$6"& ., &!!6+ .1 "77$(- $9 &-8$3 1.0 .&6>- ., 13!-& '84- .2!7$./$4& .&6>-( 0$,!'& !(8. 0!6$, 0!!*7!**7 0!6$"6 ., (,%- &"!!& &9 &'#-( 0!6+& 3',- ., $"($," .!*'+ 0'$8 "$1)-4( 0$!/ .&$6- 2!7$./$4& ,+$%. &1$6"& ."/6- ., "$("/"& !+).1) .#, 3/,000 ., 0$.," (!!%" 13!-& "#+&, (!!%. 2"!6 ,1...)*"6,"& ,("$'84) 13!-& ,+$% "$6#" !+. .(2007 !.$!( 27 0$!- 13!-&

.2$!1& ",#(( "$/$'/& &#+&&$ .$+!*& "$!$.1( "4,. 2$!1& ,#(- "4

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(#'

., 2$!1& !/'3. ',4( 0!'$'( 0!'37B& (!!%- !*'+ =$8 !3!).1 0!!'$(!) 0!/'). ,-,-&1.1.("$1* ., 0!()-() 2$#!". &,!'3. ',4($ $!(8. #9%$-& 13!-( *'+ ./

5"(%!.!'+!0/".30!!$98$!8(9.0!">,*!!'3!%$#"6!%!"8(9.!0"-'$7(!#7$

9'/-( &/$9& ., $"3!-1)!4 4!& &*'+& ., 0!6$, 0!',#&( &-)1 .1 "'9$%, &!1( $"'87-( $'38$&, "$!$(!!%"&$ 0!46" ../):'3() $-)1 .1 .*6, 0!46"($ "$!$(!!%"&( 0!'%"-& .$- "$!$6-39&& 2$!$$,( "18$+ 0!46"& ., $9 &'+& 1.2.(&*'+&& 9'/- ., 0!.(#- *'+$-& "$'!,. 0!##96& 0!%'94&, :/( 4#$$3 4*("- &#96 '#!1 :4 ,0!'%4& 0!)%.( &6$"6 *'+$-& "$'!,. "!4'%4& "$,'& &9 (.,( .'"$! 0!"$%6 0!46"( "$'!,

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—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

.9'/-& 0$!7 '%4., &+$#"& !6+).1 08 1'","

!"8$%!06"9,$!5""8$%!5"-"(.!!%!"8$%!0"-'$7(!#/$

.&*'+&& ., !9$%& 2$686-. 08 ($,% 3!#+" 13$6 "!"#!#%&$ "!"#!7+& &!).$8'& 3). "$'!, .!1+-, !*'+& =$8& 01 "!9$% "$',#"& .1 "77$(- &*'+&& 0!(' 0!'#-( "$(!,% ,! $-!1 &,16, &9$%& "'87-( !*'+& 0'$8& ., $!"$($% "'38&. ,2/. .!'$(!) ."$-8<3 &-/ :/. 4!(&. 2"!6 .&*'+& ., &+$#"( 034 "$!$/9 .1 &68& ., *(!&& 2- &(' !3!).1 0!#71$-& 0!3($1& ., '/,&$ &3$(1& !46" "4 1($# &*'+&& &9$% ,"!,4'

"$7%!!"&) ;9B6;O 9:HA;;9[ J;.2 H9 +LAC6 O9 HID6 #&(i#&> =&\\(? %$4' &4$$,&. 1.1.(0!6-!&-)4. 0!!*'+ 13!- !'84-( "!'(&)"$)'4( "$!$,'& ., ,$-!,.

"!'%7-& &!9!$$.*& !)$'1 ., 0!6!!/9. 7%!!"&( %!/, 2+$4( "$.$1 &9 8$7- "$61* 1.2..4',!(

.166 ,"& .!1. ,)0",&'60#* 3*)""*)"* 2!!61 $4' 1.3

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(#!

3!+#&. ($,% .&9 4,$6( "$4'$& .$./. .$/! "$%+. $4 ,*'+$-& "$'!,& ., 0!6.(#& 0!9'/- 2/. .0!3($1& "$!$/9$ 28-&)!#$% ., &'+& .1 77("" 4. &*'+&& ., &"$.!1!, 0$-!6!-)'/, 0$.," 06!!61, =7)!?46" .$./. 0!/!') &*'+& ., 0!9$%$ &*'+& ., "4 $%!*(!, "$4'$& .$./. :!') &*'+&& &9$% ,"!6, 1.2.28-&)!#$% ., 0&!"$4'$& 0$!#$ 2"'+& 1.7.0&- "$%-$)& &46&&)"$($* ., $4 0!*'+$-& 0!"$'!,& ., &$$,& 0"$,!86

."$,'& 01 &,16, &9$%& ., &'+& &$$&" $..& "$!6"& 2- "%4 ./ ., !.(#- ., "$!.'$3)$'+& 0&!"$!$/9 4,$6( "$*'$+- "$4'$& 08 .$./. :!') &9$%& ./$" &.4 "$4'$& ., &'+& .(3$1$ 2$!1 "$!$/9 ,2$1!* "$!$/9) 0!*'+$-& 0!"$'!,& "'87-( "49$ ,"$'!,& !.(#- !3!).1 08 4.4 ,&-)1 "$,'& !3!).1 #' 4. =/4!&.

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

.0!1)-4 !*'+& ',#"-. !$)!+& 4$& &*'+&& &9$%( $"'37&. "!9/'- "$(!,% ,!, =7$6 2!!61 0$.," ., "$',+4&, &6/7 "-!!# .&*'+&& &9$% "4 .*(. &*!.%- "$,'& $(, &'#-( 08 ,!$6!,& "4 16-" &*'+&& "-9$!- '$9%. &*.%& ., &'#-( 0!!"$1-,- 0!!$)!+

1.8.&-)1 "4 &%!/$& 4. &*'+&& !/ &13 ",(8"- $(, &'#-(

,0!3($1 "$!$/9 ., 4,$6( "$4'$& 0!..$/& 0!9'/- ,! .'$'( $6!4 &9 4,$6( 2!3& &1, !+. 1.2 0$!# "6!%(- "!9$%& &'$-"& ., &"$6/"!& "4 2$%(. "(!!%-& "!../ &/.& 2!4 :4

.(&)23 &6,-)#'+ .!1. 08 $4' .28-&)!#$% ., 0&!"$4'$& ',4/" %0!*+$,& $'!1& $!(8., ,172 ,"& .!1. ,#*"'* 2!!61( '/96 &$$,& "$,!86& 4,$6 1.7 2/, ,&.$38 &/ !'$(!)& '98-. 0"#!9 ',4 ,&'!"1& 4$,6 76/& "-8$3 0!76/( '($3- !3($1 "$+"",&$ !'$(!)& '98-( 0!6$, 0!+$8 ., &!)-'$+6!4 "8)& 4$& !9/'-& 06!!61 "('$1- &!&" &6!3-& !/ !$4'& 2- ,0"/!'1 0)1. !%'/& !46" ,&,1-. ,4!& 0&( &6!3-& %!*(" '"!& 2!($ ,!*'+ =$8 !3!( :'16 76/& 04 08 0&( "$+"",&& !46"$ 06$8'4 !46"(

".0&( '7-6& 13!-. '$(!)& "$,!86 "3!- "4.118 %"7 ,1./3)8".,"& ,(!../ #.%) 0!9$%& #$%. 32 *7 1.6

.1.0 ,"& .!1. $4' 1./ "$',+4( '!/- #$%& .'&$7&)!"( "*'+&. &-9$!. 7%!!"&( ''$1"&. &.$/! $9/ &.4, 1.8 '$-4/ ,$( 0!'$-% 0!'37)!4 ., &'#-( !*'+ .$&!6( '&$7)"!(. &6$-- .&6- !$6!- ., $6!4 &9 '37& !/ '!&(- &3$#+. %.128 =!17 ,:/. =7$6( .'&$7& !"( "3$#+. $.128 =!17(

!"#$%&'!%'(#')!"!"*+'(!#,-#.,,!*/!"#'0"1,!-./(, 2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(#(

,-#.,!*/!"#'0"1!-./(!%&#3*!#!'5"4!%,

08)$-/ ,.4',!( &'(%&$ &././& !!%( "!9/'- &1+$" "$!&. &4'6/ :!,-" &*'+&& #' 4. — !'$(!)& *+,-& ., "$/'1!& "(!!%- $9 &3($1 ."$'%4 "$!('1- "$6!3-( &4'6 &9 (.,( .!6$'#1& *(!&( 08 4.4 ,2!3& ., 0!!+!)+7& 0!../&$ 0!*'+& ($)!1(

.0!6$,4'& $!31) "4 2!!31 17$+ 4,$6( !*+,-& %!,& !/ %2$!3& ., 0!'$,!- &,$., 2!( 2!%(&. 0$#- ,! &9 '8"4 01 &!$4' "$33$-"& 0,. ., $"-.,& '%4. "*'+$-& "/'1-& .1 %$#!+&$ &*'+&& :!.&" ,&*'+&& "$.$(8 :$"$ ,!"*!, 2+$4( 4. :4 ,&.4 "$.4,( $#71 &#!7+&$ &#!#%& .&*'+&& :!.&" 1!()& '-4-& .&*'+&& 0$,!!( "$.!1!$ "$!$6-39& 2$!$$, ., "$!8$7( '#!1( "$3#-"& 2$!$$, ., 0!*(!&( 3#-"& ',4 — &!8$7( !"'$7-& !*+,-& 2$!3( 0!-!!#& 0!'7%& .1 &*'+&& "$!6!3-, "$!#71& "$!$6-39&& .1 0!33$-"-& 0!'%"-& .4 "$7%!!"&( "$6!8&$ :,-&($ — (%'& '$(!)& .1 $9 "$!6!3- ., &!"$/.,&. *1-/ 7%!!"& 4.$ ,"6-9- %,3% 0$%" ,2-9& :.&-( ,,(8. "$'$-4 &.4 "$1)& .'7%& "-.,&. "$1)& &.1& :/. ,"49 01 .&*'+&& "$.$(8 ., &!8$7. ,3#$& 2$!3& 2- #.% .&*'+&& ., !'$(!)& *+,-& 2"!6, 0!-$%" ., !3-. &(%' "'87- **',! &*'+&& "$.$(8( #$7!1& !/ %!6&. '!(7 ,! $"$4,) &*'+&& :!.&. (.&)"-$," ('!- "4 ,!3#&. ,! &.4 "$(!76( .0*!'+&. %$#!+.$ ("$6$, "$!(-$+ "$($% 2/$ "$!6!3- ,(8. &($%& "-8$3 ,"$6$, "$($%. =!+/&.

.0!*'+$-& 0!+$8& .1

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

.0/7&( #' 4.4 ,#$%( $1(#6 4. !$)!+& "$6$'#1, :/( 08+. 01* ,! ,2/ $-/ .&(

5#&-6#0!,).+2$3/%!%!*!-./(!")'"4

(#"

אוניברסיטת ת"א | אוניברסיטת ת"א · 2008. 7. 22. · Created Date: 3/27/2008...

Documents

Transcript of אוניברסיטת ת"א | אוניברסיטת ת"א · 2008. 7. 22. · Created Date: 3/27/2008...