Post on 30-Dec-2015
description
Comparison of Current Contract and 11/5/13
Company Proposal
Conclusions
• Overall company’s proposal for the initial year costs approximately the same as current contract• Increases in pay from extended longevity and higher license pay is
largely offset from savings from changes in welfare plans, and further offset by other changes in existing contracts e.g. recall / more flexible labor utilization / shift restrictions• Going forward medical trend will erode the modest pay increases
Methodology
• The analysis compares the overall compensation package• Starts with the pay rates• Subtracts average welfare premiums currently by subgroup and proposed for
the group as a whole• Adds costs for retiree medical programs by subgroup (no retiree medical
under proposal)• Adds company pension costs for UAL 401(k), CARP + Continental match, and
proposed pension• Adds difference in cost of current 15% profit sharing and proposed 3% profit
sharing to subgroups (United costing)• Adds cost of other concessions to subgroups (United costing)
Comments
• Analysis looks at averages, results for individuals could be markedly different, e.g. Sub United medical costs today are $0 for 2/3rd of the subgroup and will be several hundred dollars per month under company’s proposal
• Some more targeted examples follow
United – 12 year S-UA Employee
CURRENT PROPOSED
Pay $ 31.17 $ 30.85 + $1.50 VEBA
License 4.25 5.50
Longevity 1.00 1.00
Line 0.50 0.50
GROSS PAY $ 36.92 $ 37.85 + $1.50 VEBA
Welfare 0.00 -1.66
15% Profit Sharing 0.00 -0.56
Lifetime Recall 0.00 -0.46
Retiree Medical 0.00 -0.52
LOA 31 & Utility Spec. Restrictions 0.00 -0.31
NET PAY $ 36.92 $ 34.34 + $1.50 VEBA
United – 20 year S-UA Employee
CURRENT PROPOSED
Pay $ 31.17 $ 30.85 + $1.50 VEBA
License 4.25 5.50
Longevity 1.00 1.50
Line 0.50 0.50
GROSS PAY $ 36.92 $ 38.35 + $1.50 VEBA
Welfare 0.00 -1.66
15% Profit Sharing 0.00 -0.56
Lifetime Recall 0.00 -0.46
Retiree Medical 0.00 -0.52
LOA 31 & Utility Spec. Restrictions 0.00 -0.31
NET PAY $ 36.92 $ 34.84 + $1.50 VEBA
United – 20 year S-UA SFO Employee
CURRENT PROPOSED
Pay $ 31.17 $ 30.85 + $1.50 VEBA
License 4.25 5.50
Longevity 1.00 1.50
Line 0.50 0.00
GROSS PAY $ 36.92 $ 37.85 + $1.50 VEBA
Welfare 0.00 -1.66
15% Profit Sharing 0.00 -0.56
Lifetime Recall 0.00 -0.46
Retiree Medical 0.00 -0.52
LOA 31 & Utility Spec. Restrictions 0.00 -0.31
NET PAY $ 36.92 $ 34.34 + $1.50 VEBA
United – 20 year S-CO Employee
CURRENT PROPOSED
Pay $ 31.17 $ 30.85 + $1.50 VEBA
License 4.25 5.50
Longevity 1.00 1.50
Line 0.50 0.50
GROSS PAY $ 36.92 $ 38.35 + $1.50 VEBA
Welfare -1.62 -1.53
15% Profit Sharing 0.00 -0.56
Lifetime Recall 0.00 0.00
Retiree Medical 0.00 -0.84
LOA 31 & Utility Spec. Restrictions 0.00 -0.31
NET PAY $ 35.32 $ 35.11 + $1.50 VEBA
United – 12 year S-CO Employee
CURRENT PROPOSED
Pay $ 31.17 $ 30.85 + 1.50 VEBA
License 4.25 5.50
Longevity 1.00 1.00
Line 0.50 0.50
GROSS PAY $ 36.92 $ 37.85 + 1.50 VEBA
Welfare -1.62 -1.53
15% Profit Sharing 0.00 -0.56
Lifetime Recall 0.00 0.00
Retiree Medical 0.00 -0.84
LOA 31 & Utility Spec. Restrictions 0.00 -0.31
NET PAY $ 35.30 $ 34.61 + 1.50 VEBA