© 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

103
© 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely

Transcript of © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

Page 1: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

© 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1

Supply

Claudia Garcia-Szekely

Page 2: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

2

Perfectly Competitive Producers are Price Takers

•Do not set prices.•Take prices as a given.

The supply curve tells us how producers react to

different prices

Page 3: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

3

Quantity Supplied The number of units of a

good that a firm would be willing and able to offer for sale at a given price during a given time period

Page 4: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

© 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 4

Factors Determining a Firm’s Quantity Supplied:

The price of the product ONLY!All other factors affecting

production are assumed to remain constant.

Page 5: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

5

The Law of Supply

There is a positive relationship between the QUANTITY SUPPLIED and the price.

Price

Quantity Supplied

5

4

3 7

Supply

Th

e h

igh

er

the p

r ic e

The more units will be brought for sale

Page 6: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

6

Soybean Supply Schedule

Price

per bushel

$ 1.50

1.75

2.25

3.00

4.00

Bushels

per year

0

10,000

20,000

30,000

45,000

$4.00

30

$3.00

$2.25

$1.75

$1.50

4020100

Quantity supplied (1,000s)

PriceS

50

Page 7: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

7

Soybean Supply

Change in price from $1.75 to $2.25 cause a change in quantity supplied from 10 to 20 units.

Price$4.00

30

$3.00

$2.25

$1.75$1.50

4020100

Quantity supplied (1,000s)

S

50

Page 8: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

8

Supply in Output Markets

A firm’s decision about what quantity of a product to supply depends on a number of factors...

Page 9: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

9

Factors Determining Firm Supply

1. COST of producing the product (Prices of required inputs)o The firm would need to receive a higher price for

each unit sold in order to cover higher costs.

2. Environmental Conditionso Weather, insects, natural disasters

3. Technology used to produce the producto If more output can be produced from the same

amount of inputs, manufactures will supply more of the good at every price.

Page 10: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

10

Factors Determining Firm Supply

4. Taxes levied on producerso Act as an increase in cost of production.

5. Expectationso Threat of trade restrictions on wheat and rice

exports to Cuba, Iran, Iraq, Libya, and North Korea (the largest importers of these US crops).

6. Prices of other goodso Substitutes in production – goods for which

producing more of one implies producing less of the other: Different types of crops: opium and rubber, tea and other crops.

o Complements in production – pairs of goods that must be produced together: beef and leather,

Page 11: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

11

Changes in Quantity Supplied vs. Changes in Supply:

Changes in quantity supplied imply movement along a supply curve.

Changes in supply imply a shift in the entire supply

curve.

The result of a change in market price

The result of a change in costs, expectations, taxes, environment, technology, prices of other

goods

Page 12: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

12

From the Firm’s Supply to the Market Supply

The supply of a good or service can be defined for an individual firm, or for a group of firms that make up a market or an industry.

Page 13: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

13

Market Supply• The sum of the quantities

supplied by all the firms in the market.

• Is the horizontal sum of the individual firms’ supply curves.

Page 14: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

14

Draw the Market Supply

1

3

2

10 30 50 100 200 30 50 10020

Page 15: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

15

Choose the arrow that best represents the effect

a

h

d

cb

e

f

g

a. Increase in demand

b. Increase in quantity demanded

c. Decrease in quantity demanded

d. Decrease in demand

e. Increase in quantity supplied

f. Increase in supply

g. Decrease in supply

h. Decrease in quantity supplied

Page 16: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

16

1. Chemical companies discover a new, more efficient technology for producing benzene (It is used as an additive in gasoline, and in the production of drugs, plastics, synthetic rubber, and dyes) How would this affect the supply of benzene?

2. The high prices of grain have increased the costs of dairy farmers and beef producers. How would this affect the supply of beef and milk?

3. The price of mozzarella cheese falls. What is the effect on supply of pizza.

Page 17: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

4. Oil producers expect prices to triple by the end of next month on news of impending war between Iran and Iraq. What is the effect on supply of oil TODAY?

5. "Seven years after a two-day freeze devastated the Florida citrus crop, growers in the state are expecting their biggest crop ever, in large part because trees planted after that freeze are maturing and bearing fruit." How would this affect the supply of oranges?

6. New legislation increasing the minimum wage comes into effect. Increases in minimum wage tend to cause a wave of increases through the salary scale (wages are a cost of production). How would this affect the supply curve in the garment industry?

Page 18: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

7. The price of jet fuel rises (a cost of production). How would this affect the supply of airplane trips?

8. Assume that farmers can easily switch from growing coffee to growing coca leaves. The price of coffee decreases to record low levels. How would this affect the supply of coffee? And the supply of coca?

9. An increase in corn prices increases the cost of production of ethanol (a liquid fuel made from corn or other agricultural products such as sugar cane ). How would this affect the supply of ethanol?

10.How would a natural disaster like Katrina affect the supply of gasoline in the U.S?

11.An insect that is resistant to currently used pesticides has infested the cotton crop. How would this affect the supply of cotton?

Page 19: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

19

12. A fertilizer that increases the yield per acre of tobacco is discovered. What is the effect on supply of tobacco.

13. Wages of steel workers fall. What is the effect on supply of steel?

Page 20: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

20

a

h

d

cb

e

f

g

Page 21: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

21

Prices are Determined by Supply and Demand

Price Changes are the RESULT of either a change in supply alone, a change in demand alone or a simultaneous change in both demand and supply .

Page 22: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

© 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 22

Market Equilibrium• The condition that exists when the

quantity firms want to sell is equal to quantity consumers want to purchase.

• Equilibrium is characterized by a price and a quantity.

• At equilibrium, there is no tendency for the market price to change.

Page 23: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

23

Equilibrium may be good or bad…

Page 24: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

24

Page 25: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

25

Consider the market for Soybeans

P

0

Want to buy

Want to sell

35

$3.50

4525

$1.50

$2.50

Excess Demand

Excess Supply

EQUILIBRIUM

25 45

Demand

Supply

Page 26: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

© 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 26

Excess Demand

The condition that exists when quantity demanded exceeds quantity supplied at the current price

Page 27: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

27

Pri

ce

QuantityDemanded

QuantitySupplied

Supply

DemandShortagePo

A Shortage

5030

20

Shortages occur because the price

is “too” low

Page 28: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

28

The Effect of a Shortage

QuantityDemanded

QuantitySupplied

S

DPo

Shortage

P1

Q Supplied=Q demanded

Q demanded decreases

Q supplied increases

Shortage eliminated

A shortage causes a

price increase

20

Q Supplied=Q demanded504030

Page 29: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

© 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 29

Excess Supply

The condition that exists when quantity supplied exceeds quantity demanded at the current price.

Page 30: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

30

Pri

ce

QuantityDemanded

QuantitySupplied

Supply

DemandSurplus

Po Surplus

A SurplusA surplus

occurs because the price is “too”

high

Page 31: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

31

The Effect of a Surplus

QuantityDemanded

QuantitySupplied

Supply

Demand

Po Surplus

P1

Surpluscause

a price drop

Q Supplied=Q demanded

Q demanded increases

Q supplied decreases

Surplus eliminated

Page 32: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

32

D

S

300

40

280

320

340

20

260

60

1. Identify the equilibrium price and quantity:

Price = __;Quantity = ___2. If the price is $280 is the

market in equilibrium? Will there be a surplus or a

shortage? 3. If so, what is the size of

the surplus or shortage? 4. Given your answer to the

previous question, will you expect the price to increase or decrease? Answer. In one or two sentences explain why?

Page 33: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

33

1.Fill in the values for the Market Supply and the Market Demand 2.Find the equilibrium price and quantity: Price = ______;Quantity = _____ 3.If the price is $280 is the market in equilibrium? 4.Will there be a surplus or a shortage? 5.If so, what is the size of the surplus or shortage? 6.Given your answer to the previous question, will you expect the price to increase or decrease?. In one or two sentences explain why?

 

A&E's Supply of

good X

Bob's Supply of

good X

Rose Inc. Supply of

good XMarket Supply

Kyle's Demand

for good X

Ann's Demand

for good X

Jason's Demand

for good X

Mark's Demand

for good XMarket DemandPrice of X

120 0 0 0   100 35 25 20  

160 20 10 10   95 30 20 15  

200 30 20 30   90 25 15 10  

240 60 25 35   85 20 10 5  

280 80 35 45   75 17 5 3  

320 95 40 65   65 10 3 2  

Page 34: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

© 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 34

Changes in EquilibriumPrice and Quantity

When Demand and/or Supply shift, a surplus or a shortage appears.

Surpluses and shortages cause changes in equilibrium price.

The market equilibrium price and quantity will

change when demand and/or supply SHIFT.

Page 35: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

35

Consider the market for coffee in equilibrium.

Price per pound

0 Pounds

D

S

$1.20

13.2

What will happen to the equilibrium price and quantity of coffee exchanged?

A severe freeze in coffee

producing Brazil

Page 36: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

36

Moving to a new equilibrium:

Price per pound

0 Pounds

D0

S0

$1.20

13.2

Supply shifts left

$2.40

9.9

Shortage

A shortage appears

Price increases

Quantity exchanged decreases

S P QS1

Page 37: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

37

Consider the market for coffee in equilibrium.

Price per pound

0 Pounds

D0

S0

$1.20

13.2

What will happen to the equilibrium price and quantity of coffee exchanged?

Starbucks invents the very

popular cold coffee drinks

Page 38: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

38

Moving to a new equilibrium:

0 Pounds

S$2.20

13.2

Demand shifts right

$1.20 A shortage appears

Price increases

Quantity exchanged increases

D P Q

14

Shortage

D1D0D0

Page 39: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

39

Consider the market for coffee.

Price per pound

0 Pounds

D

S

$1.20

13.2

Newspaper headline: “Coffee

contaminated with

poisonous chemical”

What will happen to the equilibrium price and quantity of coffee exchanged?

Page 40: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

40

Moving to a new equilibrium:

0 Pounds

S

$0.90

13.2

Demand shifts left $1.20

A surplus appears

Price decreases

Quantity exchanged decreases

D P Q

10

Surplus

D1

D0D0

Page 41: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

41

Consider the market for coffee.

Price per pound

0 Pounds

D

S

$1.20

13.2

Unusually good

weather increases the size of the coffee

crop

What will happen to the equilibrium price and quantity of coffee exchanged?

Page 42: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

42

Moving to a new equilibrium:

0 Pounds

S0

$1.20

15

Supply shifts right

$0.9

A surplus appears

Price decreases

Quantity exchanged increases

S P Q

13.2

D0

S1Surplus

Page 43: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

43

Applications

• Exchange Rates• Unemployment• Rent Control

Page 44: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

44

What would cause the following

Quantity drops and price dropsQuantity increases and price dropsQuantity drops and price increasesQuantity increase and price

increases

Page 45: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

45

Use Supply and Demand to Explain:

• Why do roses cost more on Valentine’s day than during the rest of the year?

• Why do TV ads cost more during the Super Bowl than during the rest of the year?

• Why do hotels in Phoenix cost more in February than in August?

• Why do engineers earn more than social workers?

Page 46: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

46

Your answer and graph must include:1. Changes in supply and/or demand if

any2. Whether the shift causes a surplus

or a shortage? Identify surplus/shortage in your graph.

3. Effect of the surplus/shortage on equilibrium price

4. Effect on equilibrium quantity.Remember your graph must be

properly labeled. Showing clearly the original situation and the new situation.

Page 47: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

47

1. A sharp increase in the price of beef leads many consumers to switch from beef to chicken.

2. A bumper grain crop cuts the cost of chicken feed in half.

3. Extraordinary cold weather destroys a significant number of chickens

4. A sudden interest in Eastern religions converts many chicken eaters to vegetarians.

5. Increases in income and population.

Page 48: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

48

When both supply and demand increase

0

S0

$1.20

15

$0.9

13.2

D0

S1Surplus

0

S0$2.20

13.2

$1.20

14

Shortage

D1D0

S P Q

D P Q

Effect on price is

indeterminate

Quantity increases

P? Q

Page 49: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

49

When both supply and demand decrease

D0

D P QP? Q

0

D

S

$1.20

13.2

$2.40

9.9

Shortage

Effect on price is

indeterminate

S P Q

0

S

$0.90

13.2

$1.20

10

Surplus

D1

Quantity decreases

Page 50: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

50

When supply increase and demand decrease

0

S0

$1.20

15

$0.9

13.2

D0

S1Surplus

D0

D P QQ?P

0

S

$0.90

13.2

$1.20

10

Surplus

D1

S P Q Effect on quantity is

indeterminate

Price decreases

Page 51: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

51

When supply decrease and demand increase

0

D

S

$1.20

13.2

$2.40

9.9

Shortage

S P Q

0

S0$2.20

13.2

$1.20

14

Shortage

D1

D P Q

Price increases

P

Effect on quantity is

indeterminate

Q?

Page 52: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

52

In two separate graphs, show the effect of these two events. In each graph, show the following:

1. Changes in supply and/or demand if any

2. Whether the shift causes a surplus or a shortage? Identify the surplus/shortage in your graph.

3. Effect of the surplus/shortage on equilibrium price

4. Effect on equilibrium quantity.

Put these effects together and write your answer.

Remember your graphs must be properly labeled. Showing clearly the original situation and the new situation.

Page 53: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

53

1. A sharp increase in the price of beef leads many consumers to switch from beef to chicken. High prices of grain have increased the costs of raising chickens. How would this affect the market for chicken?

2. ``Alaska is awash in salmon. Huge fish runs have been building here, adding to the growing output from sources like Chilean fish farms and Russian fishing fleets.'' News report warns consumers of possible salmon contamination: “Widespread contamination of salmon with toxic mercury cast a shadow over the nutritional benefits of fish.” How would this affect the market for salmon?

3. New legislation decreasing the minimum wage comes into effect. A successful “buy American” campaign shifts consumers’ preferences towards clothes made in America. How would this affect the garment industry in the U.S.?

4. A two-day freeze over the weekend devastated the Florida citrus crop. Growers in the state are expecting their smallest crop ever. The new wave of diets low in carbohydrates has reduced consumption of orange juice. How would this affect the market for oranges?

Page 54: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

Use Supply and Demand to Explain:

Through the 1980s, enforcement apparently became much tougher, and the risk of being imprisoned as the result of being a regular dealer probably

quintupled. Yet prices fell by about half.

54

Page 55: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

55

Role of Government in Financial Markets

In addition to imposing capital controls and regulating interest rates, the government controls both

• the set of firms that can sell equity on the domestic or foreign stock markets,

• the amount they can sell. – One reason behind the sell-off in China was speculation that

Beijing would impose a capital gains tax or other measures to rein in the surging market and economy, which grew 10.7 percent in 2006.

Page 56: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

© 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 56

Consumer Surplus

The difference between the price you actually pay and the price you are willing to pay for one unit.

Page 57: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

57

Willingness to Pay

D

1

10W

illi

ngn

ess

to p

ay

2 3

8

6

$10 for one unit

$8 for the second unit

$6 for the third unit

$24$24

Page 58: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

58

Willingness to Pay

D

60

0.55

60 60

0.45

0.35

Consumer Surplus = 81 – 63= 18

If the price is $0.35

$33$27

$21$81

Consumer Actually

pays $0.35 x 180 = $63

Page 59: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

59

Willingness to Pay

D30

0.55

30 30

0.45

0.35

Consumer Surplus

If the price is $0.35

0.60

0.50

0.40

Consumer Actually

pays

Page 60: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

60

The Demand Curve for Long Distance Service

D

Wil

lin

gnes

s to

pay

$ 0.65 for the first minute $ 0.64 for the second minute

$ 0.63 for the third minute etc…

1 Minute intervals

0.650.640.63

Area below

the demand

line

3 hours

Page 61: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

D60

0.55

60 60

0.45

0.35

$33$27

$21

D30

0.55

30 30

0.45

0.35

0.60

0.50

0.40

D1 Minute intervals

0.650.640.63

3 hours

Page 62: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

62

Consumer surplus in a Perfectly Competitive market:

D

Units of output, Q

Supply = Cost

Q = 4000

Consumer Surplus

10

5

2

Page 63: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

63

Consumer surplus in a Perfectly Competitive market:

D

Units of output, Q

Supply = Cost

Q = 4000

CS = Area of triangle

10

5

2

Triangle Area = Base x Height x ½Triangle Area = 4000 x (10-5) x 1/2

Page 64: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

© 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 64

Producer Surplus

The difference between the per unit price the producer

receives and his/her per unit cost.

Page 65: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

65

Producer Surplus

S = Cost

2

4

6

1 2 3

If The market price is $6

Producer Surplus = 18 – 12 = 6

Cost=12

TR = $18

PS = 6

Page 66: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

66

Producer Surplus under Perfect Competition

D

MR

MC

2000Qm

4000Qpc

C S

Lost CS

P SPS

10

5

2

Page 67: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

67

Producer Surplus under Perfect Competition

D

MR

MC

2000Qm

4000Qpc

C S

Lost CS

P SPS = Triangle Area

10

5

2

Triangle Area = Base x Height x ½Triangle Area = 4000 x (5-2) x 1/2

Page 68: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

68

Perfect Competition

D

Q

$

MC

Qe=4000

C S

P S

10

5

2

Page 69: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

69

When a shortage occurs…

D

Q

S

P=$3

C S

P S

Qd =6000

Shortage

Qs =2000

CS

PS

Consumer surplus when

only 2000 units are purchased

due to shortage

4000

Lost consumer and producer surplus when

only 2000 units are purchased and sold at

$3

Producer surplus when only 2000

units are purchased due to

shortage

Producer surplus when 4000 units are purchased at

equilibrium

Consumers purchase 2000 at

$3 per unit

Consumer surplus when 4000 units are purchased at

equilibrium

10

5

2

Page 70: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

70

The Effect of a Price Ceiling

D

S

600

3,900

2,200

CS

300

CS

Gain to consumerLoss to Consumer7,300

1000

7,000

900

Page 71: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

71

PS

The Effect of a Price Ceiling

D

S

PS

Loss to Producer

3,900

2,200

600300

1000

7,3007,000

900

Page 72: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

72

CS

A subsidy to Consumers and a Tax to Producers

Loss to Producer

D

S

600

3,900

2,200

300

CS

PS

Gain to consumer

D

S

600

3,900

2,200

CS

300

Page 73: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

73

Welfare Loss From Price Ceiling

D

Q

$

S

P=$2

4

C S

P S$1

CS

PS

Welfare Loss

Page 74: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

74

Welfare Loss From Price Ceiling

D

Q

S

$6

40

C S

P S$4

$8

$10

20

$2

Page 75: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

75

In 1985 a woman wrote this letter to the New York Daily News: “I recently moved to New York and I pay almost $1,200 a month for a nice little apartment on the lower East Side. When I found out at a tenants' meeting that 30 of the building's 34 apartments rent for below $300 and that most of the tenants in those cheap apartments make more money that I do, I was a bit outraged. I understand protecting the old people, but protecting fellow yuppies with bargains?”

Page 76: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

76

The following letter appeared in the New York Times:

Where are the voices of all those who do not share the benefits of rent control but who actually suffer from it?

For the past seven years my husband and I have been killing ourselves to pay our exorbitant market rent for a small one-bedroom apartment in order to stay in this city. I know too many people who live in rent-controlled apartments who also own country homes. One person (whose apartment we tried to rent at the legal rate) moved to Florida and now rents out his apartment, illegally, at the market price, subsidizing his new life style. If rent decontrol would mean a fairer, less insane market, then it is a just cause.

Page 77: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

77

Most governments around the world intervene actively in the operation of their agricultural markets.

Governments in poor Third World countries routinely impose price controls to keep food prices artificially low.

They do so to gain favor with their more politically powerful urban residents. Though numerous (and partly because they are numerous), peasant farmers do not organize politically and therefore have much less political power than their urban brethren.

The irony of this situation is that by artificially depressing the price of food, Third World governments reduce incentives for farmers to produce and reduce the availability of food from domestic sources.

Page 78: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

78

When a surplus occurs…

D

Q

SP=$8

C S

P S

Qs =6000

Surplus

Qd =2000

PS

Consumer surplus when

only 2000 units are purchased due to price

above equilibrium

4000

Producer surplus when only 2000

units are sold due to price above

equilibrium

Producer surplus when 4000 units are purchased at

equilibrium

Consumers purchase 2000 at

$8 per unit

Consumer surplus when 4000 units are purchased at

equilibrium

Lost consumer and producer surplus when

only 2000 units are purchased and sold at

$8

10

5

2

Page 79: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

79

The Effect of a Price Floor on Consumer Surplus

D

S

4

2

CS

2

3Loss to Consumer

CS

6

Page 80: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

80

PS

The Effect of a Price Floor on Producer Surplus

D

S

4

2

2

3Loss to Producer

PS

Gain to Producer

6

Page 81: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

81

D

S

4

2

CS

2

3CS

PS

D

S

4

2

2

3

PS

A subsidy to Producers and a Tax to Consumers

Loss to Consumer

Gain to Producer

Page 82: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

82

D

S

4

2

CS

2

3CS

PS

D

S

4

2

2

3

PS

Loss of Surplus to Society

Loss to Consumer

Loss to Producer

Page 83: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

83

Welfare Loss from Price Floor

D

Q

$

S

P=$2

4

$5C S

P SP SWelfare

Loss

C S

Page 84: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

84

Welfare Loss from Price Floor

D

Q

S

50

$8C S

$4

$6

$10

30

$2

Page 85: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

85

D

S

30

100

20

40

50

50

10

150

Calculate Consumer and Producer Surplus and welfare loss:1. At equilibrium2. When the government imposes a price floor at $40. This floor is equivalent to a tax on

_____and a subsidy to _________ the size of this tax/subsidy is equal to __________3. When the government imposes a price ceiling at $20. This ceiling is equivalent to a tax

on _____and a subsidy to _________ the size of this tax/subsidy is equal to _________

Figure 1

Page 86: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

86

D

S

30

100

20

40

50

50

10

150

Figure 1

Page 87: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

87

D

S

15

1000

10

20

25

500

5

1500

Figure 2

Calculate Consumer and Producer Surplus and welfare loss:1. At equilibrium2. When the government imposes a price floor at $20. This floor is equivalent to a tax on

_____and a subsidy to _________ the size of this tax/subsidy is equal to __________3. When the government imposes a price ceiling at $10. This ceiling is equivalent to a tax

on _____and a subsidy to _________ the size of this tax/subsidy is equal to _________

Page 88: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

88

Fair Trade Coffee

• Agricultural prices are low because there is overproduction.

• To solve overproduction, only the most efficient farmers should remain in business.

• The market mechanism ensures that only those with lower costs (the most efficient) remain in business.

• If prices are held high artificially, farmers will not have an incentive to leave this industry and find alternatives.

• Fair trade prices perpetuate the surplus…not so good for the farmers after all.

Page 89: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

89

Why Price Supports?

• Rural districts have greater political power.– Rural districts tend to have more legislative representatives.

• Farmers are often viewed as disadvantaged. – Rural communities lack many of the amenities that cities have.– Because labor productivity is lower in agriculture than in

manufacturing, wage rates are lower.– Technological change tends to expand agricultural production faster

than consumption, reducing the price of farm products.In 1870, for example, the price of wheat was over eleven dollars per bushel. Today, it is

only about four dollars per bushel, a drop of over 60 percent. Although consumers gain by paying lower prices, the incomes of farmers drop.

• Farm prices are volatile. – Weather conditions, over which farmers have no control, are an

important determinant of how much a farmer harvests in a given year. The resulting variability of production in the face of relatively stable demand causes farm prices, and farmers' incomes, to vary from year to year. This may cause economic hardship for farm families in a bad year

Page 90: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

90

Other Forms of Price Supports2. Legislating a minimum legal price below which a

good cannot be sold rarely works. So instead of legislating minimum prices,

governments sometimes try to raise prices artificially by limiting production.

Each farmer may be issued a quota that stipulates how much he can sell in a given year.

This is done with peanuts in the United States and milk in Canada.

Limiting supply can raise market prices as long as government inspectors monitor the market to ensure that no production beyond the quota is sold for a lower price.

Leftward shift in Supply

Page 91: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

91

Forms of Price Supports

3. Requiring (or paying) farmers to take land out of production. This "set-aside" approach rarely is very effective at supporting agricultural prices.

Farmers are profit maximizers: they set aside their least productive land first.

Furthermore, a policy that creates artificial scarcity of land induces farmers to intensify their production practices on each acre that remains in production, increasing supply.

Leftward shift in Supply

Page 92: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

92

D

Q

S0

$1.5

4020 60

Effect of a Leftward shift in Supply*-

$0.5

$1

Price paid by consumers increasesQuantity decreases

S1

$2

Page 93: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

93

Forms of Price Supports4. (Most common) government agency to buy any

quantity of a product offered by the country's farmers at the guaranteed "support price."

A U.S. example is dairy products, which the CCC (Commodity Credit Corporation) buys to support the farm price of milk.

The CCC disposes of the commodities it buys in ways that will not depress the domestic market price.

For example, dairy products are often given away to low-income people, in the school lunch program, and as foreign aid.

A price floor

Page 94: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

94

D

Q

S

$1.5

4020

$2

60

Effect of a Price Floor

$0.5

$1

Surplus = 60-20 = 40No transactions allowed below $2

Price paid by consumers increasesQuantity decreases

Page 95: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

95

Forms of Price Supports

5. A variant of this policy is designed to stabilize market prices.

The CCC buys grain at the support price, stores it, and releases it back into the market if the market price rises to a prescribed trigger level of, say, 140 percent of the support price.

In this manner the policy protects growers against the risk of low prices but also protects consumers against unusually high prices.

Page 96: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

96

D0

Q

S0

$1.5

4020

$2

60

Purchase and Release

$0.5

$1

Government purchase the surplus at $2

D1

If the price in the market rises above $2

$2.5 S1

The government releases the surplus until the price is $2

Page 97: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

97

Forms of Price Supports6. The United States currently uses a hybrid approach

to price supports that also involves loans. At harvest the CCC gives grain farmers nine-month

loans equal to their production times the support price. The support price is called the "loan rate."

The CCC accepts the grain as collateral for the loan. • If, during the term of the loan, the market price

rises above the support price, farmers repay the loans with interest and sell the grain in the market.

• If the market price remains at or below the loan rate, farmers forfeit the grain to the CCC, keep the money, and have no further obligation.

Page 98: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

98

D0

Q

S0

$1.5

4020

$2

60

Purchase and Release

$0.5

$1D1

If the price in the market falls below $2, the farmer forfeits the grain and does not repay the loan

$2.5

If the price in the market rises above $2, farmers sell their crop at the higher price and repay the loan.

Government loan= Production x $2(support price)

Page 99: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

99

Farmers compete against one another for the finite amount of farmland, bidding up its price.

•In this way the value of the price supports is incorporated into land prices. Thus, it is the owners of farmland, and not farmers per se, who are the principal beneficiaries of agricultural price supports.

Price supports cause larger production and smaller consumption (since consumers will buy less of any good as its price rises), resulting in overproduction at the support price.

The only way for the price support agency to get rid of its inventories is to use export subsidies to make them cheap enough that foreigners will buy them: Is subsidizing foreign consumption a proper use of taxpayer money?

•The EC uses this approach for grains. From the mid seventies to early eighties, internal EC grain prices were 150 to 200 percent of the prices at which other countries were willing to buy their grain. Subsidies to agriculture account for over two-thirds of the total EC budget.

Effect of Price Supports

Page 100: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

100

Will this announcement cause a shift or a Movement Along the Demand Curve?

16.You are watching a national news broadcast. It is reported that a typhoon is heading for the Washington coast and that it will likely destroy much of this year’s apple crop. Your roommate says, “If there are going to be fewer apples available, I’ll bet that apple prices will rise. We should buy enormous quantities of apples now and put them in storage. Later we will sell them and make a killing.”

Page 101: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

101

D

S

15

1000

10

20

25

500

5

1500

Figure 2

1. Equilibrium price is: ______ Equilibrium quantity is __________2. If the price is $20, there would be a (surplus/shortage)_________ of size__________3. Given your answer to #2 above, you expect the price to (increase/decrease/remain the

same) to _________4. Draw a supply and demand diagram showing the effect of an increase in cost of

production. Be sure to label properly old and new values (P0, Q0, P1,Q1 etc), show shortage/surplus and write your answer.

Quiz # 3 Name ___________

Page 102: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

102

D

S

10

20

25

5

Figure 2

90 210 650

6

Page 103: © 2000 Claudia Garcia-Szekely 1 Supply Claudia Garcia-Szekely.

103

D

S

10

15

25

5

Figure 2

420200 650

20