PiXLGateway:Progression- Politics

ForStudentsStudyingEdexcelALevel

1

ContentsIntroduction...........................................................................................................................................2

“Aweekisalongtimeinpolitics”..........................................................................................................3

Synopticthinking....................................................................................................................................5

10keyfactstolearnforthestartofthecourse.....................................................................................8

©ThePiXLClubLtd.June2018...........................................................................................................12

2

IntroductionWelcometoALevelstudy!Youwillquicklylearnthatpowerisattheheartofpolitics.Itdetermineswhogetswhat,when,andhow.Politicsisthestruggleoverscarceresourcesandthemeansthroughwhichthestruggleisconducted.

1 2Debateanddisagreementlieattheheartofthissubject–evenwhencompetingpoliticiansseemtobesayingthesamething,Itisasubjectofrivalviewsandonewithoutanyabsoluteanswers,soyouneedtotakeonthechallengeofconsideringdifferentviewpoints,perspectives,andopinions–andtothinkforyourself–sothatyoucanformulatepowerfulargumentsandexpressthemconvincingly.Moreover,youwillstudypoliticsnotasaneutralobserverbutasanactiveparticipant,developingyourpersonalopinionsasyouacquireastrongunderstandingofthefactorsshapingboththeBritishandAmericansystemsofgovernmentandpolitics.Youwillalsogaininsightintosomeofthegreatpoliticalideasthathaveshapedtheworldwelivein.ThisbookletisdesignedtohelpyoutostartthinkingasanALevelPoliticsstudentandincludestaskswhichwillsupportyouthroughoutyourstudies,includingassistingyouinpreparingforyourfinalexams.

1http://bentelevision.com/prime-minister-theresa-may-speech-britain-after-brexit-2016-a-vision-of-a-global-britain/http://lybio.net/jeremy-corbyn-queens-speech-2017/people/2http://lybio.net/jeremy-corbyn-queens-speech-2017/people/

3

“Aweekisalongtimeinpolitics”

3Uniquely,Politicsisalivingsubjectsoyouwillseemuchofwhatyouarestudyinghappeninginthe‘realworld’.Itcanalsobeaveryfastmovingone,asWilson’sfamousquoteaboveindicates.Thismeansthatanytextbookis,tosomedegree,outofdatebythetimeitispublished.Thismaysounddaunting,especiallywhenthisispartofyourintroductiontothesubject,butitalsoprovidesyouwithagreatopportunity.Itispreciselybecausenobookcangiveyouthemostup-to-dateexamplesthatusingrecent/currentexampleseffectivelywillbehighlyrewardedbyexaminers.Consequently,youshouldbekeepinganeyeonAmericangovernmentandpoliticsduringYear1,whenyouarestudyingtheUK,andcontinuetofollowwhatishappeningintheUKduringYear2,whenthefocusofthecourseisontheUSA.Followingpoliticsinthemediashould,therefore,bearegularpartofyourindependentstudythroughoutthecourse.First,however,youneedtobeorganised.Onefilepercomponentisrecommended.Buyoruse‘homemade’dividersandlabelthemasfollows.Youwillthenbeabletofileyourexamplesintheappropriatesection.(Beawarethatsomeexampleswillberelevanttotwoormoretopics–moreonthislater.)Makeastartonthisnow,establishingagoodhabittocontinuethroughoutthecourse,sothatbytheendofthesummeryouwillhavefiledfiveexamplesplusyourreflectionsoneachone.Theexpectationisthatyouwillhavefiveexamplesintotali.e.itdoesnotmatterwhichtopicstheyrelateto.ThesummerisusuallyaquiettimeinthepoliticalworldbutBrexitissettoensurethatthisisnotthecasethissummer.Component1UKPoliticso Democracyandparticipationo Politicalpartieso Electoralsystemso Votingbehaviourandthemedia(Youwillalsostudythefollowingpoliticalideas:liberalism,conservatism,andsocialism)

3http://www.quotecounterquote.com/2016/04/a-week-is-long-time-in-politics.html

4

Component2UKGovernmento Theconstitutiono Parliamento PrimeMinisterandexecutiveo Relationshipsbetweenthebranches(Youwillalsostudyoneofthefollowingpoliticalideas:anarchism,ecologism,feminism,multiculturalism,nationalism)Component3ComparativePolitics-USAo TheUSConstitutionandfederalismo USCongresso USpresidencyo USSupremeCourtandcivilrightso Democracyandparticipationo Comparativetheories

Themosthighlyrecommendedresourceofall(becauseitsucceedssowellinprovidingintelligentanalysiswhichisaccessiblywrittenwithoutbeingatalldumbeddown)ishttps://www.bbc.co.uk/news/politics

Trytheotherreading/listening/watchingrecommendationsbelow,withtheintentionofcontinuingwithwhatyoufindusefulandenjoyable.Fewsubjectscanoffersuchentertaininghomework.

o Thefollowingareallqualitynewspaperswhicharefreetoaccess:Ø https://www.theguardian.com/ukØ https://www.independent.co.uk/Ø https://www.telegraph.co.uk/Ø https://www.nytimes.com/Ø http://www.washingtonpost.com/Ø https://www.washingtontimes.com/

o TVandRadio,whichcanbeaccessed,respectively,viahttps://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayerandhttp://www.bbc.co.uk/radioandhttps://www.itv.com/hub/shows(Beawarethattheseprogrammesarenotallavailablethroughouttheyearandthatschedulesmaychange):Ø Monday–Friday:PMRadio417:00–18:00;NewsnightBBC222:30–23:15Ø Tuesday:TheMashReportBBC222:00Ø Thursday:QuestionTimeBBC122:45–23:45;ThisWeekBBC123:45–00:45Ø Friday:TheNewsQuiz/TheNowShow/DeadRingersRadio418:30–19:00;HaveI

GotNewsForYouBBC121:00–21:30;TraceyBreakstheNewsBBC121:30–22:00;MocktheWeekBBC222:00–22:30

Ø Saturday:TheWeekinWestminsterRadio411:00–11:30Ø Sunday:TheAndrewMarrShowBBC109:00–10:00;Pienaar’sPoliticsRadio510:00

–11:00;PestononSundayITV10:00–11:00,repeated22:20–23:20

5

SynopticthinkingSynopticcanbebrokendowntosyn-,meaningtogether,and-optic,meaningvieworsight.Politicsisahighlysynopticsubjectand,asthespecificationadvises,“studentsmustidentifyparallels,connections,similaritiesanddifferencesbetweencontentstudied”.ThisisespeciallyimportantinComponent3,wherecomparisonswiththeUKneedtobemadewhenansweringexamquestionsontheUSA.Furthermore,thinkingsynopticallyaboutthetopicswithinComponents1and2,aswellasmakinglinksbetweenthetwocomponents,isaveryeffectivewaytodemonstrateahighlevelofunderstandingofPoliticsatALevel.Thismaywellsounddauntingbutsynopticthinkingisaskillthatcanbemasteredwithpracticeanditisalsoworthemphasisingthatyouarenotexpectedtostartthecoursewithanypriorknowledge:justthecommitmenttoacquiringit,includingthroughindependentstudy.ThetasksbelowwillgiveyousomeinsightintohowthisskillcanbeappliedtothemostrecentmajorpoliticaleventintheUK–thegeneralelectionof2017.Thiseventisstudied,toagreaterorlesserdegree,inallUKtopics.AtthetimewhenTheresaMaydecidedtocallthis‘snap’election,theConservativeshad331MPsandasmallmajorityoftwelve.Maybeganthecampaignwithanopinionpollleadindoublefiguresbutafterwardshadtodoa‘confidenceandsupply’dealwiththeDemocraticUnionistParty(DUP),whosetenMPscouldprovideamajorityincrucialvotesintheCommons–onthebudget(i.e.thesupplyofmoneyneededforthegovernmenttoimplementitslegislativeprogramme)andonanyvotesotherpartiesproposetobringthegovernmentdown(i.e.avoteof‘noconfidence’inthegovernment).

4

The2017UKParliamentarygeneralelectionwasheldonThursday8thJune.Theelectionwascalledearly,underSection2(1)oftheFixed-termParliamentsAct2011,afterthePrimeMinisterannouncedherintentionon18thAprilforanelectiontobeheld.Votingwasheldinall650constituenciesacrosstheUK:533inEngland,59inScotland,40inWalesand18inNorthernIreland.TheelectionresultedinahungParliament,withnosinglepartywinninganoverallmajority.TheConservativeParty,ledbyPrimeMinisterTheresaMay,wonthelargestnumberofseatsandvotes,taking317seatsand42.3%ofthevoteacrosstheUK.TheConservativesgained20seatsbutlost33,leavingthemwith317,13fewerthantheywonin2015.

TheLabourParty,ledbyJeremyCorbyn,won262seats,and40.0%ofthevote,upfrom232seatsand30.4%ofthevotein2015.TheConservatives’shareofthevoteisthehighestforanysinglepartysincethe43.2%wonbyLabourin1997,andtheirtotalof13.6millionvotesisthesecondhighesttotalinUKelectoralhistory.

4http://researchbriefings.files.parliament.uk/documents/CBP-7979/CBP-7979.pdf

6

1. TheConservatives’shareofthevoteisthehighestforanysinglepartysincethe43.2%wonbyLabourin1997,andtheirtotalof13.6millionvotesisthesecondhighesttotalinUKelectoralhistory.Why,then,isthe2017generalelectionresultseenassuchapooroutcomefortheConservativesingeneralandMayinparticular?

2. Maybeganthegeneralelectioncampaignwithanopinionpollleadindoublefigures.WhatdoestheoutcomeoftheelectionsuggestabouttheimportanceoftheconductoftheirrespectivecampaignsbytheConservativesandLabourandthenatureofthepoliciestheyofferedtotheelectorate?Note:ensurethatyouranswerreflectstheactualoutcomeoftheelectioni.e.thattheConservativeswonmorevotesandseatsthanLabour.

3. HowcertaincanMaybethatshewillbeabletowinvotesandsobeabletoimplementherlegislativeprogramme(onmattersotherthan‘confidenceandsupply’)?

4. Undertakeanindependentresearchtaskandwriteshortexplanationsoftheterms‘hardBrexit’and‘softBrexit’,whichcouldbeunderstoodbytypicalYear10students.

5. The‘confidenceandsupply’agreementwiththeDUPwillonlysucceedifConservativeMPssupportthepartyline.WhyisitavirtualcertaintythatConservativeMPswilldoso,evenonBrexit,despiteBrexiteersfearingthatthecountrywillnotgetthe‘hard’Brexitwhichtheyclaimiswhat“thepeoplevotedfor”andpro-EuropeanswhofearthedamagetotheUK’seconomythattheybelieveanythingotherthana‘soft’Brexitwilldo?

6. Collectiveministerialresponsibilityisaconvention(i.e.aprincipleofexpectedpractice)thatmembersofthecabinetmustpubliclysupportallgovernmentaldecisionsmadeincabinet,eveniftheydonotprivatelyagreewiththem.Iftheydonotdoso,itisexpectedthattheyeitherresignfromthegovernmentoraresackedbythePrimeMinister.BorisJohnson,theForeignSecretary,isthemostnotableexampleofacabinetmemberwhoisarepeatoffenderforbreakingthisconvention.ThishasmostfrequentlybeenontheissueofBrexit.a) WhatisrevealedaboutthestrengthandauthorityofMaythatshehasnotsacked

Johnson?b) WhatistheunderlyingreasonforyouranswertoQuestiona)?c) WhatisrevealedabouttheinfluenceofJohnsonwithinthecabinetwhenhe

criticisesgovernmentpolicyonBrexitoutsideofcabinetmeetings?

7. Politicalcartooniststypicallycrafttheircreationswithgreatattentiontodetailandcanproduceworkwhichoffersconsiderableinsight.Lookverycloselyatthetwoexamplesbelowandexplainwhatcanbelearntabouteachcartoonist’sviewofthe2017generalelection.

7

CartoonAbyDaveBrown,TheIndependent5

CartoonBbyGeraldScarfe,SundayTimes6

5https://www.indy100.com/article/cartoonists-react-general-election-2017-theresa-may-hung-parliament-77812416https://www.slideshare.net/jeffreyhill/uk-general-election-2017-cartoons

8

10keyfactstolearnforthestartofthecourse

1. Namethepartyleader:

o Conservatives=………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

o Labour=…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

o LiberalDemocrats=……………………………………………………………………………………………………

o SNP=………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

o PC=……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

o DUP=…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………

o Greens=…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….

o UKIP=………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..

2. Inthe2016EUreferendum,Leavegained…..…..%ofvotescomparedtoRemain’s

…..…..%.

3. ‘Initiatives’occurin……………………..…………andsomeUSstates,wherecitizensgather

signaturesonapetitionforapublicvoteonaproposednewlaw.Thesearesimilartoa

referendumbuttheyare……………………..………………………………………………………………………..

………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..

4. Inthe2017generalelectiontheConservativeswon…..…..%ofseatswith…..…..%ofthe

votes.

5. Inthe2017generalelectiontheLiberalDemocratsgained…..…..%ofseatswith…..…..%

ofthevotes.

6. Turnoutinthe2017generalelection(at…..…..%)wasthehighestin…..…..years.

7. Foreverytenyearsolderavoterwas,theirchanceofvotingToryin2017increasedby

around…..…..pointsandthechanceofthemvotingLabourdecreasedby…..…..points.

Thetippingpoint,thatistheageatwhichavoterwasmorelikelytohavevoted

ConservativethanLabour,was…..…...

9

8. Ahungparliamentisaparliamentinwhich…..……………………………………………………………….

Eitheraminoritygovernmentoracoalitionwillthenresult.

9. Anelectoral……………………..…………isadocumentproducedbyapoliticalpartyat

electiontimes,statingwhatpoliciesitintendstoimplementifitgainspower.

10. Anelectoral……………………..…………referstotheauthoritytogoverngrantedbyvotersto

thewinningpartyatanelection.The……………………..…………suggeststhatthe

governmentmay……………………..…………themeasuresinitselection……………………..…….

10

10keyfactstolearnforthestartofthecourseASwithanyALevelcourse,therearekeyfactsthatitisveryusefultolearnbecausetheycanbeexamplesthatillustratethepointsyouwanttomakeandprovidethebasisfromwhichyoucandevelopexplanationandevaluation.Youwillneedtolearnthefollowingkeyfacts,readyforatestinSeptember.Thetestwillreplicatetheinformationbelow–excepttherewillbegapsinwhichyouwillneedtowritewhatishighlightedhere.11. Namethepartyleader:

o Conservatives=TheresaMayo Labour=JeremyCorbyno LiberalDemocrats=VinceCableo SNP=NicolaSturgeono PlaidCymru=LeanneWoodo DUP=ArleneFostero Greens=CarolineLucasandJonathanBartley(Co-Leaders)o UKIP=GerardBatten

12. Inthe2016EUreferendum,Leavegained52%ofvotescomparedtoRemain’s48%.13. ‘Initiatives’occurinSwitzerlandandsomeUSstates,wherecitizensgathersignatures

onapetitionforapublicvoteonaproposednewlaw.Thesearesimilartoareferendumbuttheyareinitiated(started)bycitizens,notbyanationaloraregional/stategovernment.

14. Inthe2017generalelectiontheConservativeswon49%ofseatswith42%ofthevotes.15. Inthe2017generalelectiontheLiberalDemocratsgained1.8%ofseatswith7.4%of

thevotes.16. Turnoutinthe2017generalelection(at69%)wasthehighestin25years.17. Foreverytenyearsolderavoterwas,theirchanceofvotingToryin2017increasedby

aroundninepointsandthechanceoftheirvotingLabourdecreasedbyninepoints.Thetippingpoint,thatistheageatwhichavoterwasmorelikelytohavevotedConservativethanLabour,was47.

18. Ahungparliamentisaparliamentinwhichnosinglepartyhasmajoritycontrol.Eithera

minoritygovernmentoracoalitionwillthenresult.

11

19. Anelectoralmanifestoisadocumentproducedbyapoliticalpartyatelectiontimes,statingwhatpoliciesitintendstoimplementifitgainspower.

20. Anelectoralmandatereferstotheauthoritytogoverngrantedtothewinningpartyat

anelectionbyvoters.Themandatesuggeststhatthegovernmentmayimplementthemeasuresinitselectionmanifesto.

12

©ThePiXLClubLtd.June2018

ThisresourceisstrictlyfortheuseofmemberschoolsforaslongastheyremainmembersofThePiXLClub.Itmaynotbecopied,sold,ortransferredtoathirdpartyorusedbytheschoolaftermembershipceases.Untilsuchtimeitmaybefreelyusedwithinthememberschool.Allopinionsandcontributionsarethoseoftheauthors.Thecontentsofthisresourcearenotconnectedwith,orendorsedby,anyothercompany,organisationorinstitution.PiXL Club Ltd endeavour to trace and contact copyright owners. If there are any inadvertent omissions orerrors in the acknowledgements or usage, this is unintended and PiXL will remedy these on writtennotification.