Data Quality and Uncertainty Visualization

UC San DiegoCOGS 220

Winter Quarter 2006Barry Demchak

Immediate Motivation: Wiisard

A joint project of Veterans Administration and UC San Diego, funded by the National Library of Medicine

Mass casualty triage and treatment Enter patient information via PDAs Patient information summarized on tablet PCs Command/control for supervisors and incident

comment personnel Tied together using 802.11b and store-and-

forward database access

Wiisard – Explosion with Pesticides

Wiisard – Network Deployment

Wiisard – Tablet Display

Wiisard – Command/Control

Wiisard – The Problem

What if the network becomes partitioned? Tablet display shows out-of-date patient

information Summary displays are out of date, too

How does this lead to bad decisions? Supervisors may mis-deploy doctors Incident command may mis-deploy resources

People may die

DOD Example Sensor-to-shooter (STS) Networks – Patrick

Driscoll (USMA), June 2002

DOD Example

DOD Example “… our first attempt to get the military

community to realize that there is a degree of uncertainty involved in (digital) information systems that cannot be engineered out of thesystem.”

“Ultimately, our concern was an awareness issue (for the decision maker) …”

“… woman at MITRE had proposed a system of tagging intelligence starting at the source in a way that would reflect the uncertainty of the data being put into the intel database.”

The Problem

How to visualize the uncertainty in data so that humans can exercise judgment in making the best decision

Accounting for uncertainty is not the same thing as visualizing uncertainty

What Labs are Involved MIT Sloan School of Management

Richard Wang (Data Quality) Penn State University

Alan MacEachren (GIS) University of Maine

Kate Beard-Tisdale (GIS) University of California, Santa Cruz

Alex Pang (Scientific Visualization) University of Arkansas, Little Rock

Master of Sciences in Information Quality

What Conferences are There?

MIT Information Quality (IQatMIT) ACM SIGMOD Workshop on Information Qua

lity in Information Systems (IQIS) ACM SIGKDD (Knowledge Discovery and Dat

a Mining) MIT International Conference on Information

Quality (ICIQ)

Semiotic Interpretation

Data Visualization

Normal Mapping

Mapping

Normal

Data Visualization

Normal Mapping

PoorData

Quality

DataMapping

Data UncertaintyVisualization

Uncertainty Mapping

Mapping

Poor DataQuality w/

Uncertainty

Definition of Data Quality From Wand & Wang:

Metrics Timeliness How up to date relative to intended purpose

Ballou et al: Timeliness = Max(0, 1-(currency/volatility) Currency = delivery_time – input_time Volatility = length of time data remains valid Apply sensitivity factor “s”: Timeliness ^ s

Tim

elin

ess

time

Tim

elin

ess

time

Pulse = 80 Pulse = 180

Interplay with Uncertainty

Metrics are application dependent Metrics are data dependent Metrics are user dependent Question: If a metric describes an individual

data element, what is the effect of aggregating data elements having uncertainty??

GIS Examples – NCGIA

Sample point locations as overlay

Sample points and corresponding contours using naïve shading

GIS Examples – NCGIA

Gray shading uncertainty surface captures distance function used by interpolation method

Uncertainty encoded in contour line widths

Fill Clarity

Resolution

GIS Techniques

Contour Crispness

Fog

Merging Data and Uncertainty

Risk and uncertainty separately

Risk and uncertainty combined

Basic Data Examples Errors

Basic Data Examples Errors

Basic Data Examples Ambiguation

Basic Data Examples Ambiguation

Photo Realistic

Uncertainty Vector Glyphs

Uncertainty Vector Glyphs

Hue as Uncertainty With

out

With

Texture as Uncertainty

Raw

Trans-parent Points

Cer-tain-ty

Opaque Lines

Data Confidence

x is a device, is decay constant, R(x) is a weighting for device x in the calculation

Back to Wiisard

x

xpingtimexposttimecurtime

xRC

)()(1

1)(

Back to Wiisard

Individual data (annotation)

Aggregate data (annotated/integrated)

Back to Wiisard Annotated

Back to Wiisard Integrated

Research Questions

What are the dimensions of metrics relevant for determining data quality for medical providers in a mass casualty context?

What kind of visualization best conveys the use suitability for various kinds of data? Single data points Streaming bioinformation Aggregated information

Research Questions What kinds of visualizations are best suited to

field personnel? Non-IS frenzied technicians High glare, small footprint screens Low processing power

What kinds of visualizations are best suited to incident command? Seasoned experts Large, high density displays Highly connected with high data processing

Conclusion

Data Quality and Uncertainty Visualization are like the weather …

… everyone’s talks about it, but no one does anything about it