Post on 03-Jun-2018
8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
1/20
International Political Economy #19
The Problem of Poverty
William Kindred Winecoff
Indiana University Bloomington
November 7, 2013
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 1/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
2/20
What Is Development?
Sustained improvement in a societys standard of living that is broadly
shared.
Narrow definition of development: increase in GDP per capita.
Broad definition: increase in quality of life, including literacy, infant
mortality, life expectancy, education, access to health care, etc.
These things are heavily correlated with each other and with
income.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 2/20
http://find/http://goback/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
3/20
Not Just Growth; Also Distribution
The broadly shared part is very important. Net wealth of all U.S.
presidents since 1776 combined is = $2.7 billion. Contrast with the
wealth of:
Abacha (Nigeria), $5 billion;
al-Bashir (Sudan), $7 bn;Babangida (Nigeria), $8 bn;
Mobutu (Zaire, now Congo DR), over $10 bn;
Mubarak (Egypt), over $40 bn;
Khaddafi (Libya), over $60 bn.
Nigeria ex-president Olusegun Obasanjo: corrupt African leaders havestolen at least $140 billion from their people in the decades since
independence.
Mo Ibrahim Prize for African Leadership: no recipient in 50% of years:
http://www.moibrahimfoundation.org/ibrahim-prize/.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 3/20
http://www.moibrahimfoundation.org/ibrahim-prize/http://www.moibrahimfoundation.org/ibrahim-prize/http://www.moibrahimfoundation.org/ibrahim-prize/http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
4/20
The Malthusian Trap
Thomas Malthus (1798) had a theory of economic (non)growth: we can
never do much better than subsistence living.
When were poor we have lots of kids, because some die
young and because many needed to work to support society:population grows exponentially.
But production grows linearly: inputs of labor at constant
productivity.
The result? The population outgrows the capacity to sustain itself until
something plague, famine, war pegs population back.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 4/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
5/20
The Malthusian Trap in Theory
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 5/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
6/20
The Malthusian Trap in Practice - Wealth
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 6/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
7/20
The Malthusian Trap in Practice - Population
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 7/20
http://find/http://goback/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
8/20
The Great Divergence
Poor Malthus: would have been correct if writing about any other time
in human history.
Theres a way to escape the trap: grow production exponentially to keep
up with population. I.e., improve technology.
The Industrial Revolution.
Who has industrialized? The Core. Who has not, at least in part? The
Gap.
This is The Great Divergence.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 8/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
9/20
Population by Region (in Millions)
1950 2005 Growth Rate
Industrialized 813 1,211 0.5%
Asia 1,400 3,905 0.64%
World (total) 2,519 6,465 0.75%
All Developing 1707 5,252 0.89%
Africa 224 906 1.7%
Least Developed 1,707 5,253 1.8%
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 9/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
10/20
Fertility Rates by Region, 2009
Developed World 1.7
World (total) 2.5
All-Developing 2.7
Least-Developed 4.3
Sub-Saharan Africa 4.51
The correlation should be pretty clear: the richer you are, the fewer
children you have.
So while the Core has escaped the Malthusian Trap, the Gap has not
fully done so.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 10/20
http://goforward/http://find/http://goback/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
11/20
Asymmetric Growth in the Americas
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 11/20
http://goforward/http://find/http://goback/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
12/20
Globalizing Malthus
How do we escape the trap?
The application of technology to the economy.
How do we get technology?
We have to save and invest.
Development, then ultimately depends on being able to save and invest.
S I = XM.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 12/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
13/20
The Logic of Development
Complicating this a bit more, we can say that development requires
structural change in the economy:
1 Workers get pulled away from agriculture into industry, or
from less-efficient to more-efficient modes of production.2 At first they are employed in low-capital industrial production,
e.g. textiles.
3 Over time, traditional labor-intensive production methods are
replaced by more modern capital-intensive methods. This
leads to increased productivity per unit of labor.As productivity rises, incomes rise too. (Unless corrupt governments
steal it.)
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 13/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
14/20
Investment Is the Key
So we need investment. We need capital.
Investment, in this context, refers to the purchase of machines and
infrastructure that are used to produce other goods. (What economistscall capital.)
Without investment: no new production methods > no productivity
growth > no economic growth > no development.
With investment: new production methods > productivity growth >
economic growth > development.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 14/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
15/20
Getting Investment
Okay, so we want investment growth. How do we get it?
Via savings, the portion of national income that is not
consumed.
In order to invest, you first need to save.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 15/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
16/20
The Problem
Poor people are poor. Often living at a subsistence level.
It is not easy to save when most of your income goes to food and
shelter.
If you cant save, you can import investment from other parts of the
world. (Hint: you already know how this works.)
But it might be difficult for poor countries with bad infrastructure, bad
governance, a depressed local market, and little human capital to be able
to attract foreign investment. Factor in frequent civil conflicts (or the
risk of them), and you can see why outsiders might not want to invest.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 16/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
17/20
Explaining Poverty, I
The Poverty Trap: The poor are poor because they are poor.
Self-reinforcing dynamics.
This argument underlies U.N. Millennium Development goals,
and is associated with thinkers like Jeffrey Sachs.
Consider a typical Malthusian country:
Low capital (investment) per capita (K/population), plus high
birth rates.
Low savings means you cant increase K fast; high birth rates
means population grows.Hence, K per capita falls with each generation.
Problem: some countries get out of this trap, even without outside help.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 17/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
18/20
Explaining Poverty, II
Structuralism: The poor are poor because they are exploited.
Global power asymmetries: Core extracts surplus from Gap.
This view very prevalent during decolonization period,
1950-1985, particularly in the UN.
Emphasized international trade as mechanism of exploitation.
Composition of Core-Gap trade: Core sends manufactured
goods, gets resources and commodities.
Tech progress in Core means manufacturing gets more
efficient; therefore terms of trade for Gap declines over time.No development if the Gap participates in the global economy.
Problem: some countries esp. in Asia have developed by
participating in the global economy. Those that havent have stagnated.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 18/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
19/20
Explaining Poverty, III
Neoliberalism: The poor are poor because they are inefficient.
Societies sometimes squander their resources.
Provides intellectual justification for Washington Consensus.
World Bank and IMF are fans, beginning in the 1980s.
Emphasized political failure rather than market failure.
Governments are corrupt: allocate resources to stay in power
rather than develop.
Creates culture of rent-seeking rather than risk-taking.
Investment is likely to be expropriated, so is not made.Development requires limiting the role of the state.
Problem: Many states have had large role for the state and had
successful development.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 19/20
http://find/8/12/2019 Lecture 19 Problem of Poverty
20/20
The International Politics of Development
The politics of development revolve around differences in theseapproaches.
Poverty trap is a tautology, and also not much of a theory, so well focus
on the other two.
Structuralism vs. Neoliberalism:Structuralism: If the problem is that market failures prevent
development, then the solution is to use the state to correct
the market failure.
Neoliberalism: Political failure is a bigger problem then
market failure, so keep the state small and allow markets towork their magic.
I.e., this debate is about the relative role of states and markets in
development.
W. K. Winecoff | IPE #19: Problem of Poverty 20/20
http://find/