Post on 18-Apr-2015
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
NOTIFICATION
November 2012: United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change
Special Intersessional Meeting
New Haven, CT 2 and 3 November 2012
Dear Honorable Delegates,
On behalf of Secretary General Gordon Geballe you are cordially invited to the COP18/CMP8 sessions of the UNFCCC. The meeting will have parallel discussions (see below for details). We are thankful that Lauren Barredo, Environment Minister of Egypt , Kyle Poorman, Environment Minister of France, and Jeff Gustafson, Environment Minister of Belgium, have agreed to chair the AWG-KP, AWG-LCA and AWG-DP consultations, respectively. These consultations will hopefully move us to a more defined and agreed upon negotiating text. We also welcome Mr. Sai Navoti, Lead Negotiator of the Permanent Mission of the Republic of Nauru to the United Nations, as our keynote speaker and honored guest.
Please see attached agenda, list of attendees, negotiation block assignments, negotiation block chair assignments and note on principled negotiation texts.
As our Secretary-General, recently stated, “Leadership at the highest level is needed to protect the planet, save lives and build a more sustainable global economy for all. In Doha this December, the world must sign a deal.” It is the hopes of the secretariat that this session will move us closer to fulfilling this goal.
The Secretary General and the COP Presidents look forward to substantive discussions and a
constructive meeting. Additional instructions and materials are forthcoming.
Yours Sincerely,
Alark Saxena, Executive Secretary UNFCCC Jeffrey Chow Co-president UNFCCC COP 18/CMP8 Robert Fetter Co-president UNFCCC COP 18/CMP8 When: Friday, November 2, 2012 5:00-11:00PM Saturday, November 3, 2012 8:00 AM-5:00PM
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
Where: Kroon Hall, School of Forestry and Environmental Studies, Yale University Who: Please see attached invite list Attire: Friday: Business Casual, Saturday: Business
AGENDA
****The COP Presidents will be very strict on following the schedule down to the minute in
order to respect the delegates’ precious time. We thank you for your attendance****
Friday, November 2
4:45 pm Registration Kroon Hall 3rd Floor
5:30 pm
6:20 pm
Meet and greet -Delegates and observers
Opening remarks
Knobloch Center
Burke Auditorium
6:30 pm
7:30 pm
8:30 pm
Keynote Address: Sai Navoti, Lead Negotiator, Permanent
Mission of the Republic of Nauru to the United Nations
Buffet Dinner for delegates and guests
Negotiation begins (Block meetings).
Burke Auditorium
Knobloch Center
Kroon Hall
Saturday, November 3
8:00- 9:00 am Breakfast Kroon Hall 3rd Floor
9:00-9:30 am Welcome remarks by the Secretary General Burke Auditorium
9:30- 10:30 am Opening Plenary (remarks made by Blocks) Burke Auditorium
10:30-11:30 am Drafting sessions for respective thematic areas (three
simultaneous sessions)
KP- Kroon 319, LCA- Kroon 321, DP-Burke Auditorium
11:30 - 12:30 pm
11:30 - 12:30 pm
Lunch (Delegation meetings)
Side Event: International Red Cross/Red Crescent
Adaptation Game
Knobloch Center
Knobloch Center
12:30 - 1:30 pm
1:30 - 2:30 pm
Country Block meetings - draft meeting preparation.
Plenary
Kroon Hall
Burke Auditorium
2:30-3:30 pm Drafting sessions for respective thematic areas (three
simultaneous sessions)
KP- Kroon 319, LCA Kroon 321, DP-Burke Auditorium
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
3:30 - 4:30 pm Closing Plenary Burke Auditorium
4:30 - 5:00 pm Closing remarks Burke Auditorium
5:00 - 5:30 pm
5:30 - 6:30 pm
Debriefing (Q and A -experience sharing)
Closing Reception
Burke Auditorium
Knobloch Center
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
LIST OF INVITEES
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
NEGOTIATING BLOCKS
AFRICAN UNION
Berkouwer, Susanna susanna.berkouwer@yale.edu South Africa Chair
Bayasgalan, Onon onon.bayasgalan@yale.edu The Gambia
Garcia, Esperanza egarcia.ecohope@gmail.com Democratic Republic of Congo
Herron, Rick richard.herron@yale.edu Kenya
Hogue, Sarah sjh2167@columbia.edu Uganda
Jones, Hunter hunter.jones@duke.edu Angola
Medinamora, Jose jose.medinamora@yale.edu Algeria
Nicholson, Lia lia.nicholson@yale Liberia
Redmond, Mark mark.redmond@yale.edu Egypt
Santin, Kent ks3023@columbia.edu Madagascar
Zhang, Xiang xiang.zhang.xz266@yale.edu Somalia
BOLIVARIAN ALLIANCE FOR THE AMERICAS (ALBA)
Stabert, Nora elinore.stabert@duke.edu Venezuela Chair
Barbosa, Jorge jorge.barbosa@yale.edu Dominica
Davila, Liliana liliana.davila@yale.edu Cuba
Emmerman, David david.emmerman@yale.edu Ecuador
Graham, Laura lauren.graham@yale.edu Nicaragua
Knodel, Marissa marissa.knodel@yale.edu Bolivia
ALLIANCE OF SMALL ISLAND STATES (AOSIS)
Shan, Lizzie shaxuan.shan@yale.edu Nauru Chair
Ashebir, Adedana adedana.ashebir@yale.edu Papua New Guinea
Barbosa, Jorge jorge.barbosa@yale.edu Dominica
Caballero, Vivienne vivienne.caballero@gmail.com Belize
Davila, Liliana liliana.davila@yale.edu Cuba
Li, Fan f.li@yale.edu Tuvalu
Malik, Omar omar.malik@yale.edu Maldives
Miao, William niancen.miao@yale.edu Solomon Islands
Uuganbayar, Bo Bo.uuganbayar@yale.edu Antigua and Barbuda
BASIC
Wright, Kathryn kathryn.wright@yale.edu India Chair
Berkouwer, Susanna susanna.berkouwer@yale.edu South Africa
Goldfarb, Benjamin benjamin.goldfarb@yale.edu India
Johnson, Laura laura.a.johnson@yale.edu China
Mitchell-Larson, Eli eli.mitchell-larson@yale.edu China
Ryvola, Rebeka rebeka.ryvola@yale.edu Brazil
Schinn, Dustin dustin.schinn@yale.edu India
Vernoit, Alexander alexander.vernoit@yale.edu China
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
ENVIRONMENTAL INTEGRITY GROUP (EIG)
Auel, Erin ema39@georgetown.edu Mexico Chair
Harris, Emily eah85@georgetown.edu Republic of Korea
West, Laura lcw26@georgetown.edu Switzerland
EUROPEAN UNION (EU)
Callagy, Alana alana.callagy@yale.edu Cyprus Chair
Babalola, Elizabeth elizabeth.babalola@yale.edu France
Dagan, Mathew doug.dagan@yale.edu Germany
Holmatov, Bunyod bunyod.holmatov@yale.edu Spain
Mani, Aparna aparna.mani@yale.edu Greece
Semenov, Andrey andrey.semenov@yale.edu Italy
Tyree, Lucas lucas.tyree@yale.edu United Kingdom
G77+CHINA
Ashebir, Adedana adedana.ashebir@yale.edu Algeria Chair
Medinamora, Jose jose.medinamora@yale.edu Papua New Guinea
Barbosa, Jorge jorge.barbosa@yale.edu Dominica
Bayasgalan, Onon onon.bayasgalan@yale.edu The Gambia
Berkouwer, Susanna susanna.berkouwer@yale.edu South Africa
Caballero, Vivienne vivienne.caballero@gmail.com Belize
Comte, Adrien adrien.comte@duke.edu Iran
Cornelius, Adam adam.cornelius@duke.edu Qatar
Davila, Liliana liliana.davila@yale.edu Cuba
Du, Jing jing.du@duke.edu Qatar
Emmerman, David david.emmerman@yale.edu Ecuador
Fonseca, Sarah sarahfons@gmail.com Laos
Garcia, Esperanza egarcia.ecohope@gmail.com Democratic Republic of Congo
Goldfarb, Benjamin benjamin.goldfarb@yale.edu India
Graham, Laura lauren.graham@yale.edu Nicaragua
Herron, Rick richard.herron@yale.edu Kenya
Hogue, Sarah sjh2167@columbia.edu Uganda
Jagannathan, Anusha anusha.jagannathan@duke.edu Saudi Arabia
Johnson, Laura laura.a.johnson@yale.edu China
Joiner, Andrew Scott jsa18@duke.edu Qatar
Jones, Hunter hunter.jones@duke.edu Angola
Knodel, Marissa marissa.knodel@yale.edu Bolivia
Lee, Dong Won dl2783@columbia.edu Nepal
Li, Fan f.li@yale.edu Tuvalu
Lika, Selim selimlika@gmail.com Cambodia
Malik, Omar omar.malik@yale.edu Maldives
Miao, William niancen.miao@yale.edu Solomon Islands
Mitchell-Larson, Eli eli.mitchell-larson@yale.edu China
Navani, Aman amn2165@columbia.edu Bangladesh
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
Nicholson, Lia lia.nicholson@yale Liberia
Peyraud, Charlotte Cfp2114@columbia.edu Yemen
Redmond, Mark mark.redmond@yale.edu Egypt
Ryvola, Rebeka rebeka.ryvola@yale.edu Brazil
Santin, Kent ks3023@columbia.edu Madagascar
Schinn, Dustin dustin.schinn@yale.edu India
Shan, Lizzie shaxuan.shan@yale.edu Nauru
Stabert, Nora elinore.stabert@duke.edu Venezuela
Uuganbayar, Bo Bo.uuganbayar@yale.edu Antigua and Barbuda
Vernoit, Alexander alexander.vernoit@yale.edu China
Wright, Kathryn kathryn.wright@yale.edu India
Zhang, Xiang xiang.zhang.xz266@yale.edu Somalia
LEAST DEVELOPED COUNTRIES (LDC)
Bayasgalan, Onon onon.bayasgalan@yale.edu The Gambia Chair
Barrer, Reginald Rex reginaldrex.barrer@yale.edu Afghanistan
Fonseca, Sarah sarahfons@gmail.com Laos
Garcia, Esperanza egarcia.ecohope@gmail.com Democratic Republic of Congo
Hogue, Sarah sjh2167@columbia.edu Uganda
Jones, Hunter hunter.jones@duke.edu Angola
Lee, Dong Won dl2783@columbia.edu Nepal
Li, Fan f.li@yale.edu Tuvalu
Lika, Selim selimlika@gmail.com Cambodia
Miao, William niancen.miao@yale.edu Solomon Islands
Navani, Aman amn2165@columbia.edu Bangladesh
Nicholson, Lia lia.nicholson@yale Liberia
Peyraud, Charlotte Cfp2114@columbia.edu Yemen
Santin, Kent ks3023@columbia.edu Madagascar
Zhang, Xiang xiang.zhang.xz266@yale.edu Somalia
LIKE-MINDED DEVELOPING COUNTRIES
Johnson, Laura laura.a.johnson@yale.edu China Chair
Emmerman, David david.emmerman@yale.edu Ecuador
Franceschini, Laura laura.franceschini@yale.edu Phillippines
Goldfarb, Benjamin benjamin.goldfarb@yale.edu India
Graham, Laura lauren.graham@yale.edu Nicaragua
Jagannathan, Anusha anusha.jagannathan@duke.edu Saudi Arabia
Knodel, Marissa marissa.knodel@yale.edu Bolivia
Mitchell-Larson, Eli eli.mitchell-larson@yale.edu China
Redmond, Mark mark.redmond@yale.edu Egypt
Schinn, Dustin dustin.schinn@yale.edu India
Vernoit, Alexander alexander.vernoit@yale.edu China
Wright, Kathryn kathryn.wright@yale.edu India
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
ORGANIZATION OF THE PETROLEUM EXPORTING COUNTRIES (OPEC)
Joiner, Andrew Scott jsa18@duke.edu Qatar Chair
Comte, Adrien adrien.comte@duke.edu Iran
Cornelius, Adam adam.cornelius@duke.edu Qatar
Du, Jing jing.du@duke.edu Qatar
Emmerman, David david.emmerman@yale.edu Ecuador
Jagannathan, Anusha anusha.jagannathan@duke.edu Saudi Arabia
Jones, Hunter hunter.jones@duke.edu Angola
Shi, Wenjing wenjing.shi@duke.edu United Arab Emirates
Stabert, Nora elinore.stabert@duke.edu Venezuela
Thompson, Dacie dacia.thompson@gmail.com United Arab Emirates
UMBRELLA GROUP
Cho, Haein haein.cho@duke.edu United States Chair
Anjum, Rubaina rubaina.anjum@duke.edu Australia
Jiang, Lin lin.jiang@duke.edu United States
Livengood, Avery avery.livengood@duke.edu United States
Lloyd, Matt matthew.lloyd@duke.edu Canada
Son, Myeongyeon ms458@duke.edu Norway
Song, Jiayin js487@duke.edu Japan
Willensky, Regina regina.willensky@duke.edu Ukraine
Zhou, Changchang zcc.900129@gmail.com Russian Federation
GROUND RULES
The first reading of the text provides the opportunity for delegates to express their acceptance
or disapproval of the text to be negotiated. This is the time when the secretariat takes those
comments and translates them on the screen with the edited text in brackets with country
name supporting that motion. At the end of the first day this “new” text with country positions
will be emailed around to the delegates to help inform your week of informal discussions.
For example, this is what the paragraphs will basically look like after the first reading:
“PP 8 Alt 5 Deeply concerned that the adverse impacts of climate change[, including sea level rise
(Russia – add phrase)] [could constitute give rise to (CARICOM)] security [risks to implications for
(CARICOM, supported by United States)] affected countries (New Zealand – proposed pp 8 alt 5)
(Switzerland – would not want ‘could’, view supported by EU)”
Role of Science:
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
The IPCC Secretariat can only provide advice during the meeting when asked for by a country
delegate or the Chairman. Please take advantage of this. In addition, all science used for
negotiating points are only acceptable if in the Fourth Assessment Report unless new research
post-AR4 can be adequately justified by the country delegate. The Scoping document for the
Fifth Assessment Report could be used to promote priorities by different delegates.
ALL DECISIONS WILL BE MADE BY CONSENSUS, AND CONSENSUS ONLY!!
Consensus Decision Making Under the UNFCCC and Kyoto Protocol Decisions under the UNFCCC and the Kyoto Protocol are made by consensus, not majority vote. The provision in the UNFCCC Rules of Procedure relating to voting was never adopted because countries objected to being bound by majority vote. Consensus decision-making requires that all major countries consent to the arrangements you negotiate. If a country does not agree to the arrangements and the group adopts a decision without them, that country is unlikely to sign or ratify the new arrangement, which undermines the goal of an international climate regime designed to prevent dangerous climate change. Below are the ground rules previously agreed to by stakeholders. These rules require that members:
Avoid making personal attacks on other group members;
Share relevant information with other group members;
Explain the reasons behind one's statements, questions, and actions;
Keep to the agenda;
Make decisions by consensus, rather than majority rule;
No private discussions; all discussions take place as a group; and
Cell phones turned off at all times.
Only one person per group will serve as spokesman. During the First Reading for each motion the delegate is only allowed 2 minutes to state and defend their suggested addition or deletion;
The participants will achieve the best results if they present themselves as the persons described in their particular role throughout the week.
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
SCROLL DOWN…ONE MORE PAGE
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document
Negotiation Simulation For Academic Purposes Only, Fictional UNFCCC Document