Post on 03-Feb-2018
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
1/84
Northeastern University
Mechanical Engineering Undergraduate CapstoneProjects
Department of Mechanical and IndustrialEngineering
December 04, 2007
Flexible carbon nanotube based temperaturesensor for ultra-small-site applications
Brendan CrawfordNortheastern University
Dan EspositoNortheastern University
Vishal JainNortheastern University
David PelletierNortheastern University
Tis work is available open access, hosted by Northeastern University.
Recommended CitationCrawford, Brendan; Esposito, Dan; Jain, Vishal; and Pelletier, David, "Flexible carbon nanotube based temperature sensor for ultra-small-site applications" (2007).Mechanical Engineering Undergraduate Capstone Projects. Paper 55. hp://hdl.handle.net/2047/d10012904
http://iris.lib.neu.edu/mech_eng_capstonehttp://iris.lib.neu.edu/mech_eng_capstonehttp://iris.lib.neu.edu/mech_ind_enghttp://iris.lib.neu.edu/mech_ind_enghttp://iris.lib.neu.edu/mech_ind_enghttp://iris.lib.neu.edu/mech_ind_enghttp://iris.lib.neu.edu/mech_eng_capstonehttp://iris.lib.neu.edu/mech_eng_capstone7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
2/84
Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for
Ultra-Small-Site Applications
MIMU 701-702
Technical Design Report
December 4, 2007
Department of Mechanical and Industrial Engineering
College of Engineering, Northeastern University
Boston, MA 02115
Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature
Sensor for Ultra-Small-Site Applications
Final Report
Design Advisor: Prof. Constantinos Mavroidis, Prof.
Yung Joon Jung, Dr. Azadeh Khanicheh
Design Team
Brendan Crawford, Dan Esposito,
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
3/84
Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-
Small-Site Applications
Design TeamBrendan Crawford, Dan Esposito,
Vishal Jain, David Pelletier
Design Advisor
Prof. Dinos Mavroidis, Prof. Yung Joon Jung,
Dr. Azadeh Khanicheh
Abstract
There are many current and future temperature measurement applications that would benefitsignificantly from a commercially available, low power consuming, ultra-small-scaletemperature sensor. The superior material properties of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) havesuggested that it is possible to create a device that will meet these requirements and also havebetter performance when compared to devices currently available in the market However, thereare currently no commercially available temperature sensors that make use of the advantages inusing CNTs as a small-scale sensing element due to relatively high cost of manufacturing. Thisreport outlines the design, fabrication, and testing of a novel CNT-based Temperature Sensorencapsulated in a thin film of flexible Parylene C. The design employs a single-walled carbonnanotube (SWNT) network between two micro-scale electrodes as the sensing element. Theresulting device exploits the extremely small size of SWNTs as well as their superior thermal
and electrical properties by deriving the temperature based on a change in electrical resistancethat is induced by thermal strain. The sensitivity of the sensor is maximized by making use of anexpansion element (with high thermal coefficient of expansion), which is a novel method forregulating strain in the SWNT network, and was a key factor in relating thermal strain toelectrical resistance. The sensor requires power in the microwatt rangeorders of magnitudeless than that of typical micro-scale sensors. The basic concept prototype sensors beingfabricated can be characterized to measure temperature and predictions can be made successfullyabout the improvement in overall performance of the expanding element concept, whencompared against a device with it.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
4/84
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER # 1: INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................. 71.1 Problem Statement ........................................................................................................................71.2 General Information and Considerations for Nanotechnology ....................................................7
1.3 Nano-scale Challenges.....................................................................................................................91.4 Advantages of Carbon Nanotubes ..................................................................................................91.5 Summary and Significance of Nanotechnology Research .........................................................11
CHAPTER # 2: BACKGROUND............................................................................................................. 122.1 Introduction...................................................................................................................................... 122.2 Patents..............................................................................................................................................122.3 Literature Review.............................................................................................................................152.4 Summary of Current Technology ..................................................................................................212.5 Other Temperature Measurement Devices ...................................................................................222.6 Why Use CNTs for Temperature Measurement?..........................................................................22
CHAPTER # 3: Design Development.................................................................................................... 23
3.1 Introduction...................................................................................................................................... 233.2 Interviews.........................................................................................................................................233.3 Needs Assessment..........................................................................................................................283.4 Specifications ..................................................................................................................................303.5 Initial Concepts................................................................................................................................ 323.6 Concept Selection...........................................................................................................................403.7 Summary of Initial Design Concepts.............................................................................................41
CHAPTER # 4: DETAILED DESIGN ...................................................................................................... 434.1 Introduction...................................................................................................................................... 434.2 Detailed Design Concept................................................................................................................434.3 Modeling...........................................................................................................................................444.4 CAD Drawings.................................................................................................................................. 53
CHAPTER # 5: NANOMANUFACTURING PROCESS..........................................................................57
CHAPTER # 6: PROTOTYPING AND TESTING ...................................................................................636.1 Prototyping ......................................................................................................................................636.2 Testing..............................................................................................................................................70
CHAPTER # 7: CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE WORK........................................................................ 747.1 Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................... 747.2 Future Work .....................................................................................................................................74
APPENDIX A: Material Properties ........................................................................................................ 76APPENDIX B: Detailed Manufacturing Steps...................................................................................... 76
REFERENCES ........................................................................................................................................82
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
5/84
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure 1:Wilson Tennis Balls Containing Nanoengineered Materials...........................................................8Figure 2: Chirality of Carbon Nanotubes.....................................................................................................10Figure 3: Multi-walled Carbon Nanotube ....................................................................................................11Figure 4: Cross-section of an overlapped nano sensor configuration of the invention...............................13
Figure 5: Response of nano-scale temperature sensor to a 24C temperature change ............................13Figure 6: Plan view of a sensor assembly depicting aligned CNT-based conductors between twoelectrodes.................................................................................................................................................... 14Figure 7: Fabrication Process of the electrode PC board...........................................................................15Figure 8: Completed Nano Sensor Chip bonded on PC board...................................................................15Figure 9: Linear Resistance vs Temperature for CNT grown at gap width of 0.9 m and 1.8m..............16Figure 10: Temperature Co-efficient of Resistance for a typical bulk MWNT device in differentmeasurements ............................................................................................................................................17Figure 11: I-V characteristics of a typical bulk MWNT device.....................................................................17Figure 12: The micro-machined platform for DEP assembly ......................................................................19Figure 13: Schematic of the fabrication process .........................................................................................19Figure 14: SEM micrograph of the 3D assembled SWNT bundles............................................................. 19Figure 15: Measured resistance vs. temperature from a SWNT bridge .....................................................20Figure 16: The measured I-V curves from the 3D SWNT bundles before and after encapsulation...........20Figure 17: Temperature sensor using a single CNT................................................................................... 33Figure 18: SEM image showing a single CNT............................................................................................34Figure 19: A single CNT shown between two gold leads ...........................................................................34Figure 20: Sensor Concept Employing a Complex Pattern for Increased Sensitivity to Temperature....... 35Figure 21: Gold thermistor sensor with protective parylene layer...............................................................35Figure 22: Design Concept using a CNT network ......................................................................................36Figure 23: Bimetallic Position 1...................................................................................................................37Figure 24: Bimetallic Position 2...................................................................................................................38Figure 25: Bimetallic Sensor using CNTs ...................................................................................................38Figure 26 : Thermocouple Concept ............................................................................................................39Figure 27: Improved Expanding Element Concept .....................................................................................44Figure 28: Stress-Strain Curve for 20um CNT-parylene film......................................................................45Figure 29: Change in resistance.................................................................................................................45
Figure 30: Graph showing the maximum stress induced from a 100C temperature change, with changingPMMA width and insulating Parylene C layer thickness.............................................................................49Figure 31: Calibration curve for the dual PMMA expanding element, CNT-based temperature sensor ....51Figure 32: Predicted calibration curve comparison between the same device with and without PMMAexpanding elements....................................................................................................................................52Figure 33: Dual Expanding Element Layout ...............................................................................................54Figure 34: Dimension of the sensing element of the dual expansion device..............................................55Figure 35: SCS Parylene Deposition System............................................................................................. 57Figure 36 : ICP Plasma Therm 7900 ..........................................................................................................58Figure 37: Contact angle measurement of Parylene C...............................................................................59Figure 38: Contact angle measurement of Parylene C after roughening ...................................................59Figure 39: Hydrophobic recovery of Parylene C after 72 hours..................................................................60Figure 40: Brewer 100CB Resist Spinner/Bake..........................................................................................60
Figure 41: Zeiss Supra 25 FESEM .............................................................................................................61Figure 42: MRC/MAT-VAC Sputtering System...........................................................................................62Figure 43: The minimum intact features, 3um Trenches 9um Spacing in 500nm Shipley 1805 on 10um ofParylene C. .................................................................................................................................................64Figure 44: Optical Mask, 6um lines x 9um Spacing....................................................................................65Figure 45: Sonication of the SWNT solution suspended by tape ...............................................................65Figure 46: (a) Patterned wafer at 10
owith droplets of SWNT solution and (b) dried SWNT Solution........66
Figure 47: Trench in photo resist coated after dry casting SWNT solution ................................................66Figure 48: CNT Network after acetone bath, with slight overhangs ...........................................................67Figure 49: Parylene Lifting off Si Substrate after Sonication ......................................................................68
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
6/84
Figure 50: CNT lift off after pressurized acteone stream............................................................................ 69Figure 51: Ti Electrodes (Light Grey) over 6um wide CNT Network (vertical lines) over Parylene (Blue) .70
LIST OF TABLES
Table 1: Contacts List for Email Interviews.................................................................................................23Table 2: Email Interviews with Local Professors and Scholars ..................................................................24Table 3: Interview with Professor Mehmet Dokmeci...................................................................................25Table 4: Interview with Nurse Rosa Morelli.................................................................................................26Table 5: Interview with Professor Sinan Mft............................................................................................ 27Table 6: Temperature Sensor Design Specifications .................................................................................30Table 7: Concept Design Selection Matrix..................................................................................................41Table 8: Change in maximum normal stress, and thus strain, with varying temperature...........................50Table 9: Interpolation of the previous strain-resistance relationship...........................................................50Table 10: Material Properties Used in Modeling Analysis ..........................................................................76
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
7/84
Acknowledgments
The authors would like to thank the advisors Prof. Dinos Mavroidis, Prof. Yung Joon Jung, and Dr. AzadehKhanicheh for their continuous guidance and valuable support during the entire course of this project.
We would also like to thank Prof. Sinan Muftu, Northeastern University for putting several concepts into
perspective through his valuable insight and suggestions.
We are greatly indebted to the members of Kostas Center , especially Dr. Siva Subramanian, Selvapraba Selvarasah,Liala Jaberansari, Prashanth Makaram and Scott McNamara for their contribution towards the better understandingof the manufacturing processes.
We are also thankful to Prof. Mehmet Dokmech, Northeastern Universityi for sharing his knowledge on MEMSdevices.
Last but not least, we would like to thank Prof. Gregory Kowalski for continuously encouraging and being there forany help needed to take this project forward.
Copyright
We the team members,
Brendan Crawford Dan Esposito Vishal Jain David Pelletier
Dinos Mavroidis Yung Joon Jung Azadeh Khanicheh
Hereby assign our copyright of this report and of the corresponding Executive Summary to the Mechanical, andIndustrial Engineering (MIE) Department of Northeastern University. We also hereby agree that the video of our
Oral Presentations ifs the full property of the MIE Department.
Publication of this report does not constitute approval by Northeastern University, the MIE Department or its facultymembers of the findings or conclusions contained herein. It is published for the exchange and stimulation of ideas.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
8/84
CHAPTER # 1: INTRODUCTION
1.1 Problem Statement
As scientific research moves towards technological advancements on a smaller scale than ever before, it is becoming
increasingly necessary to develop sensing capabilities on an equally small scale in order to successfully study these
technologies. The superior thermal, electrical, and mechanical properties of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) have
suggested that using them as small-scale sensors would lead to sensor performance that is better than other devices
of similar size, or likewise, would lead to a smaller size than other devices of comparable performance. However, no
commercially available sensors exist which exploit the superior properties of CNTs that have been demonstrated in
research labs, primarily because the required nanomanufacturing processes are still too costly to offer a sufficient
potential for revenue.
This report focuses on ultra-small-scale temperature measurement, which is currently limited to devices no smaller
than two or three millimeters across in terms of whats commercially available. The challenge is to design,
fabricate, and characterize an ultra-small, low power consumption CNT-based temperature sensor that is
encapsulated in a flexible substrate. It is necessary to justify why using CNTs for obtaining temperature
measurements is advantageous, compared with traditional temperature measurement methods. Because of the goal
for an ultra-small sensor size, the device falls under strict restraints in terms of current nanomanufacturing
capabilities and the overall time constraint on the project. In addition, the device needs to be tested and validated
based on certain criteria such as repeatability of measurements, ease of calibration, and implementationconsiderations. The first step is to present information justifying the advantage of using CNTs in various aspects of
technology.
1.2 General Information and Considerations for Nanotechnology
A significant advancement in dimensional circuitry for electrical engineers was stepping into the micro scale, where
one micrometer is equal to 1,000thof a millimetera realm that can barely be recognized by the human eye. It is
clear to anyone in the technology field the importance of saving space; smaller products mean better portability, as
well as saving money on the physical supplies. As the technology advances, the ability to build smaller has grown
and science is currently entering the nano-scale age. One nanometer is equal to 1,000thof a micrometer. This realm
is no longer visible by the human eye. In fact, it is impossible to see by any optical equipment, since optical
wavelengths themselves are at the nanometer scale.
Besides the dimensional differences between micro-scale and nano-scale, there are some important considerations
for manufacturing differences. Physical manipulation is still possible at the micro-scale even though it requires
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
9/84
absolute precision and quality equipment. However, it is particularly challenging to physically move, assemble or
modify at the nano-scale using standard micromanufacturing equipment. More detail on current nanomanufacturing
practices are discussed in Chapter 4 of this report.
Currently there are many products on the market that employ some sort of nanotechnology. Some examples are:
longer lasting tennis balls made by Wilson, digital cameras containing nano-optic technology, and advanced
pharmaceuticals using buckyballs for selective drug delivery. Buckyballs are individual spherically shaped
molecules composed only of carbon atoms. Carbon nanotubes are the cylindrical equivalents of buckyballs, also
called buckytubes. The structurally ideal molecule geometries are what lead to their superior mechanical, electrical,
and thermal properties [1].
Figure 1:Wilson Tennis Balls Containing Nanoengineered Materials
Impact on Temperature Nanosensor Design
It is clear the there are often significant advantages to using nanoengineering in many types of products. As
engineers are learning to control nanotechnology, implementing it and exploiting the advantages are becoming
cheaper, to the point where there is a clear financial advantage to using nanotechnology in consumer products, aswell as in other industries. Employing this technology not only offers improvements in the performance of many
products, but can give a company a competitive and attractive edge in the eyes of customers as well. Remaining on
the forefront of technology is a proven strategy for running a successful company and the advantages to doing so on
the business level .
The same concepts apply for small-scale sensing. Characterizing the performance of nanotechnology elements for
use in sensors is expected, and has been shown, to be effective for making existing technology better. Doing this
also enables appropriate measurements to be made for future high-tech and small-scale applications that dont yet
have adequate sensing capabilities. Although nano-scale sensing is being researched by institutions worldwide, thecommercial availability has not yet been established because no companies see the potential for immediate revenue.
Characterizing a nanosensor to measure temperature and including a plan for implementation in several applications
might bridge the gap between promising research and actual revenue.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
10/84
1.3 Nano-scale Challenges
It is important to discuss the major challenges in designing and manufacturing at the nano-scale in order to
understand what steps are needed to successfully fabricate and characterize a temperature sensor on this scale. The
following discussion addresses these challenges.
One of the most significant differences between the behavior of objects on the meso-scale (measured in meters) and
on the nano-scale is the dominant forces controlling the matter. The dominating forces at meso-scale are gravity and
friction. The micro-scale deals with different dominant forces, specifically surface forces. Surface forces include
stiction, friction, electrostatic and Van der Waals forces. At the nano-scale, the prominent forces are intermolecular
and atomic forces, the effects of which are often neglected in meso-scale analysis. It is therefore important that
effort be put towards understanding what assumptions can and cant be made in order to accurately predict the
behavior of ultra-small-scale devices.
Assembly at the meso-scale can be as basic as using ones hands or some automated macro-scale manufacturing
equipment. On the contrary, micro-scale manufacturing requires the use of high precision mechanical equipment for
assembly, but this is not a feasible solution on the nano-scale. Manufacturing nano-scale products requires the use
of directed self-assembly, which involves indirect methods for manipulating materials.
Currently, cost is a big hurdle for the development of nanotechnology. Nanomanufacturing processes still have a
very low output of products considering the lack of metrology technology and commercial infrastructure [2]. CNTs,
for example, are actually grown but do not develop in a consistent manner. Detailed CNT properties and challenges
are discussed in the sections to follow. The CNT synthesis process is slow and costly, which places a difficult
challenge on developing various facets of nanotechnology. Even though it is expected that nanomanufacturing costs
will go down, until then it will be very hard to commercialize nanomanufactured technology
1.4 Advantages of Carbon Nanotubes
CNTs are one of the basic building blocks in nanotechnology. Understanding the properties of CNTs is essential in
understanding the feasibility of using them to improve the performance of temperature sensors. This section covers
the advantages in basic properties of CNTs which suggest that using them in small-scale sensors could yield
unprecedented sensor performance. Chapter 2 of this report will cover some specific examples of CNT-based
temperature measurement that has been demonstrated in research labs and will provide further evidence that a CNT-
based design is advantageous.
CNTs contain some amazing properties that lead to superior performance in mechanical, electrical, and thermal
comparisons. CNTs have a tensile strength of 65 300 GPa and can stretch to 20 % of their original size [3]. They
can have high thermal conductivity, high current density (higher than copper), and are 100 times stronger than steel
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
11/84
[3]. Unfortunately the processes used to create CNTs are very time consuming. These processes include arc
discharge, laser ablation, high pressure carbon monoxide (HiPCO), and chemical vapor deposition (CVD). Each
method carries with it a set of challenges but can produce a large amount of CNTs at one time. Because of the batch
fabrication capabilities, CNTs are readily available and can be purchased in solution form from many different
companies for competitive prices. Because of their commercial availability, CNTs dont need to be grown in order
to use them in new products. However, implementing them in an effective and repeatable way is very important for
bringing the overall cost of a CNT device down.
Next, it is necessary to discuss the variations of CNTs, and their respective properties. CNTs form in three variations
of chirality. Chirality is the geometric structure in which these hexagonal shapes form together. The three types are
armchair, zigzag and chiral displayed below (Figure 2) [3].
Figure 2: Chirality of Carbon Nanotubes
These variations are responsible for forming metallic, semi-metallic and semi-conductive nanotubes respectively.
The lack of chirality control is a current obstacle in nanomanufacturing. This can be overcome using procedures
such as electrophoresis, which uses electric fields to migrate only the metallic tubes [4]. Synthesis processes for
CNTs can form either single-walled nanotubes (SWNT) or multi-walled nanotubes (MWNT). MWNTs are
concentric CNTs of various diameters held together by Van der Waals forces (Figure 3). [5]
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
12/84
Figure 3: Multi-walled Carbon Nanotube
MWNTs can have adversely affected conductive properties since physical contact may not be made by the inner
tubes. Each variation can be beneficial depending on the specific scenario.
When creating CNT-based circuitry, as would be the case for a CNT temperature sensor, either individual CNTs or anetwork of CNTs can be utilized. CNT networks involve a vast amount of contacts in the mesh, which create a very
conductive carpet. This is compatible with creating complex designs on a substrate; A layer of CNT networks
can be applied and many variations of designs and can be created on the surface using electrical burn out to
remove unwanted areas. Employing a network helps to average out electrical and mechanical properties that might
otherwise be hard to predict [5].
1.5 Summary and Significance of Nanotechnology Research
Several important conclusions were made from nanotechnology research related to the design of an ultra-small-scale
temperature sensor:
Firstly, it can be concluded that manufacturing cost is the primary factor preventing CNT devices from being
commercialized. It follows that reducing the costs associate with nanomanufactured devices would lead to sensors
becoming commercially available. Due to the advanced properties of CNTs, it is possible that a single CNT sensor
design could achieve the performance required for use in many small-scale applications, to sense many different
properties, whereas other sensors are usually designed for a specific high-technology micro or nano-scale
application. Interestingly, if the superior properties of CNTs could be used to create a highly applicable temperature
sensing device, the possibility for batch fabrication of a single generic sensor design becomes realistic. With
increased potential for batch fabrication comes lower manufacturing costs.
The following chapter includes specific examples where CNTs were used in temperature measurement. These
examples will be used to confirm that it is advantageous to use a SWNT network, rather than MWNTs or single
CNTs, especially when the pattern of the sensing element needs to be relatively complex.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
13/84
CHAPTER # 2: BACKGROUND
2.1 Introduction
For this project, relevant patents and scholarly articles were examined in order to obtain a thorough understanding of
current ultra-small-scale temperature sensing options in terms of performance, size, and commercial ability. In
addition to this, the goal was to identify any gaps in the intellectual property and previous work that can be
improved upon, which has not yet been addressed. Special attention was focused on the use of CNTs in the
applications of temperature sensors because the superior properties of CNTs discussed in the previous chapter
suggest that all other methods of temperature measurement will be inferior in some aspect of the measurement
capabilities.
After a considerable amount of research, it was observed that there are relatively few patents related to a CNT based
temperature sensor. However, quite a few journals and articles have been published on this topic, indicating that a
great amount of work has been done in the field of nanotechnology in the last few years, especially related to CNTs.
Additionally, the number of available papers and the current discussion among scholars suggests that CNTs show
promise in terms of their applicability and performance in both current and developing technology fields.
This chapter presents the patents and papers that were examined for the project. Because the specific use of CNTs
in temperature sensors has not been commercialized, the following sections incorporate allof the information the
group was able to find that is directly related to the topic. The large amount of attention that is put towards each
article in this report is important because it provides a thorough understanding of what has been accomplished, and
where there is room for improvement.
2.2 Patents
2.2.1 Fabrication of Nano-Scale Temperature Sensors and Heaters [6]
This patent claims to design a nano-scale temperature sensor and heaters by depositing two strips of nano sized
metals on an electrical insulator substrate using a Focused Ion Beam (FIB) deposition process. The second metal
strip is deposited in such a way that it is slightly overlapping the first strip forming a bimetal sensing junction
(Error! Reference source not found.). The two metal strips are of different materials each of 50 nm thickness. The
two metals used are tungsten (W) and platinum (Pt). The sensor designed in this patent works on the principle of a
thermocouple and is claimed to have a sensitivity of approximately 5.4 mV/C ( Error! Reference source not
found.).
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
14/84
Figure 4: Cross-section of an overlapped nano sensor configuration of the invention
Figure 5: Response of nano-scale temperature sensor to a 24C temperature change
The patent claims that the sensor can also be used to measure other properties besides temperature. The resistive
segments of the heater can be made up of alternative segments of two different FIB deposited metals. The deposited
metals are not pure, and will contain gallium (Ga) originating from the FIB process and other contamination,
causing the deposited metal to have a resistivity that will allow heating when electric current is passed through the
metal. The ability of FIB to mill or deposit at high lateral resolution permits the preparation of site specific sensors.
The sensors can then be adapted in the fabrication of micro-electromechanical systems (MEMS).
The impact of this patent on the project is that it demonstrates that ultra-small-scale temperature measurement has
been patented. However, this device does not use CNTs and it is expected that the performance could increase if
CNTs could be properly characterized as a temperature sensor. Additionally, this patent makes use of tungsten and
platinum as the two sensor metals, which provides a starting point for the electrode and wire materials in the new
design.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
15/84
2.2.2 Integrated Carbon Nanotube Sensor [7]
This patent claims to have designed a method and structure for an integrated circuit (IC) comprising a first transistor
and an embedded carbon nanotube field effect transistor (CNT FET) proximate to the first transistor. The CNT FET
is dimensionally smaller than the first transistor.
The CNT FET is adapted to sense signals from the first transistor, where the signals consists of temperature, voltage,
current, electric field, and the magnetic field signals. Moreover the CNT FET is adapted to measure the stress and
strain in the IC, wherein the stress and strain comprise any of the mechanical and thermal stress and strain.
Although this patent makes use of CNTs in its application, it does not discuss or provide any explicit details as to
how the CNTs are involved with the primary transistor to detect/determine the various parameters of sensing. Also,
this design is geared towards a specific application. Designing a new sensor to sense only temperature, but for a
variety of applications, is a novel concept.
2.2.3 Carbon Nanotube Based Sensor and Method for Continually Sensing Changes in a Structure [8]
This patent claims a sensor for detecting changes in a structure. The CNT conductors are operatively positioned on
the substrate with at least one pair of spaced apart electrodes coupled to the opposing ends of the conductor ( Error!
Reference source not found.). The electrodes and the CNT conductors are coupled to the substrate and this
assembly is in turn coupled to the point of interest. Using the principle of resistance of CNTs and CNT strain,
changes in the portion of the structure to which the sensor is coupled induces a change in the electrical properties of
the conductor. It claims to use either SWNTs or MWNTs and the fabrication is done by controlled deposition using
an electric field to align the CNTs with respect to the electrodes.
Figure 6: Plan view of a sensor assembly depicting aligned CNT-based conductors between two electrodes
Electrodes
Single CNTs
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
16/84
The final sensor assembly is flexible and hence can be used for the purpose of strain measurements of the surface
its coupled with. Baseline parameters, level parameters of strain, temperature and pressure are measured initially.
The electrical properties of the sensors are measured over time to determine any changes from the baseline response
which is indicative of change in one of the parameters experienced by that portion of the structure [Error!
Bookmark not defined.]. This patent is not only geared towards a specific application, but it makes use of single
CNTs between electrodes. The processes used to selectively grow CNTs (specifically chemical vapor deposition)
are costly, hard to control, and lead to limitations in performance.
2.3 Literature Review
2.3.1 Nano Temperature Sensor Using Selective Lateral Growth of Carbon Nanotube between Electrodes [9]
This paper presents lateral growth of CNTs between two electrodes and its use as nano temperature sensor (Error!
Reference source not found.and Error! Reference source not found.). The fabrication of electrodes is by MEMS
techniques. The CNTs are grown selectively by MPCVD (Microwave Plasma Chemical Vapor Deposition) between
the two electrodes. The growing conditions of the CNT, such as the flow rate of CH4(methane) or N2(nitrogen) are
varied to obtain a high quality CNT sensor. Experiments were performed that used the following variables: the
distance between the electrodes, the amount of source gas, CH4(between 10 -60 %), and different amounts of N2to
make the CNTs grow horizontally. Results showed that the greater the gap between the electrodes, the more difficult
it becomes for the CNTs to connect to the electrodes.
Figure 7: Fabrication Process of the electrode PC board
Figure 8: Completed Nano Sensor Chip bonded on PC board
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
17/84
The current-voltage (I-V) curve of the CNT was measured at different temperatures and a linear relationship
between the electrical resistance of the CNT and temperature was obtained (Error! Reference source not found.).
It also shows that using titanium as an electrode provides an ohmic contact. This accounts for the fact that CNTs can
be metallic as well as semiconductive in nature.
Figure 9: Linear Resistance vs Temperature for CNT grown at gap width of 0.9 m and 1.8m
This article has a few important implications for the current project. First, the CNTs in this study are grown
selectively by using the CVD (Chemical Vapor Deposition) process, which is costly and difficult to control. This
could be part of the reason this device has not been commercialized. The use of CVD also requires bake
temperatures that are well over the transition temperature of Parylene C. This means that using current
nanomanufacturing methods, a biocompatible, flexible substrate cannot be used if the sensing element is to be a
single CNT. Even beyond the limitations in using CVD, good results have already been achieved and designing a
sensor using this concept would not present anything novel. It is therefore advisable to find other
nanomanufacturing methods that are not as difficult to optimize given the short time frame for the project.
2.3.2 Bulk Carbon Nanotube as Thermal Sensing and Electronic Circuit Elements [10]
In this paper, bulk MWNT were successfully and repeatedly manipulated by AC electrophoresis to form resistive
elements between the Au (gold) microelectrodes and were demonstrated to potentially serve as novel temperature
sensors and simple electronic circuits.
The temperature coefficient of resistance (TCR) of the MWNT bundles was determined by measuring the resistance
of the bulk MWNT with the corresponding temperature (Error! Reference source not found.). From the
experimental measurements on a typical bulk MWNT device, the resistance dropped with increasing temperature
(Error! Reference source not found.). The TCR varied by experiment but converged within -0.1 to -0.2 %/C.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
18/84
Figure 10: Temperature Co-efficient of Resistance for a typical bulk MWNT device in different
measurements
Figure 11: I-V characteristics of a typical bulk MWNT device
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
19/84
This could be attributed to variations in room temperature, mismatch in thermal coefficients of expansion between
the gold electrode and the bulk MWNTs, and contamination in the sample such as moisture. The I-V measurements
have revealed that their power consumption was in W range . This is important because it shows that using a CNT
network as a resistive element for a thermal sensor will produce power dissipation in the W range and will allow
for an ultra small device.
2.3.3 Ultra-low-power Polymer Thin Film Encapsulated Carbon Nanotube Thermal Sensors [11]
A novel polymer thin film embedded carbon nanotube (PECNT) sensor was developed for ultra low power micro
thermal sensing. Basic fabrication process for this sensor includes AC electrophoresis manipulation of the MWNT
bundles on a silicon substrate and embedding them inside Parylene C layers provide a robust protection for the
bundled MWNTs. This encapsulation process ensures that the MWNT elements can be protected from moisture and
contaminates in an operating environment. In addition, Parylene C is a flexible material, which presents the
possibility of a flexible sensor. The gap distance between the electrodes of the PECNT sensors is between 3m and
10m. The additional advantage of using Parylene C is that it is deposited as a conformal coating at room
temperature.
Experimental results showed that the TCR of the PECNT sensor was around -0.15%/C to -0.18%/C which closely
matched the previous results. This shows that the thin Parylene C layer does not affect the intrinsic thermal sensing
properties of the CNTs due to the extremely high thermal conductivity of the CNTs. The TCR is of particular
importance because it determines how sensitive the device will be and what overall temperature range it will work
over. This calculation will be need for the new sensor to be designed in later chapters of the report. In the
experimental results of the TCR on the CNT sensors without the Parylene C protection, considerable room
temperatures resistance drifting was observed in repeated measurements during the thermal annealing cycles. Hence
the Parylene C layer provides a better fixation to the CNTs with the microelectrodes when compared with those
without the Parylene C protected CNT sensors.
2.3.4 Three Dimensional Dielectrophoretic Assembly of Nanostructures on a Micro-machined Platform [12]
This paper discusses a novel platform for selectively assembling conductive nanostructures in a three dimensional
structure (Error! Reference source not found.). To realize this three dimensional assembly, a versatilemicroplatform utilizing a two mask process has been designed and fabricated (Error! Reference source not
found.). The assembly process is achieved at room temperature and is compatible with conventional semiconductor
fabrication and large scale nano assembly. It utilizes dielectrophoretic (DEP) assembly and is demonstrated with
high yield. Specifically created 3D micro-bridge structures from single walled carbon nanotubes (SWNTs) for
vertical interconnect applications and 3D micro-bridges using gold nanoparticles are potential sensors (Error!
Reference source not found.).
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
20/84
Figure 12: The micro-machined platform for DEP assembly
Figure 13: Schematic of the fabrication process
Figure 14: SEM micrograph of the 3D assembled SWNT bundles
After assembly, the I-V curves were first measured from the SWNT bridge, verifying that the assembly was
successful (Error! Reference source not found.). The measured current-voltage behavior is linear (~545slope).
To enhance the adhesion of the SWNTs to the metal electrodes and to protect the SWNTs from the environment,
assembled SWNTs were encapsulated using a thin (1m) Parylene-C layer. Contacts were next opened on the top
Parylene layer using a reactive ion etcher. Current-voltage measurements from the encapsulated 3D SWNT bridge
demonstrate a lower metal-SWNT-metal resistance (approx. 380 ) possibly attributed to the top Parylene layer
compressing the SWNTs and leading to an improved CNT-metal contact. To investigate the effect of temperature on
SWNTs, the 3D thermal sensor was placed on a SUSS PM5 analytical probe system and the change in resistance
recorded as the temperature was varied from 25C to 65C with 10C increments ( Error! Reference source not
found.).
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
21/84
As the temperature is increased from 25 C to 65 C the resistance value dropped by more than 10%. The measured
temperature coefficient of resistance (TCR) value from the single electrode device varied from -0.154 to -0.24%.
Figure 15: Measured resistance vs. temperature from a SWNT bridge
Figure 16: The measured I-V curves from the 3D SWNT bundles before and after encapsulation
The importance of this paper for the project is that is shows the advantage of using SWNTs in a network, versus
MWNTs. This paper reports very good results based on using an SWNT network as a resistive circuit element that
is encapsulated in Parylene. This basic concept for nano-scale temperature measurement is promising and shows the
potential for many applications that the group is looking for, keeping in mind that effort will still be made to create a
novel product.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
22/84
2.3.5 Measuring the Thermal Conductivity of a Single Carbon Nanotube [13]
A novel method of reliably measuring the thermal conductivity of a single carbon nanotube using a suspended
sample-attached T-type nanosensor was reported in this article. The experimental results show that the thermal
conductivity of a carbon nanotube at room temperature increases as its diameter decreases, and exceeds 2000 W/mK
for a diameter of 9.8 nm. The temperature dependence of the thermal conductivity for a carbon nanotube with a
diameter of 16.1 nm appears to have an asymptote near 320 K. The present method is, in principle, applicable to any
kind of a single nanofiber, nanowire, and even single-walled carbon nanotube. The diameter-dependent thermal
conductivity indicates that the interactions of photons and electrons between multiwalled layers affect the thermal
conductivity. The thermal conductivity increases as the number of multiwalled layers decreases. A single-walled
carbon nanotube is expected to have much higher thermal conductivity, which is of particular importance to later
chapters of this report .
2.4 Summary of Current Technology
Gathering information on the patent information and other literature provided a better understanding of the behavior
of CNTs and their application in thermal sensing. The first conclusion that can be made from this research is that it
is possible to characterize CNT-based devices as temperature sensors but the research verifies that the concept has
not yet been commercialized. The patent and literature review also revealed that CNT-based temperature sensors
can achieve comparable performance to industry standard sensors currently in use. The size of the devices that have
been fabricated is small enough to enable application in current ultra-small-scale applications as well as future
applications. However, the performance has yet to be optimized for high applicability.
Research also showed that the nature of the nanomanufacturing processes leads to limitations in what can actually be
fabricated on the nano-scale. For example, the process CVD that is involved with growing a single carbon nanotube
is not compatible with the flexible substrate Parylene C, nor is it a cost-effective or timely option for completing the
design of a novel sensor. Using Parylene C would allow a device to be flexible as well as protecting it from
chemical and moisture damage. Parylene C is also a biocompatible material, suggesting a possible application in
biomechanics. This means that other deposition processes than CVD must be used since Parylene C has clear
advantages when used on nanosensor designs, in terms of the abovementioned details and in regards to the project
goals.
A network of SWNTs has been shown in research to provide the best overall performance for a CNT-based sensor in
terms of sensitivity and repeatability in measurements and fabrication. Devices that made use of single CNTs were
able to be characterized to measure temperature, but they are extremely fragile and were able to operate over a
relatively small temperature range. Similarly, MWNTs werent able to achieve the sensitivity performance that
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
23/84
SWNTs can. If the decision was made to use a CNT-based design, a network of SWNTs was to be used. However,
different methods of measuring temperature had to be examined and compared against basic CNT concepts.
2.5 Other Temperature Measurement Devices
There are other types of sensors used to measure temperature that must be considered. Some of them include
thermocouple, semiconductor diodes, metallic resistors, thermistors, infrared thermometry, near field thermometry,
and other less-common methods such as Plasmonics and other optical methods. Each method has its own
disadvantages and advantages. For example, a thermocouple is simple in design and is inexpensive, but has
limitations in terms of its temperature range. A semiconductor diode is not suitable to measure very high
temperatures but is suitable to measure cryogenic temperatures. The spatial resolution of the above mentioned
devices is about 10 microns except for near field optical thermometry which can have a spatial resolution in the
order of 50nm. However, this method for measuring temperature involves complicated optical instrumentation and
is not very user friendly. All of the alternate methods for measuring temperature were considered during concept
brainstorming, which is discussed further in Chapter 3.
2.6 Why Use CNTs for Temperature Measurement?
The basic concept decision making process is discussed in the next chapter, but through background research and
the performance advantages discussed above, the following preliminary argument was formed regarding the design
of an ultra-small-site temperature sensor:
It is important to note that the only devices the group was able to find that were capable of taking temperature
measurements on the nano scale were CNT-based devices. Since the processes associated with manufacturing CNT-
based devices are still relatively costly and complex, it is clear that the choice would have been made by researchers
to avoid using them if it was possible to use other types of devices that might be easier and cheaper to fabricate. It is
the significant increase in performance due to the heightened properties of CNTs that make these devices attractive
in the eyes of researchers and to the community. For the case of micro-scale devices (including temperature
sensors), the manufacturing costs began very high but have since been improved until the costs were decreased
significantly. Now, MEMS devices have led to entire industries, such as microprocessors and all of the resulting
industries that came with increased computer speed. Researchers building CNT-based sensors know that it will be a
while before the comparable nanomanufacturing costs go down but when this happens, CNT-based sensors could
quickly become extremely profitable, not to mention that they would contribute directly to the development of many
future high technology and ultra-small-scale industries that have yet to even be conceptualized.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
24/84
CHAPTER # 3: Design Development
3.1 Introduction
This section covers the beginning of the design development process, including needs assessment, specification
development, concept evolution, concept drawings, and selecting a satisfying design. The needs were determined
from interviews with local professionals and scholars, which the group conducted strategically based on the results
of the background and literature search. From the interviews, a list was made of design specifications that will
satisfy the discussed needs. Once the needs were established, brainstorming was conducted, which took into
account several different ways to measure temperature and the feasibility of each on the nanoscale in terms of
manufacturing. The concepts were then compared based on weighted criteria and a selection was made.
3.2 Interviews
3.2.1 Interviews with Professors and Researchers
The following people were contacted in regards to the application and industry needs for our sensor, as well as the
manufacturability of concept designs on the nano scale (Error! Reference source not found.).
Table 1: Contacts List for Email Interviews
Name Organization Area(s) of Expertise
Xin Zhang BUCenter for Nanoscience and
NanobiotechnologyThomas Burg MIT Nanoscale Sensing @ MIT
Michel Godin MIT Nanoscale Sensing @ MIT
Will Grover MIT Nanoscale Sensing @ MIT
Scott Knudsen MIT Nanoscale Sensing @ MIT
Chris Dames UCAProperties and Applications ofNanotubes and Nanowires.
Ken crozier Harvard
Electrical Engineering andAssociated with Nano EngineeringLab. Experience withNanophotonics.
Raj Mohanty BUNanoscale Biosensors,Nanomechanics, Physics, Heads
Nano Research at BURobert Badzey BU Postdoctoral Research at BU
Tyler Dunn BUPhD candidate at BU. Nano ResearchExperience.
Dr Zhuomin ZhangGA Institute of
TechnologyHeat Transfer, EngineeringThermophysics
Dr. William P.King
GA Institute ofTechnology
Head of Nano research at GAInstitute of Technology
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
25/84
The following information was compiled based on responses from and discussion with these individuals (Error!
Reference source not found.):
Table 2: Email Interviews with Local Professors and Scholars
Interview Date and Type: 9/2007 - 10/2007, EmailInterviews
Group Members whoConducted theInterview:
David Pelletier
Statement Interpretation for Project
Most sensors which make use of CNTs are very sensitive totemperature
The properties of CNTs show a sufficientchange with temperature in order to achieve
suitable performance in terms of accuracy andsensitivity
Currently, there are many small-scale technologies beingdeveloped, such as microfluidic chips, which will eventuallyrequire good temperature measurement. Technologies that
are relatively new do not yet have suitable devices for
measuring temperature.
There is a potential for application in areas thatare currently in development, where
commercially available sensors fall short of thetemperature sensing requirements
One specific microfluidic application is to monitor the chiptemperature in a process called PCR, which is used to
amplify DNA for studying and manipulation purposes. Thereis no temperature sensor built into these particular chips
This is a specific recommended application for asmall-scale temperature sensor, where no
commercially available equipment can be used
Measuring the temperature of very small devices, locally, isvery difficult. Typically, measurements are perform at acertain distance from the area of interest. It is oftentimes
assumed that the temperature is uniform everywhere,although this might not be always true. However, in many
applications, such small temperature offset might not be aproblem
A small-scale temperature sensor could be usedto take local measurements, which would
improve upon temperature uniformityassumptions and methods. However, effects ofthese assumptions are usually minimal and so
the project cannot rely solely on these types ofapplications
Encapsulating the sensor in a material that makes the deviceresistant to chemicals and to moisture is a specification that is
important for the types of applications being investigated(especially the microfluids applications). However, this isnot going to make the sensor novel since most temperature
sensors have these qualities
Moisture and chemical resistance are crucialspecifications to have but will not make the
sensor novel
Designing for novelty in both size and sensitivity/accuracywould require more time for manufacturing and testing than
the group has available. The calibration of ultra sensitivedevices with a large temperature range is complicated and it
would probably require different sensing elements fordifferent parts of the range
It is not advisable to attempt to make a sensor
that is novel in both size andaccuracy/sensitivity while maintaining a
relatively broad temperature range
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
26/84
In using CNTs as the sensing element, there may be issueswith the inability to separate metallic behavior from
semiconducting. If these issues arise, using many CNTs in anetwork will average out the important properties of the
element
The unpredictability of behavior that is inherentin CNTs can be compensated for by using a
CNT network. This has been demonstrated inseveral papers
3.2.2 Interview with Professor Mehmet Dokmeci of Northeastern University ECE Department
The following table contains the information that was collected from an in-person interview with Professor
Mehment Dokmeci of the Northeastern University ECE department. Professor Dokmeci has experience in
nanosensor design, characterization, and testing (Error! Reference source not found.).
Table 3: Interview with Professor Mehmet Dokmeci
Interviewee Name: Mehmet Docmeci Group Members whoConducted the Interview:
Dan Esposito,Vishal Jain
Interviewee Addressor Institution: Northeastern UniveristyECE DepartmentInterview Date: 10/15/07
Statement Interpretation for Project
Many applications for flexible substrates for thermalsensor
Parylene or another flexible substrate can be used
CMOS sensors cant achieve the spatial resolution thatthe CNT based sensors can achieve (less than 50um)
Using CNTs is advantageous in terms of sensorresolution and sensitivity
If the device is made of Grade 6 biocompatible material,it can be used as an implant in human body
Parylene is a grade 6 biocompatible material. Needto find out if the presense of other materials (i.e.
metal electrodes) prevents implantability
Using the resitance of the CNTs, the device can becharacterized to provide temperature change, strainchanges and functionalized gas sensor
Measuring the resistance of a network of CNTs is a
feasible and appropriate method for creating a CNTbased sensor. Possibility for future modifications to
use as a strain or gas sensor
Parylene C is expensive but can be used as abiocompatable material
Possible biomedical application (human implants)
The advantage of using Parylene C is that it presses theCNTs to the electrode, thus increasing the contact
resistance of the device and averaging out the resistanceof the CNTs
It can be expected that the change in resistance withtemperature will be measurable and consistent.
Good for repeatability in measurements
At around 400C, metal particles start to bubble, whereasCNTs stay stable at even higher temperatures
Possible high-temperature application by usingCNTs. Justifying the advantage of using CNTs
instead of other metal resistive element
There should not be any strain-based changes inresistance of the CNT network due to percolation theory
and the overall small size of the sensor
Using a flexible substrate (parylene) will not preventaccurate calibration or temperature measurement
characterization
Can use the SUSS PM5 device to obtain the I-V curveCommon nanomanufacturing lab equipment can be
used to characterize and test the sensor. CHN atNortheastern has this equipment
Use a heatable chuck to obtain the current at varioustemperatures. This will characterize the device to be a
temperature sensor.
Common nanomanufacturing lab equipment can beused to characterize and test the sensor. CHN at
Northeastern has this equipment
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
27/84
Contact Prabhu (PhD student) for assistance oncalibration
---
Use op-amp to determine the frequency response of thedevice. This is a very important part of the
functionalization process
It is feasible to functionalize the device as atemperature sensor
This group would be the first group to functionalize a
CNT temperature sensor
Justifying novelty of design and possibility for a
patent
3.2.3 Interview with Nurse Rosa Morelli
The following table contains information that was collected in a phone interview with Nurse Rosa Morelli. The
interview was conducted with the intention of exploring applications for a small-scale temperature sensor in the
biomedical field (Error! Reference source not found.).
Table 4: Interview with Nurse Rosa Morelli
Interviewee Name: Nurse Rosa Morelli Group Members who
Conducted theInterview:
Dan EspositoInterviewee Address
or Institution:Brigham and Womens
HospitalInterview Date: 10/10/2007
Statement Interpretation for Project
Catheters are prone to infection. With infection, bodytemperature rises. Local heating helps to fight
infection. Accurate temperature sensing needed tooptimize and study infection fighting with heat
Possible catheter application: could attach a smallsensor to catheter.
Catheter type #1 to focus on: Bladder: No need for fastresponse. Needs to be in vivo and resistent to a wet
environment
A biocompatible sensor would need to be chemicaland moisture resistant. Sensor response not as
important for this application
Catheter type #2: Endotracheal: No need for fastresponse. Needs to be In Vivo and resistance to a wet
environment
A biocompatible sensor would need to be chemicaland moisture resistant. Sensor response not as
important for this application
Catheter type #3: Heart (Angioplasty): Smaller sensorneeded to move through arteries. Faster response time
would be better.
Small-size sensor needed. CNT temperature sensor isa good solution for this application due to small size,low power consumption, overall temperature range.
Core body temperature sensing: Current method isrectal thermometry. Sometimes, false conclusions aremade using this method (especially for people who are
pronounced dead due to cold)
There is a need for better method of measuring corebody temperature
Core body temperature sensing: No current way tomeasure core temperature directly
Possibility for signal-transmitting temperature sensingdevice. Needs to be in vivo, chemical/moisture
resistant, ultra small, very low power consumption,biocompatable materials, ~1 second response time,
wide temp range
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
28/84
3.2.4 Interview with Professor Sinan Mft
The following information was collected from an in-person interview with Professor Muftu of the Northeastern
University Mechanical Engineering Department. Professor Muftu was asked questions having to do with the
mechanics and modeling of the device. This interview was conducted after the concept brainstorming and
evaluations were completed. The rest of chapter 3 reflects the absence of this knowledge at that time. However, this
new information is discussed in chapter 4 and plays a key role in the detailed design development for the sensor
(Error! Reference source not found.):
Table 5: Interview with Professor Sinan Mft
IntervieweeName:
Professor SinanMft Group Members who
Conducted the Interview:Vishal Jain
IntervieweeAddress orInstitution:
NortheasternUniversity Mechanical
EngineeringDepartment
Interview Date: 10/15/2007
Statement Interpretation for Project
Expansion element below (or above the CNTnetwork) might or might not work
If an expanding element is added above (or below) the CNTnetwork, the CNT behavior is unpredictable. The CNT might
bend to form curve or might just stick to the expandingelement or might do something else
Instead of adding an expanding element aboveor below the CNT network, subject the CNTnetwork to shear forces causing it to strain
The previous design consisted of the CNTs above (or below)the CNT network. When there is a change in temperature, the
expansion element will expand greater in longitudinaldirection and less in the lateral direction. With the CNTs beingsubjected to change in the lateral direction, the effect might benegligible for the range of temperature the device is supposed
to work.
---
To overcome this, add expansion elements above and belowthe CNT network such that expansion elements and the CNT
network have the same longitudinal axes. When the expansionelements expand, they will induce a shear force in the CNT
network causing it to strain
Add parylene above and below the CNTnetwork (in between the CNTs and the
expanding element)
Parylene will be the insulator between the expanding elementand the CNTs. Use this model to thermal analysis
Perform thermal analysis to determine materialfor expanding elements, its dimensions etc.
Thermal analysis needs to be done to determine the materialfor expanding element, its dimensions such the when the
device is exposed to the change in temperature (-50C to 150C),the CNT network does not strain beyond 2% (elastic)
Use correction factor for properties
Using a correction of 0.1, 0.3 and 0.7 for the thermalproperties (linear coefficient of expansion and thermal
quantities) of CNTs and expanding element. Using correctionfactor will provide an output within a certain range
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
29/84
3.3 Needs Assessment
Based on the background research and the interviews that were conducted, the need for a novel temperature sensor
was discussed. The following paragraphs summarize the discussion:
Temperature measurement is currently a very well-covered area. There are commonly accepted sensing methods
and products for most industries and applications where temperature measurement is needed. Competing with well-
designed, industry standard sensors would be very challenging, especially when trying to sell a sensor of comparable
performance to what is currently available. Attempting to improve temperature sensing for a specific application is
not advisable for this reason.
Companies in many application areas use slightly older methods to provide temperature measurement which remain
both lawful and satisfactory for their industry. These companies rely on the fact that the temperature measurement,
in general, is not very difficult and have been well-studied for many years. Such organizations may see it as a
financial disadvantage to make use of expensive state-of-the-art methods that are designed specifically for their
application when their current method still works fine. However, the trade-off is that using state-of-the-art
temperature sensing techniques can give a company a competitive edge in the eyes of customers, especially when
the company is trying to expand their capabilities to newer technology fields while maintaining high measurement
credibility and stature. These companies have a specific need for cost-effective, yet state-of-the-art temperature
measurement.
Additionally, there are also applications where previous measurement methods fall short of what is possible usingstate-of-the-art technology of today and of the future. One example of this, as shown in Table 4, is the measurement
of the human body core temperature (the temperature of the heart). Currently, rectal thermometry is used to take
core temperature measurements. In situations such as a person being affected by extreme cold, the body can go into
an unconscious state that is absolutely mistakable for death using observation and normal medical field tests. The
core body temperature measurement is critical in determining if there is a chance that the person is still alive.
However, rectal thermometry doesnt measure the bodys core directly, but takes an indirect measurement of an area
thats close to the core. There are numerous cases where a person is assumed to be deceased based on field tests and
rectal temperature measurements, only to wake up later. In this case, there is a definite need for a method of
obtaining core temperatures without surgery. This could be done with an implantable that transmits temperaturemeasurements to equipment outside the patients body. Technology for transmitting signals from a microscopic
device to external equipment is currently being developed, which will necessitate a temperature sensor on the size
scale of individual blood cells (micro scale). This is one example of an application for temperature measurement
where the current methods unacceptably fall short of what is possible using technology that is currently in
development.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
30/84
Designing a generic, inexpensive temperature sensor could provide companies, in many application areas, with a
perfect opportunity to upgrade their techniques; even if the existing technology is sufficient, or in cases where it is
not. Designing a generic temperature sensor would be the basic task, and then starting a company to sell the design
and modify it for each customers individual application would be a necessary next step to ensure smooth
implementation.
It is important to note that if a generic temperature sensor (i.e. one with carefully selected specifications that
encompass a wide variety of applications) is designed, there is huge potential for application in technologies that
have not yet moved beyond the research phase. Currently, there are many technologies being developed which
require temperature measurement on a smaller scale than ever before. For example, some microfluid applications
are being developed which will require very intensive temperature monitoring to make it out of the research phase.
More specifically, microfluid technologies such as novel methods for performing PCR (again, a process for DNA
amplification) require precise temperature measurement. In this application, and in many others, there is no current
method for measuring temperature that can satisfy the requirements of the process. Most third party sensorcompanies will not justify designing such a method or device because they dont see the immediate potential for
revenue. However, designing a sensor that is novel in areas such as small size could lead to a patent in the near
future, and the device would be easily integrated into current or future nanotechnology applications. Since size is
such an important factor in distinguishing future technology from past technology, designing an ultra small-scale
temperature sensor shows promising applicability.
List of needs
The following list presents a summary of the needs that came from interviews and the above discussion:
- There is a need for an ultra small-scale sensor (overall size in micrometers)
- The sensor should be biocompatible if it is to be used for human implant applications
- The temperature range needs to be relatively large in order to encompass many applications. The
temperature range is limited by the response of the materials to different temperature ranges
- The sensor should be comparable in sensitivity and accuracy to what is currently available as industry
standard sensors
- Since the sensor will be used for local small-scale temperature measurement, the power consumption
should be low so the heat produced does not affect the surroundings and the measurement significantly.
- The sensor needs to be easily integrated in many applications
- The sensor should be resistant to chemicals and moisture effects.
- The manufacturing time cannot exceed approximately one month, given the time constraints on the project.
- The cost should be considered and minimized in order to sell the device and be competitive. There should
be batch fabrication capabilities.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
31/84
- The device should be easy to calibrate and test given the time constraints on the project and the goal for
overall low cost.
3.4 Specifications
The following specifications were determined based on the developed needs that govern the design of the sensor(Error! Reference source not found.):
Table 6: Temperature Sensor Design Specifications
Spec Item/DescriptionWeight
(1 = Highest)Specification
Electrical Properties
Range of Use 5 -50 C to 150C
Sensitivity 4 Medium/High
Accuracy 4 +/- 1C
Power Consumption 3 Very Low, in WResponse Time 6 1s
Physical/Chemical
Overall Dimensions(smallest possible) 1
150mx50mx12m
In-Situ/In-Vivo 8 Yes
CMOS Compatible 8 Yes
Moisture Resistance 7 Yes
Chemical Resistance 7 Yes
Mechanical
Effects of strain 3 Proportional
Manufacturability
Manufacturing Time 2 Short, ~1 month
Batch Fabrication 7 Yes
Calibration
Ease of calibration 7 Easy
Others
Repeatability 8 Yes
Supply Voltage 3 Low, 0-3V
Ease of Integration 6 Easy
Environmental effects 6 Negligible
Cost 9 Medium/Low
Based on the needs assessment discussed in the previous section, it was determined that the temperature sensor
should be smaller than other industry standard sensors of comparable performance. The specifications listed in the
table above provide a method for characterizing the overall performance of a temperature sensor. Below, the
importance of each specification is justified and discussed briefly.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
32/84
- Temperature Range: The selection of a temperature sensor for a certain application is based largely on the
temperature range that the sensor is rated for. The selected range of -50C to 150C for this design
encompasses a broad range of applications. Most industry standard temperature sensors are characterized
to function within a smaller temperature range, since most of them are application-specific. Designing a
new sensor with a slightly larger range will enable its use for a broader set of applications than most
commercially available sensors. This, coupled with small size, should give the new design an advantage
when compared against other sensor options in a given application.
- Sensitivity: This specification is important because it determines the accuracy to which measurements can
be taken. This comes into play when measurement credibility and quality are particularly important in a
given application. It is desirable for the sensor being designed to take temperature measurements with
gradations that are less than one degree Celsius to compete with the existing products.
- Accuracy: Any commercial sensors reputation is directly related to its accuracy. It is imperative to design
a sensor with strict accuracy values. Having said this, the decided accuracy value of +/- 1C was chosenwith possible applications in mind. While there is potential for an even lower value, there is no valid
requirement to do so.
- Power Consumption: Since the possible applications could be battery operated or simply require a small
power supply, it is important to design the sensor using the lowest amount of power requirements possible.
In addition, the possibility of creating a temperature variant if too much current is applied is a very real
concern.
- Response Time: After intense research of possible applications it was determined that an average response
time was completely acceptable for all scenarios. A fast response time is not necessary.
- Overall Size: The most important specification for the sensor design has been determined to be the overall
size, since the project objective is to create a sensor that is novel in size, while the performance remains
comparable with that of other industry standard temperature sensors.
- In-Situ/In-Vivo: This characteristic would allow for a bio-compatible sensor. Since, there are a few
possible applications that would require a bio-compatible sensor, and this specification can be achieved
simply by changing the encapsulating material, it was decided to go forward with this specification.
- CMOS Compatible: Possible applications included several silicon technology based products. It is of the
utmost importance that the design will not disrupt surrounding circuitry whatever the application.
- Moisture Resistance: The prospective design is a basic electronic circuit, and, like any other electrical
equipment, will corrode easily by exposure to moisture or liquid. It is incredibly important to design the
product so it is protected from all outside contaminants to ensure repeatability.
- Chemical Resistance: To ensure a large variation of possible applications and since the specification can
easily be met by choosing a suitable encapsulating material, chemical resistance is desired.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
33/84
- Effects of Strain: A valid concern for this design is to ensure there are no external strain loads applied to
the sensor. Since the sensor is primarily a strain sensor it is very important to guarantee the readings are
invariantly due to the expansion element.
- Manufacturing Time: This specification is generally kept as low as possible in order to ensure the best turn
around of the product. There is a specific manufacturing process that would shorten the total time, but cost
for the use of the equipment is not acceptable for preliminary modeling. The process being used, E-Beam
vs. Optical lithography, would be changed once mass production is required.
- Batch Fabrication: A parallel process of manufacturing will allow for batch fabrication, which means the
same time required to create one sensor can produce 21 sensors with a basic fabrication modification.
- Ease of Calibration: This has more to do with customer satisfaction. A sensor that is easy to calibrate is
more attractive to scientists then one that is not. A user friendly product is the ultimate goal.
- Repeatability: This is another fundamental specification that any quality sensor should have. The ability to
obtain the same values for consecutive measurements is a requirement for this design.
- Supply Voltage: The desire for little power consumption was discussed earlier in this section, but there isstill a numerical value needed to create a basic design. This value was found from existing products.
- Ease of Integration: It is preferable that the customer do as little as possible to integrate our product into
their system. This again has to do with keeping the product user-friendly.
- Environmental Effects: It is very important that our product not interfere with the outside environment.
Additionally, the outside environment should not interfere with the sensor. This is where the packaging
material is very important and will need to be considered intensely.
- Cost: This is an obvious specification that should be kept to a minimum by all means. It is however last on
the list of specification requirements since a quality sensor is of utmost importance and should not be
compensated due to cost.
3.5 Initial Concepts
This section presents the basic concept designs that were drafted, which explore several different options for ultra-
small-scale temperature measurement. The concepts are then compared using weighted criteria in the sections to
follow and finally, a selection is made. It is important to note that not all of the options employ CNTs. Also, the
following concepts include discussion on some nanomanufacturing processes. It is important to discuss each
concept based on the issues that are related to manufacturing. Descriptions and further information on these
processes is discussed in Chapter 4 of this report.
3.5.1 Concept # 1: Temperature Sensor Using a Single Carbon Nanotube, Oriented Using Dielectrophoresis
This design would involve using the thermal properties of a single carbon nanotube (CNT) to measure temperature.
It would consist of placing a pair of metal electrodes on a substrate. These electrodes would be separated by a single
CNT (Figure 17: Temperature sensor using a single CNT).
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
34/84
Figure 17: Temperature sensor using a single CNT
Unlike bulk CNTs, measurements from a single CNT will not average out due to the absence of tube to tube
junctions [14]. Therefore, by making use of a single CNT to measure resistance as a function of temperature, the
repeatability of the sensors manufactured from various batches will increase significantly, provided the CNTs
obtained from the various batches remain consistent.
The manufacturing process usually used for single CNT fabrication is Atomic Force Microscope (AFM)manipulation and dielectrophoresis.
Some of the challenges of this design are
Precision manipulation of CNTs
High initial equipment cost
Cannot perform batch fabrication using AFM; hence lower throughput and high production cost
Dielectrophoresis uses AC field for CNT alignment, which results in inconsistency in CNTlocation/placement
50 - 100micrometers
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
35/84
Figure 18: SEM image showing a single CNT
Figure 19: A single CNT shown between two gold leads
3.5.2 Design Concept # 2: Temperature Sensor Using Nano Scale Metallic Resistive Element
In order to obtain a higher spatial resolution and sensitivity, the sensor devices must have smaller resolutions.
One of the potential concepts would be to design a micro/nano scale temperature sensor device that includes a
metallic wire fabricated on a suitable substrate (Error! Reference source not found.). Using the
resistive/conductive properties of the metal, a correlation with change in temperature can be obtained. Gold is
one of the proven metals that has been previously used to design a thermistor based sensor [15]. The electrical
properties of gold as well as other potential metallic nano particles materials needs investigation to determine
the best option for nanoscale temperature sensor applications.
7/21/2019 Flexible Carbon Nanotube Based Temperature Sensor for Ultra-small
36/84
Figure 20: Sensor Concept Employing a Complex Pattern for Increased Sensitivity to Temperature
The fabrication of metallic element on the substrate is usually done using the process