Post on 09-Apr-2018
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 1/25
Capital Asset Pricing TheoryCapital Asset Pricing Theory
andand
Arbitrage Pricing TheoryArbitrage Pricing Theory
Chapter 19Chapter 19
11
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 2/25
Learning ObjectivesLearning Objectives
To understand the concept of CAPM theoryTo understand the concept of CAPM theory
To distinguish between CML and SMLTo distinguish between CML and SML
To trace the empirical tests of CAPMTo trace the empirical tests of CAPM
To understand APT theoryTo understand APT theory
22
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 3/25
The CAPM TheoryThe CAPM Theory
Markowitz, William Sharpe, John Lintner andMarkowitz, William Sharpe, John Lintner and
Jan Mossin provided the basic structure for theJan Mossin provided the basic structure for the
CAPM model.CAPM model.
It is a model of linear general equilibrium return.It is a model of linear general equilibrium return.
The required rate return of an asset is having a linear The required rate return of an asset is having a linear
relationship with asset¶s beta valuerelationship with asset¶s beta value i.e.,i.e.,
undiversifiable or systematic risk.undiversifiable or systematic risk.
33
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 4/25
AssumptionsAssumptions
An individual seller or buyer cannot affect the priceAn individual seller or buyer cannot affect the priceof a stock.of a stock.
Investors make their decisions only on the basis of Investors make their decisions only on the basis of the expected returns, standard deviations andthe expected returns, standard deviations andcovariances of all pairs of securities.covariances of all pairs of securities.
Investors are assumed to have homogenousInvestors are assumed to have homogenousexpectations during the decisionexpectations during the decision--making period.making period.
The investor can lend or borrow any amount of fundsThe investor can lend or borrow any amount of fundsat the riskless rate of interest.at the riskless rate of interest.
Assets are infinitely divisible.Assets are infinitely divisible.
There is no transaction cost.There is no transaction cost.
There is no personal income tax.There is no personal income tax.
Unlimited quantum of short sales, is allowed.Unlimited quantum of short sales, is allowed. 44
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 5/25
Lending and BorrowingLending and Borrowing
It is assumed that the investor could borrow or lendIt is assumed that the investor could borrow or lend
any amount of money at riskless rate of interest.any amount of money at riskless rate of interest.
R R p p = Portfolio return= Portfolio return
XXf f = The proportion of funds invested in risk free assets= The proportion of funds invested in risk free assets
11 ± ± XXf f = The proportion of funds invested in risky assets= The proportion of funds invested in risky assets
R R f f = Risk free rate of return= Risk free rate of return
R R mm = Return on risky assets= Return on risky assets
The expected return on the combination of risky andThe expected return on the combination of risky and
risk free combination isrisk free combination is
p f f m f R = R X + R (1 ± X )
55
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 6/25
The market portfolio comprised of all stocks inThe market portfolio comprised of all stocks in
the market.the market.
Each asset is held in proportion to its marketEach asset is held in proportion to its market
value to the total value of all risky assets.value to the total value of all risky assets.
Market PortfolioMarket Portfolio
66
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 7/25
The Capital Market LineThe Capital Market Line
Str onglye
icientmar k et¡
llin
or mationisr e
lectedon pr ices.Weak lye
icientmar k et¡
llhistor icalin
or mationisr e
lectedonsecur itySemistr onge
icientmar k et¡
ll pu blicin
or mationisr e
lectedonsecur ity pr icesStr onglye
icientmar k et¡
llin
or mationisr e
lectedon pr ices.Weak lye
icientmar k et¡
llhistor icalin
or mationisr e
lectedonsecur itySemistr onge
icientmar k et¡
ll pu blicin
or mationisr e
lectedonsecur ity pr icesStr onglye
icientmar k et¡
llin
or mationisr e
lectedon pr ices.Weak lye
icientmar k et¡
llhistor icalin
or mationisr e
lectedonsecur itySemistr onge
icientmar k et¡
ll pu blicin
or mationisr e
lectedonsecur ity pr ices
Rp
Rf
S
CML
Wp
77
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 8/25
The portfolio along the path R The portfolio along the path R f f S is called lendingS is called lending portfolio, that is some money is invested in the portfolio, that is some money is invested in theriskless asset.riskless asset.
If it crosses the point S, it becomes borrowingIf it crosses the point S, it becomes borrowing portfolio. portfolio.
Money is borrowed and invested in the risky asset.Money is borrowed and invested in the risky asset.
The straight line is called capital market line (CML).The straight line is called capital market line (CML).
The CML represents linear relationship between theThe CML represents linear relationship between therequired rates of return for efficient portfolios andrequired rates of return for efficient portfolios andtheir standard deviations.their standard deviations.
The Capital Market Line (Contd.)The Capital Market Line (Contd.)
88
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 9/25
ER ER p p = portfolio¶s expected rate of return= portfolio¶s expected rate of return
R R mm = expected return on market portfolio= expected return on market portfolio
WWmm = standard deviation of market portfolio= standard deviation of market portfolio
WW p p
= standard deviation of the portfolio= standard deviation of the portfolio
m f p f p
m
( ± )= ×
The Capital Market Line (Contd.)The Capital Market Line (Contd.)
99
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 10/25
R eturnR eturn
The expected return of an efficient portfolio isThe expected return of an efficient portfolio is
Expected return =Expected return =
Price of time + (Price of risk Price of time + (Price of risk Amount of risk)Amount of risk)
Price of time is the risk free rate of returnPrice of time is the risk free rate of return
Price of risk is the premium amount higher andPrice of risk is the premium amount higher and
above the risk free returnabove the risk free return
1010
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 11/25
Security Market LineSecurity Market Line
Capital market line does not show the risk Capital market line does not show the risk--returnreturn
trade off for other portfolios and individual securities.trade off for other portfolios and individual securities.
Standard deviation includes the systematic andStandard deviation includes the systematic and
unsystematic risk.unsystematic risk.
Unsystematic risk can be diversified and it is notUnsystematic risk can be diversified and it is not
related to the market.related to the market.
Systematic risk could be measured by beta.Systematic risk could be measured by beta. The beta analysis is useful for individual securitiesThe beta analysis is useful for individual securities
and portfolios whether efficient or inefficient.and portfolios whether efficient or inefficient.
1111
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 12/25
The SML helps to determine the expected return for aThe SML helps to determine the expected return for a
given security betagiven security beta
m
m f i f im/
m
± ± OV
Security Market Line (Contd.)Security Market Line (Contd.)
1212
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 13/25
Security Market LineSecurity Market Line
YRp
Rrn
Rf
01
XBeta
1313
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 14/25
Evaluation of Securities with Evaluation of Securities with
SMLSML
R
S
T
A
C
U
V
W
Rf
Y
Rp
.9 . . .2
t
SML
1414
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 15/25
The stocks above the SML yield higher returns for The stocks above the SML yield higher returns for
the same level of risk.the same level of risk.
They are underpriced compared to their beta value.They are underpriced compared to their beta value.
wherewhere PPii ² ²present price present price
PPoo ² ²purchase price purchase price
DivDiv² ²dividend.dividend.
i oi
o
P ± P + DivR =
P
Evaluation of Securities with Evaluation of Securities with
SML (Contd.)SML (Contd.)
1515
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 16/25
Empirical Tests of the CAPMEmpirical Tests of the CAPM
The studies generally showed a significant positiveThe studies generally showed a significant positiverelationship between the expected return and the systematicrelationship between the expected return and the systematicrisk.risk.
But the slope of the relationship is usually less than that of But the slope of the relationship is usually less than that of predicted by the CAPM. predicted by the CAPM.
The risk and return relationship appears to be linear. EmpiricalThe risk and return relationship appears to be linear. Empiricalstudies give no evidence of significant curvature in thestudies give no evidence of significant curvature in therisk/return relationship.risk/return relationship.
The CAPM theory implies that unsystematic risk is notThe CAPM theory implies that unsystematic risk is notrelevant, but unsystematic and systematic risks are positivelyrelevant, but unsystematic and systematic risks are positively
related to security returns.related to security returns.
The ambiguity of the market portfolio leaves the CAPMThe ambiguity of the market portfolio leaves the CAPMuntestable.untestable.
If the CAPM were completely valid, it should apply to allIf the CAPM were completely valid, it should apply to all
financial assets including bonds.financial assets including bonds. 16
16
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 17/25
Present Validity of CAPMPresent Validity of CAPM
CAPM provides basic concepts which is truly of CAPM provides basic concepts which is truly of
fundamental value.fundamental value.
The CAPM has been useful in the selection of The CAPM has been useful in the selection of securities and portfolios.securities and portfolios.
Given the estimate of the risk free rate, the beta of theGiven the estimate of the risk free rate, the beta of the
firm, stock and the required market rate of return, onefirm, stock and the required market rate of return, one
can find out the expected returns for a firm¶s security.can find out the expected returns for a firm¶s security.
17
17
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 18/25
ArbitrageArbitrage
Arbitrage is a process of earning profit byArbitrage is a process of earning profit by
taking advantage of differential pricing for thetaking advantage of differential pricing for the
same asset.same asset.
The process generates riskless profit.The process generates riskless profit.
In the security market, it is of selling securityIn the security market, it is of selling security
at a high price and the simultaneous purchaseat a high price and the simultaneous purchaseof the same security.of the same security.
18
18
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 19/25
The AssumptionsThe Assumptions
The investors have homogenous expectations.The investors have homogenous expectations.
The investors are risk averse and utilityThe investors are risk averse and utility
maximisers.maximisers.
Perfect competition prevails in the market andPerfect competition prevails in the market and
there is no transaction cost.there is no transaction cost.
1919
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 20/25
Arbitrage PortfolioArbitrage Portfolio
According to the APT theory, an investor tries to findAccording to the APT theory, an investor tries to find
out the possibility to increase returns from hisout the possibility to increase returns from his
portfolio without increasing the funds in the portfolio. portfolio without increasing the funds in the portfolio.
He also likes to keep the risk at the same level.He also likes to keep the risk at the same level.
If X indicates the change in proportion,If X indicates the change in proportion,
((XXAA
++ ((XXBB
++ ((XXCC
= 0= 0
2020
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 21/25
Factor SensitivityFactor Sensitivity
The factor sensitivity indicates the responsiveness of The factor sensitivity indicates the responsiveness of
a security¶s return to a particular factor. Thea security¶s return to a particular factor. The
sensitiveness of the securities to any factor is thesensitiveness of the securities to any factor is the
weighted average of the sensitivities of the securities.weighted average of the sensitivities of the securities. Weights are the changes made in the proportion. For Weights are the changes made in the proportion. For
example bexample bAA, b, bBB and band bCC are the sensitivities, in anare the sensitivities, in an
arbitrage portfolio the sensitivities become zero.arbitrage portfolio the sensitivities become zero.
b bAA ((XXAA + b+ bBB ((XXBB + b+ bCC ((XXCC = 0= 0
2121
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 22/25
The APT ModelThe APT Model
According to Stephen Ross, returns of the securities areAccording to Stephen Ross, returns of the securities areinfluenced by a number of macro economic factors.influenced by a number of macro economic factors.
The macro economic factors are: growth rate of The macro economic factors are: growth rate of
industrial production, rate of inflation, spread betweenindustrial production, rate of inflation, spread betweenlong term and short term interest rates and spreadlong term and short term interest rates and spread between low grade and high grade bonds. The arbitrage between low grade and high grade bonds. The arbitragetheory is represented by the equation:theory is represented by the equation:
R R ii == PP00 ++ PP11 bi bi11 ++ PP22 bi bi22 « +« + PP j j bi bi j j
wherewhere R R ii = average expected return= average expected return
PP11 = sensitivity of return to bi= sensitivity of return to bi11
bi bi11 = the beta co= the beta co--efficient relevant to the particular factor efficient relevant to the particular factor 2222
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 23/25
Arbitrage Pricing EquationArbitrage Pricing Equation
In a single factor model, the linear relationship betweenIn a single factor model, the linear relationship between
the return R the return R ii and sensitivity band sensitivity bii can be given in thecan be given in the
following formfollowing form
R R ii == PPoo ++ PPii b bii
R R ii = return from stock A= return from stock A
PPoo = riskless rate of return= riskless rate of return
b bii = the sensitivity related to the factor = the sensitivity related to the factor
PPii = slope of the arbitrage pricing line= slope of the arbitrage pricing line
2323
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 24/25
APT and CAPMAPT and CAPM
The simplest form of APT model is consistent withThe simplest form of APT model is consistent withthe simple form of the CAPM model.the simple form of the CAPM model.
APT is more general and less restrictive than CAPM.APT is more general and less restrictive than CAPM.
The APT model takes into account of the impact of The APT model takes into account of the impact of numerous factors on the security.numerous factors on the security.
The market portfolio is well defined conceptually. InThe market portfolio is well defined conceptually. InAPT model, factors are not well specified.APT model, factors are not well specified.
There is a lack of consistency in the measurements of There is a lack of consistency in the measurements of the APT model.the APT model.
The influences of the factors are not independent of The influences of the factors are not independent of each other.each other.
2424
8/7/2019 Capital Asset Pricing Theory and Arbitrage Pricing Therory
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/capital-asset-pricing-theory-and-arbitrage-pricing-therory 25/25
Chapter SummaryChapter Summary
By now, you should have:By now, you should have:
Understood the concept of CAPM theoryUnderstood the concept of CAPM theory
Learnt to distinguish between CML and SMLLearnt to distinguish between CML and SML
Traced the empirical tests of CAPMTraced the empirical tests of CAPM
Understood the concept of APTUnderstood the concept of APT
2525