Post on 13-Jun-2015
BUILDING A DIVERSE WORKPLACE
Arkansas Bar AssociationAnnual Meeting
June 10, 2010
Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMCLawyers Life Coach LLC
WHY DIVERSITY?• Values of justice and
fairness• Better problem
solving• Greater creativity,
innovation• Market
competitiveness• Greater access to
talent pool
2 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Patterns of white male dominance inherent in structure of law firms reproduce themselves
again and again.
3 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
ADVANCEMENT Attorneys of color = 4.32% partners 15.06% associates Women = 17.06% partners 47.74% associates Nationwide 41% of law offices have no partners of
color. 10% of law offices have no women partners
NALP 2004
4 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Percent of Positions at Law Firms, by Gender
1st & 2nd Ye
ar Asso
ciates
Mid-Leve
l Asso
ciates
7th Year
Associa
tes
Of-Counsel
Non-Equity
Partners
Equity
Partners
Manag
ing
0102030405060708090
100
WomenMen
5 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Where are Women of Color?
% Minority Women After 5 Years
Remaining at first firmLeaving first firm
Attrition Rate for Minority Women by 8th Year
Left first firmRemaining at firm
6 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Barriers to Advancement• Toxic organizational culture• Ethnocentrism• Emphasis on assimilation vs.
multiculturalism• Absence of diversity competence• Unconscious/unintentional bias• Lack of mentoring• Exclusion from informal networks• Lack of opportunities for
advancement• Work/family conflict• Stigmatized reduced-hours
policies
7 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
8 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
PRESSURE to Assimilate
9 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Imagine a world made by and for short people. In this world everyone is under 5’5,” and the most powerful are rarely taller than 5’3.” After years of discrimination, tall people finally call for change and short people agree that the current world is unfair and amends should be made.
Short people first try to correct things by teaching tall people to act like short people – to minimize their differences by stooping to fit in the doorways or by hunching over to fit in the small chairs. Short people insist that once tall people learn these behaviors they will fit right in.
Tall People in a Short World
Being John Malkovich, 1999
10 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Some short people take another approach to routing discrimination: trying to make their world more accommodating to tall people by fixing some of the structural barriers that get in their way. They build six-foot high doors in the back of the building and purchase desks that don’t knock tall people’s knees. They even create some less demanding career paths – tall-people tracks – for those who are unwilling or unable to put up with the many realities of the short world that just can’t be changed.
Being John Malkovich, 1999
11 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Other short people take a third approach: they celebrate the differences of their tall associates. Tall people stand out in a crowd and they can reach things on high shelves. Let’s recognize the worth of those skills and put them to good use! And so the short people “create equity” by putting tall people in jobs where their height is an advantage, like designing brand extensions targeted to tall people.
Debra E. Meyerson & Joyce K. Fletcher, (2000) “A Modest Manifesto for Shattering the Glass Ceiling,” Harvard Business Review.
12 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Faulty Assumptions about Meritocracy
The most qualified person for a job can be clearly determined.
Objective performance criteria can be established for a legal job.
Evaluators are free of bias.
Once a person is hired, everyone has an equal opportunity to succeed, limited only be individual abilities.
If a person works hard enough, s/he will be recognized and rewarded.
13 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
What's the First Thing You See?• Race, gender and age
are cues• Perceptually salient• Among first social
categories that children learn
• Lead to automatic categorization
• Hard if not impossible to inhibit
14 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
STEREOTYPES• Our brain’s tend to categorize
and to connect social categories with characteristics (stereotypes)
• These stereotypes exert a significant influence on our perceptions, memories, explanations for things that happen and behaviors – often without our awareness.
• Stereotype-driven cognitive and behavioral events create an uneven playing field for minority members in a majority culture.
15 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Stereotypes…
• allow efficient, if sometimes inaccurate, processing of information.
• often conflict with consciously held or “explicit” attitudes.
Nosek, Banaji, & Greenwald, 2002
16 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Stereotypes are Self-Confirming
Expectations can effect which information attended to and remembered as well as how we engage in interactions – often in a manner that reinforces expectations
17 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Minorities and women are often held to higher standards regarding their credibility and intelligence by supervisors and clientele, and their missteps are often more damaging to their reputations than would be the same missteps by majority colleagues who are not saddled by stereotypes that they are less capable.” MCCA Creating Pathways to Diversity, White Men and Diversity – A Closer Look p.
18 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
“I have been told on more than oneoccasion, when I asked others forwork, that a case was not the “right”one for me, but that I would be keptin mind for future assignments.I also have been asked to becomeinvolved in a matter that was deemedto be right for me — either becausethe presiding judge was black, thejury pool included significant minorityrepresentation, or the client wasblack.This raises a much larger questionthat I cannot answer: namely, do thesesame people believe a case is not agood fit for me or other black partnerswhen the judge is white, the jury poolnon-diverse, or the client is thought toprefer a white attorney?”
Phillip L. Harris, Confronting Race, Chicago Lawyer, July 2007
19 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Glass Ceiling Penalizes Women Through Two Distinct Patterns
Harder for women to be seen as competent – must demonstrate higher level of competence or demonstrate competence over and over again (descriptive stereotype)
Women penalized for being too competent (prescriptive stereotype)
20 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
What is assertive orambitious in a man
is aggressive in awoman.
21 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
He’s smartand talented; she’s lucky.
22 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
WORK-FAMILY CONFLICT
23 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Resumes of childless women received
twice as many call backs as those of mothers.
There were no differences in call backs for
men with or without children.
Correll, et. al. 2007
THE MATERNAL WALL
24 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Are Emily and Greg More Employable Than Lashika and Jamal?
White-sounding names received 50% more callbacks.
Amount of discrimination uniform across occupations, industries.
Equal Opportunity Employers and federal contractors discriminate as much as other employers.
M.Bertrand & S. Mullainathan (2003) Poverty Action Lab, 3, 1-27.
25 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
100s of 1000s of experiments across the globe over the last 14 years, many different methods, many different populations
Powerful tool for revealing unconscious bias
Unconscious bias - judgments and thoughts that, if unexamined, remain outside of conscious awareness or conscious control (e.g., stereotypes that one does not endorse, but may still influence one’s judgments or behaviors).
Unconscious bias-related tools and concepts can be used as a means of furthering workplace diversity efforts
Fairness in the workplace can only be achieved when blatant, obvious obstacles (e.g., sexual harassment and race discrimination) AND subtle, hidden barriers (e.g., stereotyping and unconscious bias) are addressed.
Implicit Association Test
https://implicit.harvard.edu/implicit
26 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Behavior Predicted by IAT
Individual showing pro-white pattern on IAT will do the following when in the presence of a black person:▪ Lean forward less▪ Turn away slightly▪ Close his/her body▪ Less expressive▪ Less eye contact▪ Stand further away▪ Smile less▪ Hesitate and stumble over words▪ Laugh at jokes less▪ Will not affect what person consciously chooses to say or feel or do▪ Individual is unlikely to be aware of changes in behavior
27 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Stereotypes are…
Applied more under circumstances of:
Time pressure Ambiguity, lack of
information Stress from competing
tasks Lack of critical mass
28 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Barriers to Equality and Inclusion• Words mean little in terms of the real
messages that we send and receive. • The meaning of our messages is frequently
delivered through subtle micromessages. • Subtle, often subconscious signals represent
core of the messages we send, and can either demonstrate inclusion or exclusion.
• Micro-inequities – apparently small events which are often ephemeral, hard to prove, covert, often unintentional, frequently unrecognized by perpetrator
• Occur wherever people are seen to be different: African Americans in a white firm, women in traditionally male environment
• Micro-inequities – usually small in nature but not trivial in effect
29 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
How Stereotypes and DominanceAre Maintained
30 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Diversity is Opportunity• Diversity can be drawn on as a
resource for building on employees’ strengths
• Allows individuals to be freed from concerns about inclusion – more able to innovate, reach potential
• Enables diverse employees to bring viewpoints of their distinctive social group memberships to generating solutions for clients and the firm
• Interactions across difference are opportunities for learning
• Fostering supportive, resilient relationships promotes individual and organizational thriving
• Because no one group valued more than another no one is marginalized – employees free to engage, challenge and support one another
• Creating an inclusive work environment is essentially about cultivating a climate of respect, compassion, openness
31 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
ALIGNMENT
POLICIES
PRACTICES
32 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Creating an Inclusive Organization
Recruitment
Development
Assignments
Evaluation
Promotion
Compensation
33 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
Path to a Diverse Firm
Commit to Long Term
Measure
Education
Define Diversity Competencies
Integrate with Firm’s Strategic Goals
Assessment
Diversity Committee
Leadership – vision, model
34 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
COMMUNICATION
CONSTRUCTIVE ENGAGEMENT
35 Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMC © 2010 Lawyers Life Coach LLC
CONTACT INFORMATION
Ellen Ostrow, Ph.D., CMCLawyers Life Coach LLC
910 17th Street, N.W.Suite 306
Washington, DC 20006Phone: 202-595-3108
Email: Ellen@lawyerslifecoach.comWeb: http://LawyersLifeCoach.com
To subscribe to our free ezine, “Beyond the Billable Hour,”
go to http://LawyersLifeCoach.com