Post on 30-Oct-2014
PIPE STRESS ANALYSIS: AN INTRODUCTION
FDC- PIPINGREAL
JAMNAGAR, GUJARAT, INDIA.
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 2
CTS Lab Admin FDC O&M Procr&
Contrc
Mech Proj Piping Elect Civil
Piping layout Design Grp.
Pipe Stress Analysis: Reliability Engg. Grp.
Safety
ConstProcess
CES
Refinery & Petrochemical(e.g. Reliance Jamnagar Refinery)v
(Not exhaustive)
BG/PSAIntro/REAL/290605BG/PSAIntro/REAL/290605 33
Let Us Start: MilestonesLet Us Start: Milestones•Introduction•Milestones•Piping Design & its Reliability Concern
•Pipe Stress Analysis - I: Loads on Piping System •Pipe Stress Analysis - II: Stresses on Piping System
•Pipe Stress Analysis – III: What are Stressed on Stress Analysis•Pipe Stress Analysis – IV: The Governing Codes•Pipe Stress Analysis – V: How Things Are Carried Out•Pipe Stress Analysis – VI: Interactions With Other Departments•Pipe Stress Analysis – VII: Few Technical Aspects•Pipe Stress Analysis – VIII: Roles of The Analyst •Pipe Stress Analysis – IX: Associated Instructions & Design guide/spec.•Conclusions & Q-A Session.
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 4
Piping Design & Its Main Concerns
Techno-Commercial Concern.
Reliability Concern: Pipe-Stress-Analysis
Future Expansion Provisions.
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 5
Reliability Concerns of Piping Design
Pipe & Piping System.
Pipe Stress.
Stress analysis.
Adding Flexibility/ Rigidity & Proper Supporting.
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 66
Pipe Stress Analysis – IPipe Stress Analysis – I
Loads On Piping SystemLoads On Piping System
Back To School: Stress – Strain Back To School: Stress – Strain Relationship.Relationship.
Loads on the Piping System: Loads on the Piping System: *Primary Vs. Secondary*Primary Vs. Secondary*Static Vs. Dynamic*Static Vs. Dynamic
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 7
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 8
Thermally deflected Upward at Elevated Temperature
The actual Pipe
Example of Secondary Loading: Thermal strain
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 9
Deflection Under Weight & Sustained Loading: Primary Loads
Actual Pipe
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 1010
Pipe Stress Analysis – IIPipe Stress Analysis – II
Stresses on Piping SystemStresses on Piping System Primary Stresses: Axial stress, Primary Stresses: Axial stress,
Longitudinal stress due to internal Longitudinal stress due to internal pressure, Bending stress due to pressure, Bending stress due to Uniform/Concentrated loading, Hoop Uniform/Concentrated loading, Hoop stress, Shear stress etc.stress, Shear stress etc.
Secondary Stresses: Thermal Expansion Secondary Stresses: Thermal Expansion stress, stress due to Vibration, Fatigue stress, stress due to Vibration, Fatigue stress due to long cycles, Time dependent stress due to long cycles, Time dependent stress like Creep etc.stress like Creep etc.
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 1111
Pipe Stress Analysis– IIIPipe Stress Analysis– III
What are Stressed on Stress AnalysisWhat are Stressed on Stress Analysis
Complying with Governing Codes.Complying with Governing Codes.
Safety for Connected Equipment & Safety for Connected Equipment & Supporting Structures.Supporting Structures.
Acceptability of Piping Displacement.Acceptability of Piping Displacement.
Stability of Piping system under Dynamic Stability of Piping system under Dynamic Loads.Loads.
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 1212
Pipe stress Analysis - IVPipe stress Analysis - IV
The Governing CodesThe Governing Codes ASME B31.1: Power Piping CodeASME B31.1: Power Piping Code ASME B31.3: Process piping CodeASME B31.3: Process piping Code ASME B31.4: Oil Transportation Piping ASME B31.4: Oil Transportation Piping
CodeCode ASME B31.8: Gas Transportation Piping ASME B31.8: Gas Transportation Piping
CodeCodeThere are Standards like ASTM, API, NEMA, EJMA There are Standards like ASTM, API, NEMA, EJMA
etc.etc.(Not Exhaustive)(Not Exhaustive)
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 1313
Pipe Stress Analysis - VPipe Stress Analysis - V
HoHow Things Are Carried Outw Things Are Carried Out Inputs:Inputs:
~ Process: P&ID & LDT (Through ~ Process: P&ID & LDT (Through PDS).PDS).
~ Layout Group: Isometrics.~ Layout Group: Isometrics.~ Mechanical: Equipment GA & ~ Mechanical: Equipment GA &
datasheets.datasheets.~ Civil: Soil Characteristics~ Civil: Soil Characteristics
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 1414
Pipe Stress Analysis– VPipe Stress Analysis– V
HoHow Things Are Carried Outw Things Are Carried Out
Processing:Processing:~Modeling~Modeling~Simulating the actual behavior.~Simulating the actual behavior.~Computing results using a Core ~Computing results using a Core
Solver of Simulating S/w CAESAR-II, 4.5v, a Solver of Simulating S/w CAESAR-II, 4.5v, a product of COADE, INC, USA.product of COADE, INC, USA.
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 1515
Pipe Stress Analysis– VPipe Stress Analysis– V
HoHow Things Are Carried Outw Things Are Carried Out Output:Output:
~Interpretation of Computer generated ~Interpretation of Computer generated output.output.~Flexibility Considerations~Flexibility Considerations~Load & Displacement consideration at ~Load & Displacement consideration at nozzles & supports.nozzles & supports. In all Operating, Upset & Occasional cases.In all Operating, Upset & Occasional cases.
Formal Stress Analysis Report generation & Formal Stress Analysis Report generation & submissionsubmission..
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 1616
Pipe Stress Analysis – VPipe Stress Analysis – V
How Things Are Carried OutHow Things Are Carried OutGeneral Contents of Formal Stress Analysis General Contents of Formal Stress Analysis
Report:Report: SATS Front Sheet, Title Sheets (Design Basis)SATS Front Sheet, Title Sheets (Design Basis) Stress Check List – I & IIStress Check List – I & II Load Summary Chart & Restraint ReportLoad Summary Chart & Restraint Report Displacement Report, Hanger ReportDisplacement Report, Hanger Report Hanger Datasheets, Special Pipe Support reportsHanger Datasheets, Special Pipe Support reports Caesar Dump, Marked up IsometricsCaesar Dump, Marked up Isometrics Equipment G/A drawing & DatasheetsEquipment G/A drawing & Datasheets P&ID, LDT.P&ID, LDT.
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 1717
Stress Team Interactions with Other Departments - VIStress Team Interactions with Other Departments - VI
Piping Team
Process Dept.
Stress AnalysisTeam
Stress AnalysisReport
Civil Dept. MechanicalDept.
Site/ Field
InstrumentationDept.
P&IDLDT
SoilCharacteristics
Civil andStructural
Support loadings
Supports Loadingsfor pipe support
selection, pipedisplacements at
operating temp.SAQ,
alongwithStress
Isometricsand other
data
EquipmentG.A.'s
Cleat Loads, Nozzleloads if more than
allowables
Fabricationand Erection
Isometric
Spring, SPS,Specials datasheets, Site problemresolutions, AuditReports
Instrument data
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 1818
Pipe Stress Analysis– VIIPipe Stress Analysis– VII
Few Technical AspectsFew Technical Aspects
Flexibility Vs. Rigidity of a Piping system.Flexibility Vs. Rigidity of a Piping system. Expansion Loops, expansion joints etc.Expansion Loops, expansion joints etc. Hanger Supports, Supports from Structures Hanger Supports, Supports from Structures
& equipments.& equipments. Pipe Guides, Line Stops, Anchors etcPipe Guides, Line Stops, Anchors etc TrunionTrunion..
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 1919
Pipe Stress Analysis– VIIIPipe Stress Analysis– VIII Roles Roles of The Analystof The Analyst
Carrying out the Analysis, releasing Report, Carrying out the Analysis, releasing Report, carrying out proper documentation for the carrying out proper documentation for the analysis.analysis.
Transferring the load values to Piping layout Transferring the load values to Piping layout Designer for passing on to other dept.Designer for passing on to other dept.
Storing the final stress reports, any other Storing the final stress reports, any other reference calculations, audit files, Caesar soft reference calculations, audit files, Caesar soft copies at proper locations and retrieving the latest copies at proper locations and retrieving the latest files as & when needed.files as & when needed.
Issuing & storing drawings & datasheets of spring, Issuing & storing drawings & datasheets of spring, SPS, snubbers etc.SPS, snubbers etc.
NOTE: This is a general simplified list. For actual NOTE: This is a general simplified list. For actual details refer to the various PL series of documents details refer to the various PL series of documents as listed belowas listed below..
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 2020
Associated Instructions & Associated Instructions & Design Guides/ SpecificationsDesign Guides/ Specifications
P-SS-PL-001:Piping Material Spec.P-SS-PL-001:Piping Material Spec.P-SS-PL-093:Stress Analysis Work Procedures.P-SS-PL-093:Stress Analysis Work Procedures.P-SS-PL-003:Piping Design & Plant Layout.P-SS-PL-003:Piping Design & Plant Layout.P-SS-PL-008:Pipe Stress Analysis.P-SS-PL-008:Pipe Stress Analysis.P-PS-PL-009:Pipe Stress Critical line List.P-PS-PL-009:Pipe Stress Critical line List.P-SS-PL-015:Pipe Supports.P-SS-PL-015:Pipe Supports.P-EP-PL-060:Documentation Procedure for P-EP-PL-060:Documentation Procedure for Springs, SPS, Snubbers etc.Springs, SPS, Snubbers etc.P-EP-PL-087/88:Support/Spring Audit P-EP-PL-087/88:Support/Spring Audit Procedure.Procedure.
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 21
Conclusion
Summary.
Benefits to the Organization
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 2222
“ “ Thank You Very Much”Thank You Very Much”
……Welcome to Your Queries !!Welcome to Your Queries !!
For any further queries:For any further queries: bhaskaram_gangopadhyay@ril.combhaskaram_gangopadhyay@ril.com 0288-30109510288-3010951
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 23
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 24
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 25
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 26
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 27
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 28
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 29
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 30
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 31
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 32
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 33
Fillet weldto high temperature line
Effect of Temperature gradient: Differential thermal growth at top & bottom of saddle causing tremendous shear force on the weld. In long term crack is obvious to generate & propagate to the extent of failure.
At ambient temperature
BG/EIPSRE/REAL/310305 34