Post on 16-Jul-2015
Project Report
On
Building Effective Teams in TECC
Submitted By
Milind Gokhale
(AM - 317)
Amdocs - III
Submitted in partial fulfillment of
Executive Post Graduate Diploma in Business Management
(EPGDBM)
(Symbiosis International University)
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
3
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
4
Acknowledgements
I would like to express my heartfelt gratitude to Amdocs DVCI and
SIBM Pune for giving me an opportunity to learn management as well as carry out
the project work and gain immensely enriching experience in doing so. My sincere
thanks to my project guide and mentor Mrs. Shaily Gupta for her timely guidance
and constant encouragement not only during the project work but throughout the
EPGDBM course. She has been giving me valuable inputs and ideas right from the
selection of topic for project till its successful completion.
I appreciate the folks at Amdocs TECC for helping me in my research
with their valuable inputs. I thank faculty of SIBM for her ongoing support and
encouragement in every aspect.
I would also like to extent my thanks to my Dad for his enlightening me
with the nuances of a research survey.
The successful completion of our project would not have been possible
without the dedicated support from all my colleagues, family and friends.
Milind Gokhale Roll No: AM-317
Tel No: 9822958236
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
5
List of Abbreviations Used
Acronym Description CC Competency Centre
TECC Test Engineering Competency Centre
ST System Test
DCUT Design Coding Unit Testing
GL Group Leader
PM Project Manager
SME Subject Matter Expert
SSME Senior Subject Matter Expert
APAC Asia Pacific
KT Knowledge Transfer
HF Hot Fix
NYSE New York Stock Exchange
DOX Amdocs stock symbol in NYSE
A&M Advertising and Media
CRM Customer Relationship Manager
ELITE Expert Line Testing Team
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
6
Table of Contents
Acknowledgements ........................................................................................ 4
List of Abbreviations Used ............................................................................. 5
Table of Contents ........................................................................................... 6
List of Figures ................................................................................................ 8
1. Executive Summary ................................................................................. 9
2. Introduction ........................................................................................... 10
2.1 Need for Building Effective teams in Amdocs. ................................ 10
2.2 Role of Amdocs TECC to improve the situation .............................. 11
3. Company Overview ............................................................................... 12
4. Objectives.............................................................................................. 13
5. Building Effective Testing Teams .......................................................... 14
5.1 Current process of building testing teams ........................................ 14
5.2 Problems within the current process ................................................ 16
6. Field Work ............................................................................................ 18
7. Data Collection ...................................................................................... 19
8. Scope of Work ....................................................................................... 20
9. Data Analysis and Interpretation ............................................................ 21
9.1 Knowledge levels and Knowledge transfer ............................................ 21
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
7
Graphical representation: .......................................................................... 21
Interpretation: ........................................................................................... 21
9.2 Crisis Period .......................................................................................... 22
Graphical representation: .......................................................................... 22
Interpretation: ........................................................................................... 23
9.3 Visibility and Clarity ............................................................................. 23
Graphical representation: .......................................................................... 23
Interpretation: ........................................................................................... 24
9.4 Frequent Rotation and Stability ............................................................. 25
Graphical representation: .......................................................................... 25
Interpretation: ........................................................................................... 25
10. Recommendations ................................................................................. 26
11. Conclusions ........................................................................................... 28
12. Bibliography .......................................................................................... 29
Annexure I ................................................................................................... 30
Annexure II .................................................................................................. 31
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
8
List of Figures
Figure No. Name of Figure Page
No. 1 WDP ST effort Estimation 14
2 Resource Requirements Calculation 15
3 Resource Knowledge Level Matrix 15
4 Chart based on survey responses to question 4 in questionnaire (Annexure II) 21
5 Chart based on survey responses to question 7 in questionnaire (Annexure II) 22
6 Chart based on survey responses to question 6 in questionnaire (Annexure II) 22
7 Chart based on survey responses to question 11 in questionnaire (Annexure II) 23
8 Chart based on survey responses to question 15 in questionnaire (Annexure II) 24
9 Chart based on survey responses to question 13 in questionnaire (Annexure II) 25
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
9
1. Executive Summary Amdocs TECC consists of about 180 members worldwide. TECC comprises of
System Testing, Performance Testing and Testing Automation. System testing teams
require testing all the products of Amdocs which are to be delivered for an account
from Amdocs. It includes integration testing of all the modules of a product and
inter-product integration testing in case of projects consisting of multiple Amdocs
products. ST plays the role of the final gateway of delivery to the customer before
User Acceptance Tests performed by the customer. Detecting and reporting defects,
tracking and delivering the functionalities of all the modules of products involved in
a project is the most important task of a System Testing team in a project.
People in Amdocs work from assignment to assignment basis. Moreover, the
timelines available with the ST teams are very less and hence it is of utmost
importance that the teams are formed very quickly and they start performing in very
less time in order to meet the deadlines to deliver the project to the customer. For
this, it is very important to form better and efficient teams in ST that can perform the
challenging testing assignments effectively through achieving synergy within the
team. Certain norms are necessary and prior training is essential in order to reduce
the lead time of team formation and performance.
The main idea behind this project is to highlight the deficiencies in the current
team building process; the shortcomings faced by the members of TECC and suggest
improvements for building effective teams in TECC through emphasis on building
up of knowledge, stability of the assignments and the work environment for the
various teams in TECC, and thus help the organization to handle the testing projects
in an efficient and effective manner.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
10
2. Introduction
2.1 Need for Building Effective teams in Amdocs.
During the period from 2009 onwards, Amdocs started to increase its presence
in Asia. There were big projects in pipeline with some of the biggest telecom giants
in various Asian countries like India, Indonesia, Malaysia, Vietnam, Thailand,
Philippines. These projects were supposed to be handled mostly from Indian arm of
Amdocs.
Asian projects are notoriously known for their inherent uncertainty. This is
mainly due to the factors like very critical timelines and constantly changing
requirements from the Customer. There was sudden spurt in the need of resources in
Amdocs. To fill in these requirements, Amdocs hired from the tier 2 and tier 3
colleges from all over India. Although people were hired in a hurry, very less was
done to impart Amdocs specific product knowledge to the people. Moreover the
attrition rate had started increasing and people with Amdocs Products knowledge
were decreasing. There were haphazard teams formed for the urgent requirement and
incomplete training and knowledge given to the team members due to the lack of
time. Result was some of the important projects failed due to improper delivery. This
situation needs to be tackled with a more rational approach and all the competency
centers need to focus on the common objective of building better project teams so as
to result in better team performance, higher possibility of project success, proper
delivery of products and in turn increased customer satisfaction.
To minimize the impact Amdocs needs to focus on matching the right number
of people to actual needs during the projects uncertainties. To accomplish this
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
11
Amdocs needs to better harness the right people for the right tasks at the right time
through proper planning and better team building process.
2.2 Role of Amdocs TECC to improve the situation
TECC is one of the major parts of Customer Delivery group, which is
responsible for the approved certification of the deliverables and the final delivery to
the customer tests i.e. User Acceptance Tests.
ST teams being the gateway of the delivery are always under squeezed
timelines and to add to the pressure, the hasty team formation and lack of product
specific knowledge has caused the ST Timelines to derail off the track time and
again for various projects. Hence TECC was worst hit by the situation and the work
life balance was also drastically degraded due to this.
As a resolution of this problem, TECC must start implementing a program to
build effective testing teams as quickly as possible with reduction in lead time.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
12
3. Company Overview
Amdocs is the market leader in customer experience systems innovation, enabling
world-leading service providers to deliver an integrated, innovative and intentional
customer experience™ at every point of service. Amdocs provides solutions that
deliver customer experience excellence, combining the software, services and
expertise to help its customers execute their strategies and achieve service,
operational and financial excellence. Amdocs has variety of software products
designed for billing solutions of telecom service providers, CRM solution, solutions
for A&M providers. A global company (NYSE: DOX) with revenue of $3.2 billion
in fiscal 2011, Amdocs has over 19,000 employees and serves customers in more
than 60 countries worldwide. Amdocs has development centers in India (Pune and
Gurgaon), Israel, Cyprus, US and Brazil and Site offices in many locations
worldwide. More information about can be found at www.amdocs.com. (1)
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
13
4. Objectives To study and analyze the approach followed in building teams for projects in
TECC.
Identify the key issues in the current process which led to the failure of some
important projects.
Analyze the reasons for these failures.
Gathering data from Employee point of view.
Suggest ways to improve and maintain project success as well as overall
employee satisfaction.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
14
5. Building Effective Testing Teams
5.1 Current process of building testing teams
Determine the scope of services:
a. Use the ST estimation model to identify the scope of the services
to be provided by TECC.
b. The estimation is based on the golden number which is 26% of
DCUT effort should be considered as ST effort.
Figure 1 (2)
c. Calculate the resource requirements as per the golden numbers.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
15
Figure 2 (2)
Team ramp up:
a. Based on the resource requirements, the resources are identified
and acquired for the project.
b. A knowledge level matrix maintained in KTV helps in identifying
the key expertise areas of the resources.
Figure 3 (3)
c. Not all the resources are veterans and many resources being new
in the CC, The testing managers try to maintain a ratio of 60%
old and 40% new resources.
d. Assignment of a GL and a PM for the project.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
16
Project Kick off
a. This activity includes an introduction of all the team members
addressed by GL and PM.
b. The objectives of the project and the expectations from the team
members are communicated to all in this meeting.
Ongoing meetings and progress
a. Throughout the various activities of the System testing scope,
there are regular meetings communicate the updates in the
account, identify the risks involved and suggest steps on
mitigation of the risks.
5.2 Problems within the current process
a. Although the golden numbers are formed based on the historical
data of various projects Amdocs has delivered. However the
golden number does not include the special effort or unique
projects especially in APAC region since Amdocs has recently
entered APAC region.
b. The special effort includes overlap of the various activities in the
project lifecycle, frequent untimely change requests from the
clients which demands regression of the previously working
functionalities frequently.
c. While acquiring resources although the team members are taken
using the KTV scores, there is a gap between the score and the
actual level of expertise of the resource. This happens due to the
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
17
improper recording of the scores and the certain amount of
subjective discretion in the scores measurement.
d. Also the resources are frequently shuffled in between products
and projects, due to which there is a fragmentation of the product
knowledge.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
18
6. Field Work Identified the GLs and SSMEs within TECC and conducted pilot interviews
with them.
Prepared a questionnaire and chose employees from TECC as part of the
sample.
Undertook a survey to collect responses from the chosen employees.
The questionnaires were sent to the employees through mail.
The employees were assured of the anonymity of the responses to avoid any
feeling of threat or biases in the responses given in the survey.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
19
7. Data Collection The data was collected by way of interviews and survey.
Interviews were conducted with GLs and SSMEs in order to identify the key
issues faced by them during team formation, managing the team and
maintenance of the team roles.
Questions were asked to GLs
Question 1: To know whether the GL has any say in the selection of team members.
Question 2: To know the problems faced by GL to handle his team.
Question 3: To know the problems faced by the GL to maintain his team and project.
Question 4: To know the time required for inducting new member into the team.
Questions were asked to SSMEs
Question 1: To know the major problems faced in their current project team.
Question 2: To know the lead time required for them to start performing in the new
project or new assignment.
Question 3: To know the work life balance of the employees.
Taking cues from the Interview responses a questionnaire was prepared.
The sample was selected consisting of candidates from various TECC
projects and varied experience levels.
The interview questions can be viewed in Annexure I and the Survey
Questionnaire in Annexure II.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
20
8. Scope of Work Interviewing group leaders and SMEs to determine the key issues faced in
building and managing teams in TECC.
Undertake a survey to collect responses and analyze them to determine the
issues from the resources point of view.
Analyze the interview responses and the survey data and provide with
recommendations for improvement of the team building and their
management process.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
21
9. Data Analysis and Interpretation
9.1 Knowledge levels and Knowledge transfer
Graphical representation:
Figure 4: Level of KT given to new comers and new team members.
Interpretation:
As per the survey responses about 66% of the people agreed that the
process for knowledge transfer is more of a knowledge bombardment than
explainations. This is really a very big problem especially for adding new
members into the team. These new members need to understand the business ,
product as well as knowledge of project specific processes. Due to the low
knowledge level specific to the project business and processes, there is lot of
confusion in the team members. Hence even small problems take long time to
resolve and work velocity and performance is hampered due to this.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
22
9.2 Crisis Period
Graphical representation:
Figure 5: Frequency of occurrence of crisis
Figure 6: Team composure in crisis period
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
23
Interpretation:
The responses in the survey clearly indicate that the majority of the
employees feel that the occurrence of the crisis in project work is very often
with the frequency of around 1 week in a month which is on an average. The
frequent crisis period is also an indicator of the bad overall health of the
projects.
In periods of crisis the miss-co-ordination surely creeps in. It is
usually seen in TECC that in period of crisis there are some star team members
who pull the work towards completion instead of the complete team. There is a
lack of synergy in the teams.
9.3 Visibility and Clarity
Graphical representation:
Figure 7
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
24
Figure 8: Frequency of change in daily tasks of a resource
Interpretation:
Although there are regular meetings of PM with the team members
there is a lack of visibility felt not only among the team members however
among GLs as well as Testing PM sometimes. Due to the less visibility the
may be frequent changes in the tasks of the team. This can result in wastage,
rework, and redundant work as well as the frustration and disharmony among
team members.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
25
9.4 Frequent Rotation and Stability
Graphical representation:
Figure 9
Interpretation:
In Amdocs many times to fill up the resource gaps people are put into
different projects just for a week to a month, without taking into consideration
the prior product experience of the resource. In such times it becomes a
liability on the target team to train the resource and also it becomes difficult for
the resources to adjust in the temporary assignment for a short time. In such a
time surely the team formation to performance transition cannot take place. In
the survey it was found that all the respondents agree unanimously that the
frequent rotation is neither useful for the project nor the individual growth of
the resources. Due to the frequent rotation plus frequent changes in the regular
day to day tasks, as well as regular occurrence of crisis periods in projects the
work life balance of the individual is completely out of control and in turn it
affects the stability of employees.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
26
10. Recommendations
Following are a few recommendations suggested as part of improving the
team building and team maintenance program
Regular knowledge building and knowledge transfer sessions should take
place among the project team members and time should be allotted for the
same.
A knowledge bank should be maintained and regularly updated in the
creative SharePoint. It has been implemented in some projects. However, it
should be leveraged along with the KT sessions at regular intervals to avoid
knowledge bombardment in a small time which is not useful for retention and
utilization.
PM and GLs to better plan the resources so as to assign stable project
assignments and reduce frequent rotation of resources. This will help in
avoiding unnecessary liabilities on the team and help in achieving true
synergy in team contribution in project. To make it possible TECC is
planning an ELITE program consisting of highly experienced product experts
within TECC.
A new way of broadcasting the account updates and its impacts to the team
must be devised in TECC APAC projects. This is required because although
there are monthly meetings of team with the PM there is a lack of clarity and
visibility in the team.
To avoid dependency on GL, small leadership tasks should be introduced
within the team. This can include tasks like HF maintenance, Defects
management, Document trackers, Knowledge champions etc.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
27
Better product and project related orientation through regular training and
standardization of processes to reduce the lead time to reach from Forming to
Performing or forming stage at least as fast as possible.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
28
11. Conclusions
Amdocs TECC should act soon to build better teams and assure better project
delivery. A good team can indeed make the project or even a major project can also
fail because of bad or hasty team formation as was seen in TECC earlier. Good
initiatives do take time and it needs to be an ongoing continuous effort to reap the
benefits of top team performance in all the projects under TECC.
As mentioned some initiatives like ELITE program have been started as steps
towards the same goal. But this program requires highly experienced and
knowledgeable groups which can perform better and quicker in various teams.
Regular training and standardization of processes will be vital to keep producing and
grooming ELITE members.
This project was very helpful in identifying the current hindrances in the
TECC teams and thinking of ways to make the situation much better. It has given
TECC management an insight and a perspective of TECC employees and GLs. This
is a great opportunity to implement the recommendations suggested and achieve the
objective of highly performing teams along with stability as well as to maintain good
work life balance within teams.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
29
12. Bibliography
1. About Us. Retrieved from http://www.Amdocs.com
2. ST Quality. Retrieved from documentcenter: http://documentcenter
3. Knowledge Maturity Model. Retrieved from http://ktv
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
30
Annexure I
The Questions asked in the pilot interviews with GLs and SSMEs
Questions asked to GLs
1. Do you have a say in the resource selection within your team?
2. What are the biggest problems or issues you face while handling your team?
3. Are the people in your team willing to take up challenges?
4. What according to you is the lead time to accommodate a new resource into
the team?
Questions asked to SSME
1. What is the major concern or issue in your current project assignment?
2. What in your view is the lead time required to start your work considering
that you’ve got an assignment for testing a new product or a new module?
3. How is the work life balance in your current project?
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
31
Annexure II
Below is the Questionnaire for the survey:
1. How long have you been working in Amdocs?
A) <2 yrs
B) 2-5 yrs
C) 5-8 yrs
D) 8-10 yrs
2. How many teams have you worked in within Amdocs TECC?
3. Out of the number of teams you’ve worked in, with how many teams
have you worked more than 2 months?
4. Whenever you enter a new team or project, is enough knowledge about
the project given to you?
A) There is hardly any knowledge given at all.
B) Little knowledge transfer sessions are arranged with information
bombardment in very less time.
C) Time-to-time 1 hour sessions are conducted in a week.
D) There is a knowledge bank maintained by the team.
5. What is the size of the current team you're working in?
6. How does your team react to intense pressure and crisis?
A) The complete team is calm and focused on the critical task and
does complete it within deadline effectively.
B) There is little miss-coordination sometimes, although the team
members co-operate and complete the task.
C) Everything goes into a mess and no one co-operates.
7. How often do you feel is the crisis period in your project?
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
32
A) All the time [Everyday]
B) Very often [1 week in a month]
C) Sometimes [2-3 weeks in 6 months]
D) Very few times [2-3 weeks in a year]
E) Never [Never]
8. How would you rate the co-operation of your team members?
A) Very cooperative
B) Somewhat co-operative
C) Never co-operate
9. Has anyone within the team ever challenged your team leader regarding
any decision?
A) Yes
B) No
10. What is the action taken by leader on raising risks, doubts and issues?
A) He is very diligent to track the issue and find a solution to the
problem.
B) He delegates the issue resolution to another team-member
C) He doesn’t listen to the problem.
11. Are there regular meetings of team along with manager to publish the
project/account updates to the team and the impacts on the team?
A) Everyday
B) Once in a week.
C) Once in a month.
D) Once in 2 months.
E) Once in 6 months.
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
33
12. In your view which location do you think is most effective for work
within your team?
A) Meeting room
B) Common Bay
C) Separate desks not necessarily within the same Bay.
13. Do you feel that being assigned into a new team for a major task for just
1-2 weeks is useful at all?
A) Yes
B) No
14. When the group leader is on a planned vacation there is a difficulty and
confusion within the team for daily tasks.
A) Strongly agree
B) Agree
C) Somewhat Agree
D) Disagree
E) Strongly Disagree.
15. On a usual working day how many times in a day is your task changed
suddenly while you're working on some task?
A) It happens very frequently
B) It happens sometimes
C) It happens very rarely
D) It never happens.
16. How many weekends do you have to work in a time period of 4 months?
A) Every weekend
B) Every alternate weekend
Building Effective Teams in TECC 2012
34
C) Once in a month
D) Once or twice in 4 months
E) Never
17. Do you feel free to ask questions to any senior or junior team member
within your team anytime?
A) There is no problem asking questions to anyone within the team
anytime. Everyone is learning all the time.
B) There is an awkward feeling while asking for information due to
the ego problems of the teammate.
C) There is an awkward feeling while asking questions since it might
reflect in your visible knowledge level.