January 11, 2006 LOST PROFITS: Are They Recoverable? When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded...

Post on 29-Jan-2016

215 views 0 download

Transcript of January 11, 2006 LOST PROFITS: Are They Recoverable? When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded...

January 11, 2006

LOST PROFITS: LOST PROFITS: Are They Are They Recoverable?Recoverable?

When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not

Awarded the Contract/Sub-ContractAwarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

Presented to

The NCMA – Cape CanaveralThe NCMA – Cape Canaveral

ChapterChapter

Presented By

Gary Marcus, Esq.Gary Marcus, Esq.

66 North Village Avenue

Rockville Centre, NY 11590

(T) 516-764-2800

(F) 516-764-2827

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

IntroductionIntroduction

“Rethinking Lost Profits”

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

Protesting A Contract AwardPrime ContractSub-Contract

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

Protesting Award Of A Prime Contract – VenuesAgencyGAOUS Court of Federal Claims

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

Protesting Award Of A Prime Contract – Denial of ReliefLack of StandingLack of Subject Matter Jurisdiction

AntitrustPatent InfringementContractor Responsibility

Override of Stay – Urgent and Compelling NeedLack of Jurisdiction Over Agency

FAAPostal Authority

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

Protesting Award Of A Prime Contract – Relief SoughtStay of Award or Contract PerformanceCancellation of Award and Award to Protestor

Recovery of Bid CostsRecovery of Protest CostsRecovery of Attorney’s FeesRecovery of Lost Profits??

Cancellation of Award and Re-Bid

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

Protesting Award Of A Sub-ContractBreach of A Teaming AgreementBreach of Implied Contract

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

Protesting Award Of A Sub-Contract – RemediesDamages – Bid CostsInjunctive ReliefLost Profits

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

Lost ProfitsWinstar CasesEnergy Capital Case

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

Lost Profits – Elements

Foreseeability

Reasonable Certainty

Proximate Cause

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

SummarySummary

Adequacy of Remedies Under Current Law

Balance of the Equities

In Terrorem Effect

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

Questions & Answers

January 11, 2006The NCMA Cape Canaveral Chapter

Lost Profits: When A Contractor/Sub-Contractor Is Not Awarded the Contract/Sub-Contract

66 North Village Avenue

Rockville Centre, NY 11590

(T) 516-764-2800

(F) 516-764-2827

www.goldbergconnolly.com