Post on 05-Apr-2018
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
1/232
5
6
7
. 8
11
:13
1-14 2-38
:56 1- 57 2- 71
:82 1- 83 2- 88
:91
1- 92
2- 96
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
2/232
:98 1-99 2
- 106 :110
1-111 2- 116
:119
:127
- :
" " 142
-: 1947
181 187
222
- 223 - 229 - 232
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
3/232
6
/ .
.
.
/
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
4/232
-
7
/1940.
..
. .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
5/232
8
*
1993
...
!!! .
.*
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
6/232
-
9
..
.
"."
.
......
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
7/232
10
.
.
..
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
8/232
-
11
.
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
9/232
12
..:
181.
181
.
/ 8/7/2010
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
10/232
-
13
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
11/232
14
-1-
.
. . !
1-
.
. 1. 2-
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
12/232
-
15
. .
. . .
..( ).
.
.
2. 3-
..
.1948
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
13/232
16
. .
. " ".
.
.
.
.
.
.""
." "
. .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
14/232
-
17
.
3. 4-
. .
1967.
.
.
4.
1996
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
15/232
18
.5.
.
.
.5-
.
..
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
16/232
-
19
6-
(" " )....6.
.
" ". .
..
.1(
2( 3(
. .
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
17/232
20
7.
)(.
:- :
" "
.
. :""
.:
.:
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
18/232
-
21
.
..
: .
.
:
.
.:
.!!.
8.7- 9
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
19/232
22
.
.
-
. .
.
. -
.
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
20/232
-
23
- .
..
.
.
-
.
)(.
.
.-
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
21/232
24
( ).
.
).(-
. .
..
. .
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
22/232
-
25
: 1-
." "
10. 2-
.
.
.
/
. .
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
23/232
26
3-
. . )WMD(
.4-
" ")(
.
.
.5-
)ACRS.( .
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
24/232
-
27
.
.
:1
- . 2-
.3-
.
.
....
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
25/232
28
11.
." ".
."
" " "
.
/.
: .
. . .
. .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
26/232
-
29
" ". )
("" .
)MERSC.(
.
.
: .
. .
. .
( ).
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
27/232
30
.
. . .
.
.
.
..
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
28/232
-
31
.
..
)ACRS( .
:. . . .
. ( )
.
. ...
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
29/232
32
1-
. ...
)DMZ( .
.2- /.
)DMZ.( .
3-
.- )(. - ." "
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
30/232
-
33
4--
. - ).(
5- -
.
-)JMC( .
)CBMs.(
).(
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
31/232
34
!!
!
) (!
. )
(.)(
)ACRS(.
.)(
.
1967
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
32/232
-
35
.
.
. 12 1-
.
.
.2-
..
.13 1973
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
33/232
36
.
2009. 3- 14
.
.
.)
( "
.". :- - . -.
1967
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
34/232
-
37
.
!
.
.
! .!!
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
35/232
38
-2-
1948
. 1967 .
1811947
1948.1967
.
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
36/232
-
39
.
.. .
( ))Citizens(
)Residents(. )Further redeployment(
85%
.
1948 1(
.2(
.3(
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
37/232
40
.
.
. :
1967 .
. ....
1- .
15.
..
. 2-
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
38/232
-
41
16.
.3-
.
..
!
4-
.17
.-:
:
.
1941948.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
39/232
42
1967
.
.
1811947
.
18: 1(
1999
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
40/232
-
43
2(
)Bantustans( . 3(
1948 . 1967
.4(
(
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
41/232
44
....
(
...
.(
. 5(
.19.
6(
. 7(
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
42/232
-
45
.. 8( 20
.: ( ( ) ( /
9(
1948
1976.
13 2000
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
43/232
46
. -:
1. )ACRS( .
1993 1996...
.2. :. .
. .
. .21
.3.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
44/232
-
47
. :
- .
- .
- ) (.
4.
22
..
5. (IGCC) (UCSD)
. .
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
45/232
48
6.
.
.7.
(CBM).
.
. :
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
46/232
-
49
- - .- .- .- .
:
( .
(
( 23.
1-
.2
- . 3- .
4- .
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
47/232
50
5- .
.6-
.7-
.
1- .
2- .
3- : -) ( ..
.-
. .
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
48/232
-
51
.
.
.
: 1-
... 1948.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
49/232
52
.2-
. 2500-7000
.3-
.4-
.5-
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
50/232
-
53
).( ..
24.
: 1(
) (.
.2(
...
.
. 25.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
51/232
54
3( .
.
.4(
.
.
.
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
52/232
-
55
( )
. .
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
53/232
56
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
54/232
-
57
-1-
.
.
.
.
.) 1923. (
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
55/232
58
.
..
.
181
..
.
.
. 1948 .
.1967
.181
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
56/232
-
59
.
.. .
1948 .
. )
( ) 1999. . .23261999(.
.
. .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
57/232
60
20 1999 :1-242
242 . "
".242
"." .
242. 271967.
2-
" "
1967. )terra nullius(
. "
."
"181"
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
58/232
-
61
!!28.
3-181 291947
181
" "
1948 181!!
4-
.
.:-
." ".
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
59/232
62
!!29.
.
.:-
" "
.12 .
. -
..-
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
60/232
-
63
.
Daniel Reisner- .
:
1- 242 """ "
" "30.2- 1967
.( ).
181 14 186 1949
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
61/232
64
181291947!!
3-
. :
1-
.: ( 15-25 .
( . ( 31.
2-+
40-50% 3-
+
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
62/232
-
65
4-
12% 5-8
. 5- 5%
32.6- 33:
13% 600
2
+ )
(. 5% .
7- 34:
:(
1.9% (
7.03%
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
63/232
66
(
:4.3%
4% 3.4%.
!
.
. )Bantustans( ..
9( )2004.
)Fait accompli(
...
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
64/232
-
67
)In loco(
35.
]
[.
.
. .
1947
36.
1967 .
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
65/232
68
1811947.
.!!
. .
. .
.1952
..
1967
37
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
66/232
-
69
242
" "1967
.
( ).
." " .242
.
.38
.
..
22%.181.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
67/232
70
! . .
.
1967
.
100 40 40239.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
68/232
-
71
-2-
1-
83,794
757,182 1922. "
" 1923
..
.
.192919331936-1939.
2-
..
.1923-1948..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
69/232
72
..
3-
291947 45%
55% 15( )1948
.
.
.( )
.4- 1949
..
. .1964 .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
70/232
-
73
5-. .1964 .
6-. . .
1967 1968
5/3/401971. 7-
.
..
.8-( )1973
.1974
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
71/232
74
- 242. ..
. . .-
.
29 1947 181.
!! -. .
.- . .
41.9
- 22/
11/
19733236 421973.
. .
- -
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
72/232
-
75
-
.10-131988. .
: -. .
242328
.
18160460560760825244646532363237
-. .
.
.11- 1988
:-
181 1947.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
73/232
76
- 242338
43.
41967
44.
:
: -
. 1811947 242338 .
1967 1967
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
74/232
-
77
...
.- :
1- :
" "
..
_ _ _
..
.
27%.
)Militaryinstallation(.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
75/232
78
_
:
* A.
. * B
.* C
.75%.
.* )
(. *
. * 12 20
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
76/232
-
79
2- :
BC
A. 18
B A C A.
..
H1H2 B A A+B 40% .
.
.3- :
..( )4-6%94-96%
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
77/232
80
.
.
.4-
. .
.
...
.
...
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
78/232
-
81
.
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
79/232
82
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
80/232
-
83
-1-
-
. .....
45.
..
..
.
1967 46)
(!
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
81/232
84
.
..
.
!
" ".
.
..
.
.
)( .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
82/232
-
85
.
.47.
" " 48 .
1990"
"""49.
- -.
.
" ".
.1871 8 26
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
83/232
86
)1920-1948( .
.1945-501946.
.
1948
. ..
.1947
.51.
20%
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
84/232
-
87
50.%
1967.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
85/232
88
-2-
11
194 .
.
.
1947 .52.
. .1964.1968 9
53.
..
1974
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
86/232
-
89
.
194 11/12/1948 11"
"54.
.. .
.1974 . .
323622 1974.
.
55. 3376"
1975
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
87/232
90
.
1811947 194 11/12/1948
..
1947 194 56.
. .
194
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
88/232
-
91
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
89/232
92
-1-
.
.1967 ..
57. 60% .
.
."2"
70-80 .
58:
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
90/232
-
93
1-.2-0.5.
3-.4- 0.6
.5- 1.40
.6- 5.
.17
..
59. !! )JWC(
GAC
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
91/232
94
.
.
.
.
. 60 .
.
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
92/232
-
95
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
93/232
96
-2-
.1966
.
.
.. ..
60% .
:1-
. 1966
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
94/232
-
97
.2-
.
.3-
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
95/232
98
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
96/232
-
99
-1-
-
.
. .
.
1897
.
61.
. " ".
"
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
97/232
100
" ""."
..
62.
..
1967.
. )
(63.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
98/232
-
101
64.
..
.
9/8/1948
..
.3/4/1949
65.
29/11/194711/12/1948
.13/12/1949
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
99/232
102
.)14( .
261949 14( )1948.
1967.
.
.
1967 .
66 :
1-:
. .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
100/232
-
103
.
2-:.3-:
.4-:
- .
( ).
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
101/232
104
.
.
.. ...
67.
68.
.199326
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
102/232
-
105
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
103/232
106
-2-
.
. .
." "
69.
.242
181..
242 1967
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
104/232
-
107
.
. ( )"
70.
"
.
. .
"71.
" "
181242 181 1947
242
72.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
105/232
108
181 1967
.1947.
73.
.
. .
.
1967 242 181
.181.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
106/232
-
109
242338 1967
181194.
!
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
107/232
110
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
108/232
-
111
-1-
1967
..
..
)terra nullius(" "
..
..
)Bantustans(.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
109/232
112
74. .
: . --.
-1948 .
- .-
:-
.-
.- .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
110/232
-
113
.75.
7/6/1967 3
12
)(1949. .
..
76.
.
.
.364.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
111/232
114
. .
77.
..
.
.
.
78. " ".
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
112/232
-
115
..
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
113/232
116
-2-
1967
1967 1967
.
.1967
1967. .
)Bantustan( 79.
1967
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
114/232
-
117
.
.80.
.. .
.
3.4%4%4.3%81.
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
115/232
118
.
...
.
.
. 82.
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
116/232
-
119
" ".
.
. . .
1967 )terra nullius( 22%
. 1811947.
. .
12%." "
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
117/232
120
.
.) .Bantustans(
. .)Fait
accompl( 83
. 1967 .
.1967.
.
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
118/232
-
121
..
) .(
. .
!!
.)CB( A 84.
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
119/232
122
.
.
..!!
!!.
1967 .
. .1964.
.
... .
:
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
120/232
-
123
..
.!!.!
.
..
..
. )( .
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
121/232
124
.85.
.
.
.
.)
(.
.. . !
1988 242338
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
122/232
-
125
.
.1967
." "
.
.
.
. .
.
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
123/232
126
1948.
. .
. .
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
124/232
-
127
..
.
.
..
1811947 .1967
.22%!!1949
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
125/232
128
..
86. .
..1- 1917
..
." "
"""
.87.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
126/232
-
129
"
!!"
."
" " ".) . .Anthony H.
Crodsman(
.
.162010 )Andrew J. Shapiro(
.
""Preserving Israel's
Qualitative Military Edge.20 " "Israel Asset or Liability
.
Strategic Bonanza
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
127/232
130
.
.
.
.
.
.2008 :
46% 30%
6% 88.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
128/232
-
131
2009
68% 11%
89.
.") "Post
American world. (
."
)Zero-sum("90. 2006"
."
. . )The Size of crisis("
/2009" "
".
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
129/232
132
" .
2008"91. ."Hu Jintao"
"".
)SCO(. 92
.
"" .
.
.
20-30. .
...
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
130/232
-
133
2- - "" 93.
..
.
1914."
. .
.
. .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
131/232
134
.:
.""
..
..
.
.
.94.
1967
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
132/232
-
135
.
.) ()300 400(
(.(.
:
!!
.
)Bantustan(
.
.
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
133/232
136
..
. . 6002
" ". :
.
..
.
...
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
134/232
-
137
..
.
.
. . "Anthony .H. Cordsman"2000 20142020
. .
..
.5-
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
135/232
138
1967. .
.
.
.
. .
.
.. .
1967.
)de facto(.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
136/232
-
139
181
.
.
!
.
. . 20-30.
.
192919351936193819481965
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
137/232
140
.
.
.
.( )
.
.
.
.( )
95.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
138/232
-
141
"
" 1811947..
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
139/232
142
" "
1967
. -. .
.
.
.""
: . .- "
". -
-.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
140/232
-
143
) .2003( ."
.
..
""One man one vote.
) .2002(
"
" "1967
......22% 78% 22. %
")Gass 2002.155(.
. .2001
"-" "Palestine Israel An Alternative
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
141/232
144
configuration". .
.-.
..
. ..
96
:
.
-
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
142/232
-
145
.
.
.
..
.
.
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
143/232
146
.
.
..
.
.1:
: -:
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
144/232
-
147
.
-:
.
.-:
.
.
.-:( )
.
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
145/232
148
-:
..
. -:
.
..
.2:
- Statehood:
.
.( )
" .Statehood" .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
146/232
-
149
-:.
1948. 4.5.
-:
1967
.
"."
.-
1948...
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
147/232
150
..
1976.
2000.
.13
2000 .
.
.-:
1948..3000
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
148/232
-
151
..
-:
..
1967.
..
.
.
.3 :
. .1978.
1993. 1967
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
149/232
152
.
"" ." "
." ".
-: .
.
.-:
.
.-:
..
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
150/232
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
151/232
154
..
..
1967.
1947...
.
. .
. .
.
..
"."
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
152/232
-
155
4:
..
.
.
..
. .
...
. . .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
153/232
156
..
.
..
.
.
.
.
25% .
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
154/232
-
157
.
...
. 62
..
. .
..
.
..
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
155/232
158
" "
. " " " "..
.1948
.
!!.
. .( )
.25%)-
(.
..
1948
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
156/232
-
159
.
.
.
..
..
..
.
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
157/232
160
Statehood
.
. ..
.
.-
.
..
.
.32
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
158/232
-
161
1996
.
..
.
. . .
..
..5:
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
159/232
162
.
.
. .
.4.5
..
.
-. -.
. :
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
160/232
-
163
.
..
.
.
. -
.
.. .
.
.
.
)
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
161/232
164
. (
. 6
-.
-.( )
.
..
-.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
162/232
-
165
. .
.
. .
.-.
..
. 7:
.-:
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
163/232
166
25. %
20 20 .
..-:
. .
-:.
:1-:
.2-:
. .
3-:
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
164/232
-
167
.
.4-:
.5-:
.6-:
..
.
.7-:
.8-:
. .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
165/232
168
9-: .
10-:.11-:
.8:
1-: .
.2-:
. 3-: :
.4-:
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
166/232
-
169
5-::
-:--.
6-:
.7-:
.
8-:.
.9-:
.10-:
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
167/232
170
8-:( )
1948 .
-:.
-:
.- :
. - :
.
- : .- :
.-
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
168/232
-
171
- :
.9:
1948.
.
.( )
.
..
.
..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
169/232
172
.
.
.
" .."
.1-
.2-
.3-
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
170/232
-
173
4- :
. .
.
242338
.181
29( )1947
. .....
.181 .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
171/232
174
:
.
-.
.194755%
45. %.
.
:
. .
:-
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
172/232
-
175
- .- .
- .( )
( ).
:-.
-.-.- .
-
.
..
1967 .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
173/232
176
--- - - - - -
.
181 1948.62
.-:
4002.
11002. 181.
..
. ..
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
174/232
-
177
.
.471.10033.991
.2001 505.91 93.3%
6.7. %33 .-:
.32%
3.368.
.4.660.
1948 .
-:
1002.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
175/232
178
.
.
.1948.
.
. . .
2202. 8.104
2343. 78%.
14 .
-:2002
. ..
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
176/232
-
179
.1949 .
.
1947...
.
)652.(
.657635802.966. 54%.
-:
:1- .2-
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
177/232
180
. 1-:
.
.
103.86399.232 4.635 5% 95. %
.
2-:
.-
1947 1947. .
- .-
1947. 652 .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
178/232
-
181
100%
77.440.
- ::1-
.2-.3- .
1-: 1.9002
1947.102 )
.(
. ..
2-:
. .
1947.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
179/232
182
.602.
3-:
202 . . 1947
..
30002
. . ..
.6502.
-. .
..
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
180/232
-
183
- : 1947
..
..
1948.
.
36% 64%
30002..
: 1948-1951
471.100 33.991 001.060 02.308
8.104 2.343 3.580 2.996
99.232 4.635
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
181/232
184
77.240 0 27.340 4.403
687.656 50.376
: 31/12/1998 1998.
:687.656 93.2% 50.376 6.8%
738.032
:( )181
25 1947..
.
.181
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
182/232
-
185
.
..
" ".
.-.
.
-
..
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
183/232
186
." "
.
. .
. .
.. .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
184/232
-
187
1947
181
..
1947 19481967.
1949 .
..
1947 .
. .
)terra nullius.(
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
185/232
188
181 97.
181194. 181 194.
70. %.
.194 181.
70% 181 .
400 .!!
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
186/232
-
189
-. .181.
.." "
. . .
1811947. .
..
1967 1948.
.181.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
187/232
190
181194.
.1947. .
. ) 181(
: ( )
1/1948
::
.: -
- .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
188/232
-
191
-
)3941(-.
:
)39(. : :
. :
.:
) ( )1 (
.( )
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
189/232
192
:: :
: : :
1/1948. :
1/1948.
1/
1948. :
1/1948.
.:
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
190/232
-
193
:: .
. :
.
.
.
. :
.
.:
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
191/232
194
1/1948( )
. :
- - .
: .
:
.: - -
.-
-.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
192/232
-
195
: ""
.
.( )
( )
.
. .
.:
.
: ( )
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
193/232
196
:( )
.:( )
. :( )
.:( )
. :( )
.:
. ( ):
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
194/232
-
197
. :
- -
- -
. :.
- -.
. :
.:
:
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
195/232
198
:
.: :
:( ) .
:( )
. .
:( ) .
..
:( ) .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
196/232
-
199
. :( )
.
. : :
( ): .
:( ) .
:( ) .
:( ) .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
197/232
200
:( )
.:( )
.
..
:( )
.:( )
.
.: :
:( )Citizenship:
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
198/232
-
201
. .
.: :(
)a:( .
.)b:(
. : :( )
)a:(
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
199/232
202
.
)B
:( .
)C:( ) " "Court of Claims(
.)D:(
.: :
:( ) .
. :( )
-- .
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
200/232
-
203
:
:( )
.( ) )1( ) (.
/1948.
:
: :( ) .
.
.
.
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
201/232
204
.
.
.
.- -
.
. -)2( ) (-
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
202/232
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
203/232
206
)a. :( )b :(
)3
. ( 5%
10%
..
.
.
.:
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
204/232
-
207
:
..
--
.:
:( )
) ( )1(.
:( )
.-
-
) 4. (
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
205/232
208
:: A: :
.
. /.
/ /
/ /
- /
.230
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
206/232
-
209
/
./
.
. // /
.
/
./
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
207/232
210
/
.
/.
/ / /
/ /
)(
.
/
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
208/232
-
211
.
./
.
/
./
/ ..150160.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
209/232
212
.
..
.
100
.90 70
/
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
210/232
-
213
.
//
.- -
.:
( ).
..
.
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
211/232
214
:
) ..( : :: :( )
)Corpus Aeparatum(
.
: :( )
. .
: :( )
: )a. :(
::( )
-
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
212/232
-
215
- - -.
:( )
.)b(:
-
.
)100(
..)c: (
:( ) ( )
:( )
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
213/232
216
.
)d: (
:( ) .
:( )
.
:( )
.)e: (
.
VETO
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
214/232
-
217
)f : (
< )g(:
.
.)h(TRANSIT:
.
.)k: (
.) j: (
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
215/232
218
)l: (
)9( ) (.
)n: (
:( - -
.:( )
. :( )
. :( )
.:( )
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
216/232
-
219
:( ) .
- -.
.:( )
.)m: (
:( .
:( )
. :( )
..
. :( )
( )
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
217/232
220
.)o(
:
.
- -
.
.
.:
- -/1948
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
218/232
-
221
..
: :
.
)128(23 1310: ( ) :
.:
.:
.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
219/232
222
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
220/232
-
223
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
221/232
224
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
222/232
-
225
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
223/232
226
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
224/232
-
227
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
225/232
228
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
226/232
-
229
: 1-FAPS Negotiation: Presentation to the Palestinian Delegation
From Israeli Delegation, 22 November 1999 Re: Israeli securityconcerns
2-. 3-. 4-. 5-. 6-Israel National security concerns and Threat Perceptions.
Presented by Israeli Delegation to IGCC workshop on Arms Controland security Improvement in the middle East. February 21-24-2000
Nicosia Cyprus. (M. General Dan Halots)7-. 8-. 9-.
10-. 11-. 12- - 1999- /
127.13-. 14-. 15-The Palestinian vision of Peace and security 22 November
1999. FAPS Negotiation: Presentation to Israeli Delegation.
16-. 17-. 18-Palestinian security concerns Fifth Workshop no Arms control
and security Improvement in the Middle East IGCC of Universityof California. Nicosia Cyprus 2124 February 2000 (M. General
Omar Ashour)19-. 20-. 21-Multilateral Negotiation. Arms Corral and Regional Security
workshops. 22-. 23- -. 24
-. 25-.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
227/232
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
228/232
-
231
60 -. . 61 . " " 62 . 63 . 64
- 6/7 /2007. 65 66 67 . 68 . . 69 -. 70 71 72 73 74 - -1995.75 76 77 78 79 80 81 . 82 -. 83 -. 84 -. 85 . 86 / - 87 . 88 Middle East Papers. Middle East strategy At Harvard89 90 Post-American WorldFareed Zakaria 91-The size of crisis , Dr.Samir Ameen92 93 94 Haman Rights in Palestinian and other occupied Arab Territories Goldston
Mission on the Gaza conflict95 -. 96 Palestine-Israel, An alternative configuration D. Nasser Abu Farha97 . 98- . 1934 1974 . .
.97.
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
229/232
232
1- FAPS Negotiation: Presentation to the PalestinianDelegation From Israeli Delegation, 22 November 1999Re: Israeli security concerns ( )
2- Israel National security concerns and Threat Perceptions.Presented by Israeli Delegation to IGCC workshop onArms Control and security Improvement in the middleEast. February 21-24-2000 Nicosia Cyprus. (M. GeneralDan Halots) ( )
3- - 1999- / 127.
) 5( 4- The Palestinian vision of Peace and security 22 November
1999. FAPS Negotiation: Presentation to IsraeliDelegation. ( )
5- Palestinian security concerns Fifth Workshop no Armscontrol and security Improvement in the Middle EastIGCC of University of California. Nicosia Cyprus 21
24 February 2000 (M. General Omar Ashour) ( )6- Multilateral Negotiation. Arms Control and Regional
Security workshops ( )7- /
- :
) (1995
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
230/232
-
233
8- Permanent Status Negotiation: Special Session on Border
Issues. Report Prepared by the legal unit of P.L.ONegotiation affairs Department 23-12-1999 ( )
9- /
) 2(. . ( ) 1999.
10- . /
2010 11- Getting to Territorial End game of on IsraeliPalestinail.
Peace settlement special Report by Israeli Palestinianworkshop of Baker institute's conflict Resolution Forum.http://www.bakerinstitute.org/publications/BI-pub-IPTerritorialEndgame-020210.pdf
12- International Court of Justice Press Release 2004/289July2004 legal consequences of construction of a wall inoccupied Palestinian Territory http://www.icj-cij.org/presscom/index.php?pr=71&pt=1&p1=6&p2=1
13- / ) 3 (
. 1999 14- -
1991 15- -
1989 16- . . 194
11/12/1948 17-
. 1995
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
231/232
234
18- . .
2003
19- 1995 20- " "
21- --
6-7 /2007
22- JMCC - 1995
23- 1964 24- Middle East Papers. Middle East strategy At Harvard,
http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/mesh/
25- Post-American WorldFareed Zakariahttp://www.cnl.com/documents/Post-American%20World.pdf
26- The size of crisis , Dr.Samir Amin,http://www.ahewar.org/eng/show.art.asp?aid=805
27- Human Rights in Palestinian and other occupied Arab
Territories Goldston Mission on the Gaza conflict,http://www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/hrcouncil/specialsession/9/factfindingmission.htm
28- Alternative Palestinian Agenda Proposal for an Alternativeconfiguration in Palestine-Israel Nasser Abufarha, August2001 www.ap-agenda.org
29- 1923
30- Hani Albasoos (2005) The security and policing of
Palestine, PhD Thesis. University of Bradford, UK
7/31/2019 Middle East Conflict: Conflicting Narratives
232/232
-
31- The OBAMA administration's approach to U.S-Israel's
qualitative military Edge The Brookings InstitutionWashington, D.C Friday, July 16, 2010,
http://www.brookings.edu/events/2010/0716_us_israel_security.aspx
32- Remarks by Robert satloff from the Nixon Center Debate"Israel: Asset or Liability?" July 20, 2010, Jerusalem Post,August 1, 2010
33- - 19471974