Transcript of Supporting Healthy Eating and Growth What can we do for kids? Ellyn Satter, MS, RD, MSSW.
- Slide 1
- Supporting Healthy Eating and Growth What can we do for kids?
Ellyn Satter, MS, RD, MSSW
- Slide 2
- Raise a capable eater Follow the division of responsibility in
feeding Ellyn Satters Feeding with Love and Good Sense II DVD
Parent: What, when, where of feeding Child: How much, whether of
eating
- Slide 3
- Slide 4
- Slide 5
- Haley 10 years Parents: Gained a huge amount of weightshot off
the scale. Sneaks food, eats from lunch counter even after she has
finished her bag lunch from home Parents deny food restriction W/A
2 - 10 yr
- Slide 6
- W/A 1 wk 33 mo Haley W/A history
- Slide 7
- Decipher the story told by the growth chart
- Slide 8
- 10 months 12 months 16 months Haley W/A 10 months: MD says
weighs too much 12 months: MD says tendency toward obesity 15
months: Error? 16 months: Mom says voracious appetite. 19 months:
Moved. New MD doesnt question weight 19 months 15 months
- Slide 9
- 1 -6.5 years. New MD doesnt question weight 3-6.5 yr: Mother in
school; father casually feeding 6.5 yr: Moved. Haley sad; mother
rigidly feeding 8.5 yr: MD dont diet but eat F&V, low fat 10.25
yr: RDFood Guide Pyramid; smart snack choices 3-years 6.5 years 8.5
years 10.25 years Haley W/A
- Slide 10
- Why do children gain too much weight? a)Misinterpretation of
normal growth: A growth agenda
- Slide 11
- 10 months 12 months 16 months Haley W/A 10 months: MD says
weighs too much 12 months: MD says tendency toward obesity 19
months 15 months
- Slide 12
- Normal growth can be consistently at the mean 50 th %tile w/a
Weight for Length Weight for age 0-36 months
- Slide 13
- Low consistent W/A High consistent W/A Normal growth can be at
the extremes
- Slide 14
- BELL CURVE From Your Childs Weight: Helping Without
Harming
- Slide 15
- Abrupt, rapid divergence likely to be problematic
- Slide 16
- Why do children gain too much weight? a)Misinterpretation of
normal growth b)Restrained feeding and circumstances that mimic
restrained feeding
- Slide 17
- 10 months 12 months 16 months Haley W/A 10 months: MD says
weighs too much 12 months: MD says tendency toward obesity 15
months: Error? 16 months: Mom says voracious appetite. 19 months 15
months
- Slide 18
- FOOD RESTRICTION BACKFIRES Children become afraid of going
hungry and overeat when they get the chance Getting children to eat
certain foods Getting children to eat more or less Depriving
children of certain foods Not letting children eat as much as they
are hungry for
- Slide 19
- WHAT DOES THIS HAVE TO DO WITH CHILD OBESITY? Hunger Appetite
Satiety Children who get the message they are too fat feel flawed
in every waynot smart, not physically capable, and not worthy.
Davison & Birch Pediatrics 2001 Girls 5 yr say they try to eat
only a little bit on purpose so they dont get fat. They tend to
overeat, and gain more weight than girls who do not restrict. Shunk
& Birch JADA 2004: 1120.
- Slide 20
- AUTHORITARIAN PARENTING: Restricting amounts undermines food
regulation ELLYN SATTERS FEEDING WITH LOVE AND GOOD SENSE: Video
and Teachers Guide The Older Baby
- Slide 21
- Slide 22
- Children whose food intake is restricted become
food-preoccupied and are prone to overeat when the get the chance
Secrets of Feeding a Healthy Family, Appendix I, Children and food
regulation: the research Ellyn Satters Feeding with Love and Good
Sense II DVD
- Slide 23
- Slide 24
- Why do children gain too much weight? a)Misinterpretation of
normal growth b)Restrained feeding c)Poor feeding practices
- Slide 25
- 10 months 12 months 16 months Haley W/A 19 months: Moved. New
MD doesnt question weight 19 months 15 months
- Slide 26
- 1 -6.5 years. New MD doesnt question weight 3-6.5 yr: Mother in
school; father casually feeding 3-years 6.5 years 8.5 years 10.25
years Haley W/A
- Slide 27
- POOR FEEDING PRACTICES Too little support Interference
- Slide 28
- Children who are coerced to eat certain foods get turned off to
them and avoid them when they can Secrets of Feeding a Healthy
Family, Appendix J, Children and food acceptance: the research
Ellyn Satters Feeding with Love and Good Sense II DVD
- Slide 29
- Slide 30
- FEEDING PRESSURE BACKFIRES Forcing, bribing, coercing, nudging,
applauding, rewarding, explaining, teaching, restricting Getting
children to eat certain foods Getting children to eat more or less
Getting children to avoid certain foods
- Slide 31
- FEEDING PRESSURE BACKFIRES Forcing, bribing, coercing, nudging,
applauding, rewarding, explaining, teaching, restricting Getting
children eat certain foods Getting children to eat more or less
Getting children to avoid certain foods 90% of parents pressure
children to eat Sherry JADA 2004:215 50% of children have feeding
problems Linscheid, Handbook of Pediatric Psycholgoy, 2003:
481
- Slide 32
- FOOD REGULATION HINGES ON THE FAMILY MEAL (AND STRUCTURED
SNACKS) Meals give a context for parental support without coercion
Allows going to table hungry but not famished, eating until
satisfied Keeps food from being a constant issue between times
Toddlers are too busy to eat on demand
- Slide 33
- Why do children gain too much weight? a)Misinterpretation of
normal growth b)Restrained feeding and circumstances that mimic
restrained feeding c)Poor feeding practices d)Stress
- Slide 34
- 3-6.5 yr: Mother in school; father casually feeding 6.5 yr:
Moved. Mother begins rigidly feeding 8.5 yr: MD dont diet but eat
F&V, low fat 10.25 yr: RDFood Guide Pyramid; smart snack
choices 3-years 6.5 years 8.5 years 10.25 years Haley W/A
- Slide 35
- 7 yr: Moved. Haley sad; mother feeding 8 yr: MD dont diet but
eat F&V, low fat 9 yr: RD dont diet but follow Food Guide
Pyramid 3-7 years 7 years 9 years 8 years
- Slide 36
- MOTHER IS RESOLUTE IN ATTEMPTS TO CONTROL HALEYS EATING Drab,
low-fat food that Haley detested One pork chop each, ran out of
rice Use your fork (over and over) The seeds are for the salad
(repeatedly) Get your elbows off the table Eat something else
before you take seconds on bread Remember she showed us a portion
size (broccoli) Hand on wrist and smile (Sadie eating too fast)
Handing her the napkin Use your napkin
- Slide 37
- HALEY IS EQUALLY RESOLUTE IN HER AVOIDANCE OF CONTROL Puts down
her fork to pick up the pieces of salad Takes the tiniest amount of
salad possible then puts the seeds in her palm Looks disgusted at
lentil soup Hunches over with her whole forearm on the table Eats
her bread when she wants to Goes back to eating fast Leaves her
napkin on the table
- Slide 38
- Stress undermines food regulation Ellyn Satters Feeding with
Love and Good Sense II DVD
- Slide 39
- Slide 40
- Stress and energy dysregulation How it works Children who are
poorly fed (e.g., restricted, forced to eat, not given structure)
do not get their emotional needs met Childrens unmet food and
emotional needs teach children to conflate eating with emotional
arousal Based on such learning, children respond to life stress by
eating too much or too little
- Slide 41
- Causes of Haleys weight acceleration Misinterpretation of
normal growth: High infant weight branded obesity Restrained
feeding: Food restriction initiated age 10 months Poor feeding
practices: Struggles around feeding exacerbated age 12 months. Lack
of structure ages 3-7. Restraint ages 7 plus. Stress: Taught to use
food for emotional reasons. Inconsistent parenting: Mother rigid
& controlling, father neglectful. Parental conflict routed
through Haley.
- Slide 42
- CHILDHOOD FEEDING DISORDER Distorted eating/feeding
attitudes/behavior Failure to regulate growth Profound finickiness
Vehement struggles about eating Unconcern about serious problems
Overconcern about minor problems Emotional/social problems
- Slide 43
- fdSatter and child overweight Your Childs Weight: Helping
without Harming, Kelcy Press Satter E. The Satter Feeding Dynamics
Model of child overweight definition, prevention and intervention.
In: O'Donahue W, Moore BA, Scott B, eds. Pediatric and Adolescent
Obesity Treatment: A Comprehensive Handbook. New York: Taylor and
Francis; 2007:287-314. Satter EM. Internal regulation and the
evolution of normal growth as the basis for prevention of obesity
in childhood. J Am Diet Assoc. 1996;96:860-864.
- Slide 44
- TRIANGULATED CHILD: PARENTS ROUTE CONFLICT THROUGH CHILD
- Slide 45
- TREATMENT: BLOCK TRIANGULATION, IMPROVE PARENT
RELATIONSHIP
- Slide 46
- TREATMENT OF FEEDING DISORDERS Eating management Psychotherapy
or case management with the whole family Psychotherapy does not
resolve eating problems
- Slide 47
- HALEY - TREATMENT PLAN Parents Jobs Get family therapy to deal
with control issues Initiate eating management after family therapy
has begun Establish and maintain division of responsibility
Identify and D/C restraint tactics Plan good-tasting enjoyable
menus Provide appealing sit-down snacks at set times Expect and
enforce positive mealtime behavior
- Slide 48
- HALEY - TREATMENT PLAN Haleys Jobs Go to the table hungry and
eat until satisfied Pay attention while you eat Ask parents to
include forbidden foods at meals and snacks Sneak up on new food
and learn to like it Let parents know when they slip up, but be
patient
- Slide 49
- Slide 50
- Haley: Once more with sDOR Satter E. Prevention and Treatment
of Child Overweight and Obesity. 2015
- Slide 51
- To prevent child overweight and obesity, support parents in
following sDOR from birth. To treat child overweight and obesity,
restore sDOR and trust the childs own homeostasis to restore
appropriate growth.
- Slide 52
- Satter feeding dynamics model: fdSatter Parents feed based on
the division of responsibility Children remain/become eating
competent Children grow in the way that is right for them. Satter
The feeding relationship, JADA 1986 Satter. Internal regulation
& child overweight. JADA 1996 Satter. Childhood eating
disorders. JADA 1996 Satter. Moderate view on fat restriction. JADA
2000 Satter. fdSatter and child overweight IN ODonahue, Pediatric
and Adolescent Obesity Treatment. 2007 Danaher, Intervention.
Childhood Obesity. 2011
- Slide 53
- Parents have to be good eaters to do good feeding Further
reading and references Secrets of Feeding a Healthy Family Part 1,
How to eat Part 2, How to raise good eaters Appendix I, Children
and food regulation: the research Appendix J, Children and food
acceptance: the research
- Slide 54
- Satter Division of Responsibility in Feeding (sDOR) Infant
Parent: What Child: How much
- Slide 55
- Transitional child Parent/feeding Still and always responsible
for what Becoming responsible for when and where Child/eating How
much Whether Satter Division of Responsibility in Feeding
(sDOR)
- Slide 56
- Toddler through adolescent Parent: What, when, where of feeding
Child: How much, whether of eating Satter Division of
Responsibility in Feeding (sDOR)
- Slide 57
- sDOR Parents take leadership with feeding Choose and prepare
healthy food Have regular meals and snacks Make eating time
pleasant Provide mastery expectations Accept and support childrens
growth
- Slide 58
- sDOR Parents give children autonomy, support childrens natural
ability with eating Children will eat They know how much to eat
They will eat a variety They will grow predictably They will mature
with eating
- Slide 59
- Slide 60
- 10 months 12 months 16 months Haley W/A 10 months: MD says
weighs too much 12 months: MD says tendency toward obesity 19
months 15 months
- Slide 61
- Slide 62
- The tendency is to slimming Serdula - Children slim down
Infants >75% Preschoolers 59-74% School-age children 37-58%
Whitlock At age 13 years, children >95th %tile W/H have a 50%
probability of adult obesity (BMI >30) Serdula Preventive
Medicine 1993 Whitlock Pediatrics 2005
- Slide 63
- 10 months 12 months 16 months Haley W/A 16 months: Mom says
voracious appetite. 19 months 15 months
- Slide 64
- Slide 65
- 10 months 12 months 16 months Haley W/A 19 months: Moved. New
MD doesnt question weight 19 months 15 months
- Slide 66
- Slide 67
- 1 -6.5 years. New MD doesnt question weight 3-6.5 yr: Mother in
school; father casually feeding 3-years 6.5 years 8.5 years 10.25
years Haley W/A
- Slide 68
- Slide 69
- 3-6.5 yr: Mother in school; father casually feeding 6.5 yr:
Moved. Mother begins rigidly feeding 3-years 6.5 years 8.5 years
10.25 years Haley W/A
- Slide 70
- 8 yr: MD dont diet but eat F&V, low fat 9 yr: RD dont diet
but follow Food Guide Pyramid 3-7 years 7 years 9 years 8
years
- Slide 71
- Structure is the bottom line In adult EC In child nutrition and
feeding In child overweight prevention and treatment.
- Slide 72
- Slide 73
- To be a competent feeder, the parent has to be a competent
eater.
- Slide 74
- Satter Eating Competence Model (ecSatter): Inclusive definition
of eating attitudes and behaviors 1.Positive attitudes about eating
and about food 2.Food acceptance skills that support eating an
ever- increasing variety of the available food 3.Internal
regulation skills that guide consuming enough food to give energy
and stamina and to support stable body weight 4.Skills and
resources for managing the food context and orchestrating family
meals Satter, E. M. (2007). J Nutr Educ Behav, 39 (suppl),
S142-S153.
- Slide 75
- ecSatter tested using the validated ecSatter Inventory ecSI
2.0ecSI 2.0 Lohse, J Nutr Ed Behav 2007
- Slide 76
- The evidence: ecSatter associated with... Superior dietary
quality Greater physical activity Better weight status More
positive parent food behaviors Decreased preschooler nutrition risk
Fewer cardiovascular risk factors Good food management skills
Higher sleep quality
- Slide 77
- The point of the fdSatter and ecSatter research? You can
achieve nutrition and wellness goals by focusing on sDOR and Eating
Competence.
- Slide 78
- For more... Satter E. The Satter Eating Competence Model for
the autodidact 2015
- Slide 79
- For more information
- Slide 80
- Join Us www.ellynsatterinstitute.org ESI mailing list