-1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für...

52
-1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering and Scintillation in Radio Astronomy Pushchino, Russia Monday, 19 June 2006

Transcript of -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für...

Page 1: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-1-

Coronal Faraday Rotation ofCoronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals Occulted Radio Signals

M. K. BirdArgelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn

International Colloquium on

Scattering and Scintillation in Radio Astronomy

Pushchino, Russia

Monday, 19 June 2006

Page 2: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-2-

OutlineOutline Coronal Faraday Rotation – Definition Coronal FR using Various Radio Sources

– Pulsars

– Extended Continuum Sources

– Spacecraft (Helios E12: 1975-1984)

FR Variations over Different Time Scales– Background Coronal Magnetic Field

– FR Signature of Coronal Mass Ejections

– FR Fluctuations: Alfvén Waves & Quasi-harmonic Oscillations

Coronal FR Mapping – the Future? Summary

Page 3: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-3-

Coronal Faraday Rotation - DefinitionCoronal Faraday Rotation - Definition

Page 4: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-4-

Faraday Rotation Faraday Rotation : Definition: Definition

sBB

N

f

K

dssBsNf

K

s

e

E

H

se

ˆ

)()(2

radians

2.36∙104 in MKS or cgs units

radio frequency (Helios: 2.3 GHz)

electron density

mag field proj. along ray path

with

Page 5: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-5-

Interplanetary Electron Column Density from EarthInterplanetary Electron Column Density from Earth

“Dispersion Measure”Units: hexems

1 hexem = 1016 el/m2

Earth

Sun

analogous plotfor Faraday Rotationdoes not exist!

I = ∫Ne(s) ds

Page 6: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-6-

Polarization Angle MeasurementPolarization Angle Measurement

Electric Vectors (semi-majoraxis of polarization ellipse):

E0 = Source (transmitted)

E = Measured (received)

Angle definitions:q = locally measured

polarization anglep = parallactic angle = Faraday rotation

Page 7: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-7-

Rotation Measure RM:Rotation Measure RM:

rad 2 RM

2-13 m rad ˆ1063.2

where

dssBNRM e

A rotation measure of RM = 1 rad m-2 yields:

= 0.97° at 2.3 GHz (=0.13 m) = 57.3° at 300 MHz (=1.0 m) = 1432° at 60 MHz (=5.0 m)

Page 8: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-8-

Coronal Faraday Rotation MeasurementCoronal Faraday Rotation Measurement

1. can be positive or negative (from polarity of interplanetary magnetic field)

2. Angle ambiguity ( ± m·180°)

3. Contributions from electron density and magnetic field cannot be separated without independent measurements

4. Correction for variable ionosphere necessary if solar offset R > 10 RS

Page 9: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-9-

Ionospheric Faraday RotationIonospheric Faraday Rotation

Page 10: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-10-

Coronal FR using Various Radio SourcesCoronal FR using Various Radio Sources

Page 11: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-11-

Coronal FR with PulsarsCoronal FR with Pulsars

Page 12: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-12-

Pulsars at Conjunction 1978-79Pulsars at Conjunction 1978-79

[Bird et al., Nature 283, 459-460, 1980]

Page 13: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-13-

Pulsar Pulse Profiles: Measurement TechniquePulsar Pulse Profiles: Measurement Technique

PSR 0525+21 PSR 0540+23

intrinsicprofile

modifiedprofile

p-angle:intrinsic

&modified

Page 14: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-14-

Coronal FR of PSR 0525+21 (1978-79)Coronal FR of PSR 0525+21 (1978-79)

Page 15: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-15-

Solwind Images during 1979 Occultation of PSR 0525+21Solwind Images during 1979 Occultation of PSR 0525+21

Page 16: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-16-

Coronal Magnetic Field from RM & DM: 1979Coronal Magnetic Field from RM & DM: 1979

Page 17: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-17-

Coronal FR with Coronal FR with Extended ContinuumExtended Continuum

Sources Sources

3C228

[Spangler, 2005]

A

B

C

1'

Page 18: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-18-

Coronal FR at VLA: 21 Aug 2003Coronal FR at VLA: 21 Aug 2003

RM:62.5 rad/m2

3C228

R = 7.1…6.2 RS

Page 19: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-19-

SOHO/LASCO: 16 AUG 2003SOHO/LASCO: 16 AUG 2003

3C228

3C228

Jupiter Venus

Page 20: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-20-

Coronal FR with HeliosCoronal FR with Helios

Helios – 1– Launch: 10 Dec 1974

– EOM: 15 Mar 1986

– q = 0.31 AU (P = 190 d)

– i = 0°, "spin up"

Helios – 2– Launch: 15 Jan 1976

– EOM: 08 Jan 1981

– q = 0.29 AU (P = 186 d)

– i = 0°, "spin down"

Page 21: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-21-

Earth-Sun Line Fixed: Helios-1Earth-Sun Line Fixed: Helios-1

Page 22: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-22-

Coronal Faraday Rotation: Helios ObservationsCoronal Faraday Rotation: Helios Observations

<FR> = 35.4° FR = 2.1°

Page 23: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-23-

Helios FR: Effelsberg/Goldstone

Page 24: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-24-

Coronal FR: Helios-1, Dec 1981Coronal FR: Helios-1, Dec 1981

180 ambiguity

Page 25: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-25-

FR Variations over Different Time Scales …FR Variations over Different Time Scales …Background Coronal Magnetic FieldBackground Coronal Magnetic Field

Page 26: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-26-

Ballerina Model of HCSBallerina Model of HCS

Page 27: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-27-

Radio Ray Path Geometry in the CoronaRadio Ray Path Geometry in the Corona

Page 28: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-28-

Coronal Faraday Rotation from Sector StructureCoronal Faraday Rotation from Sector Structure

r

RBB

r

RNN S

rS

e ;

Let

00

1

002max

1

2

then

R

RBN

f

KR SS

Page 29: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-29-

Mean Absolute FR: 1975-1976Mean Absolute FR: 1975-1976

|max| R-4.15

Page 30: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-30-

Coronal Electron Density: Coronal Electron Density: Radial ProfilesRadial Profiles

2120

0

m 104.1 2.45,

N

r

RNN S

e

Page 31: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-31-

Mean Coronal Magnetic Mean Coronal Magnetic Field 1975-76Field 1975-76

3 RS < R < 10 RS :

Br = 7.9 R-2.7 G (17) orBr = 6 R-3 + 1.2 R-2 G (18)

[Pätzold et al., Solar Phys. 109, 91, 1987]

Page 32: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-32-

FR Variations over Different Time Scales FR Variations over Different Time Scales … FR Fluctuations: Alfvén Waves & … FR Fluctuations: Alfvén Waves &

Quasi-harmonic OscillationsQuasi-harmonic Oscillations

Page 33: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-33-

FR Fluctuations: Standard Deviation vs. Solar OffsetFR Fluctuations: Standard Deviation vs. Solar Offset

Page 34: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-34-

FR Spectra for FR Spectra for Various Solar Various Solar

Offset DistancesOffset Distances

Andreev et al., [1996]

Page 35: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-35-

FR Spectral Index vs Solar OffsetFR Spectral Index vs Solar Offset

Page 36: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-36-

Two-Station Two-Station Coronal Sounding Coronal Sounding

MeasurementsMeasurements

Page 37: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-37-

Measuring Coronal VelocitiesMeasuring Coronal Velocities

Page 38: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-38-

Coronal Velocities from FR CorrelationsCoronal Velocities from FR Correlations

Page 39: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-39-

Two-Station FR MeasurementsTwo-Station FR Measurements

Page 40: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-40-

Simultaneous FR Spectra with QHCSimultaneous FR Spectra with QHC

Page 41: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-41-

Rapid Sequence of Rapid Sequence of FR SpectraFR Spectra

QHC comes…… and goes!

[Chashei et al., 1999]

Page 42: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-42-

FR Variations over Different Time Scales FR Variations over Different Time Scales … FR Signature of Coronal Mass Ejections … FR Signature of Coronal Mass Ejections

Page 43: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-43-

CME Passing throughCME Passing through Helios-2 Ray Path Helios-2 Ray Path

Solwind CoronagraphImages recorded during Helios Solar Occultations

In Oct/Nov 1979

[Bird et al., 1985]

Page 44: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-44-

CME Height-Time Diagram, 24 Oct 1979CME Height-Time Diagram, 24 Oct 1979

Page 45: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-45-

CME Magnetic Field Estimates, 24 Oct 1979CME Magnetic Field Estimates, 24 Oct 1979

UT Solar Offset

(RS)

I

(hexems)

(deg)

<BS>

(mG)

08:00 5.1 1.8 ±10 ±2

08:30 5.1 1.8 +20 +4

09:00 5.0 1.9 +40 +8

09:30 5.0 1.9 +55 +11

10:00 4.9 2.0 +35 +7

10:30 4.9 2.0 ±5 ±1

11:00 4.8 2.0 -45 -9

Page 46: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-46-

Coronal FR Mapping – the Future?Coronal FR Mapping – the Future?

Page 47: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-47-

One line of sight to a linearly polarized sourceOne line of sight to a linearly polarized source

Page 48: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-48-

Page 49: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-49-

Simulated Coronal FR for CR 1751Simulated Coronal FR for CR 1751

[J. Kasper, priv. comm, 2004.]

Page 50: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-50-

Transient Simulations: October 2003 CMEsTransient Simulations: October 2003 CMEs

CME not yet detected Large FR in 20 sources

CME!

Page 51: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-51-

FR Mapping – Conclusions regarding LOFARFR Mapping – Conclusions regarding LOFAR

Expected density of suitably polarized sources: 1 deg-2

FR maps could be used to test models of coronal magnetic topology

FR maps of transient flux ropes could be used to predict the geoeffectivity of the ensuing CME impact at Earth

Page 52: -1- Coronal Faraday Rotation of Occulted Radio Signals M. K. Bird Argelander-Institut für Astronomie, Universität Bonn International Colloquium on Scattering.

-52-

Coronal Faraday Rotation: SummaryCoronal Faraday Rotation: Summary

Faraday Rotation measurements provide a unique tool for investigating coronal magnetic structure…– Emperical model for the magnitude and radial dependence of the

background coronal magnetic field

– Evidence for outward (and inward) propagating Alfvén waves

– Evidence for dominance of magnetic fluctuations over density fluctuations

FR Mapping of CMEs is a difficult, but not hopeless, task.