Post on 06-Apr-2018
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 1/80
FLORIDA STATE UNIVERSITY
COLLEGE OF ARTS AND SCIENCES
STABILITY AND DEGRADATION PROCESSES OF
ENERGETIC MATERIALS
By
Melissa Mileham
A Dissertation submitted to theDepartment of Chemistry and Biochemistry
in partial fulfillment of therequirements for the degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Degree Awarded:Summer Semester, 2008
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 2/80
The members of the Committee approve the dissertation of Melissa Milehamdefended on July 1, 2008.
______________________________ Albert E. StiegmanProfessor Directing Dissertation
______________________________ Vincent Salters
Outside Committee Member
______________________________ Kenneth GoldsbyCommittee Member
______________________________ John DorseyCommittee Member
Approved:
_______________________________________________________ Joseph Schlenoff, Chair, Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry
The Office of Graduate Studies has verified and approved the above named committee
ii
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 3/80
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
I would like to thank Dr. Albert E. Stiegman for his invaluable guidance and
support throughout my graduate career. Thank you for answering all of my questions and
not laughing (too hard) at all of my mistakes. My experiences in the lab as well as the
people I have met have truly been priceless.
I would also like to thank Dr. Lambertus J. van de Burgt for sharing even just a
fraction of your knowledge about lasers with me. I really appreciate all of your help and
guidance over the last couple of years.
Dr. Michael P. Kramer, thank you for not only providing funding for my research,
but always having an active role in it as well. Thank you for giving me this opportunity,
and I can honestly say that there was never a dull moment. Surprising yes, but never dull.Also, many thanks to all of the staff members, especially the machine and glass
shop, without whom some of my work would not have even been possible.
iii
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 4/80
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Acknowledgments……..…………………………………………………………………iii
List of Tables ……………………………………………………………………………..v
List of Figures ……………………………………………………………………………viList of Abbreviations ………………………………………………………………….....ix
Abstract …………………………………………………………………………………...x
INTRODUCTION…..…………………………………………………………………….1
GENERAL EXPERIMENTAL …………………………………………………………..6
1. SURFACE STABILITY AND DEGRADATION STUDIES OF TNT ON METAL
OXIDES……………………………………………………………….…………………13
2. SURFACE STABILITY AND DEGRADATION STUDIES OF PETN ON METAL
OXIDES………………………………………………………………………………….28
3. LASER INITIATION PROCESSES IN THERMITE ENERGETIC MATERIALS
STUDIED BY A LASER DESORPTION IONIZATION (LDI) TECHNIQUE………..41
4. PHOTO-THERMAL INIATION PROCESSES OF ORGANIC-INORGANIC
HYBRID METASTABLE INTERSTITIAL COMPOSITE (MIC) MATERIALS……..53
SUMMARY……………………………………………………………………………...64
REFERENCES…………………………………………………………………………..66
BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH…………………………………………………………….70
iv
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 5/80
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1. TNT coverage levels on metal oxides surveyed………………………………..17
Table 2. Surface coverage of PETN on each metal oxide……………………………….32
Table 3. Effects of PETN on heat and energy given off by MIC composites…………...54
v
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 6/80
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1. Molecular structures of common high energy materials………………………..2
Figure 2. Schematic of an isocratic pumping system in HPLC…………………………...7
Figure 3. FT-IR spectrometer schematic………………………………………………….9
Figure 4. Principle of the MALDI process………………………………………………10
Figure 5. Scheme of a time-of-flight mass spectrometer………………………………...11
Figure 6. The four-level pumping system of the Nd:YAG laser………………………...12
Figure 7. Percent decomposition over time of TNT deposited on various metal oxidesubstrates…………………………………………………………………………………17
Figure 8. Differential scanning calorimetry trace of pure TNT………………………….19
Figure 9. DSC of a) 1.4 and b) 4 monolayers of TNT deposited on MnO2……………...20
Figure 10. DSC of a) 1 monolayer and b) 4 monolayers of TNT deposited onCuO………………………………………………………………………………………20
Figure 11. DSC traces of TNT deposited on KBr, LiF, and SiO2………………………..21
Figure 12. HPLC chromatograms of the products of 1.4 monolayer of TNT deposited onMnO
2(a) initially and at 50 °C for (b) 16 (c) 24 and (d) 42 days……………………….23
Figure 13. HPLC chromatograms of the products of 1 monolayer of TNT deposited onCuO (a) initially and at 50 ˚C for (b) 31 (c) 39 and (d) 58 days…………………………23
Figure 14. (a) Gas chromatogram showing two principle components at 11.83 and 11.9minutes whose mass spectra identify them as (b) trinitrobenzene and (c) unreactedTNT………………………………………………………………………………………25
Figure 15. Plot of the decomposition data of TNT on MnO2 over time fit to equation2…......................................................................................................................................26
Figure 16. The evolution of a brown gas from PETN on the surface of MoO3 after beingstored at 50 °C……………………………………………………………………………33
Figure 17. Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) of pure PETN with a vented sample pan (note exothermic processes are above the baseline)………………………………...34
vi
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 7/80
Figure 18. DSC of (a) <2, (b) 2, and (c) 6 monolayer coverage of PETN deposited onnano-scale MoO3................................................................................................................36
Figure 19. DSC of (a) <2, (b) 2, and (c) 6 monolayer coverage of PETN deposited onmicron-scale MoO3………………………………………………………………………37
Figure 20. DSC traces of PETN deposited on (a) SiO2 and (b) KBr…………………….37
Figure 21. Percent PETN remaining on MoO3 vs. time…………………………………38
Figure 22. FT-IR spectroscopy of PETN on the surface of MoO3 at 100 ˚C after a) 1, b) 5,c) 24, d) 27.5, and e) 46 hours (♦=CO2, ▲=N2O, =N2O4, =NO2)…………………39
Figure 23. SEM images of (a) 50 nm, (b) 100 nm, and (c) micron-scale aluminum particles…………………………………………………………………………………..43
Figure 24. LDI-TOF mass spectra of 50 nm aluminum at a laser energy density of (a)1.74 and (b) 1.90 J/cm2…………………………………………………………………..45
Figure 25. Aluminum ions formed at a laser energy of 1.90 J/cm2 for each aluminum particle size………………………………………………………………………………47
Figure 26. Major aluminum ions formed ([Al]+ + [Al2]+ + [Al2O]+) for each particle size
at increasing energy densities……………………………………………………………48
Figure 27. LDI-TOF mass spectra of iron(III) oxide at a laser density of (a) 1.58 and (b)1.74 J/cm2………………………………………………………………………………..49
Figure 28. LDI-TOF mass spectra of thermite mixtures at a laser energy density of (a)1.42, (b) 1.58, (c) 1.74, and (d) 1.90 J/cm2………………………………………………51
Figure 29. Relative amounts of pure iron cluster species formed during laser desorptionof the Fe2O3 control and thermite samples at an energy density of 2.054 J/cm2………...51
Figure 30. Mixed Al/Fe oxide species formed at an energy density of 2.054 J/cm 2 for 50and 100 nm and micron aluminum thermite mixtures…………………………………...52
Figure 31. Photo-thermal initiation of Fe2O3/100 nm Al samples with increasing amountsof PETN at 1064 nm (arrow indicates the position of the laser plume emission)……….57
Figure 32. Initiation time (ms) as a function of PETN coverage in mg at 1064 nm……..57
Figure 33. Deflagration duration time (ms) as a function of the amount of PETN at 1064nm………………………………………………………………………………………..58
vii
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 8/80
Figure 34. Initiation time of Al/Fe2O3 MIC materials with various concentrations of PETN initiated with a single pulse of 532 nm radiation…………………………………61
Figure 35. Energy density (J/cm2) required in order to initiate the thermite/PETN mixtureat 1064 nm………………………………………………………………………………..62
viii
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 9/80
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS
TNT 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene
TNB trinitrobenzene
RDX hexahydro-1,3,5-trinitro-1,3,5-triazine (Royal DemolitioneXplosive)
HMX octahydro-1,3,5,7-tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocine (High Molecular weight rdX)
PETN pentaerythritol tetranitrate
MIC metastable interstitial composite
LDI/TOF MS laser desorption ionization time-of-fight mass spectrometry
BET Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (mathematical formulation for surfacearea anaylsis)
YAG yttrium aluminum garnet (common garnet crystal used in lasers)
FE-SEM field emission scanning electron microscopy
DSC differential scanning calorimetry
TGA thermogravimetric analysis
HPLC high-performance liquid chromatography
GC-MS gas chromatography – mass spectrometry
FID flame ionization detector
FT-IR fourier-transform infrared
ix
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 10/80
ABSTRACT
The use of binary inorganic solid-state fuel/oxidant redox processes typified by
the classic aluminum/iron(III) oxide thermite reaction in combination with traditional
energetic materials such as 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT), hexahydro-1,3,5-trinitro-1,3,5-triazine (RDX), and octahydro-1,3,5,7-tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocine (HMX) has been of
interest in order to produce higher output explosives. This dissertation focuses on the
stability and degradation processes that occur with the combination of binary inorganic
fuel/oxidant systems with high energy materials. First is a discussion on the stability of
2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) as well as pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) deposited onto
the surface of metal oxides through a wet impregnation technique, which is followed by a
discussion of the study of the initiation processes of the aluminum/iron(III) oxide
thermite reaction using laser induced desorption-ionization time-of-flight mass
spectrometry. Finally, the photo-thermal initiation of an aluminum/iron(III) oxide
thermite with PETN deposited on the surface of the iron(III) oxide in increasing
increments was studied using a single pulse of a Nd:YAG laser at differing wavelengths
in order to understand the effects of the presence of PETN on the time to initiation, as
well as the deflagration duration of the thermite reaction.
x
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 11/80
INTRODUCTION
Stability and Degradation Processes of TNT and PETN on Metal Oxides
Recently there has been a new approach to the fabrication of high output
explosives and pyrotechnics in which binary inorganic solid-state reactive materials are
used in combination with traditional organic high energy explosives such as 2,4,6-
trinitrotoluene (TNT); hexahydro-1,3,5-trinitro-1,3,5-triazine (RDX); octahydro-1,3,5,7-
tetranitro-1,3,5,7-tetrazocine (HMX); and pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) as shown in
figure 1. The binary inorganic materials are typified by the classic thermite reaction
(equation 1), where a stoichiometric amount of a metal (fuel) and a metal oxide (oxidant)
are mixed and a highly exothermic redox reaction occurs.
Fe2O3 + 2Al Al2O3 + 2Fe ΔH = 3.97 kJ/g (1)
These binary inorganic materials have the advantage of having a high energy
density, in fact several times higher than that of a traditional high energy material.
However, the rate of energy release is much slower than that of conventional explosives
making it difficult to exploit these materials for explosive purposes. Therefore, in order to
overcome this problem, new composite materials have been developed in which the
binary inorganic systems are combined with conventional explosives such as TNT, PETN,RDX, and HMX. Thus the energy release in these combined systems is driven by the
conventional explosive, resulting in a rapid release of energy in a controlled fashion.
Previous studies have indicated that the combination of these hybrid organic/inorganic
materials provides great promise in the exploitation of the high energy density provided
by the binary inorganic mixtures. TNT, for example, has been combined with various
oxidant phases and fuels such as MnO2 and Al as well as Al-Zr and Mg-Al alloys for use
as high energy density explosives for high penetration applications and as components for
boosters and primers.1-3 PETN, on the other hand, has been studied with binary inorganic
materials where Al, Al alloys, and Zr have been used as fuels and Pb 3O4, Fe2O3, and
MnO3 have been used as the oxidant for their use as boosters and primers as well as their
use in a laser initiated system.2, 4
1
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 12/80
Figure 1. Molecular structures of common high energy materials
There is one problem that exists in the incorporation of conventional organic high
energy explosives with fuel/oxidant binary inorganic mixtures, however, in that there is a
possibility that an inherent incompatibility between the inorganic and organic phases may
occur. This incompatibility arises from the deleterious surface chemistry between the
organic material and the metal or metal oxide phase in the composite, which may arise
from an interfacial chemical process that may occur either as a reduction at the surface of
the metal or an oxidation at the surface of the oxide. The magnitude of these processes
may be affected by the degree of contact that occurs between the organic materials and
the metal or metal oxide surfaces, as well as the temperature, humidity, and other ambient
conditions of the storage and handling of these systems.
The chemical stability of both TNT and PETN when deposited onto the surface of metal oxides such as MnO2, CuO, WO3, MoO3, Bi2O3, SnO2, and Fe2O3 has been
investigated and is reported hereafter. In order to imitate storage conditions of such
materials, the samples were placed in an oven set at 50 °C, periodically removing
aliquots to be analyzed chromatographically in order to determine if a decomposition of
the energetic materials had occurred at the surface of the oxide. In a case where
2
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 13/80
degradation of the energetic material occurred, subsequent studies were completed to
understand the degradation process as well as any products that are produced at the
surface of the oxide.
Laser Initiation Processes of Thermite Energetic Materials Using Laser Desorption
Ionization (LDI)
The traditional thermite reaction (equation 1) in which stoichiometric amounts of
aluminum and iron oxide react to form aluminum oxide and iron metal has become a
great interest in the production of high energy materials due to their high energy density.
However, these materials have not been broadly useful due to slow mass-transport
processes of the reaction, which leads to a slower energy release and subsequently alower obtained power. It has recently been determined though that the energetic
properties of these binary inorganic materials may be enhanced by having at least one of
the components in the mixture of nanometer size, usually the fuel. The nano-scale fuel
causes a more intimate contact between the fuel and the oxidizer, which enhances the
mass-transport and therefore leads to an increase in power in these materials known as
metastable interstitial composites (MIC).5, 6
The thermite reaction is highly exothermic and thermal initiation of the reaction
occurs at high temperatures once the melting point of one of the components, typically
the metal has been achieved.7 This initiation begins the reactive processes which liberate
heat causing the reaction to accelerate. Ignition of the reaction occurs once the reaction
becomes self-sustaining and propagates. The incident laser energy put into a sample for
laser initiation causes high localized heating to occur, which then leads to ignition of the
bulk sample. The time to ignition is defined as the time at which the energy released by
the reaction becomes greater than or equal to the energy put into the composite by the
laser. Both the laser excitation event and the subsequent ignition and propagation are
extremely high temperature events, which generate both liquid and gas phase (plasma)
species. The chemical reactions occurring within and between these phases as well as
with the solid material all contribute to the net combustion process. This complexity and
the fact that the reaction occurs so quickly has made it difficult to observe the species
3
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 14/80
formed during the reaction other than the final products and therefore thoroughly
understand the reaction. Recently, however, this has been addressed by Dlott et al. by
using time-resolved spectroscopy, where a reaction between aluminum and nitrocellulose
was initiated by flash-heating the mixture with a 100 ps laser pulse in the near infrared.8, 9
Short-pulse photo-thermal initiation allows for the use of time-resolved spectroscopic
techniques in order to monitor reaction dynamics, interpret some of the intermediate
species of the reaction, and to observe specific structural changes in the reactive
components. Time-resolved studies of the combustion of Al/MoO3 MIC composites have
been studied and have identified neutral species such as AlO that form in the process.10
Previous studies of standard binary fuel/oxidant systems have involved
thermochemical measurements such as temperature profiles, burn rates, and non-
isothermal calorimetry (DSC, DTA, and TGA).11-13 Recent studies of MIC materials haveused laser-induced photo-thermal initiation of binary inorganic systems in order to
determine properties such as ignition time and burn rate as well as study the effect of
particle size on combustion properties. Pantoya et al. studied the combustion velocities
and ignition times of an Al/MoO3 thermite system with varying aluminum particle
diameter by observing the reaction over time using high-speed cameras.14, 15 A similar
study on the ignition process of a magnesium and barium oxide pyrotechnic mixture were
completed by Östmark et al. where the mixture was initiated using a CO2
laser and the
subsequent ignition process was observed using high-speed photography which was
synchronized with the laser pulse.16 Each study found that the combustion properties of
binary inorganic mixtures is dependant upon the particle size of the fuel.
The use of photo-thermal laser initiation coupled with time-of-flight mass
spectrometry (LDI/TOF MS) in order to directly observe the ionic species formed in the
plasma phase of both conventional Al/Fe2O3 thermite and the corresponding MIC
materials is discussed. Though this does not show the reaction to completion, the species
formed in the plasma allows for the study of the reactive processes of various aluminum
sizes in the reaction. This may be the first use of this technique to characterize reactive
species in the initiation phase of binary inorganic reactions.
4
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 15/80
Photo-thermal Initiation Processes of Hybrid Organic/Inorganic Metastable Interstitial
Composite (MIC) Materials
Two approaches used separately or in tandem have been devised in order to
overcome the slow energy release found in binary inorganic materials compared to that of
traditional energetic materials. One is the development of metastable interstitial
composite (MIC) materials in which one of the components (typically the fuel) is of
nanoscale dimensions. Improvements in the rate of energy release are generally attributed
to better mixing of the components and a more intimate fuel/oxidant contact. 5,6 Another
approach, applied to conventional (i.e. micron scale) thermite-type compositions as well
at to MIC materials, is to mix traditional organic high-energy materials such as 2,4,6-
trinitrotoluene (TNT); hexahydro-1,3,5-trinitro-1,3,5-triazine (RDX); and pentaerythritoltetranitrate (PETN) into the inorganic system to form an organic/inorganic composite. In
these systems the energy release of the binary fuel/oxide system is driven by the
conventional explosive, thereby releasing energy much more rapidly and in a controlled
fashion. Studies to date have indicated that this approach affords great promise in
exploiting the high energy density provided by binary inorganic energetic compositions.1-
4
It was determined from thermal analysis studies that depositions of at least 6
monolayers resulted in thermal properties for the decomposition of the organic species
that were the same as the bulk. This suggests that even in small amounts incorporation of
the organic phase may result in observable changes in the energy release properties of the
composite, which are amenable to laboratory study. We report here a study of the energy
release dynamics of the Al/Fe2O3 MIC materials with depositions of 16-127.9 mg of
PETN per gram of thermite. The study is carried out using short pulse (ns) photo-thermal
initiation, with the dynamics of the process studied by time-resolved spectroscopic
techniques.
5
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 16/80
GENERAL EXPERIMENTAL
Liquid Chromatography
Liquid Chromatography (LC) is an analytical technique where the components of
a mixture are separated in solution at room temperature. It is one of the most commonly
used separation techniques due to its versatility in that there are two interactive phases
(stationary and mobile phases) and this interaction may be altered in order to change the
selectivity of the system. Each component in a mixture should interact differently with
each of the two phases causing a separation to occur. The time it takes each component to
travel through the column to the detector is the retention time and is what allows for the
characterization of the species. High Performance Liquid Chromatography (HPLC)describes a liquid chromatography technique where the mobile phase is mechanically
pumped through a column containing the stationary phase; therefore, the instrument
consists of an injector, pump, column, and detector (figure 2). Reversed-phase
chromatography is the most widely used technique and is used to separate neutral
molecules by their degree of hydrophobicity. The typical stationary phase has an organic
functional group such as –CH3, -C4H9, -C8H17 and –C18H37 chemically attached to silica.
The functional group affects the retention time, which increases exponentially with chain
length, as well as the column selectivity and efficiency. The typical mobile phases used in
reversed-phase chromatography include a polar solvent, usually water, which is mixed
with a slightly less polar solvent such as methanol or acetonitrile. The polarity of the
solvent is inversely proportional to its eluting strength and the mixture used as the mobile
phase is chosen to give the desired separation.17, 18
6
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 17/80
Figure 2. Schematic of an isocratic pumping system in HPLC
Gas Chromatography - Mass Spectroscopy
Gas chromatography is a method used for separating and analyzing mixtures of
volatile compounds. Similar to liquid chromatography, gas chromatography takes
advantage of varying interactions occurring between each component and the two phases
(stationary and mobile). The main difference, however, is that gas chromatography uses a
gas as a mobile phase, and therefore in order to use this technique all components must
be volatile and thermally stable making it somewhat more limited than liquid
chromatography. Due to the fact that there is little interaction between the molecules ingas phase, the mobile phase primarily acts as a way to move the components through the
system and thus the distribution equilibria of the components is determined by their vapor
pressure and sorption by the stationary phase. Since vapor pressure plays a key role in the
separation, the column must be heated to a temperature high enough to provide an
appropriate analysis time. The most commonly used carrier gases are helium and
nitrogen; however, argon, hydrogen, and carbon dioxide may also be used. The carrier
gas is determined by its compatibility with the detector of the system, which in this study
a flame ionization detector (FID) was used due to its ability to detect organic molecules.
The column can either be a packed column or a capillary open tubular column, each with
its advantages and several options for stationary phases which will depend on the types of
solutes being separated. The gas chromatograph can also be coupled to a mass
spectrometer, which ionizes the components and subsequently separates and detects them
7
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 18/80
based on their mass-to-charge (m/z) ratio. This feature allows the confirmation of the
identity of each analyte in a mixture as well as any unknowns.19, 20
Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC)
Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) is a thermal analysis technique that
measures the heat flow associated with thermally driven endothermic or exothermic
transitions in a material. The DSC is capable of giving thermodynamic information such
as phase changes, melting, crystallization, product stability, and oxidative stability. Two
identical pans, one reference and one containing the sample, are placed on platforms that
are connected to individual furnaces. In a general experiment, the two pans are
simultaneously heated at a specific rate, typically not more than 20 ˚C/min, measuring thedifference in heat flow between the sample pan and the reference pan. The result is a plot
of heat flow versus temperature on which the features correspond either to an absorption
or release of energy in the sample upon heating due to either phase transitions or a
decomposition of the material.21
Gas Physisorption
Gas adsorption/desorption techniques are used in order to find characteristics of
porous materials such as surface area, pore size, and pore volume. Nitrogen gas is used at
incrementally higher pressures to dose a sample at liquid nitrogen temperatures. This
known dosing pressure is compared to a measured actual pressure, the difference between
which yields the amount of gas adsorbed by the sample. An isotherm plot is given by
plotting the measured volumes of adsorbed gas versus the relative pressure at which these
adsorptions took place. There are six classifications of physisorption isotherms, each of
which indicate the different adsorbent-adsorbate interactions. The first few points of the
isotherm are used to calculate the surface area, typically using a mathematical equation
developed by Brunauer, Emmett, and Teller (BET), while other equations are used to
calculate the pore size and volume.22
8
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 19/80
Fourier-Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FT-IR)
Fourier-transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy is a technique used for observing
the vibrations of the atoms in a molecule. It has become a very versatile technique, in that
almost any type of sample can be used, e.g. liquids, powders, films, gases, and surfaces.
The spectrum is obtained by using an interferometer, where radiation from the source
passes through before hitting the sample, in which interference of radiation between two
beams produces the transmitted beam to the sample at 90° from the input beam. The
fraction of incident radiation that is absorbed by the sample at a particular energy is then
determined and is converted to an absorbance spectrum using a fourier transformation
process. A schematic of the instrument is shown in figure 3.23
Figure 3. FT-IR spectrometer schematic
Laser Desorption Ionization Time-of-Flight Mass Spectrometry (LDI-TOF MS)
Matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry
(MALDI-TOF MS) is a technique that is most often used for, but not limited to, the
analysis of biomolecules because significant decomposition of the fragile molecules does
not occur and large mass ranges can be detected. MALDI-TOF mass spectrometry allows
species to be converted from the solid phase to gas-phase ions with little fragmentation
due to the simultaneous vaporization and ionization processes. Since these processesoccur in a single step, it is referred to as a desorption/ionization technique. This single-
step process is accomplished because the samples are placed under a vacuum of at least
10-6 torr, which allows the sample to sublime directly into the ion source with little or no
heating.24
9
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 20/80
The sample is usually mixed in a large excess of a matrix compound, which is
typically a weak acid that absorbs light readily at the wavelength of the laser. The sample
is then deposited onto the solid surface of the target, which is made out of a conducting
metal, most often stainless steel. The mixtures used in this case act as a matrix
themselves, and thus a typical matrix is not needed. Therefore, small holes were drilled
into the sample plate into which the mixture was tightly packed in order to ensure that the
sample would stay in place, especially under a high vacuum and the process itself is
referred to as laser desporption ionization (LDI) mass spectrometry. Once the proper
vacuum is reached, the sample may be hit with a brief laser pulse. The irradiated spot is
rapidly heated by the laser energy and becomes vibrationally excited, which results in a
portion of the deposited sample’s surface to be released from the irradiated spot, allowing
the matrix to carry a portion of the analyte into the vapor phase with little or no heating asillustrated by figure 4.24, 25
Since the LDI is equipped with a time-of-flight mass spectrometer each of the
accelerated ions from the source has a different velocity, which is based off of the mass
and charge of the ion. The accelerated ions then move from the source into the drift
region of the analyzer where the different velocities separate the ions in order to keep
them from hitting the detector at the same time. The now mass separated ions hit the
detector region, where they are counted, giving rise to a specific signal for each m/z value
proportional to the number of ions present, producing a mass spectrum.(figure 5). 24
Figure 4. Principle of the MALDI process (Wilkins et al., 2006).
10
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 21/80
Figure 5. Scheme of a time-of-flight mass spectrometer (Wilkins et al., 2006).
Nd:YAG Laser
The Nd:YAG laser uses a neodynium yttrium-aluminum-garnet (Y3Al5O12)
crystal, a common lasing medium for solid-state lasers, where a small amount (~1 %) of
yttrium ions are replaced by neodynium ions in the crystal structure. A flashlamp is used
to excite the neodynium electrons from the ground state and upon relaxation a slow decay
back to the ground state results in a dominant fluorescence around 1064 nm with a slow
decay time (ms), which results in the laser action. The neodynium ion actually has a four-
level pumping system with several different laser transitions that result in fastnonradiative decay to the upper laser level (E2). A simplified version of this system is
shown in figure 6 in which level 4 (E3) represents the combination of all the levels above
the upper laser level in the real atomic system. Level 3 (E2) is the upper laser level and
usually is a long-lived level, while level 2 (E1) is the lower laser level and level 1 (Eo)
represents the ground level The laser may be operated both in a pulsed or continuous
mode. If the laser is pulsed, it is most often operated in the Q-switching mode, which is
an optical switch that opens once the maximum population inversion of the neodynium
ions is acquired, allowing the light wave to run through the cavity, depopulating the
excited laser medium and resulting in a laser pulse. This pulse is less than ten
nanoseconds and gives an output power of 20 mW.26
11
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 22/80
Figure 6. The four-level pumping system of the Nd:YAG laser
12
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 23/80
CHAPTER 1
SURFACE STABILITY AND DEGRADATION STUDIES OF TNT ON METAL
OXIDES
Introduction
An important issue related to the incorporation of such conventional organic high-
energy materials with metal/metal oxide binary compositions is one of inherent
incompatibility between the organic and inorganic phases. This incompatibility arises
from deleterious surface chemistry between the organic and metal or metal oxide phases
in the composite. These deleterious processes arise from interfacial chemical processesincluding, but not limited to, reduction at the metals (fuel) surface and oxidation at the
oxide surface. The magnitude of these processes will likely be exacerbated by the degree
of contact between the organic materials and the metal or metal oxide surfaces and will
be affected by temperature, humidity, and other ambient conditions of storage and
handling.
The chemical stability of 2,4,6-trinitritoluene (TNT) when placed in physical
contact with metal oxide surfaces was investigated. The TNT was deposited at 1-3
monolayers of coverage on the surface of microcrystalline MnO2, CuO, WO3, MoO3,
Bi2O3, SnO2, and Fe2O3 by wet impregnation techniques. The samples were placed in a
50 °C oven and allowed to react over a period of ten months. Periodically, a small portion
of the sample was removed and analyzed chromatographically to determine if products
were being formed at the surface of the oxide. TNT proved to be inert to most oxides;
however, both CuO and MnO2 effected a clean decomposition of the TNT molecule to
trinitrobenzene (TNB).
13
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 24/80
Experimental
Materials
MnO2 (Aldrich, reagent grade, >90% purity, ~10mm particle size), CuO (Aldrich,
nanopowder, ~33 nm), Fe2O3 (Fisher, anhydrous), MoO3 (nano- and micron-scale,
Climax Molybdenum), SnO2 (Keeling & Walker Ltd.), WO3 (Atlantic Equipment
Engineering) and Bi2O3 (Aldrich) were used as received from the manufacturer. 2,4,6-
Trinitrotoluene (TNT) was obtained from Chemservice and sublimed prior to use.
Acetonitrile (Acros, reagent grade) and methanol (EMD Chemicals, HPLC grade) was
also used as received.
Long-term surface reactivity studies
Samples for long-term reactivity studies were prepared using a wet impregnation
technique. Sixty milligrams of TNT, dissolved in acetonitrile, was slurried with one gram
of the metal oxide, after which the acetonitrile was removed under vacuum (10 -3 torr) in
order to leave a dry powder of the oxide with TNT deposited onto its surface. The
approximate coverage area of TNT is 986 m2/g, which is based on the estimated area of a
TNT molecule obtained from treating the molecule as a disk with the outer circumference
defined by the oxygen atoms of the nitro groups (obtained from the crystal structure of
1,3-dinitrotoluene) with a radius extending from the center of the aromatic ring.27
Sealed containers containing the samples were placed in an oven held at 50 °C.
Periodically, a small portion of the powder (~0.10 g) was withdrawn and stirred into one
milliliter of acetonitrile. The solids were allowed to settle and the supernatant liquid
containing the organic species was removed and analyzed by HPLC using a 60:40
H2O/CH3OH solution as the mobile phase. The presence of new compounds formed from
interfacial chemistry was evident in the chromatogram by comparison to the control
samples using a UV detector set to 254 nm. The percent degradation was determined
from the ratio of the integrated peak area of the TNT in the HPLC with the sum of all the
peak areas. For samples that showed only minimal degradation, no attempt was made to
determine the products. For oxides that induced a significant amount of decomposition
the product was characterized by GC-MS.
14
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 25/80
BET surface area analysis
The surface area of each metal oxide used in the survey was found by BET
methods using a Micromeretics ASAP 2020 physisorption surface area and porosity
analyzer. Approximately 0.25 g of each metal oxide was placed in a sample tube and was
degassed under a vacuum of 20 µmHg at 90 °C for sixty minutes in order to remove any
water from the sample. A subsequent heating at 340 °C for 240 minutes was performed in
order to completely degas the material. The analysis was performed at liquid nitrogen
temperatures in order to obtain the surface area for each metal oxide.
HPLC
Liquid chromatography experiments were performed on a Beckman Coulter System Gold HPLC equipped with a 125 Solvent Module, 166 Detector and 508
Autosampler using a Beckman C18 column that is 250 x 4.6 mm. The detector was set at
254 nm in order to detect any organic compounds that may be present. A flow rate of
0.75 mL/min was used for the mobile phase, an isocratic mixture of 60:40 H2O/methanol.
The chromatogram was taken over a period of 30 minutes, allowing all compounds time
to travel through the column. TNT appears at approximately 18 minutes at this flow rate,
assuming only degradation products of the TNT molecule occur, they should elute faster
through the column due to their smaller size.
GC-MS
The GC-MS data were collected on an Agilent 6890+ GC coupled with an HP
5973 MSD (mass selective detector). The GC was equipped with a DB-5 capillary
column which had a length of 30 meters and an i.d. of 0.25 μm using helium as the carrier
gas with a flow rate of 1.5 mL/min. The oven temperature ramp was set as isothermal at
140 ˚C and the injector and detector temperatures were set to 200 and 250 ˚C,
respectively. The detector used was a flame ionization detector (FID), which is used
primarily for organic compounds due to its ability to easily detect hydrocarbons. The
sample was also ionized and analyzed by mass (m/z) in the mass selective detector. The
source of the MSD was set at 100 ˚C. This allows the mass of any of the degradation
15
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 26/80
products of TNT corresponding to elution time through the gas chromatogram to be
determined as well as the products themselves to be identified.
Thermal Analysis
Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) was performed on a TA Instruments
Q1000 DSC under both O2 and an inert N2 environment. Samples were prepared using
the wet impregnation technique as described above. A two milliliter aliquot of TNT (0.13
M in acetonitrile) was added to one gram of MnO2 or CuO and the solvent was removed
under vacuum. The dry powder containing TNT deposited onto the surface of the metal
oxide was then analyzed using a scan rate of 10 °C/min with a pin prick in the pan in
order to vent the sample pan. When the sample is analyzed in a sealed container, the
decomposition becomes a deflagration event with an abrupt release of energy. Samples of pure TNT and TNT deposited on the surface of inert materials such as silica gel and KBr
as well as LiF were prepared and analyzed under the same conditions in order to
differentiate surface chemistry specific to the metal oxides.
Results and Discussion
Degradation studies
The long-term degradation studies were designed to simulate long-term ambient
storage of multicomponent high-energy materials where TNT would be in intimate
contact with metal oxide surfaces. Relatively low concentrations (~1-3.5 monolayers) of
TNT were deposited onto the oxide surfaces to isolate specific interfacial chemistry and
to allow sensitive detection of reaction products relative to the TNT (i.e. without the
chromatogram being overwhelmed by a large amount of TNT). Table 1 shows the oxides
surveyed in the study and their TNT surface coverage in the prepared samples.
16
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 27/80
Table 1. TNT coverage levels on metal oxides surveyed
Metal Oxide BET Surface Area (m2/g) TNT coverage(equivalent monolayers)
MnO2 40 1.5
CuO 32 1.9WO3 17 3.5
MoO3 (large) 25 2.4
MoO3 (nano) 55 1.1
Bi2O3 26 2.3
SnO2 21 2.8
Fe2O3 33 1.8
A chromatogram of the samples was taken immediately upon preparation to
establish the initial purity. They were then placed in a 50 °C oven under the ambient
atmosphere and allowed to react over the course of approximately eleven months with
samples withdrawn periodically over that time and analyzed by HPLC. The amount of
decomposition of the TNT over time for each oxide surface where a measurable
decomposition is observed is shown in figure 7.
` 2 4
3 2
4 2 5
9 8 5 9
8 1 6 8 1
9 0 2 5
3 3 0 9
M n O 2
C u O
F e 2 O 3
S n O 2
B i 2 O 3
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
Percent Decomposition
time (days)
Percent Decomposition of TNT on Metal Oxides
Figure 7. Percent decomposition over time of TNT deposited on various metal oxidesubstrates
17
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 28/80
TNT proved to be inert or slightly reactive on the majority of the oxide surfaces.
In particular, no detectable decomposition was observed for MoO3 and WO3. As
indicated in figure 7, small amounts of decomposition (<10 %) were observed for Bi2O3,
Fe2O3, and SnO2 over the duration of the study. For two of the oxides, CuO and MnO 2,
more extensive decomposition was observed with 21 % of the TNT consumed over CuO
and essentially complete (100 %) consumption observed for MnO2. For the case of CuO,
the decomposition reached its maximum after about one month (figure 7), but did not
react further after that. This result suggests that this reaction is stoichiometric with a
specific surface site, which, once consumed, ceases to react further. Conversely, for
MnO2, the reaction proceeds to completion suggesting either a large amount of surface
sites on the MnO2 or that the reaction is catalytic. An important aspect of TNT reactivity
on both of these surfaces is that the HPLC data indicates that the reaction is quite clean,going primarily to a discrete product of trinitrobenzene as opposed to decomposition into
multiple species with MnO2 being somewhat cleaner than the CuO. Moreover, based on a
comparison of the retention times, the product is the same for both oxides.
Reactivity of TNT on MnO2
Thermal analysis. The thermal analysis of pure TNT using differential scanning
calorimetry (DSC) is shown in figure 8. The thermal scan shows a sharp endotherm at
80 °C, which corresponds to the melting and an exotherm, whose observed peak at this
scan rate (10 °C/min) is at 306 °C, that corresponds to the decomposition of the molecule.
This thermal decomposition process has been studied previously and was found to
initially involve oxidation of the methyl group but, even in the early stages of the reaction,
it is quite complex and ultimately yields telomeric or polymeric materials.28-31 When
considering composites of TNT with inorganic oxides, the effect of the organic-inorganic
interface on these well-known thermal processes is of interest. The DSC plot of TNT
deposited at approximately 1.4 monolayer loadings on MnO2 is shown in figure 9. At
18
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 29/80
Figure 8. Differential scanning calorimetry trace of pure TNT (note that the exothermic processes are above the baseline)
these coverage levels, the melting endotherm is not observed. This result is expected
since no crystalline bulk phase is present. More importantly, however, the thermaldecomposition process occurs at 229 °C, which is significantly lower than the bulk.
When the amount of TNT is increased to >4 monolayers, two exothermic processes are
observed, one whose peak is close to that resolved in the bulk (321 °C) and a low
temperature exothermic process at 278 °C. Our preliminary interpretation of this complex
thermal behavior is that it represents the superposition of interfacial and bulk processes
observable at the higher loadings of TNT though it may reflect a more complex
decomposition process than is initiated at the surface. A similar, but less dramatic,
interfacial effect is observed on CuO with monolayer coverage yielding decomposition
exotherms at 211 °C and 294 °C due to the interfacial effect of the CuO, while excess
loadings showing interfacial and bulk decomposition at 294 and 318 °C respectively
(figure 10).
19
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 30/80
Figure 9. DSC of a) 1.4 and b) 4 monolayers of TNT deposited on MnO2
Figure 10. DSC of a) 1 monolayer and b) 4 monolayers of TNT deposited on CuO
20
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 31/80
It is important to determine whether the interfacial mediation of the
decomposition temperature is specific to those oxides or constituted a general surface
effect. Thermal analysis of monolayers of TNT deposited on inert oxides and salts
indicates that in almost all cases the decomposition temperature is modified (figure 11).
On fumed silica the decomposition temperature is very close to that of the bulk at
310.8 °C indicating that the silica surface is inert. Interestingly, on simple salts the
interfacial effect is pronounced. Specifically, LiF shows a decomposition temperature of
293.0 °C while KBr shows an even stronger surface effect with a decomposition
temperature of 270.9 °C.
These results do not provide a chemical rationale for the interfacial effect, nor do
they provide any specifics on the decomposition pathway(s) on the surface. However, it
is clear from the thermal analysis data that there is a pronounced and surprisingly generalsurface effect between TNT and solid surfaces. This effect might well mitigate energy
release processes or affect long-term stability of heterogeneous composite mixtures.
Figure 11. DSC traces of TNT deposited on KBr, LiF, and SiO2 (note exotherms areabove the line).
21
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 32/80
Kinetics and product analysis. Reaction processes and decomposition pathways of
trinitrotoluene deposited on the surface of microcrystalline MnO2 were monitored by
HPLC. Initial chromatographic data shows only a sharp peak at a retention time (RT) of
18.57 minutes, which is assigned to TNT itself by comparison to a standard solution of
TNT in acetonitrile (figure 12). No other significant products were observed. The
samples were kept at a constant temperature of 50 °C and reanalyzed after 16 days. The
chromatogram shows two peaks, the TNT peak and a new species eluting earlier with a
retention time of 10.26 minutes. After sitting at 50 ˚C for another 8 days, the
chromatogram indicates that this species was still being produced and was present in
approximately equal amounts to the starting material. Also present in the chromatogram
was small amounts of additional species that elute significantly faster. The observed
pattern of more quickly eluting species appearing over time is suggestive of a generaldecomposition of the TNT into lower molecular weight species. Notably, however, these
faster eluting species represent a very small amount of the total dissolved mass and, in
fact, the chromatographic data shows that TNT is actually being converted relatively
cleanly into a single product in a solid-state reaction on the surface of the MnO2. Finally,
chromatograms collected after 42 days show that the new species is now predominant,
suggesting that most of the TNT has been converted. The faster eluting species, while
still present, has not increased significantly in concentration.
Similar observations were made from the surface reaction of TNT with CuO.
Chromatographic data indicates the formation of the same species eluting at 18.57
minutes after 31 days of reacting at 50 °C. While the species that forms is the same, the
extent of reaction is much more limited and, after 39 days, there is little additional
formation of this product. As with MnO2, faster eluting species are also present which,
while still minor, make up a larger fraction of the total dissolved material than they do in
the MnO2 (figure 13).
22
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 33/80
Figure 12. HPLC chromatograms of the products of 1.4 monolayer of TNT deposited on
MnO2 (a) initially and at 50 °C for (b) 16 (c) 24 and (d) 42 days.
Figure 13. HPLC chromatograms of the products of 1 monolayer of TNT deposited onCuO (a) initially and at 50 ˚C for (b) 31 (c) 39 and (d) 58 days.
23
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 34/80
Characterization of the main product of the solid-state reaction was carried out by
GC-MS (figure 14). Injection of the product mixture, after reaction for 31 days on MnO2,
resolved two relatively intense peaks at 11.83 and 11.9 minutes retention time on the GC.
The mass spectrum of the 11.9 minute peak shows the classic fragmentation pattern for
TNT with a weak parent-ion peak at 227.0 m/z and a more intense peak at 210.0 m/z
corresponding to [TNT-OH]+ due to the loss of O from an o-nitro group and a H from the
methyl group with ion bombardment to produce [C7H4(NO2)2(NO)]+.32 The mass
spectrum of the species that elutes at 11.83 minutes shows a strong peak at 213.0 m/z/
and a series of peaks at 167.0, 120.0, and 75.0 m/z. The 213.0 m/z peak can be assigned
as the parent peak of trinitrobenzene (TNB), C6H3(NO2)3, and the progression comes
from sequential loss of NO2 (or NO2 and H) groups. This assignment is confirmed
unambiguously by comparison to the published fragmentation pattern of atrinitrobenzene. The mass spectrum was also collected on some of the minor species
resolved by the gas chromatogram. They have not been fully characterized but, as would
be expected, the slower eluting species appear to be higher molecular weight biphenyl
species and the faster eluting species are lower molecular weight decomposition
fragments. Similar data was collected for the CuO catalysis. The primary product of the
solid-state reaction is TNB, though, as indicated by the HPLC data, conversion to TNB is
not as extensive as it is in the case of the MnO2. The gas chromatogram indicates that
there are generally more species, both slower and faster eluting, than form with MnO2,
suggesting that conversion to TNB is less clean and that there is more net decomposition
of the TNT.
While the mechanistic details of the reaction are not completely known, water has
been observed forming in bulk studies. As such, this suggests that the net reaction is:
24
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 35/80
Figure 14. (a) Gas chromatogram showing two principle components at 11.83 and 11.9
minutes whose mass spectra identify them as (b) trinitrobenzene and (c) unreacted TNT.
A likely pathway is the initial oxidation of the methyl group followed by a rapid
decarbonylation process. Kinetically, the reaction is extremely slow and the plots of the
relative concentration of TNT as a function of time are qualitatively consistent with a
reaction that is pseudo first order in TNT. Further analysis of the data using the
generalized approximate rate equation (equation 2) derived by Wilkinson, where p is the
fraction reacted, t is the time, n is the reaction order, and K is the apparent rate constant is
shown in figure 15.33 Evaluation of the slope (n/2) for the reaction, which is only linear
when p ≤ 0.4, p values greater than 0.4 give a reaction order to the nearest half order.
t
p=
nt
2+
1
K (2)
25
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 36/80
Evaluation of the slope in this instance yields a reaction order of 1.4, consistent with a
first order dependence on TNT and an apparent rate constant of 0.02/day for MnO2. The
half-life for the reaction is 35 days. In the absence of more detailed data about the
reaction products and mechanism, the kinetic analysis cannot be taken too far and only
serves to indicate the relative efficiencies of the reaction. It also should be noted that it is
not known whether the reaction is catalytic, using O2 as the oxidant, or whether it is
stoichiometric with oxygen taken from specific sites on the metal oxide surface.
Figure 15. Plot of the decomposition data of TNT on MnO2 over time fit to equation 2.
The net reaction is of considerable interest from a synthetic standpoint, since there
are, to the best of our knowledge, no previous reports of the direct demethylation of
aromatics. Moreover, there is no cost effective synthesis for TNB even though, from an
energetic standpoint, it is a superior high-energy material. The most direct synthesis
reported to date involves the conversion of phloroglucinol into trioximes withhydroxylamine followed by oxidation to trinitrobenzene with nitric acid.34 As such, a
single-step heterogeneous synthesis may be of commercial utility in producing TNB.
Unfortunately, attempts to scale up as a solution-solid reaction over MnO2 or as a solid-
state reaction involving larger amounts of TNT were not successful. From all the data
obtained so far, the reaction appears to occur as a very slow interfacial reaction.
26
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 37/80
Conclusions
From the standpoint of compatibility, it is clear that the interfacial chemistry
between TNT and inorganic surfaces can be pronounced. As indicated by the thermal
analysis work, this involves at one level, changes in the normal thermal decomposition
pathways of the molecule which may or may not have a net effect on stability or energy
release in bulk composite materials. For redox active metal oxide phases the interfacial
processes can result in a net chemical reaction that will slowly convert the TNT to
another species, and possibly to degradation products. For the specific oxides reported
here, the interfacial reaction converts TNT to TNB relatively cleanly and quantitatively
for MnO2 and with more overall decomposition than for the case of CuO. Clearly, this
result indicates that in composite energetic materials containing these components theTNT will be changing over time, which suggests that the stability and energy release may
also be variable. Moreover, once conversion to TNB is accomplished, further
decomposition may occur and adversely affect properties. Both MnO2 and CuO react
with TNT under relatively mild conditions. For both oxides a major product of this solid-
state reaction is the demethylation of TNT to form TNB. Over CuO this reaction does not
appear to be exclusive as many other species are formed nor does it proceed to
completion.
27
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 38/80
CHAPER 2
SURFACE STABILITY AND DEGRADATION STUDIES OF PETN ON METAL
OXIDES
Introduction
As previously stated the use of binary inorganic solid-state reactive materials in
combination with traditional organic high explosives such as 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT),
hexahydro-1,3,5-trinitro-1,3,5-triazine (RDX), octahydro-1,3,5,7-tetranitro-1,3,5,7-
tetrazocine (HMX) and pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) has recently become a new
approach to the fabrication of high output explosives. The binary inorganic materials arestoichiometric mixtures of a metal (fuel) and a metal oxide (oxidant) that react through a
highly exothermic redox reaction such as the well-known thermite reaction. These binary
inorganic materials have the advantage of having energy densities several times higher
than that of conventional explosives, though the rate of energy release is significantly
lower. In order to take advantage of the energy density of these binary materials, new
composites involving the mixture of conventional explosives with these binary
fuel/oxidant systems have been developed. These new composites allow the energy
release of the system to be driven by the conventional explosive, thus driving the kinetics
of the binary inorganic materials and thereby releasing energy much more rapidly and in
a controlled fashion.
However, it is unknown if an incompatibility between conventional explosives
and metal/metal oxide binary compositions exists. This incompatibility could occur due
to interfacial chemical processes occurring at the surface between the organic and
inorganic phase of the composite. These chemical processes may include a reduction at
the surface of the metal (fuel) and oxidation at the surface of the metal oxide. The
magnitude of these processes will likely be increased by the degree of contact between
the organic materials and the metal or metal oxide surfaces, and may be affected by
temperature and humidity along with other ambient conditions of storage and handling.
28
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 39/80
The chemical stability of pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) when placed in
physical contact with metal oxides is investigated. In this study PETN was placed on the
surfaces of a range of microcrystalline metal oxides including MnO2, CuO, MoO3, WO3,
Bi2O3, SnO2, and Fe2O3 in coverages of 1-3.5 monolayers by a wet impregnation
technique. Samples were then placed in a controlled temperature environment at 50 °C
and checked periodically for the presence of decomposition products using liquid
chromatography. PETN proved to be inert over all of the oxides except MoO3 which
showed the relatively rapid evolution of a brown gas over a period of 48 hours. Analysis
of the evolved gas indicated that it is primarily NO2 along with N2O4, N2O, and CO2.
Experimental
Materials
MnO2 (Aldrich, reagent grade, >90% purity, ~10mm particle size), CuO (Aldrich,
nanopowder, ~33 nm), Fe2O3 (Fisher, anhydrous), MoO3 (nano- and micron-scale,
Climax Molybdenum), SnO2 (Keeling & Walker Ltd.), WO3 (Atlantic Equipment
Engineering) and Bi2O3 (Aldrich) were used as received from the manufacturer.
Pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) was prepared according to the literature and was
stored in acetone (Aldrich, HPLC grade) for safety.35 Acetonitrile (Fisher, HPLC grade)
and toluene (Aldrich, HPLC grade) were used as received.
Long-term surface reactivity studies
A wet impregnation technique was used in preparing the samples for the long-
term reactivity studies. A PETN standard solution (208 μL, ~0.50 M) was diluted with
one milliliter of acetone and subsequently added to one gram of the metal oxide. The
acetone was removed under a vacuum (10-3 torr) leaving a dry powder containing the
metal oxide and the PETN on its surface. The approximate coverage area of the PETN is
1543 m2/g, which is based on the estimated area of a PETN molecule, assuming the
molecule is a disk with the outer circumference defined by the oxygen atoms of the nitro
groups (obtained from the crystal structure of PETN) with the radius extending from the
central carbon atom.36
29
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 40/80
The samples were placed in sealed containers and held at 50 °C in an oven over a
period of several months. Periodically, a small portion of the sample was removed (~0.10
g) and stirred into one milliliter of acetone. The solids were allowed to settle, and the
supernatant was collected containing any organic species and analyzed by HPLC using a
65:35 CH3CN/H2O solution as the mobile phase and toluene as an internal standard.
There was no evidence of new compounds forming in the chromatograph; however, a
comparison between the control sample and each subsequent sample removed showed a
decomposition of the PETN was occurring at the surface of the MoO3. The percent
degradation was determined from the ratio of the integrated peak area of the PETN in the
HPLC to that of the sum of all of the peak areas. For oxides that induced a significant
amount of degradation, the products were analyzed using FT-IR spectroscopy.
BET surface area analysis
The surface area of each metal oxide used in the survey was found by BET
methods using a Micromeretics ASAP 2020 physisorption surface area and porosity
analyzer. Approximately 0.25 g of each metal oxide was placed in a sample tube and was
degassed under a vacuum of 20 µmHg at 90 °C for sixty minutes in order to remove any
water from the sample. A subsequent heating at 340 °C for 240 minutes was performed in
order to completely degas the material. The analysis was performed at liquid nitrogen
temperatures in order to obtain the surface area for each metal oxide.
HPLC
Liquid chromatography experiments were performed on a Beckman Coulter
System Gold HPLC equipped with a 125 Solvent Module, 166 Detector and 508
Autosampler using a Beckman C18 column that is 250 x 4.6 mm. The detector was set at
254 nm in order to detect any organic compounds that may be present. A flow rate of
0.75 mL/min was used for the mobile phase, an isocratic mixture of 65:35
acetonitrile/H2O and toluene as an internal standard. The chromatogram was taken over a
period of 15 minutes, allowing all compounds time to travel through the column. PETN
appears at approximately 3.6 minutes at this flow rate with another peak appearing at 7.5
30
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 41/80
minutes. No other products were seen in the chromatogram due to the fact that the
degradation products appear to be solely gases.
FT-IR
The FT-IR spectra were collected on a Thermo Nicolet Avatar 360 FT-IR in
transmission mode. The sample, prepared as described above, was placed in a quartz tube
and attached to a gas phase IR cell with sodium chloride windows, which was under
vacuum (10-3 torr) allowing only gases evolved from a reaction between MoO3 and
PETN to be seen. A background was taken, and the sample was then opened to the gas-
cell allowing any evolved gas to enter the cell. The sample was heated to 100 °C allowing
a faster evolution of any reaction products and subsequent spectra were taken in the
spectral range of 750 to 4000 cm-1 with a resolution of 4 cm-1 at first every 15 minutesand then at longer intervals until no further product evolution occurred.
Thermal analysis
Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) was performed on a TA Instruments
Q1000 Series DSC under O2 at a ramp rate of 10 °C/min from 40 to 450 °C. Samples
were prepared using the wet impregnation method as described above. An aliquot of 84
µL of a PETN standard solution (~0.50 M) was diluted with a small amount of acetone
and added to 0.25 grams of MoO3 (both nano and micron sizes). The solvent was
removed under a vacuum, and the dry powder containing the PETN on the surface of the
metal oxide was then analyzed. Samples of pure PETN and PETN on the surface of silica
gel and KBr were also analyzed to differentiate surface chemistry specific to the metal
oxides.
Results and Discussion
Degradation studies
The long-term degradation studies were designed to simulate long-term ambient
storage conditions of multicomponent high-energy materials in direct contact with metal
oxide surfaces. Relatively low concentrations (1-3.5 monolayers) of PETN were
31
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 42/80
deposited onto the oxide surfaces in order to isolate specific interfacial chemistry as well
as to allow the sensitive detection of reaction products. Table 2 shows the oxides
surveyed in the study and their PETN surface coverage in the prepared samples.
Table 2. Surface coverage of PETN on each metal oxide
Metal Oxide BET Surface Area (m2/g) PETN Coverage (equivalent
monolayers)
MnO2 40 2.0
CuO 32 2.5
WO3 17 2.9
MoO3 (large) 25 2.0
MoO3 (nano) 55 0.91
Bi2O3 26 3.1
SnO2 21 3.8
Fe2O3 33 2.4
A chromatogram of the samples was taken immediately following preparation to
establish the initial purity. The samples were then placed in a 50 °C oven under ambient
atmosphere and allowed to react over the course of a couple of months, with aliquots periodically being withdrawn for analysis using HPLC. The amount of decomposition
over time of PETN for most oxide surfaces was found to be very small.
PETN proved to be inert or only slightly reactive on many of the metal oxide
surfaces. The amount of PETN on the surface of Bi2O3, CuO, WO3, Fe2O3, MnO2, and
SnO2 remains fairly constant over the period analyzed (~60 days) with only small
changes in the concentration of PETN, which were within the experimental error of the
measurement. However, PETN did show some decomposition on the surface of MoO3 as
evidenced by a decline in the amount of PETN and the concomitant production of a
brown gas, which can be observed visually in the sample container (figure 16). Increasing
the ambient temperature at which the sample is stored results in a more rapid production
of the gas.
32
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 43/80
Figure 16. The evolution of a brown gas from PETN on the surface of MoO3 after beingstored at 50 °C
Reactivity of PETN with MoO3
Thermal analysis. Thermal analysis of pure pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) using
differential scanning calorimetry (DSC) is shown is figure 17. The thermal scan shows asharp endotherm at 141 °C, which corresponds to the melting and an exotherm, whose
observed peak at this scan rate (10 °C/min) is at 205 °C, corresponds to the
decomposition of the molecule. When the sample is analyzed in a sealed container, the
decomposition becomes a deflagration event with an abrupt release of energy. When
considering composites of PETN with inorganic oxides, the effect of the inorganic-
organic interface on these well-understood thermal processes is of interest. The DSC plot
of PETN at ~2 monolayer coverage on nano-scale MoO3 is shown in figure 18. At
slightly less than 2 monolayer coverage of PETN on MoO3, the decomposition occurs at
a significantly lower temperature of 142 °C, with no melting endotherm being observed.
The lack of a melting endotherm is expected since there is no crystalline bulk phase
present. When the coverage of PETN is increased slightly to approximately 2 monolayers
a melting endotherm begins to be observed at 138 °C. The melting endotherm is
33
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 44/80
superimposed on the middle of the broad decomposition exotherm thereby splitting it into
two apparent peaks at 112 and 144 °C. There is also an exothermic process located at 192
°C, which is lower than for the pure PETN presumably due to interfacial mediation at the
surface of the oxide. An endotherm is also present at 292 °C and 287 °C for the <2 and 2
Figure 17. Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) of pure PETN with a vented sample pan (note exothermic processes are above the baseline)
monolayer samples respectively, which likely represents a desorption of some of the
products from the initial decomposition. A sample with excess PETN on the surface of
MoO3 shows an endotherm at 140.6 °C and two exothermic processes, one whose peak is
close to that resolved in the bulk (193 °C), and a low temperature exothermic process at
164 °C. This may be interpreted as coming from the superposition of the interfacial andthe bulk processes observable at higher loadings of PETN, wherein the melting
endotherm at 140.6 °C, which is more pronounced at the higher loading, now dominates
and obliterates most of the 141 °C interfacial exotherm leaving only a residual spike at
164 °C. The size of the 164 °C exotherm, however, is quite large, therefore a more
complex surface mediated decomposition process that results from the interfacial
34
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 45/80
reactions with the melt cannot be ruled out. An endothermic process just below 300 °C is
not seen in the bulk sample as it is in the monolayer samples due to the fact that it may be
attributed to a decomposition that occurs at the surface, and is therefore solely an
interfacial process.
The DSC data of PETN deposited on nano-scale MoO3 is compared to that of
PETN deposited on the larger micron size MoO3, which has a smaller surface area (figure
19). At a surface coverage of less than two monolayers, an endothermic process at 141 °C
indicating the melt of PETN is observed, as well as an exotherm at 195.4 °C for the
decomposition process. This exothermic process occurs at a lower temperature than that
of the bulk PETN (205 °C) showing that there is some interfacial mediation occurring,
however, the fact that there is a melt present and only one decomposition peak indicates
that there is mostly bulk crystalline phase present. In fact, similar processes are observedfor the samples with a higher loading of PETN, showing that the same interfacial
processes occurring on nano-scale MoO3 do not also occur on the micron scale MoO3. In
short, when the surface area gets small enough, interfacial effects become less significant
and are not observed in the thermal analysis or, alternatively, the large surface area
provided by nano-scale materials will give rise to greater surface degradation effects.
Comparable studies were performed on the remaining metal oxide surfaces, where a
surface mediation effect was only observed at the surfaces of MnO2
and CuO, which
showed the decomposition peak occurring at a lower temperature than that of pure PETN
(149 and 175 °C, respectively).
It is important to determine whether the interfacial mediation of the
decomposition temperature is specific to certain oxides or constituted a general surface
effect. Thermal analysis of monolayers of PETN deposited on inert oxides and salts
indicates that the decomposition temperature is not modified on all surfaces (figure 20).
On fumed silica the decomposition temperature is very similar to that of the bulk PETN
at 201 °C. On simple salts such as KBr, there is also no detectable change in the
decomposition temperature from that of the bulk. Thus the interfacial effect is not a
general effect, but rather a specific interaction that occurs between PETN and the surface
of nano-scale MoO3.
35
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 46/80
Figure 18. DSC of (a) <2, (b) 2, and (c) 6 monolayer coverage of PETN deposited on
nano-scale MoO3
These results do not provide a chemical rationale for the interfacial effect, nor do
they provide any specifics on the decomposition pathway(s) on the surface. It is clear
from the thermal analysis that there is a significant surface reaction with MoO3. This
effect might well mitigate energy release processes or affect long-term stability of
heterogeneous composite mixtures.
36
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 47/80
Figure 19. DSC of (a) <2, (b) 2, and (c) 6 monolayer coverage of PETN deposited onmicron-scale MoO3
Figure 20. DSC traces of PETN deposited on (a) SiO2 and (b) KBr
Product analysis. The reaction processes of pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN)
deposited on the surface of molybdenum (VI) oxide were studied using liquid
37
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 48/80
chromatography and fourier-transform infrared spectroscopic techniques. The HPLC
study was conducted over a period of three months wherein small aliquots of the sample
were removed periodically for analysis. The chromatogram shows a modest (1.3 %)
decrease in the amount of PETN present after 49 days (figure 21); however, no additional
peaks in the chromatogram that might represent the decomposition products were
observed, suggesting that the primary decomposition products are likely gaseous species
that diffuse out of the solid. Only a small amount of net decomposition is observed
chromatographically, which suggests that the reaction is localized at the interface and the
catalytic decomposition of the bulk does not occur, at least at the temperatures studied.
95
95.5
96
96.5
97
97.5
98
98.5
99
99.5
100
0 1 3 7 14 21 35 49 70
time (days)
P e r c e n t R e m a i n i n g
Figure 21. Percent PETN remaining on MoO3 after vs. time
The sample for the gas phase FT-IR study was prepared as described previously.
The container holding the sample was connected to a gas phase IR cell that had
previously been evacuated. The sample was set to heat to 100 °C, and spectra were
periodically recorded over a period of two days (figure 22). Peaks associated with the
decomposition of PETN began to appear during the first hour of heating. The products
38
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 49/80
observed by FT-IR were NO2 (1629, 1597 cm-1), N2O4 (1743 and 1270 cm-1), N2O (2236,
2212 cm-1), and CO2 (2359, 2342 and 3727-3600 cm-1).37 The band that occurs at 2918
cm-1 is due to the grease from the stopcocks of the gas cell heating slightly during the
reaction and releasing a small amount of the grease into the cell. The band at 1270 cm-1
has been assigned to N2O4, which is in accordance with the reported values found by
Mélen et al.38 However, this band seems to overlap with other fundamental vibrational
bands of NO2 as well as N2O, which are at 1320 and 1285 cm-1 respectively. A control
sample of the MoO3 without PETN prepared for FT-IR analysis showed that none of the
products found were from the surface of the MoO3 alone.
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
7.50E+021.25E+031.75E+032.25E+032.75E+033.25E+033.75E+03
Wavenumbers (cm-1)
% T
r a n s m i t t a n c e ( a . u . )
a
b
c
d
e
Figure 22. FT-IR spectroscopy of PETN on the surface of MoO3 at 100 ˚C after a) 1, b)
5, c) 24, d) 27.5, and e) 46 hours (♦=CO2, ▲=N2O, =N2O4, =NO2)
39
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 50/80
Conclusions
From the standpoint of compatibility, it is clear that the interfacial chemistry
between PETN and inorganic surfaces can be pronounced. As indicated by the thermal
analysis studies, this involves at one level, changes in the normal thermal decomposition pathways of the molecule which may or may not have a net effect on the stability or
energy release in bulk composite materials. For redox active metal oxide phases the
interfacial processes can result in a net chemical reaction that will slowly convert PETN
into another species, and possibly into degradation products. For the specific oxides
reported here, the surface interactions of PETN with MoO3 produces a gas containing
NO2, N2O, N2O4, and CO2 species. Clearly this result indicates that in composite
energetic materials containing forms of MoO3, the PETN will be changing over time,
which suggests that stability and energy release may also be variable.
40
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 51/80
CHAPTER 3
LASER INITIATION PROCESSES IN THERMITE ENERGETIC MATERIALS
STUDIED BY A LASER DESORPTION IONIZATION (LDI) TECHNIQUE
Introduction
The use of binary solid-state inorganic fuel/oxidant redox processes such as the
classic aluminum/iron oxide thermite reaction in the production of energetic materials is
of great interest due to their high energy densities. It has recently been discovered that the
energetic properties of these materials may be enhanced when at least one of the
components in the mixture is on the nanometer size scale. These materials, which arereferred to as metastable interstitial composites (MIC) have a rapid release of energy that
can be attributed to a more intimate fuel/oxidant contact that occurs in the nano-scale,
which enhances mass transport and provides more power.5,6
Thermal initiation of thermite materials typically involves heating above the
melting point of one of the components, typically the metal. This starts the reaction
processes that liberate heat, causing the reaction to accelerate. Ignition occurs when the
reaction becomes self-sustaining and propagates. For laser initiation, the incident energy
put into the sample by the laser causes high localized heating, which leads to ignition of
the bulk. The time to ignition is defined as the time at which the energy released by the
reaction becomes greater than or equal to the energy put into the composite by the laser.
Both the laser excitation event and the subsequent ignition and propagation of the
mixture are extremely high-temperature events which generate both liquid and gas phase
(plasma) species. Chemical reactions between species occurring within and between
these phases and with the solid material all contribute to the net combustion process. This
complexity coupled with the high temperatures makes these reactions difficult to study on
a microscopic level. This has been addressed recently by Dlott et al. by using time-
resolved spectroscopy and initiating the reaction between aluminum and nitrocellulose by
flash-heating with a 100 ps laser pulse in the near infrared.8,9 Short pulse photo-thermal
initiation allows the use of time-resolved spectroscopic techniques to monitor reaction
41
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 52/80
dynamics, elucidate some of the intermediate species produced during the reaction, and to
observe specific structural changes in the reactive components.
The reactive processes that occur during the laser initiation of aluminum/iron (III)
oxide metastable intermolecular composites (MIC) have been studied by laser-induced
desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry. The ions observed in the plume
from the aluminum show fragments from the ablation of the oxide coating and from the
metal core. Ablation of the iron oxide component consists primarily of pure iron species
such as [Fe]+ and [Fe2]+ and small oxides such as [FeO]+ and [Fe2O]+ ions. In smaller
quantities, metal oxide clusters that are either oxygen deficient, [Fe(FeO)x]+, or oxygen
equivalent [(FeO)x]+, are observed. When the thermite composite is initiated, mixed metal
species are observed in the plume, which correspond to the aluminum substitution
analogues of the iron oxide clusters, specifically, [FeAl2O3]+, [AlFe2O3]+, and [AlFe2O2]+. Notably, the amounts of these mixed metal products that form are inversely proportional
to the size of the aluminum particles. This suggests that the decrease in ignition time
observed in MIC materials is due to the more facile liberation of reactive metallic
aluminum when the particle size is small.
Experimental
Materials
The 50 and 100 nm aluminum samples were obtained from Argonide, while the
micron aluminum was purchased from Alfa Aesar. All aluminum samples were used as
received. The iron (III) oxide powder, <0.25 microns, was purchased from Aldrich and
was used as received.
The size and morphology of the aluminum samples were characterized by field
emission scanning electron microscopy (figure 23). The nano-scale materials are
somewhat polydispersed, with the average particle size being around 50 and 100 nm for
the two sizes, although both showed some particles above 200 and below 50 nm. Both
samples showed some agglomeration of the particles, which was more pronounced in the
50 nm material. The aluminum, which we designate as “micron” scale, was a very
polydispersed material composed largely of particles between 0.5 and 2.5 µm in size with
42
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 53/80
only a few large particles around 5 µm observable. The average size of the micron
sample, averaged from the particles observable in the SEM, was 1.75 µm. The active
aluminum content and the estimated oxide thickness for the three samples were
determined from weight gain measurements using thermogravimetric analysis on a TA
Instruments Q500 TGA. The active aluminum content for the 50 and 100 nm and the 2.5
µm materials was 71.5, 75.5, and 98.0 %, respectively, while the oxide thickness was
determined to be 2.6, 4.5, and 6.0 nm, respectively.
Figure 23. SEM images of (a) 50 nm, (b) 100 nm, and (c) micron-scale aluminum particles
Preparation of samples
The thermite samples were prepared by mixing Fe2O3 with each of the aluminum
particles at a 1:1 molar aluminum to iron ratio. The samples were thoroughly mixed by
grinding the components in a mortar and pestle to ensure a homogenous distribution.
Analysis of the samples after grinding using powder X-ray diffraction indicated that no
new phases were formed as a result of sample preparation. The samples were then packed
into a sample holder for laser desorption ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry
(LDI/TOF MS) along with the control samples of Fe2O3 and the 50 and 100 nm and the
micron aluminum.
LDI/TOF mass spectrometry
The LDI/TOF mass spectra were collected using a commercial 1999 Bruker Biflex III matrix-assisted laser desorption and ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometer
(MALDI-TOF) (Bruker Daltronics, Inc.) fitted with a solid sample holder for the
introduction of inorganic material. The instrument was equipped with a pulsed nitrogen
43
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 54/80
laser at 337 nm with a peak width of 4 ns. All spectra were collected in linear mode with
positive ion detection averaging 200 shots from the laser.
In order to thermally initiate thermite, temperatures at or above the melting point
of aluminum must be obtained. For laser pulses in the nanosecond regime, there is
enough time for thermal transport into the material. The temperature attained in each
component of the thermite can be estimated from the absorbed energy per unit volume,
Ev, using equation 3, where J is the fluence at the center of the beam, R is the reflection
coefficient, ΛD is the thermal diffusion length, which is the depth of the sample that is
heated with a single pulse from the laser, C(T) is the heat capacity, and ρ is the density.
The thermal diffusion length is calculated from the thermal diffusivity (D) and the pulse
length of the laser (equation 4).8,9,39
Ev = J (1 - R) / ΛD = ρ C (T )dT T i
T f
∫ (3)
ΛD = ½(2πDt)1/2 (4)
It was found that all of the aluminum was melted when the laser reached an
energy density of 0.158 J/cm2. The volume of aluminum that was heated per pulse was
approximately 7.42 x 10-9 cm3. Although the volume of the sample that was hit by the
laser did not change, the active aluminum content would vary based on the size of the
aluminum particle. The Fe2O3 phase composite also absorbed at 337 nm and was found toreach its melting point of 1565 °C at an energy density of 0.474 J/cm2. Temperatures
required to generate a plume from which species could be detected in TOF-MS were
found to be above these threshold values of melting.
UV-Vis diffuse reflectance
The reflectivity of the independent Al and Fe2O3 components and the
compounded thermite were measured as total reflectance against a calibrated Spectralon
diffuse scattering reference in a Perkin-Elmer Lambda 900 spectrophotometer equipped
with a 160 mm integrating sphere.
44
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 55/80
Results and Discussion
Aluminum samples in the three particle sizes, 3-5 µm and 50 and 100 nm, were
placed as tightly pressed powders in the laser desorption ionization instrument. Time-of-
flight mass spectra observed for the 50 nm Al as a function of incident laser power are
shown in figure 24. No gas-phase ionic products were observed below a threshold energy
density of 0.948 J/cm2. Above this threshold, the major products included [Al]+, [Al2O]+,
and [Al2]+ at m/z of 26.9, 69.9, and 53.9, respectively. At power densities between 1.74
and 1.90 J/cm2, small amounts of more complex AlxOy products were also observed
including [Al2O2]+, [Al3O]+, and [Al3O2]
+ at m/z 85.9, 96.9, and 113.0, respectively
(figure 24b). Since the system was evacuated, the oxide species must have originated
either directly or indirectly from the native oxide layer on the aluminum powder. Laser desorption of Al2O3 produced a large number of neutral species, with the dominant ones
Figure 24. LDI-TOF mass spectra of 50 nm aluminum at a laser energy density of (a)1.74 and (b) 1.90 J/cm2
being AlO, Al2O, and Al2O2.40,41 In fact, AlO has been observed in the emission spectrum
of combusting Al/MoO3 thermite materials.10 Since the observed aluminum oxide ion
clusters are oxygen deficient, they are likely formed from ion-molecule reactions in the
plasma between Al+ and neutrals such as those given in equations 5-7. Clearly, other
pathways may also be operating. The species AlO+ and Al2O2+ are only observed at a
higher laser power and may represent direct ion yields from ablation of the Al2O3 layer.
45
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 56/80
Al+ + AlO Al2O+ (5)
Al+ + Al2O Al3O+ (6)
Al+ + Al2O2 Al3O2+ (7)
Studies by Granier and Pantoya on the fuel particle size dependence of laser ignition of
Al/MoO3 MIC materials showed a general trend of faster ignition times as the Al particle
size dropped to nanometer dimensions.15 This effect was attributed to melting point
depression that accompanies the size reduction in the aluminum. Also important in the
laser ignition process is the presence of a native oxide layer on the aluminum. The oxide
layer is thickest on micron-size aluminum and decreases to approximately 2-4.5 nm as
the aluminum particle size reaches the nanometer dimension. Notwithstanding the thinner
oxide layer, the percent of active aluminum metal available will also decrease (i.e, Al2O3 represents a progressively higher percent of the mass of the particle). A direct effect of
this is a reduction of the burn rate at very small particle sizes. The process of laser
initiation will involve melting of the aluminum, the density change of which is sufficient
to critically stress and break the oxide layer.42 As indicated above, the ions that are
observed in the plasma can be associated with both the oxide and the aluminum phase of
the nanoparticles. Since the oxide has an extremely high melting point and a weak optical
absorption, most of the heating during the pulse will be of the metal itself. Above the
energy density threshold, the three dominant species are [Al]+, [Al2]+, and [Al2O]+, which
reflect contributions from the volatilization and ionization of the aluminum metal and the
breakdown of the aluminum oxide shell. The amounts of these species observed for all
three Al particle sizes at an energy density of 1.90 J/cm2 are shown in figure 25. The 100
nm particles show a large yield of [Al]+ and a small yield of [Al2O]+, while the converse
is true for the 50 nm particles, which show a larger yield of [Al2O]+ than [Al]+. This
difference likely arises from the higher percent of oxide present relative to the active
aluminum content in the 50 nm material, the neutrals of which will deplete more of the
available [Al]+ in the plume, according to equation 5. The 100 nm sample has a higher
active aluminum content relative to the amount of oxide present, which gives a higher
[Al]+ ion yield. Interestingly, the amount of each Al species observed for the micron-size
sample is between that of the 50 and 100 nm samples. It yields more [Al2O]+ than the 100
46
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 57/80
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
30000
Intensity
[Al]+ [Al2]+ [Al2O]+
micron Al
50 nm Al
100 nm Al
Figure 25. Aluminum ions formed at a laser energy of 1.90 J/cm2 for each aluminum particle size
nm Al, consistent with its much thicker oxide layer, but significantly less [Al]+, which
seems inconsistent with its high available Al content. The origin of this may lie in its
higher melting point, which means that less of the heat deposited by the laser pulse is
used to vaporize the sample. The power dependence of the ion yields is consistent with
this suggestion. The total yield of the most prevalent ions ([Al]+, [Al2]+, and [Al2O]+) as a
function of energy density indicates that at the threshold, ion yields are low and relatively
independent of particle size (figure 26). As the power increases, the nanometer-scale
particles produce the highest ion yields, which are consistent with the shorter ignition
times observed in the bulk materials. At the very highest energy density, however, the
micron-size sample begins to exceed that of the nano-scale aluminum. The trends
observed are explainable in the context of the free energy of the active aluminum and the
oxide layer as a function of particle size. The free energy of the active aluminum in thevolume becomes more positive (i.e. less stable) as the size decreases, which gives rise to
the melting point depression. Conversely, the free energy of the surface oxide, which
becomes the dominant contribution to the total free energy as the particles become
smaller, becomes more negative, making the oxide layer more stable and, hence, less
easily ablated into the plume.43 Notably, the results are also extremely consistent with the
47
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 58/80
recent melt dispersion model of Levitas et al., which suggests that the stronger oxide
layer on the nanoparticles results in large pressure changes during rapid melting, causing
pressure-induced spallation of the oxide layer followed by a rapid dispersion of
aluminum clusters.44 It is important to note that the laser-induced ignition of a thermite
reaction will necessarily involve many reactions taking place in different phases of the
irradiated materials. In this study, while we are observing a subset of those reactions, the
species we are observing do afford support at a molecular level of the proposed
advantages of nanoscale fuels on factors such as ignition time and burn rate.15
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
30000
35000
40000
45000
50000
Intensity
1.738 1.896 2.054
Energy Density (J/cm2)
micron
50 nm Al
100 nm Al
Figure 26. Major aluminum ions formed ([Al]+ + [Al2]+ + [Al2O]+) for each particle size
at increasing energy densities
Irradiation of the Fe2O3 sample results in ionic products at a threshold power
density of 1.58 J/cm2. At the threshold, two primary species are observed, [Fe]+ and
[FeO]+, along with K and Na impurities (figure 27a). As the laser power is increased,
more complex species are observed, in particular, [Fe2O]+
and [Fe2O2]+
, with minor products including [Fe2]
+, [Fe3O2]+, and [Fe3O3]
+ (figure 27b). Maunit et al. studied the
laser ablation/ionization of iron oxides in considerable detail, and our spectra parallel the
ones obtained by these authors under nonresonant excitation conditions and below the
threshold of Fe-O bond dissociation.45 As suggested in this previous study, neutral FeO is
an important constituent of the plume and contributes to the cluster formation through
48
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 59/80
ion-molecule reactions. The formation of [Fe2]+ was found to be through an ion-molecule
reaction between Fe+ and neutral FeO that generates oxygen (equation 8), and FeO+ and
Fe2O+ are subsequently formed through an ion-molecule reaction with the generated
oxygen (equations 9 and 10). The larger clusters that are formed in the plume are either
Fe+ + FeO Fe2+ + ½ O2 (8)
Fe+ + ½ O2 FeO+ (9)
Fe2+ + ½ O2 Fe2O
+ (10)
oxygen deficient, Fe(FeO)x, or oxygen equivalent, (FeO)x, and are also formed from ion-
molecule reactions between neutrals such as FeO and precursor ions.
Figure 27. LDI-TOF mass spectra of iron(III) oxide at a laser density of (a) 1.58 and (b)1.74 J/cm2
The TOF mass spectrometry characterization of the species forming in the plumes
of Al/Fe2O3 thermite mixtures was carried out over a range of laser powers. Of interest
are species that form between the two components, which represent gas-phase reactions
that are part of the laser ignition process. No products were observed until an energydensity of 1.11 J/cm2 was reached. At this threshold, however, the only products
observed were those produced from the independent components. It was not until an
energy density of 1.58 J/cm2 was reached that products consisting of Al/Fe mixed
components were observed. At this threshold, small amounts of [AlOFe]+ began to
appear in the spectrum (figure 28a,b). As discussed above, in the pure iron oxide, [Fe 2O]+
49
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 60/80
was formed from the reaction of [Fe2]+ with O2 (equation 10). While this reaction is
possible for the formation of [AlOFe]+, only trace amounts of the precursor ion, [AlFe]+,
were observed in the spectrum. This suggests that the [AlOFe]+ likely results from an
ion-molecule reaction between neutral FeO and aluminum ions (equation 11). Obviously,
FeO + Al+ FeOAl+ (11)
since species such as AlO and Fe+ are also present in the plume, their reaction may also
contribute to the mixed metal product. As photo-thermal heating of the thermite mixture
increases, more complex Al/Fe oxide species appear (figure 28d). All of the observed
clusters are aluminum-substituted analogues of the larger ion clusters; specifically,
[Al2FeO3]+ and [AlFe2O3]+ are related to [Fe3O3]+, while [AlFe2O2]+ is an analogue of [Fe3O2]
+. The relative amounts of the pure iron clusters produced from the Fe2O3 control
and from the thermite are shown in figure 29. It can be seen that [FeO] + and [Fe2O]+ are
actually produced in higher quantities in the thermite, while the larger pure iron clusters
are only produced in very small amounts. This is consistent with the formation of the
mixed oxide clusters at the expense of the pure iron clusters due to competition in the
plume between Al+ and Fe+ for reaction with molecular FexOy species. The fact that
[Fe2O]+ appears to be independent of the formation of [AlOFe]+ is consistent with their
respective formation through different mechanistic pathways.
The production of mixed metal products correlates strongly with the size of the
aluminum. The energy density threshold at which mixed metal products are observed is
lower for the nano-scale particles than that for the micron-scale particles (1.58 vs. 1.73
J/cm2). More significantly, the quantities of all of the mixed metal components increase
with decreasing aluminum particle size (figure 30). This provides direct evidence for the
suggestion that the shorter ignition times that accompany smaller particle sizes are due to
the lower melting point of the nano-scale materials and the active aluminum content
available in the particle that, for a given laser power, produces more reactive species.
50
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 61/80
Figure 28. LDI-TOF mass spectra of thermite mixtures at a laser energy density of (a)1.42, (b) 1.58, (c) 1.74, and (d) 1.90 J/cm2
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
16000
Intensity
[FeO]+ [Fe2O]+ [Fe2O2]+ [Fe3O3]+ [Fe3O2]+ [Fe4O4]+
Fe2O3 standard
Thermite Reaction
Figure 29. Relative amounts of pure iron cluster species formed during laser desorptionof the Fe2O3 control and thermite samples at an energy density of 2.054 J/cm2
51
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 62/80
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
16000
Intensity
[AlOFe]+ [AlO2Fe]+ [Al2O3Fe]+ [AlO2Fe2]+ [AlO3Fe2]+
50 nm Al
100 nm Al
micron Al
Figure 30. Mixed Al/Fe oxide species formed at an energy density of 2.054 J/cm2 for 50
and 100 nm and micron aluminum thermite mixtures
Conclusions
This study has provided insight into some of the reactions that occur between
aluminum and iron oxide species in the plasma phase of the binary energetic system
during laser initiation. In particular, ionic species generated directly from the laser desorption and through various ion molecules are observed for both the aluminum and
iron oxide components. When the binary thermite is laser-initiated, mixed metal ionic
species are produced in the plume. These species are mixed metal analogues of the iron
clusters and are believed to form from the competition between Al+ and Fe+. The amount
of mixed metal clusters that form in the plasma increases as the size of the aluminum
particles decreases. This provides a direct verification that the shorter ignition times
observed with decreasing fuel particle size are due to a lower melting point that liberates
more reactive aluminum during laser incidence.
52
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 63/80
CHAPTER 4
PHOTO-THERMAL INIATION PROCESSES OF ORGANIC-INORGANIC
HYBRID METASTABLE INTERSTITIAL COMPOSITE (MIC) MATERIALS
Introduction
The organic high-energy material pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) was
incorporated at low concentrations into Al (100 nm)/Fe2O3 metastable interstitial
composites (MIC) to form a hybrid organic/inorganic high-energy material. Studies of the
dynamics of energy release were carried out by initiating the reaction photo-thermally
with a single 8 ns pulse of the 1064 nm fundamental of a Nd:YAG laser. The reactiondynamics were measured using time-resolved spectroscopy of the light emitted from the
deflagrating material. Two parameters were measured: the time to initiation and the
duration of the deflagration. The presence of small amounts of PETN (16 mg/g MIC)
results in a dramatic decrease in the initiation time. This is attributed to a contribution to
the temperature of the reacting system from the combustion of the PETN that, at lower
loadings, appears to follow an Arrhenius dependence. The presence of PETN was also
found to reduce the energy density required for single-pulse photo-thermal initiation by
an order of magnitude, suggesting that hybrid materials such as this may be engineered to
optimize their use as an efficient photodetonation medium.
Experimental
Materials
The iron (III) oxide powder, <0.25 µm, was purchased from Aldrich, while the
100 nm aluminum was obtained from Argonide. All materials were used as received.
Pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) was prepared according to the literature and stored in
acetone (Aldrich, HPLC grade) for safety purposes.35
53
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 64/80
Preparation of samples
Pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN) was deposited onto the iron (III) oxide by a
wet impregnation technique. A small amount, up to 1.053 mL, of PETN standard solution
(~ 0.5 M) was added to 0.5 grams Fe2O3 in order to obtain varying loading of PETN in
the final composite (Table 3). The acetone of the stock solution of PETN was
subsequently removed under a vacuum (10-3 torr) leaving a dry powder. The thermite
samples were prepared by mixing Fe2O3/PETN samples with 100 nm aluminum particles
in a 1:1 molar aluminum to iron ratio. The samples were thoroughly mixed by grinding
the components together using a mortar and pestle in order to ensure a homogenous
mixture. Approximately 0.25 grams of this mixture was compressed in a die at an applied
pressure of 46,000 psi. The resulting pellets were 6.39 mm in diameter by 3.28 mm
giving an average density of 2.38 g/cm3.
Table 3. Effects of PETN on heat and energy given off by MIC composites
mg PETN/g MIC composite Fraction of heat given off
by PETN
Energy PETN/ g composite
(kJ/g)
16.0 0.0343 0.130
32.0 0.0615 0.260
64.0 0.116 0.52195.9 0.164 0.781
128 0.208 1.04
Nd:YAG laser
A Spectra-Physics DCR-3G Nd:YAG laser using single pulses of both 1064 and
532 nm light was used in order to combust the thermite/PETN samples. At 1064 nm an 8
ns 900 mJ pulse was focused through a fused silica 75 mm focal length lens onto the
pellet, while at 532 nm the laser pulse was 6 ns and 360 mJ. The focused beam diameter
was calculated to be 11 µm giving an energy density of 8.8 x 10 5 J/cm2 at 1064 nm and
5.7 µm with an energy density of 1.4 x 106 J/cm2 at 532 nm. The laser beam was focused
through a hole in a protective steel plate, with the hole measuring 2.54 cm in diameter,
54
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 65/80
which was covered by a fused silica window measuring 24x23x2 mm in order to catch
any debris from the combustion of the pellet.
The kinetics of the combustion flash was recorded using three photodiode
detectors (Thorlabs DET210, 0.8 mm2 Si PIN, 1 ns rise time) and recorded by digital
storage oscilloscopes (LeCroy LC 564A, 1 GHz bandwidth, 10-50 µs sampling rate for
slow signals). The photodiodes were placed 45 degrees from the laser beam axis, looking
down at the sample through a fused silica window and filtered by either a heat absorbing
filter (Hoya HA30) to reduce the 1064 nm scattered light (fast signal) or a 520 nm band-
pass filter (Thorlabs FB520-10, 10 nm FWHM) for both fast and slow signals. Spectra
were collected through a 3 mm diameter liquid light guide (Oriel 77554, NA/0.47, >50%
transmittance from 270 to 720 nm) placed above the sample at 45 degrees from the laser
beam axis coupled into a 300 mm spectrograph (Acton Research Corporation Spectra Pro308i, 150 gr/mm grating blazed at 300 nm) using a biconvex fused silica lens (Spex, 1
inch diameter, f = 28.6 mm) and the light was dispersed onto a back-thinned CCD
(1340x400 pixels, 20 µm square, Princeton Instruments LN/CCD-400EB-G1 operated at
-90 ºC). The timing for single shot operation was coordinated by triggering the CCD
shutter, laser, and oscilloscope using a digital delay generator (EG&G PAR 9650) to
trigger the CCD shutter to open for 30 ms and delaying the laser and oscilloscope triggers
for 10 ms. The CCD exposure time, set in the software to 10 ms, was determined to be 30
ms by adjusting the laser trigger delay while observing the second harmonic 532 nm laser
light.
Results and Discussion
The effect of PETN incorporation on the dynamics of Al/Fe2O3 MIC initiation
and deflagration was investigated using time resolved spectroscopic techniques. In
general, thermal initiation of the thermite reaction occurs when the reaction temperature
reaches or exceeds the melting temperature of the fuel, in this case aluminum. At this
point there is a breakdown of the native oxide layer on the aluminum and the mass
transport between the fuel and the oxide becomes large enough to propagate the
reaction.42 The combustion of the samples in this instance was achieved photo-thermally
55
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 66/80
using a single 8 ns pulse of the 1064 nm fundamental from a Spectra-Physics DCR-3G
Nd:YAG laser, which allows the use of time-resolved spectroscopic techniques. As such,
the dynamics were monitored over the total time regime of the process by light emitted
from the reacting material, collected through a band-pass filter with a λ max = 520 nm.
The time-resolved data for the Fe2O3/100 nm Al MIC materials containing
various amounts of PETN is shown in figure 31. The emissive plume generated by the
laser incidence event on the surface of the sample can be seen as a sharp spike, indicated
by an arrow in the figure, while the irregular intensity that follows in time is the plasma
emission from the deflagration of the sample. An important quantitative parameter of the
reaction dynamics is the ignition time. For photo-thermally initiated binary fuel-oxidant
materials this is defined as the time at which the energy released by the reaction becomes
greater than or equal to the energy put into the composite by the laser. For data collected photonically, the ignition time is generally taken as the time between the laser excitation
and when emitted light can be detected. In the time-resolved system employed here, the
sensitivity and dynamic ranges of the photodiodes is high, allowing the very early stages
of combustion to be observed. In analyzing the data, the ignition time is defined as the
period between the sharp plume emission from the initial laser incidence and the point at
which the intensity of the light emitted from the combusting sample is twice the intensity
of the noise, as measured in the pre-trigger region of the data. A plot of the initiation time
against the amount of PETN in each sample at 1064 nm is shown in figure 32. The
ignition time at 1064 nm for the pure thermite sample was found to be 6.05 ± 0.28 ms,
however, with the incorporation of PETN (16 mg/g thermite) the ignition time drops
precipitously to 3.35 ± 0.28 ms and continues to decrease until a minimum value of 1.60
± 0.354 ms is observed with 64.0 mg PETN/g thermite. Above this amount of PETN
there is no further decrease and, in fact, it appears to plateau or even increases slightly.
For safety reasons it was not possible to obtain data for higher concentrations of PETN.
56
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 67/80
Figure 31. Photo-thermal initiation of Fe2O3/100 nm Al samples with increasingamounts of PETN at 1064 nm (arrow indicates the position of the laser plume emission)
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
PETN (mg/g thermite)
I n i t i a t i o n T i m e ( m s )
Initiation TimeExponential Decay Fit
Figure 32. Initiation time (ms) as a function of PETN coverage in mg at 1064 nm
57
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 68/80
The intense, irregular peak that follows ignition (figure 31) is the time-evolution
of the plasma emission from the deflagration of the sample. The apparent oscillations in
the emission intensity are attributed to modulation of the light by the deflagration process
with the duration of this emission being directly related to the total time it takes for the
sample to deflagrate. From the data, the deflagration duration is measured from the
previously determined ignition point to the time where the emission intensity has returned
to a value of twice the noise level. A plot of the deflagration duration as a function of
PETN loading is shown in figure 33. As can be seen in figures 31 and 33, the
incorporation of a small amount of PETN into the MIC material has a pronounced effect
on the deflagration duration. The deflagration of a control sample of Al/Fe2O3 MIC
materials with no organic phase present shows a weak broad emission with a long (282
ms) duration. The addition of a small amount of PETN (16.0 mg/g thermite) results in asignificant decrease in the deflagration duration to 88 ms. The deflagration duration
continues to decrease as more PETN is added, albeit more gradually, until it plateaus at
31.5 ms for 64.0 mg of PETN per gram of thermite. Scrutiny of the spectral data in figure
31 shows that, in general, the decrease in deflagration duration is accompanied by an
increase in the emission intensity, which suggests that, as expected, more energy is being
released in a short time period.
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
PETN (mg/g thermite)
D e f l a g r a t i o n D u r a t i o n T i m e ( m s )
1064 nm
532 nm
Figure 33. Deflagration duration time (ms) as a function of the amount of PETN at 1064nm
58
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 69/80
The changes observed in both the ignition time and the duration of deflagration as
a function of PETN addition appear to follow the same basic trend: increasing amounts of
PETN result in a decrease in the time to ignition and the deflagration duration, the effect
of which ultimately plateaus at about 64.0 mg per gram of thermite. In general these
effects can be thought of as originating from the contribution of the heat of combustion of
the organic phase to that of the fuel/oxidant inorganic matrix, which acts to accelerate the
binary reaction. PETN is a high-energy molecule with a heat of combustion of 2,572
kJ/mol.46 The amount of energy provided by the PETN and its contribution to the total
energy output of the composite material at various levels of incorporation is given in
Table 3. At the highest loadings studied the PETN accounts for about 20% of the total
energy liberated by the composite during combustion.
The effect of the PETN on the initiation time is likely due to its combustionduring or immediately after the laser excitation event. Specifically, the laser excitation
rapidly heats a volume of the composite defined by the diameter of the beam and the
thermal diffusion length of the material. During the course of the 8 ns pulse both the
aluminum and the iron oxide are heated with the relative temperature attained by each
phase being dependant primarily on its optical absorbance at 1064 nm and its thermal
diffusivity. The PETN is not absorbing at this wavelength so its combustion occurs from
heat flow from the other components. This will happen relatively efficiently since the
combustion temperature of the PETN is 205 ºC while the temperature reached by the
inorganic components will be at or above their melting point. The PETN will contribute
heat back into the inorganic components when combusted, thereby raising the
temperature further and accelerating the initiation processes. Since even at the lowest
incorporation level the combustion of PETN provides sufficient heat to melt all of the
aluminum in the composite, its contribution to the initiation process will be substantial;
this is directly reflected in the data.
The decrease in the initiation time as a function of PETN concentration (figure
32), particularly in the region before the plateau in the time is reached, is not linear but
instead appears to be approximately exponential. This suggests possible Arrhenius
behavior in the rate (lifetime) of the initiation. Earlier studies in the rates of binary fuel-
oxidant systems have suggested that behavior of the rate is Arrhenius in the early stages
59
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 70/80
before auto-acceleration of the reaction occurs due to the extreme exothermicity.11-13 This
suggests that Arrhenius-type behavior may also be valid during the initiation process
prior to deflagration. The rate (lifetime) of the initiation in the composite will depend on
the temperature of the material, which is set to an initial value by the laser pulse and is,
subsequently, augmented by the combustion of the PETN. The contribution of the PETN
to the final temperature will be approximately proportional to the product of the mass of
PETN and the heat of combustion: T ΔH* m. An Arrhenius expression may be written
exploiting this and shown in equation 12, where the initial temperature, To, attained from
the laser pulse and the contribution from the PETN is a function of the mass, m, with the
constant, C, representing the heat of combustion of the PETN and the thermal
conductivity and heat capacity of the inorganic components that are being heated by it.
1 )( 0 CmT R
E
init
a
Aet
+−
= (12)
This form of the Arrhenius equation fits well to the initiation time data,
particularly at low PETN loadings, which is consistent with the basic model of how the
PETN affects the dynamics as shown here. The deviation from Arrhenius behavior as
initiation time plateaus at PETN loadings greater than 64 mg/g thermite mixture is
somewhat unclear but may simply be that the maximum rate has been reached and that
the additional heat placed into the melting and vaporization of the inorganic components
will have only a minimal effect.
As discussed, the deflagration duration (figure 33) of the reaction decreases
rapidly with the addition of PETN and, like the initiation time, it reaches a relatively
constant value at ≥64 mg/g. The lifetime of the deflagration is not described by the
Arrhenius temperature dependence; however, this is expected due to the high
exothermicity and concomitant auto-acceleration of the reaction. The leveling off of the
deflagration time may represent a limiting value determined by the PETN combustion
time, initiated in this fashion, as it begins to dominate the energetics of the composites.
60
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 71/80
Studies of the ignition time and deflagration duration were carried out with visible
excitation at 532 nm. Since this wavelength is achieved through frequency doubling of
the 1064 nm fundamental the highest energy density that could be realized was 1.4 x 10 6
J/cm2. At this energy density it was not possible to initiate the combustion of the pure
Al/Fe2O3 MIC materials; however the presence of a small amount of PETN (10.0 mg/g
thermite) resulted in reproducible single-pulse initiation. This effect is explainable in
terms of prior discussion. While the energy provided at 532 nm is insufficient to initiate
the pure thermite it does provide sufficient heat to combust the PETN, which then
provides enough heat to drive the combustion. Notably, PETN does not absorb at 532 nm
so there is not optical contribution to the effect. Consistent with this interpretation, the
initiation time for 532 nm excitation (figure 34) is always longer than what is observed
for 1064 nm excitation which is expected from less total heat going into the system andthe fact that initiation is achieved secondarily through the PETN. The deflagration
duration is essentially the same as that observed with 1064 nm initiation (figure 33)
which is consistent with the idea that the duration of deflagration is dictated by the
energy release of the composite system and is independent of the initiation conditions.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
PETN (mg/g thermite)
I n i t i t a t i o n T i m e ( m s )
Figure 34. Initiation time of Al/Fe2O3 MIC materials with various concentrations of PETN initiated with a single pulse of 532 nm radiation
61
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 72/80
The results at 532 nm excitation suggest that one of the propitious effects of
PETN incorporation is to lower the threshold energy required for single pulse initiation.
This could have an impact on strategies for developing efficient photodetonation systems.
To quantify this effect, the initation threshold energy was determined for the range of
PETN loadings using 1064 nm initiation. The threshold energy density required to initiate
pure Al/Fe2O3 MIC samples at 1064 nm is quite high at 4.7 x 105 J/cm2. The addition of
PETN results in a relatively linear decrease in threshold energy required for initiation at
1064 nm up to 64.0 mg PETN/g thermite with an energy reaching a minimum value of
5.03 x 104 J/cm2 at 95.9 mg PETN/g thermite (figure 35) which represents almost an
order of magnitude decrease in the necessary energy density.
0.00E+00
1.00E+05
2.00E+05
3.00E+05
4.00E+05
5.00E+05
6.00E+05
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
PETN (mg/g thermite)
E n e r g
y D e n s i t y ( J / c m
2 )
140
Figure 35. Energy density (J/cm2) required in order to initiate the thermite/PETNmixture at 1064 nm
62
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 73/80
Conclusions
In conclusion, the addition of high energy materials, in this case pentaerythritol
tetranitrate (PETN), to metastable interstitial composites (MIC) such as thermite-tyoe
Al/Fe2O3 compositions changes the energy release dynamics compared to that of
traditional MIC compositions. This is observed as a decrease in the initiation time and the
duration of deflagration of the sample. This effect is attributed to the contribution to the
overall heating of the sample due to the combustion of the PETN. Since the PETN does
not absorb light, the process occurs through the indirect heating of the PETN from the
inorganic phases to the point where combustion occurs. The initiation time and
deflagration duration decreases with increasing PETN loadings but reaches a minimum at
about 64.0 mg PETN/g thermite. Compositions containing PETN were found to require amuch lower threshold energy for photo-thermal initiation. These results indicate that the
incorporation of an organic phase, even at low concentrations, can have a profound effect
on the reaction dynamics of MIC materials. This affords the possibility of tailoring the
organic phase to better optimize desired properties of the materials.
63
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 74/80
SUMMARY
This study has provided some insight into the stability and degradation processes
of traditional energetic materials, such as 2,4,6-trinitrotoluene (TNT) and pentaerythritol
tetranitrate (PETN) when placed in physical contact with metals or metal oxides. It was
found that in the presence of the metal oxides MnO2 and CuO, a clean demethylation of
TNT occurred, leaving the product trinitrobenzene (TNB). A rapid decomposition of
PETN, on the other hand, to gaseous species primarily made up of NO2 along with N2O4,
N2O, and CO2 occurred when placed on the surface of MoO3. These results indicate that
an interfacial surface effect occurs, which was observed as a change in the normal
thermal decomposition pathways of the molecule and may or may not have a net effect
on the stability or energy release in bulk composite materials.Also of interest was the reaction processes occurring during the initiation of
binary inorganic metastable interstitial composite (MIC) materials of aluminum and
iron(III) oxide as well as the energy release dynamics of hybrid organic/inorganic MIC
materials through laser initiation techniques. A laser desorption-ionization (LDI)
technique coupled with a time-of-flight mass spectrometer was used in order to show any
species occurring during the initiation process of MIC materials as ions reacting in the
plasma phase. Mixed metal oxides, such as [AlOFe]+, form from analogues of the iron
clusters the competition between Al+ and Fe+ in the thermite reaction.
The energy release dynamics of the classic thermite reaction in combination with
traditional high-energy materials, such as pentaerythritol tetranitrate (PETN), were
studied by time-resolved spectroscopy in order to monitor the light emitted from the
plasma of the reacting material using a Nd:YAG laser. A study of the initiation time,
measured as the time between the plume of the reacting materials brought on by the laser
pulse and the point where the intensity of the light becomes twice that of the noise, was
performed. This study shows a decrease in the initiation time as a function of the amount
of PETN present. Also, the total deflagration duration, measured as the total light emitted
from the reacting plasma, decreases with increasing amounts of PETN. The threshold
energy required in order to initiate the thermite reaction was also found to decrease
significantly as the amount of PETN present increases. Since PETN does not absorb light
64
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 75/80
at the wavelengths used, but enough energy is provided to melt the inorganic material,
heat must be transferred from the Al/Fe2O3 mixture to the PETN, allowing combustion to
occur. The heat of combustion of the PETN then provides enough heat back into the
inorganic mixture to affect the energy release dynamics of the system. This effect
suggests that possible tailoring of the organic phase may be possible in order better
optimize the properties of these materials.
65
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 76/80
REFERENCES
1. Cross, C.S. Explosive Compositions, Chem. Abs., 1969:526727, U.S. Dept. of theArmy: Great Britain, (1969).
2. DeVilliers, R. Molecular Explosives Containing Metal-Metal Oxide Mixtures asBooster or Primer Compositions, Chem. Abs., 2004:675703, Metlite Alloys:South Africa, (2004).
3. Jones, J.W. High-Energy-Density Composite Explosive Containing ThermiteCompositions Dispersed in Primary High Explosives, Chem. Abs., 2002:832736,U.S.P. Office, Lockheed Martin: USA, (2002).
4. Kloeber, M. And W. Schwartz. Laser-Sensitive Igniters, Chem. Abs.,1987:499288, Diehl G.m.b.H. and Co.: Germany, (1987).
5. Armstrong, A.W., Baschung, B., Booth, B.W., and Samirant, M. Nano Lett . 2003,3, 253.
6. Pantoya, M.L., Granier, J.J. Propellants, Explosives, and Pyrotechnics. 2005, 30,53.
7. Wang, L.L., Munir, Z.A., and Maximov, Y.M. Journal of Materials Science. 1993,28, 3693.
8. Wang, S.F., Yang, Y.Q., Sun, Z.Y., and Dlott, D.D. Chemical Physics Letters.2003, 368, 189.
9. Yang, Y.Q., Sun, Z.Y., Wang, S.F., and Dlott, D.D. Journal of Physical
Chemistry B. 2003, 107, 4485.
10. Moore, D.S., Son, S.E., and Asay, B.W. Propellants, Explosives, and
Pyrotechnics. 2004, 29, 106.
11. Boddington, T., Cottrell, A., Laye, P.G., and Singh, M. Thermochimica Acta.1986, 106, 253.
12. Boddington, T., Laye, P.G., Tipping, J., Whalley, D. Combustion and Flame.1986, 63, 359.
13. Rugunanan, R.A., Brown, M.E. Combustion Science and Technology. 1994, 95,117.
14. Bockmon, B.S., Pantoya, M.L., Son, S.F., Asay, B.W., and Mang, J.T. Journal of
Applied Physics. 2005, 98, 064903.
66
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 77/80
15. Granier, J.J. and Pantoya, M.L. Combustion and Flame. 2004, 138, 373.
16. Östmark, H. and Roman, N. Journal of Applied Physics. 1993, 73(4), 1993.
17. Weston, A. and Brown, P.A. HPLC and CE: Principles and Practice. Academic
Press: San Diego, 1997.
18. Gilbert, M.T. High Performance Liquid Chromatography. Wright: Bristol, 1987.
19. Niessen, W.M.A., ed. Current Practice of Gas Chromatography – Mass
Spectrometry. Marcel Dekker, Inc.: New York, 2001.
20. Willett, J.E. Gas Chromatography. John Wiley & Sons: Chichester, 1987.
21. Wendlandt, W.W.M. Thermal Analysis, 3rd
ed. John Wiley & Sons: New York,1986.
22. Rouquerol, F., Rouquerol, J., and Sing, K. Adsorption by Powders and Porous
Solids. Academic Press: San Diego, 1999.
23. Stuart B., George, B., and McIntyre, P. Modern Infrared Spectroscopy. JohnWiley & Sons: Chichester, 1996.
24. Wilkins, Charles L. and Jackson O. Lay. Identification of Microorganisms by
Mass Spectrometry. Hoboken, N.J.: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 2006.
25. Pasch, H. and Schrepp, W. MALDI-TOF Mass Spectrometry of Synthetic
Polymers. New York: Springer, 2003.
26. Siegman, A.E. Lasers. Mill Valley, CA: University Science Books, 1986.
27. Graham, D., Kennedy, A.R., McHugh, C.J., Smith, W.E., David, W.I.F.,Shankland, K., and Shankland, N. New Journal of Chemistry, 2004, 28, 161.
28. Brill, T.B. and James, K.J. Thermal-Decompostion of Energetic Materials. 62.Reconciliation of The Kinetics and Mechanisms of TNT on the Time-Scale fromMicroseconds to Hours. Journal of Physical Chemistry, 1993, 97(34), 8759.
29. Dacons, J.C., Adolph, H.G., and Kamlet, M.J. Some Novel ObservationsConcerning Thermal Decomposition of 2,4,6-Trinitrotoluene. Journal of Physical
Chemistry, 1970, 74(16), 3035.
30. Long, G.T., Brems, B.A., and Wight, C.A. Autocatalytic Thermal DecompositionKinetics of TNT. Thermochemica Acta, 2002, 388(1-2), 175.
67
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 78/80
31. Rogers, R.N. Combined Pyrolysis and Thin Layer Chromatography – A Methodfor Study of Decomposition Mechanisms. Analytical Chemistry, 1967, 39(7), 730.
32. Yinon, J., Fraisse, D., and Dagley, I.J. Electron Impact, Chemical Ionization and Negative Chemical Ionization Mass Spectra, and Mass-Analysed Ion Kinetic
Energy Spectrometry-Collision-Induced Dissociation Fragmentation Pathways of Some Dueterated 2,4,6-Trinitrotoluene Derivatives. Organic Mass Spectrometry,1991, 26(10), 867.
33. Moore, J.W. and Pearson, R.G. Kinetics and Mechanisms. New York: John Wiley,1981, p.21.
34. Bottaro, J.C., Malhorta, R., and Dodge, A. A facile two-step synthesis of 1,3,5-trinitrobenzene. Synthesis, 2004, 4, 499.
35. Desseigne, G. Preparation and Nitration of Pure Pentaerythritol. Memorial des
Poudres, 1951, 33, 169.36. Brand, H.V. Ab Initio All-Electron Periodic Hartree-Fock Study of Hydrostatic
Compression of Pentaerythritol Tetranitrate. Journal of Physical Chemistry B,2005, 109(28), 13668.
37. Mélen, F. and Herman, M. Vibrational Bands of Hx NyOz Molecules. J. Phys.
Chem. Ref. Data, 1992, 21(4), 831.
38. Mélen, F., Pokorni, F., and Herman, M. Vibrational Band Analysis of N2O4.Chemical Physics Letters, 1992, 194(3), 181.
39. Amoruso, S., Bruzzese, R., Spinelli, N., and Velotta R. J. of Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt.
Phys., 1999, 32, R131.
40. Amoruso, S., Amodeo, A., Berardi, V., Bruzzese, R., Spinelli, N., and Velotta, R. Applied Surface Science, 1996, 96-98, 175.
41. King, F.L., Dunlap, B.I., Parent, D.C. Journal of Chemical Physics, 1991, 94,2578.
42. Rosenband, V. Combustion and Flame, 2004, 137, 366.
43. Kline, K.L.M.S. Thesis, University of Florida, Gainsville, Fl, 2003.
44. Levitas, V.I., Asay, B.W., Son, S.F., Pantoya, M. Applied Physics Letters. 2006,89, 071909.
45. Maunit, B., Hachimi, A., Mannuelli, P., Calba, P.J., and Muller, J.F. Int. J. Mass
Spectrom. Ion Process. 1996, 156, 173.
68
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 79/80
46. Ornallas, D.L., Carpenter, J.H., Gunn, S.R. Detonation Calorimeter and ResultsObtained with Pentaerythritol Tetranitrate (PETN). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 1966, 37,907.
69
8/3/2019 Melissa Mileham- Stability and Degradation Processes of Energetic Materials
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/melissa-mileham-stability-and-degradation-processes-of-energetic-materials 80/80
BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH
The author was born in Springfield, Illinois on August 2, 1981. She attended
Butler University in Indianapolis, Indiana as an undergraduate where she received her
Bachelor of Science degree in Chemistry in May 2003. She began her graduate studies in
Chemistry at Florida State University in the fall of 2003 in the Department of Chemistry
and Biochemistry under Dr. Albert E. Stiegman.