Post on 13-Jan-2016
1
Database for Energy Efficiency Resource User Demonstration
Jennifer Barnes
Pacific Energy Center
October 11, 2005
2
What is DEER?
A collection of data for Residential and Non-Residential energy efficiency measures.
http://eega.cpuc.ca.gov/deer/ It provides a common set of:
Ex ante Savings values: kW, kWh, kBtu
Measure Costs Effective Measure Life (a.k.a EUL)
3
Website Navigation
Measures categorized by Residential and non-residential Weather sensitive and non-weather sensitive
Non-weather sensitive measure impacts determined through engineering calculations
Savings do not vary by climate zone or vintage, only building type
4
Weather sensitive measures
Weather sensitive measure impacts simulated using DOE2/eQUEST Single family, multifamily, mobile homes, and 22 non-
residential building types Five building vintages 16 climate zones
Two levels of savings Customer savings - for system savings and early
replacement savings. “Above Code” Savings - for all measures affected by an
energy code or standard (reportable savings for replace on burnout)
5
Common Units
Describes the normalizing unit Per ton, lamp, household, linear feet, cloths dryer,
etc. The energy and cost common units are distinct Over 90% of cases, they are the same When different, distinctly identified
6
Measure Costs
Application – indicates if the cost is for:• Retrofit (RET) - replacing a working system with a new
technology or adding a technology• Replace-on-burnout (ROB) - replacing a technology at the
end of its useful life • New construction or major renovation (NEW) - installing a
technology in a new construction or major renovation Cost Basis – indicates if the cost is:
• Incremental (INCR) - the differential cost between a base technology and an energy efficient technology
• Installed (FULL) - the full or installed cost of the measure including equipment, labor, overhead & profit (OH&P)
7
Notable Changes
Eliminated coin-operated high efficiency clothes washers and hot water heater tank wrap
T-12 removed from DEER as a base case because of new federal guidelines. However, it may be legitimate in lamp/ballast (only) change outs.
Programmable thermostats savings diminished: Change in residential assumptions Programmable thermostats or time clocks required by code since
1992
• A/C savings reduced due to stricter code requirements
8
CFL Changes
Integral versus modular Modular – hardwired ballast with replaceable lamp. 16
year life (res.) Integral – lamp and ballast are “fused.” 9.4 year life (res.)
In service factor – applied to CFLs to account for units not in operation Non-res. CLF – “SPC” – assumes that all units are installed
and operational Non-res. CFL – in service factor of .92 Residential CFL – in service factor of .9
No in service factor for table lamps and torchieres
9
Website Navigation – Opening Screen
10
Website Navigation – Browse Measures
11
Website Navigation – Select Subcategory
12
Website Navigation – Review Summary Page - Top
13
Run ID
String variable of fixed length of 13 with the format: ABBB1122CCCCC where:
A = Sector Code. ‘R’ = Residential and ‘C’ = Commercial BBB = Building type abbreviation (see codes under
Building Type) 11 = Climate zone (see codes under Climate Zone) 22 = Vintage (see codes under Vintage) CCCCC = Measure abbreviation
Measure ID - String variable of fixed length of 7 (example: D03-001)
14
Website Navigation – Review Summary Page - Bottom
15
Website Navigation – Detailed Measure Information
16
Website Navigation – Detailed Measure information - Top
17
Website Navigation – Detailed Measure information - Bottom
18
Supporting Documents Section
Website Users Guide Net-to-Gross Ratios Table (Use .8 if in doubt) Access Tables Glossary Cost Data Cost Data User’s Guide New EUL Estimates 7-14-05 (SERA Report) Consolidated Measure Data
19
Supporting Documents Section – Consolidated Measure Data
20
Questions/Comments?
21
DEER Measure Cost Detail
22
Defining Cost ParametersMeasure Cost Specifications (Cont.)
Cost data is first cost only -- life cycle or O&M costs/cost savings not included
Pricing reflects commonly available “standard” products and excludes specialty, high-end items
Some price observations (outliers) were excluded to assume a rational purchasing policy would be used (“who would pay THAT?”)
Equipment and labor prices are specific to California to extent possible but average across state
23
Defining Cost Parameters Key Cost Definitions
Cost Observation – a single price point for an individual measure or measure configuration• Cost values are what a program participant would pay to
implement the measure consistent with definitions in the CA Standard Practice Manual (initial capital cost)
Cost units ($ / ton, $ / HP, $ / square foot, etc.)• Mostly the same although different for some measures• Distinct field in detailed cost data; appended to Cost Basis
designator in measure detail
24
Data Collection and Analysis ProcessLabor Cost Estimates
1.101.10Fresno
1.101.10Statewide average
1.081.11Sacramento
1.041.04San Diego
1.071.06Los Angeles
1.221.21San Francisco
Non-residentialResidentialCity
1.101.10Fresno
1.101.10Statewide average
1.081.11Sacramento
1.041.04San Diego
1.071.06Los Angeles
1.221.21San Francisco
Non-residentialResidentialCity
Labor cost estimates generally base on manhours required to complete task times appropriate wage rate Wage rate based on trade (electrician, plumber, etc.) and geographic location of activity RS Means used to provide wage rate and location adjustment multipliers
25
1. Website and on-site cost surveys of retailers2. Cost quotes from manufacturers, manufacturers
sales representatives, and distributors3. Cost surveys of contractors and design
professionals.4. Cost data from in California DSM program files,
particularly local programs5. Secondary sources and reports
Data Collection and Analysis Process Cost Data Sources
26
Data Collection and Analysis Process Cost Analysis Workbooks
Contact Log Data sources and contact information
Raw Data Raw cost data supplied by data sources
Data for Analysis Raw cost data organized for analysis purposes
Cost Analysis Measure cost analysis and modeling
Cost Results Final incremental and installed cost data for each measure and measure variation
Statistical Summary Summary of statistical variables for each measure including range, confidence and standard deviation.
Excel based cost analysis workbook developed for each measure.
Each workbook has 5 sections:
27
Data Collection and Analysis Process Cost Analysis Workbooks – Raw Data
Example of the ‘Raw Data’ section of the High Efficiency Electric Clothes Dryer workbook
Log IDMeasure ID Measure Description Mfr Model No. Size
Size Units Eff Eff Units Volts
Base or Measure Cost Type
Cost Basis (Eq., Incr. Eq., Inst. or Incr. Inst.)
Equipment Cost (per unit)
RF_34 D03-941 High Efficiency Electric Clothes Dryer with Moisture Sensor. Maytag MDE6400A 6.0 Cu Ft 924 kWh/year 240 Base MSRP equipment $565.00
RF_34 D03-941 High Efficiency Electric Clothes Dryer with Moisture Sensor. Maytag MDE2400A 6.0 Cu Ft 924 kWh/year 240 Base MSRP equipment $565.00
RF_34 D03-941 High Efficiency Electric Clothes Dryer with Moisture Sensor. Maytag SDE3606A 7.1 Cu Ft 924 kWh/year 240 Base MSRP equipment $442.00
RF_29 D03-941 High Efficiency Electric Clothes Dryer with Moisture Sensor. Whirlpool GEW9868K 7.4 Cu Ft 950 kWh/year 120 Measure MSRP equipment $699.00
RF_29 D03-941 High Efficiency Electric Clothes Dryer with Moisture Sensor. Whirlpool GEW9868P 7.4 Cu Ft 950 kWh/year 240 Measure MSRP equipment $649.00
RF_29 D03-941 High Efficiency Electric Clothes Dryer with Moisture Sensor. Whirlpool GEQ9800P 7.4 Cu Ft 950 kWh/year 240 Measure MSRP equipment $499.00
Tech Specs
28
Data Collection and Analysis Process Cost Analysis Workbooks – Cost Results
Example of the ‘Results’ section of the High Efficiency Electric Clothes Dryer workbook
Measure IDMeasure Name
Measure Description
Base Description
Delivery Channel Application
Energy Star?
Purchase Volume Cost Basis
Base Equipment Cost
Measure Equipment Cost
Incremental Equipment Cost
Cost Unit
D03-941
Efficient Clothes Dryer
High Efficiency Electric Clothes Dryer with Moisture Sensor.
Electric Clothes Dryer EF=3.01. Single Family, 416 dry cycles Retail ROB/NEW No low INCR/INCR $319 $557 $238 Dryer
29
Data Collection and Analysis Process Cost Analysis Workbooks – Statistical Summary
Example of the ‘Statistical Summary’ section of the High Efficiency Electric Clothes Dryer workbook
Measure IDAnalysis Method # Obs Mean Median Min Max # Obs Mean Median Min Max
D03-941 Average 40 $557 $525 $261 $869 38 $319 $296 $224 $509
BaseMeasure
30
How to find the most applicable cost information?• Measure detail pages for each run ID - the per unit
equipment measure cost of $13.65 for all 90% residential furnaces• This provides an average cost based on a 100,000 Btu furnace
• The ‘Cost Data’ file under ‘Supporting Documents’ provides prices on a range of furnace sizes • This provides a range of costs for 90% AFUE furnaces from
60,000 Btu to 140,000 Btu. Per unit costs ($/KBtu) ranges from $21.53 to $12.13, respectively
• The cost workbook section – Can use either statistical summary or individual price observations• For example, the per unit equipment measure cost for 90%
AFUE 100,000 furnaces ranges from to $12.31 to $16.52 based on 9 observations
Cost Data Defining Cost Parameters
31
DEER Non-weather Sensitive
Measure Detail
32
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Residential Measures
CFL Lighting
Refrigerators
Clothes Washers & Dryers
Dishwashers
Water Heating
Swimming Pool Pumps
33
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Residential Measures
CFL Lighting
Measure Impact = (delta watts/unit * hours/day * days/year * In Service Rate) / 1000 watts/kWh
Demand Impact = delta watts/unit * In Service Rate * Peak Hour Load Share
The “In Service Factor” is an estimate of the percentage of lamps that are actually used. It is a rough estimate based on utility experience.
.9 to be used for all residential CFL programs
.92 to be used for non-residential rebate or giveaway programs
1.0 to be used for verified installation programs. Labeled “SPC” in measure name
Hours of Operation/Day” and “Peak Hour Load Share” from KEMA CFL Metering Study
34
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Residential Measures
CFL Lighting – Example (14W CFL replace 60W Inc)
Measure Impact = (46W * 2.34 hours/day * 365 days/year * 0.9) / 1000 watts/kWh= 35.4 kWh
Demand Impact = 46W * 0.9 * 0.081 = 3.35 W
35
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Residential Measures
Refrigerators
Used the Energy Star calculator available on-line at:http://www.energystar.gov
Key Input values for the calculator:Refrigerator Type (top, side, or bottom mount freezer)Ice through the door (yes or no)Refrigerator fresh volume (cubic feet)Refrigerator freezer volume (cubic feet)
36
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Residential Measures
Clothes Washers
Utilized the three recommended Consortium for Energy Efficiency (CEE) Tiers forModified Energy Factor:
Used the Energy Star calculator (that utilizes an EF rather than MEF) on-line at:http://www.energystar.govEstimated the equivalent EF value for CEE MEF values from Energy Star list of approved washers
Other key Energy Star variables include:Number of wash cycles/year (E Star value is 392 cycles)Washer capacity (three sizes – 1.5, 2.65, and 3.5 cubic feet)
Further disaggregated impacts by water heat and clothes dryer fuel typesFuel impact disagreegations based on ‘Efficiency Vermont” estimates
Demand impact based on a energy/peak factor of 0.417. This is carryoverfrom previous 2001 DEER
37
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Residential Measures
Clothes Washer – Example (Tier 3 2.65 cu.ft)
Measure Impact = (cycles/year * capacity / base EF) – (cycles/year * capacity / measure EF) = (392 * 2.65 / 1.58) – (392 * 2.65 / 4.94) = 447 kWh
Demand Impact = Measure Impact * energy/peak factor = 447 kWh * 0.417 = 186.4 W
38
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Residential Measures
Clothes Dryer
1993 National Appliance Energy Conservation Act (NAECA) minimum efficiency used for base technology:
EF = 3.01 for electric dryersEF = 2.67 for gas dryers
Used DOE test procedure guidelines for:Drying cycles per year = 416UEC of 2.33 kWh/cycle for electric (969 kWh/year)UEC of 8.95 kBtu/cycle for gas (37.2 therms/year)
Assumed 416 cycles represented Single Family Assumed 250 cycles for Multi-Family (CEC estimate of 60% less use by MF)
Energy savings 5% of energy use. This is a carryover from previous 2001 DEER
Demand impact based on a energy/peak factor of 0.371. This is carryoverfrom previous 2001 DEER
39
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Residential Measures
Clothes Dryer – Example (SF electric)
Measure Impact = Electric base use * Savings Percentage = 969 kWh * 0.05 = 48 kWh
Demand Impact = Measure Impact * energy/peak factor = 48 kWh * 0.371 = 17.8 W
40
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Residential Measures
Dishwasher
Used the Energy Star calculator available on-line at:http://www.energystar.gov
Key Input values for the calculator:Base Energy Factor (EF) = 0.46Measure Energy Factor = 0.58Annual wash cycle (DOE test procedure) = 215 (assume SF)MF wash cycles (assumed to be ~75% of SF) = 160
Demand impact based on a energy/peak factor of 0.371. This is carryover from previous 2001 DEER
41
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Residential Measures
Water Heating
Measures:High efficiency water heater (electric EF=0.93, gas EF=0.63)Heat pump water heater (EF=2.9)Point of use water heaterlow flow showerhead (from 2.5 to 2.0 gallons per minute)Pipe wrapFaucet aerators
Note: Removed water heater blankets because they’re obsolete on models made after 1990.
Savings expressed as % of base use Base use varied by utility service area (same method as 2001)
Demand impact based on a energy/peak factor of 0.22. This is carryoverfrom previous 2001 DEER
42
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Residential Measures
Water Heating Measure Saving %:
High efficiency water heater – electric - 5.4%High efficiency water heater – gas - 5.0% Heat pump water heater – 69.7%Point of use water heater – 15.0%low flow showerhead – 4.0%Pipe wrap – 4.0%Faucet aerators – 3.0%
43
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Residential Measures
Pool Pumps
Single speed and two speed included
Relied on PG&E and SCE engineers for calculating impacts:
General assumptions:Average pool size of 25,000 gallonsAverage water turnover rate of 6-8 hours Average pump motor demand of 1.75 kVATypical filtration time of 4 to 6 hours
For single speed motors, motor downsizing and runtime reductions assumed
44
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
Interior Lighting
Exterior Lighting
Cooking
Copy Machine
Water Heating
Vending Machine Controls
High Efficiency Motors
Agriculture
45
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
Interior Lighting Measures:CFL screw-in lampsCFL hardwire fixturesHigh intensity discharge (HID) lampsPremium T8 lampsDimming BallastsDe-lamping fluorescent 4 ft and 8 ft fixtures
Note: T-12 removed from DEER as a base case because of new federal guidelines. However, it may be legitimate in lamp/ballast (only) change outs.
46
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
Interior Lighting – Basic Methodology
Measure Impact = (delta watts/unit * hours/day * days/year * In Service Rate) / 1000 watts/kWh
Demand Impact = delta watts/unit * In Service Rate * Peak Hour Load Share
47
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
Exterior Lighting & Exit Signs High intensity discharge (HID) lampsExit SignsTimeclocksPhotocells
48
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
Exterior Lighting & Exit Signs Methodology
HID lamps: delta watts saved * hours of use (4,100 hours) no peak impacts
Exit Signs: delta watts saved * 8760 hours * Interactive Effects peak = delta watts * Interactive effects * 1.0 (coincidence factor)
Timeclocks & Photocells: watts controlled * hours of control no peak impacts
49
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
Cooking High efficiency fryers (gas & electric)High efficiency griddle (gas)Hot food holding cabinetConnectionless steamer
50
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
Cooking - Methodology Relied primarily on the PG&E technology briefs
For each of these measures, the energy savings calculationmethodology is of the form:
Savings = (APECRBase – APECREfficient) * Daily Hours * Days
Where:
APECR = The Average Production Energy Consumption Rate/hourDaily Hours = 12Days = 365
51
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
Copy Machines – three sizes 0-20 copies/minute21-44 copies/minute over 45 copies/minute
Methodology assumptions from Energy Star calculator
52
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
Vending Machine Controls Characterized in two measures by being installed in:
Cold drink vending machinesUncooled snack vending machines
Measure savings and characterization from the Pacific Northwest Regional Technical Forum database
Methodology assumes operated during off-peak hours, thereforeno demand savings
53
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
Water Heating Savings expressed as % of base use
Base use varies by building type. Come from the 1994 DEER study
Measures:High efficiency gas water heater (7.1% savings)Point of use water heater (10% savings)Water circulation pump time clock (6% savings)
54
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
High Efficiency Motors Meet premium efficiency standards established by the Consortium for Energy Efficiency (CEE)
Base efficiency meets Energy Policy Act (EPACT) minimum
Motor sizes range from 1 HP to 200 HP
Motor hours of operation vary by industry sector
Motor loading from US DOE Motor Master software
Peak demand based on a coincidence factor of 0.75
55
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
High Efficiency Motors - Calculation Energy savings (kWh) = (Motor HP / EPACT motor efficiency)
* kW/HP * hours of operation * motor loading – (motor HP / premium motor efficiency) * kW/HP * hours of operation * motor loading
Peak (kW) = (motor HP * kW/HP * coincidence factor / EPACT motor efficiency) - (motor HP * kW/HP *
coincidence factor / premium motor efficiency)
56
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
Agricultural Measures Low pressure irrigation sprinkler nozzle
Sprinkler irrigation to micro irrigation conversion
Infrared film for greenhouses
Greenhouse heat curtain
Variable frequency drive for dairy pumps
Ventilation fans or box fans
High volume, low speed fans
57
Non-Weather Sensitive Measures Non-Residential Measures
Agricultural Measures Methodology taken from Express Agricultural Work Papers
Irrigation savings varied by crop type
Citrus trees
Deciduous trees
Field/vegetable
Grapes
And water source
Well
Non-well