Post on 02-Jun-2018
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 1/74
Environmental Business Council of New EnglandEnergy Environment Economy
EBC Climate Change Program
Green House Gas Reductions:The Newly Proposed
Massachusetts Clean EnergyStandard
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 2/74
Introduction
Michael ErnstProgram Chair & Moderator
Director, Regulatory AffairsTetra Tech
Environmental Business Council of New EnglandEnergy Environment Economy
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 3/74
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 4/74
Background for Clean Energy Standard
• MA RPS Standard• MA Global Warming Solutions Act
• Greenhouse Gas Target: 80% cut by 2050• Clean Energy & Climate Plan for 2020
• NESCOE Coordinated Regional Procurement• Synapse Large-Scale Hydroelectric Energy Imports
Study for DOER (Dec. 2013)
• MA Clean Energy Resources Bill of 2014• 2400 MW Regional Procurement• Canadian Hydro Focus; Renewable Carve-out?• Refiled for 2015
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 5/74
Background for Clean Energy Standard
• Natural Gas Supply Shortage for ElectricGeneration: $3 Billion for ISO-NE last winter
• New Natural Gas Pipeline Proposals:• Kinder Morgan – new pipeline• Algonquin expansion• Tennesee-Iroquois expansion
• DOER Synapse Low Gas Demand Study
• Cost-effective alternatives
• Federal Auction of Seabed South of Islands:• up to 5000 MW Offshore Wind – 1.29.15
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 6/74
Why EPA Greenhouse Gas Rules?
Our climate is changing with dangerous effects
• Average temperatures have risen since 1901• 7 of top 10 warmest years on record since 1998.• Climate and weather disasters in 2012 cost the
American economy more than $100 billion .
Nationwide, the EPA Clean Power Plan will helpcut carbon pollution from the power sector by30 percent from 2005 levels.
• Power plants are the largest source of carbonpollution in the U.S., accounting for roughlyone- third
of all domestic greenhouse gasemissions.• The proposal will also cut pollution that leads to
soot and smog by over 25 percent in 2030.
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 7/74
Why Greenhouse Gas Rules?Billions of dollars in public health & climate benefits
• Climate & health benefits worth $55-93 billion in 2030
• Reducing exposure to particle pollution and ozone in2030 will avoid a projected• 2,700 to 6,600 premature deaths• 140,000 to 150,000 asthma attacks in children
• 340 to 3,300 heart attacks• 2,700 to 2,800 hospital admissions• 470,000 to 490,000 missed school and work
days
• Shrinking electricity bills by roughly 8 percent in 2030
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 8/74
States Choose Own Compliance Plan
States will choose by June 1, 2016 (extensions to 2018)how to meet their goal through whatever measures
reflect their own circumstances and policy objectives:• demand-side energy efficiency programs• renewable energy standards• efficiency improvements at plants• co-firing or switching to natural gas• build new Natural Gas Combined-Cycle plants
• transmission efficiency improvements• energy storage technology• coal generation retirements• expanding renewables like wind and solar• new hydroelectric conversions and imports• expanding nuclear
• market-based trading programs• Smart Grid
States may develop a state-only plan or collaborate witheach other to develop plans on a multi-state basis
• Extension to June 1, 2017 for single states or toJune 1, 2018 for multi-state plans
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 9/74
Current Canadian Hydro Sites & Lines
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 10/74
5
a. Northern Pass – Hydro Quebec/Northeast Utilitiesb. Northeast Energy Link – Emera Maine/National Gridc. Green Line – New England ITCd. Bay State Offshore Wind Transmission System – Anbaric Transmissione. Northeast Energy Corridor Maine/New Brunswick/Irving
f. Muskrat Falls/Lower Churchill – Nalcor Energyg. Maine Yankee –Greater Bostonh. Maine –Greater Bostoni. Northern Maine –New Englandj. Plattsburgh NY New Haven VTk. New England Clean Power Link – TDI New England
b
d
ac e
h
i NewBrunswick
Nova Scotia
Québec
NewYork
10
On- and Off-shore Transmission Proposals are Vying to MoveRenewable Energy to New England Load Centers
f
From Newfoundland & Labrador
g
Courtesy of ISO-New England
Representative Projects and Concept Proposals
k
November 2013: Publicly available information
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 11/74
Michael D. Ernst, Esq.Director of Regulatory Affairs
michael.ernst@tetratech.com
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 12/74
Driving Continued Cost-Effective GHGReductions: The Proposed
Massachusetts Clean EnergyStandard (CES)
David CashCommissioner
Massachusetts Department of EnvironmentalProtection
Environmental Business Council of New EnglandEnergy Environment Economy
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 13/74
Driving Continued Cost-EffectiveGHG Reductions:
The Proposed MassachusettsClean Energy Standard (CES)
David W. Cash
CommissionerDepartment of Environmental Protection
January 7, 2015
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 14/74
Energy Dollars Flow Out of MAWe spend $22B per year on energy; 80% leaves MA -- $18B
Oil & Natural Gas- Canada
Oil - Venezuela
Oil & Natural Gas- Middle East
Coal – Colombia
MA Energy Imports2008 $B
Fuel Oil (heating, diesel) $5.0
Gasoline $9.2Jet Fuel $1.4Other Petroleum $0.9
Natural Gas $5.2
Coal $0.3Total $22 B
Per Household Average ~ $4,600 Natural Gas- Caribbean
Natural Gas
- U.S. Gulf Coast
1
Natural Gas- PA,NY
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 15/74
Nation-Leading Emissions Reductions
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 16/74
GWSA GHG Reduction Trajectory
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 17/74
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 18/74
Background - Electricity Used in MA
18
Source: Estimate based on 2012 Massachusetts GHG Emissions Inventory. The calculation assumes that all electricity generated in Massachusettsis delivered to customers in Massachusetts (because Massachusetts imports electricity) and assigns MWh from exporting states and Canada toMassachusetts based on a formula that considers the balance between generation and load in each state.
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 19/74
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 20/74
Stakeholder Comments
• 125 attended meeting and 60 written comments were received.• Key themes included:
– Stringency: Many comments expressed support for the need totransition to 100% clean energy to address climate change.
– Clean Energy: Many comments supported limiting eligibility to RPS-
eligible renewable energy, or at least excluding certain technologies(nuclear and large hydro). Some stakeholders supported broadeligibility, including eligibility for existing nuclear generators andimported hydroelectricity.
– Applicability: Key issue is inclusion of municipal utilities; somestakeholders support broad applicability but some municipal utilitiesquestion MassDEP authority to require compliance with CES.
• Comments are posted on line and discussed in Technical SupportDocument published with proposed regulation
20
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 21/74
CES Energy Transition: 2020 - 2050
21
• Standard includes RPS-eligible MWh and additional clean energy• Proposed 2020 standard of 45% is consistent with anticipated increases in imported Canadian
hydroelectricity• Proposal includes adjustment process to ensure progress toward 100% clean energy by 2050.• Graphic shows one possible scenario for illustrative purposes only
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 22/74
CES Proposal – Key Concepts
• Share of sales structure, with use of GIScertificates for compliance (like RPS, but with“CECs”).
• Point of regulation is electricity sales, includingmunicipal utilities.• Drives Innovation: Clean energy includes any
technology that meets 50%-below-natural gasemissions threshold: – All RPS-eligible renewable energy – New hydro and nuclear facilities are likely eligible – Carbon capture and sequestration eligible depending
on emissions.22
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 23/74
Compliance
• The proposed regulation would: – Require entities to demonstrate the use of clean energy for a
specified percent of retail electricity sales each year – Adjust the initial standard for municipal utilities to address the
fact that municipal utilities are not required to comply with RPS – Count RPS compliance toward CES compliance (so the CES
percentage would exceed the RPS percentage for each year) – Require the use of GIS certificates to demonstrate compliance
(like RPS)
– Allow banking, with CEC creation beginning in 2018 and 2019for use in complying with 2020 and 2021 standards – Allow compliance through alternative compliance payments
(ACPs):• Rate = 50% of RPS ACP rate
• Funds deposited in Clean Energy Expendable Trust for use toaddress climate mitigation and adaptation23
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 24/74
Eligible Generators
• The proposed regulation would: – Qualify clean energy generators based on a generic 50%-below-
natural-gas threshold – Require clean energy generators that are RPS-eligible to qualify
through DOER (not DEP) – Limit eligibility to generators that commenced operation after 2010 – For projects outside the ISO-NE control area ( enhance competition ):
• Include capacity commitment requirements identical to RPS• Include projects in adjacent control areas, and other control areas if
power is imported to ISO-NE or an adjacent control area through adedicated transmission line
• Require the use of transmission capacity that commenced operationafter 2010
– Require MassDEP to complete a study in 2016 of options forincluding existing (pre-2010) generators in the CES
24
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 25/74
Public Hearing Process
• Comments must be submitted by February 20 inaccordance with public hearing notice: – Email to climate.strategies@state.ma.us – Oral testimony at public hearings February 9-10 – US Mail
• All comments welcome; specific areas for comment areidentified in Technical Support Document (TSD) – Proposed regulation, TSD, hearing notice, and other documents
available on MassDEP CES web site:
http://www.mass.gov/eea/agencies/massdep/climate-energy/climate/ghg/ces.html
• MassDEP staff contact: Will Space (617-292-5610 orwilliam.space@state.ma.us)
25
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 26/74
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 27/74
Yearly and Cumulative Wind Capacity(Installed and Pipeline)
27
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 28/74
Source: Electric Drive Transportation Association,2014
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 29/74
MA Clean Energy Sector Growth
2013 Massachusetts Clean Energy Industry Reporthttp://www.masscec.com/content/2013-clean-energy-industry-report 29
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 30/74
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 31/74
2007
Executive Office of Energyand Environmental Affairs
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 32/74
2008
Executive Office of Energyand Environmental Affairs
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 33/74
2009
Executive Office of Energyand Environmental Affairs
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 34/74
2010
Executive Office of Energyand Environmental Affairs
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 35/74
2011
Executive Office of Energyand Environmental Affairs
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 36/74
2012
Executive Office of Energyand Environmental Affairs
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 37/74
2013
Executive Office of Energyand Environmental Affairs
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 38/74
Thanks
38
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 39/74
Priorities• Excellence in permitting, compliance and
enforcement• Climate Change and the Clean Energy
Economy
• Solid Waste and Recycling • Sustainable Water Management Initiative • Cutting-Edge Information Technology
• Regulatory Reform
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 40/74
Focus on Environment and Economy
d b f
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 41/74
Faster and more certain permitting is better forbusiness
d i i i i b f
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 42/74
Faster and more certain permitting is better forbusiness
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 43/74
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 44/74
Brownfields re-development: iconic
Provided by MassDevelopm ent and avai lable a tht tp: / /www.massdevelopment .com/f inancing/special ty- loan- programs/brownfields-redevelopment-fund/
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 45/74
CERP
Provided by MassDevelopm ent and avai lable a tht tp: / /www.massdevelopment .com/f inancing/special ty- loan- programs/brownfields-redevelopment-fund/
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 46/74
GHG Reductions
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 47/74
Hibbard
Provided by MassDevelopm ent and avai lable a tht tp: / /www.massdevelopment .com/f inancing/special ty- loan- programs/brownfields-redevelopment-fund/
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 48/74
• Consumers save in electricity market due to reduced LMPs and lower demand, but bear thecost of on-site renewable and EE installations/programs
• Fossil suppliers lose revenues due to reduced LMPs and lower demand, but new renewablesuppliers gain revenues and REC APS payments
• Construction and installation expenditures provide positive local economic impacts
RGGI: Driving New England Clean Energy
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 49/74
RGGI: Driving New England Clean EnergyInvestment
State Cumulative RGGIProceed
Investments (2009-2011)
Millions of Dollars
Connecticut $53.8Maine $18.4
Massachusetts $150.4
New Hampshire $31.6
Rhode Island $7.3Vermont $7.0
New EnglandTotal
$268.4
88%
6%2% 3% 1%
New EnglandRGGI Investments by Category
Cumulative-to-Date
Energy Efficiency
Clean & Renewable Energy
GHG Abatement & Climate Change Adaptation
Administration
RGGI, Inc.
Analysis Group Report Conclusion
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 50/74
50
Analysis Group Report ConclusionRGGI Delivers Results: Savings, Value, Jobs
$1.6BILLION
In net economicbenefit to the region 1
$1.3BILLIONIn energy bill savings
across the region 1
16THOUSAND
Job-years created 1
$765MILLION
Kept in region
(avoided fuel costs)1
1Source: Analysis Group (2011)
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 51/74
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 52/74
Energy Efficiency Investments & Benefits
52
$2,800
$542
$5,639
$8,980
$0
$1,000
$2,000
$3,000
$4,000
$5,000
$6,000
$7,000
$8,000
$9,000
$10,000
Residential Low Income Comm'l & Industr Statewide 3-Year Total
M i l l i o n s
Budget, E&GBenefits, E&G
Adding Renewables to the Mix Can Lower
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 53/74
Adding Renewables to the Mix Can LowerPrices
53
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 54/74
54Source: ISO-New England
The Current System is Inefficient
~6,000 MW
Energy Efficiency Programs Have Reduced GHG Emissions
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 55/74
Energy Efficiency Programs Have Reduced GHG EmissionsWhile Reducing Costs and Improving Reliability
A v oi d e d
C a p a c i t y :
~2 , 0 0 0 MW
No newEE
New EEonly inyears 1-3
New EE in years1-10
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 56/74
Pros and Cons of the proposed Clean
Energy Standard (CES)
David O’Connor Senior Vice President for Energy
and Clean TechnologyML Strategies
Environmental Business Council of New EnglandEnergy Environment Economy
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 57/74
Nalcor Energy Overview
January 2015
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 58/74
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 59/74
Newfoundland and Labrador Hydro
59
• Primary generator ofelectricity in NL.
• Installed generating capacity – 1,637 MW; 80% is clean,hydroelectric generation.
• Operating independentpower system for over 50years.
• Sound capital investment planand asset managementstrategy.
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 60/74
Churchill Falls : 5,428 MW
60
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 61/74
Churchill Falls
61
• 11 turbines with rated capacityof 5,428 MW.
• 2nd largest undergroundpowerhouse in the world.
• Largest hydro facility in AtlanticCanada.• Majority of power sold to
Hydro-Quebec to 2041.• Recall power used in Labrador
and sold in export markets innortheast.
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 62/74
Lower Churchill Hydro Development
62
Interconnecting Transmission Lines between Muskrat Falls, Gull Island, andChurchill Falls
2250 MW/ 12 TW-h/yr
Reservoir length – 232 kmFlood area – 85 km 2 (33 miles 2)
A dam and powerhouse atGull Island
Two dams and powerhouse atMuskrat Falls
824 MW/ 5 TW-h/yr
Reservoir length - 60 kmFlood area – 41 km 2 (16 miles 2)
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 63/74
Muskrat Falls : 824 MW
63
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 64/74
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 65/74
MF Spillway Formwork
65
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 66/74
HVac Transmission Line Construction
66
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 67/74
Gull Island : 2,250 MW
67
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 68/74
Delivering Hydropower to
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 69/74
Delivering Hydropower toMassachusetts
69
• Join forces with wind powergenerating facilities
• Compete for and win longterm contracts to deliverpower to MA
• Finance and construct newgenerating capacity at GullIsland
• And a new transmission lonefrom Labrador to NewEngland
• Deliver competitive, stable,reliable power for many years
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 70/74
Pros and Cons of the proposed CleanEnergy Standard (CES)
Ian SpringsteelDirector, Regulatory Policy for Clean Energy
National Grid
Environmental Business Council of New England
Energy Environment Economy
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 71/74
Pros and Cons of the proposed CleanEnergy Standard (CES)
Sean MahoneyExecutive Vice President
Conservation Law Foundation
Environmental Business Council of New England
Energy Environment Economy
Panel Discussion:
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 72/74
a e scuss o :How to Achieve Statutory Greenhouse
Gas Reductions Cost-EffectivelyModerator: Michael Ernst, Tetra Tech
Panelists:• David Cash , MassDEP• David O’Connor , ML Strategies• Ian Springsteel , National Grid• Sean Mahoney , CLF
Environmental Business Council of New England
Energy Environment Economy
Networking Break
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 73/74
Networking Break
Environmental Business Council of New England
Energy Environment Economy
Continued Discussion:
8/10/2019 1-7-15 MASTER Mass Clean Energy Standard
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/1-7-15-master-mass-clean-energy-standard 74/74
How to Achieve Statutory GreenhouseGas Reductions Cost-Effectively
Moderator: Ruth Silman, Nixon Peabody LLP
Panelists:• Will Space , MassDEP• Bob Rio , Associated Industries of MA• Francis Pullaro , RENEW Northeast
• Sandi Hennequin , NEPGA
E i l B i C il f N E l d