Post on 11-Feb-2018
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
1/99
DAVAO MEDICAL SCHOOL FOUNDATION, INC
Medical School Drive, Bajada, Davao City
College of Nursing
VIEWS AND REASONS OF ADULT CANCER PATIENTS
ON THE USE OF COMPLEMENTARY AND
ALTERNATIVE MEDICINES
A Research Paper Presented to the Faculty of College
of Nursing in Davao Medical School Foundation
In Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements
in Bachelor of Science in Nursing
By
Norman B. Juruena, BSN
Principal Researcher
Jean Leslie C. Bughao, BSN
Reyveen John B. Geli, BSN
Kathlyn Janine S. Mones, BSN
Mary Laureen M. Santarin, BSN
Rosthy John L. Soria, BSN
Rinnah Grace Q. Talatagod, BSN
Co-Researchers
March 2012
i
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
2/99
APPROVAL SHEET
ii
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
3/99
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The researchers would like to express their deepest gratitude and indebtedness to
the following people who gave their full support and invaluable help to make this study
possible:
To Ms. Elsie S. Callueng, RN, MAN, the researchers mentor, for her support and
untiring guidance, as well as valuable suggestions and inspiring words of encouragement
to finish this study;
To Mr. Ruperto Hector A. Lindo, MAEd, the research coordinator who facilitated
this thesis, endowing the researchers with valuable suggestions and for his patience in
guiding us in completing this study;
To the members of the panel at Southern Philippines Medical Center, Ms. Vilma
Comoda, RN, MAN, Ms. Elizabeth Barriga, RN, MAN, Mr. Rueben Gaoaen, RN, MAN,
Ms. Madel Dapit and Ms. Angie Revilla for their availability and for their suggestions
and positive approaches in the improvement of this thesis;
To Ms. Elizabeth R. Soriano, RN, MAN, the Dean of College of Nursing, for
allowing the research team to conduct this study;
iii
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
4/99
To our beloved parents, for providing us the moral, financial support and
commitment to help sustain the researchers in their field of endeavour, and for the faith
and inspiration to finish this study;
And most of all, to Almighty God, who is the researchers ultimate source of
knowledge, strength, wisdom, inspiration, guiding consciousness and strength during the
difficult moments of writing this thesis.
The Researchers
iv
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
5/99
DEDICATION
The researchers dedicate this research work to God Almighty,
the source of wisdom and inner strength; and also,
to the future health care professionals.
The researchers also dedicate this research work to their loved ones,
whose assistance and understanding transcended everything
until the completion of this research work.
v
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
6/99
ABSTRACT
Complementary and Alternative Medicines are healthcare systems, practices, and
products not considered a part of conventional medicine. The use of CAM has increased
steadily over the past 15 years or so, and undoubtedly it has gained medical, economic
and sociological importance (National Center of Complementary and Alternative
Medicine, 2009). This study used qualitative interviews specifically in-depth interview
approach as the method of data collection. This study had provided a qualitative account
of the adult cancer patients views and reasons on the use of complementary and
alternative medicines and the rationales behind their perspectives. The researchers sought
out five (5) possible respondents for this study who were currently admitted in a local
tertiary hospital. Three (3) respondents came from Internal Medicine Ward while the two
(2) remaining respondents came from Gynecology Ward. The researchers named the
following patients as Respondent A, Respondent B, Respondent C, Respondent D and
Respondent E. In conclusion, the five (5) respondents showed varied views and reasons
on the use of complementary and alternative medicines. Most of them viewed these
treatment modalities were partially effective in treating cancer due to several factors such
as age and absence of underlying illness. Furthermore, majority of the respondents had
shared common reasons on the use of complementary and alternative medicines such as
financial constraint, hope to cure cancer, reduced side-effects of chemo drugs and by the
influenced of others. With these views and reasons, it only showed that the use of
complementary and alternative medicines needs further research and progressive
investigation on its proper applications especially on its role as adjunctive therapy for
cancer.
vi
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
7/99
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Title Page .... i
Approval Sheet ... ii
Acknowledgement . iii
Dedication .. v
Abstract . vi
Table of Contents .. vii
List of Figures .. x
List of Tables x
I. CHAPTER I Introduction
Background of the Study .... 1
Conceptual Framework ... 3
Theoretical Framework ... 4
Statement of the Problem .... 8
Significance of the Study ..... 9
Scope and Delimitations ...... 9
Definition of Terms .... 10
II. CHAPTER II Review of the Related Literature
Related Readings .... 12
Demographic and Clinical Profile ..... 15
vii
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
8/99
Views and Reasons of Cancer Patients . 18
Related Studies .. 22
III. CHAPTER III Methodology
Research Design .... 25
Locale of the Study ... 25
Unit of Analysis ........ 25
Sampling Design ... 26
Data Collection Procedure .... 26
Treatment of Data ..... 27
Data Analysis .... 28
Ethical Consideration .... 28
IV. CHAPTER 1V Results and Discussions
Results ... 36
Discussions ... 36
Selected Demographic Profile . 37
Selected Clinical Profile .. 38
Respondents Views 39
Respondents Reasons . 42
V. CHAPTER V Summary, Conclusion and Recommendation
Summary .. 50
viii
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
9/99
Conclusion ... 52
Recommendation . 52
BIBLIOGRAPHY . 54
APPENDICES
Appendix 1 . 62
Appendix 2 . 64
Appendix 3 . 66
Appendix 4 . 69
Appendix 5 . 72
Appendix 6 . 74
Appendix 7 . 77
Appendix 8 . 80
Appendix 9 . 83
ix
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
10/99
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1. Schematic Diagram showing the Independent and Dependent Variable
of the Study .... 3
Figure 2. Revised Health Promotion Model by Nola J. Pender, 1996 ... 6
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1. Manner of Data Analysis 28
Table 2. Authorship and Contributorship . 33
x
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
11/99
CHAPTER I
INTRODUCTION
Background of the Study
Complementary and Alternative Medicines are healthcare systems, practices, and
products not considered a part of conventional medicine. Complementary therapies are
used concurrently with conventional medicine, alternative therapies are used in place of
conventional medicine, and integrative therapies combine mainstream medical therapies
with complementary or alternative therapies for which some high-quality scientific
evidence of safety and efficacy exists (National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine, 2009).
In the United States, about four (4) in ten (10) adults and one (1) in nine (9)
children are using some form complementary and alternative therapy according to the
National Health Interview Survey (Barnes, Bloom & Nahim, 2008). These therapies have
been broadly categorized as alternative medical systems, energy therapies, exercise
therapies, manipulative and body-based methods, mind-body interventions, nutritional
therapeutics, pharmacological and biologic treatments, and spiritual therapies (Office of
Cancer Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 2009). Non-vitamin, non-mineral
natural products are the most commonly used complementary, alternative, or integrative
therapies among adults. Use has increased for many therapies, including meditation;
massage therapy, deep breathing exercises, and yoga (Barnes, Bloom & Nahim, 2008).
1
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
12/99
The list of therapies will likely to continue to evolve as novel approaches are proven to be
safe and effective, accepted as mainstream medicine, and integrated into cancer care.
Researchers report that patients with cancer and survivors are more likely to use
these therapies than those without cancer (Basch & Ulbricht, 2004; Fouladbakhsh &
Stommel, 2008). The most common reason for using them is a strong belief in their
efficacy (Verhoef, Balneaves, Boon, & Vroegindewey, 2005). Methodologically rigorous
preclinical and clinical research continues in the effort to establish safety and efficacy of
these therapies through government and nongovernment funding sources. A clinical
challenge is that 40 to 70 percent of use remains undisclosed because of patients beliefs
that these therapies are natural and safe to use, concern that providers may react
negatively, or simply, providers do not ask about their use (Robinson & McGrail, 2004).
In the Philippines, cancer ranks third in leading causes of mortality with 39,634
out of 100,000 populations in the year 2001 to 2005 according to Philippine Health
Statistics (Department of Health, 2011).
According to World Health Organization (2001), there are 250,000 practitioners
of traditional medicines in the Philippines. Approximately five (5) to eight (8)
chiropractors are practicing. There are no privately owned hospitals providing formal
traditional or complementary/alternative medical services. Natural medicines are
marketed over the counter in dozens of health food stores and in a limited number of
pharmacies (World Health Organization, 2001).
2
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
13/99
The use of CAM has increased steadily over the past 15 years or so, and
undoubtedly it has gained medical, economic and sociological importance. However,
little is known about the use of CAM in cancer patients here in the Philippines. Thus, the
researchers become interested and choose this topic since there are an increased
percentage of those people who use CAM based on the facts we gathered. It is estimated
that 30 to 50 percent of cancer patients in all stages of the disease will experience pain
and 70 to 95 percent with advanced disease will have significant pain, but only a fraction
of these patients receive adequate treatment. Hence, the researchers will find out the
reasons and views of adult cancer patients on the use of Complementary and Alternative
Medicine.
Conceptual Framework
Figure 1. Schematic Diagram showing the Independent and Dependent Variable of the
Study
3
Demographic Profile
of the Respondents:
Age
Sex
Religion
Educational
Attainment
Civil Status
Occupation
Income
Views and reasons of adult cancer
patients on the use ofComplementary and Alternative
Medicines
Independent Variable Dependent Variable
Clinical Profile of the
Respondents:
Medical Diagnosis
Treatment Options
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
14/99
A variable is a characteristic that has two or more mutually exclusive values or
properties. The independent variable is the presumed cause of the dependent variable,
which is the presumed effect in a relational.
The independent variables are divided into two (2) properties: the demographic
profile of the respondents and the clinical profile of the respondents. Under the
demographic profile, the researchers would like to find out the age, sex, religion,
educational attainment, civil status, occupation and income of the respondents. On the
other hand, the researchers would also like to find out the clinical profile of the
respondents containing the medical diagnosis and treatment options. The independent
variable is made to determine the views and reasons of adult cancer patients on the use of
Complementary and Alternative Medicine which acts as a dependent variable.
Theoretical Framework
The prevalence of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) is increasing
worldwide because of the growing public interest and the predominance of cancer
worldwide. The incidence of cancer has grown dramatically around the world in recent
decades. A new American Cancer Society report estimates that there will be over 12
million new cancer cases and 7.6 million cancer deaths (about 20,000 cancer deaths a
day) worldwide in 2007 (American Cancer Society, 2007).
According to the theory of Nola Pender, Health Promotion Model (HPM), the
assumptions of the HPM reflect the behavioral science perspective and emphasize the
4
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
15/99
active role of the patient for managing health behaviors by modifying the environmental
context. The major assumptions of the HPM: (1) Persons seek to create conditions of
living through which they can express their unique human health potential; (2) Persons
have the capacity for reflective self-awareness, including assessment of their own
competencies; (3) Persons value growths in directions viewed as positive and attempt to
achieve a personally acceptable balance change and stability; (4) Individuals seek to
actively regulate their own behavior; (5) Individuals in all their biopsychosocial
complexity interact with the environment, progressively transforming the environment
and being transformed over time; (6) Health professionals constitute a part of the
interpersonal environment, which exerts influence on persons throughout their life span;
and (7) Self-initiated reconfiguration of person-environment interactive patterns is
essential to behavior change (Tomey & Alligood, 2002).
The HPM (see Figure 2) is an attempt to depict the multifaceted nature of persons
interacting with the environment as they pursue health. It is motivated by the desire to
increase well being and actualize human potential. Nola Pender asserts that there are
complex biophysical processes that motivate individuals to engage in behaviors directed
toward the enhancement of health (Tomey & Alligood, 2002).
5
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
16/99
Figure 2. Revised Health Promotion Model by Nola J. Pender, 1996. A.M. Tomey &
M.R. Alligood, 2002.Nursing Theorists and Their Work 5th edition, p.628.
Theoretical statements derived from the model provide a basis for investigate
work on health behaviors. The HPM is based on the following theoretical assertions: (1)
Prior behavior and inherited and acquired characteristics influence beliefs, affect, and
6
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
17/99
enactment of health-promoting behavior; (2) Persons commit to engaging in behaviors
from which they anticipate deriving personally valued benefits; (3) Perceived barriers can
constrain commitment to action, a mediator of behavior as well as actual behavior; (4)
Perceived competence or self-efficacy to execute a given behavior increases the
likelihood of commitment to action and actual performance of the behavior; (5) Greater
perceived self-efficacy results in fewer perceived barriers to a specific health behavior;
(6) Positive affect toward a behavior results in greater perceived self-efficacy, which can
in turn, result in increased positive affect; (7) When positive emotions or affect are
associated with a behavior, the probability of commitment and action is increased; (8)
Persons are more likely to commit to and engage in health-promoting behaviors when
significant others model the behavior, expect the behavior to occur, and provide
assistance and support to enable the behavior; (9) Families, peers, and health care
providers are important sources of interpersonal influence that can increase or decrease
commitment to and engagement in health-promoting behavior; (10) Situational influences
in the external environment can increase or decrease commitment to or participation in
health-promoting behavior; (11) The greater the commitments to a specific plan of action,
the more likely health-promoting behaviors are to be maintained over time;
(12) Commitment to a plan of action is less likely to result in the desired behavior when
competing demands over which persons have little control require immediate attention;
(13) Commitment to a plan of action is less likely to result in the desired behavior when
other actions are more attractive and thus preferred over the target behavior; and
(14) Persons can modify cognitions, affect, and the interpersonal and physical
environment to create incentives for health actions (Tomey & Alligood, 2002).
7
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
18/99
Statement of the Problem
This study aims to determine the views and reasons of adult cancer patients on the
use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine.
Specifically, this study seeks to answer the following questions:
1. What is the demographic profile of the patients in terms of:
1.1. Age
1.2. Sex
1.3. Religion
1.4. Educational attainment
1.5. Civil status
1.6. Occupation
1.7. Income
2. What is the clinical profile of the patients in terms of:
2.1. Medical Diagnosis
2.2. Treatment Options
3. What are the views of the patients on the use of Complementary and Alternative
Medicine?
4. What are the reasons why did the patients use Complementary and Alternative
Medicine?
8
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
19/99
Significance of the Study
The result of this study will benefit the following:
The Respondents. They may benefit from the result of the study because the
information will serve as vital information to determine the views and reasons of adult
cancer patients on the use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine.
The Student Nurses. This study may serve as reference and learning materials
for classroom discussions and other school related research works on determining the
views and reasons of adult cancer patients on the use of Complementary and Alternative
Medicine.
The Health Care Providers. This study may aid health institutions and medical
practitioners to acquire current trends on CAM which may help them to render better
services and effective health teachings.
The Future Researchers. This study may enhance the knowledge and skills for
future purposes for the improvement of the nursing practice for cancer care in the hospital
and even in the community.
Scope and Delimitations
The study focuses on determining the views and reasons of adult cancer patients
on the use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines. The participants will be those
aged 18 years old onwards, who are willing to take part of the study, are awake,
conscious and coherent and as well as able to communicate effectively. Only those cancer
patients who have known their conditions and have been diagnosed for malignancy for
the past three (3) months or more will be included in the study. The data on views and
9
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
20/99
reasons of adult cancer patients on the use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine
will be obtained through conduct of in-depth interview with at least five (5) participants.
During our data collection last September 23, 2011 at the certain local tertiary
hospital in Davao City, the total census was seven (7). Four (4) out of seven (7) came
from Internal Medicine Ward and the remaining three (3) came from Gynecology Ward.
Definition of Terms
The following terms in this study are defined operationally for clarity and
common frame of references.
Views refer to the cancer patients views on the use of Complementary and Alternative
Medicine.
Reasons refer to the capacity for rational thought of a cancer patient regarding on the
use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine.
Complementary and Alternative Medicines (CAM) refers to medical products and
practices that are not part of standard care or that which has not been shown consistently
to be effective.
Cancer refers to a class of diseases characterized by out-of-control cell growth. There
are over 100 different types of cancer, and each is classified by the type of cell that is
initially affected.
Cancer staging describes the severity of a persons cancer based on the extent of the
original (primary) tumor and whether or not cancer has spread in the body.
10
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
21/99
In-depth interview offers the opportunity to express their self in a way ordinary life
rarely affords them.
Age refers to the length of time that one has existed; duration of life.
Sex refers to the property or quality by which organisms are classified as female or
male on the basis of their reproductive organs and functions.
Religion refers to the belief in and reverence for a supernatural power or powers
regarded as creator and governor of the universe.
Educational Attainment refers to a term commonly used by statisticians to refer to the
highest degree of education an individual has completed.
Civil Status refers to the legal standing of a person in regard to his or her marriage state.
Occupation refers to an activity that serves as ones regular source of livelihood; a
vocation.
Income refers to amount of money or its equivalent received during a period of time in
exchange for labor or services, from the sale of goods or property, or as profit from
financial investments.
Medical Diagnosis refers to the process of attempting to determine and/or identify a
possible disease or disorder and the opinion reached by this process.
Treatment options refer to the management and care of a patient or the combating of
disease or disorder.
11
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
22/99
CHAPTER II
Review of the Related Literature
Related Readings
The use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) by cancer patients is
reported to increase. CAM are defined as methods that are not part of standard medical
treatment (as described by evidence-based clinical practice guidelines, consensus
statements or common medical practice) and are either used instead of (alternatively) or
in addition (complementary) to a standard cancer treatment. These methods represent a
great variety ranging from chemically well-defined molecules or other substances and
mixtures from plant or animal origin to non-material methods like mind-body therapies,
spiritual healing or psychosocial procedures (National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine, 2009).
Cancer is a word that none of us wants to hear, especially if it involves a
diagnoses of ones self or loved ones. It can be a very long battle and the treatment
options (especially chemotherapy regimens) can be brutal. During the battle with cancer,
most patients seek ways to cope with the emotional and physical hardships they must deal
with. In fact, according to a study in the Journal Oncologist, approximately 80 percent of
cancer patients use Complimentary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) (Cassileth et al,
2004).
12
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
23/99
The goal for most patients that use CAM therapies is not to cure their cancer but
rather help to alleviate the anxiety, stress, pain and side effects of treatment. The use of
CAM therapies, including music therapy, has gained acceptance with the medical
community as an effective tool in assisting patients deal with cancer and treatments. In
fact, the American Cancer Society has a fantastic reference for CAM therapies called the
Complete Guide to Complementary and Alternative Cancer Therapies. Hundreds of
alternative therapies, to include music therapy, are listed and the evidence (or lack of it)
as well as possible side effects are discussed. Most therapies listed are safe but the
reference also lists and discusses some therapies that are used by some patients but can be
dangerous (Cassileth et al, 2004).
The National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine (NCCAM)
classification was found pragmatically useful. It all classifies Complementary and
Alternative Medicine (CAM) into five (5) categories of therapy which include the
Alternative Medical Systems; Mind-Body-Spirit therapies; Biologically-based therapies;
Energy and biofield therapies; Manipulative and Body-based therapies; and (National
Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 2009).
Alternative medical systems are built upon complete systems of theory and
practice. Often, these systems have evolved apart from and earlier than the conventional
medical approach used in the United States. Examples of alternative medical systems that
have developed in Western cultures include homeopathic medicine and naturopathic
medicine. Examples of systems that have developed in non-Western cultures include
13
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
24/99
traditional Chinese medicine and Ayurveda (National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine, 2009).
Mind-body medicine uses a variety of techniques designed to enhance the mind's
capacity to affect bodily function and symptoms. Some techniques that were considered
CAM in the past have become the mainstream (for example, patient support groups and
cognitive-behavioral therapy). Other mind-body techniques are still considered CAM,
including meditation, prayer, mental healing, and therapies that use creative outlets such
as art, music, or dance (National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine,
2009).
Biologically-based therapies in CAM use substances found in nature, such as
herbs, foods, and vitamins. Some examples include dietary supplements, herbal products,
and the use of other so-called natural but as yet scientifically unproven therapies (for
example, using shark cartilage to treat cancer) (National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine, 2009).
Manipulative and body-based methods in CAM are based on manipulation and/or
movement of one or more parts of the body. Some examples include chiropractic or
osteopathic manipulation, and massage (National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine, 2009).
14
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
25/99
Energy therapies involve the use of energy fields. They are of two types: (1)
biofield therapies are intended to affect energy fields that purportedly surround and
penetrate the human body. The existence of such fields has not yet been scientifically
proven. Some forms of energy therapy manipulate biofields by applying pressure and/or
manipulating the body by placing the hands in, or through, these fields. Examples include
qi gong, reiki, and therapeutic touch; and (2) bioelectromagnetic-based therapies involve
the unconventional use of electromagnetic fields, such as pulsed fields, magnetic fields,
or alternating current or direct current fields (National Center for Complementary and
Alternative Medicine, 2009).
Demographic and Clinical Profile
In particular, CAM use appears to be more common among those with higher
income, higher educational level, younger age, female gender, or history of CAM use
(Cauffield JS, 2000; Eisenberg DM, Davis RB & Ettner SL et al, 1998; Hyodo I, Amano
N & Eguchi K et al, 2005; Paltiel O, Avitzour M & Peretz T et al, 2001). Also, cancer
patients resort to CAM more frequently than patients with acute or chronic diseases,
which are not malignant (Kappauf H, Leykauf-Ammon D & Bruntsch U et al, 2000). In
addition, use of chemotherapy and advanced disease are correlated with more frequent
CAM use use (Cauffield JS, 2000; Eisenberg DM, Davis RB & Ettner SL et al, 1998;
Hyodo I, Amano N & Eguchi K et al, 2005; Paltiel O, Avitzour M & Peretz T et al,
2001). A study describing the prevalence of CAM use in patients enrolled in early-phase
chemotherapy trials at the Mayo Clinic Comprehensive Cancer Center showed a high use
of such products (Dy GK, Bekele L & Hanson LJ et al, 2004). More than 80 percent of
15
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
26/99
patients simultaneously used pharmacologic CAM (like vitamins, herbs, and minerals) in
addition to their experimental chemotherapeutic agents (Dy GK, Bekele L & Hanson LJ
et al, 2004), which is (currently) often an exclusion criterion and/or formally not allowed
during this type of treatment. Additionally, a study in nearly 500 cancer patients revealed
that 65 percent of the 131 patients being treated with chemotherapy alone said they used
CAM in conjunction with their chemotherapy, whereas only 35 percent of the 142
patients receiving radiotherapy reported CAM use (Vapiwala N, Mick R & DeNittis A et
al, 2005).
Colorectal and breast cancer patients, in particular, seem to be likely to use
dietary supplements, compared with lung cancer patients (Gupta D, Lis CG & Birdsall
TC et al, 2005; Rakovitch E, Pignol JP & Chartier C et al, 2005). An increased perception
of the risk of cancer recurrence and cancer-related death are associated with CAM use by
breast cancer patients, as concluded in a study by Rakovitch et al. (Rakovitch E, Pignol
JP & Chartier C et al, 2005). In contrast, in another recent study, it was concluded that
CAM users are less likely to believe they will die from breast cancer (Helyer LK, Chin S
& Chui BK et al, 2006). In both studies, no relationship between CAM use and anxiety
and/or depression could be found. This is noteworthy because both anxiety and
depression are frequently mentioned as an important explanation for the more frequent
use of CAM, in particular CAM influencing mood like St. Johns wort or medicinal
cannabis (De Smet PA, 2002; Stevinson C & Ernst E, 1999; De Jong FA, Engels FK &
Mathijssen RH et al, 2005; Radbruch L & Nauck F, 2003).
16
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
27/99
Most cancer patients combine, rather than replace, conventional therapy with
CAM (Cauffield JS, 2000; Lafferty WE, Bellas A & Corage Baden A et al, 2004;
Burstein HJ, Gelber S & Guadagnoli E et al, 1999; Cassileth BR, Lusk EJ & Strouse TB
et al, 1984; Lerner IJ & Kennedy BJ, 1992). This is clearly demonstrated in a survey by
Cassileth et al. (Cassileth BR, Lusk EJ & Strouse TB et al, 1984), in which 304 in-
patients of a cancer center and 356 patients under the care of unorthodox practitioners
were interviewed. Of all patients studied, 8 percent never received any conventional
therapy, and 54 percent of patients on conventional treatment also used unorthodox
treatments.
The use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine in cancer survivors is
underreported (Gansler, Chiewkwei, Crammer, & Smith, 2008; Saxe et al., 2008), with as
many as 81 percent of survivors having used vitamin or mineral supplements. Although
use of the more common CAMs by cancer survivors was comparable to the general
population, Gansler et al. (2008) noted an increase in other forms of CAM. Deng,
Cassileth, and Yeung (2004) suggested that CAM users are seeking a holistic approach to
their care and see CAM as a natural way to take responsibility and control of their health
and promote an increased quality of life (Frenkel, Ben-Arye, Baldwin, & Sierpina, 2005;
Saxe et al., 2008).
Increased CAM use was reported in short and long-term survivors (Gansler et al.,
2008). Use and types of therapies differ according to cancer sites (Velicer & Ulrich,
2008). Survivors of melanoma and kidney cancers were reported as least likely to use
17
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
28/99
CAM, whereas survivors of breast, ovarian, non-Hodgkin lymphoma, and brain or central
nervous system cancers were reportedly most likely to use CAM (Gansler et al., 2008;
Richardson, Sanders, Palmer, Greisinger, & Singletary, 2000). Stage of disease also
influenced CAM use, with increases noted in advanced-stage disease (Gansler et al.,
2008). In addition, CAM use can be affected by geography, with higher use reported in
California (Goldstein et al., 2005). Goldstein et al. (2005) hypothesized that the reason
for this may be the "social milieu" that exists in California, where the population leads a
culturally creative lifestyle (Goldstein et al., 2005). Additional commonalities
identified in the survivors who use CAM included better education, a focus on health,
and a general use of more mainstream medical services (Deng et al., 2004,).
Views and Reasons of Cancer Patients
There are specific cancer-related reasons for using CAM. A Canadian survey of
more than 900 cancer patients demonstrated that 94 percent experienced disease-related
symptoms such as fatigue and anxiety that were not addressed by their conventional
treatment (Ashbury FD, Findlay H & Reynolds B et al, 1998). Most cancer patients, in
general, were satisfied with the conventional treatment they received for their cancer.
Nonetheless, they were more likely dissatisfied with the attention paid to their symptoms
and side effects. A second reason for CAM use is the presumed action as an anticancer
agent (Kosty MP, 2004; Straus SE, 2002). Several CAM products are under investigation
in clinical trials for this reason; however, they have not been under appropriate trial
development so far (Vickers AJ, Kuo J & Cassileth BR, 2006).
18
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
29/99
CAM is used for its cancer preventive properties as well. An ideal preventive
agent has little or no toxicity, high efficacy in multiple sites, capability of oral
consumption, a known mechanism of action, low cost, and above all, general acceptance
(Siddiqui IA, Adhami VM & Saleem M et al, 2006). For example, more or less conscious
use of green tea by men has gained its place in society. Indeed, in a case-control study a
protective effect of green tea against prostate cancer was suggested (Jian L, Xie LP &
Lee AH et al, 2004), which is supported by in vitro research (Siddiqui IA, Adhami VM,
Saleem M et al, 2006; Gupta S, Ahmad N & Mohan RR et al, 1999). The risk was
thought to decline with increasing frequency, duration, and quantity of green tea
consumption. However, it should be noted that conflicting results are reported by
epidemiological studies on the use of green tea as a protective substance in relation to
prostate cancer (Jian L, Xie LP & Lee AH et al, 2004).
In addition to these reasons, cancer patients, in general, have the same reasons as
other people for using CAM (Cassileth BR, 2000; Cassileth BR, Lusk EJ & Strouse TB et
al, 1984; Kronenberg F, Mindes J & Jacobson JS, 2005). Disease-related symptoms not
easily addressed by conventional treatment and concerns about the adverse effects of
chemical/pharmaceutical medicines are some of them (Cauffield JS, 2000). Also, an
increased need for more personalized health and a greater public access to health
information (i.e., the Internet) and popular media attention to CAM fuel its increasing use
in many industrialized countries (Eisenberg DM, Davis RB & Ettner SL et al, 1998; Ernst
E & Cassileth BR, 1998; Hyodo I, Amano N & Eguchi K et al, 2005). In addition, quality
of life may also be a reason for CAM use (Lis CG, Cambron JA & Grutsch JF et al,
19
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
30/99
2006). However, results are conflicting regarding the self-reported quality of life among
CAM users versus nonusers. In a recent report, a study performed at a community
hospital comprehensive cancer center was described, which found a better quality of life
among dietary supplement users compared with nonusers (Lis CG, Cambron JA &
Grutsch JF et al, 2006). In contrast, earlier data showed opposite results (Burstein HJ,
Gelber S & Guadagnoli E et al, 1999; Cassileth BR, Lusk EJ & Guerry D et al, 1991;
Paltiel O, Avitzour M & Peretz T et al, 2001). It should be mentioned that these findings
are not completely comparable because the latter studies used a broader definition for
CAM.
Survivors identified many reasons for using CAM, and indicated that locus of
control may be one important factor (Gansler et al., 2008). Survivors responses
positively correlated with the use of CAM as a means of stress and recurrence reduction
and enhancement of wellness and quality of life (Buettner et al., 2006; Greenlee, White,
Patterson, & Kristal, 2004; Saxe et al., 2008), with the belief that CAM therapies are
nontoxic (Richardson et al., 2000). Additionally, for those with advanced disease, CAM
use was believed to be associated with prolongation of life (Richardson et al., 2000), the
desire to remain hopeful (Richardson et al., 2000; Verhoef, Balneaves, Boon, &
Vroegindewey, 2005), or to provide cure (Richardson et al., 2000).
In cancer survivors, CAM was reportedly used primarily for treatment for
ailments such as diabetes mellitus, hypertension and other than the cancer diagnosis
(Goldstein, Lee, Ballard-Barbash, & Brown, 2008). The National Center for Health
20
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
31/99
Statistics reported that cancer survivors were more likely to die from noncancer causes,
and that they are more likely to have at least one functional limitation. As a result, the
negative impact on quality of life or function from chronic health issues (Goldstein et al.,
2008; Saxe et al., 2008), as well as the short- and long-term cancer-related medical issues
or symptoms (Carpenter, Ganz, & Bernstein, 2008; Greenlee et al., 2004; Miller et al.,
2008; Wesa, Gubili & Cassileth, 2008), were identified as initiating factors for using
CAM by cancer survivors. The use of chemotherapy during treatment also was associated
with an increased CAM prevalence (Mao et al., 2008).
The rising costs of health care (Saxe et al., 2008), coupled with multiple unmet
needs, equates to multiple CAM uses (Mao et al., 2008). These unmet needs were
identified by Mao et al. (2008) as emotional, physical, nutritional, financial,
informational, treatment- and employment-related, and daily living activities. Other
reasons included an identified dissatisfaction with conventional care (Richardson et al.,
2000; Saxe et al., 2008), fragmentation of care into survivorship, lack of empathy and
support, or if a survivor's subsequent needs were unfulfilled (Mao et al., 2008). In
addition, Carpenter et al. (2008) identified decreased emotional function and multiple
medical issues in very long-term breast cancer survivors who used CAM. The potential
for recurrence and high levels of worry (Mao et al., 2008) and distress (Lawsin et al.,
2007) also were reported with increased use. Finally, the use of herbal supplements were
reportedly used to reduce the side effects of treatment and to boost immune function
(Buettner et al., 2006; Deng et al., 2004; Lawsin et al., 2007; Richardson et al., 2000;
Saxe et al., 2008).
21
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
32/99
Related Studies
People who used CAM before a diagnosis are more likely to use CAM after their
diagnosis (Miller M, Boyer MJ, Butow PN, Gattelari M, Dunn SM & Childs A, 1998;
Harris P, Finlay I, Cook A, Thomas KJ & Hood K, 2003), but the biggest predictors of
use are being female, younger and tertiary educated (Harris P, Finlay I, Cook A, Thomas
KJ & Hood K, 2003; OCallaghan FV & Jordan N, 2003; Shorofi SA & Arbon P, 2010;
Girgis, A, Adams J & Sibbritt D, 2005; Hedderson M, Patterson R, Neuhouser ML,
Schwartz SM, Bowen DJ & Standish LJ, 2004).
Shorofi and Arbon (2010) claim women are more likely than men to have a
positive attitude towards CAM (Shorofi SA & Arbon P, 2010). Other studies conclude
women are 1.9 times more likely than men to use CAM (Girgis, A, Adams J & Sibbritt
D, 2005; Hedderson M, Patterson R, Neuhouser ML, Schwartz SM, Bowen D &,
Standish LJ, 2004). Hedderson et al (2004) found that about 80 percent of women and 60
percent of men used at least one CAM, and suggested it may be considered more
socially acceptable for women to seek help (Hedderson M, Patterson R, Neuhouser ML,
Schwartz SM, Bowen DJ & Standish LJ, 2004). But men were more likely to use CAM
when their symptom distress scores were higher.
In a review of public attitudes to natural medicine, Leach reported that regular
CAM users were more likely to be dissatisfied with conventional practitioners than non-
users (Leach MJ, 2004), and that over 40 percent of users turn to natural therapies
because of a perceived failure of orthodox medicine to treat their health problems.
22
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
33/99
OCallaghan and Jordan (2003), in their survey of postmodern predictors of CAM use,
quote one study with a contrary finding: that although dissatisfaction with the doctor-
patient relationship and having postmodern values of health are significant predictors,
dissatisfaction with medical outcomes is not. OCallaghan and Jordan (2003) conclude
that holding postmodern values such as rejection of authority, and feeling responsible
for ones own health predicts a positive attitude to CAM use (OCallaghan FV &
Jordan N, 2003).
In Shorofi and Arbons (2010) comprehensive study of CAM attitudes, 46 percent
of respondents had a positive attitude towards CAM, while only 10 percent had a
negative attitude. In this study, patients rated their level of agreement to 18 statements
about attitudes towards CAM and allopathic medicine. Examples include: CAM is an
important aspect of my own familys health care (36 percent agree, 25 percent disagree,
35 percent unsure) and conventional health care services are too impersonal (27 percent
agree, 44 percent disagree, 26 percent unsure) (Shorofi SA & Arbon P, 2010).
Miller et al (1998) found that 63 percent of patients felt CAM gave them
psychological benefits and 41 percent physiological benefits. A majority would
recommend the treatment they had and use the same therapy again themselves. However,
29 percent thought CAM provided no benefit (Miller M, Boyer MJ, Butow PN, Gattelari
M, Dunn SM & Childs A, 1998).
23
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
34/99
Salminem et al found that 25 percent of women reported no improvement from a
change in diet (Miller M, Boyer MJ, Butow PN, Gattelari M, Dunn SM & Childs A,
2004). However, 50 percent felt their condition had improved, while 25 percent were
unsure. Harris et als survey (2003) of 1034 people with cancer determined that 72
percent were satisfied with their CAM use, 25 percent were uncertain and 4 percent were
dissatisfied (Harris P, Finlay I, Cook A, Thomas KJ & Hood K, 2003). A similar result
was reported by Chrystal et al (2003), where 71 percent of patients thought CAM
beneficial and six (6) percent found CAM unhelpful (Chrystal K, Allan S, Forgeson G &
Isaacs R, 2003).
A participant in Verhoef et als study (2005) reported an improvement in physical
wellbeing, with massage or a natural health product most likely to cause these positive
outcomes. Some participants cited emotional improvements, including feelings of greater
control, more optimism, reduced anxiety and greater resilience. Others believed that
CAM helped them remain cancer free (Verhoef M, Mulkins A & Boon H, 2005).
24
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
35/99
CHAPTER III
METHODOLOGY
Research Design
This study used qualitative research as the method of data collection. In this
context, interviews were viewed as situations where various meanings of feelings and
experiences were constructed and negotiated by the participants.
The researchers used the phenomenological type of qualitative research in which
it studies the feelings and lived experiences of a person. Moreover, the meanings of
feelings and experiences are placed in particular social and cultural contexts. In this
context, participants accounts during an interview were viewed as products of an
interrelationship between the interviewers and the interviewees. During an interview
situation, both the researchers and the participants had strived to arrive at meanings
together that both can understand.
Locale of the Study
The study was conducted in a certain local tertiary hospital in Davao City. The
involved departments were Gynecology ward, and Internal Medicine ward.
Unit of Analysis
The unit of analysis was the adult cancer patients who were awake, conscious and
coherent whose age were from 18 years old up to 65 years old and who were currently
25
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
36/99
admitted in a certain local tertiary hospital in Davao City and who were willing to
participate in the study. This study obtained five (5) participants who were currently
using Complementary and Alternative Medicines.
Sampling Design
The non-probability purposive sampling technique was used in this study. This is
a sampling technique in which the researchers were allowed to pick respondents based on
the criteria. The criteria used for choosing the respondents were as follows: (1) must be
an adult cancer patient who is awake, conscious and coherent; (2) must be at least 18
years old; (3) must be currently admitted in a local tertiary hospital; and (4) must be a
Complementary and Alternative Medicines (CAM) user.
Data Collection Procedure
To be able to fully determine the important details and information, the
researchers devised a systematic approach to fully compensate the time involved therein.
Step 1: Preparation Phase
The researchers of this study deliberated with the necessary information. Then a
careful analysis and assessment of the data at hand and facilitated the proponents in
conceptualizing the framework for this study.
Before the researchers carry out this study, a letter of consent addressed to the
Dean of College of Nursing of Davao Medical School Foundation, Inc., the Hospital
26
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
37/99
Administrator of the Local tertiary Hospital and as well as the consent for the respondents
were considered, seeking approval to conduct the study. Furthermore, the researchers
sought for permission to the respondents to allow us to see his/her chart regarding on
his/her clinical profile.
Step 2: Interview Phase
The researchers of this study were using the open-ended question to a patient
regarding on his/her views and reasons on the use of Complementary and Alternative
Medicine. Furthermore, the researchers were using an interview guide in gathering data
in order to have sufficient information.
Step 3: Transcription of Data
Interviews were transcribed verbatim. Transcription rules regarding on how to
handle pauses, false starts, emotional expressions and etc. were agreed upon to assure
conformity between different interview transcriptions as well as different transcribers.
Step 4: Analysis and Interpretation
The researchers of this study analyzed and interpret the patients statements.
Treatment of Data
The data were encoded into the computer using the Microsoft Word. The
qualitative data analysis approach was used to analyze the views and reasons of the adult
cancer patients on the use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines.
27
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
38/99
Data Analysis
Objective Variable Statistical Treatment
To describe the patients
demographic profile
1. Age
2. Sex
3. Religion
4. Educational Attainment
5. Civil Status
6. Occupation
7. Income
Qualitative Data Analysis
To determine the clinical
profile of the patient
1. Medical Diagnosis
2. Treatment options
Qualitative Data Analysis
To determine the views
of using the CAM
Qualitative Data Analysis
To determine the reasons
of using the CAM
Qualitative Data Analysis
Table 1. Manner of Data Analysis
Ethical Consideration
1. Ethics Review
A. Office of the Dean, College of Nursing, DMSF
Permission was asked from the Office of the Dean to conduct study. (See
Sample Letter, Appendix 1)
B. Office of the Hospital Administrator and/or Hospital Research Committee
28
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
39/99
A letter was sent to the Office of the Hospital Administrator and/or
Hospital Research Committee to allow us to conduct study in the area. (See
Sample Letter, Appendix 2)
2. Informed Consent (Form)
As soon as permission from the Hospital Administrator and/or Hospital Research
Committee is granted, permission from the participating individuals was been sought.
A written informed consent was been used in different languages (English and
Filipino Version Tagalog and Cebuano). (See Informed Consent, Appendix 3
English Version, Appendix 4 Tagalog Version and Appendix 5 Cebuano Version)
3. Informed Consent (Signatory)
The researchers had been giving two copies of informed consent form (one for the
researchers copy and the other one is the participants copy) and had been requiring a
signature to formalize the consent.
4. Informed Consent (Witness)
The researchers had been seeking for somebody (especially the significant others)
to witness the signing of informed consent form.
5. Informed Consent (Proxy Consent)
29
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
40/99
The researchers allowed proxy consent if the respondent is not able to read or
write. The only person who will sign for the consent is the one who is the nearest kin
of the respondent.
6. Informed Assent
The researchers did not obtain informed assent since the unit of analysis for this
research study were adult respondents whose aged were from 18 years and onwards.
7. Informed Consent (Process)
The potential respondents were been invited to listen to a short
explanation/discussion of the study objectives. Potential respondents queries will be
entertained anytime during the explanation/discussion.
8. Informed Consent (Timing)
The researchers obtained the informed consent right after the study objectives
discussed and explained very well.
9. Informed Consent (Venue)
The researchers obtained the informed consent at the respondents bed and in
what department he/she confines.
10. Study Objectives, Risks, Benefits and Procedures
30
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
41/99
The researchers formulated study objectives and this served as the basis for the
data collection. The researchers were asking personal question to our participants and
they were free not to answer any of those questions. There may have benefits for
taking part for this study and it may help others to understand how the
Complementary and Alternative Medicines affects their life.
11. Remuneration, reimbursement and other benefits
The participants did not spend anything during our interview. But, the researchers
were giving free snacks as sign of gratitude for their active participation in this study.
12. Confidentiality
The records from this study were kept as confidential as possible. The researchers
did not reveal information about the participants to a third party without their consent
or a clear legal reason. All transcripts and summaries were given codes and stored
separately from any names or other direct identification of participants. Research
information was kept in locked files at all times. Only research personnel had
accessed to the files and only those with an essential need to see names had accessed
to that particular file.
13. Investigators responsibility during adverse events
The researchers did not provide for any payment if the participants will be harmed
as a result of taking part in this study. If such harm occurs, treatment will be
provided. However, this treatment will not be provided free of charge.
31
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
42/99
14. Specimen Handling
The researchers had not performed any tissue sampling in the study.
15. Voluntariness of participation
The researchers did not force anybody to participate in this study researcher. If the
participant will not decide to participate in this research, there will be no further
consequence be made. If the participant decides to participate, the participant may
stop participating at any time and the participant may decide not to answer any
specific question.
16. Alternative Options
The researchers respected the participants decision if they decided to withdraw or
refuse to participate in our study, and they will not be penalized or given charges for
that matter.
17. Privacy
The researchers did no longer contact the participants nor to have home visitations
after the scheduled interview.
18. Information of Study Results
The researchers decided not to inform the respondents involved in the study
regarding the result of the research conducted. This decision will help the researchers
maintain confidentiality and privacy of the participants.
32
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
43/99
19. Authorship and Contributorship
Name Authorship and Contributorship
Jean Leslie Bughao Methodology (Research Design, Locale of the Study, Unit
of Analysis and Sampling Design)
Appendix 9
Reyveen John Geli Introduction (Background of the Study)
Methodology (Data Collection Procedure, Treatment of
Data and Data Analysis)
Norman Juruena Introduction (Conceptual Framework, Theoretical
Framework and Statement of the Problem)
Review of the Related Literature
Results and Discussions
Appendices 3 and 6
Kathlyn Janine Mones Introduction (Significance of the Study)
Methodology (Ethical Consideration)
Mary Laureen Santarin Introduction (Scope and Limitation)
Appendices 5 and 8
Rosthy John Soria Acknowledgement and Dedication
Bibliography and Appendices 1 and 2
Rinnah Grace Talatagod Introduction (Definition of Terms)
Appendices 4 and 7
Table 2. Authorship and Contributorship
20. Extent of use of study data
The data were encoded in the computer. There was no identifying information
encoded to the computer so that the information cannot be traced back to the person
33
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
44/99
concerned. Only the group members had accessed to the data and the interview
schedule. The interview schedules were kept at the data storage area at the Nursing
Department of the Davao Medical School Foundation (DMSF). The interview
schedule shall be kept for a period of five (5) years. After five (5) years, the interview
schedule shall be disposed of by shredding.
21. Conflict of interest
Each of the researchers was appointed to do certain part of the research study and
was guided by the group leader and with the help of the adviser/mentor. The
researchers had shared common interest with regards in formulating the research
study.
22. Publication
The researchers will publish the research study at the end of November year 2011.
It will be placed at the Nursing Library of Davao Medical School Foundation, Inc.
This study will be use as a reference for future researchers.
23. Funding
All the expenses were coming from the researchers pocket.
24. Duplicate copy of informed consent
The researchers secured two (2) copies of an informed consent form, one for the
researchers copy and the other one is the participants copy.
34
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
45/99
25. Questions and concerns regarding the study
The researchers allowed the participants to raise questions and voice out their
concerns about the study.
26. Contact details
The participants will contact, Mr. Norman Juruena with the contact number of
09322151358 or 302-8089, if they have any questions, concerns or complaints about
the research.
CHAPTER IV
RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
35
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
46/99
Results
Five (5) adult cancer patients were interviewed for this study and who were
currently admitted in a certain local tertiary hospital. All of them were using different
complementary and alternative medicines. This study was conducted in order to find out
the selected demographic profile, selected clinical profile, and views and reasons of the
adult cancer patients on the use of complementary and alternative medicines.
Discussions
This study had provided a qualitative account of the adult cancer patients views
and reasons on the use of complementary and alternative medicines and the rationales
behind their perspectives. The findings indicated a spectrum of views and reasons on
complementary and alternative medicines. The researchers sought out five (5) possible
respondents for this study who were currently admitted in a local tertiary hospital. Three
(3) respondents came from Internal Medicine Ward while the two (2) remaining
respondents came from Gynecology Ward. The researchers obtained consent and
fortunately, the patients agreed upon on what they had read in the consent. The
researchers named the following patients as Respondent A, Respondent B, Respondent C,
Respondent D and Respondent E.
Selected Demographic Profile
This section presents the selected demographic profile of the respondents. It
includes age, sex, religion, educational attainment, civil status, occupation and income.
36
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
47/99
Age. The age of the respondents ranged from 46 to 61 years old. First respondent
is 58 years old, second respondent is 59 years old, third respondent is 54 years old, fourth
respondent is 46 years old and the fifth respondent is 61 years old. They have a mean age
of 55.6 years old.
Sex. All of the respondents were females.
Religion. Almost all of the respondents are Roman Catholic, four (4) out of five
(5), while the remaining one (1) respondent is a Protestant (Church of Christ).
Educational Attainment. There were three (3) respondents who were college
graduates and the remaining two (2) respondents were elementary undergraduates, one of
them reached only grade one (1) and the other one (1) reached only grade two (2).
Civil Status. Almost all of the respondents were married, three (3) out of five (5),
while the remaining two (2) respondents were a single and a widower respectively.
Occupation. Only one (1) respondent is currently employed, an office clerk, to a
private company. Two (2) respondents are unemployed and the remaining two (2)
respondents are self-employed, a puto maker and a binangkal seller respectively.
Income. The monthly income of the respondents ranged from Php 1,200 to Php
4,000 with a mean average of Php 2,233.33. First respondent has an estimated monthly
income of Php 1,200 to Php 1,500. Second respondent has monthly income of Php 3,000
to Php 4,000. Third respondent has an estimated monthly income of Php 3,000. The
unemployed respondents are currently supported by their children and nearest kin.
Selected Clinical Profile
This section presents the selected clinical profile of the respondents. It includes
medical diagnosis and treatment options.
37
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
48/99
Medical Diagnosis. There were three (3) breast cancer respondents, two (2) of
which were diagnosed with stage four (4) and the other one (1) was diagnosed with stage
three (3). The two (2) remaining respondents were diagnosed with ovarian cancer stage
one (1).
Treatment Options. All of the respondents had undergone diagnostic procedures
such as CBC, urinalysis, CT scan, chest x-ray, ultrasound and biopsy. Two (2)
respondents had undergone operations. One (1) who has breast cancer stage four (4) had
undergone Modified Radical Mastectomy (MRM) last June 2010. The other one (1) with
ovarian cancer stage one (1) had two (2) operations, Total Abdominal Hysterectomy
Bilateral Salphingo Oophorectomy (TAHBSO) and appendectomy last April 2011. Four
(4) out of five (5) respondents are currently on chemotherapy. The remaining one (1)
respondent was diagnosed to have breast cancer stage four (4) a year ago but refused to
undergo chemotherapy by that time. During the interview, she was about to start of the
said treatment. Almost all of the respondents, four (4) out of five (5), were receiving
chemotherapeutic drugs and some were given antibiotics, diuretics, pain reliever, anti-
emetic and beta adrenergic drugs.
Respondents Views
38
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
49/99
This section presents the different views of the respondents regarding on the use
of complementary and alternative medicines. The data were collated and the respondents
views were classified as effective, partially effective and not effective.
Effective. Only one (1) respondent said that using the complementary and
alternative medicines, specifically acupuncture, is more effective than the conventional
therapy in terms of alleviating the side effects of chemotherapeutic drugs such as pain,
nausea and vomiting.
Ang gusto dyud nako kay doctors order lang gyud kung
pwede, pero kung sa acupuncture ko mag basi maayo gyud
kaayo siya, narelieved ko sa akong ginabati. Makawala og
sakit. Makaingon ko nga epektibo siya kung acupuncture
lang ang atong basehon pero sa uban dili kaayo ko kaingon
nga epektibo jud. (All I want is the Doctors Order but
when you base on the Acupuncture all I can say that it is
more effective because it relieves me from pain and can
ease my pain but for others I cannot say that it is more
effective). Respondent D, 46 years old
However, she believed that herbal medicines were not effective in treating cancer.
Furthermore, she added that the effectiveness of complementary and alternative
medicines depend on the age of a person based on her observation.
39
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
50/99
Partially Effective. Three (3) respondents believed that complementary and
alternative medicines were partially effective. One (1) respondent believed that it will
only be more effective to those women in their pre-menopausal year (ages 12 to 45 years
old).
Pero sa akong nabantayan, mu-epekto lang man siguro
ni sa mga naga-regla pa. (As what I have observed, it is
more effective when you are still having menstruations.)
Respondent B, 59 years old.
On the other hand, the other one (1) respondent believed that these alternative
medicines alleviated her pain and other effects of the conventional therapy. Moreover,
she strongly considered that it will only help in preventing the occurrence of cancer.
Nindot siya gamiton kung wala pa kay sakit. (It is better
to use when you are not yet sick.) Respondent C, 54
years old.
While the last one (1) respondent said that the complementary and alternative
medicines had little effects in reducing the side effects of the drugs that she was taking.
She believed that only those patients diagnosed at a younger age and at the same time
using the complementary and alternative medicines will have a chance of survival.
40
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
51/99
Makatabang pud gamay og maka-ingon ko naay epekto
gamay sa akoa. (It helps me a little and I can say that it is
somehow effective.) Respondent E, 61 years old.
The three (3) respondents all believed that the use of complementary and
alternative medicines added another year of their life.
Not Effective. The remaining one (1) respondent believed that it was not
effective. At first, she strongly believed on the effectiveness of the complementary and
alternative medicines based on the experiences of others. At the long run of using the
complementary and alternative medicines, she was really expecting that she will be cured
and the conventional therapy was no longer necessary. Unfortunately, her condition
worsens.
Pag tuo nako sa una maka ayo ni sa mga sakit-sakit, pero
mali di-ay ko, dili tanan sakit kaya niya ma tambalan og
mas maayo pa mo kunsulta sa doktor mismo aron di na mu
lala ang imong sakit (Before, I thought this will cure
any kind of illnesses, but I was wrong, not all illnessess
cured by this and it is better to consult a doctor to hinder
further worsening of the illness) Respondent A, 58
years old
41
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
52/99
She decided to stop using the complementary and alternative medicines and
abided on the conventional therapy instead.
Wala siya makatabang sa akoa, gi-undangan na gani
nako. Mas epektibo pa ang sa hospital kaysa sa una
nakong gina pang himo (It didnt help me, so I stop
using it. It is more effective to be hospitalized than on what
I had used before) Respondent A, 58 years old
Respondents Reasons
This section presents the different reasons of the respondents on the use of
complementary and alternative medicines. The data were collated and the respondents
reasons were the following:
Financial Constraint. All of the respondents said that their income is not enough
to sustain their treatment regimen. In order to maintain their conventional therapy, they
borrowed money from their friends, neighbors and significant others for them to afford
the treatments that were being prescribed by their physicians. However, complementary
and alternative medicines were their first choice before they underwent the conventional
therapy.
Naga hiram lang ko ug kwarta sa akong mga amigo ug
amiga kay kulang akong kwarta pang palit ug tambal.
Estimate nako, mga 3,500 pesos siguro ang akong mga na
42
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
53/99
gastos tapos Php 1,200 to Php 1,500 lang akong makuha
sa pag baligya nako ug puto taga bulan. (Im just
borrowing money from my friends so that I can afford to
buy my own medicines for my illness. My estimated
expenses was already 3,500 while I only have Php 1,200 to
Php 1,500 earnings from my puto business)
Respondent A,58 years old female.
Kulang gihapon akong gina sweldo pang palit ug tambal
para sa akong sakit Php 3,000 to Php 4,000 lang akong
sweldo taga bulan (My salary is not enough for me to
buy all my medicines monthly. My salary is only Php
3,000 to Php 4,000 ) Respondent B59 years old female.
Isa ko ka government employee sauna, nag resign na ko
karon tungod sa akong sakit. Akong duha ka anak ang
naga tabang sa ako karon. (I was a government
employee before but I resigned from my job because of my
illness. My two children were the one who are supporting
me now.) Respondent C,54 years old female
Maski naa mi negosyo kulang man gihapon among
kwarta pang maintain sa akong mga tambal kay sige lang
43
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
54/99
ko pa lab test. (Even though we have business, our
money is not enough to buy all my maintenance medicines
because I underwent several types of diagnostic tests.)
Respondent D,46 years old female
Gamay lang kaayo ang among makuna na kwarta sa
among negosyo na binangkal, naga hiram na lng mi ug
kwarta sa akong mga igsoon pampalit ug tambal na ko.
(We only earned a little from our binangkal business,
sometimes we used to borrow money from my brother and
sister to buy my medicines.) Respondent E, 61 years old
female.
Hope to cure cancer. Four (4) out of five (5) respondents had strongly believed
that they will be cured by the complementary and alternative medicines while the
remaining one (1) respondent had partially lost her belief on the said therapy since her
condition was getting much worse. However, all of them were hoping to be cured by the
complementary and alternative medicines.
Wala siya makatabang sa akoa, gi-undangan na gani
nako. (No it doesnt help me, I stop using it)
Respondent A, 58 years old
44
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
55/99
Nakatabang man gamay kay hangtod karon buhi gihapon
ko. (It helps me a little because until now I live).
Respondent B, 59 years old
Okey lang man. Hopeless na hopeful gihapon. Ambot
kung makaayo gani siya. Pero nindot siya gamiton kung
wala pa kay sakit. (It is okay. Hopeless but hopefull still.
I dont know if it cures me. But its nice to use when you
dont have illness yet). Respondent C, 54 years old
Maayo dyud para sa akoa ang acupuncture.
(Acupuncture is good on me). Respondent D, 49 years
old
Dili man epektibo, wala man ko maayo sa akong sakit sa
pag gamit anang mga herbal pero murag naka-ingon ko
nga murag naa siya naitabang pod gamay sa akong
kinabuhi. (Not effective, I am not being cured on my
sickness when I used herbal but I can say that it helps me a
little bit in my life). Respondent E, 61 years old
Reduce side-effects of treatment. The most devastating part of the treatment
regimen is the side effects of the conventional therapy. Almost all of the respondents,
45
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
56/99
four (4) out of five (5), were given chemotherapeutic drugs. They were all experiencing
side effects of the said drugs such as pain, nausea, vomiting, hair fall, loss of appetite and
weight loss. Three (3) respondents were only using complementary and alternative
medicines for them to relieve from the unpleasant effects of the drugs that they were
taking.
Naka bati ko ug pag ka lipong ug suka suka pag ka
human sa akong chemotherapy (I felt so dizzy and I
vomited after my chemotherapy.) Respondent A, 58
years old female
Naka sulay ko ug walay gana sa pagkaon ug suka suka
pag kahuman sa akong chemotherapy(I experienced loss
of appetite and vomiting after my chemotherapy.)
Respondent C, 54 years old female.
Nag sige nako suka kay malasahan nako ang tambal,
tapos wala nako gana mukaon. (I always vomit because
I can already taste the medication, then I also experienced
loss appetite.) Respondent D, 46 years old female.
46
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
57/99
Mangurog ko, magsuka tapos wala gana kaon. (I
experienced tremors, vomiting and loss of appetite.)
Respondent E, 61 years old female.
Influenced by the friends, neighbors and others. All of the respondents were
first heard about complementary and alternative medicines through their friends,
neighbors and the significant others. They were influenced to use the complementary and
alternative medicines because of their friends experiences. Moreover, complementary
and alternative medicines have become more popular because of the advertisements in
the television, radio and newsprints. The respondents had become more interested on
complementary and alternative medicines based on the experiences to those who had
used the said therapy.
Na dunggan lang nako siya sa mga silingan nako,
makatabang man siya pero dili jud kaayo. (I heard it
from my neighbors; it helps me but not that much).
Respondent A, 59 years old
Nakabalo lang man ko sa akong amiga lang pod. Ana
siya nga iyahang amiga nga naa pod kanser sa susu kay
naga-inom og mga herbal nga tambal sama na lang sa
capsicum, grapeseed, saluyot, ampalaya, termerick,
kumintang, lagundi, mangosteen, quantum, silver cure og
47
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
58/99
bifnor liquid. Ingon siya nga naayo jud siya masking ang
iyahang doktor dili makatuo sa iyahang nakit-an nga
pagbabago. (I only knew it from my friend. She told me
that her friend, who had a cancer in her breast, used
herbal medicines such as capsicum, grapeseed, saluyot,
ampalaya, termerick, kumintang, lagundi, mangosteen,
quantum, silver cure and bifnor liquid. She told me that she
was cured by she herbal medicines and her doctor could
not even believe that there is something changed on her).
Respondent B, 59 years old
Usahay sa commercial sa T.V. na naga-ingon na maayo
gyud daw sila, ug ang uban sa ka trabaho sa akong anak
kay naka-sinati na man daw sila sa kaayo ani.
(Sometimes in the commercial on T.V. that said it can
cure, and according to my daughters coworkers said that
they have tried using it and experienced little
effectiveness.). Respondent C, 54 years old
Sa akong silingan nakadungog ani, nakagamit man pud
siya sa acupuncture og ana siya maayo daw. Mao gisulay
pud nako basi maulian ko. (I heard it from my neighbor,
and said that they were using acupuncture and said its
48
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
59/99
good. Thats why I also tried to use it). Respondent D,
46 years old
Sa mga lain tao rapud, mga silingan namo og sa seminar
na gi-conduct sa among baranggay. (I knew it from
others especially to my neighbors and on the seminar that
was conducted in our Barangay). Respondent E, 61
years old
49
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
60/99
CHAPTER V
SUMMARY, CONCLUSION AND RECOMMENDATION
Summary
The study was conducted in a local tertiary hospital in Davao City. The involved
departments were Gynecology ward, and Internal Medicine ward. This study aimed to
collect data regarding on the participants demographic and clinical profile, views and
reasons on the use of Complementary and Alternative Medicine. The data collection was
conducted through an in-depth interview with the use of interview guide. Five (5) adult
cancer patients who were awake, conscious and coherent were interviewed for this study.
The age of the respondents was ranging from 46 to 61 years old and all were
females. Almost of the respondents were Roman Catholic and the remaining was a
Protestant. Majority of them, three (3) out of five (5), were college graduates and some of
which were elementary undergraduates. Three (3) respondents were married, one (1) was
a single and the other one (1) was a widower. Only one (1) respondent is employed and
two (2) are unemployed. The remaining two (2) respondents are self-employed. The
monthly income of the respondents ranged from Php 1,200 to Php 4,000 with a mean
average of Php 2,233.33.
There were three (3) breast cancer respondents, two (2) of which were diagnosed
with stage four (4) and the other one (1) was diagnosed with stage three (3). The two (2)
remaining respondents were diagnosed with ovarian cancer stage one (1). All of the
50
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
61/99
respondents had undergone diagnostic procedures such as CBC, urinalysis, CT scan,
chest x-ray, ultrasound and biopsy. Two (2) respondents had undergone operations. One
(1) who has breast cancer stage four (4) had undergone Modified Radical Mastectomy
(MRM) last June 2010. The other one (1) with ovarian cancer stage one (1) had two (2)
operations, Total Abdominal Hysterectomy Bilateral Salphingo Oophorectomy
(TAHBSO) and appendectomy last April 2011. Four (4) out of five (5) respondents are
currently on chemotherapy. The remaining one (1) respondent was diagnosed to have
breast cancer stage four (4) a year ago but refused chemotherapy by that time. Currently,
she was about to start of the said treatment. Almost all of the respondents, four (4) out of
five (5), were receiving chemotherapeutic drugs and some were given antibiotics,
diuretics, pain reliever, anti-emetic and beta adrenergic drugs.
Only one (1) respondent said that using the complementary and alternative
medicines, specifically acupuncture, is more effective than the conventional therapy in
terms of alleviating the side effects of chemotherapeutic drugs such as pain, nausea and
vomiting. However, she believed that herbal medicines were not effective in treating
cancer. Three (3) respondents believed that complementary and alternative medicines
were partially effective and also, they were all believed that their use of complementary
and alternative medicines added another year of their life. The remaining one (1)
respondent believed that it was not effective.
51
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
62/99
Conclusion
The five (5) respondents showed varied views and reasons on the use of
complementary and alternative medicines. Most of them viewed these treatment
modalities were partially effective in treating cancer due to several factors such as age
and absence of underlying illness. Furthermore, majority of the respondents had shared
common reasons on the use of complementary and alternative medicines such as financial
constraint, hope to cure cancer, reduced side-effects of chemo drugs and by the
influenced of others. With these views and reasons, it only showed that the use of
complementary and alternative medicines needs further research and progressive
investigation on its proper applications especially on its role as adjunctive therapy for
cancer.
Recommendation
Based on the findings of this study, the researchers would like to recommend to
the following departments and institutions:
Department of Science and Technology (DOST) and other research institutes
1. To conduct concrete researches on effectivity of herbal medicines on the treatment of
cancer.
2. To disseminate research results related to complementary and alternative medicines to
avoid myths and misconceptions.
52
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
63/99
Philippine Medical Association (PMA) and other medical societies
1. To help in educating the public on the role of complementary and alternative
medicines in treatment of the cancer.
2. To strengthen preventive campaign against cancer.
3. To give updates on the recent technologies related to the treatment of cancer.
Department of Health (DOH) and Local Government Unit (LGU)
1. To educate members of baranggay health units on proper use of the complementary
and alternative medicines.
2. To establish community support group of cancer patients.
Hospitals
1. To help document patients with cancer who use complementary and alternative
medicines to monitor disease progression related to its use.
2. To help educate patients on other well-studied treatment modalities for cancer.
53
7/23/2019 Views and Reasons of Adult Cancer Patients on the Use of Complementary and Alternative Medicines
64/99
BIBLIOGRAPHY
American Cancer Society, 2007. www.cancer.org/Research/index
Ashbury FD, Findlay H, Reynolds B et al. A Canadian survey of cancer patients experi-
ences: are their needs being met? J Pain Symptom Manage 1998; 16:298306.
Barnes P.M., Bloom B., & Nahin R. (2008). National health statistics reports:
Complementary and alternative medicine use among adults and children: United
States, 2007.
Basch E., & Ulbricht C. (2004). Prevalence of CAM use among U.S. cancer patients: An
update [Editorial]. Journal of Cancer Integrative Medicine, 2(1), 1314.
Buettner C., Kroenke C.H., Phillips R.S., Davis, R.B., Eisenberg, D., & Holmes, M.
(2006). Correlates of use of different types of complementary and alternative
medicine by breast cancer survivors in