Post on 09-Jul-2015
5/10/2018 50462005 Defending Imam Fakhruddin Razi - slidepdf.com
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/50462005-defending-imam-fakhruddin-razi 1/2
ImamRazi(R.D)isallegedtrodevepopsympathyforIsmailies..Thisisanincorrectversion.Ist:Thetradition/ReportwhichsaysthatImamRazistoppedfromcriticisngIsmailisduetothreatandterrorisincorrect.Suchincorrectreportscannotbecomeaproof.Thebookswhichreportsthistraditiondonotmensionthesoureandthenounsofthereporters.2nd:AccordingtothereportGreatImamwasinterrorofismailinizariextrimis
tsofAlamut.SothisdoesnotmeanthathedriftedfromORTHODOXSUNNISMNOUNLYASHARISM..CaseofTERRORisdifferentfromthecaseofdrfting.WecanseeclearlythatanumberofMusta'liismailiimamWEREKILLEDBYNIZARIISMAILIES.MUSTALI,AMIRANDMUHAMMADTAYYUBARETHECASES.SoifImamRazibecamefrightenedandstoppedcriticizingNizariIsmailismofAlamutthisisverynatural.3rd:Etheronetakethereportasitisorrejectitcompletely.Totakeonepartandtorejectthesecondpartisanirrationalwayofdiscussion.4th:AnNizariIsmailiImaminAlamutbecameaSunnibuttheverysamepeoplewho
trytoshewthatImamRazidrifftedfromAsharismmakestrangeapologisticinterpretationsthatNizariImamofAlamutdidnotdriftedfromZizariIsmailism.seeIsmailisthroughHistory.Thisshewthateventheyinprincipledidnotagreeonsuchtraditionswhichreferstoallegedconversions.5th:WholelifeofImamRaziisinfrontofusandtodiscardhiswholelifeonasinglereport,whichisreportedbyUNKNOWNREPORTERS/NARRATORStoTHEWRITERSOFTHEbooksisincorrect.ADDITIONALLYWHENTHEREPORTitselfsaysitisacaseoffrightening,fearandterror.ItmaybeaskedthatathreattolifemadeImamtostopcriticizingNizaris.Thisshewsacowardiceattitute.ButforsafetyoflifewhenIthnaashries,IsailiesALLEGETHATJAFARBINMUHAMMAD
(whowasaSunni)didhidehisShiaismandappeardtobeaSunni,ItispossiblethatImamRazistoppedcriticizingNizariIsmailismatleastinbublicANDTHISDOESNOTIMPLYanyalleged/supposeddrftingasincorrectlyassumed.CONCLUSION:THISALLEGATIONONIMAMRAZIISFALSE.
5/10/2018 50462005 Defending Imam Fakhruddin Razi - slidepdf.com
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/50462005-defending-imam-fakhruddin-razi 2/2