Post on 19-Dec-2021
A BSRIA Guide www.bsria.co.uk
The Illustrated Guide toRenewable Technologies
By Kevin Pennycook
BG 1/2008
BG 1-2008 (Renewables) cover (rev).p65 17/03/2008, 10:013
2 ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES © BSRIA BG 1/2008
INTRODUCTION Welcome to a new BSRIA illustrated guide to low energy and renewable technologies. The publication is the ideal primer for understanding the wide variety of innovative systems that provide cleaner and less environmentally damaging ways of heating, cooling and powering buildings. This guide covers the majority of technologies that derive all or some of their power from renewable sources of energy, such as wind and biofuel. However biomass boilers can be used in conjunction with combined heat and power (CHP) and absorption refrigeration. As it’s vital that clients and designers understand the relationships between conventional low energy systems and emerging renewable energy systems, the guide covers both types (although, for reasons of brevity, not all low energy systems were able to be included). Renewable energy describes power obtained from sources that are essentially inexhaustible. This covers energy supplies such as wind power, geothermal power, biomass, and solar power including photovoltaics. Some renewable supplies can also be used to create secondary fuels, such as hydrogen for use in fuel cells. Whether the motivation comes from tighter energy regulation, higher fuel prices, or greater corporate responsibility, clients and their design teams will be required to consider using such renewable forms of energy to partially or wholly offset the use of fossil fuels and mains electricity. Some renewable energy sources are able to absorb naturally any carbon dioxide emitted as a consequence of their use or combustion. Biofuels, derived from plant crops, are a good example. The carbon dioxide emitted from burning wood chips or plant oils is absorbed very quickly by new growth. It stands to reason that burning oak is not as sustainable as burning coppiced wood, as the growth cycle is longer and the carbon dioxide emitted will hang around longer in the Earth’s atmospheric systems to play its role in increasing the greenhouse effect. Other systems, such as wind turbines and solar panels, emit no carbon dioxide when generating electricity. However, a considerable amount of carbon dioxide will have been emitted during product manufacture. The distinction is important for designers who take a whole-life costing approach to construction. Embodied energy should influence both the basis of a building’s design and the selection of products – including renewables. Photovoltaics, for example, contain precious materials that require considerable energy to manufacture and transport. Depending on their contribution to the building’s energy needs, it might take 20 years or more for the photovoltaics to redeem the energy used in their manufacture. This needs to be considered during the specification stage.
ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES 3 © BSRIA BG 1/2008
There is also a mistaken belief that buildings will automatically benefit from improved efficiency and lower carbon-dioxide emissions by being kitted-out with renewables technologies. This is a fallacy. Few technologies are truly fit-and-forget and work in a low energy mode straight out of the box. Renewable technologies, by and large, require greater attention at design, and can be demanding to manage and maintain. So when clients are being asked to invest in renewables technology, they need to know under what conditions the systems will perform, and what levels of diligence and expertise will be required in their facilities management. Fine-tuning of the renewables systems after occupation is also vital to ensure sustainable performance over the long-term. So while renewable energy systems are certainly desirable compared with conventional fossil-fuel energy sources, the starting point is not a supplier’s catalogue of gleaming solar panels or rooftop-mounted wind turbines. The starting point is to reduce the loads in the building first, and then increase the efficiency of the heating, ventilating, cooling and lighting systems. This can be achieved by investing in passive design, building it properly, and through discerning product specification. The third step is to halve the carbon in the mains fuel supplies, perhaps by taking power from off-site wind turbines or district biomass-CHP. Community energy schemes using large-scale wind power, co or tri-generation and district heating make more environmental and economic sense than lots of separate, smaller renewable systems serving single buildings. By following this process, designers can cut carbon-dioxide emissions to one-eighth of what they would otherwise be before need arises for specifying renewables technology. As we head into a changing world where carbon neutrality will soon become a government objective, the mantra is this: keep it simple, do it well, finish things off properly, and only get clever with renewables where they are truly justified. And when you do, use this guide as your design primer. Roderic Bunn BSRIA, March 2008
4 ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES © BSRIA BG 1/2008
SUMMARY Technology Characteristics Functionality Cost
effectiveness Reliability Maintenance
requirement CO2 saving Overall
rating
Absorption cooling
Requires no mechanical vapour compression. Activated by external heat source
High. Waste heat from CHP source used to provide cooling source for air conditioning
Medium. More expensive than conventional chillers but uses waste heat
High. Few moving parts
Low Medium – high
***
Biomass Uses plant-derived organic material (relatively carbon neutral). Can produce heat or biogas depending on the type of technology
High. Direct combustion systems can replace gas/oil-fired boilers. Requires large fuel storage facility
Medium. More expensive than conventional boilers
High for direct combustion systems. Anaerobic digestion and gasification systems can be problematic
Medium. Direct combustion systems are partially self cleaning
High *****
CHP Generates both electricity and heat using fossil or renewable fuels
High. Requires predictable and relatively constant loads for best performance
Medium. Requires full utilisation of waste heat
Medium. Proven technology
Medium. Requires regular planned maintenance
Medium. Can be improved if biomass fuel is used
****
Fuel cells Electrochemical device that produces electricity and heat on-site
High. Same as CHP
Low. Limited range of commercially available fuel cells, and expensive
Medium. Long-term reliability data not yet available. Expected to be reliable
Medium. Few moving parts. Fuel cell stack has finite life
Medium. Depends on full utilisation of generated heat and fuel source
**
Greywater recovery
Reuses waste water (bathing, washing, laundry) for toilet flushing, irrigation, and other non-potable uses
Medium. Requires match between waste water source and use
Low. Installation and on-going costs may not justify savings
Medium. Pumps, filters, and sensors can present problems
Medium. Requires planned maintenance regime to cover health risks
Low **
Ground source systems – air
Uses heat from the ground to pre-condition the supply air to a building
High. Can pre-cool air in summer and pre-heat it in winter
Medium. Depends on cost of drilling or excavation to install pipes
High. No moving parts
Low. Providing steps are taken to pre-filter air and avoid water ingress
Medium ***
Ground source systems – water
Makes use of water from aquifers (either directly or indirectly) to provide cooling in summer
High. Can be combined with heat pump technology. Heat source can pre-heat ventilation air
Medium. Depends on cost of boreholes
High. However, open-loop systems are susceptible to blockages and biological fouling
Low for closed-loop systems
Medium ***
Ground source heat pumps
Takes up heat from ground and releases it at higher temperatures. Heat can be used for space heating and domestic hot water
High. Systems can be run in cooling mode
Medium High. Relatively few moving parts. Proven technology
Low Medium. High COPs are dependant on relatively low supply temperatures in heating mode
****
ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES 5 © BSRIA BG 1/2008
Technology Characteristics Functionality Cost effectiveness
Reliability Maintenance requirement
CO2 saving Overall rating
Photovoltaics Converts sunlight directly to DC electrical power. Requires inverter to convert to AC
Medium. Requires careful positioning for optimum performance. Wide range of installation options
Low. However, costs are predicted to improve
Medium. Associated inverters can cause problems
Low, but specialist
Low. Relative to high cost
***
Rainwater recovery
Collects and stores rainwater from roofs and other catchment areas for toilet flushing
Medium. Requires a balance between collected water and its use. Large storage tanks may be required
Low. Installation and on-going costs may not justify savings
Medium. Pumps, filters, and sensors can present problems
Medium. Requires inclusion in a planned maintenance regime
Low **
Solar air heating
Collects solar energy to heat supply air. Can also heat re-circulated air
Medium. Relatively large number of techniques. Can also pre-heat domestic hot water
Medium. Solar collectors can be an integral part of the building fabric
High Low. System cleaning required, so access can be an issue
Low – medium. Requires fan power, however this could be provided by photovoltaics
***
Solar cooling Solar thermal energy used to drive absorption, adsorption or desiccant cooling
Medium. Requires matching of solar collector temperature with chiller operating temperature.
Low. Relatively high cost of absorption chillers and solar collectors
High Low. Absorption chiller is low maintenance
Low – medium
*
Solar water heating
Solar energy used to heat water, usually for domestic hot water purposes
Medium. Proven technology with a range of collectors for different operational requirements
Medium Medium – high. Circulation pump and valves are relatively reliable
Low Medium. Circulating pumps can be PV powered
****
Surface water cooling
Uses pumped water from the sea, lakes or rivers to provide a cooling medium
Low. Relatively few buildings close to suitable water sources
Low – medium. Depends on the length of piping required
Medium – high. Filtration required to prevent heat exchanger fouling
Low Medium. Depends on the pumping power required
***
Water conservation
Range of devices used to limit water consumption
Can be used in a wide range of applications and building types
Medium. Depends on device
Generally reliable, but some devices may be susceptible to hard water
Low – medium. Waterless urinals require regular and correct maintenance
Low ****
Wind Turbine/ generator converts wind energy to electrical power
Best performance in open, non-urban locations. Can be installed on, or integrated into, a building
Low. Depends greatly on available wind conditions. Actual power output likely to be much less than the rated output
Medium. Turbulent air conditions associated with urban locations may reduce lifespan of components
Medium. Requires regular maintenance. Access may be an issue
Low – medium. Large sized turbines in non-urban or off-shore locations will be more effective
**
ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES 7 © BSRIA BG 1/2008
CONTENTS Page
SUMMARY 4
ALPHABETICAL LIST OF SYSTEMS AND EQUIPMENT 8
ABSORPTION COOLING 9
BIOMASS 13
COMBINED HEAT AND POWER 20
FUEL CELLS 27
GREYWATER 32
GROUND SOURCE SYSTEMS 36
Ground source systems – air 36 Ground source systems – water 39 Ground source heat pumps 42
PHOTOVOLTAICS 47
RAINWATER RECOVERY 53
SOLAR 59
Solar air heating 59 Solar cooling 63 Solar water heating 66
SURFACE WATER COOLING 73
WATER CONSERVATION 75
WIND POWER 80
8 ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES © BSRIA BG 1/2008
ALPHABETICAL LIST OF SYSTEMS AND EQUIPMENT Absorption chillers 9-10, 12 Lithium bromide 10
Absorption cooling 63 Membrane filters 33
Adsorption cooling 64 Micro CHP 20, 22
Ammonia refrigeration 10 Open-loop systems 39, 41, 60-61, 68, 73
Anaerobic digestion 15 Perforated air-collectors 61
Back-pressure steam turbine systems 21 Photovoltaics 47, 52
Biofuel 13 Pitched roofs 48-49, 70
Biological treatment 33, 56 Plate heat-exchanger 21
Biomass CHP 22 Pressurised systems 68
Biomass storage 17 Rainwater 34-35, 53-56, 58
Biomass system 18 Reciprocating engine CHP 11
Building façade 48-49, 51, 59, 71, 82 Reed beds 33, 57
Cavity collector 60 Sand filters 33
Closed-loop collector 60 Seawater cooling system 74
Closed-loop systems 40 Shell and tube heat-exchanger 21
Collection tanks 55 Showers and baths 77
Combined heat and power 17, 18 Sloping roofs 48, 49, 70
Condenser 9-10, 12, 39 Soakaway 35, 58
Dehumidification 45 Solar air systems 59
Desiccant cooling 65 Solar collectors 60
Direct combustion 13, 18 Solar heating of ventilation air 59
Directly pumped systems 53 Solar shading devices 48, 50
Disinfection 57-58 Solar water heating systems 66, 70
Domestic hot water heating 45 Space cooling 23, 45
Drainback systems 69 Space heating 44
Dry air-coolers 12 Steam turbines 21
Evacuated-tube collectors 67 Surface water cooling 73
Evaporator 9-10, 42 Tri-generation 22
Flat roofs 48-49, 51 Unglazed plastic collectors 68
Flat-plate collectors 59 Urinals 75
Foul drainage 35, 58 Vapour-compression chiller 12
Fuel cells 27-31 Vertical-axis turbines 80
Gas turbines 11, 20-21 Water conservation 75, 79
Gasification 16 Water storage 34
Glazed flat-plate collectors 67 Water treatment 33
Gravity systems 53 Water-efficient WCs 76
Greywater systems 32 Waterless and vacuum toilets 77
Ground-coupled systems 36 Wet cooling towers 12
Ground source heat pumps 40, 42-46 Wind turbines 80-84
Heat exchangers 21, 39, 43-46, 60, 66-70, 73-74 Woodchip fuel 13
ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES 9 © BSRIA BG 1/2008
ABSORPTION COOLING System description
In a conventional vapour-compression chiller an electric motor is used to drive a compressor. In an absorption chiller a heat source drives the cooling process. Heat sources can include hot water, steam, hot air or hot products of combustion (exhaust gases) from the burning of fuel. In a conventional mechanical vapour-compression chiller the refrigerant evaporates at a low pressure and produces a cooling effect. A compressor is then used to compress the vapour to a higher pressure where it condenses and releases heat. In an absorption chiller the compressor is replaced by a chemical absorber, generator and a pump. The pump consumes much less electricity than a comparable compressor (approximately nine percent of that for a vapour compression plant). The majority of the energy required to drive the cooling process is provided by the external supply of heat. Absorption cycles use two fluids: the refrigerant and the absorbent. The most common fluids are water for the refrigerant and lithium bromide for the absorbent. These fluids are separated and re-combined in the absorption cycle. The low-pressure refrigerant vapour is absorbed into the absorbent releasing heat. The liquid refrigerant/absorbent solution is pumped to a generator with high operating pressure. Heat is then added at the high-pressure generator which causes the refrigerant to desorb from the absorbent and vaporise. The vapours flow to a condenser, where heat is rejected and condensed to a high-pressure liquid. The liquid is then throttled through an expansion valve to the lower pressure in the evaporator where it evaporates by absorbing heat. This absorbing of heat is used to provide a useful cooling effect. The remaining liquid absorbent in the generator passes through a valve where its pressure is reduced and is then re-combined with the low-pressure refrigerant vapours returning from the evaporator. The cycle is then repeated.
Schematic of absorption chiller.
Benefits Can make use of waste heat
Refrigerants used have no global warming potential
Quiet and vibration-free
Reliable
Relatively low maintenance costs
Limitations Low efficiency, and low coefficient of
performance compared to conventional chillers
Relatively high cost compared to vapour compressors
Larger heat-rejection plant than conventional chillers
Slower to start up and slower to respond to changing loads
10 ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES © BSRIA BG 1/2008
Absorption chillers have a number of advantages:
They are activated by heat
No mechanical vapour-compression is required
The refrigerants used do not damage the atmosphere and have no global warming potential (some refrigerants used in vapour compression chillers have very high global-warming potential)
Require no lubricants
Quiet and vibration free.
System types Absorption chillers can be classified based on the type of heat source, the number of effects and the chemicals used in the absorption process. Indirect-fired absorption chillers use waste/rejected heat from another process to drive the absorption process. Typical heat sources include steam, hot water or hot gases. Direct-fired chillers include an integral burner, usually operating on natural gas. In a single-effect absorption chiller the heat released during the chemical process of absorbing refrigerant vapour into the liquid stream is rejected as waste heat. In a double-effect absorption chiller some of this energy is used to generate high-pressure refrigerant vapour. Using this heat of absorption reduces the demand for heat and boosts the chiller system efficiency. Double-effect chillers use two generators paired with a single condenser, absorber and evaporator. Although they operate with a greater efficiency they require a higher temperature heat input compared with a single-effect chiller. The minimum heat source temperature for a double-effect chiller is 140oC. Double-effect chillers are more expensive than single-effect chillers. Triple-effect chillers are under development. Two absorbent-refrigerant mixtures are widely used. These are lithium bromide water mixture and ammonia refrigeration mixture. In a lithium bromide water mixture the lithium bromide (a salt) is the absorbent and the water is the refrigerant. Lithium bromide systems are the most commonly used absorption system, particularly for commercial cooling. In an ammonia system the water is the absorbent and the ammonia is the refrigerant. Ammonia systems are typically used when low temperature cooling or freezing is required. Lithium bromide water systems are widely available as packaged units with capacities ranging from 100 kW to several thousands of kilowatts. A practical limitation associated with this type of system is that the minimum chilled water temperature that can be produced is approximately 5oC. Ammonia refrigeration systems are available in small (30-100 kW), medium (100-1000 kW) and large (>1000 kW) sizes. Cooling temperatures down to -60oC are possible.
Allied technologies
CHP
Industrial processes producing waste heat
Renewable sources producing heat.
Table 1: Absorption chiller range.
Chiller type Heat source
Hot water (80-130oC) or steam (0·2-1·0
bar)
Steam (3-9 bar)
Engine exhaust
gases (280-800oC)
Single-effect
Refrigerant Water - -
Condenser type Water cooled
- -
Co-efficient of performance
0·7 - -
Double-effect
Refrigerant - Water Water
Condenser type - Water cooled
Water cooled
Co-efficient of performance
- 1·2 1·1
Source: CIBSE Guide B4
ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES 11 © BSRIA BG 1/2008
Where to use Absorption cooling can be considered as an alternative to traditional chillers if one of the following factors applies:
An existing combined heat and power (CHP) unit is present and not all of the waste heat is being used
A new CHP installation is being considered
Waste heat is available from a process
Renewable fuel sources can be used such as landfill gas. The available heat source will determine the type of absorption chiller that is suitable for a specific application. Typical sources of heat include:
Gas turbine CHP
Reciprocating engine CHP
Waste heat
Hot water and steam. With a gas turbine CHP, the exhaust gas from the gas turbine is used to raise steam in a waste heat boiler. The high-pressure steam available is suitable for supplying a double-effect absorption unit. The overall efficiency of the CHP can be enhanced if second stage heat recovery using the exhaust gases is used to heat water for domestic hot water and/or space heating uses. Reciprocating engine CHP units typically provide hot water at 85-90oC. This can be used for a single-effect absorption chiller, although the performance of the chiller will have to be down-rated (single-effect absorption chillers normally work on a heat source at 102oC and above). Some CHP engines can produce water at higher temperatures, in which case the performance of the absorption chiller will be improved. Waste heat from other sources such as industrial processes can also be used to drive absorption chillers. Low-pressure steam and water can be used with single-effect absorption chillers while higher pressure steam (7-9 bar) can be used to drive double-effect chillers. In instances where boilers provide space heating and are required to supply a small load in summer, or where a large ring-main is used to supply a few users, the efficiency of the boiler system can be improved by using the heated water/steam to drive an absorption chiller. In practice, however, it may be more efficient to reconsider the heating strategy and install a number of small local boilers.
Application considerations The factors that determine whether a heat source is suitable for an absorption cooling application are:
Temperature of the source heat-stream
Flow rate of the recovered heat-stream
Chemical composition of the source heat-stream
Intermittency of the recovered heat stream temperature and flow.
12 ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES © BSRIA BG 1/2008
The performance of an absorption chiller is dependent on the following:
A higher chilled water temperature gives a higher coefficient of performance (COP) and cooling capacity
A lower cooling water temperature gives a higher COP and cooling capacity
A higher temperature heat source gives a similar COP but increases cooling capacity.
Using a lower heat source temperature, higher condenser water temperature or lower chiller water temperature will reduce the cooling output. This means that a larger, more expensive machine will be required. The heat rejection from an absorption chiller will be greater than a conventional chiller with the same cooling capacity. This will require larger heat rejection units (such as dry air-coolers or wet cooling towers) for absorption chillers. The associated space and weight constraints on some sites may be an issue. Absorption chillers are slower to start-up than mechanical vapour compression chillers. They are also slower to respond to changing loads. For large systems a buffer tank may be required to increase the inertia for the chilled water circuit. The frequent starting and stopping of absorption chillers should be avoided. Absorption chillers have few moving parts and have correspondingly lower maintenance requirements compared to conventional chillers. Maintenance costs can be lower than conventional chillers. An absorption chiller can be used to meet the base-load cooling demand in a building, while peak cooling loads can be met by a conventional chiller. This approach can be advantageous because conventional chillers usually cost less than the equivalent absorption chiller. Their use is therefore more cost-effective for limited running hours. Designers should consider the requirements for a standby heat source should the normal heat source (such as a CHP unit) not be available. The requirement for standby capacity will depend on the criticality of the business function associated with the building. Designers should also consider whether it is more appropriate to size the absorption chiller on the available heat source or on the building’s cooling demand. The temperature of the heat source will determine whether a single or double-effect chiller is appropriate. An absorption chiller used in conjunction with a CHP unit will raise the viability and cost effectiveness of the CHP unit. Most CHP installations are sized on the basis of heat demand. This usually means that the building’s electrical base load is higher than the CHP’s electrical output. By using an absorption chiller the additional heat load allows increased running hours while reducing the electricity demand associated with conventional chillers. .
Glossary Vapour-compression chiller A refrigeration device that uses mechanical means (usually driven by an electric motor) to raise the pressure of a refrigerant
Combined heat and power system A system that simultaneously generates electricity and heat in a single integrated unit. The heat (usually in the form of heated water or steam) can be used for building services-related processes. Also referred to as cogeneration
Dry-air coolers A device used to reject heat from a refrigeration system. Air is passed over a heat exchanger (condenser)
Wet cooling towers A heat-rejection device that extracts heat from a refrigeration system to the atmosphere through the cooling of a water stream to a lower temperature. Heat is lost through evaporation of some of the water. Also referred to as an evaporative cooling tower
Evaporator A part of a refrigeration system in which the refrigerant evaporates and in so doing takes up external heat in its vicinity
Condenser A part of a refrigeration system, which enables the refrigerant to condense, and in so doing gives up heat
Standards None identified
References and further reading An Introduction to Absorption Cooling, Good Practice Guide 256, Energy Efficiency Best practice Programme 2001
Application Guide for Absorption Cooling/Refrigeration using Recovered Heat, ASHRAE 1995, ISBN 1 88341326 5
ASHRAE Handbook – Refrigeration ASHRAE
Refrigeration and Heat Rejection, CIBSE Guide B4
Small-Scale Combined Heat and Power for Buildings, CIBSE AM12, 1999
ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES 13 © BSRIA BG 1/2008
BIOMASS System description Biomass is any plant-derived organic material that renews itself over a short period. Biomass energy systems are based on either the direct or indirect combustion of fuels derived from those plant sources. The most common form of biomass is the direct combustion of wood in treated or untreated forms. Other possibilities include the production and subsequent combustion of biogas produced by either gasification or anaerobic digestion of plant materials. Liquid biofuels such as bioethanol can also be used. The use of biomass is becoming increasingly common in some European countries (some countries such as Austria are heavily dependant on biomass). The environmental benefits relate to the significantly lower amounts of energy used in biomass production and processing compared to the energy released when they are burnt. This can range from a four-fold return for biodiesel to an approximate 20-fold energy return for woody biomass. CHP systems and absorption chillers are discussed elsewhere in this guide.
Biomass system types
Direct combustion The direct combustion of wood-based fuel sources is likely to be the most practical use of biomass in building applications. Potential fuel sources are wide ranging and include solid wood, wood off-cuts, woodchips, pellets and briquettes. Typical examples of woody biomass include willow short-rotation coppice and miscanthus (perennial grass).
Table 2: Typical properties.
Energy density by mass
Energy density by mass
Bulk density Energy density by volume
Energy density by volume
Fuel
GJ/tonne KWh/kg Kg/m3 MJ/m3 KWh/m3
Wood chips (very dependent on moisture content)
7 – 15 2 – 4 175 – 350 2000 – 3600 600 – 1000
Log wood (stacked – air dry 20% moisture content)
15 4·2 300 – 550 4500 – 8300 1 300 – 2300
Wood (solid oven dry) 18 – 21 5 – 5·8 450 – 800 8100 – 16 800 2300 – 4600
Wood pellets 18 5 600 – 700 10 800 – 12 600 3000 – 3500
Miscanthus (bail) 17 4·7 120 – 160 2000 – 2700 560 – 750
Table 3: An overview of biofuels, the feedstocks and processes used in their production.
Biofuel type Specific name Biomass feedstock Production process
Bioethanol Conventional bioethanol Sugar beets, grains Hydrolysis and fermentation
Vegetable oil Pure vegetable oil Oil crops (such as rapeseed, sunflower seeds)
Cold pressing and extraction
Biodiesel Biodiesel from energy crops Rapeseed methyl ester (RME), fatty acid methyl/ethyl ester (FAME/FAEE)
Oil crops (such as rapeseed, sunflower seeds)
Cold pressing and extraction and transesterfication
Biodiesel Biodiesel from waste (FAME/FAEE) Waste, cooking and frying oil Transesterfication
Biogas Upgraded biogas (Wet) biomass Digestion
Bio-ETBE Bioethanol Chemical synthesis
Benefits Biomass-fuels can be used to produce energy
on a continuous basis (unlike renewables such as wind or solar energy)
Biomass can be an economic alternative to fossil fuels
Biomass is a potential source of both heat and electricity
Biomass technology is flexible and scaleable, from a single boiler to a power station
Limitations Biomass fuels have a lower energy density
compared to fossil fuels
Biomass systems have particular design management and maintenance requirements associated with sourcing, transportation and storage
Biomass can be less convenient to operate than mains-supplied fuels such as natural gas
Biomass systems are more management intensive and require expertise in facilities management
Sources of biomass can fluctuate, so boilers should be specified to operate on a variety of fuels without risk of overheating or tripping out
14 ILLUSTRATED GUIDE TO RENEWABLE TECHNOLOGIES © BSRIA BG 1/2008
Biomass heaters range from small, simple wood-burning stoves to large fully automated boilers intended for large commercial/public buildings or community heating schemes. Features of a good large-scale boiler include the following:
Thermal efficiency greater than 85%
Emissions at full load less than 250 mg/m3 CO, 150 mg/m3 dust and 300 mg/m3 NOx
Automatic cleaning of the boiler heat-exchanger and automatic ash removal
Remote monitoring of the boiler operating parameters.
Table 4: Large-scale biomass boilers are available in a range of combustion types.
Combustion type
Feed Fuel Power
Dual-chamber furnace
Mechanical Woodchips, bark
35 kW – 3 MW
Underfeed furnace
Mechanical Woodchips 20 kW – 2 MW
Stocker-fired furnace
Mechanical Woodchips From 200 kW
Cyclone furnace Pneumatic From 200 kW
Fluidized-bed combustion
Mechanical Woodchips From 10 MW
Source: Planning and Installing Bioenergy Systems. The operational characteristics of biomass boilers differ significantly from traditional boilers (such as gas-fired boilers). Start-up times are longer and heat retention within the boiler means that heat is transferred to the heated medium for a considerable period after boiler shutdown. Although most biomass boilers are designed to allow modulation of the boiler output down to typically 30% of the maximum output, they are not best suited to frequent modulation. For efficient, low emission combustion, biomass needs to be burned rapidly and at a high temperature. One approach to achieving optimum performance is to incorporate a buffer tank into the system. A large volume of water is used as a thermal store between the boiler and the load side of the heating system. When the load decreases the temperature of the water in the tank rises and when the load subsequently increases there is a store of hot water to satisfy demand until the boiler output rises. Another possible approach is to size the biomass boiler to meet the building’s base heating load and use a small conventional boiler to meet peak demands. This approach is also appropriate for dealing with seasonal variations in heating demand. However, care needs to be taken with the design and specification of the control system, which will be required to manage two boilers with very different operating characteristics. Other considerations include types of biomass materials. Biomass boilers are available that are suitable for a wide range of woody fuel sources. Biomass should be selected for its local availability as well as for its combustion characteristics, as the environmental costs of transporting relatively bulky fuel over large distances will reduce the environmental benefits of biomass combustion. Alternative sources of supply are also very important.
An example of a 3D integrated biomass boiler and fuel delivery system.
A 400 kW district-heating biomass boiler.
A typical biomass boiler, installed in a UK primary school.
Cou
rtes
y of
Koh
lbac
h H
oldi
ng G
mbH
Heat Pumps
A guidance document for designers
by Reginald Brown
BG 7/2009
A BSRIA Guide www.bsria.co.uk
BG 7-2009 heat pumps cover2.qxd 21/10/2009 08:56 Page 1
HEAT PUMPS – A GUIDANCE DOCUMENT © BSRIA BG 7/2009
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
This publication has been written by BSRIA’s Reginald Brown with additional information provided by David Bleicher and Mike Smith, and has been designed and produced by Ruth Radburn. BSRIA would like to thank the following for their help and guidance in reviewing the document: Heat Pump Association Strategy Committee Steve Pardy, Zisman Bowyer & Partners
©BSRIA BG 7/2009 October 2009 ISBN 978 0 86022 686 4 Printed by ImageData Ltd
All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic or mechanical including photocopying, recording or otherwise without prior written permission of the publisher.
This publication has been printed on Nine Lives Silk recycled paper.
HEAT PUMPS – A GUIDANCE DOCUMENT © BSRIA BG 7/2009
CONTENTS
1 INTRODUCTION 1
2 HEAT PUMP FUNDAMENTALS 2 2.1 Heat pump technology and the economic carbon case 2 2.2 Refrigeration cycles and efficiency 3 2.3 Heat sources and sinks 4 2.4 Combined cycles 6 2.5 Integration of renewable energy 7
3 LEGISLATION 8 3.1 F-Gas Regulations 8 3.2 Handling of refrigerants 8 3.3 Pressure Systems Safety Regulations 9 3.4 Waste Electrical and Electronic Equipment Regulations 9 3.5 Building Regulations 9 3.6 Construction Design and Management Regulations 9
4 OUTLINE DESIGN 11 4.1 Sizing heat pump systems 11 4.2 Selection of heat source and sinks 14 4.3 Estimation of performance 15
5 DETAILED DESIGN OF HEATING AND COOLING SOURCE 16 5.1 Packaged units 16 5.2 Air source 17 5.3 Exhaust air source 20 5.4 Ground source 21 5.5 Ground water 28 5.6 Surface water 30
6 DETAILED DESIGN OF HEATING AND COOLING DISTRIBUTION 31 6.1 Principle 31 6.2 Air-to-air systems 31 6.3 Water (or brine) to air systems 36 6.4 Hydronic systems 36 6.5 Domestic hot water 40 6.6 Integration with conventional heat sources 42 6.7 Integration with renewable energy 44
7 SYSTEM CONTROLS 47
8 INSTALLATION 49 8.1 Delivery and positioning 49 8.2 Electrical installation 49 8.3 Internal pipework installation 50 8.4 Ground loops and boreholes 50
HEAT PUMPS – A GUIDANCE DOCUMENT © BSRIA BG 7/2009
CONTENTS
9 COMMISSIONING AND TESTING 54 9.1 Electrical aspects 54 9.2 Refrigeration circuit 54 9.3 Heat source 54 9.4 Heating and cooling distribution 54 9.5 Handover 55
REFERENCES 71
BIBLIOGRAPHY 70
APPENDIX A: HEAT PUMP THERMODYNAMICS 57
APPENDIX B: COMMISSIONING AND TESTING 64
APPENDIX C: F-GAS REGULATIONS 67
Table 1: Heat sources and typical design assumptions 5 Table 2: Heat sinks and typical design assumptions 5 Table 3: Heat pump design factors for water-based heat
distribution 11 Table 4: Practical selection issues for heat sources and sinks 14 Table 5: Maximum extraction rates for buried ground coils 21 Table 6: Recommended maximum length for different tube sizes 22 Table 7: Maximum extraction rates for close loop boreholes 23 Table 8: Absorption refrigeration 62 Table 9: Comparison of vapour compression refrigerants 65 Table 10: Absorption refrigerants 66 Table 11: Key dates for implementation of F-Gas requirements 68 Table 12: Common refrigerants subject to the F-Gas Regulations 68 Table 13: Obligations under the F-Gas Regulations 69 Table 14: Frequency of checks on heat pump systems required
by F-Gas Regulations 69
APPENDICES
TABLES
HEAT PUMPS – A GUIDANCE DOCUMENT © BSRIA BG 7/2009
FIGURES
Figure 1: Heat pump circuit 2 Figure 2: COP versus temperature lift 4 Figure 3: Gas engine heat pump 6 Figure 4: Example annual temperature profile corresponding
space heating load 12 Figure 5: Possibilities to reduce noise from free standing
external units 19 Figure 6: Buried ground coils 22 Figure 7: Proprietary manifold chamber 23 Figure 8: Preparation of an Energy Piles™ 24 Figure 9: Completed Energy Piles™ 25 Figure 10: Carbon dioxide heat-pipe 26 Figure 11: Schematic summary of air-to-air heat pumps 32 Figure 12: VRF with heat recovery 34 Figure 13: Use of a buffer vessel 38 Figure 14: Passive cooling from a ground loop 39 Figure 15: Tank-in-tank domestic hot water 40 Figure 16: Using a buffer vessel to pre-heat domestic hot water 41 Figure 17: Heat pump with a boiler 42 Figure 18: Solar contribution to ground source 45 Figure 19: Typical solar hot water integration 45 Figure 20: Typical small drilling rig used for heat pump boreholes 52 Figure 21: Components of a typical heat pump circuit 57 Figure 22: Heat pump cycle 58 Figure 23: Process efficiency and the pressure - enthalpy diagram 59 Figure 24: Temperature - entropy diagram 60 Figure 25: Vapour injection cycle 61 Figure 26: Reversible heat pump 62 Figure 27: Schematic of absorption chiller 63 Figure 28: Pressure enthalpy diagram for R134a 64
INTRODUCTION
HEAT PUMPS – A GUIDANCE DOCUMENT 1 © BSRIA BG 7/2009
1
1 INTRODUCTION
Heat pumps are increasingly being considered as an alternative to combustion-based heating plant as a means to reduce operating costs and carbon emissions. In some countries heat pumps have already taken a significant proportion of the market for heating appliances and this is likely to be a long-term trend throughout Europe. However, while it is true that space heating and hot water needs in housing and most other buildings can be fulfilled by heat pumps, it would be wrong to treat heat pumps simply as a drop-in replacement for conventional boilers. Heat pumps can replace boiler plant in existing houses, but this should not be done without a thorough review of the associated heat distribution system and rarely without system changes. Conversely, a hydronic heat distribution system, optimised for a heat pump should also work well with a condensing boiler. This guide explains the design of heat-pump based heating and cooling systems to maximise the benefits of reduced operating costs and carbon emissions while avoiding excessive capital costs for plant and infrastructure. The guide’s emphasis is on the application of packaged heat pump plant for residential and small commercial buildings. Some guidance is provided for component-based plant that may be used for larger scale applications. The information contained in this guide is drawn from a variety of sources including:
• Heat Pump Installer Manual. BSRIA
• Heating Systems in Buildings – Design of Heat Pump Heating Systems. BS EN 15450:2007
• Ground Source Heat Pumps, BSRIA TN 18/99, 1999
• Guide to Good Practice - Heat Pumps, HVCA TR30 2007 Other published material is identified in the text, and a full list of bibliographies and references can be found on pages 70 – 71.
INTRODUCTION 1
HEAT PUMP FUNDAMENTALS
2 HEAT PUMPS – A GUIDANCE DOCUMENT © BSRIA BG 7/2009
2
2 HEAT PUMP FUNDAMENTALS
2.1 HEAT PUMP TECHNOLOGY AND THE ECONOMIC CARBON CASE
A heat pump is a device for transferring heat from a lower temperature heat source to a higher temperature heat sink. This is opposite to the natural flow of heat from a hot source to a cold sink, but is made possible by the application of an external energy source to drive a thermodynamic refrigeration cycle. The important characteristic of a heat pump is that the amount of heat that can be transferred is greater than the energy needed to drive the cycle.
Figure 1: Heat pump circuit.
The ratio between the heat provided to the sink and the energy required is known as the coefficient of performance (COP). Electrically driven heat pumps used for space heating applications in moderate climates usually have a COP of a least 3·5 at design conditions. This means that 3·5 kWh of heat is output for 1 kWh electricity used to drive the process. The COP is the determinant of whether the heat pump will be more economic to use than an alternative heating appliance and whether the carbon emissions with will less than an alternative heating appliance.
2 HEAT PUMP FUNDAMENTALS
HEAT PUMP FUNDAMENTALS
HEAT PUMPS – A GUIDANCE DOCUMENT 3 © BSRIA BG 7/2009
2
For example, consider a space heating load of 100 kWh per week that can be served by a typical electric heat pump operating at an average COP of 3·5 or condensing gas boiler operating with a thermal efficiency of 100 percent (net calorific value basis):
Heat pump energy consumption = Load/COP = 100/3·5 = 28·6 kWh Boiler energy consumption = Load/Efficiency = 100/100%
= 100 kWh In simple terms, such a heat pump will be cheaper to operate provided that the electricity price is no more than 3·5 times the price of an alternative fuel. There are other factors that come into a more detailed analysis of the benefits, such as maintenance costs and equipment life, but the fuel price ratio is the key. This is also the main reason why the heat pump markets in some other countries have developed much more quickly than the UK where, historically, electricity has been more than 3·5 times the cost of natural gas. However, the long-term trend is for gas prices to increase faster than electricity prices, while heat pump COP gradually improves to provide a clear operating cost advantage for heat pumps. Heat pumps are already cheaper to operate than oil and LPG, and much cheaper to operate than direct electric heating. While the operating costs for heat pumps and condensing boilers are rather similar at current fuel prices, the case for heat pumps as a low carbon technology is more conclusive. In 2009, the current UK generator mix emitted carbon dioxide (CO2) at a rate of approximately 0·43 kgCO2/kWh of electricity used (DEFRA 2007 data for greenhouse gas emissions reporting ). The corresponding figure for natural gas is 0·194 CO2/kWh. Using the example given above for an electric heat pump with a COP of 3·5 and a condensing boiler operating with an efficiency of 100 percent (net calorific value basis), the carbon dioxide emissions are:
Heat pump CO2 emissions = 28·6 x 0·43 = 12·3 kg CO2 Boiler CO2 emissions = 100 x 0·194 = 19·4 kg CO2
The heat pump therefore emits 35 percent less CO2 than the condensing boiler.
2.2 REFRIGERATION CYCLES AND EFFICIENCY
Although a detailed knowledge of thermodynamics is not required for the practical application of heat pumps, a basic understanding of the factors that influence efficiency is important for all heating systems designers, whether using packaged plant or component-based solutions. A brief review of the thermodynamic refrigeration cycle is given in Appendix A – Page 57 and the properties of common refrigerants in Appendix B – Page 64.