Post on 09-Apr-2018
2
Presentation Content
Review of Chemistry and Hazards
Comparison of Water-Based, Solvent Based and Energy Curable Inks
Health and Safety Risks
EPA Position
Ink Composition
Sustainable Issues
New technology approach for flexible packaging ink
Biodegradability
3
Flexible Packaging Inks: Are They Green and Are they Safe?
As with most printing inks, Flexo and Gravure inks do contain “hazardous”components, but are safe and effective when used properly.
Potential hazards:
– Solvent based inks are flammable and ignitable, however, generally these inks are not reactive.
– Water-based inks, dependent on the % solvent incorporated can also be flammable, they are not ignitable or reactive.
– UV inks can be reactive depending on composition.
– EB inks can be reactive depending on composition
Although significant portions of inks may be composed of bio and naturally occurring components, this may not imply they would be classified as “Green” or non-hazardous!
4
Potential Risks vs. Classification of Ink Systems
Flammability Ignitability Reactivity
Solvent- Based
Highly Yes No
Water-Based Low to high No No
UV/EB No No Yes
5
Health and Safety Concerns
All ink classes may impose some potential chemical risk
Dermal and inhalation are the main routes of exposure
Solvent and water-based inks risk are generally related to solvents.
UV risk is mainly related to reactivity skin sensitivity.
Press-side additions, common in both water-based and solvent-based inks can pose an additional risk in handling and containment.
Even when formulated to contain bio-derived materials, health and safety risks must be accessed
6
EPA’s Structure Activity Study
EPA performed a thorough study comparing 3 different Flexo ink chemistries to determine overall risks and environmental impact.Study included water-based, solvent-based and UV inks, all used for printing wide-web flexo.Study was completed in early 2000’s and did not include EB, which today is also a viable method.For the purpose of this presentation EB is similar in chemical composition to UV, without photoinitiators.
EPA found Water-based inks to have lower potential hazards with lower energy requirements
7
Water-Based Inks
As regulated, water-based inks can contain up to 25% solvent to be classified as “water-based”– Typical water-based inks may contain from 1-10% solvents– Additionally, some water-based inks contain hazardous air
pollutants (HAP’s)– Alcohols, amides, nitrogenous compounds and glycols exposure
routes are typically inhalation and dermal.– Energy consumption of water-based inks are considered favorable
in comparison to solvent-based inks which required treatment.– Water-based inks can easily utilize bio-based components
In practice, water-based inks require adaptations in applicationand are generally printed at lower press speeds, but are effective
8
Solvent-Based Inks
High concentration of VOC’s compared to water-based inks
Oxidizers are used to destroy emissions outside of the printing facility
Alcohols, esters and some hydrocarbon solvents and glycols represent potential risk to workers.
Bio-based alcohols may be used in favor of petro-based, however, overall impact on sustainability is low.
9
UV/EB InksAcetylated polyols used as reactive diluents.Components are active and not volatilePhotoinitiators have the potential for migration issues to occur in the final package.EB technology is applicable to “Wet on Wet” trapping, inks are commercially available. EC inks can be formulated with negligible VOC levels, eliminating the energy used to recapture solvent. Curing process often consumes less energy than the dryers required to evaporate other inks. Energy curable inks do not dry up on press, wash-up is facilitated
UV and EB cured inks offer a number of advantages towards reducing environmental impact at the press.
10
Newest Technology for Flexo: Advantages of EB vs. Other Ink Chemistries
EB Wet-On-Wet Advantages:– NO SOLVENTS– NO VOC’S– NO SOLVENT LICENSING or EXPOSURE– NO SOLVENT COSTS– NO INCINERATION– NO INTERSTATION DRYING– NO HEAT… less waste– NO PHOTOINITIATORS– NO/LOW EXTRACTABLES– NO/LOW ODOR– POTENTIAL IN-LINE LAMINATION
*Reproduced from ESI
11
EB AdvancementsHigher potential for use in food packaging vs. UV
May offer some cost advantages vs. UV
Applications for a variety of end-use packaging
No VOC’s
Lower energy requirements
Excellent reproduction quality
EB provides a favorable carbon footprint
12
Overall Ink Considerations:
Solvent-based inks appear to have the most “suspect” ingredients. – As they are readily captured, the overall risk is low. – Oxidators used on press may contribute to green-house gases and other
potential pollutants. – Energy consumption related to the use of solvent-based inks were rated
high, primarily due to the recovery systems employed.Water-based inks represent lower risks than solvent-based inks. – Water-based inks with high VOC’s may have similar risks to solvent-based
inks. – Water-based inks were found to have lower energy requirements, even
though they require higher air volumes and heat on press to dry.EB will likely be favored vs, UV, both represent low risk
Independent of source and origin, green materialscarry similar risks in a formulated ink products.
14
Sustainability Factors for Inks
Various organizations and companies have released sustainability definitions and statements.Dominant themes are:– Source of materials– Energy / conservation– Waste / end-of-life– Economics / performance
15
Sustainability Factors for Flexible Packaging Inks
Ink manufacturing– Renewable materials
– Production (emissions, energy, waste)
– Origin and transportation
Performance on sustainable substrates– Printability / appearance
– Functionality
– Barrier coatings applied by printing
End-of-life– Biodegradability of final article
with dry ink film
– Recycling
16
Current Status of Flexible Packaging Inks
Current ink systems often contain some bio- based materials and can be combined with petroleum-based materials to deliver the performance demanded for theapplication(s). Use of bio-derived materials should positively impact sustainability from a material perspective.
17
ASTM MethodsFrom ASTM D 6852:
Bio-based Material: Organic material in which carbon is derived from a renewable resource via biological processes. Bio-based materials include all plant and animal mass derived from CO2 recently fixed via photosynthesis.
Renewable Resource: Resource that replenishes or can be made to replenish on an essentially predictable time schedule. Old growth forests, rare species and all fauna and flora not regenerated on an essentially predictable time scale are not considered renewable resource. Generally the renewal cycle time is less than human life span (<100 years).
A renewable or bio-based material does not imply it is compostable or biodegradable
18
Sustainability Factors for Flexible Packaging Inks
A variety of opportunities to improve sustainability arise during the formulation, manufacture, and use of ink.
Scorecards and statements emphasize the need for many factors to be considered when selecting or developing products with improved sustainability.
Ink and adhesive impact has not yet been addressed by retailers and consumer product groups.
19
Ink CompositionMain ink components:
Pigment: The majority of pigments in use today are synthetic materials designed to deliver high strength so that they can be formulated at low levels, due to their impact on costs. – Organic or inorganic solids which provide color– May not be present in transparent coating productResin: Ink resins must interact successfully with the pigments, the solvents, the printing technology they are designed for, and the substrate they will adhere to. Their chemistry may contribute to the drying/crosslinking of the ink film on the substrate. They help give formulated inkthe viscosity for the printing method and provide adhesion, appearance (gloss), and resistance properties to the final film – Wets pigment; provides gloss, adhesion, other propertiesSolvent: Solvents mobilize the solid components. The phase change from a liquid or paste ink to a solid ink film is accomplished by evaporation, curing, or absorption of the solvent into the substrate. A range of solvent systems are encountered in inks, depending on the printing method, including water, oils, toluene, alcohols, acetates, and none at all. – Mobilizes the solid components; cures, evaporates, or penetrates substrateAdditives: A variety of materials including waxes, defoamers and special functional material are available.– For special performance needs
Actual raw materials used vary widely among different printing technologies and substrates
20
Polymer Examples of Bio-based Materials in InksModern ink systems often contain some bio-based materials and are combined with petroleum-based materials to deliver performance demanded by current printing technologySome bio-based resources currently used in inks suffer supply/price pressures– Rosin-derived resins
Prices skyrocketingFuture global capacity questionable
– ShellacPrice fluctuations, inconsistent performanceLimited harvesting
– NitrocelluloseGlobal reduction in number of manufacturersHigh costPotential danger in handling and storage
21
Examples of BiopolymersPolyesters– Polylactic acid– Polyhydroxyalkanoates
Proteins– Silk– Soy protein– Corn protein (zein)
Polysaccharides– Xanthan– Gellan– Cellulose– Starch– Chitin
Polyphenols– Lignin
– Tannin
– Humic acid
Lipids– Waxes
– Surfactants
Specialty polymers– Shellac
– Natural rubber
– Nylon (from castor oil)
Thames Research Group
22
Pigments
Mainly organic; typically constitute 10-18% of inkAlternative manufacturing to reduce loss/waste and lower environmental impact has been successfulStrength and purity of colorants difficult to reproduce using alternative chemistriesNaturally occurring pigments do not afford the color values required
New renewable resource technology will likely impact resins first, pigments later
23
Bio-derived Materials in Flexo Inks
Ink technology Film-forming component
Solvent & mobilizing component
Amount renewable resource / VOC’s
Water-based Acrylic emulsion or solution
Water Little or none (but 95% VOC-free)
Solvent-based Cellulose esters, urethanes, polyamides, acrylic
Organic solvents (and corn-based ethanol)
10-15% (50% VOC at application)
Oleoresinous Rosin esters; vegetable oils and alkyds
Petroleum distillates, fatty acid esters
30-40% (higher levels available); VOC varies
Energy curing Acrylate esters or biscycloaliphatic epoxides
Reactive diluents (acrylates, epoxides)
10% possible with fatty acid derivatives (VOC- free)
24
Bio-derived Materials in Inks
Renewable Resource Function Application
Vegetable oils (linseed, Tung, soybean)
Oxidative drying Litho publication, sheetfed packaging
Cellulose (nitro-, acetate, propionate)
Modified rosin
Shellac
Proteins
Film-formers (meet required solubility, drying, resistance properties)
Solvent-based flexo; solvent-based screen; litho packaging
Esterified fatty acids Solvents Litho publication and some packaging
Functions of some major renewable resources in inks
25
Bio-derived Materials in InksSources of sustainable raw materials:
Cultivated streams (corn, soybean, etc.)– Some receiving increased support due to biofuels
initiatives– Polysaccharides (starches, etc.), proteins, oilsBiomass waste streams– Lignocellulosics, chitin/chitosanBio-based building blocks– PLABiosynthesis– Xanthan, pullulan, bacterial cellulose, PHA
26
Bio-derived Materials in Inks
Some already have a history as raw material sources for inks, coatings, and additives
Many experiencing increasing interest as resins for coatings/films
27
Bio-derived Materials in Flexo Inks
Sustainable raw materials: renewable and availableContrast:Petroleum-derived raw materials (acrylics, etc): essentially non-renewableTraditional bio-based raw materials (NC, rosin, shellac): manufacture/availability issues driving up price
28
Bio-derived materials in Inks
Properties bio-based resins must meet in printing formulations:– Gloss– Adhesion– Viscosity/stability– Pigment wetting– Compatibility– Fast, thorough drying on substrate while easy to clean off press– Durability in final product– Easy to handle– Low Cost– Compatible with many different films and adhesives
Current systems extensively formulated to provide these properties today, some compromises may be realized when incorporating Bio- based materials
29
Bio-derived Materials in Inks
Printing inks based on naturally-derived raw materials are available.
For some applications, further research will be required to develop bio-based resins with the needed performance properties.
Development of bio-based pigments will likely lag behind development of bio-based resins.
Percentages of bio-based components will vary by application
31
Emerging Solutions: Barrier Coatings
Considering the potential for compromised ink performance using bio-based/naturally derived materials, enhancements to the performance of these inks are possible by employing barrier coatings.
Functional and barrier coatings based upon chemistries outside the scope of traditional ink components can be used.
Materials are compliantAfford performance attributes to finished productAre generally non-bio accumulatingReadily biodegradability
32
Prevents the penetration or loss of gases, light or odors which can cause advanced spoilage of the packaged product. In addition act as effective barriers to prevent migration.
Prevents the penetration or loss of gases, light or odors which can cause advanced spoilage of the packaged product. In addition act as effective barriers to prevent migration.
What are Barrier CoatingsWhat are Barrier Coatings
33
Alternative Approach: Barrier Coatings
Barrier coatings: lower permeability of oxygen, aroma, moisture, etc. –extend shelf life of package contents– Current technology: often a barrier substrate or laminate, which includes
an adhesive– Alternative technology: printable coating (flexo, gravure, other coating
process) which can be thinner and facilitate lower waste, easier disposal & recycling
– Potentially, a thin barrier film will have less impact on compostability of degradable packaging
34
Alternative Approach: Barrier Coatings
Barrier coatings can offer enhancements to conventional inks and packaging structures
Barrier coatings to reduce number of packaging elements
Barrier coatings can prolong shelf-life
Barrier coatings that replace non-preferred structures and coatings (PVDC etc.)
Barrier coatings can promote compliance
Barrier coatings as “light-weighting” alternatives offer benefit to multi-layer complex structures
35
RetortPackaging
FoodPackaging
Dry Foods PerishableFoods
Barrier Coatings: Primary Focus and Application Space for Barrier Coatings: Primary Focus and Application Space for Flexible PackagingFlexible Packaging
Targeted Market Applications
OxygenBarrier
LiquidLaminates
36
Commercial 3-Ply Laminate New 2-Ply Laminate
Barrier Coatings: Oxygen Barrier Coatings andBarrier Coatings: Oxygen Barrier Coatings and Sustainable FeaturesSustainable FeaturesLight Weighting Flexible Model
Less complex laminate structureLighter weight packaging (30% reduction)
Improved laminate integrity (post flexing O2 barrier improvement)Improved shelf life
Removal of Metalized layer and one layer of adhesiveImproved recycling
Coatings that enable the next generation of food packaging technology and design while promoting an environmental focus
Polymer FilmAdhesiveMET Polymer FilmAdhesivePolymer Film
Polymer FilmAdhesiveBarrier CoatingPolymer Film
37
Coatings designed for in-line application
PVdC or EVOHCoated Films
MET-PolymerFilms
e.g. MET-Polyester or MET-Polypropylene
CoextrudedFilms
e.g. Polyethylene-EVOH-Polyethylene
Al2 O3 / SiOxCoated Films
Oxygen Barrier Coating: Oxygen Barrier Coating: Model ApplicationsModel Applications
Light Weighting
e.g. Clear barriers, mainly PET
e.g. Chlorine elimination
38
Barrier Coatings for Bio-Based Substrates
Preliminary research : flexo system lowered oxygen permeability of biodegradable substrates (23°C, 50% RH):– PLA film with no coating: >> 100 cc/m2/day
with coating: 2.7
– Cellulose film with no coating: 30.2 with coating: 0.50
Printing technology can be used to improve properties of renewable substrates.
39
Polymers from renewable sources
Coatings with lower environmental impact
Waste reduction
Conservation of energy, less processing
Improved recycling
Solution: Functional Coatings Solution: Functional Coatings
Making products greener
41
Converters have an interest in understanding the degree to which inks are biodegradable.
For most printed articles intended to be labeled as biodegradable, this environment would probably be industrial or home composting.
Compostable substances must biodegrade at a rate similar to the materials normally found in compost; 90% of the carbon in a blend of polymers must be converted into carbon dioxide in 180 days.– Inks are rarely 100% composed of individual materials that would be considered compostable by this definition.
The biodegradation rate of natural materials such as cellulose can be slowed by derivatization, and some bio-based materials may undergo cross-linking in the final film. – This makes it difficult to assume that these components will meet the qualifying rate of compostability, despite
their natural origin.
– Ink film makes up only a small portion of most printed articles, and may not affect their compostability rate much.
Biodegradability: How important is it?
The standards by which biodegradability is determined rely on identifyingthe environment in which the article would be expected to undergo decompositionby microorganisms.
42
Biodegradability
Normally, dry ink film is not expected to significantly affect biodegradation rate of final article, even when ink contains pigments or acrylics– Many current ink resins such as cellulose derivatives and vegetable oils
will biodegrade, but not as quickly as starches/proteins (e.g. cellulose acetate: similar to wood)
Must establish that heavy metal requirements are met and that plant growth is not affected– e.g. blue and green inks may contain Cu
43
Biodegradability
In many applications (smaller print area on medium-heavy gauge material), amount of dry ink film will be almost negligible
Certain heavy metals such as Cr, Pb have been eliminated from most ink products
Alternative metal-based pigments available and continue to be developed
D 6400 EN 13432As 20.5 5
Cd 17 0.5
Cr - 50
Cu 750 50
Pb 150 50
Hg 8.5 0.5
Mo - 1
Ni 210 25
Se 50 0.75
Zn 1400 150
Heavy metal limits (concentration in tested product, mg/kg):
44
Biodegradability
Consider all aspects of ink formulation such as metals
Continuing research on bio-based resin / pigment materials should increase print loading possible on thinner compostable substrates
45
ConclusionsFlexo inks regardless of the chemistry chosen are safe and effective.
– End-use and packaged components are paramount in deciding process and chemistry
Each class of chemistries used in developing flexo inks have positive and negative implications
– Total cost to use models are available
A variety of opportunities to improve sustainability arise during the manufacture and use of ink
Printing inks based on naturally-derived raw materials are available
46
Conclusions
Further research will be required to develop and expand use of bio-based resins and pigments
Printing technology can be used to apply barrier coatings to renewable substrates
Dry ink film on a typical package may not have much impact on compostability - should confirm through testing
Barrier coatings can increase product integrity and package performance
We can manage and minimize risks that can positively enhance safety and environmental impact