Post on 14-Aug-2021
SCIENCE FICTION AND SUSTAINABILITY
PUBLIC LECTURE ON PLANET TALKS
IMPRI
17/11/2020
1#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
What makes a good Science / Dystopian Fiction work?
• Dystopia (antonym of Utopia) – unfair, injustice, postapocalyptic
– Themes – Religion, Psychology, Culture, Economy, Society, Environment, Ethics, Technology but going beyond this and the uncharted territories in these themes
– Create something which is not plausible at all
– Create a thesis and an antithesis – the more the dialectics the larger is the dystopian element
2#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
The Process
• Respond to an injustice, a situation and then personalise it
• Then take it to a set of all plausible outcomes
• Create outcomes and counteroutcomes
• Create Plots and Counter Plots
• I think of a situation and express it into my music and then play notes and counter notes and then I can see characters and plots for a certain situation and then I create a world through melodies and counter melodies, rhythm and counter rythms
3#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
How important is research and study to deliver a believable and convincing work of fiction ?
• Extremely important• It is a must• Instances of a book – Dystopia: Natural History (2017) – Cleares• We (1921)• Animal Farm, 1984 (black market to produce select materialistic
goods, domination of the state on individuals)• Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World
– Role of parents are forgotten, Children are born automatically– Society and class structures are reconstructed– Fondly Fahrenheit – people going to rural society for consumption
• Joanna Russ (Female Man), 1919 (Sultana’s Dream) - RokeyaSakhawat Hossain– Both are about how an imaginary society is happening centering about
power shifts to women from men and different gender types
4#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
Science / Dystopian fiction novels can challenge readers to think differently about current social and
political climates, and can inspire action.
• Yes• It is like a parabola which opens up possibilities and helps
us to see future with different possibilities• Even if you don’t add the post apocalyptic element to
dystopia, anything which is not fair or injustice can also motivate us to think of a dystopia and create an action towards the utopia
• So dystopia creates an action towards utopia• When utopia is not attained, a state of dystopia can again
arise for further utopia• So utopia is justice and dystopia is somewhat the law
(which needs to be practised to attain the dream of justice)
5#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
• ‘’Sustain’’ and ‘’Ability’’
• Sustain to be Able or Ability to Sustain?
• Is there a difference between ‘Children’ and ‘Adult’ Science Fiction, from a sustainability standpoint?
What is Sustainability?
6#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
Why Children Science Fiction and Sustainability?
• Because it is – “A pot of green and a pot of orange paint spilled on the floor and forms a murky brown together which does not belong to any pot but who cant distinguish that is also a fool” – (McDowell 58, Nodelman, Hidden Adult 188)..
• Because as Roger Sale wryly says – “Everyone knows what children science fiction literature is until one is asked to define it”!!
• Trust it or not, Sustainability is exactly having these two above characteristics!!!!
7#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
So why the idea of merging children science fiction and sustainability emerged?
1. Can depict a schematic moral view of life (Mcdowell, Nodelman)
2. Active (full of action) and ruminant (full of introspection, reflection and liberation) at the same time
3. Simple, formulaic as well as abstract, open ended at the same time
4. A dialectics between a small and large vision within the storytelling
8#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
To do that – What was essential is to understand the history
And hence the historical exploration started …
9#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
• Lessons from Old Testament – the ship of Noah - A pair of animals to secure a sustainable lifecycle
• Lessons from Mahabharata – Khandava Dahan?
• Lessons from Indian scriptures like the Vedas, Upanishads, Ramayana, Bhagavad Gita, Manusmriti, Arthashastra – Sustainability is about - human beings, make people capable of joint performance, to
make their strengths effective and their weaknesses irrelevant by imbibing culture, common goals, shared values, commitment, communication
Sustainability in Mythology and Early Scripture Context?
10#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
• Jagadananda Roy's Shukra Bhraman (Travels to Venus)
• Hemlal Dutta as one of the earliest Bengali science fiction writers for his Rohosso (The Mystery)
• 1882 in the pictorial magazine Bigyan Dorpon (Mirror of Science)
• Jagadish Chandra Bose - Kuntol Keshori, Palatak Tufan (Runaway Cyclone)
• Roquia Sakhawat Hussain (Begum Rokeya), an early Islamic feminist, wrote Sultana's Dream –a world where role reversal happens between men and women
• Premendra Mitra wrote the first novel, Kuhoker Deshe (In the Land of Mystery). HemendraKumar Ray wrote Meghduter Morte Agomon
• Qazi Abdul Halim's Mohasunner Kanna (Tears of the Cosmos), Tomader Jonno Valobasa (Love For You All),
• In 1997, Moulik, the first and longest-running Bangladeshi science fiction magazine, was first published, with famous cartoonist Ahsan Habib as the editor
• Nasim Sahnic is a promising young science fiction writer in Bangladesh. His latest science fiction books like Genetic code, Robopsychologist, Sundarbone Truti, Coxsbazarer Cossop are very famous to young generation
• OTHER THAN THIS – Tagore, Narayan Sanyal, Adrish Bardhan, Bibhutibhushan, SukumarRay, Leela Majumdar, Shirshendu Mukhopadhyay, Syed Mustafa Siraj, Samarjit Kar, AnishDeb, Biswajit Ganguly, Siddhartha Ghosh, Suman Sen (Sarpa Manav: NagmoniRohosyo, Ajana Sima: The X Boundary),[4] Rajesh Basu and Abhijnan Roychowdhury SatyajitRay are well know mainstream writers who are popular and everyone reads them
My Journey began with my vernacular which is absolutely essential and critical for everyone to
understand sustainability
11#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
Science Fiction Magazine in Bengali (happened in 2016)
• Publication of Kalpabiswa (কল্পবিশ্ব)
(www.kalpabiswa.com), first ever Science Fiction and Fantasy themed Bengali web-magazine for adult readers
• Once the vernacular is known – 1%, let me explore to the world literature which I did to understand sustainability
12#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
Historical Narrative
Name Year Author Genre Content
Utopia 1516 Thomas More Scientific Voyages Imaginary voyage to an
unknown land
Somnium 1632 Johannes Kepler Lunar voyage How earth’s motion looks
from moon
Gullivers
Travels
1726 Jonathan Swift Voyage to an imaginary
land
Fiction on gulliver’s
experiences in a Lilliput land
Frankenstein 1818 Mary Shelley Limits of scientific
understanding and
humanity’s
relationship to created
beings
Innovation in the realm of
science rather than
supernatural
Critique of
science fiction
After 1818 Paul Alkon Defined as narrative
use of science to
create myths to bring
in novel view points
Science to create myths
allowing novel points of view
Amazing
stories
1926 Hugo Gernsback Scientifiction to
Science fiction
Codified an already existing
literary form which included
fantastic voyages, utopia,
disaster fictions, invention
tales, scientific romances 13#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
Historical NarrativeName Year Author Genre Content
Future Shock 1970 Alvin Toffler Contemporary western cultures
grappling with rapidity of
technological and social change
Technological and social change
acting as a centre point of
change
Pulp Magazines 1940 John W Campbell Focusing on pulp science fiction Science fiction culture
Le Zombie 1941 Bob Tucker Relationship between
enthusiastic group of fans and
emergence of science fiction in
magazines
Practicing science fiction
Brave New
World
1932 Aldous Huxley Science fiction practice of generic
attribution
Sites of both high and low
culture
The Time
Machine
1895 Jules Verne Polarization of humans into two
bleak species
Vision of an alien and an
alienating planet
Some fiction
works
Over a long
range of
time
H.G. Wells Focuses on philosophical and
social implications of scientific
discoveries
Understanding of ethical choices
and perceptions of material
world changes over time
M.S Found in a
Bottle
1833 Edgar Allen Poe Range of engagements with the
sublime nature
Transmutation into the
comforting sense of wonder
The Sentinel 1951 Arthur C Clarke Human confrontation with a
manufactured than a natural
object
Evolutionary time scale of a
technology 14
#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI SAS 2020
Historical NarrativeName Year Author Genre Content
Argosy 1882 –
1978
Story
Magazine
Sensationalist novels Science fiction with a special magazine
culture
The Strand 1891 –
1950
Story
Magazine
Mixture of story types Transformed market place with different
story mixes
The War of
Worlds
1898 H.G. Wells Alien invasion Centred around anthropocentrism
The New
Atlantis
1624 Francis
Bacon
Scientific discoveries
demonstrate our lack of
empire over matter
A world powerful than ours
The War of
the worlds
1898 (first
hardcover
) and
serialised
first in
1897
H G Wells Challenges the way of
understanding the world.
The superior imperialist
British race is outweighed
by Martian technology
Martians are doing the same thing as done
by British in their colonies. Comparisons are
drawn with extinction of bison and dodo by
human activities, extinction of Tasmanians
by European immigrants. Questions the
anthropocentric view of religion,
Christianity which poses humanity above
nature, whereas science has no special
interest in homo sapiens. Gives us a more
heterogenic view of the world making
humans conscious of future given life exists
in Mars.
Ralph
124C41+
1911 –
1912
Gernsback Adventure story of Ralph
saving his girl in an
adventurous journey
Ralph moves from one future technology to
the other viz. television, video phone, solar
energy, synthetic food, spaceflight
15#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
Historical NarrativeName Year Author Genre Content
Martian
Odyssey
1934 Stanley G.
Weinbaum
How to communicate with
aliens
Questions the paradigm of human and alien
friendship in an alien landscape of Mars by
questioning whether reason or technology
should decide such friendship
A Door Into
Ocean
1986 Joan
Slonczweski
Understanding off
planetary life
Rational differentiation between
ecofeminist and technorationalist approach
to understand planetary life
Astounding
Stories to
Astounding
Science Fiction
1937 John W.
Campbell
Bringing in technology for
explaining nuances of
social life
Technocratic rationalism to replace
emotions to explain the social world
Who goes there 1938 John W.
Campbell
Explores the value of
science fiction conceived as
a rationalist worldview
Discovery of a long buried spaceship in
Antartica and the crisis amongst men
stationed in the research camp where alien
body is discovered. The conflict between
nature and human science is explained
when the alien starts taking the form of any
life with which it has contact
That only a
mother
1948 Judith Merril Intersections of public
science and domestic life
A mother writing a letter to her husband
posted in a secret station related to nuclear
warfare about possibilities of mutation in
her baby16
#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI SAS 2020
More Narratives for the Birth of Lucy
• Liar (1941) - Isaac Asimov - Misunderstandings launched by a mind reading robot - deception by robot and misunderstandings between human race
• Runaround (1942) - Isaac Asimov - The law of robotics - A robot should not harm a human being or through inaction will not allow the human being to harm the robot. A robot will follow the orders of a human being unless and until there is a defiance of the first law.
• Reason (1942) - Isaac Asimov - The conflict between reason and logic. In a space station, the scientists try to convince a robot that he has been created by the humans and the robot disagrees to acknowledge that fact.
• Forbidden Planet (1956) - Wilcox - The robot refuses to attack a monster as a human being is behind the monster attack and this follows the discourse of robotic law of Asimov
• The Female Man (1966) - Joanna Russ - DNA derived artificial lover who scares another woman
17#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
More Narratives for the Birth of Lucy
• Culture Novels (1987 - 2012) - Ian.M. Banks - AI Mind Citizens in human relationships
• We Who Are About To (1976) - Joanna Russ - Talks of a civilization where women are reduced to the role of breeders
• Fondly Fahrenheit (1954) - Alfred Bester - It comments on what science fiction has overlooked due to its attachment to rational explanation. The story is about the master slave relationship where the master creates an android and the android starts to trouble and the master has to change his identities again and again due to that. Finally, a point comes where the master decides to sell the android when the android makes the claim that he cant be sold following the law of Robotics. Projection of the master's mind onto the slave - it is not clear. Is the android a subconscious depiction of the psychology of the master.
• Childhood's End (1953) - Arthur C. Clarke - Alien Overlords come to the earth and owing to their superior technology they become Gods to humans and establish a peaceful, equal society on earth. The overlords create a new set of telepathic, human species who work for a better future. So the human civilization's doubts of colonization here progresses towards a betterment. 18
#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI SAS 2020
More Narratives for the Birth of Lucy
• The Liberation of Earth (1953) - William Tenns - also highlights about alien invasion - Two alien invasion - one trying for betterment and the other not for betterment and human race caught in between two superpowers of space - just like USSR and US.
• The Day Earth Stood Still (1951) - Wise - Is about a nuclear warfare race and its impact on environment
• Aleutian Trilogy, White Queen (1991), North Wind (1994), Phoenix Cafe (1997) - Gwyeneth Jones - are all about the complex exploration of cultural difference and misunderstandings arising from not able to accommodate the cultural differences. Not able to understand the aliens immortality, telepathic aspects.
• When we went to see the end of the world (1972) - Robert Silverberg -Highlights the conspicuous consumption nature of middle class and their constant race to go high up in the ladder of the society in comparison to others by getting a better vacation package to conduct a time travel vacation towards seeing the end of the world without actually worrying about the end of the world
19#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
• Journey within a train (like a nemesis in compartments), and
• In a ship (like a Sindbad)
The journey of Lucy in the Context : After this journey of mine – I needed a catharsis and hence Lucy
happened
20#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
A moment that pushed you for the Science / Dystopian Fiction genre?
• I started following this genre from the age of 12• I was travelling in a local train which was jampacked from
Jadavpur to Ballygunge and it was so fully packed, I was constantly pulled apart from all sides in the two stop journey and I felt can there be a transportation medium in which everyday I can travel from home to school on air with airpumped shoes – I looked for options – I started reading Flash Gordon after being attracted through a visual
• I saw something unfair around me and I felt if I can change the world for a betterment and then I started thinking how would that world will look like and hence I started reading about the world where I can see about these possibilities and hence I started to move towards the genre
21#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
Feeling , Sustainability and Science Fiction?
• Practice feeling and responding to any unfair and injustice happening around you
• Then practice how would you like to change it and what are the possibilities of changing it
• Practice it and then in that possibility create a plot
• To implement the plot create characters through whom you change it and then create the possibilities you want to see
• The more dialectical the possibilities are, the better is the dystopian fiction
22#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
And hence LUCY (Love, Understanding, Creation and Youth) and her tryst with Sustainability was born
Within a train (like a nemesis in compartments) moving through challenges
in order to be able to sustain
In a ship (like a Sindbad) –towards future unknowns with an unknown vigilance of Artificial Intelligence
Sketch Potrait Created First in Diary and then projected through coral draw
Sketch Potrait Created First in Diary and then projected through coral draw
23#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020
THANK YOU
Email:anandajit.fbss@mriu.edu.in,
anandajit.teri@gmail.comgoswami.anandajit@gmail.com
24#PlanetTalks IMPRI India Water Portal TERI
SAS 2020