Post on 28-Jun-2020
1
WhistleblowersunheardbyCQCByMinhAlexander,PamLinton,ClareSardariandafourthNHSwhistleblower,30November2016SummaryCommondecencyandgoodgovernancerequiresthatwhistleblower’sconcernsarelistenedto,properlyexplored,analysedforpatternsandtransparentlylearnedfrom.However,governmentsmaydeliberatelyputineffectiveorinadequatestructuresandprocessesinplacetodealwithwhistleblowers,tomakeitlookasifsomethingisbeingdonewhenitisnot.1ThePublicInterestDisclosureAct(PIDA)2iscriticallyflawedpartlybecauseitdoesnotsetouttheresponsibilitiesofthebodiesthathavealegaldutytoreceivedisclosuresfromwhistleblowers–socalled“prescribedpersons”.SincePIDAcameintoforcein1999,prescribedbodieshaverevealedlittleinformationaboutthenatureandextentofwhistleblowers’concerns.TheCareQualityCommission(CQC)isaprimeexampleofsuchopacity,despiterepeatedpromisestobetransparent.TheCQChasforyearsresistedproper,proactiveuseofwhistleblowerintelligence.TheCQChasunparalleledwhistleblowingdata,yetithasstillnotprovidedasystematic,nationalpictureofwhistleblowinginhealthandsocialcare.TheCQChasrespondedreluctantly,scantilyandsometimesinaccuratelywhenaskedfordataaboutitsanalysisanduseofwhistleblowerintelligence.EvenwithveryincompleteandpossiblyinaccuratereportingbyCQC,itseemstherehavewellbeenover33,347whistleblowingcontactswithCQCsinceitsinception.Fromdatafortheyear2012/13,thegreatmajority(86%)ofwhistleblowingcontactshaverelatedtosocialcare.However,thereisverylittledataonthenatureofconcernsorhowtheywereresolved.OnlypartialinformationhasbeenprovidedunderFOI,buteventhisshowsthatCQCisofteninformedaboutseriouscarefailuresandinstitutionalcoverups.However,thedataalsosuggeststhatCQCreliesheavilyonwhatemployerssaytheyhavedonetoresolvestaffconcerns.Quiteoften,CQCdoesnotevencontacttheregulatedbodyandmerelyrecordsveryseriousdisclosuresas“informationnotedforfutureinspections”,withnofurtherrecordofoutcome.1AnexampleofthisisthesituationinHungarywherewhistleblowerprotectionlawwaspassed,butnoagencywasestablishedtoreceiveorinvestigatedisclosures.http://blog.transparency.org/2013/11/12/hungarys-whistleblower-law-offers-no-real-protection/2PublicInterestDisclosureAct1998http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1998/23/contents
2
QuestionsariseaboutCQC’spastclaimtoHealthCommitteethatitwouldinvestigate“everysingle[whistleblower]case”.3ThereisnoevidencethatCQCsystematicallytrackswhetherwhistleblowersexperiencedetrimentafterwhistleblowing.CQChasmadenoefforttoanalyseintelligencesuppliedbyEmploymentTribunalsaboutwhistleblowingclaimsagainstemployers.CQClargelydoesnotrevealthenumbersofwhistleblowersineachorganisation.Thisaddstoisolationandmarginalisationtowhichwhistleblowersaresometimesdeliberatelysubjectedbyemployers.CQChasnottakenanyevidentactiontodeterstillwidespreaduseofgagsintheNHS.Ithasnotuseditspowerstoremoveanyseniormanagerswhohavecoveredupandmistreatedwhistleblowers.Whistleblowersarenotproperlyprotected.Unmetharmandneed,andmalfeasanceidentifiedbywhistleblowersremainlargelyobscured,atatimeofharshpublicsectorcutswhenwhistleblowers’voicesneedtobeheardloudandclear.CQChasfailedwhistleblowersandthepublicinthepast.Itstilldoesnotmeetparliament’sexpectationsonwhistleblowing.CQChasalsonotactedproperlyontherecommendationsoftheFreedomtoSpeakUpReviewonNHSwhistleblowing.WecallonparliamenttorecognisethatCQChasseriouslyfailedandisunlikelytochangeitsapproach,andtoensurethatthereisnowseriousandcrediblewhistleblowingreform.ContentsSummary Page11.Background Page32.CQC’shandlingofwhistleblowerintelligenceandapproachtowhistleblowers
Page5
2.2.Parliament’sexpectations Page52.3.Key,relevantrecommendationsfromtheFreedomtoSpeakUpReview
Page6
2.4.CQC’spromisesandperformanceonwhistleblowing Page6
3OralevidencebyMikeRichardsCQCChiefInspectorofHospitals17June2014toHealthCommitteeinquiryonwhistleblowing:“Whatwecansayisthateverysinglecasewillbeinvestigated.Wewilllookatthosewhistleblowingcasesaswehearaboutthem,orotherpatientconcerns,andsay,“Whoisthemostappropriatepersontobedealingwiththat?”Itmaybeoneofourinspectorsoritmaybeoneofourmanagers,oneofourheadsofhospitalinspection,butwewilltakeitseriouslyeverytime.”http://data.parliament.uk/writtenevidence/committeeevidence.svc/evidencedocument/health-committee/complaints-and-raising-concerns/oral/10801.html
3
2.4.1CQCpolicy Page72.4.2CQCdenialofresponsibilityforwhistleblowing Page72.4.3CQCregistrationandratingofproviders Page82.4.4CQCresponsetoWinterbourneView Page102.4.5CQCfailuretorecordwhistleblowingoutcomes Page102.4.6ExternalreviewofCQC’sresponsetowhistleblowers Page112.4.7CQC’swhistleblowingdatapilot Page112.4.8CQC’sinspectionmethodology Page122.4.9CQC’sintelligentmonitoring Page132.4.10CQCannualreports Page142.4.11CQCpublicationofdata Page152.4.12CQCFOIdisclosuresaboutwhistleblowingcontacts Page152.4.13ThereisaquestionovertheaccuracyofCQC’swhistleblowingfigures
Page20
2.4.14CQChandlingofintelligencefromEmploymentTribunals Page202.4.15CQChasnottoourknowledgesystematicallymeasuredwhistleblowers’experienceofitsprocess.
Page21
2.4.16CQC’sfailuretoapplyRegulation5FitandProperPersons Page222.4.17CQC’sfailuretoregulatetheuseofcompromiseagreements Page223.Conclusions Page221.BackgroundPIDAsaysremarkablylittleaboutthedutiesofprescribedpersons.4ThegovernmentsaidinareportofMarch2015thatthisisthepurposeofaprescribedperson:
“Thepurposeofaprescribedpersonprovidesworkerswithamechanismtomaketheirpublicinterestdisclosuretoanindependentbodythatmaybeabletoactonthem.Aworkerwillpotentiallyqualifyforthesameemploymentrightsasiftheyhadmadeadisclosuretotheiremployeriftheyreporttoaprescribedperson.”5
443FDisclosuretoprescribedperson.(1)Aqualifyingdisclosureismadeinaccordancewiththissectioniftheworker—(a)makesthedisclosureingoodfaithtoapersonprescribedbyanordermadebytheSecretaryofStateforthepurposesofthissection,and(b)reasonablybelieves—(i)thattherelevantfailurefallswithinanydescriptionofmattersinrespectofwhichthatpersonissoprescribed,and5DepartmentofBusiness,SkillsandInnovation.PrescribedPersonsguidanceMarch2015https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/415172/bis-15-201-Prescribed-persons-guidance.pdf
4
Theresponseofprescribedpersonstodisclosuresisun-standardised.Thegovernmentsaysthatprescribedpersonsmaytakearangeofactionsdependingontheirindividualpowers,butisvagueaboutwhattheseactionscomprise.Thesamereportalsostressestheimportanceof“managingthewhistleblower’sexpectations”.Andyetthegovernmentacceptsthatprescribedpersonsarecruciallyimportantwhenwhistleblowershavebeenunabletoprogresstheirconcernsinternally:
“Theprescribedpersonisparticularlyimportantwherethereisinternalresistancetoaddressingtheconcernsraised,eitherdeliberateorthroughinertia,orwheretheconcernsareembeddedwithinanorganisation,systematicallysupportedwithinitsoperationsoroccuratthehighestlevels.”
ThegovernmentrespondedtocriticismbythePublicAccountsCommitteein2014thatwhistleblowerintelligenceisunder-used6,byrequiringthatprescribedpersonsshouldpublishdataaboutthenumberofwhistleblowingdisclosuresreceivedandactiontakeninresponsetodisclosures.7ThisdutycomesintoforceinApril2017.Thegovernment’sproposalsinfactfallshortofPublicAccountsCommittee’srecommendationsformoremeaningfulandproactiveanalysis:
“Departmentsshouldcollectandapplyintelligenceonconcernsraisedbywhistleblowersfromthefullrangeofarm’slengthbodiesandotherprovidersinvolvedintheirsectors.Theyshoulduseandanalysethedatatoidentifyanysystemicissues.”6
TheyalsofallshortofPublicAccountsCommittee’srecommendationsforactivetrackingofdetrimenttowhistleblowers:
“24.Somedepartmentsacknowledgedatourhearingthattheydonotcollectgoodqualityintelligenceinconnectionwithwhistleblowing.Wefound,forexample,thatdepartmentsdonotrecordeventhemostbasicinformationonwhetherwhistleblowinghasbeendetrimentaltoanindividualordamagingtotheircareers.Noneofthedepartmentscouldtellushowmanywhistleblowerswentonlong-termsickleaveafterraisingaconcern.ThisindicatorisonethatisusedbytheUSCongressandbyEuropeaninstitutionstogaugewhetherarrangementsareworkingappropriately.
6PublicAccountsCommittee,Inquiryreportonwhistleblowing,1August2014http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201415/cmselect/cmpubacc/593/593.pdf7DepartmentforBusiness,SkillsandInnovation.Prescribedbodies.Annualreportingrequirementsonwhistleblowing.March2015.https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/411894/bis-15-2-whistleblowing-prescribed-bodies-reporting-requirements-government-response.pdf
5
…Departmentsshouldalsoconsiderhowtheycanenhancetheirsupportforwhistleblowers,lookingforinstanceatmeasuresliketrackingemploymentskillsandcareerprogressionandaskingwhistleblowersabouttheirviewsonthewhistleblowingprocess.”6
PublicAccountsCommitteehascontinuedtocriticisethegovernment’slackofappetiteforensuringgoodwhistleblowinggovernance.82.CQC’shandlingofwhistleblowerintelligenceandapproachtowhistleblowers2.2Parliament’sexpectationsExternalwhistleblowingdisclosurestoCQCrepresent,inmostcases,afailureofgovernancebyemployerstocreatetheconditionsinwhichconcernscanbesafelyraisedandresolved.HealthCommitteehasaskedCQCtoshowthatithastakenactioninresponsetowhistleblowingdisclosures:
“…inthemostseriouscasestheCQCmustdomorethansimplylistentothepublicandincorporatecommentsintoriskprofiles.IftheCQCistogenuinelytreatfeedbackfromthepublicasfreeintelligencethenitmustshowthatitcanactswiftlyonintelligencewhenseriouscomplaintsaremade.”9
HealthCommitteehasgoneasfarastorecommendthatCQCshouldrefusetoregisterproviderswhodonotcreateasafereportingenvironment:
“Akeyelementofthisassessmentshouldbeajudgementabouttheabilityofprofessionalstaffwithintheorganisationtoraiseconcernsaboutpatientcareandsafetyissueswithoutconcernaboutthepersonalimplicationsforthestaffmemberconcerned.Anorganisationwhichdoesnotoperateonthisprincipledoesnotprovidethecontextinwhichcarestaffcanworkinamannerwhichisconsistentwiththeirprofessionalobligations.ItshouldthereforeberefusedregistrationbytheCQC,”9
8PublicAccountsCommittee,Progressreportonwhistleblowing.11March2016http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201516/cmselect/cmpubacc/602/602.pdf9HealthCommitteereportofaccountabilityhearingwithCQC,2012http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201213/cmselect/cmhealth/592/592.pdf
6
2.3Key,relevantrecommendationsoftheFreedomtoSpeakUpReviewInFebruary2015RobertFrancisadvisedviahisreportoftheFreedomtoSpeakUpReview10thatCQCandotherregulatorsshoulddomoretoprotectwhistleblowers.
“Ibelievethereisscopeforthesystemregulatorstoplayabiggerroleinsupportingstaffwhoraiseconcerns.Irecommendthattheydomoretoexercisetheirpowerstotakeregulatoryactionagainstanyregisteredorganisationthatdoesnothandleconcerns,ortheindividualswhoraisetheminlinewiththegoodpracticesetoutinthisreport.Thisshouldincludeprotectingthosewhoraiseconcernsdirectlywitharegulator,aswellasthosewhohavedifficultieswithinternaldisclosures.”
Headvisedthatifneeded,regulatorsshouldseekchangesintheirpowersinordertoprotectwhistleblowers:
“CQC,Monitor,NHSTDAinconsultationwiththeDepartmentofHealthshouldworktogethertoagreeproceduresanddefinetherolestobeplayedbyeachinprotectingworkerswhoraiseconcernsinrelationtoregulatedactivity.Wherenecessarytheyshouldseekamendmentoftheregulationstoenablethistohappen”
InhisreportoftheFreedomtoSpeakUpReview,RobertFrancisalsorecommended:
“AllNHSorganisationsshouldpublishintheirQualityAccountsquantitativeandqualitativedataaboutformallyreportedconcerns.ThiscouldthenbeusedbytheNationalLearningandReportingSystemtoidentifysafetyissuesthatarecommonacrosstheNHS,andtospreadlearningandbestpractice.ThisrequirestheNHSsystemregulatorstoadoptacommonapproachtodataaboutconcerns,withasharedunderstandingofwhatgoodlookslike…”
2.4CQC’spromisesandperformanceonwhistleblowingAnauthoritativesourceonceobserved:
“CQCendedupwitharoletheydon’tunderstandorwant.…WhistleblowingalertswerediscussedbetweenCQCinspectorsandmanagerswithasigh.…Whatthey
10FreedomtoSpeakUpReview11February2015http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20150218150343/https://freedomtospeakup.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2014/07/F2SU_web.pdf
7
exceliniskeepingalidonwhistleblowers.…Andthat’swhattheSecretaryofStatereallyrequiresoftheorganisation.”
CQChasbeenrepeatedlycriticisedoverfailurestoactappropriatelyuponwhistleblowers’disclosures,bothinhealthandsocialcarecases.111213Therehavebeenvariouselementstothisfailure.2.4.1.CQCpolicy:InthefirsttwoandahalfyearsofCQC’slife,itdidnotevenhaveanyexternalwhistleblowingpolicytogovernthehandlingofwhistleblowingdisclosuresbythestaffofregulatedbodies.ItwassuggestedtoCQCinJune2011–amonthafterPanoramahadrevealedthecarescandalatWinterbourneView-thatCQCshouldhaveanexternalwhistleblowingpolicywithclearstandards.14ItwasnotuntilDecember2011thatCQCpublishedsuchapolicy.15CQChasalsoindicatedviavariousFOIdisclosuresthatitonlystartedrecordingwhistleblowingcontactsfromJune2011.2.4.2CQCdenialofresponsibilityforwhistleblowing:Inresponsetoa2014FOIenquiryaboutwhetherithadconductedanyanalysisofwhistleblowingintelligence,beyondsimplenumbers,CQCextraordinarilydeniedinDecember2014thatithadanyremitforwhistleblowingconcerns:
“ToclarifyCQCcanonlyreportonvolumes/outcomesinrelationtothewhistleblowingconcernsthatwereceive.However,itisnotwithintheroleofCQCtodealwithwhistleblowingconcerns.”16
Insteadofawillingnesstoseekchangestoitsregulationstoprotectwhistleblowers,asadvisedbyRobertFrancis,CQChasmoreoftenemphasisedwhatitcannotdotoprotectwhistleblowers.
11WinterbourneViewSeriousCaseReview4September2012http://sites.southglos.gov.uk/safeguarding/adults/i-am-a-carerrelative/winterbourne-view/12OrchidViewSeriousCaseReviewJune2014http://www.hampshiresab.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/June-2014-Orchid-View-Serious-Case-Review-Report.pdf13DoyoubelieveintheCareQualityCommission?DrPhilHammond23September2015http://www.drphilhammond.com/blog/2015/09/23/private-eye/medicine-balls-private-eye-1341/14LetterfromMinhAlexandertoJoWilliamsCQCChair23June2011“Iwouldalsosuggestthatallpublicbodieshaveawhistleblowingpolicythatisnotjustfortheirownstaffbutcoversotherpartieswhomaydisclosetothem.Soforinstance,thattheCQChasawhistleblowingpolicythatitcanroutinelygivetostafffromallNHSorganisationswhomaycontactthecommissiontoprovideintelligence,whichgivesclearinformationontheCQC'srelevantresponsibilitiesinthematter,confidentiality,howtheCQCwilldealwiththeperson'sconcerns,andtimescales.”15CQCstatement14December2011aboutthepublicationofanexternalwhistleblowingpolicyhttp://www.cqc.org.uk/content/quick-guide-raising-concern-about-your-workplace16CQCFOIresponse29December2014https://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/cqc-foi-response-29-12-2011-wb-data-analysis-20141229-to-cqc-iat-1415-0691.pdf
8
CQC-throughitsChiefInspectorofHospitals-promisedHealthCommitteeinJune2014that“everysingle[whistleblower]casewillbeinvestigated”.3However,CQCrepeatedlytellswhistleblowersthatithasnoremittoinvestigateindividualmatters.CQC’sDecember2014report“ComplaintsMatter”stressesthis:
“PeoplewithhistoriccasesalsocontactCQCinthehopethatwecanhelpresolvetheirconcernsorholdaprovidertoaccountforitsactions.Whileeachcaseprovideslearningforusabouttheproblemsthatcanoccur,andhowweneedtomouldournewmethodsofinspectiontodetectsimilarproblemsandtakeeffectiveaction,wedonothavetheremittoresolveanindividualcase.Aswithcomplaints,webelievethereisaregulatorygap…”17
CQChasalsoarguedthatoversightmay“undermine”employers’responsibilityfordealingwithconcerns:
“Finally,wewouldliketoemphasisethatthefirstresponsibilityfordealingwithstaffconcernshastobewithproviders.Anyproposedchangesthatintroducedfurthertiersororganisationsintothesystemshouldavoidunderminingtheresponsibilityofproviders.”18
2.4.3CQCregistrationandratingofproviders:Asforparliament’srecommendationthatCQCshouldrefusetoregisterprovidersongroundsthattheyhavefailedtocreateasafereportingculture,wearenotawarethatCQChaseverdoneso.Infact,weareawarethatCQChasratedorganisationswherewhistleblowershavereportedseriousdetrimentas“Good”andeven“Outstanding”.WellknownexamplesincludeSheffieldTeachingHospitalsNHSFoundationTrust,HomertonUniversityHospitalNHSFoundationTrust,BasildonandThurrockUniversityHospitalsNHSFoundationTrust,NorthumberlandTyneandWearNHSFoundationTrustandtheChristieNHSFoundationTrust.Therehavebeenmultiplewhistleblowersatthesetrusts.AnaccountbyoneoftheHomertonwhistleblowersonCQC’sfailurestoactproperlyuponconcernsispublishedbyparliament.19
17ComplaintsMatter.CQCreportoncomplaintsandwhistleblowing.December2014http://www.cqc.org.uk/sites/default/files/20141208_complaints_matter_report.pdf18CQCsubmissiontoFreedomtoSpeakUpReview17September2014https://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/20140917-cqc-submission-to-the-francis-review-freedom-to-speak-out-up.pdf19WrittenevidencebyPamLintontoHealthCommitteeInquiryonComplaintsandRaisingConcernshttp://data.parliament.uk/WrittenEvidence/CommitteeEvidence.svc/EvidenceDocument/Health/Complaints%20and%20Raising%20Concerns/written/7200.html
9
WhistleblowersoftensaythatCQCinspectionreportsdiluteevidenceofpoorwhistleblowinggovernance.AnexampleofthisisCQC’sreportingaboutSheffieldTeachingHospitalsNHSFoundationTrust.
SheffieldTeachingHospitalsNHSFoundationTrustTheCQCratedSheffieldTeachingHospitalsinJune2016as“Good”acrosstheboard.20CQCdealtminimallywithwhistleblowingdisclosuresinitsinspectionreport.Thisisdespiterecent,multiplewhistleblowingeventsandwhistleblowers’dissatisfactionwiththewayinwhichCQChasrespondedtotheirdisclosuresaboutpoorcare,manipulatedinvestigationsandthetrust’sbehaviourtowardswhistleblowers.CQCstatesinitsinspectionreport:
“Thetrusthadpreviouslyhadconcernsraisedinasmallnumberofservices.Theseincludedconcernsregardingclinicalcareandbullyingandharassment.Theinformationwereceivedwastakenintoaccountbytheteamsinspectingtherelevantcoreservices.Wedidnotfindanyevidenceofbullyingandharassmentduringtheinspection.…Whereissueshadbeenidentified,wesawtheyhadbeeninvestigated.Thisincludedthetrustcommissioningexternalindependentreviewsinresponse.Somereviewshadtakenlongerthanexpectedandthismeantfindingsandactionswerenotalwaysimplementedinatimelymanner.Welookedatthecommissionedexternalreviewsincardiacsurgery,plasticsurgeryandaudiovestibularmedicineandnotedthattherewerenosubstantialclinicalconcernsidentified”
FOIdatadisclosedbyCQCinfactrevealedatotalof22recordedwhistleblowingcontactsfromSheffieldTeachingHospitalsstaffsince2012(datawasalsorequestedfor2011butCQCadvisedthatitdidnotstartrecordingwhistleblowingcontactsuntilJune2011).21ItwasalsoevidentthatCQCmostlyreliedonwhatitwastoldbythetrustaboutthesematters.CQCinitiallyrefusedtodisclosethenumberofSheffieldwhistleblowersonspeciousgroundsoflownumbersandpotentialidentifiability,buteventuallyconcededthatthereitheldmorenamesthanitoriginallyclaimed.Intotal,therewere7namedwhistleblowersandanunknownnumberofanonymouswhistleblowers.22
20CQCinspectionreportonSheffieldTeachingHospitalsNHSFoundationTrust9June2016http://www.cqc.org.uk/sites/default/files/new_reports/AAAE8129.pdf21CQCFOIdataonwhistleblowingdisclosuresreceivedfromSheffieldTeachingHospitalsNHSFoundationTruststaffhttps://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/20160803-sheffield-teaching-hospitals-whistleblowing-contacts_ir7989-v2.xlsx22CQCFOIresponseaboutthenumberofwhistleblowersatSheffieldTeachingHospitalshttps://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/cqc-foi-response-number-of-sheffield-whistleblowers-6-september-2016.pdf
10
Suchinformationisofgreatimportancetowhistleblowersforavarietyreasons,butCQCinspectionreportsrarelyprovidecompletedataonthenumbersofstaffwhohaveraisedconcerns.Significantly,SheffieldTeachingHospitalshadahighnumberofcompromiseagreements(228overfiveyears).WhistleblowersbroughtthistoCQC’sattentionbutthereisnoevidenceinCQC’sinspectionreportthatithasexaminedanyofthese.23
2.4.4CQC’sresponsetoWinterbourneView:AftertheWinterbourneViewscandalinwhichaseriouscasereviewconcludedthatCQChadfailedpatientsandwhistleblowers,andwasnotcapableofdetectingthe“factandextentofinstitutionalabuse”11,theCQCpromisedthatwhistleblowerdisclosureswouldbetrackeduntilresolved.24Itproducedguidanceforitsstaffonhowtoprocesswhistleblowingcontacts.25CQCalsopromisedthatitwouldaudititshandlingofwhistleblowingdisclosures.CQChasnotpublishedanyoftheaudits,butDavidBehanCQCchiefExecutiveclaimedinoralevidencetotheHealthCommitteethatinternalauditshowed17ofasampleof40whistleblowingcontactstriggeredresponsiveinspections.24ItisnotclearwhatstandardsCQCauditeditselfagainst.Thesestandardsshouldbeinthepublicdomainandavailableforcritique.
2.4.5CQCfailuretorecordwhistleblowingoutcomes:CQC’shandlingofwhistleblowingdidnotimprovedespitethepromises.Scandalscontinuedtoemerge.CQC’ssubmissionof September 2014 to the Freedom To Speak Up Review, via David Behan CQC chiefexecutive18revealedthatCQC-hadupto2014-beenfailingtorecordtheoutcomesofwhistleblowers’ disclosures in thousands of cases. In 2013, 3154 of 9495 (33%) ofwhistleblowingdisclosures toCQChadno recordedoutcome.This submissionbyCQCwas not initially published, and only reluctantly disclosed months after CQC waschallengedaboutthislackoftransparency.
23FOIresponsebySheffieldTeachingHospitalsNHSFoundationTrustoncompromiseagreementshttps://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/sheffield-11-02-2016.pdf24Oralevidence,HealthCommitteeaccountabilityhearingwithCQC2012http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/cm201213/cmselect/cmhealth/592/120911.htm25CQCguidanceforstaff.HandlingconcernsraisedbyworkersofprovidersregisteredwithCQC.November2013https://www.whatdotheyknow.com/request/350100/response/855109/attach/3/CQC%20Whistleblowing%20Policy%20CQC%20IAT%201617%200300.pdf
11
2.4.6ExternalreviewofCQC’sresponsetowhistleblowers:InawrittensubmissionofFebruary2014toHealthCommittee’sinquiryintocomplaintsandraisingconcerns,theCQCclaimedthatitwouldundertakeareviewofitsperformanceasaprescribedpersonunderPIDAandthesupportthatitprovidedtowhistleblowers:
“An external independent review will also be conducted looking at how CQChandles protected disclosures made to it as a ‘prescribed person’, under thePublic InterestDisclosureAct (PIDA) by staff in care providers and can supportpeople who approach the CQC under PIDA. The terms of reference of both ofthese reviewshave justbeen finalised. It isanticipated that the reviewswillbecompletedbySpring2014.”26
TheCQCwassubsequentlyreluctanttoprovidemuchinformationaboutthisexercisewhenaskedtodosolastyear.Itadvisedthatitdidnotintendtopublishtheresultsofthereview,whichitadmittedcostapproximately£150K27andincludedthehireofaCapitaconsultant.CQCclaimedthatdespitethesignificantexpenditure,therewasnoreportontheoutcomeoftheexercise.IteventuallydisclosedcorrespondencebytheCapitaconsultanttoDavidBehan,whichpurportedtoserveasaprogressreport.28ThiscorrespondencegavenomeaningfuldetailonhowCQC’shandlingofwhistleblowinghadbeenorwouldbeimproved.Nevertheless,DavidBehanwrotetoHealthCommitteetoinsistthatCQChadbeentransparent.292.4.7CQCwhistleblowingdatapilot:CQCclaimedincorrespondenceonanoverlappingmatterthatitwasundertakingapilotofdatacollectionaboutwhistleblowingevents.Whenpressedformoreinformation,CQCreportedthatitwasexperimentingwithcategorisingthenatureofconcernsraisedbywhistleblowersbasedonananticipatedsampleof360whistleblowingcontacts.Ofconcern,CQCstatedthatitmightnotcontinuecategorisationofwhistleblowingdisclosuresalongtermbasis.30CQCalsoadvisedthatitwouldnotpublishtheoutcomeofthedatapilot.3126CQCwrittenevidenceFeb2014toHealthCommittee’sinquiryonComplaintsandRaisingConcernshttp://data.parliament.uk/WrittenEvidence/CommitteeEvidence.svc/EvidenceDocument/Health/Complaints%20and%20Raising%20Concerns/written/7294.html27CQCFOIdisclosure1October2015aboutcostofexternalreview(thisrelatedbothtoresponsestowhistleblowersandother“customercare”issues)https://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/cqc-foi-response-1-october-2015.pdf28Email2February2015fromCarolineFawcettCapitaconsultanttoDavidBehanCQCchiefexecutivehttps://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/cqc-iat-1516-0597-documents-for-disclosure.pdf29Letter24September2015byDavidBehantoSarahWollastonMPChairofHealthCommitteehttps://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/cqc-ext-indep-review-behan-response-24-09-2015-20150924-pocu-1516-0181-letter-to-dr-sarah-wollaston-re-dr-minh-alexander.pdf30Letter26August2015fromDavidBehantoMinhAlexanderhttps://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/20150826-pocu-1516-0181-dr-minh-alexander-wb-intel-final.pdf31Letter15September2015fromDavidBehantoMinhAlexanderhttps://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/cqc-behan-letter-re-pub-wb-pilot-received-16-09-2015-copy.pdf
12
Whenrecentlyaskedtodisclosetherelevantreportsfromthepilot,theCQCinitiallyclaimedthatitheldnosuchdata.Whenchallenged,theCQCadmittedthatitsinitialresponsewasincorrect.32Itdisclosedtworeports,onedated25September201533andanundateddocumentthatreportedonatrialofatriagetoolthatwascarriedoutinJuly2015.34Neitherofthesereportspecificallyonthe360whistleblowingdisclosuresorhowtheywerecategorised.Thereportsfocuslargelyonbureaucraticaspectsofcallhandling,suchasCQCstaffworkload,“efficiencies”,“productivity”andrespondingtoCQCinspectors’complaintsthattoomanywhistleblowingenquirieswerecodedas“high”priority.Theoutcomeoftheexercisewasthatalmosthalfofcallscodedashighprioritywerere-classifiedtomediumpriority.CQCconcludedthat:
“…informationcouldinsteadgodirectlytointelligenceforanalysisandreducedinspectorworkload”33
Soinshort,itseemsthattheobjectoftheexercisewasnottosomuchapatient-centredattempttoimprovelearningfromwhistleblowerintelligence,butaninstitution-centricexerciseincostcuttingtoreducetheinconvenienceposedbywhistleblowers.2.4.8CQCinspectionmethodology:CQCpromisedparliamentinFebruary2014thatitwoulddevelopamethodologyforinspectingregulatedbodies’whistleblowinggovernance:
“Wehavealsomadeacommitmentto‘inspectthewayhospitalslistenandrespondtocomplainantsandwhistleblowers…’andareintheprocessofdevelopingamethodologythatwillallowustodothisacrosshealthandsocialcareaspartofournewapproachtoinspections.”26
Famously,CQCrecruitedawhistleblowerviaasixmonthsecondmenttohelpimproveitsresponsetowhistleblowers.WhilstthisearnedCQCanendorsementandCQCusedthisventureformuchpublicrelationsgain,thereisnosubstantiveaccountorevidenceofchangesthatCQCactuallymadeasaresultofthiswork.ItissuggestedinablogpublishedbyCQCfourdaysaftertheFreedomtoSpeakUpReviewwasreleased,that
32CQCFOIcorrespondence21November2016https://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/20161121-final-decision-notice-cqc-iat-1617-0511.pdf33CQCinternalreport25September2015fromRespondingtoConcernsProgrammehttps://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/document-one-cqc-iat-1617-0511.pdf34UndatedCQCreportfromstafffocusgroupsonanewtriagetoolhttps://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/document-two-cqc-iat-1617-0511.pdf
13
thereweresubsequent“trials”andevaluation.ToourknowledgetheoutcomesofthesetrialsandevaluationshaveneverbeentransparentlyreportedbyCQC:
“Althoughmysecondmentendedlastyear,Iwasinvolvedintheevaluationoftheworkoncethetrialshadbeencompleted.IhavebeenkeepingacloseeyeonthingsastheydevelopatCQC;Ihaveeveryfaithinthem–andthatperhapsthingscanchangeforthebetter.”35
Similarly,CQCemployedahighprofile“NationalAdviserforPatientSafety”,whogaveoralevidencetoHealthCommittee’sinquiryoncomplaintsandraisingconcerns.Atahearingon17June2014,theNationalAdviserreportedthatCQCwasdevelopingaframeworkforinspectingwhistleblowinggovernancebyregulatedbodies.3However,wearenotawareofanysubsequent,specificCQCguidancetoinspectorsonhowtoinspectwhistleblowinggovernance.Thereareonlysomebriefsupportingnotestoinspectorsaboutthebasicsofwhistleblowerlegislation.CQC’sreport“ComplaintsMatter”gaveindicationsofbroadareasofinspection,buttherewasnodetailedmethodology.17ExaminationofgenericCQCinspectionframeworks36revealsnoclearstandards,onlygeneralquestionswithnoassociatedmeasures.Forexample:
“Dobothleadersandstaffunderstandthevalueofstaffraisingconcerns?Isappropriateactiontakenasaresultofconcernsraised?”“Doesthecultureencouragecandour,opennessandhonesty?”“Howarelessonslearnedfromconcernsandcomplaints,andisactiontakenasaresulttoimprovethequalityofcare?Arelessonssharedwithothers?”
A letter to CQC by whistleblowers in October 2015 about CQC’s lack of crediblemethodologyforinspectingwhistleblowinggovernance37didnotresultinanyeffectiveactionbytheCQC.2.4.9CQC’sintelligentmonitoring:CQCacknowledgesthatithas“…auniqueoverviewofqualityacrossthehealthandadultsocialcaresector”butithaspublishedlittleorganisation-levelwhistleblowingdata.
35BlogforCQCbyKimHolt,16February2015http://www.cqc.org.uk/content/whistleblowers-story36CQCinspectionframeworkshttp://www.cqc.org.uk/content/inspection-frameworks-hospital-and-ambulance-core-services37Letter19October2015toDavidBehanbywhistleblowers,onCQCinspectionmethodologyhttps://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/c2a0letter-to-cqc-19-october-2015.pdf
14
CQC’sso-called‘intelligentmonitoring’reportssometimesflagwhetherspecificorganisationshavebeensubjectto‘whistleblowingalerts’,buttheygivenoindicationofnumberandthemes.Forexample,foroverthreeyears,NorthCumbriaUniversityHospitalsNHSTrusthasbeenthetrustwiththemoststaffwhistleblowingdisclosurestoCQC(moreinformationisprovidedlaterinthisreport).However,fromthepublic’spointofview,allthatisvisibleisfiveintelligentmonitoringreportsthatacknowledgetherehavebeenwhistleblowingalerts.382.4.10CQCannualreports:CQCannualreportshavealsoprovidedlimitedandincompleteinformationonwhistleblowing,ininconsistentformats.CQChasreceivedwellover33,347whistleblowingcontactssinceinception.ThefulltotalisunknownbecauseCQChasnotprovideddataforthreeoutofsevenyears.Table1.DatainCQCannualreportsaboutwhistleblowingYear Datagiveninannualreportaboutwhistleblowingdisclosures
receivedbyCQC2009/10 Nospecificmentionofwhistleblowing2010/11 Afewanecdotalreferencestowhistleblowers’sdisclosurestoCQC,
butnostatisticaldataprovided2011/12 InresponsetofailuresexposedatWinterbourneView,theCQC
claimedthatithadestablishedawhistleblowingteamtospecificallydealwithconcernsreceived,thatitwasreceivinganaverageof400whistleblowingdisclosuresamonth,andthatitwasundertaking“periodicauditsofasampleofcasestoanalysehowwhistleblowinginformationisbeingused.“[Assumingthattherateofcontactswas400/monththroughthewholeyear,thisgivesatotalof4800whistleblowingcontactsfortheyear]
2012/13 CQCreportedthatthenumbersofwhistleblowerdisclosureshaddoubledto8643overtheyear,andthatthevastmajorityrelatedtosocialcare–7456(86%)
2013/14 CQCreportedthatithadreceived9473whistleblowerdisclosuresandthatithadaskedanNHSwhistleblowertoadviseitonimprovingitsprocesses.
2014/15 Nodataprovidedonwhistleblowingdisclosures,apartfromonecaseexample.[Inoralevidencetoparliament,DavidBehanstatedthatCQChadreceived1573whistleblowingcontactsintheperiod1April2014toJune2014]
2015/16 CQCreportedthatwhistleblowingdisclosuresformed11%ofall80,530concernsreceivedbyCQC.[Thisgives8858whistleblowing
38CQCintelligentmonitoringreportsonNorthCumbriaUniversityHospitalsNHSTrusthttp://www.cqc.org.uk/provider/RNL/reports
15
disclosures]Total Theabovegivesatotalfigureinexcessof33,347whistleblowing
contactstoCQC,todate
2.4.11CQCpublicationofdata:Asabove,RobertFrancishadanexpectationthatallNHSorganisationsshouldregularlypublish“quantitativeandqualitativedata”onwhistleblowingconcernsraisedbytheirstaff.
CQChasnothelditselftothisstandard,eitherwithrespecttoreportingonwhistleblowingbyitsownstaff,orwhistleblowingbystaffoftheorganisationsthatitregulates.CQCgavenoinformationonwhistleblowingbyitsstaffinthetwoannualreportspublishedaftertheFreedomtoSpeakUpReview.Moreover,CQChasdecidedthatitsownlocalFreedomtoSpeakUpGuardianshouldnotrelatetotheNationalGuardian.39
“ThedecisionbyCQCtoappointitsowninternalGuardianisseparatetothearrangementsfortheNationalGuardianandtherewillbenoformalworkingrelationshipbetweenthetworoles.”
ThestructuralisolationofCQC’slocalGuardianandCQC’slackofaccountabilityaboutitsinternalwhistleblowingaffairssetapoorexampletotheorganisationsthatCQCregulates.2.4.12CQCFOIdisclosuresaboutwhistleblowingcontacts:InMay2014,viaFOI,CQCprovideddataonthenumberofwhistleblowingdisclosuresabouttheNHSintheyearbetweenMay2013andApril2014.40Thisdisclosurerevealedatotalof981contactsbythestaffofEnglishNHStrustsovertheyear.Analysisofthedatarevealsarangeof1to33whistleblowingcontacts(averageof4.8)pertrust.Twentyfivetrusts,mostlyacute,werethesubjectof10ormorewhistleblowingcontactstoCQC.TheyaccountedforalmosthalfofallwhistleblowingcontactstoCQC(402of981).Mentalhealthtrustsaccountedforalmostaquarterofthewhistleblowingcontacts(222of981).41The25trustswiththehighest
39CQCFOIresponse25January2016https://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/cqc-local-guardian-appt-nat-guardian-foi-response-25-01-2016-iat-1516-0638.pdf40CQCFOIdataMay2014https://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/cqc-foi-on-wb-disclosures-may-2013-to-april-2014.xlsx41AnalysisofdisclosurestoCQCaboutmentalhealthtrusts1May2013to30April2014https://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/wb-disclosures-to-cqc-on-mh-trusts-may-2013-to-april-2014.xlsx
16
numberofwhistleblowingcontactsaregiveninTable2.Manyofthenameswillbeveryfamiliartowhistleblowers.Table2.TrustswiththehighestnumberofstaffwhistleblowerdisclosurestoCQCNHSTrust Numberofstaffwhistleblowingcontacts
madewithCQCMay2013-April2014NorthCumbriaUniversityHospitalsNHST 33BartsHealthNHST 27YorkshireAmbulanceService 25UniversityHospitalsofLeicesterNHST 24ColchesterHospitalUniversityNHSFT 23OxfordUniversityHospitalsNHSFT 22NorfolkandSuffolkNHSFT 19HeatherwoodandWexhamParkHospitalsNHSFT
18
MidYorkshireHospitalsNHST 15EastLancashireNHST 15HeartofEnglandNHSFT 14WirralUniversityTeachingHospitalNHSFT 14CroydonHealthServicesNHST 13NottinghamUniversityHospitalsNHST 13TamesideHospitalNHSFT 13DorsetHealthcareUniversityNHSFT 12HullandEastYorkshireNHST 12UnitedLincolnshireHospitalsNHST 12StGeorgesHealthcareNHST 12BrightonandSussexUniversityHospitalsNHST
11
StGeorgesHealthcareNHST 12LiverpoolCommunityHealthNHST 11NorthernLincolnshireandGooleNHSFT 11UniversityHospitalsofMorecambeBayNHSFT
11
LeedsTeachingHospitalsNHST 10Significantly,CQCstatedinthisFOIresponsethat“CQChasnotperformedanycentralanalysisofthereasonsbehindeachwhistleblowingconcernwehavereceived.”Clearly,thisinformationhasthepotentialtoseriouslyembarrassthegovernment,butsuchanalysisisvitaltounderstandingsystemicproblemsandriskstopatientsandsocialcareusers.
17
AglimpseintoCQC’svastpoolofwhistleblowingdatawasaffordedwhenthemediareportedonanFOIaboutthenatureofNHSwhistleblowingdisclosurestoCQC.42TheCQCdeclinedtoprovideallthedatarequested,butevenitspartialdisclosureonstaffconcernsinfivetrustswiththehighestnumberofwhistleblowingreportsrevealedseriousanddisturbingmatters.43ThefivetrustswereNorthCumbria,OxfordUniversity,Colchester,MidYorksandBarts.TherewereallegationsthatNHSmanagersignoredconcernsandriskstopatients,manipulatedthesystemandtoldstaffto“lietoCQCinspectors”.Forexample,theseweresomeofthestaffdisclosuresabouttheverytroubledColchesterHospitalUniversityNHSTrust:
“Complaintaboutlackofpermanentstaff-onlytemps.Alsolackoftransparencyreinvestigations.Staffareunabletoraiseissueswithmanagers,astheydiscriminate.AlsoallegationthatmanagersemploymorestaffpriortoCQCinspection.”“Concernswithstaffinglevelsonward.AllegationelderlySUarebeingneglected.”“Allegationsofabullying/blameculturefromseniormanagementleadingtostafffearingtoraisewhistleblowingconcerns.Alsoconcernsthatpatientsareatriskduetopatientsbeingoffloadedfromambulancesandleftincorridorswithminimumfacilitiesandsupportforextendedperiodsoftime.”
AnupdateFOItoCQCrevealedthattherateofwhistleblowingcontactsbyNHStruststaffhascontinuedatbroadlythesamerateoverthefinancialyears2013to2016,withatotalof2959contactsandanaverageof986ayear,withanaverageof3.9contactspertrustperyear.44NorthCumbria,oneofthe14“Keogh”trusts45,remainsthetrustthatwhistleblowerscomplainaboutthemosttoCQC.Inthethreefinancialyears2013to2016,therewerea
42WhistleblowingNHSstaffcomplainedabouthospitalfailingsincludingdrugdealingandpoorcare,MatthewDavis,Mirror26April2015http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/whistleblowing-nhs-staff-complained-hospital-558469943CQCFOIdataonwhistleblowingdisclosuresbyNHSstaffhttps://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/cqc-foi-20150330-cqc-iat-1415-0865-enquiries-top-5-internal-review-for-disclosure.xlsx44CQCFOIdisclosure24October2016onwhistleblowingdisclosureshttps://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/20161019-final-information-for-disclosure-cqc-iat-1617-0427.xlsx45Reviewintothequalityofcareandtreatmentprovidedby14hospitaltrustsinEngland:Overviewreport,BruceKeogh,NHSEngland16July2013http://www.nhs.uk/nhsengland/bruce-keogh-review/documents/outcomes/keogh-review-final-report.pdf
18
totalof83disclosures,manyofwhichrelatetobullying,failuretolistentostaff,unsafestaffing,whistleblowerreprisal,allegedmanipulationanddishonestyinthemanagementofthetrust.Table3.SomeofthemostworryingdisclosuresaboutNorthCumbriawereasfollows:Dateofdisclosure
NatureofconcerndisclosedtoCQC ActionthatCQCsaysittookinresponsetodisclosure
December2013
Concernsthatincidentsarenotbeingproperlyinvestigatedandclosedinordertomanipulateperformancefigures
Informationnotedforfutureinspection
January2014 ConcernaboutmonitoringandcontrolofthebacteriaPseudomonasinthehospitalwatersupply
DiscussedwithTrustchiefexecutive
March2014 Concernsthatincidentsarenotbeingproperlyinvestigatedinordertomanipulateperformancefigures.
Informationnotedforfutureinspection
April2014 Concernthatlessonsnotlearnedfromrecentnevereventreviews
Informationnotedforfutureinspection
April2014 Concernsthatawhistleblowerwasbadlytreatedafterraisingconcernswithmanagementandacultureofbulllyingandharassment.
Informationnotedforfutureinspection
September2014
Concernsaboutincidentreporting,thatmanagementdonotinvestigateincidentsappropriatelyandallegationthatinvestigationoutcomefiguresaremanipulated.
Informationnotedforfutureinspection
November2014
Concernthatmanagementarepressurisingstafftosigntosaytheyhavehadtrainingwhentheyhavenot.Staffhavetotrainthemselvestouseequipment.Lackofconsistencyintraining/competenceacrosswards.
HeadofHospitalsInspectioninformedNotedforfutureinspection
March2015 Concernsaboutpoorstaffinglevelscompromisingcareofserviceusersandmanipulatingofresultstomakethedepartmentlookgood
HeadofHospitalsInspectioninformedNotedforfutureinspection
March2015 Concernsaboutmanipulating/misplacingresultscausingpatientcaretobecompromised
HeadofHospitalsInspectioninformedNotedforfutureinspection
April2015 Concernsaboutmanipulatingresults Notedforfuturereviews
19
ItisofgreatconcernthatrepeatedallegationsoffalsificationbyNorthCumbriamanagementweresimplynotedbyCQCforfutureinspection.AkeystandardrecommendedbyRobertFrancisandadoptedbythegovernmentisthathealthcareorganisationsshouldpublishtruthfuldata.Amoreresponsiveapproachissurelyrequiredwhenthereareallegationsthatorganisationsarereportingdishonestly.Ofthe83whistleblowingdisclosuresbyNorthCumbriastaff,67weresimply“notedforfutureinspection”or“notedforfuturereview”.Ofthese67,aHeadofHospitalsInspectionwasinformedin12instances.ThemostthatCQCdidinresponsetowhistleblowerdisclosureswastooccasionallydiscusstheissueswiththeTrust.Nowhereisthereanyreferencetoactive,externalreviewofthetrust.Infact,whenonewhistleblowercomplainedthatconcernsthatweredisclosedtotheKeoghreviewteamhadnotresultedinmeaningfulaction,CQCalsosimplynotedthisforfutureaction.Whilstthepicturethatemergesfromthisdataisdisturbing,itcorrelateswiththeexperienceofmanywhistleblowerswhohavereportedbeingfobbedoffbytheCQC.ThedatacertainlydoesnotsupportaclaimmadetoparliamentbyCQC’sChiefInspectorofHospitalson17June2014:
“Whatwecansayisthateverysinglecasewillbeinvestigated.”3
Indeed,thedataandinspectionreportsprovidealmostnoevidencethattheCQCfollowedupthegravedisclosureswithchecksonNorthCumbriawhistleblowers’wellbeing,andwhethertheyperceiveddetrimentafterwhistleblowing.ThisisoneofthemostdisappointingaspectsofCQC’sresponsetowhistleblowers.Parliamenthasadvisedthatitisimportantforpublicbodiestorecordandmonitordetrimentexperiencedbystaffwhoraiseconcerns.RobertFrancisadvisedthatCQCshouldassessthewayNHSproviderstreatedwhistleblowersaspartofthe“WellLed”domain.CQChasapproachedthissuperficiallyinmostofitsinspectionreports.Itreportsprimarilyonstaffwillingnesstoraiseconcerns,andusuallyavoidsanyaccountsofreporteddetrimenttowhistleblowers.CQC’sinspectionreportsonNorthernCumbriahavenotrevealedthegravityofstaffdisclosures.Theyrefermostlytothefactthatdisclosureshavebeenmade,butnotwhattheycomprise.CQCreportsreferredtoproblemsofculture,withoutreportingthattheseincludeseriousallegationsofdishonesty.TheinspectionreportscontainnoreferencetoFitandProperPersons,otherthancommentsonthetrust’scompliancewithbureaucraticprocess.Despitethestaffreportsofseriousmanagementmisconduct,CQCasserted:“Manyoftheconcernscouldandshouldhavebeenaddresseddirectlybymanagerswithstaff.”Thisisaminimisationofthesevererisksandobstaclesthatstafffacewheretherearemanagementcoverups.
20
Italsoevidentthatatnationallevel,CQCisstillnotanalysingthethemesfromwhistleblowingdisclosures.On13September2016CQCadvisedthat“currentlytheCQChasnotconductedanyanalysisofenquiriesrecordedaswhistleblowing”.46On21September2016,CQCadvisedthatthewhistleblowingdataitholdscentrallyrelatesonlytothenumbersofdisclosures,andnootherinformationhasbeencentrallycollated.47Ofcourse,afailuretoanalysedatahastheeffectofprotectingCQCfromFreedomofInformationrequests,andundertherules,enablesCQCtorefuserequestsfordataonthenationalpictureongroundsofcost.2.4.13ThereisaquestionovertheaccuracyofCQC’swhistleblowingfigures.InanFOIresponseof13September2016,CQCclaimedthatithadreceivedatotalof254whistleblowingcontactsfromthestartoffinancialyear2016/17.Prorata,thisgivesanumberof609fortheyear,whichisasharpdropfromthepreviousyear.However,CQChasdeniedthatitsmethodofcountingwhistleblowercontactshaschanged.2.4.14CQChandlingofintelligencefromEmploymentTribunals:Asaprescribedbody,CQCreceivesnotificationsfromEmploymentTribunalsaboutlegalactiontakenbywhistleblowersagainstregulatedbodies,ongroundsofwhistleblowingdetriment.Thisinformationisaveryimportantindicatoroflikelycoverupsandmistreatmentofwhistleblowers.However,FOIdatarevealsthatCQChasalsofailedtoproperlyanalysethisintelligence:
“WedonotcurrentlylogorrecordET1forms[ET1formsaresummariesofindividualclaimstotheEmploymentTribunal]inacentraldatabaseandhavenotconductedanoverallanalysis.Instead,anyET1formwereceiveisloggedagainstourrecordsfortherelevantprovider.”48
CQCrefusedtoprovidenationaldataonET1formsreceived,ongroundsofpurportedcost.Adatadisclosedon24November2016,onasampleoftrustsknowntohavehadsignificantwhistleblowingproblems,revealsrelativelylownumbersofnotificationsbytheEmploymentTribunal.
46CQCFOIresponse13September2016https://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/pam-linton-cqc-foi-correspondence-september-2016.pdf47CQCFOIresponse21September2016https://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/cqc-correspondence-21-09-2016-only-numbers-held-centrally.pdf48CQCFOIdisclosure27October2016https://minhalexander.files.wordpress.com/2016/09/cqc-foi-response-et1-intelligence-27-october-2016.pdf
21
WebelievetheET1datasuppliedbyCQCisunreliable:
2.4.15CQChasnottoourknowledgesystematicallymeasuredwhistleblowers’experienceofitsprocess.Instead,CQCisaversetochallengeandhasonoccasionsoughttocharacteriseitscriticsasdifficult.Ithasattimesrespondedlegalisticallyandthreatenedorimposedcommunicationbans.CQChasalsotriedtoresistrequestsforinformationbythreateningtodeclareoractuallydeclaringrequestsas“vexatious”.Forexample,CQCdeemedanFOIrequestaboutDavidBehan,DavidPriorandWinterbourneViewas“vexatious”.Theinformationcommissionersubsequentlyoverturnedthis.49CQCalsofrequentlyrefusestohearfromwhistleblowersabouttheirexperiencesofvictimisation,claimingthatemploymentmattersarenotwithinitsremit,wheninfactreprisalagainstwhistleblowersisinfactaveryseriousgovernanceissue.
49ICOdecisionnotice20August2014https://ico.org.uk/media/action-weve-taken/decision-notices/2014/1021508/fs_50532615.pdf
22
2.4.16CQC’sfailuretoapplyRegulation5FitandProperPersons:InadditiontoCQC’swilfulblindnessandrelativesilenceaboutwhistleblowerdetriment,CQChasalsonotuseditspowersunderRegulation5FitandProperPersons(FPPR)toremoveanyseniormanagerswhohavesuppressedandharmedwhistleblowers.5051ItsgeneralfailureonFPPRhasbeensoseriousthatevenRobertFrancis,aCQCnonexecutivedirector,haspubliclyacknowledgedthatFPPRisnotworking.522.4.17CQC’sfailuretoregulatetheuseofcompromiseagreements:RobertFrancisadvisedintheFreedomtoSpeakUpReviewreportthatCQCshouldinspectthecompromiseagreementsusedbyemployers.CQCclaimedthatitwoulddosoif“necessary”.ThereisinfactnoevidencefromareviewofallinspectionreportsonNHStruststhatCQChasexaminedanycompromiseagreements.53OngoingFOIworkshowsthatgaggingremainswidespreadintheNHSandthatsomeemployersusegaggingclausesasstandard.3.ConclusionsCQC’srepeatedfailurestoactappropriatelyuponwhistleblowers’concernshavedamagedpublicconfidence.Thereisnosubstantiveevidenceofchange.CQC’sinspectionmethodologyonregulatedbodies’whistleblowinggovernanceisnotrigorous.Itlacksclearlydefinedstandardsandsodoesnotlenditselftoauditandmeasurement.CQC’sresponsestowhistleblowers’disclosuresaretoooftenpassiveandreluctant.CQCstilldoesnotanalysethemesinwhistleblowingdisclosures.CQCdoesnotseemtohavestoredwhistleblowerintelligencereceivedfromEmploymenttribunalsinasystematicmatter,andithasnotanalysedthisvitalinformation.
50CQC’sFitandProperParade.MinhAlexander29July2016https://minhalexander.com/2016/09/24/cqcs-fit-and-proper-parade/51FitandProperMess.MinhAlexander19October2015https://minhalexander.com/2016/10/19/fit-and-proper-mess/52RobertFranciscallsforregulationofseniormanagers.HealthServiceJournal9November2016https://www.hsj.co.uk/topics/workforce/exclusive-robert-francis-calls-for-regulation-of-senior-managers/7013089.article53NHSgagging.HowCQCsitsonitshands.MinhAlexander22September2016https://minhalexander.com/2016/09/23/nhs-gagging-how-cqc-sits-on-its-hands-2/
23
Fromtheperspectiveofwhistleblowers’experience,whistleblowingisahighlyriskyventure.Riskofreprisalincreasesifstaffpersistinraisingtheirconcernsormakedisclosuresoutsideoftheirorganisations.WherestaffarebraveenoughtotaketheaddedriskofcontactingtheCQC,thisoftendoesnotresultinsatisfactoryorproportionatesystemresponses.Employersmaybetippedoff(evenifdisclosuresaremadeanonymously),andtheycanrealisticallycountontheCQCnottotakemuchrealactionorfullyrevealtheextentofgovernancefailures.CQCisnotrigorouslytrackingwhistleblowers’experience,eitherofemployers’orCQC’sprocesses,andisnotinacrediblepositiontojudgewhetheremployershavegoodwhistleblowinggovernance.CQCreportsverysuperficiallyonhoworganisationstreatwhistleblowers.Thisregulatorywilfulblindnessgivesemployersafreehandtointimidateandvictimisestaff.CQC’sfailuretoreportclearlyonthenumbersofwhistleblowersforeachorganisationalsohastheeffectofreinforcingtheisolationandmarginalisationthatemployersdeliberatelyimposeonwhistleblowers,todisempowerandintimidatethem.ThesefailuresareallthemoreseriousbecausetheypersistoversevenyearsafterCQCwasestablished.ThislevelofrepeatedfailurecallsintoquestionwhetherCQCwishestosupportbetterwhistleblowinggovernance.WedonotbelieveontheevidenceavailablethatCQCprioritisesthepublicinterestorwhistleblowers’welfare.Webelievethatparliamentshouldstoppatchingupanunrepairable,unreliableregulatorymodel.Muchmorefundamentalreformofwhistleblowerprotectionisneeded.Thisshouldincludesubstantivelawreform,robustandindependentinvestigationofwhistleblowers’concernswhenneeded,andmuchgreatertransparencyaboutthesystemresponsetowhistleblowers.END