Post on 06-Apr-2018
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
1/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
2/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
3/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
4/123
Vll1 PREFACE
what strikes us most prominently is tha! we can use thc notion 01 truth in orderto endorse or to deny a statement or ser of statemcnts without being requiredactualIy to repeat the statements; it is enough that we be ahle to nalTle thestatements. Thus, if 1 say
Every ex cathedra pronouncement 01' the Pope is true.1 have endorsed a1l of the ex cathedra pronouncemenrs of (he Pope. J havc, in asense, asserted rhe conjunction of al1 the Pope's ex cathedra pronouncements.Wlthout employing thc noton of tnJth, 1 could not do this, for 1 surely cannorrepear a11 of the Pope's pronouncemcnts. Using the norion of truth in the ordnaryway, we are able, lO etlect, ro pmduce (he conjuncrion or the disjuncton of aoarbltrary namcd set of sentences. Enabling us to do this is essental ro thenonphJ!osophical uscfulness of the ordinary notion of truth, aod if our scentifically reconstructcd notion of truth is to continue to perform the useful work thatOUT .ordmary notion performs, then it, too, must enable us in effeet to formconJunctlOns and dis junctions of named sets 01' sentenees. A l ~ h o u g h t h i ~ requirement by no means umquely determines our new theory of truth, it reIls us a greatde a) about what rhe new theory ought to look lile.Here 1 would like to develop a specific proposal for a way of thinking abouttrurh WhlCh wrll 1 hope h 1 .. ' . ' reserve tose oglcal 1'eatures which make our presentnotlOn of rruth so slllgularly usef l .. ' . u as a practJcal means for conveying informati onyet aVOld rhe contradictions th t ak '. . a m e our present norion of rruth so singularlyunsultable as a vehlcle for th . 1 ., , eoretlca undersrandlOg. The specific proposal is rotreat true as a vague term 1 d ' .. o not SUppose that lO ordlllary usage 'true' isslmply a vague tem like orher vague terrns 'True'" d' ' . 1many of the char t ", " lP. or lllary usage, dlSp ayst JI' ac ensrlCS typlcal ofv ague terms, but it displays other characteris-les a ltS Own notably the .I propenslty to paradox. The propasal here is that we:? a:e OUr OrdlOary usage of 'true ' by a sciemificaJly respectable usage that treatsrue S ~ n : P l y as a vague predicate Jike other vague predicates This reforrncdusage o true' wIIl, 1 shall cla1m be s' t" 'f ' bo .' " 'understandng f rh . ' a 1S actor)' eh as a busls tnr u thcoreticalo e connecrlOn between la d hfor accomplishing th nguage an t e world and as a meansour . e practIca], nonphilosophicaJ work now abJy per form ed byna] ve usage.We shall develop rule f ' fand show iliat thcse 1 s o bllllerence goveming the reformed usage of 'true'we employed th ru es ~ n a e us to employ the refoffilCd usage in jusr the wayse n3Jve usage to sImular , ' . . .sets of sentences Th d ' . conJunctlOn and dlsJunction of narncd. e para oxes anse Jt wIll be d f .of these rules of i n f e r e ' ' argue , rom the llllsapplicationTh l ' . nce 10 natural bur fallacious wayse u tlmate alm of rhis ende . .but rdo not attempt anythin av obr IS to develop a theory of truth for Engbsh,1 g so am ItlOUS here He 1 k' .anguages doing work th t . r' . re wor entlfely Wlth formalfor English. The plan' ta dS pre l m m ~ to the development of a theory of truthIS o eVlse techmques th t bla ena e us to develop a theory
PREFACE IX
of trurh for a formal Janguage : i within ,L itself, then to see Ir these sametechl1lques will not enable us ro develop a theory of trurh for Engllsh wlthmEnglish itself We are employing WJttgenstein's method ol' language games,practicing our phlosophlcal moves in a slmplified settlng before trying rhem outon English.The big phtlosophical cause this book aims uJtimately to promote IS the unity01 SClence. The dominant opinion has JI thar the bar antnomy proves that it isncver posslbJc ro clevclop a successful theory of truth for a language wlthlO thelanguage Itself; instead, one must clcveJop the theory of truth for a language : iwithlll a rnctalanguage that is richer than y; in expressivc power. ThJS implesIhat, sincc we have no rnetalanguage richer than English, we cannot develop atheory 01" truth for English, or for any naturallanguage. We can develop theoriesof tnHh for various fragJTIcnts of a natural language; fur exampJe wc can developa theory (Jf truth for the fragrIlent of lhe language thar we use when we talk aboulchernistry. But we cannot extend rhe theory ro encompass Ihe language wc usewhen we talk about language. We can develop a unified zooJogy that takesaccounl of aJI (he anirnals, and a unificd astronorny that takes account ol' all thelhe heavenly bodics. But we cannot, accordlOg to the dominant VICW, develop aunlfied linguisics Ihat takes accoun( of al! natural languages; we cannot evendcvelop a linguisric Iheory rhar takes account of he entlrety of any particularnatural language. UnlIkc natural phenomena, human languages lie mysteriouslybeyond the reach of scientific inqUlry.By provicling an altemative to rhe dominant vew, this work airns to encouragethe prospects far a unified science rhat trears nature and language as parts of aunited whole. 1 hope to prom ate the outlaok that human language lS a product ofhuman culture and human culture is part of the natural order, not inherently elthermore mysterious or less intelhgible rhan the planetary orbltSThis hook started out, several revisions ago. as my doctoral dissertatJOn forthe Logic and Methodology of SClence program ar rhe University of CalIforniaat Bcrkclcy. Bcrkeley is nor only a fun place to vlsit, it is an excellent place togo to graduate sehool, and 1 owe a great de al to the faculty there and to my felJowstudents.My dlsserta(ion adviser was Charles Chihara, who spent a great deal of timeand effort helping me with this project. His lOsights have proven invaluable;wilhout his help, this book could nor ha ve been wntten.Jack SjJver has given me a tremendous amount of help. He was very generouswith his time and ideas, and his extraordlllary combinaton of mathematical andphiJosophlcal ablllries have made his assistance nvaluableLet me express my thanks to three orher members of rhe faculty, EmestAdams, George Myro, and Bruce Vermazen, and to two of my fellow students,Shaughan Lavine and Sreven YabJo.Since Jeaving BerkeJey, 1 have been at rhe Unversty af Arizona. 1 used a
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
5/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
6/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
7/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
8/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
9/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
10/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
11/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
12/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
13/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
14/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
15/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
16/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
17/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
18/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
19/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
20/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
21/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
22/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
23/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
24/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
25/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
26/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
27/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
28/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
29/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
30/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
31/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
32/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
33/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
34/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
35/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
36/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
37/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
38/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
39/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
40/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
41/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
42/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
43/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
44/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
45/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
46/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
47/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
48/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
49/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
50/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
51/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
52/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
53/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
54/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
55/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
56/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
57/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
58/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
59/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
60/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
61/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
62/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
63/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
64/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
65/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
66/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
67/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
68/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
69/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
70/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
71/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
72/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
73/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
74/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
75/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
76/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
77/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
78/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
79/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
80/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
81/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
82/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
83/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
84/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
85/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
86/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
87/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
88/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
89/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
90/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
91/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
92/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
93/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
94/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
95/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
96/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
97/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
98/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
99/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
100/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
101/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
102/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
103/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
104/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
105/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
106/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
107/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
108/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
109/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
110/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
111/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
112/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
113/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
114/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
115/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
116/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
117/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
118/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
119/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
120/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
121/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
122/123
8/3/2019 MC GEE - Truth Vagueness and Paradox
123/123