Post on 07-Apr-2018
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
1/25
The Harris-Todaro Model
If wages were perfectly flexible equal
wages would be paid in industry andagriculture and there would be no
unemployment
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
2/25
In a perfectly competitive market
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
3/25
For a variety of reasons however workers in
the urban formal sector are paid higher than
equilibrium wages Unions
government policy
incentives to workers to expend effort whenlabor cannot be directly supervised withouttremendous costs.
The threat being fired. Then one wouldhave to return to the country or find work inthe urban informal sector.
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
4/25
At the same time, in the rural sector and the informal urban
sector wages rise and fall according to supply and demand.
Such conditions
give rise to the
following:
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
5/25
Here LF workers find employment in good jobs in the cities,
LA remain behind in the countryside working at a lower wage
of wA. Those who migrated from the countryside to the city
find themselves employed in the urban informal sector
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
6/25
As a result, many people end up
in relatively unproductive dead-
end service sector jobs in thecities.
Urban overcrowding due to high rates of
migration from rural areas to cities and
high informal sector employment is a fact
of life in many low and middle income
countries. (review table 2.4, page 39)
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
7/25
The Harris-Todaro model helps
to explain this seemingly
irrational phenomenon
First, lets define real per capita
income in the rural sector:(PA/P)(Q
TA/N
TR)
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
8/25
Definition of terms
PA=agricultural prices
P=general price levelQTA=total agricultural production.
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
9/25
Next we define urban formal
sector income
wF*n*((NT
C-Nu)/NT
C)=wFn(1-u)
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
10/25
Definition of terms
WF =the wage paid for good jobs in the
city.
N=the number of hours worked per period
per worker
u=the formal sector unemployment rate
(other terms defined in class).
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
11/25
Finally lets define urban
informal sector income
WI *n*u
where wI=the wage per hour paid inthe informal sector.
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
12/25
It is sensible to assume that migration
continues as long as urban incomes are
significantly higher than rural incomes.
Or in otherwords migration occurs
when wFn(1-u)+wInu>k[(PA/P)(Q
TA/N
TR)]
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
13/25
Now think about u, the rate of
unemployment in the formal sector (1) The higher U is, the more people there
are actively seeking formal sector
employment that are unable to find it. (2) The higher U is the lower the probability
of a new migrant from the country finding a
formal sector job. (3) Without a social safety net, he or she
will have to make work for themselves in
the informal sector.
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
14/25
And because of the preceding
wFn(1-u)+wInu
Can be thought of as the wage one
can expect if they move to the city.And the lower u is the higher the
expected wage
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
15/25
The main point of Harris-Todaro is
that if the expected urban wage ... equals rural income there is no incentive to
migrate.
is greater than rural income there is a greatincentive to move from country to city
were less than rural incomes there would be an
incentive to move in the other direction. (South
Korea in recent years)
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
16/25
The expected urban wage
depends on what type of
job you land, that dependson probabilities and these
are linked to current urbanunemployment rate as
defined above.
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
17/25
Therefore to understand the model
set rural and expected urban
incomes equal and solve the abovefor u, the urban unemployment rate
U={wFn- (k[(PA/P)(QTA/N
TR)]}
/n(WF-WI)
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
18/25
From this result we can show the
following: U will increase if wF increases!
U will increase if n increases!
U will increase if k drops.
U will increase if QTA/NT
Rfalls.
U will increase if wI increases!
U will increase if PA/P decreases.
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
19/25
One failing of the Harris-Todaro
model assumes migrants are risk-
neutral
This means that the utility of a
gamble where the payoff is $6000 isthe same as the utility of $6000
guaranteed.
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
20/25
This is not realistic. Especially
poor migrants will be risk averse
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
21/25
This means that to the degree
potential migrants are risk-averse
The less net migration out of rural
areas will be given the gap betweenrural and urban wages. Consider k a
measure of the degree of risk
aversion.
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
22/25
Rays discussion of social capital
Ray raises an interesting point in
relation to this issue of risk aversion.He begins by pointing out that
information is high and mobility is
low in rural areas
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
23/25
In other words, every one
knows your business in asmall village and it is hard
to move.
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
24/25
This means that
In terms of insurance and credit, rural areas
provide a strong support network for the poor (this
is his social capital)
If someone runs into trouble the community
knows why.(If not due to your own negligence
you will receive some support)
Low mobility also gives rise to reciprocity . Onehelps others in their time of need knowing that
they will help them in return.
8/6/2019 Harris-Todaro Chapter 10 D Ray
25/25
Once migration starts however
This social capital will be eroded and
thus, all else equal, lowers the cost ofmigrating since local rural support
breaks down.