Post on 26-Dec-2015
Federation of GCC Chambers Conference on
Frameworks for funding industrial projects
12 October 2010
Banks
Sukuk
ECA
Public
Bo
nd
Banks
Sukuk
ECA
Public
Bo
nd
2
Agenda
Lay of the Land
What is Project Finance?
Structuring Considerations
Sources of Liquidity
Financial Process & Scheduling
3
The Economic Backdrop - Global
What has happened is known; what will happen is now the subject of much debate .....
Source: HSBC Research
New questions over EuropeGlobal - Real GDP growth
-6.00%
-4.00%
-2.00%
0.00%
2.00%
4.00%
6.00%
8.00%
10.00%
1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011
Developed Emerging
4
Despite significant regional government liquidity, the Middle East has not been immune to the effects of external liquidity constraints
Source: Dealogic, 12 May 2009
0
5,000
10,000
15,000
20,000
25,000
30,000
35,000
40,000
45,000
Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
Volume (US$m) No. of loans
Volume (US$m) No. of loans
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009
Key Player – The Middle East
5
What is Project Finance?
6
What is Project Finance?
Form of lending which can be be applied to a wide range of industries and involves the financing of a single major capital investment
For which repayment (either largely or exclusively) of the lenders relies on the cash flow and assets of the project, with such debt facilities being “limited” or “non-recourse” to the owners of the asset
Project finance facilities are typically provided to a SPV (a project company) established by the project sponsors solely to own and operate the project
A form of asset based finance
driven by cashflow analysis
Significant advantages to
lenders as well as owners
Shareholders
Project
LendersRelative Repayment Risk
Low High
Shareholders
Lenders
Commercial and Financial Completion support
Project
= Lender credit risk
7
Why is Project Finance used?
Allows for high levels of leverage and is therefore investment enhancing
Enables cash constrained - or risk averse - project sponsors to raise significant amounts of debt - and share risks - whilst still retaining the benefit of equity upside
Enables sponsors to leverage off general banking relationships to (1) potentially circumvent constraints on corporate debt, and / or (2) access longer term funding
Facilitates multiple joint venture partners raising finance to undertake major projects, especially if the partners have different credit standing
Depending on the country / industry,
project finance may offer
significant advantages for
Project hosts or sponsors...
8
Project Finance vs Corporate Lending
Corporate Lending
Full recourse
Lenders rely on established balance sheet and cash flow
Credit analysis and rating
Usually unsecured
Limited covenants (financial, cross default and negative pledge)
Relatively low fees and margins
Short to medium tem tenor
Refinancing risk
Project Finance
Limited or non recourse
Security over project assets including physical and accounts
Detailed economic and financial analysis carried out by lenders with support of independent consultants
Comprehensive covenant package (affirmative, negative)
Usually relatively high fees and margins, although current trends favourable to borrowers
Long term tenor
Key differences between
corporate lending and project
finance
9
Structuring Considerations
10
Lenders closely scrutinize the Project’s rationale and its ability to withstand difficult market conditions. The following aspects in relation to project economics are analyzed:
Demand / supply analysis and likely competition
Evidence ability to generate sufficient cash against credible product pricing forecasts
Project’s competitive advantage, including:
– Feedstock volume and pricing
– Terms and conditions of the offtake arrangement
Project Economics and Rational
In structuring the financing, it is important
to ensure complementary
contracting and product marketing solutions
11
Project Finance – identifying the risks
The risks associated with the repayment of the project debt can be categorised into three broad areas:
Completion Risk
Operational Risk
Revenue Risk
12
Completion Risk & EPC Contracting Strategy
Completion risk is at the core of any project
finance structuring given that this
determines the availability of future
cash flow
If a full guarantee is to be avoided then completion risk
mitigation and allocation become the
critical elements of the financing
Completion risk for projects is basically a function of construction strategy:
– Which parties are responsible for completion?
Lenders’ “default” position will be a full completion guarantee (full repayment)
There are other forms of completion support
Residual Risks
(non-insurable FM, EPC performance)
Completion Risk
Vendor Performance
Engineering
Process technology
Insurable Force Majeure
EPC Contractor(s)
Process Licensor(s)
Insurers
SponsorsLenders
13
Revenue Risks
It is usually necessary that an independent market advisor to lenders indicate that the Project will be competitive based on
– Relatively low feedstock costs
– Economies of scale
– Detailed marketing and logistics planning
Lenders will require independent product price forecasts
Lenders will expect term sheet risk mitigation items for short term variations
– Debt Service Reserve Account
– Dividend lock-up tests
– Variable repayment schedules
– Occasionally contingent equity is required
Lenders will usually take some revenue risks
when they are comfortable with the
Project
Utility projects are often financed without such
risks, however
14
Revenue Risks
Lenders will usually take some revenue risks
when they are comfortable with the
Project
In other sectors the long-term offtake obligations come from one or a small number customers (for example in the LNG or power and water sectors)
Due to the nature of the petrochemical business and the large number of customers, long-term volume offtake commitments from shareholders are often considered, provided they are “natural” petrochemical players; third parties may be considered if shareholder group not sufficiently experienced
Product sale contracts can vary between long-term marketing arrangements and long-term volume offtake commitments
Production ramp-ups are usually built into the contracts
15
Technical & Operating Risks
Technical risks relate to the risk of the plant being capable of operating reliably on the basis that it has been designed to – one of the two components determining the plant’s cash flow (the other being refining margins)
– Technical problems can be either process or mechanically based
– Mechanical problems will usually be covered under the terms of the EPC contract
– Although the process technology deployed in refining tends to be viewed as less of an issue than in typical petrochemical plants, the multiple processes involved can give rise to concerns over inter-licensor disputes in the event of non-performance
In addition to concerns over technical operating issues, lenders will also require comfort that the operator of the plant is sufficiently experienced
Different models can be used, usually either an external O&M contractor (which could be sponsor) or operating staff hired directly by the project SPV
Lenders will require a detailed due diligence report by an engineering firm to review these risks and it is important that this process is controlled
Operational reliability post-construction is a
critical area for lenders and external
advice will be sought to analyse the risks
involved
16
Key Due Diligence Areas
Thorough audit of the Financial Model by a recognised Accountancy firm/ Model Auditing specialist
Production of Model Audit Report on behalf of the LendersModel Audit
Review of proposed Insurance Programme (incl. levels of cover, principal exclusions, deductibles etc)
Production of Independent Consultant’s report on behalf of the Lenders
Insurance
Detailed review by Lenders’ Legal Counsel of all Project contracts
Detailed review of local law issues that may affect the Project
Detailed review of Lenders’ security arrangements
Production of Legal Counsel’s report on behalf of the Lenders
Assist lenders in negotiation and drafting of Finance and Security Documents
Legal
Conduct analysis of the target export markets
Produce and agree price forecasts to be used in the Lenders’ Base Case Financial Model
Evaluate the competitiveness of the Project compared to competing plants elsewhere in the world
Production of Independent Consultant’s report on behalf of the Lenders
Market
Conduct Environmental & Social Impact Assessment
Categorise Project under EP and evaluate EP compliance
Develop Environmental and Social Action Plans
Production of Independent Consultant’s report on behalf of Lenders confirming EP compliance
Environment
Independent review of technology, and key operating assumptions etc
Independent review of capex budgets, construction timetable etc
Production of Independent Consultant’s report on behalf of the Lenders
Technical
Key ActivitiesDue Diligence Area
Thorough audit of the Financial Model by a recognised Accountancy firm/ Model Auditing specialist
Production of Model Audit Report on behalf of the LendersModel Audit
Review of proposed Insurance Programme (incl. levels of cover, principal exclusions, deductibles etc)
Production of Independent Consultant’s report on behalf of the Lenders
Insurance
Detailed review by Lenders’ Legal Counsel of all Project contracts
Detailed review of local law issues that may affect the Project
Detailed review of Lenders’ security arrangements
Production of Legal Counsel’s report on behalf of the Lenders
Assist lenders in negotiation and drafting of Finance and Security Documents
Legal
Conduct analysis of the target export markets
Produce and agree price forecasts to be used in the Lenders’ Base Case Financial Model
Evaluate the competitiveness of the Project compared to competing plants elsewhere in the world
Production of Independent Consultant’s report on behalf of the Lenders
Market
Conduct Environmental & Social Impact Assessment
Categorise Project under EP and evaluate EP compliance
Develop Environmental and Social Action Plans
Production of Independent Consultant’s report on behalf of Lenders confirming EP compliance
Environment
Independent review of technology, and key operating assumptions etc
Independent review of capex budgets, construction timetable etc
Production of Independent Consultant’s report on behalf of the Lenders
Technical
Key ActivitiesDue Diligence Area
17
Sources of Debt
18
Despite difficult market conditions, the Saudi-based institutions have actively provided balance sheet capacity for top-tier Saudi projects and relationship clients.
12 primary domestic Saudi banks, out of which 7 are considered to be active in project finance transactions in Saudi Arabia
Inma Bank, Rajhi Bank and to a certain extent National Commercial Bank finance only Sharia compliant debt facilities. Other active banks in the PF market will have the capability to fund on Islamic or conventional basis
Saudi banks have fared better compared to other international and regional banks. None of the Saudi banks have had to request any government support or to raise additional equity to shore up balance sheet
Due to severe shortage of liquidity and risk averseness in the international market, Saudi banks have significantly reduced their lending in US Dollars
Saudi Commercial Banks
Aided by a stable depositor base, strong
capital adequacy ratios and continued growth in
the local economy, Saudi banks continue to
represent an important source of funding for
projects in KSA
19
Regional and international banks have been severely impacted by the financial crisis, with most of the banks having to resort to government funding due to significant investment writedowns
It will take these banks some time before they are able to restore their financial strength and play a major lending role in projects in the region and Saudi Arabia
Currently, the pool of liquidity available to projects from international and regional banks is much smaller than that seen during times before the financial crisis. The international and regional banks have the following characteristics:
Selective participation in projects within the region with focus on enhancing existing relationships
Understand the risks of project finance lending activity in Saudi Arabia but focussed on reducing their Risk Weighted Assets
Concern over tenors and pricing are a dominant theme
Likely to increase involvement in ECA covered facilities
Appetite from this liquidity pool is
mostly dependant on availability of
ECA cover
Regional and International Banks
20
The SIDF usually has a longer approvals process as it involves detailed review of technical and market issues by SIDF’s own experts.
SIDF has a normal lending limit per project of US$160m for an LLC. However if there the Project comprises multiple plants then multiple loans can be granted of up to 50% of project cost or US$530m whichever is lower
In order to manage the timing issue, SIDF as soon as possible upon completion of the feasibility study and completion of application formalities such as application form, copies of industrial licences, commercial registration of project companies applying for the loan, copies of commercial agreements, quotes from EPC contractors, etc.
Given the time required for first drawdown, SIDF loan will however still need to be bridged by Saudi commercial banks.
Saudi Industrial Development Fund
SIDF remains an important participant in
project financings in KSA
21
PIF is a main source of concessionary financing available in the Kingdom
One of the main conditions for PIF participation is direct or indirect government ownership of at least 5% of the project. In any case, PIF's board of directors has the discretion to set PIF's investment strategy, as well as the parameters that must be met before PIF makes an investment
PIF currently has increased its limit to lower of 40% of total project cost or US$1.3 billion (US$ 800 million where the project company is not majority owned by the government)
The terms and conditions generally match those of the commercial tranches which make it an attractive source of concessionary financing
From our experience, if both SIDF and PIF are considering participation in a project, PIF approvals will almost always follow SIDF approvals.
If PIF financing is not available at financial close, additional commitments can obtained from the local commercial banks to bridge the financing gap on temporary basis
The PIF is a main source of concessionary
financing available in the Kingdom
Public Investment Fund
22
Export Credit Agencies (ECAs) - I
ECAs are government sponsored agencies which exist to promote the export of goods and services from within their countries
They function by providing direct loans, guarantees or insurance policies to commercial banks
In most cases the level of ECA support is directly ‘tied’ to procurement of eligible goods and services although ‘untied’ facilities are also possible
The financing terms ECA can provide are governed by the OECD Consensus Guidelines. This covers areas such as:
– Specific ‘content’ requirements
– Minimum contract down payment of 15%
– Support capped at 85% of contract value
– Maximum repayment term of 14 years (with average life of 7.25 years)
By providing credit enhancement to lenders
ECAs can facilitate greater appetite, longer
tenors and cheaper pricing than purely
commercial sources of funding
23
Increasing proportion of hard currently liquidity …but critical to pair with a considered procurement strategy.
Commercial banks provide a loan to the Borrower. This loan benefits from a guarantee or insurance policy from the ECA The proceeds of this loan is used to pay for specific goods and services from the exporting country The ECA is paid a premium/guarantee fee
Project Company
Exporter ECAs
Lenders
Drawings
Loan Agreement
Principal & Interest
Political or comprehensive
insurance and/ or direct loan
Premium
Commercial Contract
Application Documentation
Goods & Services
Export Credit Agencies - II
24
Since 2002, ECAs became an increasingly important source of financing in the region. Pre-financial crisis the ECA lending to project increased due to:
Upgrade in OECD country risk classification for Saudi Arabia from category 3 to category 2 in Nov 2005
ECA financing became much more competitive compared to cost of borrowing from commercial banks
Scale and number of opportunities combined with historically low exposure to Saudi Arabia resulted in substantial ECA appetite
Strong track record of ECA support was established for both limited and full recourse financings in Saudi Arabia, for example SEPC, Hadeed, Yansab, Petro-Rabigh, and Shuaibah
Interest of ECAs was not limited to tied facilities linked to specific exports of goods and services but also started extending to untied facilities where there was a wider national interest.
For well-structured projects in Saudi
Arabia, we anticipate that
ECAs would be keen to continue
providing support with expected
participation dependant on the EPC procurement
strategy.
Export Credit Agencies - III
25
In light of reduction in appetite from international and regional banks post financial crisis, there is substantially increased demand from sponsors for ECA support. This has led to:
ECAs focussing more on supporting projects involving contractors and equipment providers from their home countries (ie less focus on untied ECA financings)
ECA premiums have increased in some cases to reflect changes in perceived risk while bank pricing for funding ECA assets has risen substantially as a result of liquidity charges
ECA supported financing continues to be very competitive for borrowers and attractive for banks given very low return on weighted assets
Where ECAs provide direct lending programmes these have also seen increased demand, given the attractive long-term fixed interest rates and the reduced liquidly of commercial banks even for covered facilities
For well-structured projects in Saudi
Arabia, we anticipate that ECAs
would be keen to continue providing
support with expected
participation dependant on the EPC procurement
strategy.
Export Credit Agencies - IV
26
Multilateral Agencies
Multilateral Agencies are financial institutions jointly owned by a group of countries and designed to promote international and regional economic co-operation
Examples of Multilateral Agencies include:
– International Finance Corporation (IFC)
– European Investment Bank (EIB)
– European Bank for Reconstruction and Development (EBRD)
– Asian Development Bank (ADB)
– Islamic Development Bank
Have ‘developmental’ agendas and can be useful in certain markets
Can provide a range of funding including direct lending and equity participation
Commonly used instruments on project finance transactions are:
– EIB direct loans (with or without bank counter guarantees)
– IFC / EBRD ‘A’ – ‘B’ Loans
27
The Financing Process
28
The Project Finance Process: Summary Timeline
Estimated Timeframe:
3 - 6 months
PHASE 5
1. Negotiation of Project and Finance Agreements
2. Achieving Financial Close
Estimated Timeframe:
3 months
PHASE 4
1. EPC finalisation
2. Launch to market
3. Preferred bank selection
Estimated Timeframe:
2 - 4 months
PHASE 3
1. EPC bid review
2. Lender due diligence
3. Document drafting
4. Info Memo
Estimated Timeframe:
2 - 4 months
PHASE 2
1. Tender for Contractors
2. Commercial Development
3. Term sheet development
PHASE 1
1. Prioritise Key Project Objectives
2. Finalise JV Discussions
3. Obtain Stakeholder Approval
Such may vary materially depending on the progress of commercial and contractual negotiations
29
Managing the Project Finance Process: Delivering the Financing Plan and Strategy
Size the project and define the funding requirement;
Assess the potential debt sources for the financing for the Project, with particular attention to appetite, tenor, capacity, liquidity and pricing;
Advise the sponsors on the commercial contractual negotiations to ensure such contracts are bankable;
Identify studies typically required to successfully obtain the Financing, including technical, market and environmental reports.
Appoint and manage the lenders’ technical and environmental consultant to identify key lender issues that need to be addressed in the structuring;
Develop a financial model to analyze the economics of the Project and provide information to support the Sponsor’s investment decision; and
Recommend an appropriate financing plan and strategy taking into account current financial market conditions.
The Financial Advisors can support developers
in structuring a bankable project and securing an
optimal funding package
The Financial Advisor can act as Lead
Consultant to coordinate and manage technical,
legal, marketing, environmental and other
advisors
30
Managing the Project Finance Process: Marketing Phase - Achieving Financial Close
Develop a bankable financing structure using data from the financial model and bank market practice and taking into account inputs from the Sponsor’s tax, legal, and accounting advisors;
Develop an engagement timetable for the different sources of liquidity, bearing in mind that certain pools of liquidity will require longer lead times than others;
Assist in the development of a preliminary term sheet in order to secure Sponsor approval;
Prepare a bid package for potential debt providers including an invitation letter, a confidentiality agreement, a draft arranging and underwriting mandate letter, a draft term sheet for the Financing and its security package, a preliminary information memorandum (the “PIM”), a preliminary Bank Financial Model and summaries of third party reports;
Review and summarise the financing bids and assist the Sponsor in selecting the optimal financing group;
Assist the Sponsors and Legal Counsel in the negotiation and finalization of the financing documentation until signing of the documents, satisfaction of conditions precedents and draw-down of the facilities.
31
Conclusions
Economic outlook remains uncertain, however the GCC is well positioned for robust and sustainable growth
Select the right financing methodology that suits your requirements and objectives ie corporate vs project financing
Financiers are now far more selective with transactions so maximise the sources of funding – tap the Money Tree
Focus on developing well structured and viable projects that have a clear competitive advantage, are aligned with the government’s industrialisation strategy and are supported by credible financial and technical sponsors