Killing Twitter Trolls: finding & validating eyewitnesses

Post on 08-May-2015

7.781 views 0 download

description

Tech reporter and validation expert Henk van Ess presented 10 tips to validate tweets during a internet forum in Amsterdam on October 4th 2012

Transcript of Killing Twitter Trolls: finding & validating eyewitnesses

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Accounts fromTwitter

Henk van Ess www.searchbistro.com @henkvaness

finding & validating eyewitnesses

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

1. Find eyewitnesses

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Problem: an eyewitness doesn’t say eyewitness very often

https://twitter.com/i/#!/search-advanced

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

So what do eyewitnesses say?

We studied 2000 confirmed tweets of eyewitnesses ** Henk van Ess Medialab VVOJ.NL

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

So what do eyewitnesses say?

We studied 2000 confirmed tweets of eyewitnesses ** Henk van Ess Medialab VVOJ.NL

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

So what do eyewitnesses say?

We studied 2000 confirmed tweets of eyewitnesses ** Henk van Ess Medialab VVOJ.NL

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

So what do eyewitnesses say?

We studied 2000 confirmed tweets of eyewitnesses ** Henk van Ess Medialab VVOJ.NL

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

So what do eyewitnesses say?

We studied 2000 confirmed tweets of eyewitnesses ** Henk van Ess Medialab VVOJ.NL

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

So what do eyewitnesses say?

We studied 2000 confirmed tweets of eyewitnesses ** Henk van Ess Medialab VVOJ.NL

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

my

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

my

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

my

I, me

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

my

I, me

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

my

I, me

my

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

my

I, me

my

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

my

I, me

my

I

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

my

I, me

my

I

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

my

I, me

my

I

he

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Personal pronoun =possible relation of the

eyewitness withfact(s)/object(s)

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Personal pronoun =possible relation of the

eyewitness withfact(s)/object(s)

Use the laws of language

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Personal pronoun =possible relation of the

eyewitness withfact(s)/object(s)

Use the laws of language

WE

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Personal pronoun =possible relation of the

eyewitness withfact(s)/object(s)

Use the laws of language

HEWE

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Personal pronoun =possible relation of the

eyewitness withfact(s)/object(s)

Use the laws of language

IHEWE

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Personal pronoun =possible relation of the

eyewitness withfact(s)/object(s)

Use the laws of language

IHE

HIS

WE

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Personal pronoun =possible relation of the

eyewitness withfact(s)/object(s)

Use the laws of language

I

ME

HE

HIS

WE

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Personal pronoun =possible relation of the

eyewitness withfact(s)/object(s)

Use the laws of language

I

ME

HE

HIS

MY

WE

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Difference between geodata in bio & actual tweets

tweet

bio

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

geodata in bio can be easily faked

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

geodata in bio can be easily fakedgeodata in tweet is harder to fake

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

geodata in bio can be easily fakedgeodata in tweet is harder to fake

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

geodata in bio can be easily fakedgeodata in tweet is harder to fake

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Mind your language

• Use personal pronouns with keywords

• Try also, if any, to include geodata

• Keep it simple

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

https://geofeedia.com

By location:

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

www.bing.com/social

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012twicsy.com

By pictures:

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

http://searchinstagram.com

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

http://search.coolstreaming.us/live/

By Livestreams

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

By newspapers

www.bing.com

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

2. Validation tips

Friday, October 5, 12

all fake accountsFriday, October 5, 12

all fake accountsFriday, October 5, 12

all fake accountsFriday, October 5, 12

all fake accountsFriday, October 5, 12

all fake accountsFriday, October 5, 12

all fake accountsFriday, October 5, 12

all fake accountsFriday, October 5, 12

all fake accountsFriday, October 5, 12

all fake accountsFriday, October 5, 12

all fake accountsFriday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

So who should we believe?

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

TIP 1

• The usual stuff: fact checking! F.e. can you find proof for the claim that Malik is an independent reporter? What does the text in Arabic say?

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

bio check:

https://twitter.com/malikalAbdeh

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Why a Syrian reporter?

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Why a Syrian reporter?

In hindsight : it makes sense :)

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Why a Syrian reporter?

In hindsight : it makes sense :)

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

TIP 2

• Look who’s talking (to him)

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012https://twitter.com/i/#!/search-advanced

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

https://twitter.com/i/#!/search/realtime/to%3Amalikalabdeh

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

TIP 3

• Analyze followers & who Malik follows

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

https://followerwonk.com/analyze/MalikAlAbdeh

Who he follows

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

His followers

https://followerwonk.com/wPFV

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

https://followerwonk.com/analyze/MalikAlAbdeh

His words

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

http://www.tweetstats.com/graphs/malikalabdeh

His virtual friends & more

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

TIP 4

• Do historical research. Try to find hidden data with historical research & archive.org

• Find older tweets with Datagrip/ Gnip

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Check owner of the website for a period of years

http://www.domaintools.com

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

TIP 5

• Check stats for irregularities

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012http://twittercounter.com/MalikAlAbdeh/6month/followers

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Is the timezone consistent?

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Is this what you expected?

https://followerwonk.com/analyze/MalikAlAbdeh

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Tip 6

• Use Klout - yeah, it has some purpose :)

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

http://klout.com/#/MalikAlAbdeh

glance at possible topics find people who can vouch for your subject

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Tip 7

• Do additional research in Socialmentions.com

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

http://socialmention.com/search?q=malikalabdeh&t=all&btnG=Search

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Tip 8: too much data ? Use Excel

Excel file from http://socialmention.com/search?q=malikalabdeh&t=all&btnG=Search

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Tip 9

• Search for more photo’s and video’s: databases of Twitter & YFrog/Mobypicture/Twitpic DO differ!

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

yfrog.com

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

http://twicsy.com/i/nAJh5

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Tip 10

• Validate pictures

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

http://images.google.com

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

http://images.google.com

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

http://images.google.com

Friday, October 5, 12

Twitter: we got the killer!

Friday, October 5, 12

Friday, October 5, 12

Friday, October 5, 12

Text

Friday, October 5, 12

other tips

• is the person in a list, if yes, which one (s)?

• too good to be true ?

• consistency

• check favorite tweets

• always think contextual

Friday, October 5, 12

Slides from Henk van Ess / NVJ Forum October 4th 2012

next time

• how to validate protected accounts!

Friday, October 5, 12