Post on 13-Mar-2018
Minutes of the meeting of the Shikshan Shulka Samiti (Medical Education) held under the Chairmanship of Justice P.S. Patankar (Retd.) on Tuesday, the llth November 2014 at 11.30 a.m. in the Conference Hall, Ofice of the Samiti, 305, 3rd floor, Government Polytechnic Building, 49, Kherwadi, Bandra (E), Mumbai 400 051. Draft Minutes:-
Following Members and Officers were present:
1. Dr. (Mrs.) Snehalata Deshmukh : Member
2. Dr. A.S. Vyas : Member
Invitees :
Smt. Manisha lvlhaiskar Member Secretary and principal Secretary Medical Education and Drugs Department, Mantralaya being unable to attend the meeting was granted leave of absence.
Shri S.B. Bhagwat, CA Member being unable to attend the meeting was granted leave of absence.
Shri P.E. Gaikwad, I.A.S. having additional charge of Office Secretary, Shikshan Shulka Samiti, was present in the meeting.
Mrs. K.V. Sane, Desk Officer, Shikshan Shulka Samiti, Mumbai was present in the meeting.
The copies of the agenda along with copies of the relevant documents were circulated to the Members.
I tem No. 1: To approve and confirm minutes of Meetins of Shikshan Shulka Samiti (Medical Education] held on 'rhursdav the 16'~ October 2014 at Conference Hall, Office of the Samiti, 305, 3rd floor, Government Polvtechnic Buildina, 49, Kherwadi, Bandra (El, Mumbai 400 051.
Minutes of the Meeting of Shikshan Shulka Sarr~iti (Medical Education) held on Thursday, 1 6 ~ ~ October 2014 are approved and confirmed.
I tem No.Z(a): To review actions taken bv office on decisions arrived at in the ~revious meetinq on 16'~ 0ctober 2014.
The action taken by the office on the decisions taken by the Samiti during its meeting held on 16th October 2014, the details of the same are as follows:
SSS - Medical llth Nov. 2014
Item No.1: To convey the approval and confirmation of the Minutes of the Samiti dated 1 6 ~ ~ October 2014.
1 1 1 also put up on the Notice 1
Minutes of the Samiti Published on the website
Item No. 2: To appraise of the action taken by office and review of disposal of work for AY 2014-15.
Actionable Points
of the Samiti on 18/10/2014.. The copy of said minutes is
Action Taken by Office
Item NO. 3 7
Item No. 40)
Item No. 4(ii)
decide on the proposals received for approval of the fee structure for the courses started during AY 2014- 15:
a) To consider and decide on proposals where there are no discrepancies.
b) To consider and decid; on proposals where discrepancies are yet to be pointed out and cleared by the Colleges/Institutes.
c) To consider and decide on proposals where discrepancies are yet to be pointed out to the Colleges/ Institutes.
d) To consider and decide on proposals under scrutiny of the office.
To consider the letter dated 3/09/2014 bearing No. 3. - P ~ P ' ~ / ~ . ~ . P P ~ ? / ~ W - 7 WFd? received from Medical Education Department Mantralaya for initiating actions in respect of private Ayurved college charging exhorbitative fees.
Board on 18/10/2014.. Decision of the Samiti in respect of Colleges are published on the website & also put up on the Notice Board on 18/10/2014..
Decision is conveyed to the Principal of respective Colleges by a separate letter dated 21/10/ 2014
Decision is conveyed to the Secretary, Medical Education & Drug Department, by a separate letter dated 21/10/2014.
To consider and decide on letter dated 4/09/2014 received from Padmashree Dr. Vithalrao Vikhe Patil Foundation Medical College Ahmednagar informing a fee structure for repeater students of Post Graduation admitted in AY 2011-12.
Decision is conveyed to the Principal of Ashvin Rural Ayl.lrved College by a separate letter dated 21/10/2014.
Decision is conveyed to the Principal of Padmashree Dr. Vithalrao Vikhe Patil Foundation Medical College by a separate letter dated 21/10/2014.
Item No. 4(iii)
To consider and decide on letter dated 9/08/2014 received from Ashvin Rural Ayurved College regardirrg fixation of fee for PG course for AY 2013-14 (Ref: Item No. 4 (iv) of minutes
3 SSS - Medical llth Nov. 2014
The Samiti noted it.
Meeting of
Points
To consider and decide on letter dated 4/10/2014 received from Dr. Wasudev B. Durge i~iforrr~ing the financial irregularities and manipulations done by Dr. PDM Medical College Amravati.
Item No.Z(b): To review disposal of work - present Scenario for Academic Year 2014- 15.
Action Taken by Office
Decision is conveyed to Dr. Wasudev B. Durge & Others by a separate letter dated 21/10/2014.
Chart Showing No. of fees approval proposals received from the Institutes of Medical Courses for Academic Year 2014-15.
Monthly Chart of pendency of fee approval proposals month of 30 September 14
1 I MDIMS (PG) ( 12 1 11 1 12
-$ Streams
3 PG Dental 18 12 10
4 BDS 25 20 20
5 PG- Ayurved 14 10 10
6 Ayurved 44 38 38
7
< a un
g 2 2 i u 0 o r\l I: u a
- 2 < .- a L L u VI - gp a m OcS re o V I 4 g cv -l 0 cvo z LL r\l,
4, n d $0 u n! g $ Qz re m
0 0"
'8
PG. Homeopathi C
E K m 24 F " g g -,: -I
- 2 m q- g s 4 n a L 2 2 % n E g y=cv 0 6 U 1
U
V) m 8 u 2 .'
8 L o g (j
14
No. of Pending Proposals
,.N c v . ~ - a 22cv = IX
10 11
o
u a ELj $ >. > 0
4 SSS - Medical 2014
* un a g 2 2 i U 0 o N c w a
Rs.495501-
Rs.520201-
Rs.681301-
Rs.433501-
Rs.61930/-
Rs.619301-
Rs.520201-
Rs.557301-
Rs.619301-
Rs.557301-
P
a Rs.52500/-
Rs.412901-
Rs.412901-
Rs. 176901-
Rs. 176901-
Streams
Homeopathi c
9 yisiothera
P i -.-I
g s g> -- g 9s "-"I
O 8 o s z g
45
22
22
1
-
12
PIP-TH (PG.- Phisiotherap Y > Occupationa l Therapy P.G.Occupat ional
m = . - I e m o d o 4-l a n L 2 = J % a g € F g e 0 6 ( " w
42
19
2
0
0
13
14
15
16
l7
m
Onz 2 .2 n~
6 z
42
19
6
0
0
0
0
0
5
1
1
9
18
l9
20
21
22
23
PG - Unani
Unani
BASLP
M.Sc.Nursin
P.B.B.Sc. Nursing
llth Nov.
0
2
0
2
The Samiti noted it.
B.Sc.Nursin
DMLT(After B.Sc.) RAN M Nursing
RGNM Nursing
Dental Hygienist Dental Mechanic Total
4
6
2
13
27
0
2
0
2
- m < ii, = a V) -
gP a m 2 - , 5 ; -
52
I
605
220
1162
1
3
0
11
28
E t m 2 Z Z z g
2
No. of Pending Proposals
1
3
0
11
2!a ,-.N- a l . ~
61
0
408
175
865
U al 4 ~ c i S A -
1
2
0
0
0
\c o m * cu .-I
0 cuo ZLLN
39
17
6
59
,E
3
2
0
0
0
13 46
4 - l < V)
2
0
0
0
0
9
0
393
171
845 312
205
81
528
0
188
90
317
0
127
61
0
0
212
0
0
0
61
29
105
SSS - Medical llth IVov. 2014
I tem No. 3 : To decide on the proposals received for a ~ ~ r o v a l of fees structure for the courses started durinq Academic Year 2014-15:
I tem No. 3(a) : To consider and decide on ~roposals where there are no discrepancies.
The Samiti considered the proposals of the following Colleges/Institutes for finalization of fee structure for the students who joined the course started during Academic Year 2014-15. After deliberations, The Sarr~iti decides to approve the final fee structure of the following Colleges/Institutes for the students who joined the course started during Academic Year 2014-15, subject to final approval/affiliation/permissions from respective Authorities. Figures are arrived at after considering the calculations drawn in the worksheet - calculation sheets of the respective colleges/institutes prepared by a Chartered Accountant. The students admitted in Acaderr~ic Year 2014-15 and there after continuing their studies will pay an enhanced fee of 5% each successive year as per the norms for 2014-15 till completion of the course. For example if the fee approved is Rs. 1,00,000/- then from 11" years onward till completion of the course i.e. say 11, I11 and IV year the fees will be Rs. 1,05,000/- per @. I n case the students take V th years for completing the course then he shall pay the fee approved in that year. Worksheet - Calculation sheets are available in the office.
BDS
111 Collected
Sr' no.
BHMS
Final Fees for
Final Fees for
Interim Fees for
'Ode
No.
1 I 1 1 Feesfor 1 Feesfor 1 Feesfor / 1 .
Name of the Institute
Final Final Interim
Sr' no.
course Starting from AY 2013-14
BHMsoolo
Code No.
course
from AY 2014-15
LMF's Homeopathic College, Chinchwad, Pune
Name of the Institute
course
from AY 2014-15
41200
Institute Demands
course Starting from AY
43260
course starting from AY
48000
course starting from AY
61119
Institute Demands
SSS - Medical llth Nov. 2014
BAMS
BSC NURSING
no. Code No.
BAMSo021
BAMS0042
from AY 1 from AY 1 from AY 1 1 2013-14 2014-15 2014-15
Final Fees for
Final Fees for
1 z:, 1 'Ode
Interim Fees for
Name Of the Institute
BSCN0036
BSCN0040
BSCN0042
BSCN0072
Final Fees for course
starting from AY 2014-15
100000
165000 * 32471
Name of the Institute Institute Demands
121781
166881
Final Fees for course Starting from AY 2013-14
ppppp
105000
125000
165000 Collected
Ashwin Rural Ayurved College, Sangamner, Ahmednagar
course starting
MIT Nursirrg College, Aurangabad
Hiranandani College of Nursing, Powai, Mumbai
Br. Nath Pai College of Nursing, Kudal
Oyster Nursing College, Aurangabad
Interim Fees for course
starting from AY 2014-15
110250 -
131250
UG
PG
ADITYA AYURVED COLLEGE, BEED-Y
course starting
50380
78000 Collected
65000
47190 Collected
course 1 Institute 1 starting Demands
52899
-
68250
-
52560
78000
72000
48000
52607
78000
80000
50170
7
PBSCN
SSS - Medical llth IVov. 2014
Interim Fees for Fees for Fees for
I Final I I Final I from AY 1 from AY 1 1 Fo":-z 1 2014-15 2014-15
Sr. 1 no. 1 C::? I Name Of the Institute
PBSCN Ganpatrao Adke College of 1 0001 1 Nursing, Nashik 1 60000 1 63000 63040 1 69698 1
course starting
course I course I Institute I starting starting Demands
PBSCN 0021
PBSCN KDA Nursing College, 1 0031 1 Andheri, Mumbai 1 78000 1 81900 1 I 78000 1 78000 I
3
Kasturba Nursing College, Sevagram, Wardha
PBSCN Oo2'
PBSCN 0033
50000
PHYSIOTHERAPY
NAMCO College of Nursing and Research Institute, Nashik
Hiranandani College of Nursing , Powai, Mumbai
Final Fees for
Sr. no.
Lokmanya IYedical Foundation and Research
PT0021 Centre's College of Physiotherapy, Chinchwad, Pune
52500
course starting from AY
P.E. Society's PT/ PT0019 Modern College of MPTH Physiotherapy
53080FY
60000SY onwards
53500 Collected
Interim Fees for
'Ode
No. Institute Demands
56000
Final Fees for
2014-15
70000
55734
57000
Name of the Institute
57245
60000
course starting from AY
840 15
course starting from AY
8 SSS - Medical llth NOV. 2014
RANM
Name of the Institute Sr. no.
Final 1 Interim 1 Final I Fees for Fees for Fees for
Code No. course starting fromAY 2013-14
Navjeevan Nursing School (ANM), Chamorshi, Dist Gadchiroli
Savitribai Phule RANM Nursing College, Shrigonda, Ahmednagar
Rashtramata Jijau Nursing School, Latur
course starting fromAY 2014-15
Phaltan Education Society's School of Nursing, Phaltan
56000
60000 Collected -
course starting fromAY 2014-15
Institute Demands
58800
RANM0030
RANM0042
/ Vamanrao Ithape Nursing 1 8 I RANM0074 School, Sangmner,
60000
7
1 1 I Ahmednagar
87489
Jeevan Jyot Nursing College, Osmanabad
Indira Gandhi Nursing School, Osmanabad
Maa Ganga Nursing School, Washim 1 63860 67053 1 70000 74588 1
RANM0047
I 1 Dr. Dalvi Memorial
55000
35000 Collected
1 10 1 RANMOllO I Hospital & Research Centre Nursing Training
Sharda Nursing School Khapa, Tumsar, Bhandara - 441912
G.B.Patil School of Nursing, Udgir, Latur
57750
64380
55000
40000
75 183
83141
67599 72000 87157
12
l3
l4
l5
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
SSS - llth NOV.
68600
82300
82000
45000
23000
52620
57420
58000
76790
45000
63000
66000
40700
45000
48000
Medical 2014
68616
82307
97366
94184
22944
87654
81256
78688
80000
73878
100000
84571
78206
108548
RANM0117
RANMo128
RANM0132
RANM0141
RANM0144
RANMO15O
RANMO152
RANM0164
RANM0175
RANM0182
RANM0185
RANM0194
RANMO201
RANM0254
RANM0256
67379
79065
78750
0
44394
52500
58590
54600
78750
47250
60900
69300
42000
-
44100
Shri Sai Nursing School , Jalna
Late Mahaling Swami Nursing School, Latur
Dhanwantari School of Nursing, Aklunj
Sahara Insitute of Nursing Education, Aklunj
Dr. J.J. Magdum Institute of Nursing Education, Jaysingpur
Padole Nursing School, Yavatmal
Ekvira School or IVursing, Amravati
Right Value Nursing, Nagpur
IYanik Nursing School, Aurangabad
Manik Nursing School, Buldhana
Mauli Nursing School, Parbhani
L.D.H.T. Nursing School, Hingoli I
SAVITRIBAI PH ULE SCHOOL OF IVURS[NG, KOLHAPUR Gandhi Nursing School, Kada, Beed Muktai Nursing School, Nanded
9
64170
75300
75000
42280
50000
55800
52000
75000
45000
58000
66000 (As Per
affidavit Colelded
Rs. 60000/-)
40000
35000 Coleded I
42000
10 SSS - Medical llth IVov. 2014
I I I I
Jawalge Nursing School, latur 1 45000 1 47250 1 50000 1 76205 /
I I I I
Dr. Dahipale Medical Medical Foundanation Trust School of Nursing, 1 50000 1 52500 1 55000 1 71950 1
-
Aurangabad
Saflya Nursing School, Barad, Nanded Collected 35000 1 Maharashtra Nursing School, Chakur, Latur 50000 1 52500 55000 72530 1
RANM0332
Jijamata Nursing School, 33 RANM0353 Shevgaon, Ahmednagar , 32
Gurumauli Institute of Nursing Scinece, Arnravati
Shree Venkatesh Nursing SC~OOI, Latur
RANM0345
66000
Sant Gqjanan Maharaj Nursing School (RANM), Sindewahi , Chandrapur
35 1 Pravara Medical Trust's
RANM0389 School of Nursing , 1 Shevgaon
36
37
Sau Rg Mali Nursing School, Ner, Dist - Dhule
69300
38
39
1 41 RANM0431 Kiran Nursing Scho, Dhule
RANM0397
RANM0399
72000
RANM0400
RANM0427
78904
Swami Narayan Nursing Institute, Nashik
Kalai Nursing School (RANM), Beed
Mauli Nursing School (RANM), Beed
Matoshri School of RANM Nursing, Nashik
60000
82000
76700
0
63000
86100
80535
45000
66000
58787
77083
86100
80600
107337
99044
11 SSS - Medical llth Nov. 2014
Uma Institute of Nursing Education, Sangli 1 45000 47250 1 50000 73730 1 Asnaram School of Nursing, Kamptee, 1 70000 1 73500 1 77000 1 111420 1
44
LOKNETE RNARAMBAPU PATIL TRAINING COLLEGE OF NURSING, URUN ISIAMPUR SHRI JAYRAMSETH CHAUDHARI INSTITUTE OF NURSING AND PARAMEDICAL SCIENCE MURBAD THANE
45
Omakar Nursing School, Biloli
RANM0466
RANM0477
nagpur
DZHES Aurangabad Nursing School, Aurangbad
Pragati Nursing School,
Rajiv Gandhi Memorial ANM Nursing College, Nashik
66000 69300 72000
DIAMOND NURSING INSTITUTE DEOLI, WARDHA
Pawanraja Nursing School, Purni, Bhandara
1 50000 1 52500 1 55000
56000
50000 52500 51470 75000 I
ASHIRWAD NURSING COLLEGE OF ANM,SAKOLI
55000
58800
66000
53
1 1 1 DEVANG NURSING / 39320M 1 1 I 1
57750
54
62000
69300
Jijamata School of Nursing, Buldhana
84150
61000
72000
RANM0588
1 55
71181
48000
Kanishka School of Nursing, Satara
RANM0596
50400
75000
SCHOOL (RANM), RATNAGIRI
56860 117413
78750
40000SY onwards
48000
41286
85000
40000 1 40000
12 SSS - Medical
RGNM
2014
82080
55712
40156
62059
no.
1
llth Nov.
50000
40390
30000
45000
50000
30000
I
I
56
57
58
59
60
6 1
2
I OF NURSING
RGNMoool
4
Institute Demands
RGNM0002
RGNMoo16
RANM0597
RANM0604
IWNMo6O7
RANM0615
RANM
RANM0616
Code No.
School of Nursing Krishana Hospital & MRC, Karad-Y
RGNIY0018
RGNM0047
39320FY
50000SY onwards
37088 Collected
20000 Collected
39320FY 4 5 0 0 0 ~ ~ onwards
-
D.C.T.'S LATE MRS. ABOLI KULDEEP PEDNEKAR NURSING SCHOOL
Gondia City Institute of Nursing & Paramedical Sciences, Gondia
Smt. Anitatai Naik Nursing School, Yavatmal
Sau. Rukhmini Manohar Machale Nursing School, Beed
Dayanand School of Nursing, Talasari, Thane
Savitribai Fule Mahila mandal, Parvatibai nursing School, Wardha
~nterim Fees for course
Starting from AY 2014-15
Phaltan Education Society's School of Nursing, Phaltan
Sahara Institute of Nursing, Aklunj
41286
41286
0
Final Fees for course
starting from AY 2014-15
6
Name of the Institute
. 56000
Dr. 1.1. Magdum Institue of IVursing Education , Jaysingpur MAHARASHTRA HOMIOPATHIC FOUNDATION'S SCHOOL
Fees for course starting from 2013-
14
58800
50000
84000
43690
64380
52750
63000
52500
88200
62950
60000 i
89707
45875
67599
65285
43220
55000
43233
87157
13 SSS - Medical llth IVov. 2014
6
7
RGNM0075
I I Kasturabai Nursing School, 10 RGNM0114 Latur I 50000 52500 1 56000 1 166644
RGNM0074
9
Late Aasrabai Darade 11 RGNMOl19 School of RGNM Nursing,
I Rajeev Gandhi Memorial 12 RGNM0130 GNM Nursing College, 1 55000 57750 61000
69300 1 15000 1 77249 I
RGNM0061
of Nursing , Haveli, Pune
Mauli Nursing School (RGNM), Beed
Nashik LOKNETE RAlARAMBAPU
Rajmata Jijau Shikhshan Prasarak Mandal's School
RGNM0087
1 Nanded
Dagdojirao Patil RGlVM Nursing School, Hadgaon,
66000
( ISIAMPUR I I I I
66000
45150
Vamanrao Ithape Nursing School (RGNM), Sangmner, Ahmednagar
l3
I 1 SI-~ri Jayramseth Chaudhari I 1 I
69300
I 'OLLEGE ( 46066 1 48369.3 1 47300 RGNM0136 OF NURSING, URUN
47408
70000
~ 1 Murbad, Thane I I 1
73000
l4
YASHWANT NURSING l5 RGNM0150 INSTITUTE KODOLI i I 1 66000 69300 1 72000 1 98018 1
I
50000
99078
73500
I ~nsitute of Nursing and RGNM0141 Parameidcal Science, 1 62000 1 65100 1 62000
54699
75000
l6
80132
17
18
RGNM0153
RGNMO 154
RANM01621 RGNM0163
Sushrusha Nursing School, Daund, Pune
66800
DZHES MARATHWADA NURSING SCHOOL , NANDED.
64400
45040 Colleded
Shri Bhgwan School of Nursing, Latur
70140
RANMIRGNM
67620
-
73000 131381
64400
49720
84150
53280
SSS - Medical llth NOV. 2014
I I I I I
I Collected 1
71426
SHRI DHANESHWARI RGNM0166 RGNIvl NURSING SCHOOL,
ALl RANGABAD
RGNM0172 1 G.B.PATIL SCHOOL OF NURSING (RGNM) UDGIR
71420 l9
66000
BHAUSAHEBSARDESAI
Manik Nursing School I 63000 66000 77480 1 60000 1
RGNM0165
69300
S5000/-
SCHOOL OF RGNMO 175 NURSING,TALEGAOIV
GENERAL HOSPITAL, - PUIVE
RAMR/UE COLLEGE
::RsING , DAPO L I KAMAL NURSING
66000 Shri Sai RGhlM Nursing School, Jalna
RANMIRGNM
69300
69140
0
INmTUT I RANMIRGNM E KAIJ
69385
DIST- BEED
48960
Savitribai Phule RGNM Nursing College
48967
Oneness School o f Nursing, Buldhana
K.J. Somaiya School o f nursing , Sion , Mumbai 1 47000 1 49310 I
54000 I 70444
( Aurangabad
29
Note : R.G.N.M. course is of 3 % years and hence for the last six months half of the fees for 1 year can be chaw&.
RGNM0217
Dr. Dahiphale Medical Foundation Trust's School of Nursing (RGNM),
48000 50400 54000 60 164
15 SSS - Medical 1lth Nov. 2014
Note: The fee approved, for above courses is subject to a ffiliation/permission from respective Authorities.
Note: *Additional fee to be collected from all students of the course except those admiffed in the year 2014-15.
Item No. 3(bl: To consider and decide on proposals where discrepancies are vet to be pointed out to the Colleaes/ Institutes.
Nil
Item No. 3(cl: To consider and decide on proposals where discrepancies are vet to be pointed out to the Colleqes/ Institutes.
Nil
Item No. 3(d1: To consider and decide on groposals under scrutinv of the office.
Office to scrutinize and place the proposals before the Samiti in due course.
Item No. 4(il: To consider and decide on letter dated 26/9/2014 received from Swatantra Senani Uttamraoii Patil Nursing Colleqe, Auranaabad reauestinq for reduction in penalty amount for AY 2014-15 as per Item No. 4(iv) of minutes 16/10/2014.
Considered the report of the office as per Item No. 4(iv) of the meeting held on 16/10/2014. I t is concerning 3 different courses 1) Basic Bsc. Nursing 2) Post Bsc. IYursing 3) RANM. The Institute has submitted on line proposals on 28/7/2014 in respect of these courses. Further hard copies were submitted on 1/10/2014. As far as the courses regarding the Basic Bsc. Nursing and Post Bsc. Nursing are concerned, the hard copy of the online proposal submitted on 1/10/2014 is the same. Therefore they are to get back the penalty/late fee of Rs. 60,000/- paid for these courses. The office to refund the same immediately. As far as RANM course is concerned, the. online proposal submitted on 28/7/2014 was different from the hard copy submitted on 1/10/2014. Now the Institute wants this to be considered .There is therefore delay. The penaltyllate fee was Rs. 30,000/-. Therefore the office has correctly collected the amount of Rs. 30,000/- in respect of this course.
Item No. 4(ii): To consider and decide on letter dated 22/10/2014 received from Davanand School of Nursinq reqardinq submission and proposal for the AY 2014-15.
This is concerning RANM course. The Institute is situated at Village Vadoli, Talasari which is totally tribal area. It is pointed out that all the students are tribals. I t is pointed out that it has no online facility or availability of any modern gadgets. I t is
16 SSS - Medical llth Nov. 2014
also pointed out that there is no electricity even available for more than '/2 a day every day. For the first time they are coming before the Samiti. It is pointed out that they were not aware that they are required to get the fee approved from the Samiti. It is stated that it may not be possible to run the institute without the help of the Government. The hard copy is already submitted. It is prayed that there may not be any late fee and the proposal made be evaluated considering all this aspects. We feel that it is better to waive the late fee and also to approve the fees. Office to communicate it.
Item No. 4fiii): To consider the letter dated 30/10/2014 bearinq No. KMED 1011 / Pra.Kra. 22/11. EDN2. Medical Education & Druq Dept. askinq an opinion of Samiti reqardins caption fees in respect of a complaint aqainst Tilak Maharashtra University.
Considered the letter dated 30/10/2014 received from Deputy Secretary Medical Education and Drug Department Maharashtra State. It is in respect of Tilak Maharashtra University, Pune. It is a deemed University. It does not come within the purview of this Samiti. This Samiti has passed the resolution in the meeting held on 5/8/2014 (H&T) in respect of similar querry. It is in Item No. 6(a). It is resolved as under:
"Item No. 6fal: To consider and decide on letter dated 14/7/2014 received from Mr. Dinesh Sethi submittinq an affidavit as per Item No. 4fiii) of minutes 16/6/2014.
Consklered the le!ter dated 14/7/2014 and the Amdavit fled along with the same by Mr. Dhesh Sethi, It is in respect of NMIMS Shhpur College. It requli-es to be noted that it has been granted Deem University Status. The question is whether this Samiti can approve the fee of the course B. Tech Computer Engineering run by it, The complahant is pointing out to the GR dated 24/9/2003 under which the Samiti was constituted and in Para 3 there is mention of Deem University. But the University Grands Commission Act 1956 in sec 2(i7 defines University. It covers deemed University or an Instiute run by it as well Section 3 thereof is about application of the Act to institutions for Higher studes other than universities. It reads as under:
"The Central Government may, on the advie of the Commission, declare by notification in the Official Gazette, that any institution for higher education, other than a University, shall be deamed to be a University for the purposes of this Act, and on such a declaration being made, all the provisions of this Act shall apply to such institution as if it were a University within the meaning of clause (I7 of section 2':
SSS - Medical llth NOV. 2014
Therefore the courses run by the Deemed University are governed by the same Act. Section 12 (A) came in to existence by Act 59 of 1984, It deals with powers and functions of the commission, This Act makes provision regarding the inspection, teaching standard and fees etc, Section 12 (A) provides for Regulation of fees and prohibition of donation in certain cases, Certainly this will prevail over the said GR dated 24/9/2003. Hence this S a m shall have no jurisdiction to approve the fee in such cases.
It requires to be noted that we have not approved the fee of the said Institute. Furfher no Institutes conducting Higher Studies in a Deem Universities is coming to this S a m and we are not approving the fee, Hence the complaint is rejected Ofice to communicate. ."
Therefore the fees of Tlak Maharashtra University, Pune are not approved by the Samiti. Further the question is in respect of students making complaints about collection of high fee or capitation fee prohibited under "The Maharashtra Education Institutional (Prohibition Of Capitation Fee) 1987". The complaint of the students that the said University is collecting higher fees, it is for the Medical Education Department to investigate this complaint about the capitation of fee and not this Samiti. Office to communicate it.
Item No. 5: Anv other matter with the ~ermission of the Chair.
The next meeting of the Shikshan Shulka Samiti (Medical Education) would be held on Monday the lSt of December 2014 at 11:30 a.m. in the Meeting Hall, Office of the Samiti at 305, Government Polytechnic Building, 49, Kherwadi, Ali Yawar Jung Marg, Bandra (E) Mumbai 400 051. / v? P.S. PATANKAR)
CHAIRMAN